Getting Fatima Right

Jimmy Akin (2019-08-05)

https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/getting-fatima-right

In 1915, as World War I raged in Europe, a Portuguese girl saw

something strange in the sky.

The girl—Lucia dos Santos—was seven years old and lived near the
town of Fatima. One day, as she was tending her family’s sheep
along with three other girls, they began to say the rosary and saw a
strange sight.

In the second of four memoirs she would write, Lucia recalled: “We
saw a figure poised in the air above the trees; it looked like a statue
made of snow, rendered almost transparent by the rays of the sun.”
She also wrote, “It looked like a person wrapped up in a sheet.”

They did not know what to make of the sight, and it vanished when
they finished praying. The same thing happened on two more
occasions.

The angel of peace

In the spring of 1916, Lucia and her cousins Francisco and Jacinta
Martos (then 7 and 6) began seeing an angel.

It appeared as “a young man, about fourteen or fifteen years old,

whiter than snow, transparent as crystal when the sun shines
through it, and of great beauty.”

The angel identified itself as “the angel of peace” and as the

guardian angel of Portugal. Lucia understood it to be the same
figure she had seen in the sky.

The angel appeared to the children on three occasions, taught them

prayers, and during the last appearance showed them a host and
chalice that hung miraculously in the air. It then gave them Holy
Communion.
‘I am from heaven’
On May 13, 1917, the three were again tending their sheep when
they perceived what they thought was a flash of lightning. As they
hurried home, there was another flash, and they beheld a beautiful
woman in a hemlock tree that grew in a field known as the Cova da
Iria.

“We beheld a Lady all dressed in white. She was more brilliant than
the sun and radiated a light more clear and intense than a crystal
glass filled with sparkling water, when the rays of the burning sun
shine through it” (Fourth Memoir).

When asked where she was from, the Lady replied, “I am from
heaven.” She requested that the children return to the spot once a
month for six months.

She also informed the children that they would go to heaven, and
she asked if they were wiling to offer themselves to God and bear
the sufferings he would send them, in reparation for sin and the
conversion of sinners. They replied they would.

She also told them: “Pray the rosary every day, in order to obtain
peace for the world and the end of the war.”

“Jesus wishes to make use of you”

When the Lady reappeared the next month, Lucia asked her to take
the three children to heaven, and she replied, “I will take Jacinta and
Francisco soon. But you are to stay here some time longer. Jesus
wishes to make use of you to make me known and loved. He wants
to establish in the world devotion to my Immaculate Heart.”

This prediction was fulfilled. In 1918, toward the end of the war, a
global flu pandemic took the lives of millions. Among them were
Francisco, who died in 1919, and Jacinta, who died in 1920. Lucia
would not die until 2005 at the age of 97.

A secret revealed
At the July apparition, the Lady promised that, in October, she would
identify herself and perform a miracle so that all might see and
believe.
She also gave the children a secret, which included a vision of hell
that caused Lucia to cry out. Afterward, the Lady said:

“You have seen hell where the souls of poor sinners go. To save
them, God wishes to establish in the world devotion to my
Immaculate Heart. If what I say to you is done, many souls will be
saved and there will be peace. The war is going to end; but if people
do not cease offending God, a worse one will break out during the
pontificate of Pius XI. When you see a night illumined by an
unknown light, know that this is the great sign given you by God
that he is about to punish the world for its crimes, by means of war,
famine, and persecutions of the Church and of the Holy Father.

“To prevent this, I shall come to ask for the consecration of Russia to
my Immaculate Heart, and the Communion of Reparation on the
First Saturdays. If my requests are heeded, Russia will be converted,
and there will be peace; if not, she will spread her errors throughout
the world, causing wars and persecutions of the Church. The good
will be martyred, the Holy Father will have much to suffer, various
nations will be annihilated. In the end, my Immaculate Heart will
triumph. The Holy Father will consecrate Russia to me, and she will
be converted, and a period of peace will be granted to the world. In
Portugal, the dogma of the Faith will always be preserved; etc. . . .
Do not tell this to anybody.”

Arrested
The children were prevented from returning to the site on August 13
because the local mayor—an opponent of the apparitions—had the
young visionaries arrested. Despite threatening them, he was
unable to get them either to admit that they were lying or to reveal
the secret.

