You are on page 1of 6

578

Journal of Food Protection, Vol. 66, No. 4, 2003, Pages 578–583


Copyright q, International Association for Food Protection

Determination of Thermal Lethality of Listeria monocytogenes in


Fully Cooked Chicken Breast Fillets and Strips during Postcook
In-Package Pasteurization
R. Y. MURPHY, 1* L. K. DUNCAN, 2 K. H. DRISCOLL, 1 B. L. BEARD, 1 M. B. BERRANG, 3 AND J. A. MARCY 4

1Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering and 2 Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville,

Arkansas 72701; 3 U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, 934 College Station Road, Athens, Georgia 30605; and
4Center of Excellence in Poultry Science, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, Arkansas 72701, USA

MS 02-263: Received 2 August 2002/Accepted 30 October 2002

ABSTRACT
Fully cooked chicken breast Ž llets and strips were surface inoculated with a cocktail of Listeria monocytogenes culture.
The inoculation level was 107 to 108 CFU/g meat. The inoculated products were vacuum packaged and pasteurized at 908C
with a pilot-scale steam or hot water cooker. After heat treatment, the survivors of L. monocytogenes were enumerated. No
signiŽ cant difference was found on survivors of L. monocytogenes between steam- and hot water–treated products. To achieve
a 7-log10 (CFU/g) reduction, approximately 5, 25, and 35 min were needed for single-packaged Ž llets, 227-g package strips,
and 454-g strips, respectively. The results from this study were subsequently veriŽ ed by a computer model that could predict
the thermal lethality of pathogens in fully cooked meat and poultry products during postcook in-package pasteurization.

Listeria monocytogenes is a well-documented food- (18%) than that in a continuous cooker (6). Studies have
borne pathogen and has been associated with many product also compared steam with hot water pasteurization on mi-
recalls (12). Exposure of fully cooked meat or poultry after crobial lethality and found that there was no signiŽ cant (at
cooking, but before packaging, could be a point of contam- a 5 0.05) difference on microbial lethality between steam
ination with L. monocytogenes (14). Isolation of L. mono- and hot water treatment (4).
cytogenes from  oors, drains, or stepping ladders in a poul- The objective of this study was to determine the effec-
try further processing plant has been reported (1). The pres- tiveness of in-package pasteurization on eliminating L.
ence of L. monocytogenes in processing environments ren- monocytogenes from three types of vacuum-packaged fully
ders meat or poultry products at risk for contamination after cooked chicken breast meat products (Ž llets or strips) that
cooking and before packaging. Therefore, contamination by were treated with a continuous pilot-scale steam or hot wa-
L. monocytogenes of fully cooked meat or poultry products ter cooker. The results from this study were conŽ rmed by
as a result of exposure to processing environments is a con- a computer model (ThermoPro; contact: Dr. Rong Murphy,
cern. Thermal Processing and Food Safety Program, 203 Engi-
Several studies have evaluated postcook pasteurization neering Hall, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR
to reduce or eradicate Listeria on fully cooked meat (2, 11) 72701) that could predict the thermal lethality of pathogens
or poultry products (6). Cygnarowicz-Provost et al. (2) in different locations of products. The model (ThermoPro)
studied surface pasteurization of beef frankfurters and ob- was developed on the basis of previous studies by Murphy
tained 4-log10 (CFU/ml) reductions of Listeria innocua on and Berrang (4) and Murphy et al. (5–8).
the surface of the frankfurters after they had been treated
with 115 to 1368C steam for 30 to 40 s. Roering et al. (11) MATERIALS AND METHODS
found that L. monocytogenes was reduced about 3 log10
Product. Fully cooked chicken breast meat products were
(CFU/g) in vacuum-packaged summer sausage after being used in this study. The products were obtained from a commercial
treated for 30, 60, or 90 s in a water bath at 99, 88, or processor and kept at 2208C until use. The products were used
778C, respectively. within 4 months.
Continuous or batch pasteurization processes were
evaluated in a previous study by Murphy et al. (6) for their Culture preparation. Five strains of L. monocytogenes were
effectiveness in reducing Salmonella Senftenberg and L. in- obtained on slants from Dr. M. E. Berrang (1). From each slant,
nocua in commercially packaged chicken breast strips. The a loopful of culture was transferred to 10 ml of tryptic soy broth
reduction of Salmonella Senftenberg or L. innocua in the plus yeast extract (TSB1YE) in a test tube and then incubated
overnight at 358C as a stock culture. The test tubes were vortexed,
product that was processed in a batch cooker was slower
and 1 ml of each stock culture was transferred to a 250-ml Erlen-
meyer  ask containing 100 ml of sterile TSB1YE. Each culture
* Author for correspondence. Tel: 479-575-2542; Fax: 479-575-2846; was individually incubated overnight at 358C on an orbit shaker
E-mail: rymurph@uark.edu. at 600 rpm. An equal volume of each culture (109 CFU/ml) was
J. Food Prot., Vol. 66, No. 4 LETHALITY OF LISTERIA IN CHICKEN PRODUCTS 579

