You are on page 1of 25

Roberto Omar Berizonce

procedimientos preliminares y
prueba anticipada como instrumentos
para la decisión temprana de los
conflictos*
Roberto Omar Berizonce**

Resumen
"QBSUJSEFMBQSFNJTBEFMBDSFDJFOUFKVEJDJBMJ[BDJØOEFMPTDPOnJDUPT
RVFDPOEVDFBMBTPCSFDBSHBEFMBMBCPSEFMPTUSJCVOBMFTZMBFYDFTJWB
EVSBDJØO EF MPT QSPDFTPT  TF QSPQPOF BOBMJ[BS NPEFMPT  JOTUJUVDJPOFT
Z UÏDOJDBT RVF TF FYIJCFO FO FM %FSFDIP DPNQBSBEP  FTQFDJBMNFOUF
FO MB FYQFSJFODJB EF MPT QBÓTFT JCFSPBNFSJDBOPT 4F TPTUJFOF RVF
MPT SFHÓNFOFT EF NFEJBDJØO PSJVOEPT EFM %FSFDIP OPSUFBNFSJDBOP
OP TF DPNQBEFDFO DPO FM TJTUFNB EF WBMPSFT Z DSFFODJBT EF OVFTUSBT
TPDJFEBEFT FOQBSUJDVMBSMBNFEJBDJØOTØMPiGBDJMJUBEPSBw&YJTUFOPUSBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFTTVQFSBEPSBT RVFTFBOBMJ[BO RVFFOTVDPOKVOUPSFTVMUBO
NÈT BQSPQJBEBT B MPT mOFT QFSTFHVJEPT &OUSF FMMBT  MB JOTUSVDDJØO
QSFMJNJOBSQSPCBUPSJB RVFQVFEFDPOWFSUJSTFFONFDBOJTNPBVYJMJBUPSJP
EFMBOFHPDJBDJØOFOUSFMBTQBSUFTQBSBGBDJMJUBSFOMBBOUFTBMBEFMEFCBUF
KVEJDJBMBDVFSEPTEFiKVTUBDPNQPTJDJØOwEFMDPOnJDUPZRVF BMNJTNP
UJFNQP TJSWFDPNPQSPDFEJNJFOUPEFJOTUSVDDJØOUFNQSBOBEFMBDBVTB

3FDJCJEPNBS[PEFo"QSPCBEPKVMJPEF

 "SUÓDVMPJOÏEJUP
 1BSB DJUBS FM BSUÓDVMP #&3*;0/$&  3PCFSUP 0NBS 1SPDFEJNJFOUPT QSFMJNJOBSFT Z QSVFCB
BOUJDJQBEB DPNP JOTUSVNFOUPT QBSB MB EFDJTJØO UFNQSBOB EF MPT DPOnJDUPT Revista del
Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal/P KVMJPEJDJFNCSF#PHPUÈ*OTUJUVUP
$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBMQQ
 1SPGFTPS&NÏSJUPEF-B6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF-B1MBUB "SHFOUJOB1SFTJEFOUF)POPSBSJP
EFM*OTUJUVUP*CFSPBNFSJDBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 19


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

Palabras clave: 4PCSFDBSHB  NFEJBDJØO  JOTUSVDDJØO QSFMJNJOBS  QSVFCB


BOUJDJQBEB KVTUBDPNQPTJDJØO

Abstract
'SPN UIF QSFNJTF PG UIF JODSFBTJOH DPOnJDUT KVEJDJBMJ[BUJPO MFBEJOH
UP PWFSMPBE UIF XPSL PG UIF DPVSUT BOE UIF FYDFTTJWF QSPDFTT MFOHUI  JU
JT QSPQPTF UP BOBMZ[F NPEFMT  JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE UFDIOJRVFT FYIJCJUFE JO
DPNQBSBUJWFMBX FTQFDJBMMZJOUIFFYQFSJFODFPG-BUJO"NFSJDBODPVOUSJFT
*UJTBSHVFEUIBUUIFNFEJBUJPOSFHJNFTOBUJWFTPG/PSUI"NFSJDBOMBX
EPO}UTZNQBUIJ[FXJUIUIFTZTUFNPGWBMVFTBOECFMJFGTPGPVSTPDJFUJFT 
FTQFDJBMMZ UIF iGBDJMJUBUPSw POMZ NFEJBUJPO ͳFSF BSF PUIFS PWFSDPNJOH
JOTUJUVUJPOT  XIJDI BSF BOBMZ[FE  UIBU UPHFUIFS BSF NPSF BQQSPQSJBUF UP
UIFBJNTQVSTVFE*ODMVEJOHUIFQSFMJNJOBSZQSPCBUJWFJOTUSVDUJPO XIJDI
DBOCFDPNFBOBVYJMJBSZNFDIBOJTNPGOFHPUJBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFQBSUJFT
UPGBDJMJUBUFiGBJSDPNQPTJUJPOwBHSFFNFOUTPGUIFDPOnJDUJOUIFBOUFSPPN
PGUIFKVEJDJBMEFCBUFBOE BUUIFTBNFUJNF JUTFSWFTBTFBSMZJOTUSVDUJPO
QSPDFEVSFPGUIFDBVTF
Keywords: 0WFSMPBE  NFEJBUJPO  QSFMJNJOBSZ JOTUSVDUJPO  BOUJDJQBUFE
UFTU GBJSDPNQPTJUJPO

1. Planteamiento del tema. Tutela judicial efectiva,


razonable, duración del proceso y simplificación
de los trámites
&T IBSUP DPOPDJEB  Z OP TØMP FOUSF OPTPUSPT QVFT TF USBUB EF GFOØNFOPT
HFOFSJ[BEPTRVFBRVFKBOMBQSFTUBDJØOEFMTFSWJDJPEFKVTUJDJBFOUPEBTMBTMBUJUVEFT 
MBJOTBUJTGBDDJØOQPSMBGBMUBEFWJSUVBMJEBEFONÞMUJQMFTDBTPTEFMBHBSBOUÓBGVOEB-
NFOUBMEFMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFmDB[ZFmDJFOUF RVFTFQSPDMBNBFOGÈUJDBNFOUFEFTEF
MB$POTUJUVDJØOZMBTDPOWFODJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT$MBSPRVFTPOQMVSBMFTZDPOnV-
ZFOUFTMBTDBVTBTQSPGVOEBTEFMGFOØNFOP FOUSFMBTDVBMFTPDVQBOVOMVHBSEFTUBDBEP
UBOUPVOBDSFDJFOUFEFNBOEBEFKVTUJDJB FYQSFTBEBFOQSPHSFTJØOHFPNÏUSJDB DPNP
MB DPSSFMBUJWB DPNQMFKJEBE EF MBT DVFTUJPOFT RVF TF MJUJHBO 6OB NBZPS DPODJFODJB
JOEJWJEVBMZDPMFDUJWBZFMFNQPEFSBNJFOUPEFMPTiOVFWPTwZUSBEJDJPOBMFTEFSFDIPT
HFOFSBO JOFWJUBCMFNFOUF VOB NBSDBEB  Z TJFNQSF FO BTDFOTP  KVEJDJBMJ[BDJØO EF
MPTDPOnJDUPTZ DPOFMMP MBBDFOUVBDJØOEFMBDUJWJTNPEFMPTKVFDFTNBOJGFTUBEPEF
NPEPTEJWFSTPTZDBNCJBOUFT1PSVOMBEP FTUÈODPNQFMJEPTBSFTPMWFSFTBNBTB
JODFTBOUFEFSFDMBNPT QFSPBMNJTNPUJFNQPFMNPEFMPQSPDFTBMOPMFTCSJOEBMBT


/PT QFSNJUJNPT SFNJUJS B OVFTUSB PCSB Tutelas procesales diferenciadas #VFOPT "JSFT
3VCJO[BM$VM[POJFEDBQ7* 

20 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

IFSSBNJFOUBT OFDFTBSJBT QBSB FODBVTBSMPT FO GPSNB BEFDVBEB -B NBZPSÓB EF MPT
QSPDFEJNJFOUPTUSBEJDJPOBMFToCBTUFQFOTBSFOFMPSEFOBNJFOUPOBDJPOBMBSHFOUJOP
WJHFOUFQSÈDUJDBNFOUFTJOSFGPSNBTEFTEFoTFNVFTUSBOBUPEBTMVDFTJOFmDBDFT 
JOTVmDJFOUFTQBSBFMMPHSPEFMPTPCKFUJWPTDFOUSBMFTTJOUFUJ[BEPTFOFMproceso justo2.
%FBIÓFMEFOPEBEPFNQF×PQPSFODPOUSBSOVFWPTPSFGPSNBEPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPT 
JOTUJUVDJPOFTZUÏDOJDBTQSPDFTBMFTRVFQFSNJUBOTJNQMJmDBSZBDFMFSBSMPTEFTBSSPMMPT
MJUJHJPTPT  TJO NFOPTDBCP EFM QSJODJQJP CÈTJDP EFM DPOUSBEJDUPSJP "SSJCBS B MB
EFDJTJØOFOUJFNQPSB[POBCMFJNQMJDBFMBQFUFDJEPSFTVMUBEPÞUJMEFMBKVSJTEJDDJØO
$MBSPRVFTPOEJWFSTPTZBNFOVEPDPOnVZFOUFTMPTDBNJOPTRVFQVFEBOUFOUBSTF
5SBEJDJPOBMNFOUF TF WJODVMBO DPO MB BCSFWJBDJØO Z TJNQMJmDBDJØO EF MPT USÈNJUFT
FO HFOFSBM Z BVO  FO FM QFOTBNJFOUP QSPDFTBM DPOUFNQPSÈOFP  FO MB BSUJDVMBDJØO
EFMPTEFOPNJOBEPTNFDBOJTNPTEFKVTUJDJBiUFNQSBOBwoUVUFMBTBOUJDJQBUPSJBTEF
VSHFODJB Z EF FWJEFODJB  KV[HBNJFOUP BOUJDJQBEP EFM NÏSJUP  FKFDVUPSJFEBE EF MBT
TFOUFODJBT SFDVSSJEBT  FTUSVDUVSBT NPOJUPSJBT Z TJNJMBSFTo )BZ UPEBWÓB BQVFTUBT
NÈT ESÈTUJDBT  ESBDPOJBOBT  DPNP MBT RVF UJFOEFO B PQFSBS TPCSF FM QSPQJP nVKP 
QPSEJWFSTBTSB[POFTEFTNFTVSBEP EFMBMJUJHJPTJEBEOPQBSBJNQFEJSVPCUVSBSFM
MFHÓUJNP BDDFTP B MB KVSJTEJDDJØO  OJ EFTJODFOUJWBSMP DPO DBSHBT FDPOØNJDBT DPNP
FOFMNPEFMPFDPOPNJDJTUBQMBOUFBEPFOMPTB×PTOPWFOUB TJOP FOUPEPDBTP QBSB
DBOBMJ[BSMPTSFDMBNPTQPSPUSBTWÓBT FOFTQFDJBMQPSMPTSFWBMPSJ[BEPTNFEJPTBMUFS-
OBUJWPTQBSBTVEFDJTJØO
1SFDJTBNFOUFOVFTUSBTSFnFYJPOFTUSBUBSÈOEFDFOUSBSTFFOFTUPTÞMUJNPTQBSB
BOBMJ[BS TV WJSUVBMJEBE  DPOGSPOUBSMPT  FO QBSUJDVMBS  DPO FM NPEFMP EFM QSPDFTP
KVTUP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM Z MBT USBEJDJPOFT DVMUVSBMFT Z QBSB DPODMVJS TPCSF TV JOTVm-
DJFODJBFJOVUJMJEBE"QBSUJSEFFTBQSFNJTBOPTQSPQPOFNPTQMBOUFBSVONPEFMP
SFDPHJEPEFMBFYQFSJFODJBDPNQBSBUJWB TVQFSBEPSEFMBNFEJBDJØOiGBDJMJUBEPSBw 
iEFFTQBMEBTBMBKVTUJDJBw6ONFDBOJTNPRVF BUSBWÏTEFMBJOTUSVDDJØOQSFMJNJOBS
QSPCBUPSJB QPTJCJMJUFBMKVF[MBKVTUBSFTPMVDJØOEFMDPOnJDUP FOBSNPOÓBDPOMPT


$0.0(-*0-1i(BSBOUÓBTNÓOJNBTEFMAQSPDFTPKVTUPDJWJMFOMPTPSEFOBNJFOUPTIJTQB-
OPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTw&O: Rev. Iberoam.W%FS1SPDFTBM #VFOPT"JSFTQQZTT
7"--&41¶/1²3&;%El modelo constitucional de juicio justo en el ámbito del proceso civil.
#BSDFMPOB "UFMJFS    passim .03&--0 ". El proceso justo ‹ FE  #VFOPT "JSFT
-FYJT/FYJT-&1  passim.

#*"7"55* 1Tendencias recientes de la justicia civil en Europa4BOUB'F3%1 QQ
ZTT."3*/0/* -( "3&/)"35 4$Z.*5*%*&30 %i$VSTPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM”.
&O: Rev. dos TribW 4ÉP1BVMP QQZTT ZTT.*5*%*&30 %Anticipaçâo da
tutela4ÉP1BVMP&EJUEPT5SJC QQZTT1&:3"/0 +8El dictado de decisiones
judiciales anticipadas. El factor “evidencia”#VFOPT"JSFT-B-FZ #QQZTTid. La
tutela anticipada de evidencia#VFOPT"JSFT-B-FZ $ QQZTT%&-";;"3* &/
La ejecución provisoria de la sentencia como tutela de urgencia y de evidencia#VFOPT"JSFT
-B-FZ 'QQZTT

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 21


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

QSJODJQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTRVFTVTUFOUBOMBKVSJTEJDDJØO TPCSFNBOFSB FMMPHSPEF


EFDJTJPOFT KVEJDJBMFT RVF  FO UÏSNJOPT EF DBMJEBE  SFTVMUFO iKVTUBT Z FRVJUBUJWBTw
fair and equitable
4.

