You are on page 1of 6

Development of Electrochemical

Micromachining (ECMM) Setup


Deependra Singh1, Piyush Bardia1, Mohamed Iqram1, Gautam Gupta1,

Mayank Sinha1, Akshay Agarwal1, Vinod Yadav2

Abstract— Electrochemical micromachining ECMM, Disk Cutting-ECMM, Pocket Milling-


(ECMM) is considered as a viable micromachining for ECMM, Cylindrical Grinding-ECMM and
the fabrication of micro-features, micro-holes, micro- Surface Grinding-ECMM. Sinking-ECMM
slots and micro-channels in electrically conductive configurations are used for making non-
difficult to machine workpiece materials. This paper symmetrical cavities or holes using non rotating
presents the in-house development if an ECMM table micro tools. Drilling configurations are used for
top setup in sinking configuration including power
supply system, electrolyte supply system and electrode
fabricating symmetrical cavities or holes using
feeding system. A preliminary observation about the rotating micro tools. Milling configurations are
hole profile made by sinking ECMM is measured used for fabricating 3D pockets by adapting a
using optical measuring microscope and reported in movement strategy similar to that in
this paper. conventional milling. In grinding configuration
of ECMM no abrasive wheel is used but a disk
Keywords — micromachining, shape base wheel is allowed to rotate against a
electrochemical micromachining, pulsed power cylindrical workpiece or flat workpiece. This
supply, inter electrode gap control, hole, paper presents in-house development of ECMM
circularity table top setup in sinking configuration capable
to produce micro holes and micro cavities.
I. INTRODUCTION
II. FUNDAMENTALS OF ECMM
In the recent years, numerous developments in
ECM have focused on the fabrication of micro ECMM works on the principle of faraday’s
products made of difficult to machine electrically laws of electrolysis for the removal of material.
conductive materials. Electrochemical The removed material is flushed out using
micromachining (ECMM) is an emerging electrolyte jet. The gap between the workpiece
technology having potential of machining and micro tool is accurately controlled and the
through and blind-micro holes, micro-grooves, tool is fed accordingly. Finely, negative shape of
micro-slots and complex micro contours. ECMM tool is created in the workpiece. The way of
is more appropriate for micromachining material removal, anodic reactions, mass
applications due to its inherent advantageous transport and electrolyte circulation is described
features such as tool wear and zero heat affected here.
layer in workpiece. The process is also capable
to machine wider range of materials with A. Material removal in ECMM
controlled material removal, better precision and In the machining region where the workpiece
high surface quality. directly faces the cathode tool, the anodic
Current ECMM technology used for reaction rate is constant for a constant Inter-
fabricating micro features can be categorized Electrode Gap (IEG) and the electrolyte
into nine different configurations: Die Sinking- conductivity. The machining performance is
ECMM, Die Drilling-ECMM, Hole Sinking- influenced by various predominant process
ECMM, Hole Drilling-ECMM, Wire Cutting- parameters, such as current density, IEG,
electrolyte flow rate, concentration and type of
1 electrolyte, and also the anode reactions. If IEG
Deependra Singh et al., Senior undergraduate students at
Motilal Nehru National Institute of Technology Allahabad. e- is reduced, the resolution of machining shape
mail: deependra.singh.mech@gmail.com becomes better. Material removal is maximum
2
for small IEG. Experimental results have proved
V. Yadav, Professor at Motilal Nehru National Institute that the addition of a magnetic field causes
of Technology Allahabad. e-mail: vinody@mnnit.ac.in
increase in material removal rate and accuracy and diffusion layer thickness which play an
[9]. The material removal rate is expressed in important role in high-rate anodic dissolution
terms of unit removal (UR) in the micro- process. Metal ions produced at the anode are
machining domain [9]. UR is defined as a unit of transported into the solution by convective
workpiece removed during one cycle/pulse of diffusion and migration. To maintain