FIGURE 2. Heating rate at the center and product-package in-


terface for fully cooked and vacuum-packaged chicken breast Ž l-
lets.

at different locations in a pouch. The thermal proŽ les were veri-


Ž ed by the computer model (ThermoPro).

Microbial enumeration. After the product was cooled to


,208C in an ice-water bath, the pouch was blotted with paper
towels and wiped with 75% ethanol, and a 25-mm slot was asep-
tically made. Fifty milliliters of sterile 0.1% peptone solution was
pipetted into the pouch and massaged by hand for 4 min. From
this point, serial dilutions were made in sterile 0.1% peptone so-
lution and spread plated in duplicate on thin-agar-layer overlay
FIGURE 1. Thermal proŽ les during heating for fully cooked and plates that consisted of modiŽ ed Oxford medium overlaid with 5
vacuum-packaged chicken breast meat products. (a) Fillets and ml of TSA1YE to resuscitate heat-injured cells (3). Preliminary
(b) strips. testing compared cell counts from heat-treated samples when
plates were incubated at 25 and 358C, respectively. Incubation
temperature made no substantial difference to the plate counts
pipetted into a sterile  ask and mixed just before the inoculation from heat-treated samples (unpublished data). In this study, the
of the meat products. plates were incubated at 358C and counted every day for 4 days.

Inoculation. Three types of packaged chicken breast meat Data analysis. Three different packages of chicken breast
products were evaluated in this study. They included chicken meat products (227-g strips, 454-g strips, and 120-g Ž llets) were
breast strips in 454- or 227-g packages or single-packagedchicken cooked by one of two treatment methods (steam or hot water) for
breast Ž llets (120 g each, approximately 127 mm in diameter by varying amounts of time. The products were inoculated with L.
13 mm thick). The strips were obtained by slicing the chicken monocytogenes before cooking. The amount of L. monocytogenes
breast Ž llets into 13-mm-wide strips. Each product (Ž llets or remaining on the product was enumerated after cooking. The goal
strips) was surface inoculated with a cocktail of Ž ve L. monocy- of the analysis was to determine whether the survival of L. mon-
togenes cultures by dripping the culture at a ratio of 5 ml of ocytogenes was different between steam- and hot water–treated
culture per 500 g of meat samples to cover the entire sample samples and to obtain a statistical model that would describe the
surface and then mixed with sterile tongs for 4 min in a sterile survivors of L. monocytogenes in each product.
pan. The surface-inoculated Ž llets or strips were placed on a ster- Because the initial cell counts were large and the data sets
ile wire rack. The inoculated meat samples were kept at 48C for were overdispersed between initial counts and Ž nal counts, a neg-
30 min to allow bacterial attachment. In a preliminary study, it ative binomial model was used to Ž t the data. Considering the
was found that 20 min at 48C was sufŽ cient for the pathogen to variations among the product shapes and sizes, each type of prod-
attach to fully cooked chicken breast meat tissues (unpublished uct (Ž llets or strips) was analyzed separately. SigniŽ cant differ-
data). The inoculation level in each batch of meat samples was ences between the treatments (steam or hot water) were conducted
enumerated to be 107 to 108 CFU/g meat. The inoculated products by type III statistical analysis. The analysis was also conducted
were placed in 0.08-mm-thick plastic pouches (152 by 254 mm to determine whether the thermal lethality of L. monocytogenes
for 454-g strips or 140 by 140 mm for 227-g strips or Ž llets) and was signiŽ cantly different between 227- and 454-g package strips.
sealed under 1.0 bar vacuum (105 Pa). Statistical analysis was performed using SAS version 8.1 (copy-
right 1999–2000, SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, N.C.).
Heat treatment. Each package was individually heat treated
at a temperature of 908C with a steam cooker (Model 102, Stein- RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
DSI FMC, Sandusky, Ohio) or a hot water cooker (Magni Whirl,
Thermal proŽ le and heating rate. Figure 1 shows the
Blue M Electric Company, Blue Island, Ill.) for 0.5 to 40 min.
thermal proŽ les for fully cooked and vacuum-packaged
Six packages were processed at each trial as one experimental
unit. After thermal treatment, the products were immediately sub- chicken breast Ž llets and strips during heat treatment. The
merged in an ice-water bath. During heating and cooling, the meat temperature at the interface between product and packaging
temperatures were monitored every 1 s by a data acquisition sys- Ž lm increased much faster than the temperature inside the
tem (CR23X Micrologger, Campbell ScientiŽ c, Inc., Logan, Utah) product. The center temperature of the chicken breast Ž llets
with Ž ve thermocouple probes (gauge 40, type K) that were sealed reached 708C in about 5 min. For the strips, the temperature
580 MURPHY ET AL. J. Food Prot., Vol. 66, No. 4

