You are on page 1of 66

IALCCE 2012

Third International Symposium


on Life-Cycle Civil Engineering

Keynote Lecture

Sustainable Design of Structures:


The Outcomes of the COST
Action C25-WG3
Raffaele Landolfo
University of Naples "Federico II", Naples, Italy

Hofburg Palace, Vienna, Austria, October 4, 2012


IALCCE 2012, Hofburg Vienna, October 4

1. Introduction
2. Sustainable Design of Structures
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25
4. What’s next? UNINA

Content
IALCCE 2012, Hofburg Vienna, October 4

1. Introduction
2. Sustainable Design of Structures
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25
4. What’s next? UNINA

Content
1. Introduction UNINA

The concept of “Sustainable Development”

Sustainable Development is the "development which meets the needs of the present
without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs"
(Brundtland Report: Our Common Future, 1987)

The 3 main pillars (dimensions) of sustainable development

ECONOMY • Growth of employment


and income
• Security SOCIETY • Eco – efficiency
• Health • Economic development
• Education • Productivity
• Cultural identity
• Empowerment
SUSTAINABLE
• Accessibility DEVELOPMENT
• Stability
• Equality
• Ecosystem integrity
• Reproducibility of
natural resources
ENVIRONMENT • Biodiversity

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
View from Rockefeller Center, New York. Photo by Landolfo (2006)
1. Introduction UNINA

The impact of construction sector on sustainability

The construction sector exercises a wide influence on the rest of society,


having huge impacts on…

…. THE PLANET
ENVIRONMENT

The Construction Industry consumes 50% of


the raw material extracted from the Earth’s
Crust

Constructions comprises the largest energy


consuming sector in Europe with almost
half of the primary energy used

The waste arising from the construction


related activities consists of a third of the
total waste, 970 million tones, produced in
EU
Source : Communication COM(2004)60

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

The impact of construction sector on sustainability

The construction sector exercises a wide influence on the rest of society,


having huge impacts on…

….THE ECONOMY
ECONOMY

The building sector has major economic


impact which has traditionally been the main
economic background of the EU coutries

The Construction industry accounts for about


the 10% of the GDP in Europe
The majority of EU Countries buildings
constitute over half of the national wealth

Construction is the largest industrial sector in


EU, representing a quarter of the total output

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

The impact of construction sector on sustainability

The construction sector exercises a wide influence on the rest of society,


having huge impacts on…

….THE SOCIETY
SOCIETY

The Construction sectore, in Europe, has


2.5 million of enterprise and 13 million
employees

People spend almost 90% of time in


buildings

People want constructions safe,


economical and environmental friendly

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

Sustainability & Constructions


Common language for sustainable construction
New concepts, phrases, terms and expressions are being used in the construction industry across
Europe in order to:

1. improve the environmental, social and economic impact of the industry and its outputs

2. provide a common base for the development of harmonized standards for the sustainable
design of constructions

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

COST Action C25

European COoperazion in the field of Scientific and Techical research

COST ACTION C25:

Sustainability of Constructions
Integrated Approach to Life-time Structural Engineering

“…to promote science-based developments in sustainable


construction in Europe through the collection and collaborative
analysis of scientific results concerning life-time structural
engineering and especially the integration of environmental
assessment methods and tools for structural engineering…”

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

COST Action C25

European COoperazion in the field of Scientific and Technical research

COST is an intergovernmental framework for European Cooperation in Science


and Technology, allowing the coordination of nationally-funded research on a
European level.

COST contributes to reducing the fragmentation in European research


investments and opening the European Research Area to cooperation worldwide.

COST supports mobility of researchers to create a scientific network and


stimulate innovative activities

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

COST Action C25 - The network

26 countries + EU JRC
Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo
Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
1. Introduction UNINA

COST Action C25 – Coordination and Working Groups

MC Management Committee  Chair: L. Bragança


 Vice-chair: H. Koukkari

WG1 Criteria for Sustainable Constructions  Chair: R. Blok


Global methodologies, assessment methods,  Vice-chair: H.Gervásio
global models and databases

WG2 Eco-efficiency  Chair: M. Veljkovic


Eco-efficient use of natural resources in  Vice-chair: Z. Plewako
construction materials, products and processes

WG3 Life-time structural engineering  Chair: R. Landolfo


Design for durability, life-cycle performance,  Vice-chair: V. Ungureanu
including maintenance and deconstruction

