Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sarah Berry, Vanesa Hernandez, Raul Palma, Chelsea Ruthrauff, and Katelyn Sult
Executive Summary
Motherhood is one of the most important occupations in this world. In Sierra Leone, the
transition into motherhood becomes a time of great risk, and these risks should be addressed in a
priority-like manner. In 2010, approximately forty percent of the population in Sierra Leone had
access to health care (CARE, 2010). There are nearly two million people living in Sierra Leone,
and with fewer than 180 government health workers who can assist with maternal delivery,
maternal risks have increased dramatically (CARE, 2010). Sierra Leone has one doctor for every
33,000 people (CARE, 2010). In comparison, within the United States, there are approximately
730 people to one doctor (CARE, 2010). These statistics need to be changed in order to help the
Through our proposed project, based off the learnings of evidence-based practice
literature reviews, we aim to reduce the maternal mortality rate in Sierra Leone from 1,360
deaths out of 100,000 live births to seventy out of 100,000 live births by the year 2030 (Mason,
2016). In order to achieve this goal, parenting classes will be provided in order to educate
traditional birth assistants (TBAs) by utilizing formal midwifery training. Funding for this
proposal will come from grants, donations, and fundraising efforts. The initial team will be
comprised mainly of medical volunteers, who are obtained by volunteer advertisement in local
hospitals, informational meetings, and religious affiliates. The group of medical professionals
will consist of a multidisciplinary team comprised of nurses, physicians, medical students, and
nursing students, all who have been formally trained before departure. Upon arrival to Sierra
Leone, contact will be made with the gatekeeper, person of contact, in order to appropriately
communicate with the community. The gatekeeper, elders, TBAs, current health care
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 3
professionals, and all other members of society will have the opportunity to be involved in the
educational opportunities presented. Using personal and working relationships, autonomy and
confidence will be instilled in the TBAs so improved, quality health care is provided to all
observations. Limitations are further detailed in the section labeled monitoring and evaluation.
Maternal mortality rates are a growing concern in Sierra Leone. As an aim to help this
vulnerable population, a proposal has been created with efforts from volunteers, various methods
of funding, and a growing opportunity for educational enhancement. Throughout this paper,
discussion of the problems at hand, a literature review and analysis, a logic model, project goals
and objectives, the technical approach and work plan, and monitoring and evaluation methods
will be discussed.
Background
The transition into motherhood should be filled with joy, love, and happiness. But for the
women living in Sierra Leone, childbirth equates to death. Why is this? This is because many
areas within Sierra Leone are absent of obstetric, antenatal, and postnatal services. This means
that multiple complications have the capability to arise without professional assistance. Antenatal
care is typically never received; resulting in nearly 1,360 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births
in Sierra Leone (Mason, 2016). The United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund
(UNICEF), estimates that in “2015, 1 in 17 mothers [in Sierra Leone] have a lifetime risk of
death associated with childbirth.” (Mason, 2016). Currently, there is a shortage in skilled health
care workers in Sierra Leone because of the Ebola outbreak; this has negatively affected the
According to a study done by Amara (2012), many expecting mothers have turned to
TBAs, to assist during the birthing process. The quality of care provided by a health care facility
is significantly better than that of TBA usage (Amara, 2012). TBAs are not trained to care for
postpartum hemorrhage, which is a major cause of maternal deaths, especially in the rural
locations in Sierra Leone (Mason, 2016). TBAs and other medical staff should be properly
mortality rates within Sierra Leone. On average, antenatal care received throughout Sierra Leone
was 86 percent, but not timely due to distance, transportation methods, and social norms to delay
care-seeking until pregnancy is visible (Sharkey et al., 2016). These barriers were present
especially within the poorer areas of Sierra Leone (Sharkey et al., 2016). Approximately only
53.6 percent of women and newborns, delivered at home, had postnatal checks. In contrast, if
delivery was done within a health care facility, 94.1 percent of women and newborns received
postnatal care (Sharkey et al., 2016). Clean cord care, delaying first baths, and immediate