2. La búsqueda de soluciones a través de los medios


alternativos y especialmente la mediación
/PFTUÈFOEJTDVTJØORVFMPTiFRVJWBMFOUFTKVSJTEJDDJPOBMFTwCSJOEBOJOTUBODJBT
EJGFSFODJBEBTEFQBSUJDVMBSVUJMJEBEQBSBEJSJNJScierta categoría de conflictos TJUVB-
DJPOFTFYDFQDJPOBMFTFOSFBMJEBE ZBRVFMBSFHMBTJHVFTJFOEPFMTPNFUJNJFOUPQMFOP
BMBEFDJTJØOKVEJDJBM4JOFNCBSHP EFFOUSBEB DBCFBMFSUBSSFTQFDUPEFVOFRVÓWPDP
DPODFQUVBMRVF EFDPNÞO FNQB×BFMFOUFOEJNJFOUPEFMPTmOFTEFQPMÓUJDBKVEJDJBM
FOKVFHP-BJNQMBOUBDJØOEFMPTNFEJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTFOHFOFSBM ZFOQBSUJDVMBSEFMB
NFEJBDJØOFOMBNPEBMJEBEQSFWBMFDJFOUFFOUSFOPTPUSPToHFOFSBMNFOUFFOMPTQBÓTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTo OPQVFEFFODPOUSBSTVKVTUJmDBDJØOFOFMBSHVNFOUPEFDPOTUJUVJS
VO SFNFEJP QBSB MB DSFDJFOUF TPCSFDBSHB EFM TJTUFNB EF JNQBSUJDJØO EF KVTUJDJB.
&M SB[POBNJFOUP FT GBMB[ QPSRVF OP TF SFQBSB FO RVF EJDIPT NFEJPT BMUFSOBUJWPT
SFTQPOEFO Z TF MFHJUJNBO  FO UBOUP RVF MBT TPMVDJPOFT UÓQJDBT RVF USBFO DPOTJHP 
QSFDJTBNFOUF  SFTVMUBO TFS MBT NÈT BEFDVBEBT QBSB MB EFDJTJØO EF MPT DPOnJDUPT EF
RVFTFUSBUB"TÓPDVSSFFOMPTEFGBNJMJBZMPTEFSJWBEPTEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFiDPFYJT-
UFODJBMJEBEw FOHFOFSBM4POEJGFSFOEPTRVFFODVFOUSBOSFTQVFTUBTNÈTQSPQJBT iB
NFEJEBw FOBRVFMMBTUÏDOJDBT MPDVBMDPOTUJUVZFSB[ØOTVmDJFOUFQBSBDPOTBHSBSMBT 
NÈT BMMÈ EF RVF oBEFNÈTo FMMP QVFEB DPBEZVWBS B MB EFTDPOHFTUJØO KVEJDJBM 4F
DPOGVOEF  FO SFBMJEBE  FM PCKFUJWP FTFODJBM EFM QSPDFTP KVEJDJBM EF CSJOEBS B MPT
MJUJHBOUFTWÓBTFTQFDJBMFTTJNQMFTZEFTGPSNBMJ[BEBTNÈTBEFDVBEBTQBSBMBSFTPMVDJØO
oPMBiEJTPMVDJØOwoEFDJFSUBTDVFTUJPOFT DPOMPTNFEJPTQBSBUPSOBSFmDB[FMTFSWJDJP
&O MP RVF TJHVF  TF JOUFOUBSÈ EFNPTUSBS MB OPUPSJB JOTVmDJFODJB EFM NÏUPEP EF
MBNFEJBDJØO FOFMNPEFMPQSFWBMFDJFOUFFOUSFOPTPUSPT QBSBTBUJTGBDFSFMPCKFUJWP
ÈVSFPEFMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBZFMQSPDFTPKVTUP

3. Los métodos de solución de conflictos como expresión


de la cultura comunitaria
"QBSUJSEFMBQSFNJTBJOEJTQVUBEBEFRVFMPTNÏUPEPTEFSFTPMVDJØOEFDPOnJDUPT
TF FODVFOUSBO QSPGVOEB Z SFDÓQSPDBNFOUF DPOFDUBEPT DPO MPT EFUFSNJOBEPT Z

4
$"11&--&55* .Z("35) #El acceso a la Justicia-B1MBUBFE$PM"CPHBEPT-B1MBUB 
Q$0.0(-*0 -1Garantías mínimas… Ob. cit.QQZTT

(*"//*/*  -+ i{&T MB NFEJBDJØO PCMJHBUPSJB FO "SHFOUJOB VO JOTUSVNFOUP EF BDDFTP B MB
KVTUJDJB w&O: Rev. Iberoam. Der. Proc., Rev. dos TribunaisWPM 4ÉP1BVMP QQ

22 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

FTQFDÓmDPT FMFNFOUPT RVF DPOmHVSBO  EF NPEP HFOÏSJDP  FM DPOUFYUP TPDJBM Z
DVMUVSBM Z MB JEJPTJODSBTJB EF MBT TPDJFEBEFT FO RVF TF BQMJDBO  MFKPT EF DPOTUJUVJS
TJTUFNBT BJTMBEPT  QSPEVDUP EF FYQFSUPT  FTQFDJBMJTUBT P CVSØDSBUBT EF UVSOP 
EFCFNPTQSFHVOUBSOPTTJFMNPEFMPEFSBÓ[OPSUFBNFSJDBOBBEPQUBEPBCJFSUBNFOUF 
ZDBTJTJODPODFTJPOFTEFiBEBQUBCJMJEBEwFOEJWFSTBTMFHJTMBDJPOFTEF*CFSPBNÏSJDBZ
FTQFDJBMNFOUFFO"SHFOUJOBQPSMB-FZEF SFTQPOEFBOVFTUSBTQBSUJDV-
MBSJEBEFTDVMUVSBMFTP TJTFQSFmFSF TJSFnFKB ZTFSFnFKBFO
MPTTJTUFNBTEFDSFFODJBT 
WBMPSFT Z QSJODJQJPT NÈT BSSBJHBEPT RVF QSFWBMFO FO MB FTUJNBUJWB DPNVOJUBSJB FO
UPSOPEFMBKVTUJDJB

3.1 El método de la mediación en la experiencia


norteamericana
4FIBTF×BMBEPRVFMBBQBSJDJØOEFMPT"%3 .FEJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFTPMVDJØOEF
DPOnJDUPT
FOMBÞMUJNBQBSUFEFMTJHMP99TFJOTFSUØFOVOFTRVFNBEFQSPHSFTJWP
BCBOEPOPEFMNÏUPEPUSBEJDJPOBMEFFOKVJDJBNJFOUPKVSJTEJDDJPOBM FODPOTPOBODJB
DPO EJWFSTBT DPSSJFOUFT TPDJBMFT &O TV HÏOFTJT JOnVÓB VOB JNQPSUBOUF DSJTJT EF
MJUJHJPTJEBE BVORVFUBNCJÏOOPUPSJBTDBVTBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT QPMÓUJDBTZDVMUVSBMFT
&TUBT FTUBCBO  NÈT FTQFDÓmDBNFOUF  BUBEBT B DBNCJPT FO MPT WBMPSFT FO DPOnJDUP 
MB EFTDPOmBO[B FO FM HPCJFSOP  MBT QPMÓUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFT EF QSJWBUJ[BDJPOFT  MB
IVNBOJ[BDJØO EF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT B HSBO FTDBMB  FM QSPHSFTP TPDJBM B USBWÏT EF MB
NFKPSBJOEJWJEVBMZFMFTDFQUJDJTNPQPTNPEFSOPBDFSDBEFMBSFBMJEBEPCKFUJWB RVF
FYQSFTBCBO JOHSFEJFOUFT GVOEBNFOUBMFT EF MB DVMUVSB OPSUFBNFSJDBOB MB MJCFSUBE 
FMJOEJWJEVBMJTNP FMQPQVMJTNP MBJHVBMEBEZFMMJCFSBMJTNP-PT"%3 FOSFBMJEBE 
BCBSDBOBMMÓVOBCBOJDPEFNÏUPEPTZQSPDFEJNJFOUPTRVFJODMVZFOMBOFHPDJBDJØO 
MB NFEJBDJØO  FM BSCJUSBKF  MB FWBMVBDJØO OFVUSBM QSFWJB  MPT KVJDJPT TVNBSJPT DPO
KVSBEPFJOBDBCBCMFTDPNCJOBDJPOFTEFBMHVOPTPWBSJPTEFFMMPT#JFORVFIBOTJEP
MBNFEJBDJØOZFMBSCJUSBKFMBTGPSNBTNÈTEJGVOEJEBTZVUJMJ[BEBTFOWJODVMBDJØO OP
TJFNQSFDFSUFSBOJQBDÓmDB DPOMBMBCPSEFMPTUSJCVOBMFTKVSJTEJDDJPOBMFT%FIFDIP 


$"11&--*55*  . i"TQFDUPT TPDJBMFT Z QPMÓUJDPT EFM QSPDFEJNJFOUP DJWJM SFGPSNBT Z
UFOEFODJBTFWPMVUJWBTFOMB&VSPQBPDDJEFOUBMZPSJFOUBM
w&O: Proceso, ideologías y sociedad.
USBE44FOUÓT.FMFOEPZ5"#BO[IBG #VFOPT"JSFT&EJBS QQZTT FTQFDJBMNFOUF
QQ"TJNJTNP TPCSFMBQSPGVOEBWJODVMBDJØOEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTQBSBMBSFTPMVDJØO
EFDPOnJDUPTDPOTVDPOUFYUPDVMUVSBM%"."4," .JSJBNLas caras de la justicia y el poder
del Estado. Análisis comparado del proceso legal4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFFE+VSÓEEF$IJMF 
passim.

$)"4& 0Law, culture and Ritual. Disputing Systems in Cross-Cultural Context/FX:PSL
/FX:PSL6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 4FHVJNPTMBUSBEVDDJØODBTUFMMBOBEF.BSUÓO%J[ 'FSOBOEP
Derecho, cultura y ritual. Sistemas de resolución de controversias en un contexto intercultural.
.BESJE#BSDFMPOB#VFOPT"JSFT.BSDJBM1POT  passim.

$)"4& 0Ob. citQ

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 23


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

TVFYQBOTJØOIBTJEPDSFDJFOUFNFOUFTJHOJmDBUJWBBQBSUJSEFMPTB×PTPDIFOUBZFTUÈ
WJODVMBEBBMJOnVKPEFMPTDBNCJPTFOFM%FSFDIP JNQVMTBEPTUBOUPQPSFM$POHSFTP
DPNPQPSFMQSPQJP1PEFS+VEJDJBM BUSBWÏTEFEJWFSTPTQSPHSBNBTEFVUJMJ[BDJØO
iJOUSBKVEJDJBMFTw "TÓ IB PDVSSJEP DPO MB NFEJBDJØO HFTUJPOBEB EJTDSFDJPOBMNFOUF
QPS MPT KVFDFT Z QVFTUB B DBSHP  HFOFSBMNFOUF  EF BCPHBEPT RVF BDUÞBO IPOPSB-
SJBNFOUFTJOSFUSJCVDJØO.
-BTCBTFTEFTFNFKBOUFNPWJNJFOUPFOWFSEBETFFODPOUSBCBOQSPGVOEBNFOUF
BSSBJHBEBTFOMBTSBÓDFTZFOFMQBTBEPIJTUØSJDPEFMQBÓT RVFQVFEFSFDPOPDFSTFZB
FOMBÏUJDBZMBQSÈDUJDBEFMPTQSJNFSPTDPMPOPTJOHMFTFT%FTEFFOUPODFT DMBSPRVF
DPOnVDUVBDJPOFT MBTBMUFSOBUJWBTBMQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMIBOTJEPVOBDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBEFM
NPEFMPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPEFSFTPMVDJØOEFDPOnJDUPT"OUFTEFMHSBOJNQVMTPEFmOFT
EFMTJHMPBOUFSJPS MBDPODJMJBDJØOFTUBCBSFEVDJEBBMBiQFSJGFSJBwEFMTJTUFNBKVSÓEJDP 
NJFOUSBT FM BSCJUSBKF IBCÓB RVFEBEP SFDPOEVDJEP B MBT OFDFTJEBEFT EFM NVOEP
FNQSFTBSJBM oQPESÓBNPT DPMFHJS RVF TFNFKBOUF SFBMJEBE FSB  EF BMHVOB NBOFSB 
TJNJMBSBMBOVFTUSBo-BFYQMPTJØOTVDFTJWBZFMSBEJDBMDBNCJPEFUFOEFODJBBQBSUJS
EFMPTB×PTPDIFOUBFOWFSEBEOPIBCSÓBOTJEPDPOTFDVFODJB DPNPDPSSJFOUFNFOUF
TFQJFOTB EFMEFTCPSEFEFMBMJUJHJPTJEBEoGFOØNFOPQSÈDUJDBNFOUFVOJWFSTBMo TJOP
RVF FTUF ÞMUJNP IBCSÓB UFOJEP VO QBQFM NVDIP NÈT NPEFTUP  EFTEF RVF  BmSNB
$IBTF  MB WFSEBEFSB Z GVOEBNFOUBM DBVTB EF TFNFKBOUF DBNCJP EF UPSOBT EFCF
CVTDBSTF FO MB DPOGPSNBDJØO EF VOB WFSEBEFSB Z QSPQJB cultura EF MPT "%3 RVF
BTJFOUBFOEJWFSTPTQJMBSFTMBSFBDDJØODPOUSBFMiIJQFSMFHBMJTNPwMBiDPOUSBDVMUVSBw
EF MPT B×PT TFTFOUB MB DPOHPKB QPS MB iQÏSEJEB EF MB DFSUJEVNCSFw EF MB UBSEÓB
NPEFSOJEBEZFMDSFDJNJFOUPEFMBTQSJWBUJ[BDJPOFTDPNPVOJEFBM
B &OMPRVFOPTJOUFSFTBQBSBOVFTUSPBOÈMJTJT MBTQPMÓUJDBTOFPMJCFSBMFTZEFJNQVMTP
BMBQSJWBUJ[BDJØOFOÏQPDBEF3FBHBOJOnVZFSPOFOFMÈNCJUPEFMBSFTPMVDJØOEF
DPOnJDUPTMPTEFSFDIPTEFMPTMJUJHBOUFTQPESÓBOTFSSFNJUJEPTGVFSBEFMBØSCJUB
EFMPTUSJCVOBMFTZFMBSCJUSBKFTFFYUFOEJØNBTJWBNFOUFBQBSUJSEFMBTDMÈVTVMBT
DPNQSPNJTPSJBTFOMPTDPOUSBUPTEFFNQMFP DPNQSBWFOUBZDPSSFUBKF BMFOUBEP
QPSMBKVSJTQSVEFODJBEFMB4VQSFNB$PSUF
C 1PS PUSP MBEP  MB GBMUB EF DFSUJEVNCSF Z TFHVSJEBE  UBNCJÏO KVSÓEJDB  DBSBDUF-
SÓTUJDBEFMPTUJFNQPTQPTNPEFSOPT JOnVZØFOMBWJTJØOEFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPT
KVEJDJBMFTFTDFQUJDJTNPZDPOTFDVFOUFEFTDBMJmDBDJØOEFDJFSUPTNFEJPTUSBEJ-
DJPOBMFT EF QSVFCB  DPNP FM UFTUJNPOJP EF UFTUJHPT EJSFDUPT  FM JOUFSSPHBUPSJP
ZBVOFMWBMPSEFDJFSUBTQSVFCBTQFSJDJBMFT QPSMBWJSUVBMJEBEZEFTQSFDJPEFMB


Ibidem.QQ EPOEFSFTF×BOVNFSPTBTFTUBEÓTUJDBTRVFBWBMBOTVTDPODMVTJPOFT DPNP
UBNCJÏO TJHOJmDBUJWPT QSPOVODJBNJFOUPT EFM 5SJCVOBM 4VQSFNP Z OPSNBUJWBT MFHBMFT RVF
JOnVZFSPOEFDJTJWBNFOUFFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMPT"%3FOUSFFTUBTÞMUJNBT MB"%3"DUBEF


Ibidem.QQZTT

24 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

iDJFODJBCBTVSBw&MFTDFQUJDJTNPOPTFMJNJUBBMBBWFSJHVBDJØOEFMPTIFDIPT
TJOPRVFTFFYUJFOEFBMBEFDJTJØOKVEJDJBM4JOPIBZVOBiSFBMJEBEwRVFQVFEB
EFUFSNJOBSTFJOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEFMBNFUPEPMPHÓBFNQMFBEB TFBSHVZF {QPS
RVÏCVTDBSMB 1SFDJTBNFOUFQPSFMMP BmSNBO MBNFEJBDJØOFTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
BUSBDUJWBDPNPPQDJØOFODVBOUPRVFTVPCKFUJWPFTFMMPHSPEFVOSFTVMUBEPRVF
OPEFQFOEFEFMBiKVTUJDJBw OJEFMiTVF×PwEFMBDFSUF[BBCTPMVUB
D &O EFmOJUJWB  TF DPODMVZF MB FOUSPOJ[BDJØO Z FM BVHF EF MPT "%3 FO MPT
&&66 GVF QSPEVDUP EF QFUJDJPOFT JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT  NBOJPCSBT QPMÓUJDBT Z FM
NPWJNJFOUPDVMUVSBMEFMBÏQPDB RVFIBOTJEPGVFSUFNFOUFDVFTUJPOBEPTEFTEF
TVBQBSJDJØO.

