Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Julius Fink, Brad Jon Schoenfeld, Anthony C. Hackney, Masahito Matsumoto,
Takahiro Maekawa, Koichi Nakazato & Shigeo Horie (2018): Anabolic-androgenic steroids:
procurement and administration practices of doping athletes, The Physician and Sportsmedicine,
DOI: 10.1080/00913847.2018.1526626
Article views: 12
DOI: 10.1080/00913847.2018.1526626
Authors
t
Julius Fink1, Brad Jon Schoenfeld2, Anthony C. Hackney3, Masahito
ip
Matsumoto4, Takahiro Maekawa5 Koichi Nakazato6 and Shigeo Horie7
cr
Affiliation
1Graduate School of Medicine, Department of Metabolism and Endocrinology,
us
Juntendo University, Tokyo, JAPAN
2Department of Health Sciences, Lehman College, Bronx, NY, USA
an
3Department of Exercise & Sport Science; Department of Nutrition – School
of Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA
4Advanced Diabetic Therapeutics, Department of Metabolic Endocrinology,
M
Corresponding author
Ac
There is no funding received for this work (from NIH, Wellcome Trust,
1
HHMI, or any others). There are no professional relationships with
companies or manufacturers who will benefit from the results of the present
study for each author.
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
2
Review
of doping athletes
t
ip
Authors
cr
Julius Fink1, Brad Jon Schoenfeld2, Anthony C. Hackney3, Masahito Matsumoto4,
us
Takahiro Maekawa5 Koichi Nakazato6 and Shigeo Horie7
an
Affiliation
M
1
Graduate School of Medicine, Department of Metabolism and Endocrinology,
ed
2
Department of Health Sciences, Lehman College, Bronx, NY, USA
ce
3
Department of Exercise & Sport Science; Department of Nutrition – School of
4
Advanced Diabetic Therapeutics, Department of Metabolic Endocrinology,
5
Department of Rehabilitation for the Movement Functions Research Institute,
3
National Rehabilitation Center for Persons with Disabilities
6
Graduate Schools of Health and Sport Science, Nippon Sport Science
t
7
ip
Graduate School of Medicine, Department of Urology, Juntendo University,
cr
Tokyo Japan
Corresponding author
us
an
Name: Julius Fink
M
Telephone: +81-3-3813-3111
pt
Fax: +81-3-3813-596
ce
E-mail: j-fink@juntendo.ac.jp
Ac
4
Abstract
t
become more and more dangerous. Prior to the mid-1970’s, anabolic steroids
ip
were not regulated and easily available from physicians and pharmacies in
several countries. In 1990, the United States enacted the Anabolic Steroid
cr
Control Act, leading to the proliferation of black markets and underground
laboratories. The shift from pharmacy to underground online sites for the
us
procurement of anabolic steroids led to an increase of fake products with low
purity and the ability to potentially endanger the health of anabolic steroid users.
an
Underground laboratories emerged both locally and in countries with lax legal
regulations. “Anabolic steroid tourism” and large networks of online resellers
emerged, leading to the banalisation of the illegal procurement of anabolic
M
misinformation and dangerous practices that currently exist. The dosages and
ways of administration recommended on these forums can be false and
misleading to those who lack a medical background and cannot go to their
pt
physician to seek advice because of the fear of repercussions. This review aims
to elucidate and describe current practices of the anabolic-androgenic steroids
ce
5
Introduction
Anabolic-androgenic steroids (AAS) have existed since the discovery of
synthetic testosterone in the 1930’s. Their potent beneficial effects on sports
performance due to increased neuromuscular performance and muscle fiber
characteristics (1) were soon discovered and became widely used by athletes
until they were banned by the International Olympic Council in 1972.
t
Nevertheless, medical research led to the development of several new
ip
testosterone derivatives triggering a rise in demand among athletes who early
on noticed not only the performance-enhancing properties of these compounds,
cr
but also their anabolic effects. The use of AAS in competitive bodybuilding
became widespread and was often supervised by physicians who supplied the
us
drugs to the athletes, ensuring what they were injecting was pure while
monitoring and minimizing side effects such as infertility, liver toxicity, impaired
an
lipid profiles, high blood pressure, acne, hair loss or gynecomastia. During this
time, there was no need for a black market or underground laboratories (UGL)
since these drugs were readily available from heath professionals. However, the
M
Act of 2004. In 2014, the Designer Steroid Control Act was enacted in an attempt
to close loopholes for slightly modified compounds. These events created an
immense demand for black market products, which facilitated the creation of
pt
UGL products and the importing of drugs produced in countries with lax AAS
legislations.
ce
t
quality products, even though they are not controlled and the manufacturing
ip
facilities are often below standard for the production of human grade drugs.