breastfeeding were inadequate across all districts (Sharkey et al., 2016). “Efforts should be made
to improve geographic access to facility-based care in these settings, and traditional and
newborn health as the country works to strengthen and even rebuild its fragile health system”
Literature Review
Article One
The purpose of the study was to discuss the many interacting vulnerabilities that
Sagbakken, & Treacy, 2018). The research design method was a qualitative study that collected
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 5
data through seven focus group discussions and twenty-two in-depth interviews with women
who had been pregnant within the last year, older women who had been involved in a delivery or
had a close family member in the village who had been pregnant within the last year, and men
who had a close family member in the village who had been pregnant within the last year. The
results of this study showed that pregnant women in rural Sierra Leone face many intersecting
vulnerabilities including poverty, gender inequality, and the unequal distribution of money,
power, and resources. Males were deemed to be the childbirth decision makers. Essentially,
childbirth decisions are greatly influenced by the constraints of poverty and other social
Article Two
The purpose of this study was to examine the quality of free antenatal services and access
to emergency obstetric care in Sierra Leone (Bangura, et al., 2017). A cross-sectional survey was
done in ninety-seven peripheral health facilities and three hospitals. One hundred antenatal care
providers were interviewed, and 276 observations were made and 486 pregnant women were
interviewed. A few assessments were completed: the adequacy of antenatal and delivery services
were assessed, the distance between each facility providing delivery services and the nearest
comprehensive emergency obstetric care (CEOC) facility was calculated, and the proportion of
facilities in a chiefdom within fifteen kilometers of each CEOC facility was calculated. The
results of this study showed that the quality of services was poor. Only twenty-seven percent of
women were examined, two percent were screened on their first prenatal visit, and forty-seven
percent got interventions as recommended. Ninety-four percent of the facilities provided delivery
services, a mere forty percent had delivery rooms, forty-two percent had delivery kits, and only
forty-six percent had portable water. Thirty-five percent of deliveries were supervised by skilled
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 6
attendants and only thirty-five percent of those were adequately documented. In regard to
national standards, none of the five basic emergency obstetric care facilities were completely
compliant. The central and northernmost parts of the district had the least access to
Article Three
This study’s purpose was to identify why women use services provided by TBAs as
compared to health facilities, and to suggest strategies to improve utilization of health facilities
for maternity and newborn care services (Amara et al., 2012). Qualitative data were collected
through focus group discussions conducted in urban and rural areas of Sierra Leone. There were
four sites with five focus groups consisting of young women, young men, adult women, and
adult men. There were eight participants in each focus group. Additional inclusion criteria
consisted of presence in the vicinity of a hospital and previous personal use of the hospital by
oneself or a family member. The results of this study are that the quality of care in relation to the
survival of pregnant women and their newborns in health facilities are only marginally better
than the services provided by TBAs. The cost in time, dignity and money associated with using
health facilities outweigh the benefits and serve as barriers to health facility utilization while
better than TBA care, free of financial considerations at the point of need and with appropriate
infrastructure that will begin to go away from TBAs and make the idea of universal skilled
Article Four
According to the authors, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the implementation of
an emergency obstetric referral system in terms of its use, acceptability and accessibility
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 7
(Bhopal, Halpin, & Gerein, 2012). It was a mixed-method study. Records were kept detailing
each use of the ambulance including: date, patient identifying details, start and end mileage, total
mileage, reason for referral, treatment, outcome, and staff member name. To get more
information regarding acceptability and value of the service, fourteen in-depth semi-structured
interviews were carried out with the lead members, staff members, ambulance drivers and
ambulance users. The result of this study showed that a motorbike ambulance provided at low