3.2 El trasplante de la mediación norteamericana y su recepción


en Iberoamérica y, en particular, en la normativa nacional
argentina
B &T CJFO DPOPDJEB MB HÏOFTJT EFM EFTFNCBSDP EF MB NFEJBDJØO FOUSF OPTPUSPT 
JOTFSUB FO VO BNQMJP Z BNCJDJPTP iQBRVFUFw EF SFGPSNBT DPO QSFUFOTJPOFT EF
FSJHJSTFFOWFSEBEFSBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBT JNBHJOBEBTQBSBMBUSBOTGPSNBDJØOEF
MBT FTUSVDUVSBT Z MPT QSPDFEJNJFOUPT DJWJMFT 1SPEVDUP EF VOB WJTJØO TFTHBEB Z
VOJMBUFSBM EF MPT DPNQMFKPT GFOØNFOPT JODBSEJOBEPT FO MPT TJTUFNBT KVEJDJBMFT
GVFSPOMPTFTUÓNVMPTBMBSFGPSNBRVFFOMPTB×PT}TFJNQVMTBSPOFOOVNFSPTPT
QBÓTFTEFMTVCDPOUJOFOUFBNFSJDBOP QPSBDDJØOEFMPTCBODPTNVMUJMBUFSBMFTEF
DSÏEJUPRVFJOZFDUBSPOQSFTUBNPTSFTUJUVJCMFTDPOFTBmOBMJEBE&MMPFOFMNBSDP
EF MB CÞTRVFEB EF USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT FTUSVDUVSBMFT EFM &TUBEP RVF  TFHÞO TVT
JOTQJSBEPSFT FODPOUSBCBOPCTUÈDVMPFOFMTJTUFNBEFKVTUJDJB%FTEFFMQVOUPEF
WJTUBFTUSBUÏHJDP ZOPTJODJFSUBJOHFOVJEBE MPTQSPHSBNBTBVTQJDJBEPTQPSMBT
FOUJEBEFT DSFEJUJDJBT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT QBSUÓBO EF MB QSFNJTB EF RVF FO FM TFDUPS


Ibidem.Q 

7"3("47*"/$04 +&Eficiencia en la justiciaFOsistemas judiciales$&+" 4EF$IJMF /¡
 Q EPOEFTFTPTUJFOFRVFMBCÞTRVFEBEFMBFmDJFODJBFTUÈÓOUJNBNFOUFSFMBDJPOBEB
DPOMBJEFBEFMBFTDBTF[ZmOJUVEEFSFDVSTPT MPRVFIBEFJOnVJSFOMBUPNBEFEFDJTJPOFT 
BVOQPSFODJNBEFMBDPODFQDJØOUSBEJDJPOBMRVFWFFOMBKVTUJDJBVOUFNBEFQSJODJQJPTZEF
WBMPSFTUSBTDFOEFOUFT RVFJOFYPSBCMFNFOUFEFCFOTFSDVNQMJEPT QQ
4FUSBUB QBSB
OPTPUSPT EFVOBTFTHBEBWJTJØOFDPOPNJDJTUB RVFEFTDPOPDFQSJODJQJPTCÈTJDPTEFMBDDFTPB
MBKVTUJDJBZFMTJTUFNBEFWBMPSFTGVOEBOUFTEFMBGVODJØOQÞCMJDBKVSJTEJDDJPOBM EFSBJHBNCSF
DPOTUJUVDJPOBMFOUPEPTOVFTUSPTQBÓTFT4PCSFFMUFNB OPTQFSNJUJNPTSFNJUJSB#&3*;0/$& 
30i&MDPTUPEFMQSPDFTP DPNPTBDSJmDJPQBSBFMFSBSJPZDPNPJNQFEJNFOUPQBSBFMBDDFTPB
MBKVTUJDJB
w. &O: Derecho Procesal Civil actual#VFOPT"JSFT"CFMFEP1FSSPU-&1 QQ
ZTT"TJNJTNP FODVBOUPBRVFMBNFEJBDJØOOPFTJOTUSVNFOUPÞUJM TJOP BMDPOUSBSJP 
QBSBGBDJMJUBSFMBDDFTPBMBKVTUJDJB(*"//*/* -+{&TMBNFEJBDJØOPCMJHBUPSJBy Ob. cit.

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 25


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

KVEJDJBMMBUSBOTGPSNBDJØOTFMPHSBSÓB NÈTRVFBMNPEJmDBSMBTMFZFTQSPDFTBMFT 
QPSWÓBEFUSBTMBEBSMBTOPDJPOFTEFHFTUJØONPEFSOB QSPQJBTEFMTFDUPSQSJWBEP 
BMRVFIBDFSKVSJTEJDDJPOBM-BJODPSQPSBDJØOEFUÏDOJDBTEFHFTUJØO EFMBNBOP
EFFYQFSUPTFOFMMBT TFSÓBFMDBNJOPQBSBMBTBOTJBEBTTPMVDJPOFT.
 &OWFSEBE NÈTQSFPDVQBOUFBÞOFSBMBJEFPMPHÓBEFOFUPTFTHPFDPOPNJDJTUB 
FOCPHBQPSFTFFOUPODFT RVFTFQSFUFOEÓBJNQPOFSDPOTFNFKBOUFTQSPQPTJ-
DJPOFT FODVZPDFOUSPBMFUFBCBMBDPODFQDJØOEFDJNPOØOJDBEFMBKVTUJDJBDJWJM
DPODFCJEBDPNPiCJFOQSJWBEPw DVZPTCFOFmDJPTTPOIFDIPTTVZPTQSFEPNJOBO-
UFNFOUFQPSMBTQBSUFTMJUJHBOUFT%FBIÓFMQSPQØTJUPEFEFTBMFOUBSMBEFNBOEB
EFKVTUJDJB EFTEFRVFMBQSPWJTJØOEFMTFSWJDJPDPNPCJFOQÞCMJDPJODFOUJWBSÓB
B MPT TVKFUPT B MJUJHBS NÈT BTJEVBNFOUF #BKP FTF QSJTNB  FM GVODJPOBNJFOUP
ØQUJNPEFMTJTUFNBKVEJDJBMJNQMJDBMBUVUFMBEFMEFSFDIPBMNFOPSDPTUPQPTJCMF
QBSBFMFSBSJP DPNPNFEJPQBSBPCUFOFSMBSFEVDDJØOEFMDPTUPEJSFDUPEFMPT
SFDVSTPTEFTUJOBEPTBMBTPMVDJØOEFDPOnJDUPTZMBPDVSSFODJBNJTNBEFEJDIPT
DPOnJDUPTQPSFMFGFDUPEFEJTVBTJØOFKFSDJEP BUSBWÏTEFMBTUBTBTRVFHSBWBOFM
TFSWJDJP.
C &O FM CBMBODF  QPS DJFSUP OFHBUJWP  EF FTBT QPMÓUJDBT EF DV×P OFPMJCFSBM IB EF
SFTDBUBSTF  TJO FNCBSHP oDPNP CJFO MP IB EFTUBDBEP 7"3("4 7*"/$04o
RVF MPT NPEFTUPT DBNCJPT FO MB HFTUJØO KVEJDJBM oGSVUP QSJODJQBMNFOUF EF MB
JOJDJBUJWBEFKVFDFTDSFBUJWPTo UÓNJEBNFOUFJOUFOUBEPTFOOVFTUSBSFHJØO OP
PCTUBOUFFMFTDBTPBWBODFRVFIBOTJHOJmDBEPFOMBNFKPSBEFMTJTUFNBKVEJDJBM 
IBOUFOJEPMBWJSUVE EFUPEPTNPEPT EFJOTUBMBSJEFBTEFFmDJFODJBZQSPEVD-
UJWJEBEZIBOHFOFSBEPVOQSPDFTPEFJOOPWBDJØOOBEBEFTEF×BCMF4PCSFUPEP 
WBMFBHSFHBS TJOPTFQJFSEFEFWJTUBMBPSHBOJDJEBEEFMÓOUFHSPTJTUFNBEFKVTUJDJB
ZTFBUJFOEFDPODPNJUBOUFNFOUFBMBNFKPSBFOMPTEFNÈTTFHNFOUPT


-PRVFFOFMGPOEPTVQPOÓBEFKBSEFMBEPMBWJTJØOEFMPTQSPDFTBMJTUBTTPCSFMPTQSPCMFNBT
KVEJDJBMFTQBSBVUJMJ[BSMBEFMPTFYQFSUPTFOHFTUJØO 7"3("47*"/$0 +"Eficiencia en la
justicia. Op. cit.QQ


IbidemQQ4PCSFFMmOQÞCMJDPEFMBKVSJTEJDDJØOQPSUPEPT$06563& &+Proyecto
de Código de Procedimiento Civil.POUFWJEFP Q

4FIBTPTUFOJEPRVFQBSBBMJWJBSZSBDJPOBMJ[BSMBDBSHBEFUSBCBKPEFMPTUSJCVOBMFTZFWJUBS
MB iSFHSFTJWJEBE EFM HBTUP FO KVTUJDJBw IBZ RVF QSFPDVQBSTF QPS DPOUSPMBS MB EFNBOEB  Z OP
TPMBNFOUFMBiPGFSUBEFMCJFOwZRVF FOUSFPUSBTGPSNBTEFBMJWJBSBRVFMMBDBSHB BEFNÈTEF
EFTBIPHBS MPT BTVOUPT QVSBNFOUF BENJOJTUSBUJWPT Z BRVFMMPT RVF QVFEFO DBOBMJ[BSTF QPS
NFDBOJTNPTEFSFTPMVDJØOBMUFSOBUJWPT FTNFOFTUFSDPCSBSQPSMPTTFSWJDJPTBUSBWÏTEFMBT
UBTBTKVEJDJBMFT 7"3("47*"/$0 +"Eficiencia en la justicia. Op. cit.QQ
1BSB
VO BOÈMJTJT QSPGVOEP EF MB mMPTPG ÓB FDPOPNJDJTUB Z TVT SFnFKPT FO FM %FSFDIP FO HFOFSBM
.²/%&;  )0 Z .²/%&; ". Globalización y justicia GBTD  #VFOPT "JSFT +" 
***QZTT

7"3("47*"/$0. Eficiencia en la Justicia. Op. cit.QQ

26 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

3.3 Superioridad del sistema de la conciliación - mediación


“valorativa” frente al modelo norteamericano
B &OFMNPEFMPUFØSJDPPSUPEPYPEFMBNFEJBDJØO "%3
FMDPOnJDUPTFSFTVFMWFDPO
QSFTDJOEFODJBEFMBBQMJDBDJØOEFM%FSFDIPZFOBUFODJØOUBOTØMPEFMPTJOUFSFTFT
FO QVHOB  DVZP CBMBODF TF QFSTJHVF  MP DVBM JOEVDF B MBT QBSUFT FOGSFOUBEBT B
BSSJCBS QPSTÓNJTNBT BVOBTPMVDJØOBVUPDPNQVFTUB-BGVHBEFMQSPDFTPOP
TJHOJmDBTBMJSEFMBKVSJTEJDDJØOKVEJDJBMoDPNPFOFMTPNFUJNJFOUPBÈSCJUSPTo 
TJOP MJTBZMMBOBNFOUF TBMJSEFMBKVTUJDJBNJTNB EFTFOUFOEFSTFEFMBKVTUBZ
FRVJUBUJWBDPNQPTJDJØOEFMDPOnJDUP&OCVFOSPNBODF UBOUPDPNPDPOUFOUBSTF
DPOVOBKVTUJDJBiEFTFHVOEBw VOQPCSFTVTUJUVUPEFMBSFTPMVDJØOKVEJDJBMZ NÈT
BÞO VOBSFUJSBEBEFMBKVSJTEJDDJØO.
 &ODPOUSBQPTJDJØO MPTmOFTQÞCMJDPTEFMQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMZ DPOTFDVFOUFNFOUF 
MBNJTJØOEFMPTKVFDFToDPNPBmSNB'JTToFTIBDFSKVTUJDJB EBSGVFS[BZIBDFS
SFBMJEBE MPT WBMPSFT DPOUFOJEPT FO MB $POTUJUVDJØO Z MB MFZ &O MB DPODJMJBDJØO 
FODBNCJP BVORVFMPTDPOUFOEJFOUFTDSFBOJOEFMJCFSBEBNFOUFRVFFMBDVFSEP
TBUJTGBDFTVTFYQFDUBUJWBT CJFOQPESÓBOIBCFSBSSJCBEPBMNJTNPTJORVFDPOFMMP
TFIVCJFSFIFDIPKVTUJDJB
C -BUFPSÓBEFMBSFTPMVDJØOEFDPOnJDUPTRVFTVCZBDFFOMPTNFEJPTBMUFSOBUJWPT
QSFTVQPOFEFNBOFSBJNQMÓDJUBRVFFOUSFMPTDPOUFOEJFOUFTFYJTUFVOBSFMBDJØO
EFJHVBMEBE-BDPODJMJBDJØOEFJOUFSFTFTTFDPODJCFDPNPVOBBOUJDJQBDJØOEFM
SFTVMUBEP EFM KVJDJP  FO MB RVF TF BTVNF RVF TVT UÏSNJOPT TPO TJNQMFNFOUF FM
QSPEVDUPEFMBTQSFEJDDJPOFTEFMBTQBSUFTBDFSDBEFFTFSFTVMUBEP4JOFNCBSHP
oTF×BMB BDFSUBEBNFOUF 0 'JTTo  MB BMVEJEB DPODJMJBDJØO EF MPT JOUFSFTFT FTUÈ
DPOEJDJPOBEBFOSFBMJEBEFOGVODJØOEFMPTSFDVSTPTFOHFOFSBMEFRVFEJTQPOF
DBEBQBSUFQPSBTVNJSFMQSPDFTP MPTDVBMFT DPOGSFDVFODJB FTUÈOEJTUSJCVJEPTFO
NBOFSBEFTJHVBM&MMPBGFDUBSÈJOFWJUBCMFNFOUFFMQSPDFTPEFOFHPDJBDJØOQPSMB
TJUVBDJØOEFEFTJHVBMEBEEFMBQBSUFNFOPTGBWPSFDJEBZQPSMBNFOPSDBQBDJEBE
QBSB PCUFOFS Z BOBMJ[BS MB JOGPSNBDJØO OFDFTBSJB  ZB TFB QPS MB VSHFODJB RVF
QVFEB USBFS DPOTJHP TV SFDMBNP P QPS MB JNQPTJCJMJEBE EF DPTUFBS VO QSPDFTP
KVEJDJBM4JCJFOMBEFTJHVBMEBEEFMBTQBSUFTUBNCJÏOQVFEFEJTUPSTJPOBSFMQSPQJP
QSPDFTPKVEJDJBM FOFTUFRVFEBTJFNQSFMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFRVFMBJOUFSWFODJØOEFM
KVF[DPOUSJCVZBBEJTNJOVJS BMVUJMJ[BSMBTEJWFSTBTUÏDOJDBTQSPDFTBMFT FMJNQBDUP


#*"7"5* 1Tendencias recientes de la justicia civil en Europa… Ob. cit.QQ7*(03*5* 
7 Giustizia e futuro: conciliazione e class actionO4ÉP1BVMP3F1SP QQ


'*44 0i$POUSBMBDPODJMJBDJØOw. &O: El derecho como razón públicaUSBE&3FTUSFQP4BMEB-
SSJBHB.BESJEo#BSDFMPOB#VFOPT"JSFT.BSDJBM1POT Q

IbidemQQ

IbidemQQ

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 27


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

EF BRVFMMBT EFTJHVBMEBEFT &O SFBMJEBE  MB DSFDJFOUF VUJMJ[BDJØO EF MPT NFEJPT
BMUFSOBUJWPTDPOTUJUVZFVOJOEJDBEPSFMPDVFOUFEFMBUFOEFODJBBMBQSJWBUJ[BDJØO
EFMBKVTUJDJBFTUBUBM.
D &MQSPCMFNBDFOUSBMRVFQMBOUFBMBNFEJBDJØOFTFMEFMBJOTVmDJFODJBBCTPMVUB
DPNPNFEJPEFSFTPMVDJØOEFMBTEJTQVUBTQBSBMMFWBSBDBCPVOBBEFDVBEBUVUFMB
EFMPTEFSFDIPTJOWPMVDSBEPT&MQSJODJQJPEFMBiOFVUSBMJEBEwEFMPTNFEJBEPSFT 
FTFODJBMBMPCKFUJWPEFRVFMBTQBSUFTZTØMPFMMBTBMDBODFO FODVBMRVJFSDBTP TFB
DPNPGVFSF FMBDVFSEP DPOEVDFJOFWJUBCMFNFOUFBRVFTFBSSJCF BNFOVEP B
TPMVDJPOFTJOKVTUBT OPTØMPQPSRVFOPTFUJFOFFODVFOUBMBEJNFOTJØOKVSÓEJDB
EFMDPOnJDUP TJOPUBNCJÏOQPSRVFTFQPTJCJMJUBRVFMBQBSUFNÈTGVFSUFUFSNJOF
JNQPOJFOEPMPTUÏSNJOPTEFMBDVFSEP-PRVFFTQFPS OBEJFTFSÈSFTQPOTBCMF
EF MB QÏSEJEB EF MPT EFSFDIPT P EF MBT DIBODFT EF MB QBSUF EFTGBWPSFDJEB FO MB
SFMBDJØOZBOPFTUÈOMPTKVFDFTOJFM&TUBEPQBSBSFTQPOEFSQPSEFGFDUPTEFMB
QSFTUBDJØOTFSWJDJBM

