Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT Microorganisms involved in the spoilage of poultry meat stored at —2, 4, and 15 C
were identified. The numbers of spoilage organisms on poultry meat after storage for different time
periods at the above temperatures were determined. Attempts were made to extend the shelf-life of
poultry meat by treatment with two solutions containing citric acid, potassium sorbate, and
modified cornstarch. Solution 1 consisted of 10% citric acid, 6% potassium sorbate, and 34%
modified cornstarch in water (pH 3.2). Solution 2 consisted of 20% citric acid, 6% potassium
sorbate, and 24% modified cornstarch in water (pH 2.4). Chicken broiler wings were dipped in
boiling water for 10 sec, dipped in Solution 1 or 2 for 60 sec, drained for 3 sec, and packaged
individually in polyethylene bags.
Untreated poultry meat samples (portion of wing consisting of ulna and radius with attached
skin and muscle) had a shelf-life of less than 1 day at 15 C, 7 days at 4 C, and 14 days when stored
at —2 C. Wings treated with Solution 1 had a shelf-life of 4 days at 15 C and 14 days at 4 C. Wings
treated with Solution 2 had a shelf-life of 6 days at 15 C and longer than 28 days when stored at 4
C. Wings treated with Solution 1 remained acceptable for 1 day when stored at 25 C, whereas those
dipped in Solution 2 were acceptable after 2 days. Pseudomonads were identified as the major
organisms responsible for spoilage of both treated and untreated samples. Throughout the study,
samples treated with Solution 2 had lower microbial counts than samples treated with Solution 1.
Treatment of thighs with Solution 1 had no adverse effect on the sensory characteristics of bar-
becued samples. Samples treated in Solution 2 were scored lower but were not undesirable. Bar-
becuing consisted of oven baking and basting with a spicy tomato base sauce.
(Key words: modified cornstarch, citric acid, potassium sorbate, broiler shelf-life, microbiological
spoilage organisms)
1982 Poultry Science 61:2200-2207
2200
EXTENDING THE SHELF-LIFE OF CHICKEN BROILER MEAT 2201
and spraying with a sorbic acid solution. report in the literature on the successful preser-
Murphy and Murphy (1962) reported that the vation of meat at above refrigeration tempera-
addition to chill water of lactic, citric, or tures. This study was designed to provide such
hydrochloric acids at .05 to .25% lowered the information.
bacterial count of chill water as well as of the
surface of the carcasses. Mountney and O'Malley
(1965) reported that acetic, adipic, succinic, EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
citric, fumaric, malonic, sorbic, hydrochloric, Sample Preparation. Chicken broiler wings
phosphoric, and lactic acids were effective in of unknown history were obtained from a local
descending order in controlling bacterial food store and products of known history were
numbers and preventing off-odor development. obtained from the Meat Division, Animal
Arafa and Chen (1978) reported that dipping Sciences Department, Purdue University. Wings
cut-up broiler parts in a 1% ascorbic acid were obtained from Purdue University either
solution for 8 min retarded microbial growth immediately after evisceration or in frozen
and increased their refrigerated (3 C) shelf-life condition. These sources were chosen by
when compared to water-dipped controls. design to represent: 1) poultry meat already in
Dipping in ascorbic acid had no adverse effect the retail food store; 2) poultry meat exported
on the organoleptic characteristic of the cooked to developing countries by developed countries;
meat. Cox et al. (1974) reported that chicken and 3) poultry meat obtained directly from
parts treated with 3% succinic acid for 3 min at processing plants. Wings obtained in frozen
60 C had reduced microbial numbers when condition were thawed overnight at 4 C before
compared to untreated controls. Cunningham use. The portion of chicken wings consisting of
(1979) reported that potassium sorbate ex- radius and ulna with attached skin and muscle
tended the shelf-life of fresh poultry meat were used for this study. Modified edible
stored at 4 C. The use of a 5 or 10% potassium cornstarch (Maltrin 100; monosaccharides 1%,
sorbate solution as dip for 30 to 60 sec did not disaccharides 4%, trisaccharides 6%, tetrasac-
affect sensory characteristics of cooked poultry. charides 5%, pentasaccharides 84%) was ob-
Cunningham (1980) reported that a 10% tained from Grain Processing Corporation,
potassium sorbate solution controlled the Muscatine, IA. All microbiological media were
growth of spoilage organisms associated with purchased from Difco Laboratories, Detroit,
fresh poultry parts and effectively reduced MI.