cost as part of the healthcare system in rural areas can help reduce a large barrier to receiving
Article Five
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of healthcare provider training
intervention programs with the goal of reducing maternal and newborn mortality (Ameh et al.,
2016). There was an evaluation of knowledge and skills of 5,939 healthcare providers before and
after three to five days of skills and drills in EmOC&NC in seven sub-Saharan African countries
and two Asian countries. Standardized assessments using multiple choice questions and objective
structured clinical examinations (OSCE) were used to measure change in knowledge and skills
and the improvement ratio by cadre and country. A linear regression was done to identify
variables associated with pre-training and improvement ratio. The results were that Ninety-nine
and seven tenths of healthcare providers improved their overall score. There were significant
improvements in knowledge and skills for each cadre of healthcare each individual provider and
each country. Essentially, the short in-service of EmOC&NC training was associated with an
improvement in knowledge and skills for all cadres of healthcare providers working in maternity
Article Six
This study’s purpose was to determine retention of knowledge and skills after
standardized “skills and drills” training in Emergency Obstetric Care (Ameh et al., 2018). This
was a longitudinal cohort study. There were 609 maternity care providers of whom 455 were
nurse/midwives in Ghana, Malawi, Nigeria, Kenya, Tanzania and Sierra Leone. Their knowledge
and skills were assessed before and after training at three, six, nine, and twelve months. An
analysis of variance to explore differences in scores by country and level of healthcare facility
for each cadre was done. Mixed effects regression analysis to account for potential explanatory
factors including: facility type, years of experience providing maternity care, months since
training and number of repeat assessments. The results of this study were that for up to one year
after training, both knowledge and skills were close to the levels obtained immediately after
training. Health care facility levels and experience were not determinants of retention. Overall,
after training, healthcare providers retain knowledge and skills for up to twelve months (Ameh et
al., 2018).
To meet the program goal of decreasing maternal mortality, the following objectives have
been prioritized: increase the education regarding maternal mortality and prevention in the Sierra
Leone community within one month, increase accessibility to family planning services within a
twelve-month period, access to health-care will increase to 70 percent by 2030, and maternal
mortality will decrease within twelve-month. The inputs for the project include the use of
evidence-based practice literature to formulate community plans with awareness conferences and
educational programs. The input of funding will be through grants and fundraising, and staffing
will be provided by medical recruits, volunteers, and medical missionaries that will help run the
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 9
programs provided. The outputs include activities involving midwifery programs, local
programs, and an awareness conference for the community. The participants in these activities
include midwives, medical staff, community members, and leaders. Short-term outcomes will
result in an increase in knowledge and awareness to staff and community members, regarding
maternal mortality and family planning methods. Knowledge regarding obstetric services and
access to these services is also expected to increase. The medium-term outcomes are expected to
result in medical staff practicing skills that decrease maternal mortality. Also, members of the
community will be accessing services early to prevent complications; health and well-being
reports from individuals are also expected to improve. Long-term outcomes involve an overall
education of the community, and a decrease in maternal complications. The effects of the project
are expected to yield 250 TBAs and midwives that will be knowledgeable on how to improve
obstetric services, 170 leaders of the Sierra Leone cities will bring awareness to their own
communities and villages regarding maternal mortality, and by the end of the local program, 500
locals will report an increase in knowledge regarding family planning and maternal health
services. It is assumed that there is a lack of access in services, lack of knowledge in maternal
health, and lack of adequate training for staff to prevent the incidence of maternal mortality. The
external factors present include policies affecting health care services, funding by government,
and supply availability. Finally, the success of the project will be evaluated by analyzing a
decrease in maternal mortality to 1,000 of 100,000 live births within a twelve-month period.