TABLE 1. Type III statistical analysis for the effect of heating cooked and vacuum-packaged chicken breast strips. Since
time (minutes) on different packages of fully cooked chicken steam and hot water treatments were not signiŽ cantly dif-
breast meat products during postcook in-package pasteurization ferent in this study, the results from steam and hot water
Product Source x2 P . x2 treatments were pooled together. Because of the geometrical
differences between Ž llets and strips, further data analysis
Fillets Time 17.16 ,0.0001 was performed separately for Ž llets and strips. The Ž nal
Time2 76.23 ,0.0001
statistical model for the survival of L. monocytogenes in
227-g packaged strips Time 4.86 0.0275 fully cooked and vacuum-packaged chicken breast strips
Time2 86.53 ,0.0001 was expressed, by a quadratic model, as ln(N/N0) 5 a 1 b
454-g packaged strips Time 65.02 ,0.0001 (time) 1 c (time)2, where a, b, and c were the parameters
Time2 122.60 ,0.0001 for constant, linear, and quadratic terms, respectively, and
time was in minutes.
The results in Table 1 indicate that the heating time
at the package center reached 708C in about 25 and 35 min signiŽ cantly (at a 5 0.05) affected survivors of L. mono-
for 227- and 454-g packaged strips, respectively. Strips be- cytogenes for all three types (Ž llets and strips) of chicken
came heated much slower than Ž llets because of the greater breast meat products during postcook in-package pasteuri-
thickness of the packaged products. The thickness of the zation. The deviance/df values were 1.2745, 1.2149, and
Ž llet packages was about 13 mm. The thickness of the strip 1.2089 for the Ž llets, 227-g packaged strips, and 454-g
packages was 35 and 44 mm for 227- and 454-g packages, packaged strips, respectively. These values indicate that the
respectively. models Ž tted the data well. The perfect Ž t would have a
Figure 2 illustrates the heating rate (temperature deviance/df value equal to 1.
change with a unit time change, dT/dt) for fully cooked
chicken breast Ž llets at the product-Ž lm interface and the Fillets. The parameter estimates for the model are giv-
package center. The heating rate varied with location and en in Table 2. The log10 (CFU/g) reduction of L. monocy-
time. At the interface between packaging Ž lm and product, togenes is plotted in Figure 3 along with the 95% conŽ -
the heating rate was highest at the beginning of the heat dence limits (broken lines) and experimental values (sym-
treatment; then, it gradually decreased until reaching zero bols). In Figure 3, a stochastic model underestimated the
(steady-state). At the center of the Ž llet, the heating rate log10 reduction of L. monocytogenes in chicken breast Ž l-
gradually increased to the maximum (23.48C/min) and then lets, which meant that the model would give a more con-
decreased. Similar proŽ les of heating rates were also ob- servative prediction. After pasteurizing for about 5 min, L.
tained for vacuum-packaged chicken breast strips, except monocytogenes was reduced by 7 log10 (CFU/g). Because
the maximum heating rate at the package center was 4.2 the product was surface inoculated and the culture may mi-
and 38C/min, respectively, for 227- and 454-g packages, grate from the surface inward to some degree, the survivors
which was 82 or 87% slower than that of Ž llets (data not of L. monocytogenes in the Ž llets could vary with the depth
shown). This result was apparently because single-pack- from the product surface to center. However, since the enu-
aged Ž llets (13 mm thick) were thinner than multipackaged meration of L. monocytogenes in different depths of the
strips (35 or 44 mm thick). Ž llet was experimentally impossible, a computer model (8)
Treatments. In this study, there were no signiŽ cant (at was used to predict the thermal lethality of L. monocyto-
a 5 0.05) differences in the thermal lethality of L. mono- genes at different depths of the Ž llet.
cytogenes between steam- and hot water–treated products. In the model, the thermophysical and heat transfer pa-
This result was consistent with a previous Ž nding by Mur- rameters from Murphy et al. (8), Murphy and Marks (9),
phy and Berrang (4) for Salmonella and L. innocua in fully and Murphy et al. (10) were used. With these parameters,