Pilgrims who had gathered at the site of the apparitions reported

strange phenomena. Some said they saw a blue and white cloud
descend and then ascend again, some reported lightning, and some
reported seeing our Lady.

‘A chapel that is to be built’

Since the children had not been able to come to the site of the
apparitions on August 13, the Lady appeared to them a few days
later.
When asked what should be done with money that pilgrims were
leaving at the apparition site, she indicated that two processional
litters should be made for the feast of Our Lady of the Rosary,
adding, “What is left over will help toward the construction of a
chapel that is to be built here.”

On September 13, large crowds of pilgrims greeted the children and

urged them to present their petitions to the Lady.

As the children and the crowd prayed the rosary, she appeared, this
time promising, “In October our Lord will come, as well as Our Lady
of Dolors and Our Lady of Carmel. Saint Joseph will appear with the
Child Jesus to bless the world.”

The miracle of the sun

On October 13, the Lady said, “I am the Lady of the Rosary.
Continue always to pray the rosary every day. The war is going to
end, and the soldiers will soon return to their homes.”

According to Lucia, the Lady opened her hands, “made them reflect
on the sun, and as she ascended, the reflection of her own light
continued to be projected on the sun itself.”

Lucia then called for people to look at the sun, and an event called
“the miracle of the sun” occurred. Although not everyone claimed to
see the phenomenon, numerous individuals reported that the sun
appeared to change colors, spin, and “dance” in the sky.

In the wake of this event, the children reported visions of St. Joseph,
the Child Jesus, and our Lady in various guises, including Our Lady of
Dolors and Our Lady of Carmel, as had been promised.

First Saturdays devotion

In the July 1917 apparition, the Lady had indicated that she would
request a devotion involving the First Saturdays of the months.

This request was made on December 10, 1925, when Lucia was a
novice among the Dorothean Sisters. On that day, Sr. Lucia
experienced an apparition of the Virgin Mary and the Child Jesus, in
which Mary said:
“All those who during five months, on the first Saturday, go to
confession, receive Holy Communion, say a rosary, and keep me
company for fifteen minutes, meditating on the fifteen mysteries of
the rosary for the intention of making reparation to me, I promise to
assist them at the hour of death, with all the graces necessary for
the salvation of their souls” (Documents on Fatima & the Memoirs of
Sister Lucia, 279-280).

On January 15, 1926, she experienced an apparition of the Child

Jesus, asking if she had spread this devotion, which has come to be
known as the First Saturdays devotion.

Consecration requested, apparitions approved

The July 1917 apparition also indicated a request would be made for
the consecration of Russia, and this was done on June 13, 1929. On
that night, Sr. Lucia experience a vision of the Holy Trinity and the
Virgin Mary, in which Mary said:

“The moment has come in which God asks the Holy Father, in union
with all the bishops of the world, to make the consecration of Russia
to my Immaculate Heart, promising to save it by this means”
(Documents on Fatima & the Memoirs of Sister Lucia, 393-394).

On October 13, 1930, the bishop of Leiria, Portugal—in whose

territory Fatima lies—granted formal approval for the 1917
apparitions, declaring “as worthy of credence the visions of the
children in the Cova da Iria, parish of Fatima, of this diocese, on the
thirteenth day of each month from May to October 1917”
(Documents on Fatima & the Memoirs of Sister Lucia, 290).

“An unknown light”

In the July 1917 apparition, the Lady stated that the war (World War
I) would end but that a worse one could break out in the reign of
Pius XI, who would not be elected until 1922. The sign presaging this
event was to be “a night illumined by an unknown light.”

On the night of January 25-26, 1938, an extraordinary display of the

aurora borealis was widely visible in Europe. In her Third Memoir, Sr.
Lucia interpreted this as the sign indicating the new war was close.

World War II broke out the following year.

The third part of the secret
Between 1935 and 1941, Sr. Lucia wrote a series of four memoirs
concerning the 1917 apparitions and her cousins.

In the Third Memoir, she revealed the first two parts of the secret
they had been given on July 13, 1917: the vision of hell and the
material concerning Russia and the pope, along with the
forthcoming requests for the First Saturdays devotion and the
consecration of Russia.