The goal of our project is derived from the United Nations Sustainable Development
goals for maternal mortality. The current maternal mortality rate of Sierra Leone is 1,360 out of
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 10
100,000 live births (Mason, 2016). Our primary goal is to reduce the maternal mortality rate of
Sierra Leone to seventy out of 100,000 live births by the year 2030 (Mason, 2016). In order to
achieve this goal, our project consists of short, medium, and long-term objectives. These
objectives are all highly supported by the review of the literature. Currently, in Sierra Leone,
pregnant women have increased vulnerability to maternal mortality due to poverty and social
factors (Bangura, et al., 2018). These factors often influence decisions made in regard to
maternal health and childbirth (Bolkan et al., 2018). We have focused on providing parenting
classes to address these factors in addition to formal midwifery classes provided to TBAs. Most
women in Sierra Leone chose to utilize the assistance of a TBA instead of a care facility due to
comfort and accessibility (Daoh et al., 2012). These facilities also only offer limited services and
are noncompliant to the requirements for obstetric care facilities (Banguar et al., 2017). It has
also been proven that the use of EmOC&NC will enhance the skills and knowledge of those
receiving the training (Ameh at al., 2016). These trainings are standardized and have resulted in
the retention of knowledge for up to twelve months (Ameh et al., 2018). These trainings will be
incorporated into the midwifery course content in order to improve and enhance the skills of the
TBAs. The above stated literature supports the objectives of the project.
The first objective of the project is that education regarding maternal mortality and
prevention will increase in the Sierra Leone community within one month. Evidence of this will
be determined through the introduction of midwifery classes for TBA. Attendance and
demonstration of learning during the classes will provide evidence as to whether this objective is
met. The next objective is that women will have an increased access to family planning services
within a twelve-month period. This objective will be evaluated similarly to the previous
objective, but through the introduction of maternal health courses for women in all seventeen
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 11
villages of Sierra Leone. Attendance of these classes will be the primary evidence of increased
access to family planning services. The next objective is that women’s access to health care will
increase by seventy percent by the year of 2030. Evaluation of this objective requires careful
record keeping of all maternal health care interactions. This includes prenatal, labor and delivery,
and postnatal care. The final objective is that maternal mortality rates will decrease within a
twelve-month period. While the goal is for the rate to decrease to at least 1,000 out of every
100,000 live births, any significant decrease in mortality rates would provide evidence that the
interventions are effective. These four primary objectives will help assist in meeting the goal of
the project.
The initial step in the technical approach is to thoroughly research the topic. This
involves research on cultural practices of the people living in Sierra Leone, the primary cause of
high maternal mortality, and evidence-based solutions. The next step is to create a set of goals
and objectives and determine how the effectiveness of interventions will be assessed. The team
must then create a plan of action including the logistics of transportation, housing, and location
for volunteers and staff. This also includes coming in contact with a gatekeeper, which is
essentially a contact person living within the culture that can act as a guide for newcomers
(Social Research Glossary, 2019). Other factors in the plan of action consists of specific
interventions, review of education content, and determining who will participate in the
education. Once these factors have been determined, the team must then obtain funding to
complete the project. The primary source of funding will be grants which require detailed grant
proposals. Additional funding could also come from donations and fundraising efforts. The
initial team must then build a larger team composed of volunteer medical professionals.
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 12
Advertisement in local hospitals and informational meetings can assist in obtaining volunteers.
In the event of sufficient funding, volunteers may become paid staff depending on expertise and
involvement. Prior to traveling to Sierra Leone, the entire team must frequently meet to discuss
goals, objectives, and interventions, collaborate on education techniques, and complete logistical
tasks to ensure that details of travel and accommodation are adequately planned. Once the team
has traveled to Sierra Leone, the participants must establish a relationship with the people in the
area; specifically, traditional birth assistants working in Sierra Leone. Elders will be contacted in
nearby villages and the gatekeeper will act as a liaison between the two cultures. During the
well as cultural values within childbirth practices. During this step, the team must create
awareness of the issue and encourage participation in future education. After establishing a
relationship, education must begin, initially starting with current traditional birth assistants. This
will include midwifery programs that focus on evidence-based techniques for labor and delivery,
infection prevention, and interventions for hemorrhage. Incorporated into these classes will be
EmOC&NC training which has proven to enhance the knowledge and skills of those receiving
the training (Ameh et al., 2016). Within these educational classes, assessment of learning will
occur through observation of skills and verbalized discussions. Education will then be expanded
through the use of family planning and maternal health classes for local women. We will
encourage the traditional birth assistants in the midwife classes to advertise these classes and
help to lead the education. This will produce autonomy and confidence within the future
midwives as well as assist to create trusting relationships between all participants. This classes
will also initially function to meet the six short-term objectives. The original team of healthcare
professionals will also accompany the new midwives to births and assist with the use of
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 13
evidence-based techniques. Throughout this process, the team will record maternal mortality
statistics in order to assess the long-term outcome of the interventions. While some results, such
as outcome of education, can be observed immediately, long term effects may take a few years to
occur. As a result of the long timeframe, the volunteers may return to the United States
intermittently. The team will continue to obtain long-term funding through the use of grants and
continue to recruit new volunteers. After the interventions have proven long-term effectiveness,
the team can progress to new goals such as the establishment of long-term facilities and self-
According to (Zief. Knab, & Cole, 2016), the primary goal of monitoring and evaluating
that would meet the community and stakeholders’ standards. To achieve this goal, our team has
created a logical framework model for maternal morbidity that includes a situation and program
goal, outputs, outcomes, assumptions, and external factors to serve as stepping stones toward a
final evaluation.
