Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Peters
G.A. Covic
J .T. Boys
state vectors
ua,, ... = orthogonal component of output state volt-
age space vector
U, = average output voltage vector for modula-
tion period b I I
L
T = modulation period
Fig. 1 Reduced switch count four-quadrant converter topologies
0 = angle of average output voltage vector a Single- to three-phase bidirectional converter utilising six switches
b Three- to three-phase bidirectional converter utilising eight switches
V l p .U = per unit base for voltage
A = modulation depth in per unit
The desire of manufacturers to meet regulatory
1 Introduction changes as inexpensively as possible has stirred an
interest in new converter topologies. Of most interest to
Significant advances in power electronics have been AC drives manufacturers are those with reduced switch
made during the past decade, including the develop- count operating off either single or three-phase sup-
0IEE, 1998 plies, under both fixed and variable speed operation
IEE Proceedings online no. 19982022
[2-10]. Two such converters with regenerative utility
interfaces are shown in Fig. 1. The output stage is iden-
Paper first received 28th July 1997 and in revised form 19th February
1998 tical in either case, comprising only four switches which
G.L. Peters is with PDL Electronics Ltd., PO Box 741, Napier, New Zea- are connected to two phases of the motor. The third
land phase of the motor is connected to the midpoint of the
G.A. Covic and J.T. Boys are with the Department of Electrical and Elec- DC link. There are a number of application issues
tronic Engineering, University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, New Zea- regarding the performance of such topologies, of most
land
importance is the ability to maintain balanced output
326 IEE Puoc.-Electr. Power Appl., Vol. 145. No. 4, July 1998
waveforms in the presdnce of nonideal DC link condi- The standard approach to generating pulse width
tions. modulation (PWM) waveforms from the four-switch
This paper considers the causes, effects and remedies inverter has been to assume that the link is balanced
pertaining to the output distortion resulting from volt- and of constant voltage. This assumption ceases to
age imbalance in the split DC link. The theoretical remain valid as the output frequency is reduced to low
development herein de,scribes the major factors leading levels. An analytical treatment of the interaction
to voltage imbalance and the effect it has on the output between two reduced switch count converters sharing
voltages produced by the four-switch inverter. Practical the same DC link (Fig. lb) was first presented in [lo].
implementation issues and results showing typical link A link voltage compensation scheme based on sine-tri-
imbalance conditions are also given. The effectiveness angle PWM was briefly mentioned, however no results
of the dynamic imba1,ance compensation technique is showing its effectiveness were presented.
illustrated with measurements taken from a four-switch
inverter driving a three-phase induction motor load.
'b a
'
a b
Fig.3 Space vector diagram of switching state space vectors, with maxi-
(9)
mum permissible circular trajectory shown
a Balanced DC link voltages ( y = 0.5) 2
b Unbalanced DC link voltages ( y < 0.5)
U , = 5(1 - ?)Ed, (10)
For a fixed value of total link voltage Ed,, the verti- If one per unit voltage is defined as the magnitude of
ces of the four-switch inverter rhombus remain fixed the maximum circular trajectory vector under balanced
and only the origin shifts with imbalance. Fig. 36 conditions ( y = 0.5) then
shows how the maximum circular voltage locus that the Ed c
rotating space vector can prescribe within the rhombus v1p.u. = -
2&
has been reduced by the imbalance. In a similar man-
ner to the six-switch inverter, higher output voltages This corresponds to the maximum sinusoidal RMS line
can be generated by forcing the rotating space vector to voltage that can be applied to the motor (neglecting
follow a hexagonal locus [12]; the main difference here on-state voltage drop). If the rotating space vector fol-
being that the vertices of the maximum hexagonal locus lows the hexagonal locus, then the resulting trapezoidal
must be constrained to be less than or equal to the line voltages have a fundamental component that is
smallest switching state vector. 5.3% larger than the sinusoidal case. Taking A as the
per unit modulation depth, and T the modulation
2.3 Definition of switching times period, then eqns. 12-14 for the space vector switching
The four-switch inverter cannot produce any physical times are obtained using eqns. 5-11 for 8 in the range
null switching states like those inherent in the six- 0-180":
switch inverter, so in order to regulate the magnitude
of U, a new mechanism is needed. Here the excess
modulation time is shared between two opposing vec-
tors (U,, U,) or (Ub, U,). The choice of which vector
pair to use for the production of these effective null
states represents the required degree of freedom, with-
out a significant increase in switching frequency. Covic
et al. [7] presented an efficient asymmetric space vector
328 IEE ProcElectr. Power AppL, Vol. 145, No. 4, July 1998
Similar expressions can be derived for the period 180- tively a snapshot in time and the imbalance will be
360" where the Ub veci.or becomes redundant ( t b = 0), oscillating along the UalU, axis, causing the constraint
and Ud becomes active. Eqns. 12-14 are modified by to vary with time.