3.4 La mediación “facilitadora” no se compadece con el sistema


de valores y creencias que prevalece en nuestra sociedad
actual
B -BT GPSNBT EF SFTPMVDJØO EF DPOnJDUPT SFnFKBO MB DVMUVSB EF CBTF EF VOB
DPNVOJEBE oTVT WBMPSFT  TVT DPOWFODJPOFT TPDJBMFT Z MPT TÓNCPMPT B USBWÏT
EF MPT DVÈMFT TF SFQSFTFOUBOo &TB SFMBDJØO FT SFDÓQSPDB  MPT NÏUPEPT QBSB MB
SFTPMVDJØOEFMBTEJTQVUBTTPOVOGBDUPSEFJNQPSUBODJBFOMBUBSFBJOBDBCBEBEF
iDPOmHVSBSwMBDVMUVSBFOMBDVBMTFJOTFSUBO FOFMTFOUJEPEFRVFMPTDBNCJPTFO
MB MJUJHJPTJEBE SFQFSDVUJSÈO FO MB NJTNB DVMUVSB %F BIÓ RVF DVBMRVJFS SFGPSNB
QSPDFTBMUSBTDFOEFOUFOPQVFEFTFSDPOTJEFSBEBÞOJDBNFOUFEFTEFFMQSJTNBEFM
UFDOJDJTNPMFHBM.
C $PODSFUBNFOUFFOSFMBDJØOBMBNFEJBDJØO QBSFDFOÓUJEPRVFFMFNQF×PEFTV
JNQPTJDJØOPCMJHBUPSJBOPQVFEFEFTFOUFOEFSTFEFMBFYJTUFODJBFOUSFOPTPUSPT
EFVOBGVFSUFDVMUVSBUSBEJDJPOBMRVFIBTJEPSFGSBDUBSJB QPSSB[POFTNÞMUJQMFT B
TVBENJTJØO4FUSBUB QSFDJTBNFOUF QVFEFBSHVNFOUBSTF EFQVKBSQBSBQFSNFBS 
USBOTGPSNBSFTBDVMUVSBZTVTUJUVJSMBQPSPUSBEFTJHOPPQVFTUP4JOFNCBSHP FM
JOUFSSPHBOUFDFOUSBMTJHVFTJFOEP{FTBDVMUVSBOVFWBBDPNQB×BZTFTVTUFOUBFO
MPTWBMPSFTZDSFFODJBTQSFEPNJOBOUFT FOFTUPTUJFNQPT FOOVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFT 
0 NÈTTJNQMFNFOUF FOUÏSNJOPTRVFQMBOUFB$IBTF {MBJEFBRVFUSBOTNJUFMB


(*--&4 1Civil Justice Sistems and Civil Procedures in conversión…QQ

5"36''0 .Una alternativa a las alternativas… Op. cit.QQ

$)"4& 0Ob. cit.QQ  

28 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

NFEJBDJØOSFTQFDUPBMBBEFDVBEBPSEFOBDJØOEFMBTPDJFEBEFOTVDPOKVOUP FT
BDFQUBCMF .
D 4FOUBEB MB SFDÓQSPDB Z QSPGVOEB DPOFYJØO FOUSF DVMUVSB Z NFEJPT EF TPMVDJØO
EF DPOnJDUPT  DBCF BGSPOUBS MB SFNBOJEB DVFTUJØO EF MB iDVMUVSB EFM MJUJHJPw P
iEF MPT EFSFDIPTw GSFOUF B MB iDVMUVSB BMUFSOBUJWB EF MB QBDJmDBDJØOw P iEF MPT
JOUFSFTFTw%FCFNPTDPNFO[BSQPSBENJUJSRVFFOVOBTPDJFEBEMJCSFZQMVSBMMPT
DPOnJDUPTQVFEFOTFSSFTVFMUPTFONPEPTEJWFSTPTZMBFMFDDJØOEFVOBVPUSBWÓB
EFQFOEFFYDMVTJWBNFOUFEFMBWPMVOUBEEFMPTQSPQJPTJOUFSFTBEPT)BZSB[POFT 
ZTPCSFUPEPDJSDVOTUBODJBToGÈDUJDBTZKVSÓEJDBTo RVFIBDFOQSFGFSJCMF QPSSFHMB 
FMDBNJOPEFMBKVSJTEJDDJØORVFDPOEVDFBMBTFOUFODJB&ODBNCJP DVBOEPTF
USBUB EF DJFSUPT Z EFUFSNJOBEPT DPOnJDUPT oSFMBDJPOFT EF GBNJMJB  EF WFDJOEBE 
EFDPFYJTUFODJBMJEBEFOHFOFSBM ZEFNFOPSDVBOUÓBo FMTFOEFSPEFMPTNFEJPT
BMUFSOBUJWPTSFTVMUBNÈTQSPQJDJP
&O MB NFEJBDJØO MB SB[ØO  MB DVMQB P FM FSSPS TF iEJTVFMWFOw QBSB GVOEJSTF FO MB
QPOEFSBDJØOEFMPTJOUFSFTFT4FFWJUBODJFSUBNFOUFMPTSJFTHPTZEFTWFOUVSBTEFM
QSPDFTP QFSPIBZRVFSFTJHOBSTFBMBOPKVTUJDJB&TQPTJCMFRVFTFBÞUJMQBSB
SFDVQFSBSMBGFSFDÓQSPDBZBVOFODBSSJMBSMBTSFMBDJPOFTNFMMBEBTQPSFMDPOnJDUP
EJTVFMUPQPSVOSFTVMUBEPTBUJTGBDUPSJPQBSBBNCPT
 4JOFNCBSHP DPNPFYQSFTB#JBWBUJ FMQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMFTUÈEFTUJOBEPmTJPMØHJ-
DBNFOUFBSFHVMBSTØMPMBNÓOJNBQBSUFEFMPTDPOnJDUPTTPDJBMFT QFSPDVBOEPFM
MJUJHJPFTUBOBHVEPDPNPQBSBSFRVFSJSMBJOUFSWFODJØOEFMBKVSJTEJDDJØO OPTF
QVFEFDPNQSJNJSMBOFDFTJEBEEFMJUJHBS EFNPEPRVFFTOFDFTBSJPFODBSSJMBSMP
FOMBTWÓBTEFVOBPSEFOBEBDPOGSPOUBDJØOKVEJDJBM1PSPUSPMBEP ZRVJ[ÈTMPNÈT
JNQPSUBOUF OVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFTNBOJmFTUBOVOBGVFSUFOFDFTJEBEEFMFHBMJEBE
-BQÏSEJEBEFMPTWBMPSFTQÞCMJDPTZEFMCJFODPNÞO FOOPNCSFEFVOJOUFSÏT
QSJWBEPRVFTFQFSTJHVFBUPEBDPTUB FTDPOTFDVFODJBUBNCJÏOEFMBEFDBEFODJB
EFMBGVFS[BEFMBMFZZEFMBGBMUBEFBQUJUVEQBSBBQMJDBSMB&MQSPDFTPKVSJTEJD-
DJPOBMEFTFNQF×BFMSPMEFEFDJSFMEFSFDIPZEFSFDPSEBSRVÏDPTBFTKVTUBZMÓDJUB
ZRVÏDPTBOPMPFTQBSBMBDPNVOJEBE4FUSBUBEFVOSPMFTFODJBMBMRVFOPTF
QVFEFSFOVODJBS.
E -B DVMUVSB iBEWFSTBSJBMw  IB EF BENJUJSTF  QVFEF Z EFCF DPOWJWJS DPO BRVFMMB
DPNQMFNFOUBSJBEFMBDPPQFSBDJØOQBDJmDBEPSB6OBZPUSBJOUFHSBOFMTJTUFNB


Ibidem.Q

Ibidem.Q

#*"7"5*  1 Argomenti di Diritto Processuale Civile #PMPHOB #POPOJB 6OJW 1SFTT  
QQ&OTFOUJEPTJNJMBS(6;.«/ /-Análisis crítico de la implementación de
los métodos alternativos de solución de conflictos #VFOPT"JSFT3%1 QQZTT 
FTQFDJBMNFOUFQQ"TJNJTNP$0.0(-*0 -1Mezzi alternativi di tutela e garanzie
costituzionale3JW%JS1SPD $FEBN 1BEPWB Q

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 29


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

EFSFTPMVDJØOEF MBTDPOUSPWFSTJBT&YJTUFDPOTFOTPTPDJBMBMSFTQFDUP ZFMMPIB


TJEPFMMPHSPZMBUSBOTGPSNBDJØORVFPQFSBEFTEFMPTB×PTOPWFOUB
 /PPCTUBOUF OPQPESÓBBmSNBSTFRVFJHVBMDPOTFOTPTPDJBMTFIVCJFSFHFOFSBEP
FO UPSOP B MB NFEJBDJØO iGBDJMJUBEPSBw 1PS FM DPOUSBSJP  QVFEF BTFWFSBSTF RVF
FTFNÏUPEPWBBDPOUSBQFMPEFMPTQSJODJQJPTZWBMPSFTDPNVOJUBSJPTSFDPHJEPT
Z FYQSFTBEPT FO MB $POTUJUVDJØO Z FM 1BDUP EF 4BO +PTÏ RVF MB JOUFHSB  WÈMJEPT
Z FYJHJCMFT en lo sustantivo para todas las formas de solución de conflictos,
incluyendo a la regulación de la mediación &O FM CBMBODF EF MPT WBMPSFT Z
QSJODJQJPT JNQMJDBEPT  IBO EF QSFWBMFDFS BRVFMMPT EF KVTUJDJB F JHVBMEBE RVF
DPOGPSNBOZTFFYQSFTBOFOFMiOÞDMFPEVSPwEFMBTHBSBOUÓBTZ FOFTQFDJBM FM
EFSFDIPBMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBZBMBDDFTPJSSFTUSJDUPBMBKVTUJDJB
 /JOHVOBEFMBTWFOUBKBTRVFTFBEKVEJDBOBMBNFEJBDJØOQVSBNFOUFiBTJTUJEBw 
EFDPODFSUBDJØOEFMPTJOUFSFTFT KVTUJmDBEJTQFOTBSMBQFSTFDVDJØOEFBRVFMMPT
WBMPSFTZQSJODJQJPT&MDJVEBEBOPUJFOFMBQSFSSPHBUJWB DVBOEPFTUÈFOKVFHPFM
SFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFTVTEFSFDIPTWVMOFSBEPT EFVUJMJ[BSFMNÏUPEPEFDPNQP-
TJDJØONÈTBEFDVBEP1FSPBM&TUBEP$POTUJUVDJPOBMEF%FSFDIPMFFTUÈWFEBEP
QSPQJDJBSQSPDFEJNJFOUPT DVBMFTRVJFSBGVFSFO RVFMPFNCSFUFOFOFTRVFNBT
SFEVDUPSFTRVFOPQVFEBOBTFHVSBSMFTPMVDJPOFTKVTUBTZFRVJUBUJWBT&TRVFMB
NFEJBDJØOOFVUSBMEFJOUFSFTFT BMDPMPDBSTFiEFFTQBMEBTwBM%FSFDIP SFOVODJB
BMBNJTJØOQÞCMJDBFTFODJBM RVFDPSSFTQPOEFBMÓOUFHSPTJTUFNBEFKVTUJDJBEFM
RVFGPSNBQBSUF EFFTDMBSFDFSBMBDPNVOJEBEFOSFMBDJØOBMPTDBTPTDPODSFUPT
BDFSDB EF RVÏ DPOEVDUB P TJUVBDJØO FT KVTUB Z MFHÓUJNB Z DVÈM OP MP FT  QBSB
EBSTJHOJmDBEPBMPTWBMPSFTQÞCMJDPT&TUPFTUBOUPDPNPSFTJHOBSMBGVODJØO
DPOTUSVDUJWB EF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT KVSÓEJDBT Z MB JOnVFODJB EF MBT EFDJTJPOFT FO
MBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOBMFT MPRVFDPOmSNBMBWJODVMBDJØOSFDÓQSPDBFOUSF
MJUJHJPTJEBE Z DVMUVSB  UBOUP DPNP MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MBT BDUVBDJPOFT QSPDFEJ-
NFOUBMFT FO DVBOUP B TV SFQFSDVTJØO FO FM NBOUFOJNJFOUP EF MBT DSFFODJBT Z
DPOWFODJPOFT TPDJBMFT -B JEFB RVF USBOTNJUF MB NFEJBDJØO EF JOUFSFTFT  FO
EFmOJUJWB DPMJTJPOBDPOMBBEFDVBEBPSEFOBDJØOEFMBTPDJFEBEFOTVDPOKVOUP 
QBSBVTBSMBZBSFGFSJEBFYQSFTJØOEF$IBTF

4. Algunas experiencias superadoras que se destacan en la


legislación comparada
%FFOUSFMBBNQMÓTJNBHBNBEFNPEFMPTRVFNVFTUSBFM%FSFDIP$PNQBSBEP 
SFTVMUBDPOEVDFOUFSFTBMUBSBMHVOBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTOPWFEPTBTUÓQJDBTEFMFHJTMBDJPOFT
EFMTJTUFNBEFMcivil lawDPOUJOFOUBMFVSPQFP DPNPTPOMBTEF*UBMJBZ"MFNBOJB 
Z  QPS PUSP MBEP  BRVFMMBT QSPQJBT EFM common law JOHMÏT 1SFTFOUBO UPEBT FMMBT


'*44 0Ob. cit.Q

$)"4& 0Ob. cit.QQ 

30 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

QBSUJDVMBSFT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT RVF EFTQJFSUBO OVFTUSP JOUFSÏT EF DPOGSPOUBDJØO DPO


OVFTUSBTJOTUJUVDJPOFT
4.1&OFMPSEFOBNJFOUPJUBMJBOPDPOTBHSBEPQPSFMEFDSFUPMFHJTMBUJWPO¡ EFMEF
NBS[PEF FOJNQMFNFOUBDJØOEFMB%JSFDUJWBEFMB6OJØO&VSPQFBEFMEF
NBZPEF TFJOUSPEVDFMBEFOPNJOBEBmediación estructurada29PJOTUJUVDJPOBM
RVF FOMPRVFBRVÓJOUFSFTB QVFEFTFSEJTQVFTUBQPSFMKVF[ UPEBWF[RVFEVSBOUFFM
EFTBSSPMMPEFMQSPDFTPDPOTJEFSFEFVUJMJEBE BSU¡ JOD¡
&TUBQSFTFOUBMBQBSUJDV-
MBSJEBEEFQPOFSFMBDFOUPFOMBDPNQSPCBDJØOGÈDUJDBEFMPTEFSFDIPTRVFJOWPDBO
MBT QBSUFT " FTF mO  TF BENJUF FO MB JOTUBODJB EF NFEJBDJØO MB QSFTFOUBDJØO EF
EPDVNFOUPTZPUSBTQSVFCBT FOFTQFDJBMMBTQFSJDJBMFT JODMVJEBTMBTDPNQSPCBDJPOFT
FTQFDJBMJ[BEBT BSU¡ JOD¡BSU JOD¡ZDPODPSEBOUFT
-PTBDVFSEPTBSSJCBEPT
SFRVJFSFOIPNPMPHBDJØOKVEJDJBM BDUPRVFOPTFBHPUBFOMBNFSBWFSJmDBDJØOEFMB
SFHVMBSJEBEGPSNBMEFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPT TJOPRVFTFJOUFHSBDPOMBDPOTUBUBDJØO
EFRVFTVDPOUFOJEPOPFTDPOUSBSJPBMPSEFOQÞCMJDPPBOPSNBTJNQFSBUJWBT BSU