machining [14]. electroneutrality, electrolyte anions accumulate
from the anode to be compensated by the rate of
B. Anodic reaction
migration towards the anode. The extent of ion
Depending on the operating conditions and build-up depends on the current density, metal
metal electrolyte combinations, different anodic dissolution efficiency, and hydrodynamic
reactions take place at high current densities. The conditions.
rates of these reactions are dependent on the
ability of the system to remove the reaction
products as soon as they are formed and supply
fresh electrolyte to the anode surface. All of
these factors influence the machining
performance, namely dissolution rate, shape
control and surface finish of the workpiece. The
current efficiency of metal dissolution, η is
related to weight loss, ∆w by
∆wZF
η= Fig. 1 Nerst diffusion layer concept describing
Ita (1) mass transport at the dissolving anode surface. A
where I is the applied current, t is the typical anodic polarization curve exhibiting a
machining time, F is Faraday’s constant, Z is the limiting current is also included (inset) [1].
valence of metal dissolution and a is the
molecular weight of the metal. Actually, the
The Nernst diffusion layer concept has been
dissolution valence v will influence the metal
used frequently to obtain a simplified description
removal and is related to the UR as follows:
of mass transport effects in high-rate dissolution
Iaη
UR = of metals. A stagnant diffusion layer of thickness
pZFAρ (2) δ is thus assumed to exist at the anode as shown
where ρ is the density in g/m3, A is the surface in fig. 1. Inside the diffusion layer, a
area in m2 and p is the number of pulse/unit time. concentration gradient exists and the transport
Current efficiency for metal dissolution, which is occurs exclusively by diffusion. Outside the
a function of current density and local flow diffusion layer, transport occurs by convection
conditions, varies as a function of distance from and the electrolyte concentration is assumed to
the tool. be constant.
For an anodic reaction that is controlled
C. Mass transport
by convective mass transport, the anodic current
Mass transport processes influence the EMM density, I, is given by
performance in several ways. First, they C s − Cb
influence the maximum rate of an I = nFD
δ (3)
electrodissolution reaction, thus giving rise to a
so called limiting current; second, mass Where D is the effective diffusion coefficient
transport-controlled anodic reactions affect the that takes into account the contributions from
morphology of dissolved surfaces; and finally, transport by migration, CS is the surface
mass transport processes influence the concentration, Cb is the bulk concentration, and δ
macroscopic and microscopic current is the diffusion layer thickness.
distribution on the workpiece. An understanding Current distribution and accuracy of the job
of mass transport effects are, therefore, a can be affected by the mass transport conditions.
prerequisite for he development of ECMM An increase in current density leads to an
processes [1]. increase in the rate of metal dissolution at the
During anodic dissolution, the anode. In anodic dissolution, salt film
concentration at the anode surface can be mechanism and acceptor mechanism have been
significantly different from that of the bulk. identified for mass transport. In the salt film
These concentrations are mainly determined by mechanism, the rate of transport of dissolution
the rate of mass transport, transport mechanisms products from the anode surface is rate limiting.
In high rate anodic dissolution in neutral
electrolyte, the transport of reaction products process adversely. It was also found that
away from the anode is rate limiting and salt film hydrochloric acid solution is useful in fine-hole
precipitation occurs at the surface of the anode. drilling because it dissolves the metal hydroxides
In the acceptor mechanism, the limiting factor is as they are produced. Recently, it was reported
the rate of transport towards the anode of that less toxic and dilute electrolyte, 0.1 M
acceptor types such as complexing ions; these H2SO4 can be applied for the machining of
varieties react with the dissolved metal ions to stainless steel with ultra-short pulses [9].