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
IALCCE 2012, Hofburg Vienna, October 4

1. Introduction
2. Sustainable Design of Structures
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25
4. What’s next? UNINA

Content
Four-storey building which is completely recyclable,
produces no emissions and is self-sufficient in terms of
heating energy requirement. Because of its assembly it is
also completely recyclable ( W. Sobek )

W. Sobek (1998-1999). R128 house. Ref: http://www.wernersobek.de


Foster (2004). Viaduc de Millau. France
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures: a multi-performance based approach


The challenge of sustainability of structures is to maximize the mechanical, durability,
economic and environmental performance of a structure, during the whole life-cycle,
reducing, at the same time, the adverse impacts played on planet, people and economy

ENVIRONMENTAL requirements
• Hygiene, health and environment
• High recycling rates of structural components ECONOMIC requirements
• Reduced energy and water consumption
• Reduced waste disposal • Raw material cost
•… • Production costs
• Reduced construction cost
• Reduced operational costs,
SOCIAL requirements • Reduced maintenance costs
• Mechanical resistance and stability • Increase revenue
• Safety in case of fire •…
• Safety in use
• Protection against noise
• Structural resistance
• Robustness & resiliency

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures

DESIGN

END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION

LIFE CYCLE

DISMANTLMENT IN USE

MAINTENANCE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
Multi-performance Time-Dependant Based Approach

INTEGRATED APPROACH
LIFE CYCLE DESIGN
1 MULTI-PERFORMANCE
• Enhanced safety and reliability
• Reduced environmental impacts
END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION • Optimized life-cycle costs
• ...

2 LIFE-CYCLE ORIENTED
The basic requirements shall be achieved
during the whole life-cycle of the
construction

IN USE
DISMANTLMENT 3 BASED ON QUANTITATIVE
METHODOLOGIES
Performance requirements shall be verified
MAINTENANCE according to quantitative methodologies

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
Multi-performance Time-Dependant Based Approach
ASSESSMENT METHODS

LIFE CYCLE DESIGN

END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION


LCA LIFE CYCLE ENVIRONMENTAL
ASSESSMENT
(ISO 14040:2006; ISO 14044:2006)
+
LIFE CYCLE COST
LCC
(ISO 15685-5:2008)
IN USE
DISMANTLMENT
+
MAINTENANCE LIFE CYCLE PERFORMANCE
LCP
(EN 1990-1999; ISO 13823:2008)

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
The Design Approach – Methods for Environmental assessment
LIFE CYCLE ENVIRONMENTAL
DESIGN
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT ( LCA )
ISO 14040: 2006 and ISO 14044: 2006
END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION
LCA
Process to valuate the environmental burdens
LCC associated with a product process or activity by
LCP
identifying energy and materials used and wastes
DISMANTLMENT IN USE
released to the environment, and to evaluate and
implement opportunities to affect environmental
MAINTENANCE improvement

OBJECTIVES To identify energy and materials used and wastes released to the environment, and to
evaluate and implement opportunities to affect environmental improvement.

At design stage, LCA addresses the selection among different design options and it helps to
BENEFITS identify the life cycle stages associated with maintenance, repair and rehabilitation
of components

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
The Design Approach – Methods for Environmental assessment
LIFE CYCLE ENVIRONMENTAL
DESIGN
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT ( LCA )
ISO 14040: 2006 and ISO 14044: 2006
END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION
LCA

t CO2
S1: GFRP Wrapping
LCC
LCP
DISMANTLMENT IN USE
S2: RC Jacketing

MAINTENANCE
GWP

1 Goal and Scope definition (G&S)


2 Life Cycle Inventory (LCI)
3 Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCIA) Four main stages
4 Life Cycle Interpretation (LCIN)

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
The Design Approach – Methods for Economic assessment
LIFE CYCLE COSTING
DESIGN
LIFE CYCLE ( LCC )
ISO 15686-5: 2008
END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION

LCA

Calculation methodology concerned with the


LCC estimation of the costs, in monetary terms, over
LCP
DISMANTLMENT IN USE the whole life cycle : construction, operation,
maintenance and repair (and sometimes
demolition) of a building.
MAINTENANCE

Minimising the sum of the life cycle costs, in current values, thus benefiting both owner and
OBJECTIVES end users. LCC aims at the optimization of the design granting better results in extended life,
performance and sustainability, avoiding over design and excessive waste.