Recently, UGL labs have begun to advertise modern production facilities on
cr
their websites to reassure potential customers as to product efficacy. UGL
products are often sold under different brand names as compared to
us
pharmaceutical grade products or just labeled with the active ingredient
depending on the manufacturer.
an
3) AAS produced in countries such as Thailand, India, Pakistan or Mexico are
often illegally imported and sold online. These products are often shipped
directly from the country of origin to the buyer’s house. This category of AAS
M
black market. The risk of losing their license or getting incarcerated often
makes sellers charge several times the retail price of the products. However,
Ac
due to the increase of fake AAS and the health risks associated with
counterfeits, many AAS users are willing to pay the higher price to ensure the
quality and safety of what they are using.
5) SARMs are not approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
However, many sellers on the black market use the fact that SARMs are not
yet listed as banned substances and can therefore be sold as research drugs.
However, this is a grey zone and might be soon regulated by the FDA.
7
Even though legitimate pharmaceutical grade AAS can be purchased on the
black market via several routes, physician supervision of usage is lacking,
making a legitimate pharmaceutical product potentially dangerous for
uninformed users. Since buying and using AAS (without a medical prescription)
is a criminal act in many countries, the AAS user is often reluctant to seek advice
from a physician when health issues arise. Indeed, a survey found that AAS
t
users very often have no trust in physicians’ knowledge about AAS and typically
ip
do not disclose their AAS use to them (11).
cr
In sum, the AAS market has undergone major changes over the past
20 years, especially caused by shifts in the legal status. The purpose of this
us
review is to elucidate the routes, practice of usage and the context in which
athletes procure and use AAS currently, as well as provide information to
an
prevent this population from endangering themselves via the use of illicit doping
drugs.
M
A survey of 1,955 AAS users showed that the major route of procurement is the
Internet (52.7%), followed by local sources (16.7%), friends or training partners
(15%), physician’s prescription (6.6%) and obtaining them from foreign countries
pt
(5.8%) (5). Routes of procurement can basically be divided into the following five
methods:
ce
1) Local dealers: These transactions often take place at gyms. The buyer has to
Ac
rely 100% on the credibility of the dealer with regard to the products he is
buying.
2) The Internet: Currently there are numerous online sites selling AAS
worldwide.
3) Overseas: “Steroid tourism” in countries without prohibitive laws against
AAS.
4) Local pharmacies or physicians.
5) Patients with prescription for drugs.
8
The quality of products offered by a local dealer can vary widely, ranging from
legitimate pharmaceutical grade drugs to counterfeits. This method of
procurement is the preferred choice for most newcomers because of its ease as
well as the personal advice often provided by the dealer. Moreover, this method
of procurement is not traceable and therefore is generally regarded as the safest
t
with regard to avoiding law enforcement. However, buyers cannot track the
ip
origin of the products and are frequently given inaccurate advice with regard to
dosages and injection practices.
cr
A recent study showed that AAS-selling websites are mainly registered in the
us
United States (46.7%) and Europe (30%) (6). Besides AAS, several other
performance/muscle mass enhancing products (clenbuterol: 76.7%; growth
an
hormone/insulin-like growth factor-1; 60%, thyroid hormones: 46.7%;
erythropoietin: 30%, and insulin: 20%) and products aimed at reducing
AAS-induced side effects (estrogen antagonists: 63.3%; products for erectile
M
information collected, and the use of credit cards, many potential buyers are
reluctant to order online. This has led many online sellers to accept anonymous
payment methods such as Bitcoin, thus making the transaction safer for the
pt
buyer. Parcels are typically shipped in package size and labeling approaches
aimed at avoiding customs inspection (6). The online sellers can be divided into
ce
two categories: online sellers offering brand name counterfeit products often
targeting newcomers without knowledge and online sellers offering UGL or
Ac
pharmaceutical grade products from overseas. The former online sites are often
scams aiming to make large profits within a short period of time until the scam is
exposed in the AAS user community. The latter online sites, often calling
themselves “online pharmacies,” attempt to take advantage of the self-regulated
aspect of this industry and the lax regulations of several overseas countries,
making them immune against the laws of countries in which AAS users are
buying from. These sellers typically target more experienced AAS users and
develop sophisticated supply systems from a number of different countries. This
9
type of online site tends to have greater credibility among AAS users, but the risk
of seizure at customs can discourage consumers from choosing this method.