&OTVNB TFFTUSVDUVSBVOTJTUFNBRVFTFBMFKBEFNPEPQBMNBSJPEFMBTJNQMF
NFEJBDJØOiGBDJMJUBEPSBw CJFORVFMBJOUFSWFODJØOMFHJTMBUJWBWJFOFHFOFSBOEPWJWBT
EJTQVUBTEPDUSJOBSJBT.
4.2 5BNCJÏO  DJFSUBNFOUF FO MBT BOUÓQPEBT EFM TJTUFNB OPSUFBNFSJDBOP  BVORVF
QPSSB[POFTEJWFSTBT TFVCJDBFMNPEFMPEFTBSSPMMBEPFOMBMFHJTMBDJØOBMFNBOB-B
UFOEFODJBIBDJBMBQSJWBUJ[BDJØONFEJBOUFMBBEPQDJØOEFMPT"%3OPUVWPNBZPS
SFDFQUJWJEBE  FOUSF PUSPT NPUJWPT oTFHÞO TF BmSNBo  QPSRVF FM QSPDFTP KVEJDJBM
PSEJOBSJP GVODJPOB BEFDVBEBNFOUF Z  QPS MP EFNÈT  PGSFDF EFOUSP EF TVT QSPQJPT
FOHSBOBKFT TVmDJFOUFT QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF DPNQPTJDJØO BNJHBCMF 4PO MPT QSPQJPT
USJCVOBMFTMPTRVFFYUJOHVFOQPSUSBOTBDDJØOFOUSFFMWFJOUFQPSDJFOUPZFMUSFJOUBQPS
DJFOUPEFMPTMJUJHJPT&MQSPDFEJNJFOUPDPODJMJBUPSJPFTUÈSFHVMBEPFOFMf;10Z
TFEFTBSSPMMBBUSBWÏTEFMEJÈMPHPFOUSFFMKVF[ZMBTQBSUFT FOSFVOJPOFTTFQBSBEBT FO
MBTRVFTFEFTUBDBRVFFOMBBVEJFODJBEFDPODJMJBDJØOFTUFQVFEFJOUFSSPHBSMJCSFNFOUF
BMBTQBSUFTDPOFMmOEFMFTDMBSFDJNJFOUPEFMBDVFTUJØOMJUJHJPTB*HVBMNFOUF TJMBT
QBSUFT OP QSFTFOUBO VOB QSPQVFTUB EF USBOTBDDJØO QPS FTDSJUP  FM QSPQJP USJCVOBM


#*"7"5* 1Argomenti… Ob. citQQZTT&OSFMBDJØOBMSÏHJNFOBOUFSJPSFODPOGSPO-
UBDJØODPOMBTHBSBOUÓBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT$0.0(-*0 -1Mezzi alternativi… Ob. cit.QQ
ZTT

7*(03*5*  7 Ob. cit Q  &M SÏHJNFO EF SFGFSFODJB OP JOTUJUVZF VOB NFEJBDJØO DMÈTJ-
DBNFOUFFOUFOEJEB TJOPVOJOTUSVNFOUPBUSBWÏTEFMDVBMTFJOEVDFBMBTQBSUFTFODPOnJDUP
BBDFQUBSVOBQSPQVFTUBEFDPODJMJBDJØOFYQSFTBEBQPSVOUFSDFSP %"--"#0/5« 4i-B
PSJHJOBMBDUVBDJØOFO*UBMJBEFMB%JSFDUJWB$&yw&O: Civil Procedure ReviewW O
 QQZTT%JTQPOJCMFFOXXXDJWJMQSPDFEVSFSFWJFXDPN


7*(03*5*7Ob. cit.QQ#*"7"5* 1Argomenti… Ob. cit.Q

45Ã3/&3 3Sobre as reformas recentes no direito alemäo…4ÉP1BVMP3F1SP O¡ 
QQZTT 

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 31


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

QVFEFIBDFSMP f BQBSU


&MBDVFSEPIPNPMPHBEPDPOTUJUVZFUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWP
fBQBSU
-BTBUJTGBDDJØODPOFMTJTUFNBQBSFDFTFSHSBOEF QPSRVFMBTQBSUFT
SBSBNFOUFSFDVSSFOBMBNFEJBDJØOQSJWBEB TJOPRVFQSFmFSFOOFHPDJBSBOUFVOKVF[
FTUBUBMFOFMNBSDPEFVOBJOTUSVDDJØOKVEJDJBMDPNQMFUB4ØMPFOBMHVOPTDBNQPT
FTQFDJBMFT Z  QPS FMMP  SFTJEVBMFT IB UFOJEP TVDFTP MB NFEJBDJØO QSJWBEB  BTÓ FO MBT
DVFTUJPOFTEFGBNJMJBZEJWPSDJP.
.ÈT BMMÈ EF MBT OPUPSJBT TJOHVMBSJEBEFT EFM FTRVFNB HFSNÈOJDP  QBSFDF TJHOJ-
mDBUJWP SFTBMUBS MB SFJWJOEJDBDJØO RVF TVQPOF  FO UBOUP RVF TVTUFOUB MB TPMVDJØO
BNJTUPTBFOMBQSPQJBTFEFKVEJDJBM CBKPHFTUJØOEFMKVF[ RVFBMBDUVBSTFHÞOTViMJCSF
DPOWJDDJØOwQVFEFMMFHBSBQSPQPOFSBDVFSEPTUSBOTBDDJPOBMFT&TFOFMNBSDPEFMB
JOTUSVDDJØOEFMQSPDFTPRVFTFGBDJMJUBMBCÞTRVFEBEFMBDPODJMJBDJØO RVF TJCJFO
EFQFOEF FOUFSBNFOUF EF MB WPMVOUBE EF MBT QBSUFT  OP RVFEB DPOEJDJPOBEB QPS FM
EFTDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBTJUVBDJØOGÈDUJDBPEFMBTDIBODFTRVFFOFMQMBOPKVSÓEJDPTPO
EFDJTJWBTQBSBFMBDJFSUP FOUÏSNJOPTEFKVTUJDJB EFMSFTVMUBEP/PQPESÓBBmSNBSTF
RVF FM BDVFSEP BTÓ MPHSBEP RVFEF iEF FTQBMEBT B MB KVTUJDJBw  OJ RVF MB USBOTBDDJØO
BTJTUJEBKVEJDJBMNFOUFGVFSFVOTJNQMFTVDFEÈOFPiEFTFHVOEBw
4.3 6O NPEFMP OP NFOPT TJOHVMBS QFSP RVF FODVBESB FO MBT MÓOFBT UFOEFODJBMFT
QSFWBMFDJFOUFT  OP PCTUBOUF JOTFSUBSTF FO MB USBEJDJØO EFM common law  FT FM RVF
TF BSUJDVMB FO *OHMBUFSSB  DPO SFTVMUBEPT BMUBNFOUF TBUJTGBDUPSJPT  FO UBOUP RVF MB
USBOTBDDJØOFTFMFQÓMPHPNÈTGSFDVFOUFEFMBTDPOUSPWFSTJBT HSBDJBTBVOBQPMÓUJDB
QÞCMJDBEFQSPNPDJØOEFMBDVMUVSBEFMBTTPMVDJPOFTBVUPDPNQVFTUBT RVFTFSFnFKB
FOEJWFSTPTNPNFOUPT:BFOMBGBTFQSFQSPDFTBM MPTpre - action protocolsSFHVMBO
MBT USBUBUJWBT FODBNJOBEBT BM MPHSP EF MB USBOTBDDJØO  DPNP VOP EF TVT PCKFUJWPT
QSJODJQBMFT'SBDBTBEPFMJOUFOUPFJOJDJBEPFMQSPDFTP FM$13EFFOGBUJ[BMB
OFDFTJEBEEFRVFUBOUPFMKVF[DPNPMPTBCPHBEPTJNQVMTFOVOBUSBOTBDDJØO-PT
EFCFSFTEFMUSJCVOBMJODMVZFOMBPCMJHBDJØO QSPQJBEFMcase management EFBTJTUJSB
MBTQBSUFTBFTPTmOFT BEFNÈT FMBTVOUPQVFEFEFSJWBSBBMHVOPEFMPTNFEJPTBMUFS-
OBUJWPTFTQFDÓmDPT "%3
JODMVJEBMBJOUFSWFODJØOBTPMJDJUVEEFQBSUFEFVOUFSDFSP
OFVUSBM early neutral evaluation)1BSBGPS[BSBMBTQBSUFTSFNJTBTBMBVUJMJ[BDJØOEF
FTPTNFDBOJTNPT DVBOEPFMKVF[MPTDPOTJEFSBDPNPMBBMUFSOBUJWBNÈTQSPQJDJB TF
BENJUFMBQPTUFSHBDJØOFOTVDBTPEFMUSÈNJUFEFMQSPDFTP%FUPEPTNPEPToDPNP


Ibidem.Q"TJNJTNP1²3&;3"(0/& "+Z035*;13"%*--0 +$Código Procesal
Civil alemán (ZPO) .POUFWJEFP , "EFOBVFS 4UJGUVOH   QQ    )""4  6 Z
#0$6$$* %Il rapporto tra il giudice e le parti nell diritto tedescoO¡4ÉP1BVMP3F1SP 
QQZTT

45Ã3/&3 3Ob. cit.Q%FUPEPTNPEPT DPOSFGFSFODJBBMPTSFTVMUBEPTQSÈDUJDPTEFMPT
NFEJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTZFMHSBEPEFDBMJEBEBMDBO[BEPFODPNQBSBDJØODPOMPTRVFTFBTJHOBBM
TJTUFNBKVEJDJBMPmDJBM IBCSÈRVFDPOWFOJSRVFFYJTUFOEJmDVMUBEFTDBTJJOTBMWBCMFTQBSBVOB
FWBMVBDJØOSBDJPOBM$POG,&3/ $"Percepçâo, perfomance e política: recentes formas de
abordagem da comparaçâo qualitativa dos sistemas de justica civilO¡4ÉP1BVMP3F1SP 
QQZTT

32 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

TFIBTPTUFOJEPoSFTVMUBGVOEBNFOUBMDPNQSFOEFSRVFMBDPODJMJBDJØOOPIBEFUFOFS
MVHBSiBMBTPNCSBEFM%FSFDIPw RVFFTUBOUPDPNPEFDJSRVFTVSFTVMUBEPOPQVFEF
TFSJOKVTUPBMBWJTUBEFM%FSFDIP
4.4"IPSB WFSFNPTVOBSFGFSFODJBTJRVJFSBTVDJOUBBMSÏHJNFORVFDPOTBHSBFM$1$
CSBTJMF×P FO WJHPS EFTEF  &OUSF TVT NÞMUJQMFT OPWFEBEFT TF FTUBCMFDF DPNP
QPMÓUJDBQÞCMJDBRVFMPTUSJCVOBMFTDSFBSÈODFOUSPTKVEJDJBMFTEFTPMVDJØODPOTFOTVBM
EFDPOnJDUPT SFTQPOTBCMFTQPSMBSFBMJ[BDJØOEFTFTJPOFTZBVEJFODJBTEFDPODJMJBDJØO
ZNFEJBDJØOZQPSFMEFTFOWPMWJNJFOUPEFQSPHSBNBTEFTUJOBEPTBBVYJMJBS PSJFOUBS
ZFTUJNVMBSMBBVUPDPNQPTJDJØO&TUBUVZFFMSÏHJNFOTJOHVMBSEFMPTDPODJMJBEPSFTZ
NFEJBEPSFTDPNPBVYJMJBSFTEFMBKVTUJDJB $1$ BSU
4FSFHVMBVOBBVEJFODJB
PCMJHBUPSJBEFDPODJMJBDJØOPEFNFEJBDJØOFOTFEFKVEJDJBMBOUFTEFMBQSFTFOUBDJØO
EFMBEFGFOTBEFMEFNBOEBEP DPOMBmOBMJEBEEFFTUJNVMBSMBTPMVDJØODPOTFOTVBM
EFMPTMJUJHJPT BSU
TJOQFSKVJDJPEFMBNFEJBDJØOQSFWJBPFYUSBKVEJDJBMBRVF
QVFEFO TPNFUFSTF MPT JOUFSFTBEPT 4J MB QFUJDJØO JOJDJBM TF BKVTUB B MPT SFRVJTJUPT
FTFODJBMFTZOPGVFSFFMDBTPEFJNQSPDFEFODJBMJNJOBS FMKVF[EFTJHOBSÈBVEJFODJB
EFDPODJMJBDJØOPEFNFEJBDJØODPOBOUFMBDJØONÓOJNBEFUSFJOUBEÓBT&MDPODJMJBEPS
PNFEJBEPS RVFFTVOBVYJMJBSEFMKVF[ BSU f
BDUVBSÈOFDFTBSJBNFOUFFOMB
BVEJFODJB TJOQFSKVJDJPEFMBJOUFSWFODJØOEFBRVFMFODJFSUPTTVQVFTUPTEFFYDFQDJØO
&O FM DVSTP EFM QSPDFEJNJFOUP TF PCTFSWBSÈO MPT QSJODJQJPT EF JOEFQFOEFODJB 
JNQBSDJBMJEBE  BVUPOPNÓB EF MB WPMVOUBE  DPOmEFODJBMJEBE  PSBMJEBE  JOGPSNBMJEBE
Z EF EFDJTJØO JOGPSNBEB BSUT  Z TT
 -B JODPNQBSFDFODJB JOKVTUJmDBEB EF
DVBMRVJFSBEFMBTQBSUFTBMBBVEJFODJBTFDPOTJEFSBBDUPBUFOUBUPSJPBMBEJHOJEBEEF
MBKVTUJDJBZTBODJPOBEPDPONVMUB0CUFOJEBMBBVUPDPNQPTJDJØO TFSÈIPNPMPHBEB
QPSTFOUFODJB BSU f
4FFTUJNBRVFMBDPODJMJBDJØOFTMBIFSSBNJFOUBNÈT
BEFDVBEBQBSBMPTDPOnJDUPTQVSBNFOUFQBUSJNPOJBMFTFMDPODJMJBEPSQVFEFTVHFSJS
TPMVDJPOFTQBSBFMMJUJHJP&ODBNCJP MBNFEJBDJØOFTUÈQFOTBEBQBSBMBTIJQØUFTJT
EF DPOnJDUPT SFGFSJEPT B SFMBDJPOFT EF DPOUJOVJEBE  EF iDPFYJTUFODJBMJEBEw  DPO
FM PCKFUJWP QSJODJQBM EF QSFTFSWBS P SFTUBVSBS MPT WÓODVMPT FOUSF MBT QBSUFT EF BIÓ
RVFFMNFEJBEPSMBTBVYJMJBQBSBRVFJEFOUJmRVFO QPSTÓ BMUFSOBUJWBTEFCFOFmDJP
NVUVP BSUffZ
&OUSFMBTQSJNFSBTFWBMVBDJPOFTEFMOVFWPTJTUFNB TFIB


"/%3&84  / i0 NPEFSOP QSPDFTP DJWJM GPSNBT KVEJDJBJT F BMUFSOBUJWBT EF SFTPMVÎÉP EF
DPOnJUPTOB*OHMBUFSSBwUSBE5"SSVEB"MWJN8BNCJFSRev. dos Trib.4ÉP1BVMP QQ
ZTTid. Controversie colettive, tranzacione e conciliazione in Inghilterra 3F1SP O 
QQZTTid. Relaçôes entre a Corte e as partes na era do case managementO¡4ÉP
1BVMP3F1SP  QQZTT

."3*/0/* -("3&/)"35 4$Z.*5*%*&30 %Curso de Processo Civil. Ob. cit.W 
QQ

1*/)0  )%# EF A mediaçâo judicial no novo CPC FO Desvendando o novo CPC %(
3JCFJSPZ.'+PCJNPSH1PSUP"MFHSF-JW%P"CWPHBEPFE QQZTT FTQFDJBMNFOUF 
QQ    "336%" "-7*. 8".#*&3  5 i1SJNFJSPT DPNFOUBSJPT BP /PWP $ØEJHP EF
1SPDFTTP$JWJMw&O: Rev. dos Tribunais.4ÉP1BVMP QQ