Compared to the current approach, which estimates only the direct costs for construction and
maintenance, LCC extends the analysis over the whole life of the project, showing the real
BENEFITS value of the investment.

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
The Design Approach – Methods for Economic assessment
LIFE CYCLE COSTING
DESIGN
LIFE CYCLE ( LCC )
A reliability-based life cycle costing
END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION
Cost (€)
LCA
total expected cost
LCC
LCP
DISMANTLMENT IN USE
Initial cost

MAINTENANCE
Maintenance
& repair cost
• Design/Construction
Failure cost
Total • Preventive Maintenance
Expected • Inspection
βopt
Cost • Repair Reliability (β)
• Failure
Ref: FRANGOPOL & ESTES (2005). A representation of reliability-based life cycle costing.

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
The Design Approach – Methods for Structural assessment
LIFE CYCLE PERFORMANCE
DESIGN
LIFE CYCLE ( LCP )
EN 1990-1999; ISO 13823:2008
END OF LIFE CONSTRUCTION

LCA Evaluation of structural performances during the life-cycle


Structural
LCC performance
LCP Presumed capacity Actual capacity considering the
DISMANTLMENT IN USE deterioration occurred
Capacity
F
Demand
MAINTENANCE
F: “Failure event”
Required
tfail: Time of failure
performance level
t
tfail

OBJECTIVES Evaluate the period of time during which a structure or any component is able to achieve the structural performance
requirements defined at the design stage with an adequate degree of reliability.

Durability requirements shall be checked at the same design level that is currently used for ordinary
BENEFITS mechanical design (limit state method, probability based design)

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
2. Sustainable Design of Structures UNINA

Sustainability of structures
Towards an integrated approach for the structural design

WG3
LCP

LCC

LCA

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
IALCCE 2012, Hofburg Vienna, October 4

1. Introduction
2. Sustainable Design of Structures
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25
4. What’s next? UNINA

Content
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

WG3 Organization

WG3 Life-time structural engineering


Design for durability, life-cycle performance, including
maintenance and deconstruction

WP1 Life-cycle performance: verification methods for


durability of constructions (degradation models and
service design life)

WP2 Monitoring of life-cycle performance (life-cycle safety,


functionality, quality, demolition and deconstruction)

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Contribution of WG3 members


Main tasks

WP1 T1. State of the art on Service Life Prediction and


Design Methodologies
A
T2. State of the art on Deterministic and Probabilistic DESIGN
Degradation Models

WP2 T3. State of the art on survey and condition assessment


of structures
B
T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques IN USE
and planning

T5. Demolition and deconstruction C


END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Contribution of WG3 members


Main tasks

T1. State of the art on Service Life Prediction and


Design Methodologies
A
T2. State of the art on Deterministic and Probabilistic DESIGN
Degradation Models

T3. State of the art on survey and condition assessment


of structures
B
T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques IN USE
and planning

T5. Demolition and deconstruction C


END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T1. Service life prediction & design methodologies


Main Topics
Each construction, during its life cycle, will face with deterioration depending on
several factors such as:

material susceptibility

natural aging process

execution of the works


A
environmental exposure conditions DESIGN

quality of the material


B
planned maintenance IN USE

……
C
Generally speaking, a deterioration could lead to a decrease of performance to such
an extent that a structure could be not able to satisfy the basic serviceability and END OF LIFE

safety requirements before the design life has expired

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T1. Service life prediction & design methodologies


Main Topics
In order to prevent the premature failure of a construction due to an unexpected
deterioration, a quantitative evaluation of the durability performances shall be
performed since the design stage.

