D/A BIM _ WS 2019

Marco Mondello

D/ABIM December 20th, 2019

Coordination
beyond 3D
C A D L O G I C : G R O U P 5 / 6
THEORY 4
M A R C O M O N D E L L O
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
BIM standards
what the
Recap T3
Marco Mondello

PROJECT ENVIRONMENT
allows

what the what the

harsh
CLIENT reality CONTRACTOR
asked for built

colliding interests
happy
concept
coincidence
in the design process

what the
DESIGNER
designed

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello
what the
PROJECT ENVIRONMENT
allows

what the WTF the

harsh
CLIENT reality CONTRACTOR
asked for built ??

happy
concept
coincidence

what the
DESIGNER
designed

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello
what the
PROJECT ENVIRONMENT
allows

what the WTF the

harsh
CLIENT reality CONTRACTOR
asked for built ??

happy
concept
coincidence

what the
DESIGNER
designed

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello
what the
PROJECT ENVIRONMENT
allows

what the WTF the

harsh
CLIENT reality CONTRACTOR
asked for built ??

happy
concept
coincidence

what the
DESIGNER
designed

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello
what the
PROJECT ENVIRONMENT
allows

what the WTF the

harsh
CLIENT reality CONTRACTOR
asked for built ??

happy
concept
coincidence

what the
DESIGNER
designed
Find more: https://book.mstake.com/post/84307540184/top-40-funniest-construction-mistakes

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

T H E H A R D P A R T O F B I M I S

A S S U R I N G D ATA
IS RIGHT
F R O M A H U M A N P E R S P E C T I V E

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

The

Coordination
Model

BIM semantics How to

Design coordination
Standards & Navisworks
Clash Detection
Classification vs Solibri

Data exists Data is right

C O O R D I N AT I O N B E Y O N D 3 D
LOD explained Types of Check

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Putting together bits and pieces

The Coordination Model

Marco Mondello

RIGHT DATA AT THE RIGHT TIME

 Big Database
 Visually demanding
 Multidimensional layers of data
 Produced over the project program
 Supports decision making

COORDINATION MODEL  Federated file

ASSET ENTITIES BREAKDOWN

 Per Discipline
 Per System (if any)
 Per Volume Strategy
 Into constructible elements

ASSET OBJECTS
 BIM = Object-oriented design
DISCIPLINARY MODELS  3D-database
4775 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110827] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4777 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110829] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4778 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110830] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4780 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110832] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4782 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110834] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4788 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110837] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft

GRAPHICAL DATA  Level of Geometry (LOG) NON-GRAPHICAL DATA  Level of Information (LOI)
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

C O O R D I N A T I O N M O D E L : I T ´ S D I F F E R E N T T O A S S U R E

D A T A D A T A

EXISTS IS RIGHT
= =

S I M P L E A S S U R A N C E Q U A L I T Y A S S U R A N C E

Model VALIDATION Model CHECK

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Model Validation

Level of Development (LOD)

Marco Mondello

LOG LOI
S355JO 203x203x86kg/m Steel Column with 30thk baseplate,
LOD. LOI Verified on site LOD 500 4No. M24 holding down bolts & 80x80x6RSA alignment frame^,
verified on site bolt type and oprational

S355JR 203x203x71kg/m Steel Column with 30thk baseplate,

LOD For fabrication LOD 400 4No. M24 holding down bolts & 70x70x5RSA alignment frame…

LOG Detailed geometry

LOD 300 203x203x86kg/m Steel Column

Basic geometry
LOD 200 300x300 Steel Column

Placeholder LOD 100 Building X, Floor 8

LOD = classification system to Phase .

v a l i d a t e t h e A M O U N T O F DATA

4775 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110827] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4777 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110829] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4778 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110830] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4780 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110832] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4782 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110834] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft
4788 4 Column Base Plate-4 Hole-Cross [1110837] 4.000 ft -0.833 ft Concrete-Rectangular-Column : 12 x 18 0.667 ft 0.500 ft 0.089 ft 1.333 ft 0.083 ft

GRAPHICAL DATA  Level of Geometry (LOG) NON-GRAPHICAL DATA  Level of Information (LOI)
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

LOD
LOD

LOD

LOD

100 200 300 400 500

W H A T L O D I S T H I S ?