replacing t b with td to reflect these changes.
3 Experimental results
3. I Practical implementation
Most commercial AC drives measure the DC link volt-
Fig.4 Production of a rotat8ngspace vector U, using only three switch-
age level for control and protection purposes. Provid-
ine state vectors
* ¬es a reference quantity ing an additional voltage feedback signal from the
a Switching vectors for y = 0.5 (halanced link)
b SVM using link conditions shown in Fig. 4a (A* = 0.3, 8* = 30 deg) midpoint of the split D C link allows the degree of link
c Switching vectors for y = 0.3 (unbalanced link) voltage imbalance (y) to be determined. Implementa-
d SVM using link conditions shown in Fig. 4c with no attempt to compensate
for imbalance (A* = 0.3, 8* = 3Cl deg) tion of the compensation technique within the wave-
e SVM using link conditions shown in Fig. 4c with dynamic imbalance com- form generation interrupt routine can be done with a
pensation (A* = 0.3, O* = 30 de€)
few additional lines of software. A single 80C196KB
microcontroller running at 12MHz was used to control
The generation of circular space vector trajectories the four-switch inverter to prove that such a low-cost
that comes from effective compensation is only possible 16 bit processor was more than adequate to provide
if the modulation depth is constrained to be less than compensated waveform generation, I/O handling, sys-
the length of the shortest switching state vector tem protection and host communications. A 1.5kHz
(Fig. 5a). It should be noted that Fig. 5 shows effec- switching frequency was used in the generation of the
IEE Proc.-Electr. Power Appl., Vol. 145, No. 4 , July 1998 329
following results, this could easily have been increased for a 50Hz supply. In consequence, the voltages on the
to improve output current ripple. The low modulation two halves form a total level ripple at a frequency of
depth usually associated with low output frequencies 100Hz, and an imbalance ripple of 50Hz. Secondly, the
may require the effects of dead time to be considered as operation of the four-switch inverter loads the D C link
the switching frequency is increased. in a manner which causes imbalance ripple at the
An initial study of the effects of link imbalance on output frequency; this effect is much worse at lower
waveform quality was carried out using an evaluation frequencies and lower modulation depths. The combi-
circuit. This circuit utilised the gating waveforms gener- nation of these two imbalance generating phenomena
ated by the 80C196, logic gates to mimic the inverter results in complex harmonic and imbalanced voltages
action, and two separately regulated adjustable voltage in the D C link.
sources to emulate a D C link imbalance. Fig. 6a illus- Figs. 7 and 8 show the AC measured link voltages
trates the origin shift in the space vector plane for a for a four-switch inverter operating from a total DC
fixed D C imbalance if waveforms are generated assum- link voltage of 500V. Each of these results shows a
ing balanced conditions. Fig. 66 also shows that it is snapshot in time lasting 400ms. With reference to
possible to successfully remove the output offset and Fig. 1; the total link voltage is measured as (VHo+
return the circular space vector trajectory to the origin, V,,) and the imbalance as (VHo- V,,). Figs. 7a and b
indicative of a balanced system, by accounting for the show these link voltages ( VHo+ VoL)and ( VHo- VoL),
changed magnitude and phase relationships between respectively, at an output frequency of 10Hz. The
the switching state vectors when calculating switching imbalance ripple resulting from unequal loading of the
times. split D C link by the four-switch inverter is clearly
shown in Fig. 7b, where the dominant frequency com-
ponent is the fundamental output frequency (1OHz).