The scientific research in the field of


Risk based
durability and service life prediction
has been very active in the last years
Probabilistic A
DESIGN
Semi-probabilistic

B
Deterministic
feedback from practice IN USE

C
The first task of WG3 (T1) dealt with a critical review of the different methodologies
END OF LIFE
developed in the framework of international scientific literature for the verification of the
structural performance over the life cycle

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T1. Service life prediction & design methodologies


WG3 contribution Deterministic
feedback from practice

State of the art review on concept and method provided in standard and codes
concerning service life prediction

ISO and CEN standards concerning service life planning Service Life Planning (SLP) for
buildings and constructed assets (ISO 15686) developed by ISO/TC59/SC14

FACTOR METHOD ISO 15686-1 2000 A


DESIGN
ESL=RSL x A x B x C x D x F x G A. Quality of components as supplied to the project;
B. Design level of a component or assembly’s
installation; B
RSL= Reference service life C. Work execution level or skill level of the installers;
IN USE
D. Indoor environment;
E. Outdoor environment;
ESL= Estimated service life F. In-use conditions;
G. Maintenance level. C
END OF LIFE

Vesikari & Landolfo_Service Life Prediction Methods Referred to by Eurocode 0; Trinius & Sjöström_Standardization of Service Life Methodologies

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T1. Service life prediction & design methodologies


Semi-probabilistic
WG3 contribution
Special focus on methods given in the ISO 13823:2008 Probabilistic

‘General principles on the design of structures for durability’

The standard provides conceptal framework for the application of limit states
methods to durability design

• Basic concepts for verifying durability A


• Definition of durability limit states DESIGN
• Durability requirements
• Formats for checking durability B
• Design life of a structure and its components IN USE

• Strategies for durability design


C
END OF LIFE

Landolfo & E. Vesikari, Service Life Design Methods for Civil Engineering Structures;

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T1. Service life prediction & design methodologies


WG3 contribution Risk based

This approach utilizes quantitative definitions of exposure, robustness and vulnerability


of building structures. Both direct and indirect consequences associated with loss of
functionality, failure or collapse should be taken into consideration.

Hazard identification, modeling of hazard


A
scenarios, estimation of probabilities and
consequences compels the designer to careful DESIGN

examination of the whole building process and


its interactions with safety, economy, social and B
natural environment.
IN USE

C
END OF LIFE

Sz. Wolinski, Risk Based Approach to Service Life Assessment of Building Structures

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Contribution of WG3 members


Main tasks

T1. State of the art on Service Life Prediction and


Design Methodologies
A
T2. State of the art on Deterministic and Probabilistic DESIGN
Degradation Models

T3. State of the art on survey and condition assessment


of structures
B
T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques IN USE
and planning

T5. Demolition and deconstruction C


END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T2. Degradation models


Main Topics
The second task of WG3 deals with the problem of modeling the deterioration of
structural materials for the life cycle performance evaluation of structures.

Deterioration models of structural materials are usually expressed as dose-response


functions which provide the deterioration rate of a given material over time as a
function of both material related factors and structure environment parameters.

STRUCTURE TRANSFER ENVIRONMENTAL


MATERIAL ACTION EFFECT
ENVIRONMENT MECHANISM ACTION
A
Thickness loss,
Outdoor Condensation; Atmospheric DESIGN
STEEL aesthetic loss, rust
atmosphere no drainage corrosion
expansion

REINFORCED Outdoor/indoor Loss of bond, failure of


CONCRETE atmosphere Diffusion Chloride attack
reinforcement B
IN USE
Direct Subterranean Loss of material,
WOOD Ground
exposure termites strength

C
WG3 attempted to provide an overview of the degradations models developed in END OF LIFE
the framework of scientific literatures for, steel, concrete, masonry and timber.

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T2. Degradation models


METAL structures – Corrosion model

Modeling approaches of atmospheric corrosion


damage of metal structures, which are available in
both ISO standards and the literature

Dose response function. ICP MATERIALS


International Co-operative Programme on Effects on Materials including
A
Historic and Cultural Monuments
DESIGN
Material Mass Loss, ML [g/m2]

Weathering steel (unshltered) ML=34[SO 2 ]0.33 exp{0.020Rh+f(T)}t 0.33


B
Zinc ML=1.4[SO 2 ]0.22 exp{0.018Rh+f(T)}t 0.85 +0.029Rain [H+]t IN USE

Aluminium ML=0.0021[SO 2 ]0.23 Rhexp{f(T)}t 1.2 +0.000023Rain [Cl-]t

Copper ML=0.0021[SO 2 ]0.23 [O3 ]0.79Rhexp{f(T)}t 0.78 +0.029Rain[H+]t C


Weathering steel (shltered) ML=8.2[SO 2 ]0.24 exp{0.025Rh+f(T)}t 0.66 END OF LIFE