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 33


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

BmSNBEPRVFOPQBSFDFTFSJEFBMMBTPMVDJØORVFQSFDPOJ[BBQFOBTVOTJTUFNBEF
NFEJBDJØOJODJEFOUBMDVBOEPZBIBTJEPQVFTUBFONPWJNJFOUPMBNÈRVJOBKVEJDJBM
"TJNJTNP EFTEFVOTFDUPSEFMBEPDUSJOBTFIBQSPQJDJBEP FOVOBMÓOFBTJNJMBS MB
DSFBDJØOEFVOQSPDFEJNJFOUPQSPCBUPSJPFYUSBKVEJDJBMGBDVMUBUJWP EFTWJODVMBEPEF
MBGVUVSBEFNBOEB DPOMBmOBMJEBEEFJOUFSDBNCJBSJOGPSNBDJPOFTQBSBGBDJMJUBSMB
CÞTRVFEBEFVOBTPMVDJØOOFHPDJBEB TJOMBJOUFSWFODJØOKVEJDJBM%FUPEPTNPEPT 
TFSÈNFOFTUFSFTQFSBSMBBQMJDBDJØOQSÈDUJDBEFMPTOPWFEPTPTNFDBOJTNPT UÓQJDPT
EFM%FSFDIPCSBTJMF×P TJCJFOTFSFDPOPDFTVmMJBDJØOFOMBMFHJTMBDJØOBSHFOUJOBEF
.
4.5 1PS ÞMUJNP  BMHVOBT TPNFSBT DPOTJEFSBDJPOFT BDFSDB EFM SÏHJNFO WJHFOUF FO
$PMPNCJB RVFQVFEFDPOTJEFSBSTFVOCVFOFKFNQMPEFMBFWPMVDJØOEFMPTTJTUFNBT
JCFSPBNFSJDBOPT " QBSUJS EF MB EÏDBEB EF MPT B×PT OPWFOUB EFM TJHMP QBTBEP Z
FTQFDJBMNFOUFDPOMB-FZEF TFFTUBUVZFFMSÏHJNFOBDUVBMNFOUFWJHFOUF 
DPOBMHVOBTNPEJmDBDJPOFT4FFSJHFVOBBVEJFODJBEFDPODJMJBDJØOFYUSBKVEJDJBM
FO EFSFDIP Z FO FRVJEBE DPNP SFRVJTJUP EF QSPDFEJCJMJEBE FO MPT QSPDFTPT
EFDMBSBUJWPT RVF EFCFO USBNJUBSTF B USBWÏT EFM QSPDFEJNJFOUP PSEJOBSJP oBIPSB
QSPDFEJNJFOUPWFSCBM $(1 BSU 
oPBCSFWJBEPoBIPSB WFSCBMTVNBSJP
BSU id.
oZFODJFSUPTQSPDFTPTEFGBNJMJB&TUFQSPDFEJNJFOUPTFMMFWBBDBCP
BOUFMPTDPODJMJBEPSFTEFMPTDFOUSPTEFDPODJMJBDJØO EFMFHBEPTEFMB%FGFOTPSÓB
EFM1VFCMP BHFOUFTEFM.JOJTUFSJP1ÞCMJDPZOPUBSJPT-BEFOPNJOBEBDPODJMJBDJØO
FYUSBKVEJDJBM FO WFSEBE DPOTUJUVZF VOB NFEJBDJØO  FO FM TFOUJEP EF RVF TF USBUB
EFVONFDBOJTNPBUSBWÏTEFMDVBMEPTPNÈTQFSTPOBTHFTUJPOBOQPSTÓNJTNBT
MB SFTPMVDJØO EF TVT EJGFSFODJBT DPO BZVEB EF VO UFSDFSP JNQBSDJBM Z DBMJmDBEP 
EFOPNJOBEPDPODJMJBEPS-BDPODJMJBDJØOKVEJDJBM QPSTVMBEP QVFEFTFSQSPWPDBEB
QPS FM KVF[ FO DVBMRVJFS NPNFOUP EFM QSPDFTP Z UJFOF MVHBS  FTQFDJBMNFOUF  FO
PDBTJØOEFMBBVEJFODJBJOJDJBMPQSFMJNJOBS EPOEFBRVFMiFYIPSUBSÈEJMJHFOUFNFOUF
BMBTQBSUFTBDPODJMJBSTVTEJGFSFODJBT QBSBMPDVBMEFCFSÈQSPQPOFSGØSNVMBTEF
BSSFHMP TJORVFFMMPTJHOJmRVFQSFKV[HBNJFOUPw $(1 BSU JOD
-B-FZ
EF BTVUVSOP FTUBCMFDJØRVFDPOMBTPMJDJUVEEFDPODJMJBDJØOFYUSBKVEJDJBMTF
EFCFBDPNQB×BSDPQJBJOGPSNBMEFMBTQSVFCBTEPDVNFOUBMFTPBOUJDJQBEBTRVFTF
UFOHBFOTVQPEFSZRVFTFQSFUFOEBIBDFSWBMFSFOFMFWFOUVBMQSPDFTP-PBOUFSJPS 
CBKPMBQSFWFODJØOEFRVF TJGSBDBTBSFMBDPODJMJBDJØO OPTFSÈOBENJUJEBTFOBRVFM


1*/)0  )%# EF Ob. cit QQ  Z TT  FTQFDJBMNFOUF  QQ    "336%" "-7*.
8".#*&3 5Primeiros comentarios… Ob. citQQZTT 

(3&$0 - A reforma do direito probatorio no processo civil brasileiro O¡  4ÉP 1BVMP
3F1SP QQZTT

1*/)0 )%#EFOb. citQ

-»1&;#-"/$0 )'Procedimiento Civil. Parte General*OTUJUVDJPOFTEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM
$JWJM$PMPNCJBOP‹FE U*#PHPUÈ%VQSÏFE QQZTT#&+"3"/0(6;.«/ 
R. Procesos declarativos, ejecutivos y arbitralesBFE#PHPUÈ5FNJT QQZTT

34 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

BSU
"EFNÈT MBJODPNQBSFDFODJBOPFYDVTBEBBMBBVEJFODJBDPOMMFWBRVFiTF
DPOTJEFSBSÈ DPNP JOEJDJP HSBWF FO DPOUSB EF TVT QSFUFOTJPOFT P FYDFQDJPOFT EF
NÏSJUPFOVOFWFOUVBMQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMw.
'VFSBEFFMMP SFTVMUBEFJOUFSÏTDPOTJHOBSRVFFM$(1SFHVMBMBTQSVFCBTFYUSB-
QSPDFTBMFT BSUT  B 
 oBOUFT EFOPNJOBEP QSPDFEJNJFOUP QBSB QSVFCBT Z
FYIJCJDJØOBOUJDJQBEBo RVFJODMVZFOFMJOUFSSPHBUPSJPEFQBSUF EFDMBSBDJØOTPCSF
EPDVNFOUPT  FYIJCJDJØO EF EPDVNFOUPT  UFTUJNPOJPT BOUJDJQBEPT  JOTQFDDJPOFT
KVEJDJBMFTZQFSJDJBMFT&OUPEPTMPTTVQVFTUPTOPTFSFRVJFSFVSHFODJBFJODMVTPTF
QVFEFOQSBDUJDBSEJDIBTNFEJEBTQSPCBUPSJBTEFDPNÞOBDVFSEPGVFSBEFMQSPDFTP
QBSBTFSBQPSUBEBTBOUFTEFMBTFOUFODJB BSU
*NQPSUBTF×BMBSFOSFMBDJØOBMB
QFSJDJBMRVFNJFOUSBTFMBOUFSJPSBSUÓDVMP$1$SFHVMBCBEFNPEPJOEFQFOEJFOUF
FMQFEJEPEFEJDUBNFOEFQFSJUPT DPOPTJOJOTQFDDJØOKVEJDJBM FMUFYUPEFMBSUÓDVMP
$(1MJHBMBJOUFSWFODJØOEFQFSJUPBMBJOTQFDDJØOKVEJDJBM

5. La instrucción preliminar probatoria como instrumento


para la decisión temprana de los conflictos
)BZUPEBWÓBPUSBTFYQFSJFODJBTRVFNVFTUSBMBMFHJTMBDJØODPNQBSBUJWBZRVFTPO
ÞUJMFT B MPT QSPQØTJUPT EF FTUB JOEBHBDJØO /PT SFGFSJNPT B BRVFMMBT NPEBMJEBEFT
TVQFSBEPSBT RVF SBEJDBO MBT TPMVDJPOFT BVUPDPNQPTJUJWBT FO MB FUBQB QSFMJNJOBS
EFMQSPDFTP&TDPOPDJEBMBUFOEFODJBBBDFOUVBSMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMBJOTUSVDDJØO
QSFMJNJOBSEFMBTDBVTBTZBBSUJDVMBSQSPDFEJNJFOUPTRVFBOUFDFEFOBMEFTFNCPRVF
FO MB BDDJØO KVEJDJBM RVF  QSFDJTBNFOUF  UJFOEFO B FMJNJOBS FM DPOnJDUP FO FTB
JOTUBODJBUFNQSBOB44.
5.1 "TÓ  FO FM %FSFDIP BMFNÈO  MB SFGPSNB EF  B MB ;10 JOUSPEVKP VO OVFWP
UFYUPBMf FODVZBWJSUVEQVFEFTPMJDJUBSTFFMDPTUPEFMBSFQBSBDJØOEFMEB×P 
BOUJDJQBEBMBQSVFCBQFSJDJBMTPCSFFMFTUBEPEFVOBQFSTPOBPFMFTUBEPPWBMPSEF
VOBDPTB MBDBVTBEFVOEB×PBQFSTPOBT BVOBDPTBPWJDJPEFFTUB&MJOUFSÏTKVSÓEJDP
TFUJFOFQPSFYJTUFOUFDVBOEPFMEJDUBNFOQVFEFBZVEBSBFWJUBSVOQSPDFTP.


#&+"3"/0(6;.«/ 3Ob. citQQ 

-»1&;#-"/$0 )'Ob. citU*** PruebasQQ
44
#*"7"5* 1i5FOEFODJBTSFDJFOUFTEFMBKVTUJDJBDJWJMFO&VSPQB PCDJU Q7*--"14 
-B FUBQB QSFMJNJOBS BM QSPDFTP DJWJMy &O: XXV Congreso Nacional de Derecho Procesal…
Ponencias generales…#VFOPT"JSFT'BDEF%FSFDIP6#"""%1 QQZTT&MUFNB
GVFPCKFUPEFEFCBUF BTJNJTNP FOFM9***$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM DPO
SFMBUP HFOFSBM EF / "/%3&84 Z # (30&/  JOTFSUPT FO Direito Processual Comparado 
XIII Word Congress of Procedure Law"1&--&(3*/*(3*/07&3Z1$"-.0/DPPSE 
'PSFOTF 3EF+BOFJSP 

-&*#-& 4 Proceso civil alemán.#JC+VS%JLF,"EFOBVFS4 #PHPUÈ QQZTT

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 35


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

5.2"MNJTNPPCKFUJWPBQVOUBMBSFGPSNBJUBMJBOBEFMB-FZEF BMBNQMJBS
MBTGPSNBTEFPCUFODJØOQSFWFOUJWBEFMBTQSVFCBT DPOQSFTDJOEFODJBEFMSFRVJTJUP
EF VSHFODJB  F JOUSPEVDJS MB consulenza tecnica BOUFSJPS BM QSPDFTP  DPO GVODJØO
DPODJMJBUPSJB 4FHÞO FM BSUÓDVMP  bis $1$  MBT QBSUFT  BOUFT EF DPNFO[BS VOB
DBVTB QVFEFOTPMJDJUBSRVFFMKVF[EFTJHOFVOFYQFSUPQBSBRVFQSFTFOUFVOJOGPSNF
PSJFOUBEP B iDPNQSPCBS Z EFUFSNJOBSw MPT DSÏEJUPT EFSJWBEPT EFM JODVNQMJNJFOUP
DPOUSBDUVBM PQPSIFDIPTJMÓDJUPT iJOUFOUBEP BMNJTNPUJFNQP MBDPODJMJBDJØOEF
MB litisw. 4F QFSTJHVF BMMFHBS VOB WBMPSBDJØO UÏDOJDB PCKFUJWB RVF QFSNJUB B MBT
QBSUFT FNCBSDBSTF FO VOB OFHPDJBDJØO GSVDUÓGFSB  UBO QSPOUP DPNP RVFEB JEFOUJ-
mDBEP FM DPOnJDUP  Z EFTFNQF×BS VOB GVODJØO SFEVDUJWB FO SFMBDJØO BM TJTUFNB EF
KVTUJDJB EJSJHJEBBFWJUBSFMQMFJUP FTQFDJBMNFOUFDVBOEPMBTQSVFCBTUJFOFOFmDBDJB
EJSJNFOUF BEFNÈTEFMFGFDUPFWFOUVBMEFMBGPSNBDJØOEFQSVFCBUFNQSBOBQBSBFM
GVUVSPQSPDFTP.

5.3 -B NJTNB mOBMJEBE QFSTJHVF MB acción autónoma de producción de prueba 
TJHOJmDBUJWBOPWFEBEEFM$1$CSBTJMF×PEF-BQSPEVDDJØOBOUJDJQBEBEF
QSVFCBTFSÈBENJUJEBDPOGPSNFBMBSUÓDVMPoBEFNÈTEFMTVQVFTUPDPNÞOFORVF
IBZBGVOEBEPSFDFMPEFRVFWFOHBBUPSOBSTFJNQPTJCMFPNVZEJGÓDJMMBWFSJmDBDJØO
EFDJFSUPTIFDIPTo FOPUSBTEPTIJQØUFTJTRVFBRVÓOPTJOUFSFTBO4VDFEFBTÓFOMPT
DBTPTFORVFMBQSVFCBBTFSQSPEVDJEBTFBTVTDFQUJCMFEFWJBCJMJ[BSMBBVUPDPNQP-
TJDJØOVPUSPNFEJPBEFDVBEPEFTPMVDJØOEFDPOnJDUPT f**
PZBDVBOEPFMQSFWJP
DPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTIFDIPTQVFEBKVTUJmDBSPFWJUBSFMFOKVJDJBNJFOUPEFMBBDDJØO


#*"7"5* 1Tendencias recientes… Ob. cit4"-&55* "i&MOVFWPSÏHJNFOEFMBT
NFEJEBTDBVUFMBSFTZQPTFTPSJBTw&O: Rev. Peruana de Der. Proc.-JNB$PNNVOJUBT  9*
QQZTT$"31* 'Z5"36''0 .Commentario breve al Codice di Procedura Civile‹
FE $FEBN 1BEPWB QQ"/4"/&--* 7Le prove a futura memoria nel
diritto italianoO¡4ÉP1BVMP3F1SP QQZTT RVJFOEFTUBDBMPTBOUFDFEFOUFT
EPDUSJOBSJPTZKVSJTQSVEFODJBMFTEFMBSFGPSNB

&MMFHJTMBEPSEFDPODSFUØVOBTVTUBODJBMFRVJQBSBDJØO CBKPFMQFSmMGVODJPOBM FOUSFMBT
NPEBMJEBEFTEFMBBERVJTJDJØOEFMPTDPOPDJNJFOUPTFYQFSUPTGPSNBEPTQSFWFOUJWBNFOUFP
EVSBOUF FM QSPDFTP  GSVUP EF VOB UFOEFODJB B FYUFOEFS MPT FTQBDJPT EF VUJMJ[BDJØO EF UBMFT
DPOPDJNJFOUPTBOUFTEFMQSPDFTP "/4"/&--* 7Ob. citQQ


."((*  ' Z $"3-&55*  ' i* QSPWWFEJNFOUJ EJ JTUSV[JPOF QSFWFOUJWBw. &O: Il processo
cautelareBFE BDVSBEJ(5BS[JBF"4BMFUUJ$FEBN 1BEPWB QQZTT

#*"7"5*  1 Tutela cautelar, anticipatoria y sumaria en la reforma italiana 3%1 #VFOPT
"JSFT3VCJO[BM$VM[POJFE QQZTT"/4"/&--* 7Ob. cit.QQZTT

"336%" "-7*. 8".#*&3  5 Z PUSPT Primeiros comentarios… Ob. cit. QQ  Z TT
."3*/0/* -("3&/)"35 4$Z.*5*%*&30 %Novo Curso de Processo Civil. Ob. cit.
WQQZTT

4FIBTF×BMBEPRVFFOSFBMJEBEOPTFUSBUBEFQSPEVDDJØOBOUJDJQBEBQVFTMBNFEJEBTFMJNJUB
BimKBSwMBQSVFCBRVFQVFEFJOUFSFTBSBPUSP GVUVSP
QSPDFTP QFSNJUJFOEPRVFFMMBTFBaquí
QSPEVDJEB ."3*/0/* -("3&/)"35 4$Z.*5*%*&30 %Ob. citQQ