15, , I I I
10
> 5
a i 0
-B
a
-5
-10
-15f 1
>
-20
a
' '
time (25ms/div)
I
I"
> 5
g o
m
r -5
9 -10
, /
time (25msidiv)
40: , , ,
b b time (25msidiv)
Fig.6 Voltage vector trajectory for aJixed D C offset imbalance Fig.8 Ripple components in the split D C link for 17.5Hz output
a Assuming fixed y = 0.5 a Total link level AC ripple
b Accounting for variable y b Link imbalance AC ripple
3.2 DC link conditions Figs. Sa and b illustrate the reducing imbalance con-
In general, a single phase uncontrolled diode rectifier tribution of the four-switch inverter as the output fre-
causes the worst case imbalance conditions to occur in quency is increased. As a consequence of this, the 50Hz
the D C link. For this reason the remainder of the imbalance component caused by input rectification
paper will consider the dynamic imbalance compensa- becomes more pronounced (Fig. 86).
tion of three-phase output waveforms from a four-
switch inverter supplied by a voltage-doubling single- 3.3 Distortion caused by uncompensated
phase diode rectifier. link imbalance
As discussed in Section 2.1, the DC link is affected If PWM output voltages are produced without consid-
by two load dependent phenomena. First, with a volt- ering the nonideal D C link conditions described in Sec-
age-doubling rectifier the different halves of the split tion 3.2 then unbalanced stator voltages will result at
link are charged at different times, some lOms apart low output frequencies. Relatively small voltage asym-
330 IEE Pvoc.-Electi. Power Appl., Vol. 145, No. 4,July 1998
metries can cause large stator current variations [13]. resonance. The increased stator and rotor losses result-
There are two torque Icomponents that result from such ing from operating motors with unbalanced voltages
asymmetry: an average component produced by the may also necessitate derating of the motor [15].
summation of positive and negative sequence compo-
nents, and a pulsating component at twice output fre- 3.4 Effectiveness of compensation
quency resulting from the interaction between the Using the same experimental technique as used to
stator currents and stator flux linkages [14]. This is in obtain the results shown in Section 3.3, and enabling
addition to the pulsating torque components produced the compensation described in Section 2.3, output
due to the PWM switching pattern, which can be waveform distortions due to voltage imbalance in the
reduced by increasing the switching frequency of the DC link are eliminated. This is clearly shown in
inverter, Fig. IOU where the flux trajectory is circular, and
At an output frequency of lOHz the stator flux Fig. 10b where balanced stator currents are produced.
space-vector trajectory is elliptical due to the close rela-
tionship between the imbalance ripple frequency and 1.c
0.5
-0.5
g
3
x‘ 0
=
> -1 .c
-1 .o -0.5 0 0.5 1 .o
X flux, Wb
-0.5
-1.o
-1.o -0.5 0 0.5 1.o
X flux, Wb
a
-2
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
time, s
b
Fig. 10 Motor supply with compensationfor DC link voltage imbalance
clearly showing restoration of balanced inverter output supply
a Stator flux space-vector trajectory (10Hz)
h Stator current (10Hz)
-2 1
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 The compensation technique described in this paper
time, s allows high quality balanced three phase voltages to be
b
generated down to near DC output frequency. In a
Fig.9 Motor supply without compensation for DC link voltage imbal-
ance bidirectional single to three phase converter (Fig. la)
a Stator flux space-vector trajeztory (lOHz), ideal circular pattern also shown the lower limit in frequency is governed by the level of
b Stator current (10Ha)
input current distortion allowed as the switching
rectifier looses its ability to force input currents
It is important to note that for a given level of volt- correctly [8, lo].