QUIZ
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
BIM standards & semantics

Who develops LODs and similar?

Marco Mondello

BEING ABLE TO FIND / USE THE INFORMATION BIM HASN´T ONE SINGLE SOURCE OF TRUTH
Classification is a general process in which objects are recognized, differentiated, BIM Forum : the American Institute of Architects.
and understood. Most important are Uniclass and Omniclass . PAS 1192-2 & PAS1192-3 : British Standard Institution
No automation is possible without standardizing the information exchange process. NBS BIM Toolkit : National BIM Library (it´s global, actually)
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello
Clash
Detection
Design Coordination :
prevent nasty stuff from
happening before it´s too
late (on the building site).
Work with tolerances
(for example : it´s OK to
drill a hole in a
plasterboard, if the pipe
needs to go trough).
Spatial
Requirements
Use the object definitions to
verify normative compliance
(for example: escapeways,
disabled people access,…),
space modelling, unallocated
areas, room program.
If standardized, the check
can be automated
IS Data Right?
Types of Check
Design Performance COBIe what else?
Criteria Validation Checking
Monitor whether the Construction Operations
read the
BEP
Control the project outcomes
Building Information Exchange
LOD/LOI and specifications through model simulations
(COBie) is a data format
(= text document) have been (for example: 4D programme,
focused on delivering
implemented in the project 5D quantity take-off, energy
 in the 2D drawings and analysis…) or other KPIs. non-geometrical asset data
(for example: 6D BIM). Everything to be agreed
non-graphical data
Monitor the implementation of within the Collaboration
Check data against any
It´s the typical job of a the collaboration framework Framework
conditions with
senior professional  necessary internal check
Rules / Rulesets
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
How to?

Clash Detection
Marco Mondello

Or, use a platform that allows to share issues across the various stakeholders.

Or, the standard method: a walkthrough to spot the coordination and deisgn issues.

Source: bimtrack.co . The internet is a cool place stuffed with free resources.
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

LOD
LOD

LOD

R E D S E T :
LOD
S T R _ C O N C R E T E

G R E E N S E T :

M E P _ L I G H T I N G

W H A T I S C L A S H I S T H I S ? W H A T S H O U L D Y O U D O ?

QUIZ
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

LOD
LOD

LOD

R E D S E T :
LOD
M E P _ H E A T I N G

G R E E N S E T :

M E P _ L I G H T I N G

W H A T I S C L A S H I S T H I S ? W H A T S H O U L D Y O U D O ?

QUIZ
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

LOD
LOD

LOD

R E D S E T :
LOD
A R C _ N O - S T R - W A L

G R E E N S E T :

M E P _ H E A T I N G

W H A T I S C L A S H I S T H I S ? W H A T S H O U L D Y O U D O ?

QUIZ
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

C O O R D I N A T I O N M O D E L : 2 D I F F E R E N T A P P R O A C H E S

A C C E P T A C C E P T

N AT I V E O N LY
F O R M AT S .IFC
Closed BIM Open BIM

D/ABIM
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello
44
formats
Naviswork is a trash-bin program
that reads seamlessly
most of native data formats.
A matter of Data formats
Navisworks
.RVT .NWC .NWF .NWD
Disciplinary model in Owned by the Typically given to clients and
Exported from most software. BIM-Coordinator.
native format. site personnel.
Feeds a NWF : it represents a Contains all links, rulsets
Contains the selection Can be viewed on a free
disciplinary model and data of the
sets to be exported. version (Naviswork viewer).
(or its breakdown, if any) coordination model. Can be placed into Revit.
READ & INTERPRET DATA
Navisworks imports most data native formats and allows classifying the
information in set (i.e.: search set, visualization set). This way is both
possible to check the data, run clash detection and visualize the project.
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

SOLIBRI MODEL CHECKER

 Automated rule-based check process
 Data visualization
 Data integrity & quality assurance
 Room program check
 Normative and space requirements
 Best Practices
 Quantities

DISCOVER SOLIBRI HERE

D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

D ATA
IS RIGHT
BUT
ARCHITEC
T U R E M AY
BE NOT
D/A BIM _ WS 2019
Marco Mondello

// THANKS //

Q U E S T I O N S ?

N O W L E T ´ S P I N H - 3 S U B M I S S I O N S U P .

D/ABIM