However, she did not reveal the third part at that time. On January
3, 1944, at the request of her bishop, Sr. Lucia did record it, placing
the text in a sealed envelope, which in 1957 was transferred to the
Holy See.

Before giving the sealed envelope containing the third part of the
“secret” to the then bishop of Leiria-Fatima, Sr. Lucia wrote on the
outside envelope that it could be opened only after 1960, either by
the patriarch of Lisbon or the bishop of Leiria. Archbishop Bertone
therefore asked: “Why only after 1960? Was it our Lady who fixed
that date?” Sr. Lucia replied: “It was not our Lady. I fixed the date
because I had the intuition that before 1960 it would not be
understood, but that only later would it be understood” (The
Message of Fatima; all subsequent quotations are taken from this
document).

When 1960 came, the Holy See chose not to reveal the third part of
the secret.

Assassination attempt
On May 13, 1981—the anniversary of the first Fatima apparition—a
Turkish man named Mehmet Ali Agca shot John Paul II in St. Peter’s
Square. The pope almost died from the wound, but surgeons were
able to save his life.

Though Agca has repeatedly changed his story, it is widely thought

he was acting on behalf of Communist forces wishing to neutralize
the Polish pope, who went on to play a key role in the downfall of
Soviet Communism.
On July 18, 1981, John Paul II read the third part of the secret for the
first time and learned what it contained.

The consecration performed

As early as 1942, Pius XII consecrated the entire world to the
Immaculate Heart of Mary, and in 1952 he specifically consecrated
Russia.

Following the assassination, while he was still recuperating, John

Paul II had a special act of entrustment performed on June 7, 1981,
and it was repeated in Fatima on May 13, 1982.

However, there was a question of whether these fulfilled the request

made by the Virgin Mary, as she had asked that the pope perform
the consecration “in union with all the bishops of the world.”

Consequently, “in order to respond more fully to the requests of ‘our

Lady’ . . . on 25 March 1984 in St. Peter’s Square, while recalling the
fiat uttered by Mary at the Annunciation, the Holy Father, in spiritual
union with the bishops of the world, who had been ‘convoked’
beforehand, entrusted all men and women and all peoples to the
Immaculate Heart of Mary.”

Subsequently, in a letter dated November 8, 1989, Sr. Lucia

confirmed that the consecration had been done, writing, “Yes, it has
been done just as our Lady asked, on 25 March 1984.”

The fall of communism

The Cold War, which began in the wake of World War II, was a tense
period. It saw various conflicts; national borders were redrawn
(“various nations will be annihilated”), and the world itself was
threatened by the prospect of nuclear war.

In 1989, the Soviet bloc collapsed, and in 1991 the Soviet Union
itself dissolved, with the Communist Party losing power in Russia.

Beatification and disclosure

In 2000, John Paul II beatified Francisco and Jacinta. He also decided
that the time had come to release the third part of the secret, and
the Holy See issued The Message of Fatima, which contained it
along with supporting documents.
The third part of the secret turned out to be a vision of destruction
in which an assassination attempt was made on the pope. Others
also were martyred.

Interpreting the secret

The first part of the secret was a vision of hell, the ultimate
consequence of human sin, and the second and third parts
contained references to how human sin would play out in the course
of the twentieth century.

The Lady referred to the end of World War I and the outbreak of
World War II.

According to Sr. Lucia, “The third part of the secret refers to our
Lady’s words: ‘If not, [Russia] will spread her errors throughout the
world, causing wars and persecutions of the Church. The good will
be martyred; the Holy Father will have much to suffer; various
nations will be annihilated.’”

The third part of the secret therefore seems to refer in a special way
to the Cold War and the persecution of the Church by atheistic
Communism.

“The vision of Fatima concerns above all the war waged by atheistic
systems against the Church and Christians, and it describes the
immense suffering endured by the witnesses of the faith in the last
century of the second millennium. It is an interminable Way of the
Cross led by the popes of the twentieth century.”

The assassination attempt on John Paul II on the anniversary of the

first Fatima apparition, along with his act of consecration and his
role in the fall of Soviet Communism, seems to indicate that he, in a
special way, was tied to the fulfillment of the prophecy.