form hydrated complex ions. In EMM, a smooth Although resolution is improved at lower
surface finish can be achieved only at limiting concentrations, there is a lower limit to
current density. If the current density is too high,
concentration that can be used. For example, an
it may cause the formation of heat-affected
experiment was attempted unsuccessfully with
zones, and it finally results in improper surface
an electrolyte concentration of 0.01 M HCl [10].
finish and low accuracy. The limiting current
density is governed by convective mass At this low ionic concentration, the ion- content
transport; the anodic limiting current density J is in the small gap between the electrodes is
given by insufficient to supply the charge carriers
vFDC S necessary to complete the charging of the double
J= layer capacitance. It was possible to add small
δ (4)
where D is the effective diffusion coefficient, amounts of other ionic species such as NaCl or
which takes into account the contribution from KCl to the 0.01 M HCl solution to increase the
transport by migration, Cs is the surface total electrolyte concentration and thus create an
concentration, δ is the diffusion layer thickness environment with enough solution conductivity
and ν is velocity flow rate. to support electrochemistry. For Ni the
electrochemical reaction critical point was rather
D. Electrolyte independent of high acid or chloride
The electrolyte completes the electric circuit concentration, i.e. the chemical nature of the
between the tool and workpiece, and allows the electrolyte, and depends mainly on bulk
desired machining reactions to occur. It also electrolyte conductivity and ionic strength [10].
carries away heat and reaction products from the
machining zone. The electrolytes are classified III. DEVELOPMENT OF SINKING-ECMM SETUP
into two categories: passivating electrolytes Basic theoretical and fundamental research
containing oxidizing anions, e.g. sodium nitrate, work and preliminary industrial practice have
sodium chlorate, and non-passivating indicated that ECMM using pulsed current offers
electrolytes containing relatively aggressive considerable potential for enhancement of the
anions such as sodium chloride. Passivating ECM process [11]. The high current density
electrolytes generally give better machining required for proper operation of the ECMM
precision [14]. The electrolyte must possess less process may give a high concentration of
throwing power to increase the accuracy. For reaction products, which can only be partly
neutral electrolyte, sodium nitrate is more removed by the electrolyte, especially if the
advantageous than sodium chloride due to its inter-electrode gap is narrow. Increasing
lower throwing power, and highly controlled contamination can cause deposition on the micro
metal removal, which increases the accuracy in tool, so the workpiece material no longer
machining. Since the precipitate from reaction dissolves uniformly. Furthermore, changes in the
increases the possibility of short circuit between electrolyte composition may cause a raise in
tool and workpiece, it is preferable to use fresh temperature, and hence the electrical resistivity
can also decrease the accuracy. These problems
and clean electrolyte instead of re-circulated one.
can be largely avoided by applying a pulsed
The pH value of the electrolyte solution is
voltage instead of a continuous voltage.
chosen to ensure good dissolution of the
Pulsating current has three parameters: pulse on-
workpiece material during the machining without time, pulse off-time and peak current density,
affecting the tool. Acidic electrolytes are which can be varied independently in order to
preferable in micro ECM because they do not achieve the desired machining rate. It can also
create insoluble reaction products. It is also usual help to control the dimensional accuracy and
to use neutral electrolyte such as sodium nitrate. surface finish.
Some chemicals like NaHSO4 can be added with
specific concentrations that do not affect the
accuracy as observed by Cagnon et al. [9].
Preliminary tests have been conducted on two
frequencies namely 0.05MHz and 0.5MHz. The
schematic of pulse generator primary circuit can
be shown as in fig. 3.