These types of websites often project the appearance of import services from
overseas pharmacies, offering a large variety of drugs in addition to AAS.
Sometimes the products offered on these sites include pharmaceutical grade
drugs for human consumption and UGL products that are not approved for
t
human consumption; this creates confusion among naïve consumers who
ip
believe they are buying legitimate pharmaceutical grade drugs.
cr
Traveling overseas to obtain AAS in countries such as Mexico or Thailand is a
popular option. Since such drugs are sold without prescription at pharmacies in
us
these countries, the user is able to isolate the origin of the product. Moreover,
AAS are often cheaper in these countries, creating a financial incentive to travel
an
abroad. However, in certain countries, counterfeit products might be sold even in
pharmacies. There also is the legal risk of passing through customs with the
AAS; if caught, the user may face significant jail time.
M
Buying AAS from a physician or pharmacist willing to “bend” the laws is perhaps
ed
The final option is to buy AAS from individuals receiving medical treatment for
conditions such as HIV, cancer, chronic kidney disease, primary or secondary
Ac
In conclusion, there are several routes to buy AAS on the black market, however
10
each of these include substantial personal health and/or legal risks.
A recent survey showed that the major source of information for AAS users is the
internet, while information from health care providers was sought out by less
t
than 50% of respondents (10). The internet, with its underground forums and
ip
“information” sites, often spreads misleading or false information to AAS users.
Search results for information on the internet about AAS frequently lead to
cr
AAS-promoting websites that are linked to black market sites. These sites
invariably attempt to promote sales by highlighting the muscle-building and
us
performance-enhancing effects of illicit drugs while downplaying associated
health risks.
an
Since there is strong incrimination of AAS use, athletes are often reluctant to visit
a physician to get proper advice and instead turn to the internet to gather
M
false advice to other users with the potential for serious health complications.
Improper advice can range from the type of drug to take to dosages and injection
practices. Very often, 3 or more compounds taken in enormous dosages 5 to 29
pt
t
bodybuilding-related drugs found that more than 80% of drugs seized at the
ip
Swiss customs office did not contain the claimed substance in the respective
amount, with 60% being under-concentrated and 8% containing no active drug
cr
at all (14). Another study found even more alarming rates (48.6%) of inert
products in counterfeit drugs (7). These products may contain steroids or
us
steroid-like substances, potentially leading to serious health risks.
an
AAS and other performance enhancing drugs on the black market
ester, seems to be the most popular drug on the black market, followed by
methandienone, stanozol, nandrolone, oxandrolone, boldenone, mesterolone,
ed
use are popular amongst athletes (Figure 1). From the data of a recent study
investigating the Google search trends with regard to AAS, seasonal fluctuations
for several AAS have been observed (13). For instance, “hardening” agents (i.e.
AAS thought to decrease body fat while increasing muscle mass without water
retention) used by bodybuilders pre-contest such as oxandrolone, trenbolone
and stanazolol show peaks during pre-contest/contest season (spring/summer),
whereas compounds used year-round such as testosterone do not show such
seasonal trends (13).
12
Several UGL have improved their packaging systems in an attempt to assume
the appearance of legitimate pharmaceutical companies. Some of them even
have websites displaying the line of products and identification code security
check systems linked to a number on the vials. This information is provided
despite the lack of a corporate address or telephone number information on the
t
website. Other UGL websites even display videos of the production of the AAS
ip
and includes a “research” section on the website, making it very difficult for
novices to distinguish it from legitimate pharmaceutical company websites.