John Paul II regarded the fact he survived the assassination attempt

as a special grace. “Sr. Lucia was in full agreement with the pope’s
claim that ‘it was a mother’s hand that guided the bullet’s path and
in his throes the pope halted at the threshold of death.’”
The significance of Fatima
The Church teaches that private revelations like Fatima do not have
the same status as the public revelation God has given us in
Scripture and Tradition.

The latter requires the assent of faith, but private revelations—even

when approved—do not. The “ecclesiastical approval of a private
revelation has three elements: the message contains nothing
contrary to faith or morals; it is lawful to make it public; and the
faithful are authorized to accept it with prudence.”

The purpose of private revelation is to help people live the Faith in

particular circumstances, such as the conflicts that affected the
Church in the twentieth century. However, even when these
circumstances are past, apparitions can have an enduring value
going forward.

In The Message of Fatima, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope

Benedict XVI) wrote:

Insofar as individual events are described, they belong to the past.

Those who expected exciting apocalyptic revelations about the end
of the world or the future course of history are bound to be
disappointed. Fatima does not satisfy our curiosity in this way, just
as Christian faith in general cannot be reduced to an object of mere
curiosity. What remains was already evident when we began our
reflections on the text of the “secret”: the exhortation to prayer as
the path of “salvation for souls” and, likewise, the summons to
penance and conversion (ibid.).

Secret No More
Jimmy Akin 2000-01-10

After reading the secret, the Holy Father realized the

connection between the assassination attempt and Fatima.
He has since consistently attributed his survival of the
gunshot wound to the intercession of Our Lady of Fatima. 
For years I have had a special devotion to Our Lady of Fatima. Of all
the recent Marian apparitions, Fatima has spoken to me the most.
Like millions of others, I had often wondered about the contents of
the “third secret of Fatima,” which is more properly termed the
third part of the secret of Fatima.

When the Holy See released the text of the 83-year-old third secret
June 26, it was as part of a booklet prepared by the Congregation for
the Doctrine of the Faith titled The Message of Fatima (MF). I wasn’t
the only one surprised at its contents. It did not contain prophecies
of the end of the world, of a great apostasy, or many of the other
things it had been rumored to contain. However, I was not
disappointed. (Relieved would be a better word.) And it gave me a
new appreciation of the Church’s struggle with Communism and of
the current pontiff by showing me the view from heaven.

What Happened at Fatima, Portugal

Lucia dos Santos—the only Fatima seer alive today—is in many ways
the “core” visionary of Fatima. She says she experienced
supernatural visitations as early as 1915, two years before the
famous appearances of the Virgin Mary. In 1917, she and two of her
cousins, Francisco and Jacinta Marto, were working as shepherds
tending their families’ flocks. On May 13, 1917, the three children
saw an apparition of Our Lady. She told them, among other things,
that she would return once a month for six months.

At Our Lady’s third appearance, on July 13, Lucia was shown the
secret of Fatima. She reportedly turned pale and cried out with fear,
calling Our Lady by name. There was a thunderclap, and the vision
ended.

The children again saw the Virgin on September 13. In the sixth and
final appearance, on October 13, a dramatic outward sign was given
to those gathered to witness the event. After the clouds of a
rainstorm parted, numerous witnesses—some as far as 40 miles
away—reported seeing the sun dance, spin, and send out colored
rays of light.

Meanwhile, as World War I raged across Europe, an epidemic of

Spanish flu swept the globe. It erupted in America and was spread
by soldiers being sent to distant lands. This epidemic killed an
estimated 20,000,000 people. Among them were Franciso and
Jacinta, who contracted the illness in 1918 and died in 1919 and
1920, respectively. Lucia entered the convent.

On June 13, 1929, at the convent chapel in Tuy, Spain, Lucia had
another mystical experience in which she saw the Trinity and the
Blessed Virgin. Mary told her, “The moment has come in which God
asks the Holy Father in union with all the bishops of the world to
make the consecration of Russia to my Immaculate Heart, promising
to save it by this means” (S. Zimdars-Schwartz, Encountering Mary,
197).

On October 13, 1930, the bishop of Leiria (now Leiria-Fatima)

proclaimed the apparitions at Fatima authentic and worthy of
assent.

