I am confused in design of shell & tube e...

Page 1

 Search for people, jobs, companies, and more... Advanced  

Home Profile Connections Jobs Interests Business Services Try Premium for fre

ASME-PVP Pressure Vessels and Piping 18,791 members

Division 

Discussions Promotions Jobs Members Search

I am confused in design of shell & tube exchanger. in process Top Contributors in this Group
data sheet there is a table related to depressurization
temperarure of tube side. should I consider this temperature in
mechanical design?

Follow Ali Ali Biglari

Basheer Mohamed
Mechanical engineer at Tasha Manufacturing co
Sr.Mechanical Design Engineer (Static Equipments)
Follow Basheer
See all members

Like (1) Comment (5) Follow Reply Privately3 days ago Your group contribution level
Start by commenting in a discussion. Group
Comments participants get 4x the number of profile views.

 Renato Mercuri likes this

 5 comments

Patrick Marcotte
Sr. Engineer, Piping & Pressure Vessels at PVP Engineering Ltd
Top Contributor
Latest Activity
Patrick Yes, but "consider" does not necessarily mean calculate. It can mean "compare to the other
scenarios and determine what is governing". Often the largest temperature differentials (tube vs Charles Miller,
shell) govern the design. But for all I know differential pressure could be the governing condition. iman jafari, and 8
others joined a group:
In brief summary: imagine the circle of lawyers you would gather if you didn't consider this
temperature and there was some mechanical problem...
Like Reply privatelyFlag as inappropriate 1 day ago

Sanjeev Shukla ASME-PVP Pressure

Vessels and Piping
Sr Mechanical Engineer at PTTEP
Division
Ali, PVPD Mission
Statement Provide a
Sanjeev Depressurization temperature can govern following two cases; forum for the
engineering and
1. MDMT for the tube side. You need to check if any any other MDMT value is provided in the scientific communities
datasheet for the design temperature. If another value is provided for MDMT @ design to promote, share and
disseminate state-of-
temperature, you need to check if these depressurization temperatures govern for MDMT
the-art pressure
considering MDMT/ impact test reduction as allowed in the code for the corresponding pressure/ technologies, relating
stress. to power generation,
sustainable energies,
2. If not a floating head or 'U' tube exchanger, larger differential temperature of shell and tube side and petrochemical
and process...
may generate excessive stresses and bellows may be required. 1h ago

Unless you check it by design, you can not consider the effect of the same. Christopher Wright P.E.
Like (1) Reply privatelyFlag as inappropriate 21 hours ago on a discussion in ASME-PVP Pressure
Vessels and Piping Division
 Simon Hung, P.E. likes this D. Seperating Pm(membrane
stress) and Pb(bending
Vivek Goyal Stress): an important concept,
but often overlooked.
Entrepreneur
Again this is me. I have some questions
as listed below: 1) How to seperate Pm
Yes, all operating case need to be considered and most governing to be used in mechanical
and Pb ?. and Is there any softwares
Vivek design. available to do it?.. 2) How Pm and Pb
Like Reply privatelyFlag as inappropriate 17 hours ago can be related to Circumferential...
2h ago

Ivory Moy Kelly Venegoni commented on a

K.B.R / Sr Q/A HEMP/E.M.P inspector U.S. Aegis Ashore Missile Defense System discussion in ASME-PVP Pressure
Vessels and Piping Division
Yes of course it is common for mechanical design. The Tempreture of the tube side that is Oakley Where can I find a
Ivory provided through MDMT just like Sanjeev said it does matter on type of tubing if it is the U tube or fabricator for some elliptical
the floating head design look at the API 510 has the tempreture chart for both design but i am not heads? 50mm A516 70 and
3mm 316L - 1700mm ID to be
clear on if you talking about the heat exchanger or the pressure vessle side of design both will beSuggested discussion
delivered to Vietnam. Contact me if
treated very differently in tempreture pressure and let the code determine your tempreture designLooking for Mechanical
interested and I will put you in contact
Like Reply privatelyFlag as inappropriate 14 hours ago with the
Engineers (and others)
2h ago
... end user. 

https://www.linkedin.com/groupAnswers... 11/17/2014 5:06:13 PM

 I am confused in design of shell & tube e... Page 2

Ali Farhadzadeh  Search for people, jobs, companies, and more... Advanced  
Seeking Job
Home Profile
Dear Ali, are Connections
you using B-Jac, or Jobs
PV-Elite? Interests Business Services
Subgroups Try Premium for fre
Ali Like Reply privatelyFlag as inappropriate 8 hours ago
High Pressure Technology
846 members

Add a comment...
Components
 Send me an email for each new comment. Add Comment 47 members

769 members

About Feedback Privacy & Terms

LinkedIn Corp. © 2014

Help Center About Press Blog Careers Advertising Talent Solutions Small Business Mobile Developers Language Upgrade Your Account
LinkedIn Corporation © 2014 User Agreement Privacy Policy Community Guidelines Cookie Policy Copyright Policy Send Feedback

Suggested discussion
Looking for Mechanical
Engineers (and others) ... 

https://www.linkedin.com/groupAnswers... 11/17/2014 5:06:13 PM