numbers of Salmonella after 2 days of storage
For sensory evaluation, chicken thighs were
at 22 C. Robach and Ivey (1978) reported that
obtained as nonfrozen product from the Meat
5% potassium sorbate, when used as a dip,
Division of Purdue University's Animal Sciences
reduced the growth of Salmonella inocu-
Department. All thighs were subjected to the
lated on the surface of chicken and also ex-
appropriate treatment within 48 hr of slaugh-
tended the shelf-life of fresh poultry. To and
tering of the poultry. Storage prior to experi-
Robach (1980) reported that the refrigerated (3
mental study was at 2 C.
C) shelf-life of fresh whole broilers was extended
Solutions consisting of a modified edible
by dipping freshly chilled carcasses in a 5%
cornstarch in combination with citric acid and
solution of potassium sorbate for 1 min. Also,
potassium sorbate were prepared. Modified
dipping in sorbate reduced the growth of
cornstarch was used as a means of minimizing
Salmonella spp., and Staphylococcus aureus
the penetration of chemicals into chicken
inoculated onto the broiler carcasses.
wings. Its main function was to hold the citric
Schwall and Stadelman (1964) reported that acid and potassium sorbate on the surface of
dipping of chicken parts into a corn starch or poultry meat. Solution 1 consisted of 10%
modified corn starch solution resulted in an citric acid, 6% potassium sorbate, and 34%
edible coating for the chicken parts. modified cornstarch in water. Solution 2
In light of the growing concern regarding consisted of 20% citric acid, 6% potassium
the relatively short shelf-life of poultry meat sorbate and 24% modified cornstarch. Chicken
and also the increasingly high cost of energy, wings were dipped in boiling water for 10 sec
this study was conducted to examine the effect and immersed in Solution 1, 2, or distilled
of citric acid-modified, corn starch-potassium water for 1 min. The wings were allowed to
sorbate solution on the shelf-life of raw poultry drain for 3 sec and then were packaged indi-
meat stored at 4, 15, and 25 C. There is no vidually in polyethylene bags. Samples were
2202 IKEME ET AL.
"-•£
E
13
O
Solution I (pH 3.2)
A---A Solution 2 (pH 2.4)
=5
U-
U 6
O
O O Solution I (pH 3.2)
A A Solution 2 (pH 2.4) 5 Solution I (pH 3.2)
&---A Solution 2 (pH 2.4)
I
0 2 4 6 8 7 14 21 28
DAYS OF STORAGE DAYS OF STORAGE
FIG. 6. Total plate count on chicken wings treated FIG. 7. Total plate count on chicken wings treated
with Solution 1 or 2 and stored at 15 C (obtained with Solution 1 or 2 and stored at 4 C (obtained
from a local food store). Control samples had a shelf- from a local food store). Control samples had a shelf-
life of less than 2 days. life of less than 7 days.
after 2 days at 25 C. Samples dipped in Solution the most acceptable as measured by lowest
1 remained acceptable after 1 day (Table 2). total plate counts obtained. The initial total
Microbial counts on chicken wings dipped in plate counts for these samples were low when
Solution 2 after 2 days of storage at 25 C were compared to chicken broiler wings from the
similar to counts on wings dipped in Solution 1 local food store or broiler wings obtained
after storage at 25 C for 1 day. immediately after evisceration from Animal
The initial number of microorganisms Sciences Department. This favors exportation
present greatly influenced the shelf-life of of frozen poultry meat to developing countries.
treated and nontreated broiler wings. This is in In this study development of off-odor and slime
agreement with previous reports (Arafa and were remarkably suppressed by the acidic dips.