TABLE 2. Parameter estimates for the model ln(N/N0) 5 a 1 b (time) 1 c (time)2 of Listeria monocytogenes in fully cooked chicken
breast meat products during postcook in-package pasteurization (time is in minutes)
95% conŽ dence limits

Product Parameter Estimate Standard error Lower Upper x2 P . x2

Fillets a 20.4484 0.2559 20.9500 0.0533 3.07 0.0798


b 1.3550 0.2948 0.7772 1.9329 21.12 ,0.0001
c 21.0988 0.0775 21.2507 20.9469 201.03 ,0.0001
227-g packaged strips a 0.0331 0.2235 20.4049 0.4710 0.02 0.8823
b 20.1134 0.0488 20.2090 20.0179 5.41 0.0200
c 20.0208 0.0019 20.0246 20.0169 113.52 ,0.0001
454-g packaged strips a 20.1919 0.2123 20.6079 0.2242 0.82 0.3660
b 0.2514 0.0313 0.1900 0.3127 64.38 ,0.0001
c 20.0210 0.0010 20.0229 20.0190 446.82 ,0.0001
J. Food Prot., Vol. 66, No. 4 LETHALITY OF LISTERIA IN CHICKEN PRODUCTS 581

FIGURE 3. Log10(N0 /N) for L. monocy-


togenes in fully cooked and vacuum-pack-
aged chicken breast Ž llets. The lines are
the Ž tted model with 95% conŽ dence in-
tervals. The symbols are the experimental
values.

the continuity equations that led to the following governing was the moisture content of air in kilograms of moisture
equations for coupled heat and mass transfer was used (13): per kilograms of air.
Using equations 1 to 4, the time-temperature relation-
rC p ]T/]t 5 ¹(k¹T) 1 rL]M/]t (1)
ship was obtained and compared with those obtained ex-
]M/]t 5 ¹(D¹M) (2) perimentally. The veriŽ ed time-temperature relationship
was used to predict the log10 (CFU/g) reduction at different
in which r was the density in kilograms per cubic meter, depths of the product, by ($10(T 2 70)/z dt)/D70, where T was
Cp was the speciŽ c heat in joules per kilogram per kelvin, the temperature at time t, D70 (0.13 min) was the decimal
T was the temperature of product in kelvin, t was the time reduction time at a reference temperature of 708C, and z
in seconds, k was the thermal conductivity in watts per (5.728C) was the temperature difference required for the
meter per kelvin, L was the latent heat in joules per kilo- thermal inactivation curve to drop a logarithmic cycle (5).
gram, M was the moisture content in kilograms of moisture The relationship between the product depth and the pas-
per kilograms of product mass, and D was the mass dif- teurization time for achieving a 7-log10 (CFU/g) reduction
fusivity in kilograms per second. is shown in Figure 4. Combining the analysis from the sta-
The boundary of the evaluated system might be subject tistical model with that of the computer model prediction,
to heat loss due to evaporation. Therefore, the following after 5 min of the pasteurization, about 3.5 mm of the depth
boundary equations were used in describing the process: from the product surface toward the center should have
k¹T · n 5 h(T a 2 Ts ) 1 DrL¹M· n (3) achieved 107 CFU/g of the reduction.