cr
Besides AAS, peptide hormones like GH and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1),
us
selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERM), and human chorionic
gonadotropin (HCG) are also often offered on these sites. GH is a very
an
expensive and a controlled medical substance, however its anabolic actions and
“fat burning” (lipolytic) effects are highly sought by athletes, even though its
effects on sport performance are still not clear yet, especially due to its usage
M
often in combination with AAS which makes it difficult to assess the effects of GH
(12). This has led to a boom of counterfeit GH flooding the black market. In
ed
however the potency of such products often deteriorates during the shipping and
storage process since GH is a very labile peptide hormone that requires cool
ce
storage. Recently, several UGLs have began to offer dangerous drugs such as
erythropoietin (EPO), which increases the amount of red blood cells (i.e.,
Ac
hematocrit) and thus the potential for increased endurance performance. AAS
are also known to increase the amount of red blood cells, and can be potentially
dangerous when used in combination with EPO due to blood viscosity issues
and increased myocardial stress. Insulin, another potentially very dangerous
anabolic drug, is readily available in many countries, limiting its demand on the
black market.
Online sellers also are now offering selective androgen receptor modulators
13
(SARMs), which are believed to have similar effects as AAS without the same
degree of negative side effects due to their discriminating targeting of receptors.
However, steroid-like side effects such as liver toxicity, increased potential of
heart attack and stroke, infertility and mental health problems may also occur
with the usage of SARMs. The term “selective” in SARM means they
preferentially bind to androgen receptors in muscle tissue without triggering
t
androgenic effects in other tissues such as the prostate (2, 4, 8). The popularity
ip
of SARMs has also increased among athletes seeking anabolic effects while
minimizing androgenic side effects. The legal status of SARMs allows many web
cr
sites to legally sell these products as “research products not for human
consumption”. Popular SARMs include Andarine, Accadine (AC-262536),
us
Cardarine, Endurobol (GW501516), Mk-677 (Ibutamoren), Ligandrol
(LGD-4033), Ostarine (Mk-2866), Trestolone (RAD-140), S-23, Stenabolic
an
(SR-9009) and YK-11. Even though not approved by the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA), many individuals on the black market take advantage of
the fact that SARMs are not yet listed as banned substances and can therefore
M
SARMs without realizing the long-term side effects of these drugs are still under
investigation, even though similar side effects to AAS have been observed.
pt
ce
Ac
14
Table 1. List of most popular AAS sold on the black market
Name of the AAS Form of Approval for human use
administration
Anadrol Oral Yes: treatment of anemia,
(oxymetholone) osteoporosis and muscle wasting in
HIV patients
t
Anavar Oral Yes: osteoporosis, weight gain after
ip
(oxandrolone) surgery or trauma, during chronic
infection, counteract catabolic effects
cr
of long-term corticosteroid therapy,
recovery from burns, Turner
us
syndrome and muscle wasting in
HIV patients
an
Deca durabolin Intramuscular Yes: anemia, osteoporosis, recovery
(nandrolone) injection from burns, cancer, HIV
Dianabol Oral Formerly approved for the treatment
M
cancer
Primobolan Oral (acetate) Yes (Japan and Moldova only):
(metenolone) or recovery after surgery or burns,
intramuscular osteoporosis
injection
(enanthate)
Trenbolone Intramuscular No: only veteran medicine
15
injection
Winstrol (stanozol) Oral or No: Was approved by the FDA in
intramuscular 1962 but discountinued for human
injection use in most countries
t
Nontransparent AAS market
ip
Several pharmaceutical companies produce AAS via subsidiaries in different
cr
countries and under different names, creating confusion among users and
making it an attractive business for counterfeit dealers. For a variety of reasons,
us
it is often difficult to search for a given drug on the official website of the
pharmaceutical company for non-medical personnel. First, the website might be
an
accessible only for licensed medical personnel. Second, the products might be
sold in certain countries only or not be marketed by the company directly but
rather by third parties with different names, which makes it nearly impossible for
M
a potential AAS buyer to confirm the legitimacy of the products sold on black
market online stores. Counterfeit producers can therefore easily dupe
ed
distinguish between real and counterfeit products since the average AAS user
does not acquire his drugs from a physician or pharmacy.
ce
Table 2 indicates that price fluctuations strongly depend on the compound being
sought by the athlete. Black market prices often reflect the offer and demand
situation and the difficulty to manufacture the given product. With regard to AAS,
legitimate product prices do not substantially differ from black market prices,
except legitimate drugs sold on the black market by physicians. However, huge
differences can be observed with regard to GH. This gap in the GH price might
16
be mainly explained by the price regulation of each country. Indeed, depending
on different regulations, the price of GH can be nearly twice as much in countries
with similar cost of living. For instance, 10mg GH costs about $600 in the United
States and Germany as compared to about $350 in Japan. The same 10mg of
GH might even be sold for under $100 in the Eastern world. However, in most
Western countries, legitimate AAS can only be purchased with a prescription
t
and are very hard to obtain, leading to higher retail prices on the black market.
ip
Table 2. Comparison of AAS and other hormone prices produced by Japanese
cr
pharmaceutical companies with black market products in 2018.