Chen, 1977; Dawson and Stadelman, 1960). A possible explanation was given by Perry et al.
Wings obtained from the Department of Animal (1964) who reported that sorbic acid inhibited
Sciences, Meat Division, Purdue University had undesirable enzymatic changes resulting from
a longer shelf-life at both 15 and 4 C than microbiological activity. Throughout the study,
chicken wings purchased from the food store. counts obtained from samples dipped in Solution
Chicken wings frozen before use appeared to be 2 (pH 2.4) were lower than counts obtained
from samples dipped in Solution 1 (pH 3.2),
probably due to the difference in pH. Limited
studies conducted during this research showed
TABLE 2. Microbial counts from chicken wings that a 10 sec dip in boiling water coupled with
treated with Solution 1 or 2 and stored at 25 C a 1 min dip in Solution 1 or 2 effectively
reduced the numbers of a naladixic acid resistant
Microbial counts (cfu/ml) strain of Salmonella typhimurium (10 6 cells/ml
Day 0 Day 1 Day 2 inoculated onto chicken broiler wings) during 4
Trial (Initial count) (Solution 1) (Solution 2) days storage at 15 C.
Identification of Microorganisms. Pseudo-
1 5.6 X 10' a 3.5 X 10 6 monads were the major spoilage bacteria
2 3.8 X 10 s 5.9 X 10' 7.9 X 10 6
isolated from untreated chicken wings, stored
3 8.2 X 10 3 5.5 X 10' 7.1 X 10'
4 6.2 X 10 2 1.6 X 10 6 7.5 X 10* at —2 and 4 C, at all stages of storage examined
(Table 3). For untreated samples at 15 C,
Count delayed until Day 3. Microbial count on Pseudomonas was the major organism identified
Day 3 was 3.4 X 10s cfu/ml. at the time of spoilage. Of 54 isolates, 75.9%
2206 IKEME ET AL.
*p -*P - p - p vP
p* o"~ p * ff* ff* O o TABLE 4. Sensory evaluation mean scores,
<N OS
© o\ o^ o\ © m 00 40 observations per treatment
>rt 00 00 O
© 3
Mean
& -a Treatment Score1
- f
Solution 2 (pH 2.4), Day 4 3.4 a
Solution 2 (pH 2.4), Day 2 3.3 a
p Solution
Control
Solution
1 (pH 3.2), Day 4
a
' Means not followed by the same letter are sig-
nificantly different at P<.01.
1
Low score preferred, scale of 7.0.
s JS
00 * N
ti r-i
T3
Is parison showed that there was no significant
°^
<•. . 2
difference (P>.05) between samples after 2 and
<M U N U 4 days of storage (Table 4). There was no
I * I * * B ^
S5SS significant difference between samples dipped
III!
o 3 .
in solution 1 and the control (P>.05). Samples
dipped in solution 2 (pH 2.4) were scored
mil
lower than those dipped in solution 1 (pH 3.2)
u 0 or the controls but scores for all products were
£ < in the desirable range.
^<£
EXTENDING THE SHELF-LIFE OF CHICKEN BROILER MEAT 2207
The results of this study showed that shelf- Cunningham, F. E., 1980. Microbiology of poultry
life of refrigerated (4 C) and nonrefrigerated parts dipped in potassium sorbate. Poultry Sci.
60:969-971.