Fig. 2 Pulsed Power Supply [12]

The IEG should be as small as possible. If the


electrode gap is kept small, the resolution of the
machined shape becomes better and the
possibility of applying ECM to micro-machining
increases. Localization of the dissolution process
can be increased by reducing the gap width. The Fig. 3 Schematic of pulse generator circuit
gap width is the only parameter characterizing The amplitude of pulses generated from IC555
the micro-machining precision. It can also is of transistor-transistor logic (TTL) and varies
increase accuracy and unit removal. In the EMM from 0-5V. The amplitude of machining pulses
process, the IEG is kept in the order of 10–50 can be modified by using metal–oxide–
µm. Maintaining the specific range of IEG, i.e. semiconductor field-effect transistor which can
15–20 µm uniformly is an important requirement also operate as a high frequency switch. The
to achieve high accuracy and surface finish. The operating voltage amplitude has been
electrical conduction method for maintaining the successfully modified up to 20V.
electrode gap distance between the tool electrode
and workpiece can be applied. Around 1 V can B. Feedback and tool feeding system
be applied between the tool electrode and the The feedback system is driven by controller
workpiece for measuring the current so that the that computes the required feed and actuates the
electrical contact of the micro tool electrode with motor accordingly. Also it is controller that is
the workpiece can be checked. In a pulsed EMM fed with external interrupts that provides human
system, the IEG and tool position monitoring can interface with it. The controller is connected with
be conducted during pulse off-time, leading to a computer that keeps check on the machining
significant reduction in the indeterminacy of the parameters. Any human interface difficult with
gap. Machining inaccuracy is directly external interrupts can be compensated with
proportional to the IEG size. computer control. The code for controller is
Tool feed goes hand in hand with IEG. The written in C and is compiled and dumped using
motor actuation is controlled by Atmega32 Atmega AVR studio. This gives the flexibility to
microcontroller. The microcontroller is attached operate the setup in absence of any human
with computer in turn to provide feedback. presence as well as provides controls for human
Although pulse generator is separate from interface. The schematic of feedback circuit is as
actuation system, they have been inter-related shown in fig. 4.
with high frequency feedback.
A. Pulsed power supply
Pulsed power supply is created with IC555.
The noise induced while generating pulses was
removed to with 10nF capacitor. The duty cycle
and frequency can be varied according to need.
The only limitation arises from use of IC555 is
with duty cycle. The duty cycle in present circuit
cannot be reduced to less than 50%. The
available options apart from using IC555 are
crystals. 16MHz crystal coupled with Atmega32 Fig. 4 Schematic feedback and controller circuit
is capable of producing pulses of varying duty The assurance of generator
constant TTL supply is
cycles, as per our need, and pulses up to 57ns. provided with IC7805. The driver for actuating
These ultrashort pulses are thought to be capable DC motor is L298 which is controlled via
enough to machine workpiece of appropriate controller through Pulse Width Modulation
(PWM). PWM is successfully utilized to actuate
the motor according to the difference present in
required operating voltage and voltage present
between tool and workpiece operating voltages.
Tool driving system consists of ball screw
bearing mechanism. Mechanical actuator is
present in form of DC motor. The motion of
motor is rotatory and is converted into linear
motion with the help of lead screw. The
constraint for making nut on lead screw move in
linear motion direction is provided in form Fig. 6 Schematic of Electrolyte circulation system
bearing ways.
Extensive calculations have been performed in
order to obtain appropriate elevations for each
chamber and losses at various points. Entire
circulation system is optimized and
accommodated with tool feeding system in order
to obtain seamless flow of electrolyte (Fig. 7).