The Secret Is Written Down

Between 1935 and 1941, on the orders of her superiors, Sr. Lucia
wrote four memoirs of the Fatima events. In the third of these, she
recorded the first two parts of the secret, explaining that there was
a third part she was not yet permitted by heaven to reveal. In
the Fourth Memoir, she added a sentence to the end of the second
part of the secret: “In Portugal, the dogma of the faith will always be
preserved, etc.” This sentence has been the basis for much
speculation that the third part of the secret concerned a great
apostasy. Sr. Lucia also noted that in writing the secret in the Fourth
Memoir, “With the exception of that part of the Secret which I am
not permitted to reveal at present, I shall say everything. I shall not
knowingly omit anything, though I suppose I may forget just a few
small details of minor importance.”

Upon the publication of the Third and Fourth Memoirs, the world

became aware of the secret of Fatima and its three parts, including
Our Lady’s request that Russia be consecrated (entrusted) to her
Immaculate Heart by the pope and the bishops of the world. On
October 31, 1942, Pius XII consecrated not only Russia but the
whole world to the Immaculate Heart of Mary. What was missing,
though, was the involvement of the world’s bishops.

In 1943, the bishop of Leiria ordered Sr. Lucia to put the third secret
of Fatima in writing. She did not feel at liberty to do so until 1944. It
was then placed a wax-sealed envelope on which Sr. Lucia wrote
that it should not be opened until 1960.

The “Third Secret” and the Popes

The secret remained with the bishop of Leiria until 1957, when it
was requested (along with photocopies of Sr. Lucia’s other writings)
by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. According to
Cardinal Bertone the secret was read by both Pope John XXIII and
Pope Paul VI (see MF, “Introduction”). “John Paul II, for his part,
asked for the envelope containing the third part of the ‘secret’
following the assassination attempt on 13 May 1981” (ibid.). He read
it sometime between July 18 and August 11.

It is significant that John Paul II did not read the secret until after the
assassination attempt was made on his life. He notes in Crossing
the Threshold of Hope (1994), “And thus we come to May 13, 1981,
when I was wounded by gunshots fired in St. Peter’s Square. At first,
I did not pay attention to the fact that the assassination attempt had
occurred on the exact anniversary of the day Mary appeared to the
three children at Fatima in Portugal and spoke to them the words
that now, at the end of this century, seem to be close to their
fulfillment” (221).

After reading the secret, the Holy Father realized the connection
between the assassination attempt and Fatima. He has since
consistently attributed his survival of the gunshot wound to the
intercession of Our Lady of Fatima. “It was a mother’s hand that
guided the bullet’s path,” he said, “and in his throes the Pope halted
at the threshold of death” (Meditation from the Policlinico Gemelli to
the Italian Bishops, May 13, 1994).

As had Pius XII, John Paul II decided to consecrate not only Russia
but also the entire world to her Immaculate Heart. After he read the
third part of the secret in July, he decided to journey to Fatima on
May 13, 1982, and there performed the Act of Entrustment.

This act, however, did not appear to satisfy the requested

consecration, and so, “on 25 March 1984 in Saint Peter’s Square,
while recalling the fiat uttered by Mary at the Annunciation, the Holy
Father, in spiritual union with the bishops of the world, who had
been ‘convoked’ beforehand, entrusted all men and women and all
peoples to the Immaculate Heart of Mary” (Bertone, MF).

“Sister Lucia personally confirmed that this solemn and universal act
of consecration corresponded to what Our Lady wished (‘Yes it has
been done just as Our Lady asked, on 25 March 1984’: Letter of 8
November 1989). Hence any further discussion or request is without
basis” (Bertone, MF).

The Fall of Communism

After it became public that there was a secret of Fatima and that it
mentioned Russia, many pondered Fatima in the light of Russian
Communism.

Nineteen seventeen was a year of turmoil for Russia. Besides

fighting in World War I, the country experienced two civil wars
known as the February Revolution and the October Revolution. The
former led to the creation of a provisional government that proved
unstable. On October 24–25, less than two weeks after the final
appearance of Our Lady of Fatima, the second revolution resulted in
the creation of the Soviet government.