Collecting data can be expensive and resource intensive. Utilizing resources such as
money, time, and overall dedication to the project, one must be able to propose a realistic and
efficient means for gathering data. What our team proposes for this project is a mixture of both
qualitative and quantitative data collection methods that will be beneficial to our project goal.
Qualitative data is to gain insight and understanding on underlying reasons and motivations for
an issue. Three means of qualitative data collection that we propose are providing face-to-face
personal interviews, a paper survey or questionnaire, and focus group interviews. According to
Anastasia (2017), face-to-face personal interviews are among the most common qualitative data
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 14
collection methods. We propose a personal, semi-structured interview asking the same series of
open-ended questions to all respondents. This allows the interviewer to probe further by asking
follow-up questions and getting more information in the process; however, limitations to this
method can be language barriers, cultural differences, and geographical locations. A paper
survey or questionnaire is ideal for large populations, providing more detail will aid in the
analysis of data, but also make the analysis process more tedious and time-consuming. During a
focus group, an interview method will be done in a group discussion setting among three to ten
with something in common; most likely village midwives, nurses, and those who aid during the
childbearing process. Our focus group method can obtain highly detailed and descriptive data by
Quantitative data collection methods proposed are quantitative surveys, and quantitative
observations of the global health issue. By conducting quantitative surveys, our team will
provide a closed question survey with answers provided; this will be ideal for large populations
in gathering generalizations about our issue, but it will restrict some of the details, so we will
pair this method with our qualitative proposal of focus groups and interviewing. Lastly, we
propose a quantitative observation data collection method. This method of data collection is done
by systemic observation by being immersed into the issue. Our researchers will currently assess
services in a specific area, or number of services used in a vicinity through being involved in
involvement from the beginning (CDC, 2007). By involving stakeholders in the beginning of the
evaluation process, our group will be more likely to: reduce stakeholders’ distrust and fear of
evaluation, increase the chances that stakeholders will support our evaluation efforts and
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 15
advocate for the program, and increase the credibility of findings. We can first involve potential
meetings, to brief stakeholders on our program as well as the activity we want to evaluate; in our
case it would be the maternal morbidity rates in Sierra Leone. We should also obtain a clear
program and evaluation. Asking questions such as how available they are to participate in the
evaluation process, and how we can meet their evaluation and communication needs can help us
determine the amount of involvement stakeholders want to participate in. During the meeting
stakeholders should be asked that they clearly identify their roles and responsibilities related to
the evaluation process before it begins. We can better determine a sense of involvement by
having them reflect on their strengths and resources, and how much that they want to be
involved. Another way to involve stakeholders in key activities throughout the planning and
implementation of the evaluation can include identifying and prioritizing program activities that
determining and using evaluation findings for program improvement (CDC, 2007).