age imbalance in the IIC link the relative output distor-
tion caused increases dramatically as the modulation 4 Conclusions
depth is lowered. This characteristic has limited the
adoption of the four-switch topology as a low-cost gen- Reducing the number of power switching devices in a
eral purpose inverter. The torque ripple effects resulting converter can lead to an overall cost reduction of the
from such distortion limit its use in low speed applica- unit. To do this, however, special topologies such as
tions, especially in fadduct systems where the low the one described in this paper are required. It was
frequency torque ripple could cause annoying duct shown that the generation of a low frequency output
IEE Proc -Electr Power Appl, Vol 145, No 4, July 1998 331
can cause considerable voltage imbalance in the DC VAN DER BROECK, H.W., and SKUDELNY, H.C.: ‘Analyti-
link. Severe output distortion will occur if this imbal- cal analysis of the harmonic effects of a PWM AC drive’, ZEEE
Trans. Power Elec., 1988, PE-3, (2), pp. 216-223
ance is not considered when calculating the inverter ENJETI, P., and RAHMAN, A.: ‘A new single to three-phase
switching times. converter with active current shaping for low cost AC motor
Asymmetric space vector modulation, with link volt- drives’, ZEEE Trans. Znd. AppL, 1993, 29, (4),pp. 806-813
age feedback, is capable of producing a high quality ENJETI, P., RAHMAN, A., and JAKKLI, R.: ‘Economic single
phase to three phase converter topologies for fixed and variable
balanced three-phase supply suitable for driving cage frequency output’, IEEE Trans. Power Elec., 1993, 8, (3), pp.
induction motors. The computational efficiency of the 329-335
waveform generation makes it simple to implement RODRIGUEZ, J., PONT, J., BARRAZA, J., and WIECH-
MA”, E.: ‘Field oriented control of a three-phase induction
such a DC link imbalance and ripple rejection scheme machine driven by a regenerative converter with sinusoidal input
while allowing maximum possible output voltages. The current.’ Proceedings of 5th European conference on Power eZec-
real time nature of this technique provides near instan- tronics and applications, EPE93, Brighton, UK, Sept. 1993, Vol.
taneous control of frequency and amplitude, allowing IEE Conf. Pub. 377, pp. 4.154.20
COVIC, G.A., PETERS, G.L., and BOYS, J.T.: ‘An improved
high performance control strategies to be physically single phase to three phase converter for low cost AC motor
realised. drives.’ Proceedings of IEEE international conference on Power
With balanced output generation now possible down electronics and drive systems, PEDS’95, Singapore, Feb. 1995,
Vol. 1, pp. 549-554
to near DC frequencies, the four-switch inverter struc- PETERS, G.L., and COVIC, G.A.: ‘Asymmetric PWM inverters:
ture is an attractive topology for low cost, small power reducing the switch count in regenerative AC drives.’ Proceedings
AC motor drives. It is particularly well suited for single of IPENZ Annual conference, Dunedin, New Zealand, Feb. 1996,
phase input applications requiring low distortion utility Vol. 2, (I), pp. 187-191
BLAABJERG, F., FREYSON, S., HANSEN, H.H., and
interfaces and regenerative capability. This paper has HANSEN, S.: ‘A new optimized space vector strategy for a com-
shown that it is possible to avoid adding excessive ponent minimized voltage source inverter.’ Proceedings of 10th
amounts of costly DC link capacitance to limit the annual Applied power electronics conference, APEC‘95, March
voltage distortion generated at low output frequencies. 1995. nn. 511-585
I I I ~ ~ ~~~
332 IEE Pvoc.-Electr. Power Appl., Vol. 145, No, 4,July 1998