36 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

f***
-BQSVFCBQBTBBTFSDPOTJEFSBEBOPTØMPFOTVGVODJØOEFJOTUSVNFOUPQBSB
GPSNBSMBDPOWJDDJØOKVEJDJBM TJOPUBNCJÏODPNPNFEJPQBSBBVYJMJBSBMBTQBSUFTFO
MBWBMPSBDJØOEFTVTDIBODFTEFÏYJUPFOVOBGVUVSBEFNBOEBoZDPOFMMPGBDJMJUBSMB
CÞTRVFEBEFTPMVDJPOFTDPODFSUBEBToPUBNCJÏOQBSBTVVUJMJ[BDJØOFOFMQSPDFTP
DPOTJHVJFOUF4PODMBSBNFOUFNFEJEBTUFOEJFOUFTBMBSFEVDDJØOEFMBMJUJHJPTJEBEZ
FMNÈTBQSPQJBEPFODBVTBNJFOUPEFMBTQSFUFOTJPOFTEFMBTQBSUFT.
&OMBQFUJDJØO FMSFRVJSFOUFQSFTFOUBSÈMBTSB[POFTRVFKVTUJmDBOMBBOUJDJQBDJØO
EFMBQSVFCBZNFODJPOBSÈDPOQSFDJTJØOMPTIFDIPTTPCSFMPTRVFIBEFSFDBFS&M
KVF[QSPDFEFSÈBDJUBSBMPTJOUFSFTBEPT TBMWPTJOPFYJTUJFSBDBTPDPOUFODJPTPQPS
UFOFSDPNPÞOJDPQSPQØTJUPMBEPDVNFOUBDJØOEFMBDUPS/PTFSFRVJFSFJOEJDBSMB
BDDJØO iQSJODJQBMw RVF  QPS PUSB QBSUF  FT QPTJCMF RVF OP TF QMBOUFF FO FM GVUVSP
-PTJOUFSFTBEPT BTVWF[ QPESÈOSFRVFSJSMBQSPEVDDJØOEFDVBMRVJFSQSVFCBFOFM
NJTNPQSPDFEJNJFOUP TJFNQSFRVFFTUÏSFMBDJPOBEBDPOMPTNJTNPIFDIPT TBMWP
TJ TV QSPEVDDJØO DPOKVOUB BDBSSFBSB FYDFTJWB EFNPSB &O FM QSPDFEJNJFOUP OP TF
BENJUJSÈEFGFOTBPSFDVSTPT FYDFQUPDPOUSBMBEFDJTJØOEFTFTUJNBUPSJB BSU
&O
SFBMJEBE UBOTØMPTFMJNJUBFMÈNCJUPEFMBEFGFOTB QFSPFMJOUFSFTBEPQPESÈBMFHBS
DVFTUJPOFT EF PSEFO QÞCMJDP MP RVF OP TF QFSNJUF FT FM EFCBUF TPCSF FM EFSFDIP
NBUFSJBM3FBMJ[BEBMBQSPEVDDJØOEFMBTQSVFCBT FMKVF[EFCFEBSQPSDPODMVJEPFM
QSPDFTPNFEJBOUFTFOUFODJBRVFTFMJNJUBBEBSGFEFMPBDUVBEPEFNBOFSBSFHVMBS
Z MFHÓUJNB " FTUF MF FT QSPIJCJEP GPSNVMBS DVBMRVJFS KVJDJP EF WBMPS TPCSF EJDIBT
QSVFCBT BSUT f

5.45BMFTFYQFSJFODJBTEFNVFTUSBORVFFMMFHJTMBEPSOPTFDPOUFOUBDPOGPNFOUBS
GØSNVMBTDPNQPTJUJWBTZEFKBSMBTMJCSBEBTBMKVFHPEFMPTQVSPTJOUFSFTFTEFMBTQBSUFT
CBKPMBHVÓBEFHFTUPSFTOFVUSBMFT DPNPFOFMNPEFMPEFMBOFHPDJBDJØOFOCPHB TJOP
RVFTFBMJFOUBOMBTTPMVDJPOFTBVUPDPNQVFTUBTFOFMNBSDPEFMBKVTUJDJBPmDJBM DPO
DPOUSPMEFMKVF[Z TPCSFNBOFSB FOMBBOUFTBMBEFMQSPDFTP4JODMBSJmDBDJØOEFMPT
IFDIPT BÞOFOHSBEPEFWFSPTJNJMJUVEZTVQFSmDJBMJEBE MBOFHPDJBDJØOiQFEBMFBFO
FMBJSFw FTBMHPBTÓDPNPVOWVFMPBDJFHBT"MFOTBNCMBSTFBQSPQJBEBNFOUFBNCBT
BDUJWJEBEFT  MBT QBSUFT MMFHBO BM BDVFSEP BNJTUPTP con conocimiento de causa  MP
RVFHBSBOUJ[BVODPOTFOUJNJFOUPiNBEVSPwGSVUPEFVOBFWBMVBDJØOGVOEBEBEFMBT
DJSDVOTUBODJBTEFIFDIPZEFEFSFDIPRVFQBSUJDVMBSJ[BOFMDBTP
5.5 -B JODPSQPSBDJØO B OVFTUSPT PSEFOBNJFOUPT EF MPT NFDBOJTNPT Z UÏDOJDBT EF
JOTUSVDDJØO QSFMJNJOBS QSPCBUPSJB DPOTUJUVJSÓB  TJO EVEB  VO BWBODF USBTDFOEFOUBM
QBSB FM NFKPSBNJFOUP EFM TJTUFNB EF KVTUJDJB DPNÞO  QPS UPEBT MBT SB[POFT ZB
BOBMJ[BEBT
B 4VJNQMFNFOUBDJØOSFRVJFSFEFVOBOÈMJTJTQSPGVOEPFOSFMBDJØOBMBTSFGPSNBT
MFHBMFTOFDFTBSJBTBCBSDBUJWBTUBOUPEFMPTBTQFDUPTPSHÈOJDPGVODJPOBMFT DPNP


"336%""-7*.8".#*&3 5ZPUSPTOb. citQ

Ibidem.Q."3*/0/* -("3&/)"354$Z.*5*%*&30 %Ob. citQQ

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 37


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

EFMBTUÏDOJDBTZQSPDFEJNJFOUPTGPSNBMFT&OFMQSJNFSPEFFTPTBTQFDUPT TFOUBEP
RVFMBDPOEVDDJØO HFTUJØOZCÞTRVFEBEFMBTTPMVDJPOFTOFHPDJBEBTDPSSFTQPOEF
QSJODJQBMNFOUF BM ØSHBOP KVSJTEJDDJPOBM  IBCSÈ RVF BDPNFUFS MB DPNQMFKB
DVFTUJØOEFMBDPOGPSNBDJØOEFMQSPQJPØSHBOPZEFMPTBVYJMJBSFTRVFMPJOUFHSFO
&OFTFTFOUJEP OPTQBSFDFRVFVONPEFMPBEFDVBEP BMNFOPTQBSBMBSFBMJEBE
BSHFOUJOB MPDPOTUJUVZFFMRVFTFVUJMJ[BFOMPTDPOnJDUPTEFGBNJMJBFOHFOFSBM
"TÓ FOUSFPUSPT FMSÏHJNFOEFMB1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT -ZNPEJG
 
FO FM RVF TF JNQMFNFOUB VO DVFSQP EF DPOTVMUPSFT P DPOTFKFSPT  GVODJPOBSJPT
RVFUPNBOBTVDBSHPMBDPOEVDDJØO JNQVMTPZHFTUJØOFOVOBFUBQBQSFWJBBM
KVJDJP EFMBCÞTRVFEBBDUJWBEFTPMVDJPOFTDPODFSUBEBT"DUÞBOCBKPTVQFSWJTJØO
EFMKVF[BRVJFOTFSFTFSWB QPSMPEFNÈT MBWBMPSBDJØOEFMPTBDVFSEPTBSSJCBEPT
ZTVIPNPMPHBDJØO TJOQFSKVJDJP OBUVSBMNFOUF EFMBTQPUFTUBEFTEFFTUFQBSB
QSPWPDBS FODVBMRVJFSUJFNQPZFUBQBEFMQSPDFTP MBDPODJMJBDJØOEFMBTQBSUFT
0USP BTQFDUP  RVF OP FT NFOPT FTFODJBM  FT RVF FM ØSHBOP TF JOUFHSB  BEFNÈT 
DPO VO DVFSQP UÏDOJDP BVYJMJBS P HBCJOFUF NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJP  QBSB JOUFSWFOJS
UBNCJÏOFOMBFUBQBQSFMJNJOBS TJOQFSKVJDJPEFTVBDUVBDJØOFOFMDVSTPVMUFSJPS
EFMQSPDFEJNJFOUP&OEFmOJUJWB TFUSBUBSÓBEFDPOGPSNBSEFVONPEPTJOHVMBS
FM QSPQJP ØSHBOP KVSJTEJDDJPOBM QBSB RVF QVFEB DPOEVDJS FmDB[NFOUF MB FUBQB
QSFMJNJOBSDPOMBmOBMJEBEEFQSPQFOEFSBMBTPMVDJØOBNJTUPTBEFMEJGFSFOEP
 0USPNPEFMPBMRVFBMUFSOBUJWBNFOUFQPESÓBSFDVSSJSTFTFSÓBVOSÏHJNFOTJNJMBS
BMBEPQUBEPFOFM$1$EF#SBTJMRVF DPNPIFNPTWJTUP DPOGÓBMBTUBSFBTBDPODJ-
MJBEPSFTZNFEJBEPSFT KVOUPDPOMBTDÈNBSBTPJOTUJUVDJPOFTQSJWBEBTJOTDSJQUBT
FOVOSFHJTUSPPSHBOJ[BEPQPSMBTNÈTBMUBTBVUPSJEBEFTKVEJDJBMFToOPBENJOJT-
USBUJWBTo FOMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$1$ MPTDVBMFTTFEFTFNQF×BO
DPNPBVYJMJBEPSFTEFMBKVTUJDJB BSUEFMNJTNP
$PNPUBMFT FTUÈOTPNFUJEPT
B VO SÏHJNFO KVSÓEJDP EF %FSFDIP QÞCMJDP DVZPT QSJODJQJPT SFHVMB FM DJUBEP
BSUÓDVMPoJOTDSJQDJØOFOSFHJTUSPEFMUSJCVOBMDPSSFTQPOEJFOUF DBQBDJUBDJØO 
DPOTFOTPQÞCMJDP DBUBTUSPQÞCMJDPDPOEBUPTEFEFTFNQF×P SÏHJNFOEFJODPN-
QBUJCJMJEBEFTo.
C &O DVBOUP BM NPEFMP QSPDFTBM  TF IBDF NFOFTUFS SFHVMBS MBT EJWFSTBT FUBQBT Z
QSPDFEJNJFOUPT RVF DPOGPSNBO MB NFOUBEB JOTUSVDDJØO QSFMJNJOBS  JNBHJOBEB
DPO VOB EPCMF mOBMJEBE J
 DPNP NFDBOJTNP BVYJMJBUPSJP GBDJMJUBEPS EF MB
OFHPDJBDJØOFOUSFMBTQBSUFT FODVBOUPDPOUSJCVZFBMFTDMBSFDJNJFOUP TJRVJFSB


#&3*;0/$& 30#&3.&+0 41Z".&/%0-"3" ;Tribunales y proceso de familia.
-&1 -B1MBUB QQZTT ZTT ZTT

"336%""-7*.8".#*&3 5ZPUSPTPrimeiros comentarios… Ob. citQQ
1*/)0 )%#EFOb. citQQ

4PCSFMPTFTUÓNVMPTZQSFEJTQPOFOUFTQBSBGBWPSFDFSMBWPMVOUBEDPODJMJBUPSJBEFMBTQBSUFT
1&:3"/0  +8 Anotaciones sobre la gestión conciliatoria… 3%1 #VFOPT "JSFT 3VCJO-

38 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

QSPWJTJPOBM EFMPTIFDIPTDPOEVDFOUFTZEFDJTJWPTQBSBMBTPMVDJØOEFMDPOnJDUP.
-PBOUFSJPS EFNPEPRVFMBTQBSUFTRVFEFOFOMBTNFKPSFTDPOEJDJPOFTEFDPOPDJ-
NJFOUPFJOGPSNBDJØOTPCSFMBGVOEBCJMJEBEEFMPTEFSFDIPTRVFFTHSJNFOZ FO
DPOTFDVFODJB QVFEBOBDPSEBSEFNPEPMJCSF EFMJCFSBEPZDPOTDJFOUF TJWJFSBO
RVFMFTDPOWJFOF VOBTPMVDJØOBNJTUPTBJJ
DPNPQSPDFEJNJFOUPEFJOTUSVDDJØO
EF MB DBVTB FO VOB FUBQB UFNQSBOB  TJO SFTUSJDDJPOFT QPS SB[POFT EF VSHFODJB
EF DPOTFSWBDJØO EF MBT QSVFCBT DPNP FO FM USBEJDJPOBM FTRVFNB EF MB QSVFCB
BOUJDJQBEB $1$/BSHFOUJOP BSU
ZDPOWBMPSTJNJMBSBMBTPUSBTQSPCBO[BT 
FOTVQVFTUPEFGSBDBTPEFMBDPODJMJBDJØO QBSBTFSFWBMVBEBTFOMBTFOUFODJBEF
NÏSJUP.
D &MQSPDFEJNJFOUPEFJOTUSVDDJØOQSFMJNJOBSTFJOJDJBSÈBSFRVFSJNJFOUPEFQBSUF 
NFEJBOUFQFUJDJØOTJNQMFZDPODSFUBRVFJOEJWJEVBMJDFMPTIFDIPTDPOEVDFOUFT
ZPGSF[DBMBTQSVFCBTQFSUJOFOUFT QBSBMPDVBM FMKVF[EFCFBTFHVSBSMBJHVBMEBE
TVTUBODJBMFOFMUSBUPQSPDFTBMTJOQFSKVJDJPEFMBJOGPSNBMJEBEZDFMFSJEBEEFM
QSPDFEJNJFOUP&TUFQSPQVHOBSÈFMNÈTBNQMJPJOUFSDBNCJPEFJOGPSNBDJØOZ
QSVFCBTFOUSFMBTQBSUFT-BTQSVFCBTQFSJDJBMFT FOTVDBTP RVFEBSÈOBDBSHP
EFMPTQFSJUPTDPNQFUFOUFTEFMDVFSQPBTFTPSJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP&OFMBDUBmOBM
TF EFKBSÈ DPOTUBODJB EF MBT QPTUVSBT EF MBT QBSUFT  FTQFDJBMNFOUF DVBOEP MB
BVUPDPNQPTJDJØOIVCJFSFGSBDBTBEP%JDIBTBUFTUBDJPOFTTFSÈODPOTJEFSBEBTFO
TVNPNFOUPQBSBFWBMVBSFMDPNQPSUBNJFOUPZMBCVFOBGFRVFTFSFRVJFSFEF
MBTQBSUFT-BIPNPMPHBDJØOKVEJDJBMEFMBDVFSEPDPOTUJUVJSÈUÓUVMPFKFDVUPSJP
OPTFMJNJUBSÈBMBWFSJmDBDJØOEFMDVNQMJNJFOUPGPSNBMEFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPT 
TJOPRVFIBEFWBMPSBSMBKVTUJDJBEFMPBDPSEBEP&OTVDBTP TFJNQPOESÈOMBT
DPTUBTEFMVMUFSJPSQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMDVBOEPMBTFOUFODJB BVOTJFOEPGBWPSBCMF 
BDPSEBSFBRVJFOSFTVMUØSFTQPOTBCMFEFMBGSVTUSBDJØOEFMJOUFOUPDPODJMJBUPSJP
FMNJTNPJNQPSUF PVOPJOGFSJPSBMPGSFDJEPQPSMBDPOUSBSJBFOMBOFHPDJBDJØO.