According to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) (2014),
disseminating findings to stakeholders should follow a dissemination plan. This plan includes a
Why- Sierra Leone is a country that continues to have high maternal mortality rates, What-
maternal morbidity and a better quality of life can be accomplished through better healthcare
education and proper training in Sierra Leone, To whom- the stakeholders and global healthcare
professionals, How- research articles, and conference presentations, and a When- the ideal
timing of the project and agenda of the audience (AHRQ, 2014). Our team believes that findings
should be disseminated to stakeholders through the use of journal articles that agree to publish
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 16
the findings, and through conference presentations to reach a larger audience who is more
Conclusion
Sierra Leone, a country that has dealt with civil unrest, disease epidemics, and most
recently the global health issue of maternal mortality. Throughout this paper our team has
comprised a literature review showcasing the effects of education and the improvements made
towards decreasing maternal mortality rates in Sierra Leone. Established was the use of a logic
model and project goal that can provide guidance for our team to effectively look at the issue and
plan accordingly. Devising technical approaches and work plans that incorporate evidence-based
practices to discuss and approach the issue with a realistic approach. Determining monitoring
and evaluation methods to effectively gather data using a combination of qualitative and
stakeholders’ post-research. Childbirth should be received with joy and an acceptance of the task
of becoming a maternal figure. These feelings can be fleeting for the women of Sierra Leone due
to their high rates of maternal mortality and lack of prenatal care. Is it a lack of education?
Neglect? Or perhaps, is it a cultural point of view on how women are to bring life into the world?
Whichever way one looks at this issue, it is an issue of prominence and concern on a global
standard because women should not have to give their own lives to bear future generations.
Appendix
Logic Model
GLOBAL HEALTH PROJECT 17
References
Amara, P., Daoh, K., Garbrah-Aidoo, N., Harding, Y., Kanu, R., Oulare, M., Oyerinde, K., &
Shoo, R. (2013). A qualitative evaluation of the choice of traditional birth attendants for
maternity care in 2008 Sierra Leone: Implications for universal skilled attendance at
1061-4
Ameh, C. A., Broek, N., Dickinson, F., Jones, S., Kana, T., Kerr, R., Lambert, J., Madaj, B.,
Mdegela, M., & White, S. (2016). Knowledge and skills of healthcare providers in
sub- saharan Africa and Asia before and after competency-based training in emergency
doi:10.1371/journal. pone.0167270
Ameh, C. A., Broek, N., Dickinson, F., Madaj, B., Mdegela, M., & White, S. (2018). Retention
Anastasia. (2017). Overview of Qualitative and Quantitative Data Collection Methods. Retrieved
from https://www.cleverism.com/qualitative-and-quantitative-data-collection-methods/
Bangura, E., Kamara, M., Kamara, S., Keita, N., Koroma, M., & Lokossou, V. (2017). The
quality of free antenatal and delivery services in Northern Sierra Leone. Health Research
Bhopal, S. S., Halpin, S.J., & Gerein, N. (2012). Emergency obstetric referral in rural Sierra
Bolkan, H. A., Sagbakken, M., & Treacy, L. (2018). Distance, accessibility and costs. Decision
making during childbirth in rural Sierra Leone: A qualitative study. PLOS ONE, 13(2).
e0188280. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0188280
CARE. (2010). Maternal mortality: A solvable problem findings from the CARE learning tour
Trip-Report.pdf
Centers for Disease and Control [CDC]. (2007). Engage Stakeholders. Retrieved from
https://www.cdc.gov/std/program/pupestd/Step-1-SPREADS.pdf
Mason, H. (2016). Making strides to improve maternal health in Sierra Leone. Retrieved from
https://www.unicef.org/childsurvival/sierraleone_91206.html
Sharkey, A., Yansaneh, A., Bangura, P., Kabano, A., Brady, E, Yumkella, F., & Diaz, T. (2017).
Maternal and newborn care practices in Sierra Leone: a mixed methods study of four
http://www.qualityresearchinternational.com/socialresearch/gatekeeper.htm
Zief, S., Knab, J., & Cole, R. (2016). A Framework for Evaluation Technical Assistance.
org.libproxy.csustan.edu/10.2105/AJPH.2016.303365