Name of the Official Overseas Overseas UGL price Counterfeit
us
hormone retail price pharma retail price price
grade
an
products
sold on the
local black
M
market
price
ed
enanthate
Methenolone $2/100mg - - $12/100mg $3.5/100mg
ce
acetate
Growth $350/10mg $150/10mg $40/10mg $130/10mg $40/10mg
Ac
hormone
17
Conclusion
The legislation of many countries with regard to AAS and other performance
enhancing drugs has seen dramatic shifts towards incrimination in the past
decades, leading to the rise of inferior quality drugs flooding black markets
worldwide. The lack of official supervision of facilities and manufacturing
t
processes of underground laboratories endangers the health of AAS users.
ip
Even though legislation bans more and more substances, the desire to enhance
performance and appearance does not fade, driving athletes and bodybuilders
cr
to seek illegal ways of procurement and thus incurring the associated health and
legal risks. The internet enabled the rise of such a black market, not only
us
providing a platform for selling illegal drugs, but also for propagating misleading
information to athletes. Besides the well-recognized anabolic and performance
an
enhancing effects of AAS and other performance-enhancing drugs, severe side
effects may occur with their use, especially when the products come from
uncontrolled environments such as many AAS sold on the internet.
M
Declaration of funding
ed
18
References
1. Alen M, Häkkinen K, and Komi P. Changes in neuromuscular
performance and muscle fiber characteristics of elite power athletes
self‐administering androgenic and anabolic steroids. Acta physiologica
scandinavica 122: 535-544, 1984.
2. Basaria S, Collins L, Dillon EL, Orwoll K, Storer TW, Miciek R, Ulloor J,
t
Zhang A, Eder R, and Zientek H. The safety, pharmacokinetics, and
ip
effects of LGD-4033, a novel nonsteroidal oral, selective androgen
receptor modulator, in healthy young men. Journals of Gerontology
cr
Series A: Biomedical Sciences and Medical Sciences 68: 87-95, 2010.
3. Bhasin S, Cunningham GR, Hayes FJ, Matsumoto AM, Snyder PJ,
us
Swerdloff RS, and Montori VM. Testosterone therapy in men with
androgen deficiency syndromes: an Endocrine Society clinical practice
an
guideline. The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 95:
2536-2559, 2010.
4. Choi SM and Lee B-M. Comparative safety evaluation of selective
M
2011.
7. da Justa Neves DB, Marcheti RGA, and Caldas ED. Incidence of anabolic
steroid counterfeiting in Brazil. Forensic science international 228:
e81-e83, 2013.
8. Dalton JT, Taylor RP, Mohler ML, and Steiner MS. Selective androgen
receptor modulators for the prevention and treatment of muscle wasting
associated with cancer. Current opinion in supportive and palliative care
7: 345-351, 2013.
19
9. Parkinson AB and Evans NA. Anabolic androgenic steroids: a survey of
500 users. Medicine & science in sports & exercise 38: 644-651, 2006.
10. Perry PJ, Lund BC, Deninger MJ, Kutscher EC, and Schneider J.
Anabolic steroid use in weightlifters and bodybuilders: an internet survey
of drug utilization. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine 15: 326-330, 2005.
11. Pope HG, Kanayama G, Ionescu‐Pioggia M, and Hudson JI. Anabolic
t
steroid usersd Schneider J. Anabolic steroid Addiction 99: 1189-1194,
ip
2004.
12. Saugy M, Robinson N, Saudan C, Baume N, Avois L, and Mangin P.
cr
Human growth hormone doping in sport. British journal of sports medicine
40: i35-i39, 2006.
us
13. Teck JTW and McCann M. Tracking internet interest in
anabolic-androgenic steroids using Google Trends. International Journal
an
of Drug Policy 51: 52-55, 2018.
14. Weber C, Krug O, Kamber M, and Thevis M. Qualitative and
Semiquantitative Analysis of Doping Products Seized at the Swiss Border.
M
20