R. Landolfo, L. Cascini & F. Portioli Modelling of Corrosion Damage for Metal Structures

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T2. Degradation models


METAL structures – Fatigue
Fatigue load model

Fatigue is a major aspect within the design and


maintenance of bridges during the whole life time

The current fatigue design procedure for steel and Strees history and cycle counting
composite according to the Eurocodes offers a quite
up to date concept including: A
• different verification procedures ranging from DESIGN

simplified to quite sophisticated,


• different safety concepts taking into account the B
owner’s strategy concerning maintenance and IN USE
inspection
A detail from the I 35W bridge on Mississippi
• a detail catalogue with more than 70 different river Minneapolis (USA). Collapsed on august C
2007
constructional details that allows in most cases a END OF LIFE
proper and durable design over the whole life U. Kuhlmann, H.-P. Günther, J. Raichle, & M. Euler
time. Fatigue of Steel and Composite Bridges

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T2. Degradation models


REINFORCED CONCRETE structures

The models for general degradation in concrete


structures are widely accepted and they can be
used for predicting the service life of a concrete
structure

A
Carbonation DESIGN

Penetration of chlorides
B
IN USE
Corrosion of reinforcement

Freeze-thaw deterioration C
END OF LIFE

E. Vesikari, Ch. Giarma & J. Bleiziffer Degradation Models of Concrete Structures

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T2. Degradation models


WOOD structures

A
• For service life of wood products, modeling of biological deterioration DESIGN

will give a tool to evaluate the effect of environmental exposure to


performance of wood in exterior conditions B
IN USE
• These models can also be as basic knowledge for developing the service life
evaluation methods for wood products and structure.
C
• Factor method presented in the ISO 15686 can be used as a basic methods for
END OF LIFE
evaluate the service life of wooden cladding
H.A. Viitanen, T. Toratti, R. Peuhkuri, T. Ojanen & L. Makkonen Durability and service life of wood structures and components

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Contribution of WG3 members


Main tasks

T1. State of the art on Service Life Prediction and


Design Methodologies
A
T2. State of the art on Deterministic and Probabilistic DESIGN
Degradation Models

T3. State of the art on survey and condition assessment


of structures
B
T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques IN USE
and planning

T5. Demolition and deconstruction C


END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T3. Survey and condition assessment of structures


Main Topics

The third task of WG3 was to collect information concerning the state of art, the
specification, the implementation and the operation of:

MONITORING CONCEPTS AND


TECHNIQUES
A
DESIGN
SURVEY AND CONDITION ASSESSMENT
METHODS & PRACTICES
B
IN USE
CONDITION ASSESSMENT TOOLS

C
END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T3. Survey and condition assessment of structures


WG3 Contribution on monitoring
• Instrumental techniques • Structural health monitoring

Special attention is devoted to


hardware and analysis aspects
of implementation of automated
SHM systems for civil structures
Typical sensors monitoring specimen
Fabbrocino & C. Rainieri Monitoring of structural behaviour of
buildings A
DESIGN
• Wireless sensor network

Overview of the B
Strain gauges Inductive position sensor
technology and IN USE
specific
challenges of
wireless sensor C
network
END OF LIFE
G. Hauf & O. Hechler Monitoring – an introduction Feltrin, R. Bischoff, J. Meyer & O. Saukh

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T3. Survey and condition assessment of structures


WG3 Contribution on survey and condition assessment of structures
During the last decades, focus has been put on inspection of the existing building
and bridge stock and related condition assessment procedures.

Diagnosis, on-site assessment and visual inspection of reinforced concrete structures.

A
DESIGN

B
With respect to bridges, a step-by-step
procedure, based on a general procedure IN USE

developed by the Joint Committee for Structural


Safety (JCSS 2001), for the fatigue assessment is C
proposed.
END OF LIFE

B. Kühn & O. Hechler Survey and Condition assessment

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T3. Survey and condition assessment of structures


WG3 Contribution on survey and condition assessment of structures

MEDEA is a damage and vulnerability assessment tool, which


guides engineers toward a the safety assessment of reinforced
concrete and masonry structures.
The assessment tool is based on the identification of possible
typological vulnerability factors of masonry and r.c. buildings,
which are listed and combined with potential collapse
mechanisms to be activated under seismic excitation
A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

C
END OF LIFE

G. Zuccaro & M. F. Leone

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Contribution of WG3 members


Main tasks

T1. State of the art on Service Life Prediction and


Design Methodologies
A
T2. State of the art on Deterministic and Probabilistic DESIGN
Degradation Models