Fig. 5 3D model of tool driving


system Fig. 7 3D model of tool driving system in
combination with electrolyte circulation
C. Electrolyte circulation system system
Maintaining a proper flow of electrolyte to the
machining chamber is the ultimate aim of any
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
design of electrolyte circulation system. To
achieve this, various methods have been carried ECMM table top setup has namely powers
out. Three step chamber system is very common supply, feedback control, tool feeding and
out of all. The particles which are removed by electrolyte circulation systems. The tool feed has
machining are filtered by filters of various been successfully maintained upto 0.1 µm per
thicknesses and then cleaned electrolyte is operating pulse. The controller takes and records
supplied to the electrolyte supply tank by means the feedback at 125kHz and hence computes the
of a pump. This process should continue for a required feed at the same mentioned rate. Power
long period of time without any error to make supply has been demonstrated to work at various
the machining smooth, because machining time duty cycles and operating frequencies up to
for a through hole can span over hours, therefore 0.5MHz. Successful regulation of electrolyte
it is requisite to design a model which has proper flow through tool has been achieved for
supply and an effective filtering system which electrolyte flow rate of up to 1 m/s.
lasts long enough till the machining is complete. Preliminary tests were conducted with
0.05MHz (duty factor: 0.67) and 0.1N NaCl
solution. A through hole drilled with above
mentioned parameters provided results as shown
in Fig. 8.
machine holes of different profile whether it is
symmetric or non symmetric. The developed
ECMM setup is performing all required activities
for machining such as power supply, electrolyte
supply and tool feeding. The circular crossection
hole produced shows very small circularity error.
Many challenging activities required for the
improvement of present setup needs further
research effective utilization.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author is grateful to his seniors who
Fig. 8 Optical Measuring Microscope (OMM) helped and guided the project in direction.
image of through hole
REFERENCES
Above captured image is analyzed with image
[1] J. Mcgeough, Micromachining by Electrochemical
processing software to provide with best fit circle Dissolution, Marcel Decker Inc., New York (USA),
for circular profile. The contour hence obtained 2001, 239-275
from the software is handy to find the circularity [2] V. K. Jain, Introduction to Micromachining, 2010,
and applicability of developed set up. Narosa Publishing House Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi
[3] T. Masuzawa, State of the Art of Micromachining,CIRP
Annals - Manufacturing Technology, 49, 2, 2000, 473-
488
[4] M. Dutta, R.V. Shenoy, L.T. Romonkiw, Recent
advance in the study of electro-chemical micro
machining, 1996, Journal of Engineering for Industry,
118, 29, 29-36
[5] B. Bhattacharya, S. Mitra, A. K. Biro, Electrochemical
machining: New possibilities for micromachining,
2002, Robotics and Computer Integrated
Manufacturing, 18, 283-289
[6] J. Kozak, K. P. Rajurkar, Y. Makkar, Selected problems
of micro-electrochemical machining, 2004, Journal of
Materials Processing Technology, 149, 426-431
[7] B. Bhattacharyya, Advancement in electrochemical
micro-machining, 2004, International Journal of
Machine Tools and Manufacture, 44, 15, 1577-1589
[8] M. Kunieda, K. Mizugai, S. Watanabe, N. Shibuya, N.
Iwamoty, Electrochemical micromachining using flat
electrolyte jet, 2011, Annals of CIRP- Manufacturing
Technology, 60, 251-254
[9] Laurent Cagnon et al., Electrochemical
Fig. 9 Contour of image of through hole
Micromachining of Stainless Steel by Ultrashort
Preliminary tests show the appropriateness of Voltage Pulses, 2003, Z. Phys. Chem., 217, 04, 299-313
[10] Trimmer, A. L., Hudson, J. L., Kock, M., Schuster, R.,
developed set up for machining. Surface finish Single-step Electrochemical Machining of Complex
and quality of machined surface is expected to Nanostructures with Ultrashort Voltage Pulses, 2003,
improve with further optimization of the set up. Applied Physics Letters, 82, 19, 3327-3329
Developed set up has fulfilled the expected [11] R. Maeda, K. Chikamori, H. Yamamoto, Feed rate of
wire electrochemical machining using pulsed current,
objectives to a large extent and can further be 1984, Precision Engineering, 6, 4, 193-199
improved with proper calibration of machining [12] B. Bhattacharya, Recent Developments in
parameters. Further experimentation and Electrochemical Micromachining
calibration is underway and it is expected to [13] Harmen S.J. Altena,EDM and ECM for mass
production Philips DAP, 2004, Journal of Materials
provide set up that can be used in more Processing Technology, 149, 1–3, 18-21
applications than used till now. Overall [14] Kim, B. H., Na, C. W., Lee, Y. S., Choi, D. K., Chi,
dimensions are reduced to a large extent in C.N., Micro Electrochemical Machining of 3D Micro
comparison to the commercially produced mini- Structure Using Dilute Sulfuric Acid, 2005, Annals of
the CIRP, 54, 1, 191-194
ECM [13].

V. CONCLUSIONS
The ECMM setup has been developed in-
house successfully. The setup is capable to

You might also like