rD¹M· n 5 k m (M s 2 M a ) (4) Strips. The parameter estimates for the statistical mod-
els are given in Table 2. Figure 5 shows the log10 (CFU/g)
in which n was a unit vector that is normal to the product reduction of L. monocytogenes from the Ž tted models
surface in an outward direction, h was the convection heat (lines) and experimental data (symbols) for 227- and 454-g
transfer coefŽ cient in watts per square meter per kelvin, Ta packaged strips. Stochastic models underestimated the log10
was the environmental (steam or hot water) temperature in reduction of L. monocytogenes in the packaged chicken
kelvin, Ts was the surface temperature in kelvin, km was breast strips, indicating that the predictions by the models
the mass transfer coefŽ cient in kilograms per square meter from this study would be conservative (Figure 5). In a pre-
per second, Ms was the surface moisture content in kilo- vious study, Murphy and Berrang (4) found that product
grams of moisture per kilograms of product mass, and Ma size interacted with heating time and subsequently affected
the thermal lethality of Salmonella and L. innocua in fully
cooked and vacuum-packaged chicken breast strips. Similar
results were found in this study. The type III statistical anal-
ysis showed that the product size interacted with the heating
time. The P value was 0.0006 for the interaction term (time
3 product), indicating that the effect of product size on
survivors of L. monocytogenes was signiŽ cant at the 95%
level. The speciŽ c time when the number of surviving L.
monocytogenes in the two packaged (227 and 454 g) strips
was signiŽ cantly different was determined by contrast anal-
ysis (Table 3). At a 5 0.05, the survivors of L. monocy-
togenes in the two packaged (227 and 454 g) strips started
FIGURE 4. Relationship between heating time and product depth to be signiŽ cantly different at a heat treatment time of 6
for a 7-log10 (CFU/g) reduction. min (P 5 0.0339).
582 MURPHY ET AL. J. Food Prot., Vol. 66, No. 4

FIGURE 5. Log10(N0 /N) for L. monocy-


togenes in fully cooked and vacuum-pack-
aged chicken breast strips. The lines are
the Ž tted models with 95% conŽ dence lev-
els, and the symbols are experimental val-
ues. (a) 227-g packages and (b) 454-g
packages.

A process lethality model as detailed by Murphy et al. perimentally obtained data from this study. Therefore, if the
(5) was also used to predict the log10 (CFU/g) reduction in correct parameters are used, the process lethality model can
fully cooked and vacuum-packaged chicken breast strips. be used to predict the thermal lethality of the pathogen up
The process lethality, $10(T 2 T(ref))/z dt, was deŽ ned as the to 7 log10 in fully cooked and vacuum-packaged chicken
time required to produce the same degree of the pathogen breast strips during postcook pasteurization.
reduction at a reference temperature T(ref) at the given pro-
CONCLUSIONS
cess under the time (t) and temperature (T) history. As
shown in Figure 6, the prediction by the process lethality This study indicated that both steam and hot water pas-
model indicated that approximately 25 min (for 227-g pack- teurization were effective for the thermal inactivation of L.
ages) or 35 min (for 454-g packages) were needed to
achieve a 7-log10 (CFU/g) reduction of L. monocytogenes
in fully cooked chicken breast strips with steam or hot wa-
ter pasteurization. This prediction was consistent with ex-

TABLE 3. Results of the contrast analysis to compare survivors


of Listeria monocytogenes between 227-g and 454-g packaged
chicken breast strips
Time (min) x2 P . x2

