Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(b) ‘God gave humankind guidance and teachings.’ Why does the
Qur’an lay emphasis on the need to gain knowledge? J18 P11
Having given guidance (through the Qur’an and sunnah, etc.), God wants
knowledge to be used to learn about life and to live lives in a good way.
Without learning, humans would not know about their rights and
responsibilities or about their potential as human beings. In order to respond
to what God wants or what is of benefit to themselves or others, they have to
learn how to respond. God is full of mercy and love, He is guiding people so
they benefit in this life and in the next. The most beneficial knowledge would
be that which helps a person fulfil their rights towards God, fellow humans,
and to develop themselves.
(b) The Prophet (pbuh) could not read or write. In what way has this
always been significant for Muslims? N19 P12
(b) Why do you think the revelation was sent to a person who could not
read or write? [4] N16 P12
(b) Was it significant that the Qur’an was revealed to someone who
could not read or write? Give reasons for your answer. J14 P1
Being unable to read or write it would not have been possible for the Prophet
to have composed the Qur’an himself; the implication is that not being able
to compose the Qur’an himself, it shows that the Qur’an is from God; the
Arabs had a strong oral tradition which allowed the Qur’an to be preserved
through memory alone; he showed his faith in his companions when he
allowed them to write down the verses revealed to him, God did not want
anyone else to be the
Prophet’s (pbuh) teacher, as that would have meant someone was superior
to him in his knowledge of God. It was a miracle of God. It was not important
that he was not able to read/write because God will send the revelation to
whomever He wills and/or other reasons +elaborate on it to emphasise the
importance or significance of it.
(b) Explain the significance of the Qur’an being revealed over a period
of time.[4] N12 P11
(b) The Qur’an was revealed in parts over a number of years. Why was
this important? J18 P12
God says in the Qur’an that had He sent the Qur’an upon a mountain it
would have come apart (59.21). So had it been revealed as a whole to
Muhammad (pbuh) it would have been too heavy for him to carry the
burden. God was taking care of the Prophet (pbuh) and his followers by
revealing it in parts continuously and whenever the need for guidance arose,
as it was sent to strengthen hearts (25.32), which could be done due to the
partial revelations. God also sent it in this way to allow the Prophet (pbuh)
and the early Muslims to ponder over its meanings and have time to
implement the teachings in their lives. It was also sent in parts in response
to the needs of different situations and times.
(b) What does the Prophet’s first experience of revelation tell us about
the nature of prophet hood in Islam? N09P1
Answer in notes.
(b) Explain why God sends his revelations through messengers. J11 P1
The revelations given to all messengers not just the Prophet Muhammad.
Mankind’s need for guidance and inspiration, and why messengers/humans
were the best way to send that guidance, e.g. it was sent to different nations
in different languages so it would be universal and the messengers
convinced through strength of character and moral example.
(b) How does the Qur’an in written form help Muslims around the
world? J19 P11
(b)What is the significance to Muslims today of having the Qur’an in
the form of a book? N11 P1
The Qur’an in book form ensures a standard copy. Having a standardised
copy also lessens the likelihood of it being reproduced with mistakes. If the
Qur’an had
not been collected into book form, parts may have been lost. It also
suggests unity between Muslims, e.g. they use the same book, they read it
in its original language even if that language is not their own. The practical
benefits include that copies can be carried by individuals, and referred to
with ease. The relevance of the Qur’an to people’s lives today, how it is used
in their daily lives and/or other points. Or that old Qur’ans such as the one
that was found in Birmingham, allow Muslims to authenticate that the written
copies of the early Muslims are the same as the ones now. . As Islam has
spread, the written Qur’an can be read by those whose first language is not
Arabic.
Legal thinking
(b) To what extent is the Qur’an the basis of legal thinking in Islam? [4]
J13 P1
In notes+ Candidates need to address the “to what extent” part of the
question as this is an evaluative question not a descriptive one.
(b) How useful are ‘ijma and qiyas when dealing with modern
issues?N18 P12
Their uses as they are secondary sources of Islamic law w.r.t examples
smoking, drug use, medical treatments, using internet etc. Rejection: reason
(b)Why do some legal scholars reject the use of analogy (qiyas)? J09 P1
(b) Why do you think some scholars do not favour the use of qiyas? N19
P11
Qiyas is comparing a new issue with an old ruling to arrive at a new ruling.
Some scholars have said that this involves too much of a person’s own
opinion to be creditable. They argue that relying on personal opinion in law-
making would mean that each individual could ultimately form their own
subjective conclusions. This would mean that they could make decisions for
their own benefit and not for the benefit of society/Islamic community. Shi’a
scholars reject the use of qiyas. The majority of scholars do allow the use of
qiyas but there is a preference for ijma’.
(b) Give an example to show how the Qur’an could be used in the
exercise of qiyas (analogy) to face a new situation. [4] N10 P1
Brief account of what qiyas is. An example that can clearly be shown to be
using qiyas, so there should be a fundamental teaching (from the Qur’an), a
new matter in question, and a linking cause that connects them.
(b) Why do you think the Qur’an and Sunna are not the only sources of
Law and are supplemented by ‘ijma and qiyas? N17 P11
For e.g. that all eventualities could not have been put in the Qur’an and
Hadith. The Prophet’s life was an example of the Qur’an, and the way that
Islam should be lived, and so was limited to the norms and culture of that
time. Now there are advancements in ideas and technology that need
clarification, so ‘ijma and qiyas are required for these new issues, but they
have to be based on original rulings, and therefore on the Qur’an and sunna.
+ examples of issues that are not covered solely by the Qur’an and Sunna
and require the use of ‘ijma or qiyas such as smoking, using the internet,
drugs, medical treatments etc.
(b) Do you think that both ijma’ and qiyas are equally important for
solving present day issues? Give reasons for your answer. [4] J16 P12
(b) How important is the use of ijma’ or qiyas in Islamic law in present
day situations? Give reasons for your answers. [4] N14 P11
The primary sources contain everything that is the basis for Islamic law, but
as time passes new issues arise which are specific to this time, which need
an answer. Those who are learned in Islamic law can make new rulings,
based on Qur’an and sunna, but using ‘ijma or qiyas. (choose one of these
sources and not only say why it is important but give an example using a
new issue that has arisen, such as smoking, using the internet, drugs,
medical treatments etc.) It is important otherwise Muslims would not know
how to react to these new issues.
[*NOTE: Examples of Ijma, If a father dies before his son, and the son dies
before his grandfather, it is agreed that the grandfather shares in the son’s
estate. (1 mark) This agreement is based on Sura 2.180, ‘When death
approaches any of you, if he leaves any goods he should make a bequest to
parents and next of kin’. (1 mark) This verse shows that the immediate
relatives should be considered before any other claimants to a legacy. (1
mark)]
Write about the experiences of two prophets you have studied in the
Qur’an (not including the Prophet Muhammad). [10] (b) What lessons
can Muslims learn from these stories? [4] N13 P11
These experiences can provide examples for Muslims, e.g., depend on
God and should be patient+ expand on these ideas and say why or how
they could be patient, giving concrete examples. Any relevant answers
should be credited as long as they provide evaluation.