[BM$VM[POJFE QQZTT FTQFDJBMNFOUFQQ404" 5& i*OTUSVDDJØO


DJWJMQSFQBSBUPSJBw. &O: XXVIII Congreso Nacional de Derecho Procesal, Ponencias generales
y ponencias seleccionadas 1+ 1SPW +VKVZ""%1  4BO 4BMWBEPS EF +VKVZ   QQ  Z TT 
FTQFDJBMNFOUFQQZTT&OTFOUJEPTJNJMBS(*"//*/* -+La homologación judicial de los
acuerdos en mediación. &OMBNJTNBPCSB QQZTT FTQFDJBMNFOUFQ

)BEFFWBMVBSTFMBDPOWFOJFODJBPOPEFMJNJUBSMBJOTUSVDDJØOQSFMJNJOBSBBRVFMMPTDBTPTFO
RVF MBT QBSUFT TØMP EFCBUFO FM NPOUP EF MPT DSÏEJUPT RVF UJFOFO GVOEBNFOUP DPOUSBDUVBM P
FYUSBDPOUSBDUVBM DPNPFOFMNPEFMPEFMBSUÓDVMPCJT$1$JUBMJBOP$POG7*--" 14Ob.
citQ

404" 5&Ob. citQQ

(3*--0$*0$$)*/* 1i*OUFSDBNCJPEFJOGPSNBDJØOZQSVFCBBOUFTEFMBEFNBOEBw. &O:
XXV Congreso Nacional de Derecho Procesal… Ob. citQQZTT

&O FM EFSFDIP QPSUVHVÏT  FM %FDSFUP -FZ   NPEJmDBUPSJP EFM BSUÓDVMP  $1$ 
FTUBCMFDFRVFFMBDUPSRVF QVEJFOEPSFDVSSJSBNFEJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTPQUFQPSFMQSPDFTPKVEJDJBM 

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 39


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

E 2VFEBO  FO mO  PUSPT BTQFDUPT DPNQMFNFOUBSJPT EF JNQMFNFOUBDJØO RVF


oTJ FYJTUJFSF DPOTFOTP FO DVBOUP B MBT QSPQVFTUBTo EFCFSÓBO TFS BOBMJ[BEPT
QVOUVBMNFOUF.

Conclusiones
&TUBNPTBIPSBFODPOEJDJPOFTEFGPSNVMBSMBTTJHVJFOUFTDPODMVTJPOFTTVNBSJBT
1. -B DSFDJFOUF DPODJFOUJ[BDJØO EF MB QFSUFOFODJB Z BQSPQJBDJØO EF MPT EFSFDIPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFTZ FOFTQFDJBM EFMPTEFSFDIPTFDPOØNJDPT TPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFT 
JNQVMTBVOBBSSPMMBEPSBKVEJDJBMJ[BDJØOEFMPTDPOnJDUPTRVF BTVWF[ DPOEVDF
EFNPEPJOFWJUBCMFBMBTPCSFDBSHBEFMPTUSJCVOBMFTZBMBFYDFTJWBEVSBDJØOEF
MPTQSPDFTPT
2.-PTNFEJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTZ FOQBSUJDVMBS MBNFEJBDJØOUBOTØMPiGBDJMJUBEPSBw RVF
OPTFDPNQSPNFUFDPOFMSFTVMUBEPKVTUPEFMBTEFDJTJPOFT OPTPOÞUJMFTQBSBFM
SFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFMBQB[TPDJBMOJTBUJTGBDFOMBTFYJHFODJBTEFMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBM
FGFDUJWB.ÈYJNFRVFOPTFDPNQBEFDFDPOFMTJTUFNBEFWBMPSFTZDSFFODJBTRVF
QSFWBMFDFFOMBBDUVBMTPDJFEBE
3. &OFM%FSFDIPDPNQBSBEPTFFYIJCFOEJWFSTPTNPEFMPT JOTUJUVDJPOFTZUÏDOJDBT
TVQFSBEPSBT FOUSFMPTDVBMFTTFEFTUBDBOBMHVOPTRVFQVFEFOTFSÞUJMFTQBSBTV
BEPQDJØOFOUSFOPTPUSPT
4 -B JODPSQPSBDJØO EF MB JOTUSVDDJØO QSFMJNJOBS QSPCBUPSJB DPOTUJUVZF VO BWBODF
USBTDFOEFOUBMQBSBFMNFKPSBNJFOUPEFMTJTUFNBEFKVTUJDJB RVFTFJOTFSUBFOUSF
MBTUÏDOJDBTEFMBEFOPNJOBEBiKVTUJDJBUFNQSBOBwoNFEJEBTBOUJDJQBUPSJBT TBUJT-
GBDUJWBTZEFVSHFODJB UVUFMBTEFFWJEFODJB FKFDVDJØOQSPWJTJPOBMEFMBTTFOUFODJBT 
FTUSVDUVSBTNPOJUPSJBTZPUSBTo$POMBQBSUJDVMBSJEBEEFRVFTVJNQMFNFOUBDJØO
SFRVJFSF SFGPSNBT MFHBMFT DPNQSFOTJWBT EF BTQFDUPT PSHÈOJDP  GVODJPOBMFT Z 
DPNPUÏDOJDBQSPDFTBMBEFDVBEB MBBNQMJmDBDJØOEFMBTUSBEJDJPOBMFTNFEJEBTEF
QSVFCBBOUJDJQBEBQBSBTFSBENJUJEBTDPOBNQMJUVEZOPTVQFEJUBEBTBMSFRVFSJ-
NJFOUPEFMBVSHFODJB
5. -B JOTUSVDDJØO QSFMJNJOBS BUJFOEF B VO EPCMF PCKFUJWP B
 DPNP NFDBOJTNP
BVYJMJBUPSJP GBDJMJUBEPS EF MB OFHPDJBDJØO UFNQSBOB FOUSF MBT QBSUFT  FO CBTF BM
NBUFSJBM QSPCBUPSJP SFDPHJEP Z FM FTDMBSFDJNJFOUP TJRVJFSB TVQFSmDJBM Z QSPWJ-
TJPOBMEFMPTIFDIPTFODVFTUJØO%FWJFOFÞUJMQBSBMBFWFOUVBMEFDJTJØOKVEJDJBM

EFCFSÈTPQPSUBSMBTDPTUBTEFQBSUFDPOJOEFQFOEFODJBEFMSFTVMUBEPEFMBlitis 5&*9&*3"%&
4064" .Um novo processo civil português: a la recherche du temps perdu?O3F1SP 
4ÉP1BVMP Q


6OB QSPQVFTUB TJNJMBS  BVORVF DPO WBSJBOUFT EJHOBT EF TFS BOBMJ[BEBT  FT MB RVF GPSNVMB
130501*4"/* "I processi a cognizione piena in Italia dal 1940 al 2012O¡3F1SP 4ÉP
1BVMP QQZTT FTQFDJBMNFOUFQQZTT

40 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

IPNPMPHBUPSJBDVBOEPFMBDVFSEPBMDBO[BEPSFQSFTFOUFiVOBKVTUBDPNQPTJDJØO
EFMPTEFSFDIPTFODPOnJDUPwZC
DPNPQSPDFEJNJFOUPEFJOTUSVDDJØOUFNQSBOB
EFMBDBVTB FOFMRVFMBTQSVFCBTSFDPHJEBTFODPOUSBEJDUPSJPBERVJFSFOQMFOP
WBMPSTVBTPSJPFOMBFWFOUVBMBQSFDJBDJØOBMUJFNQPEFSFTPMWFSTPCSFFMNÏSJUP

Referencias Bibliográficas
"/%3&84  /FJM  i0 NPEFSOP QSPDFTP DJWJM GPSNBT KVEJDJBJT F BMUFSOBUJWBT EF
SFTPMVÎÉPEFDPOnJUPTOB*OHMBUFSSBw5SBE5FSFTB"SSVEB"MWJN8BNCJFS&O: Rev.
dos Trib.4ÉP1BVMP 
___________ Relaçôes entre a Corte e as partes na era do case management.3F1SP 
4ÉP1BVMP O¡ 
"/4"/&--* 7JODFO[P Le prove a futura memoria nel diritto italiano3F1SP 4ÉP
1BVMP O¡ 
"336%""-7*.8".#*&3 5FSFTB i1SJNFJSPTDPNFOUBSJPTBP/PWP$ØEJHP
EF1SPDFTTP$JWJMw&O: Rev. dos Tribunais4ÉP1BVMP 
#&+"3"/0(6;.«/ 3BNJSP Procesos declarativos, ejecutivos y arbitralesB
FE#PHPUÈ5FNJT 
#&3*;0/$&  3PCFSUP 0NBS  #&3.&+0  4JMWJB 1BUSJDJB Z ".&/%0-"3" 
;VMNB Tribunales y proceso de familia-B1MBUB-&1 
#&3*;0/$& 3PCFSUP0NBS El costo del proceso (como sacrificio para el erario
y como impedimento para el acceso a la justicia) en Derecho Procesal Civil actual.
#VFOPT"JSFT"CFMFEP1FSSPU-&1 
#*"7"5* 1BPMP Argomenti di Diritto Processuale Civile.#PMPHOB#POPOJB6OJW
1SFTT 
_______ Tutela cautelar, anticipatoria y sumaria en la reforma italiana 3%1
#VFOPT"JSFT3VCJO[BM$VM[POJFE 
_______ Tendencias recientes de la justicia civil en Europa3%14BOUB'F 
$"11&--&55* .BVSP Z("35) #SZBOU El acceso a la Justicia-B1MBUBFE$PM
"CPHBEPT-B1MBUB 
$"11&--*55*  .BVSP  i"TQFDUPT TPDJBMFT Z QPMÓUJDPT EFM QSPDFEJNJFOUP DJWJM
SFGPSNBT Z UFOEFODJBT FWPMVUJWBT FO MB &VSPQB PDDJEFOUBM Z PSJFOUBM
w &O: Proceso,
ideologías y sociedad USBE 4 4FOUÓT .FMFOEP Z 5" #BO[IBG #VFOPT "JSFT &EJBS 

$"31*  'FEFSJDP  Z 5"36''0  .JDIFMF Commentario breve al Codice di
Procedura Civile$FEBN 1BEPWB ‹FE 
$)"4&  0TDBS  Law, culture and Ritual. Disputing Systems in Cross-Cultural
Context /FX :PSL /FX :PSL 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT   7FSTJØO EF MB USBEVDDJØO
DBTUFMMBOB EF ."35¶/ %*;  'FSOBOEP  Derecho, cultura y ritual. Sistemas de

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 41


Procedimientos preliminares y prueba anticipada

resolución de controversias en un contexto intercultural .BESJE#BSDFMPOB#VFOPT


"JSFT.BSDJBM1POT  passim.
$0.0(-*0  -VJHJ 1BPMP  i(BSBOUÓBT NÓOJNBT EFM AQSPDFTP KVTUP DJWJM FO MPT
PSEFOBNJFOUPT IJTQBOPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTw &O: Rev. Iberoam. Der. Procesal  W 
#VFOPT"JSFT
___________ Mezzi alternativi di tutela e garanzie costituzionale3JW%JS1SPD 
$FEBN 1BEPWB 
Controversie colettive, tranzacione e conciliazione in Inghilterra 3F1SP  O  

$06563& &EVBSEP+ Proyecto de Código de Procedimiento Civil.POUFWJEFP 

%"--"#0/5« 4JMWBOB i-BPSJHJOBMBDUVBDJØOFO*UBMJBEFMB%JSFDUJWB
$&w&O: Civil Procedure ReviewW O%JTQPOJCMFFO XXXDJWJMQSPDFEVSF-
SFWJFXDPN

%"."4,"  .JSJBN  Las caras de la justicia y el poder del Estado. Análisis
comparado del proceso legal4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFFE+VSÓEEF$IJMF  passim.
%&-";;"3* &EVBSEP/ÏTUPS La ejecución provisoria de la sentencia como tutela
de urgencia y de evidencia.#VFOPT"JSFT-B-FZ '
'*44  0XFO  Contra la conciliación en El derecho como razón pública USBE &
3FTUSFQP4BMEBSSJBHB.BESJEo#BSDFMPOB#VFOPT"JSFT.BSDJBM1POT 
(*"//*/*  -FBOESP +VMJP  i{&T MB NFEJBDJØO PCMJHBUPSJB FO "SHFOUJOB VO
JOTUSVNFOUPEFBDDFTPBMBKVTUJDJB w&O Rev. Iberoam. Der. Proc., Rev. dos Tribunais.
WPM4ÉP1BVMP 
___________ La homologación judicial de los acuerdos en mediación en la misma
obra.
(*--&4 1FUFS Civil Justice Sistems and Civil Procedures in conversion3F1SP 4ÉP
1BVMP O¡ 
(3&$0  -FPOBSEP  A reforma do direito probatorio no processo civil brasileiro.
3F1SP 4ÉP1BVMP O¡ 
(6;.«/ /ÏTUPS-FBOESP Análisis crítico de la implementación de los métodos
alternativos de solución de conflictos3%1 #VFOPT"JSFT 
)""4 6MSJDI Z#0$6$$* %BOJFMF Il rapporto tra il giudice e le parti nell diritto
tedesco. 3F1SP 4ÉP1BVMP O¡ 
,&3/  $ISJTUPQI " Percepçâo, perfomance e política: recentes formas de
abordagem da comparaçâo qualitativa dos sistemas de justica civil3F1SP 4ÉP1BVMP 
O¡ 
-&*#-& 4UFGBO Proceso civil alemán#JC+VS%JLF #PHPUÈ,"EFOBVFS4 
-»1&;#-"/$0 )FSOÈO'BCJP Procedimiento Civil. Parte General. Instituciones
de Derecho Procesal Civil Colombiano‹FE#PHPUÈ%VQSÏFE 

42 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P


Roberto Omar Berizonce

."((*  'SBODFTDB  Z $"3-&55*  'BCSJ[JP  I provvedimenti di istruzione


preventiva en Il processo cautelare, a cura di G. Tarzia e A. Saletti B FE $FEBN 
1BEPWB 
."3*/0/* -VJ[(VJMIFSNF "3&/)"35 4FSHJP$SV[Z.*5*%*&30 %BOJFM 
i$VSTPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMw&O: Rev. dos TribW4ÉP1BVMP 
.&/%&;  )ÏDUPS 0TDBS Z .&/%&;  "HVTUJOB .BSÓB  Globalización y justicia.
+" #VFOPT"JSFT GBTD ***
.*5*%*&30 %BOJFM Anticipaçâo da tutela4ÉP1BVMP&EJUEPT5SJC 
.03&--0 "VHVTUP.BSJP El proceso justo‹FE#VFOPT"JSFT-FYJT/FYJT
-&1 passim.
1²3&;3"(0/& "MWBSP+ Z035*;13"%*--0 +VBO$BSMPT Código Procesal
Civil alemán (ZPO).POUFWJEFP,"EFOBVFS4UJGUVOH 
1&:3"/0 +PSHF8BMUFS El dictado de decisiones judiciales anticipadas. El factor
“evidencia” #VFOPT "JSFT -B -FZ  # id. La tutela anticipada de evidencia.
#VFOPT"JSFT-B-FZ $
1*/)0  )VNCFSUP %BMMB #FSOBSEJOB EF A mediaçâo judicial no novo CPC
en Desvendando o novo CPC. %(3JCFJSPZ.'+PCJNPSH1PSUP"MFHSF-JW%P
"CWPHBEPFE 
130501*4"/*"OESFB I processi a cognizione piena in Italia dal 1940 al 2012.
3F1SP 4ÉP1BVMP O¡ 
4"-&55* "DIJMMF i&MOVFWPSÏHJNFOEFMBTNFEJEBTDBVUFMBSFTZQPTFTPSJBTw&O:
Rev. Peruana de Der. Proc.9*-JNB$PNNVOJUBT 
45Ã3/&3 3PMG Sobre as reformas recentes no direito alemäo3F1SP 4ÉP1BVMP 
O¡ 
5&*9&*3"%&4064" .JHVFM Um novo processo civil português: a la recherche
du temps perdu?3F1SP 4ÉP1BVMP O 
7"--&41¶/1²3&; %BWJE El modelo constitucional de juicio justo en el ámbito
del proceso civil#BSDFMPOB"UFMJFS passim.
7"3("47*"/$04 +VBO&OSJRVF Eficiencia en la justicia en Sistemas Judiciales.
$&+" 4EF$IJMF /¡ 
7*(03*5* 7JODFO[P Giustizia e futuro: conciliazione e class action3F1SP 4ÉP
1BVMP  O
7*--" 1FESP4FCBTUJÈO La etapa preliminar al proceso civil. &O997$POHSFTP
/BDJPOBM EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM 1POFODJBT HFOFSBMFT 'BD EF %FSFDIP 6#"""%1 
#VFOPT"JSFT 
9***$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM DPOSFMBUPHFOFSBMEF"/%3&84 
/FJMZ(30&/ #BSU JOTFSUPTFODireito Processual Comparado9***8PSE$POHSFTT
PG 1SPDFEVSF -BX "EB 1&--&(3*/* (3*/07&3 Z 1FUSPOJP $"-.0/ DPPSE 
'PSFOTF 3EF+BOFJSP 

issn - tQQt+VMJP%JDJFNCSFEFt#PHPUÈ %$$PMPNCJB 43

You might also like