In the ensuing years, Russia expanded its sphere of influence,

exporting Communist ideology and revolution to other lands and
martyring Christians wherever it spread. Once Pope John Paul II’s
1984 consecration took place, first the Soviet bloc and then the
USSR itself crumbled from a variety of social, political, and economic
factors.

As the Pope himself noted, “And what are we to say of the three

children from Fatima who suddenly, on the eve of the outbreak of
the October Revolution, heard: ‘Russia will convert’ and ‘In the end,
my [Immaculate] Heart will triumph’ . . . ? They could not have
invented those predictions. They did not know enough about history
or geography, much less the social movements and ideological
developments. And nevertheless it happened just as they had said”
(CTH, 131; emphasis in original).

Though he did not reveal the third part of the secret until this year,
six years earlier John Paul II hinted at its contents. Immediately after
he meditated on the fall of Communism in connection with Fatima,
he went on to write:

“Perhaps this is also why the Pope was called from a ‘faraway
country,’ perhaps this is why it was necessary for the assassination
attempt to be made in t. Peter’s Square precisely on May 13,1981,
the anniversary of the first apparition at Fatima – so that all could
become more transparent and comprehensible, so that the voice of
god which speaks in human history through the ‘signs of the times’
could be more easily heard and understood” (CHT, 131-132).

By the year 2000, the Holy Father felt able to reveal the final part of
Fatima’s secret, since “the events to which the third part of the
‘secret’ of Fatima refers now seem part of the past” (Sodano, MF,
“Announcement”). The pontiff selected the beatification of Francisco
and Jacinta on May 13, 2000 in Portugal as the occasion to
announce this fact.

Interpreting the Secret

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, prefect of the CDF, points out that the
key to the apparition of Fatima is its call to repentance and
conversion (MF, “Theological Commentary”). All three parts of the
secret serve to motivate the individual to repentance, and they do
so in a dramatic way.

The first part of the secret—the vision of hell—is the most important,
for it reveals to individuals the tragic consequences of failure to
repent and what awaits them in the invisible world if they are not
converted.

In the second part, Mary says, “You have seen hell where the souls
of poor sinners go. To save them, God wishes to establish in the
world devotion to my Immaculate Heart.” Speaking of devotion to
the Immaculate Heart as a means of salvation is not part of our
cultural vocabulary and is easily misunderstood. Some anti-Catholics
have even taken it as a false gospel replacing the gospel of Christ. It
is no such thing, as Cardinal Ratzinger explains:

“According to Matthew 5:8, the ‘immaculate heart’ is a heart which,

with God’s grace, has come to perfect interior unity and therefore
‘sees God.’ To be ‘devoted’ to the Immaculate Heart of Mary means
therefore to embrace this attitude of heart, which makes
the fiat —‘your will be done’—the defining center of one’s whole life.
It might be objected that we should not place a human being
between ourselves and Christ. But then we remember that Paul did
not hesitate to say to his communities: ‘imitate me’ (1 Cor. 4:16;
Phil. 3:17; 1 Thess. 1:6; 2 Thess. 3:7, 9)” (op. cit.).

After explaining the vision of hell, Mary spoke of a war that “will
break out during the pontificate of Pius XI.” This latter war, of
course, was World War II, which Sr. Lucia reckoned as having been
occasioned by the annexation of Austria by Germany during the
reign of Pius XI (J. de Marchi, Temoignages sur les apparitions de
Fatima, 346).

Sr. Lucia understood the night of the “unknown light” mentioned by

Our Lady to be January 25, 1938, when Europe was witness to a
spectacular nighttime display of light in the sky. In her third memoir
she wrote, “Your Excellency is not unaware that, a few years ago,
God manifested that sign, which astronomers chose to call an
aurora borealis. . . . God made use of this to make me understand
that his justice was about to strike the guilty nations.”

Much has been made of the statement “Russia will be converted.”

Many people have assumed this meant the Russian people as a
whole would become Catholic. But the language of the text does not
require this: The Portuguese word converterá doesn’t necessarily
mean converted to the Catholic faith. It can mean simply that Russia
will stop its warlike behavior, and thus “there will be peace.” This
interpretation seems to be the one understood by John Paul II in a
passage cited above from Crossing the Threshold of Hope.

The Third Part

In reading the third part of the secret, it is important to understand
that its imagery is similar to that of many prophecies in the Bible in
four key ways.