5 0.86 0.3526
6 4.50 0.0339
FIGURE 6. Predicted log10 (CFU/g) reduction from the process
7 13.17 0.0003
lethality model for L. monocytogenes in fully cooked and vacuum-
10 61.18 ,0.0001
packaged chicken breast strips.
J. Food Prot., Vol. 66, No. 4 LETHALITY OF LISTERIA IN CHICKEN PRODUCTS 583

monocytogenes in fully cooked and vacuum-packaged breast meat products during postcook in-package pasteurization. J.
Food Prot. 66:242–248.
chicken breast meat products. The heat penetration rate was
6. Murphy, R. Y., L. K. Duncan, E. R. Johnson, M. D. Davis, R. E.
affected by the thickness of the product. The thicker the Wolfe, and H. G. Brown. 2001a. Thermal lethality of Salmonella
product was, the slower the heating rate. The process le- Senftenberg and Listeria innocua in fully cooked and packaged
thality model is an effective tool in determining up to 7 chicken breast strips during steam pasteurization. J. Food Prot. 64:
log10 (CFU/g) of thermal lethality for L. monocytogenes in 2083–2087.
7. Murphy, R. Y., E. R. Johnson, L. K. Duncan, E. C. Clausen, M. D.
fully cooked chicken breast meat products during in-pack-
Davis, and J. A. Marcy. 2001b. Heat transfer properties, moisture
age pasteurization. loss, product yield, and soluble proteins in chicken breast patties
during air convection cooking. Poult. Sci. 80:508–514.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
8. Murphy, R. Y., E. R. Johnson, L. K. Duncan, and M. D. Davis.
This research was partially supported by grants from USDA-NRI, 2001c. Thermal inactivation of Salmonella and Listeria in chicken
USDA-CSREES, and USDA-ARS NAFS. The authors thank Tyson Foods, breast patties cooked in a pilot-scale air convection oven. J. Food
Inc., Springdale, Ark., for products and G. Dwyer, E. Johnson, and K. Sci. 66:734–741.
Story for their assistance. 9. Murphy, R. Y., and B. P. Marks. 1999. Apparent thermal conductiv-
ity, water content, density, and porosity of thermally processed
REFERENCES ground chicken patties. J. Food Process Eng. 22:129–140.
10. Murphy, R. Y., B. P. Marks, and J. A. Marcy. 1998. Apparent speciŽ c
1. Berrang, M. E., R. J. Meinersmann, J. K. Northcutt, and D. P. Smith. heat of chicken breast patties and constituent proteins by differential
2002. Molecular characterization of Listeria monocytogenes from a scanning calorimetry. J. Food Sci. 63:88–91.
poultry further processing facility and from fully cooked product, p. 11. Roering, A. M., R. K. Wierzba, A. M. Ihnot, and J. B. Luchansky.
2. In Proceedings of The International Poultry ScientiŽ c Forum 1998. Pasteurization of vacuum-sealed packages of summer sausage
(SPSS), Atlanta, Ga. inoculated with Listeria monocytogenes. J. Food Saf. 18:49–56.
2. Cygnarowicz-Provost, M., R. C. Whiting, and J. C. Craig. 1994. 12. U.S. Department of Agriculture. 2002. Recall notiŽ cation report.
Steam surface pasteurization of beef frankfurters. J. Food Sci. 59: Food Safety and Inspection Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture,
1–5. Washington, D.C. Available at: http://www.fsis.usda.gov/OA/recalls/
3. Kang, D.-H., and D. Y. C. Fung. 1999. Thin agar layer method for recpactv.htm#2002.
recovery of heat-injured Listeria monocytogenes. J. Food Prot. 62: 13. Vilayannur, R. S., V. M. Puri, and R. C. Anantheswaran. 1998. Size
1346–1349. and shape effect on nonuniformity of temperature and moisture dis-
4. Murphy, R. Y., and M. E. Berrang. 2002. Effect of steam and hot tributions in microwave heated food materials: part II. Experimental
water post process pasteurization on microbial and physical property validation. J. Food Process Eng. 21:235–248.
measures of fully cooked vacuum packaged chicken breast strips. J. 14. Wenger, J. D., B. Swaminathan, P. S. Hayes, S. S. Green, M. Pratt,
Food Sci. 67:2325–2329. R. W. Pinner, A. Schuchat, and C. V. Broome. 1990. Listeria mon-
5. Murphy, R. Y., L. K. Duncan, K. H. Driscoll, and J. A. Marcy. 2003. ocytogenes contamination of turkey franks: evaluation of a product
Lethality of Salmonella and Listeria innocua in fully cooked chicken facility. J. Food Prot. 53:1015–1019.

You might also like