T3. State of the art on survey and condition assessment


of structures
B
T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques IN USE
and planning

T5. Demolition and deconstruction C


END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques and planning


Main Topics

State of the art concerning theories and techniques for the maintenance, repair and
rehabilitation of building and bridges

General presentation of computer based systems for the management of


constructions, such as the life cycle management tools developed in the framework
of the European Project LIFECON (2001-2003) and the BIM based tools for the
predictive life-cycle management developed by Technical University of Munich, TUM A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

C
END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques and planning


WG3 Contribution

State of the art review on the general approach of structural intervention together
with an overview of the available techniques for the retrofit of existing building

A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

C
END OF LIFE
V. Ungureanu, A. Dogariu, D. Dubina, A. Ciutina, R. Landolfo, F.M. Mazzolani& F. Portioli
Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation of buildings

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques and planning


WG3 Contribution
Lifecycle Management tools based on Building
Information Models

• Development of a predictive life-cycle


management system for concrete buildings
(mainly bridges)
A
• BIM-based management of all information
relevant for the assessment of a building’s DESIGN

state.
• Prediction: future state is computed on the B
basis of inspection data and prognosis final IN USE
objective: cost-effective, optimized, and
sustainable maintenance of concrete
buildings C
END OF LIFE

E. Vesikari, A. Borrmann & K. Lukas Management systems for maintenance, repair and rehabilitation

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques and planning


WG3 Contribution Generate random population of
PM times Ti and number of
applications Q for all PM types
An advanced method for the optimization of
structural maintenance of bridges is presented. Perform GA operations

Automated multi-objective optimization of Repeat for each GA chromosome

maintenance strategies considering the lifetime


unavailability and the life-cycle cost as criteria are Repeat for each PM type
presented.
Tsi = [T1, T2, …, TQ]
A
The proposed approach is able to provide optimum
DESIGN
maintenance strategies considering a combination of Perform EM optimization
multiple essential maintenance options and multiple
preventive maintenance options applied at regular or Compute objective functions B
irregular time-intervals. for the obtained strategy
IN USE

The lifetime unavailability is calculated based on no


GA converged?
lifetime functions. Genetic algorithms are used to C
solve the optimization problem. yes
END OF LIFE
Obtain Pareto-optimal solution

D.M. Frangopol & N.M. Okasha Bridge Maintenance, Repair and Rehabilitation in a Life-Cycle Context

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Contribution of WG3 members


Main tasks

T1. State of the art on Service Life Prediction and


Design Methodologies
A
T2. State of the art on Deterministic and Probabilistic DESIGN
Degradation Models

T3. State of the art on survey and condition assessment


of structures
B
T4. Maintenance, repair and rehabilitation techniques IN USE
and planning

T5. Demolition and deconstruction C


END OF LIFE

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


Main Topics

The total production of construction and demolition waste in the European Union is
about 450 million ones per year and represents the most part of waste stream.

In the EU, the amount of construction and demolition waste is estimated to be 480 kg
per person per year.

A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

Besides, construction and demolition waste has a very high recycling potential
C
In line with that, in the last of WG3 (T5) the key principles of different design strategies END OF LIFE
for re-use and recycling of buildings are presented, including design for adaptability, for
dismantling and design for deconstruction

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


WG3 Contribution on demolition
A general overview of the most common
techniques for the demolition of buildings and
bridges are presented.
Main techniques Usage Quota

Deconstruction by excavators with shears etc. 82%


Exploding 4%
Deconstruction with wrecking balls 3%
Other machines 3%
Precussion, abrasion, heating etc. 3% A
Robots 0.3%
DESIGN
Other 1.7%

Excavated
Construction material
site wasre (140,90)
B
(4,30)
Besides, an analysis of the construction waste IN USE
arising from demolition, with a special focus on
Building
no more usable products (such as plastic, PVC, demolition
polystyrene, rubbish.) is presented. waste (52,10) Composition C
of C&D
Waste in END OF LIFE
Germany
Road demolition
waste (16,60) (2005)
P. Kamrath Deconstruction of buildings: Masses and types

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


WG3 Contribution on End of life scenarios and Design for Deconstruction
END OF LIFE SCENARIOS
Disassembly technique is a new discipline within the field of architectural/engineering practice and
theory. In a resource perspective, the implementation of documentation which explains how
buildings are demolished, or how materials can be reused and respectively recycled becomes
crucial.