First, its depiction of events is non-literal. When it describes the

pope’s ascent to the foot of a cross, it can be seen as symbolic of
the continual struggle of the pope to follow Christ.
Second, it compresses events that occur over many years and in
many places into a single image. The third secret of Fatima is
essentially an icon of the twentieth-century conflict between the
Church and Communist Russia. And, like any icon, the elements that
it shows us must be meditated upon in a kind of timeless fashion.

Third, the third secret is written according to the language of

appearances. It describes things as they appeared in the vision, not
necessarily as they are in reality. We see this mode of speech
(called “phenomenological language”) in the Bible, for example,
when Scripture speaks of the sun rising and setting. The
sun appears to move around the earth, though in reality it is the
motion of the earth around the sun that causes this phenomenon.

Fourth, scriptural prophecies often can be changed by the response

of human free will. For instance, when Jonah preached destruction to
Nineveh and it repented, God spared it. Similarly, in Scripture, God
declares, “If at any time I declare concerning a nation or a kingdom
that I will pluck up and break down and destroy it, and if that nation,
concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will repent of
the evil that I intended to do to it” (Jer. 18:7–8).

In one crucial respect, the secret of Fatima is unlike any of the

biblical prophecies: It is not divinely inspired. While it is the product
of God’s grace, God does not guarantee the exact wording or even
every element of the text the way he does with the statements of
Scripture.

In a letter to John Paul II date May 12, 1982, Sr. Lucia wrote: “The
third part of the secret refers to Our Lady’s words [in the second
part]: ‘If not, [Russia] will spread her errors throughout the world,
causing wars and persecutions of the Church. The good will be
martyred; the Holy Father will have much to suffer; various nations
will be annihilated’ (13-VII-1917)” (MF, Introduction).

In interpreting the third part of the secret, the angel with the
flaming sword clearly represents the judgment that would fall on the
world were it not for the intercession of Mary (and, of course, the
intercession of others, though here it is Mary with whom we are
concerned). For many years it was rumored that the third part of the
secret involved the possibility of a nuclear war. If there is anything
in the text that suggests this, it is the flames of the sword, which Sr.
Lucia noted “looked as though they would set the world on fire.”

In Scripture, fire tends to be an image of judgment or conflict in

general. In his commentary on the angel’s flaming sword, however,
Cardinal Ratzinger seems to allude to nuclear war: “Today the
prospect that the world might be reduced to ashes by a sea of fire
no longer seems pure fantasy: Man himself, with his inventions, has
forged the flaming sword” (ibid.). In the 1984 consecration of the
world to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, the second of Pope John Paul
II’s specific petitions was, “From incalculable self-destruction, from
every kind of war, deliver us” (Sodano, MF, “Introduction”).

The angel then signifies the means by which the judgment is

averted: “Pointing to the earth with his right hand, the Angel cried
out in a loud voice: ‘Penance, Penance, Penance!’”

The seers then saw in the unapproachable light of God a reflection

of someone who, Lucia says, ‘we had the impression . . . was the
holy father.’”

With the pope were others climbing a mountain to a rough-hewn

cross. Mountains are traditional places where man meets with God,
the difficult process of ascending the mountain suggesting the
perseverance required to follow God. The ruggedness of the cross
depicted in the vision evokes the harshness of the sufferings of
Christ and those who share in his sufferings.

The journey of the pope and those with him through the half-ruined
city suggests that the Church must pass through the destruction
that accompanies war, and it evokes the suffering of the pontiff in
witnessing this destruction but being unable to stop it. This reflects
the experience of many twentieth-century popes.

Then comes the part of the vision reflecting the attempted

assassination on Pope John Paul II. It shows that he, like numerous
other members of the Church, must face the possibility of
martyrdom in the conflict between the Church and Russian
Communism. (There are, in fact, significant indications that the
would-be papal assassin, Mehmet Ali Agca, was on a mission
sponsored by the Russian secret police, the KGB.)
There are two.aspects of this part of the secret that will be seized
upon by those who wish to challenge the Holy See’s interpretation.
First, the killers are described as a group of soldiers using guns and
arrows, not as a lone gunman who is not a soldier.