(15 C) poultry meat could be extended using
Cox, N. A., A. J. Mercuri, B. J. Juven, J. E. Thomson,
modified cornstarch-potassium sorbate-citric and V. Chew, 1974. Evaluation of succinic acid
acid solutions described in this study. More and heat to improve the microbiological quality
research needs to be done before the results of of poultry meat. J. Food Sci. 39:985-987.
this study can be put into commercial practice. Dawson, L. E., and W. J. Stadelman, 1960. Micro-
organisms and their control on fresh poultry
The absence of food poisoning or pathogenic meat. North Central Regional Publ. 112. Michigan
microorganisms in the product must be con- State Univ. Bull. No. 278.
firmed. The effect of cornstarch-potassium Harrigan, W. F. and M. E. McCance, 1976. Pages
sorbate-citric acid solution on organisms like S. 66—81 in Laboratory Methods in Food and Dairy
aureus and Salmonella needs to be examined Microbiology. Academic Press, London.
Kaloyereas, S., R. M. Crown, and C. S. McCleskey,
further.
1961. Experiments on preservation with a new
ice containing glycol diformate and sorbic acid.
Food Technol. 15:361-364.
REFERENCES Karel, M., O. R. Fennema, and D. B. Lund, 1975.
Arafa, A. S., and T. C. Chen, 1977. Characteristics of Food preservation. Page 5 in Physical Principles
microorganisms associated with hot-packaged, of Food Preservation. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New
washed and immersion chilled broilers. Poultry York, NY.
Sci. 56:918-923. Mountney, G. J., and J. E. O'Malley, 1965. Acids as
Arafa, A. S., and T. C. Chen, 1978. Ascorbic acid poultry meat preservatives. Poultry Sci. 44:582—
dipping as a means of extending shelf-life and 586.
improving microbial quality of cut-up broiler Murphy, J. F., and R. E. Murphy, 1962. Method of
parts. Poultry Sci. 5 7 : 9 9 - 1 0 3 . treating poultry. US Pat. 3,025,170.
Ayres, J. C , W. S. Ogilvy, and G. F. Stewart, 1950. Olson, V. M., B. Swaminathan, D. E. Pratt, and W. J.
Post-mortem changes in stored meats. I. Micro- Stadelman, 1981. Effect of five cycle rapid
organisms associated with development of slime freeze-thaw treatment in conjunction with
on eviscerated cut-up poultry. Food Technol. various chemicals for the reduction of Salmonella
4:199-205. typhimurium. Poultry Sci. 60:1822-1826.
Barnes, E. M., G. C. Mead, C. S. Impey, and B. W. Perry, G. A., R. L. Lawrence, and J. Melnick, 1964.
Adams, 1979. Spoilage organisms of refrigerated Extension of poultry shelf-life by processing with
poultry meat. Pages 101—116 in Cold Tolerant sorbic acid. Food Technol. 18:891-897.
Microbes in Spoilage and the Environment. A. D. Robach, M. C , and F. J. Ivey, 1978. Antimicrobial
Russel and R. Fuller, ed. Academic Press, New efficacy of a potassium sorbate dip on freshly
York, NY. processed poultry. J. Food Prot. 4 1 : 2 8 4 - 2 8 8 .
Barnes, E. M., and M. J. Thornley, 1966. The spoilage Schwall, D. V., and W. J. Stadelman, 1964. Page 11 in
flora of eviscerated chickens stored at different Effects of Corn Starch and Corn Syrup on
temperatures. J. Food Technol. 1:113—119. Moisture Retention, Color, Flavor and Oxidative
Cochrane, W. W., 1975. The world food problem. Page Changes in Poultry Meat. Res. Progr. Rep. 143,
1 in Physical Principles of Food Preservation. Purdue Univ., Lafayetter, IN.
Karel, M., O. R. Fennema, and D. B. Lund, ed. To, E. C , and M. C. Robach, 1980. Potassium sorbate
Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, NY. dip as a method of extending shelf-life and
Cunningham, F. E., 1979. Shelf-life and quality inhibiting the growth of Salmonella and Staphy-
characteristics of poultry parts dipped in potas- lococcus aureus on fresh, whole broilers. Poultry
sium sorbate. J. Food Sci. 44:863-864. Sci. 59:726-730.