End-of-life scenarios

Building reuse or relocation,


Component reuse or relocation in a new building,
A
Material reuse in the manufacture of new DESIGN
component,
Material recycling into new materials.
B
THE 4 STEP OF DECONSTRUCTION: IN USE

Design for deconstruction is thus defined as “design for


deconstruction of structures and complex building parts C
into basic materials” so that they enable resubmission of
the materials in the resource loop at the end of life of a END OF LIFE
building or structure.
O. Hechler, O. P. Larsen & S. Nielsen Design for Deconstruction

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


WG3 Contribution
Principles of the structural design for deconstruction

• Use as wide of structural grid as


possible to maximize the non-structural
wall elements
• Use prefabricated subassemblies and a
system of mass production
• Use an open building system where A
parts of the building are more freely
DESIGN
interchangeable and less unique to one
application
• Minimize the number of different B
types of components for simplification
IN USE
of sorting
• Simply supported beams should be
used in concrete structures C
• Design modular structures END OF LIFE

O. Hechler, O. P. Larsen & S. Nielsen Design for Deconstruction

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


WG3 Contribution
Deconstruction techniques for buildings and bridges

A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

C
END OF LIFE

F. Portioli, M. D‘Aniello, E. Cadoni, R.P. Borg & O. Hechler Demolition and deconstruction of bridges

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


WG3 Contribution
Some examples of best practices of structures designed for deconstructions

A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

C
Restaurant of Cz pavilion END OF LIFE
left: EXPO ’58
right: reused as Office building in Praha, Cz, 2008 O. Hechler, O. P. Larsen & S. Nielsen Design for Deconstruction

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

T5. Demolition and deconstructions


WG3 Contribution
Some examples of best practices of structures designed for deconstructions

Footbridge to
the German
pavilion
(left: EXPO’58;
right: reused in
Duisburg,
Germany, 2008.
A
DESIGN

B
IN USE

C
END OF LIFE

O. Hechler, O. P. Larsen & S. Nielsen Design for Deconstruction

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25 UNINA

Summary Report of the WG3


Volume 2: Integrated
Approach to Life-time
structural engineering
Publisher(s): University of Malta
ISBN/ISSN: 978-99957-816-2-0
Pages: 398

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
IALCCE 2012, Hofburg Vienna, October 4

1. Introduction
2. Sustainable Design of Structures
3. The Outcomes of WG3 of the Cost Action C25
4. What’s next? UNINA

Content
4. What’s next? UNINA

Concluding remarks

Nowadays, the sustainability of


constructions has become a current topic
which involves all sectors with the relevant
expertise.

In line with that, theoretical methodologies,


tools and best practice rules have been
developed in order to achieve the goals of
sustainable design of structures according to
a time-dependent multi-performance based
approach.

The next challenge is to cope the gap between research and common practice even at standard level. In
this direction the Construction Sector Network (CSN) of the European Committee for Standardization
(CEN), has planned to develop a second generation of Eurocodes, widening of the scope from the current
structural design to other design criteria related to sustainability.

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
4. What’s next? UNINA

Catastrophic events & Resilient urban environments


Constructions are subjected more and more to exceptional
actions, which were not taken into account at the design stage,
producing huge damages.

In line with that a growing attention has been put towards the
concept of resilience of urban environments. With the aim to
reduce both the produced damages and the repair time.

but resilience & Sustainability are related. Many of the


essential principles of sustainability are strictly linked to the core
pillars of resilience. The next step is to take a step forward and
talk about sustainable resilience

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
4. What’s next? UNINA

European Erasmus Mundus Master - SUSCOS

SUStainable COnstructionS
under natural hazards and
catastrophic events

http://steel.fsv.cvut.cz/suscos

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
4. What’s next? UNINA

European Erasmus Mundus Master - SUSCOS

United Nations Secretary-General’s High-Level Panel on Global Sustainability (2012).


Resilient people, resilient planet: A future worth choosing, Overview. New York: United Nations.

Keynote lecture Raffaele Landolfo


Sustainable Design of Structures: The Outcomes of the COST Action C25-WG3
Thanks for kind attention

UNINA
Raffaele Landolfo

You might also like