The response to this objection is simple. The third part of the secret
simply describes one group of people killing another group. The
soldiers in the vision represent all those who have been used by
Communists to martyr or attempt to martyr Catholics, and those
being killed represent all Catholics who suffer in this way at the
hands of Communists. The vision thus indicates that the Holy Father
will himself be a victim of this violence, though without indicating
the particular means by which it will be brought to bear upon him.

Critics of the Holy See’s interpretation will also point to the fact that
Pope John Paul II did not die. To this there are a couple of responses:

(1) If in the vision Lucia saw the pope being shot and falling over,
she might well have thought that he had been killed even though in
reality he would only be gravely wounded.

(2) The intercession of Mary may have changed what would have

happened. “That here ‘a mother’s hand’ had deflected the fateful
bullet only shows once more that there is no immutable destiny,
that faith and prayer are forces which can influence history and that
in the end prayer is more powerful than bullets and faith more
powerful than armies” (Ratzinger, MF, op. cit.).

In the final image of the two angels, an aspersorium can refer to a

stoup, basin, or vessel used to hold holy water, or it can refer to
the.aspergill used to sprinkle holy water. Either way, the angels
using the blood of the martyrs to sprinkle the souls going to God
gives us a powerful symbol of salvation, of the honor shows to the
martyrs by God, and of the significance of their blood. Cardinal
Ratzinger points out: “Therefore, the vision of the third part of the
‘secret,’so distressing at first, concludes with an image of hope: No
suffering is in vain, and it is a suffering Church, a Church of martyrs,
which becomes a sign-post for man in his search for God” (op. cit.).
Apologetic Fallout
Having looked at the entire secret of Fatima, it remains for us to
assess a few questions and apologetic issues that remain in the
wake of the release of its final part:

1) Has the Vatican revealed the whole of the secret?

Yes. Any accusation to the contrary is simply not credible. John Paul
II clearly believes that the third secret of Fatima is crucial to
understanding his own pontificate. He is specially invested in the
third secret, and, if he says that he has released the full text of the
document, then he has. No one with an accurate appraisal of the
moral character of John Paul II could think otherwise.

2) Why does the end of the second part of the secret not
flow seamlessly into the third? 
Because the third part was written more than three years after the
first two. Though the three parts describe a single event, they were
not composed as a single narrative. For whatever reason, when Sr.
Lucia wrote down the third part of the secret she chose not to write
it in a way that fit seamlessly with her previous narrative.

3) Wouldn’t it have been of use for people to have known

the secret much sooner? 
Sr. Lucia herself explained: “It may be . . . that some people think
that I should have made known all this some time ago, because they
consider that it would have been twice as valuable years
beforehand. This would have been the case, if God had willed to
present me to the world as a prophetess. But I believe that God had
no such intention, when he made known these things to me. If that
had been the case, I think that, in 1917, when He ordered me to
keep silence . . . He would, on the contrary, have ordered me to
speak” (Third Memoir, 115).

This highlights the error of those who have insisted that the Virgin
Mary demanded that the third part of the secret be read to the
world by 1960 at the latest. When queried about this, Sr. Lucia
replied: “It was not Our Lady. I fixed the date because I had the
intuition that before 1960 it would not be understood but that only
later would it be understood” (Bertone, MF, “Conversation”).
4) To what does the triumph of Mary’s Immaculate Heart
refer?
Cardinal Ratzinger explains, “The Heart open to God, purified by
contemplation of God, is stronger than guns and weapons of every
kind. The fiat of Mary, the word of her heart, has changed the
history of the world, because it brought the Savior into the world ”
(op. cit.).

5) Are other interpretations of the “third secret” possible?

Since the Holy See has not infallibly defined the subject, other
interpretations are possible. This does not mean that other
interpretations are rational—at least if they depart from the main
lines of the interpretation given by the Holy See.

The reason has to do with the nature of private revelation. Since it is

principally for the benefit of the individuals directly involved, they
are the most likely to interpret it properly. In this case, both Sr.
Lucia and the Holy Father are in agreement that the interpretation
offered in The Message of Fatima is the correct one. Those of us who
are not principals have little reason to question the judgment of
those for whom the revelation was given.

Bottom line: If they’re satisfied, we should be.