Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Impactofemotiononmemory PDF
Impactofemotiononmemory PDF
net/publication/12211285
CITATIONS READS
110 494
8 authors, including:
Tokiji Hanihara
Shinshu University
60 PUBLICATIONS 1,620 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Toru Imamura on 30 July 2014.
343
K A ZU I E T A L
T
Table
able 1 Demographic and cognitive characteristics of patients with Alzheimer's disease and normal controls disease patients' amnesia was severe.
Instead, we used a simplified version of
Patients Controls the recall paradigm. As the photographs
were presented one by one again in the
Gender (male:female) 7:27 3:7 same order, subjects were asked questions
Age (mean (s.d.) years) 71.6 (6.5) 70.8 (5.5) about the story line (one question per
Education (mean (s.d.) years) 9.4 (2.6) 9.2 (2.1) photograph). If they could answer a
Mini-Mental State Examination score (mean (s.d.)) 22.6 (2.9) 28.6 (1.7) question perfectly, they scored 2 points; if
they could not answer at all, they scored 0
Alzheimer's Disease Assessment Scale (Cognitive) score (mean (s.d.)) 15.7 (5.3) NA
points; if their answer was partially correct,
they scored 1 point. Thus, the maximum
scores of phases 1, 2 and 3 were 8, 8 and 6
ASSESSMENT picted a mother taking her son to visit his
points. Recall scores were expressed as a per-
father at work. In the middle four photo-
centage of the maximum of each phase,
We used the illustrated story paradigm that graphs (phase 2), the narrations in the
because of the different numbers of
has been validated in many studies as an arousing story differed from those in the
questions given for each phase.
appropriate test for the assessment of neutral story: phase 2 of the arousing story
The second part of the experiment was
emotionally influenced memory (Heuer & was emotionally charged and phase 2 of
carried out 2 weeks later. On this occasion,
Reisberg, 1990; Cahill et al,al, 1994; Cahill the neutral story was not. In phase 2 of the
those groups who had been read the arous-
& McGaugh, 1995; Adolph et al, al, 1997; arousing story, the boy was badly hurt in
ing story 2 weeks previously were now read
Hamann et al, al, 1997a
1997a). In this paradigm, an automobile accident, and surgeons
the neutral story, and those who had been
subjects viewed 11 colour photographs struggled to save his life; while in phase 2
read the neutral story 2 weeks previously
which were shown in sequence, accom- of the neutral story, the boy watched a dis-
were now read the arousing story. The
panied by either an emotionally charged aster drill in the hospital. For the last three
scores in the AD±AN and AD±NA groups
story narrative, or a narrative which was photographs (phase 3), the narrations in the
were evaluated together as scores of the
not emotionally charged. The emotionally arousing story were nearly identical to those
Alzheimer's disease subjects, and the scores
charged story (arousing story) and the in the neutral story: phase 3 of both stories
in the NC±AN and NC±NA groups were
emotionally uncharged story (neutral story) depicted the mother leaving the hospital.
evaluated together as scores of the normal
were translated from the English of the The arousing and neutral stories are closely
controls.
original version into Japanese. Together, matched in content, complexity and style,
the photographs and narrative (one and were confirmed to be matched in
sentence per photograph) tell a story. The comprehensibility (Cahill & McGaugh, Statistical analysis
photographs were presented on a 17-inch 1995). The rating of the emotional charge of the
Apple high-resolution colour monitor at a The subjects were told to pay close stories was analysed by using two-way
rate of 1 photograph every 20 seconds, attention to the photographs and the analysis of variance (ANOVA) for repeated
controlled with the Aldus Persuasion narrative and to remember the story. measures with one between-factor (group)
version 3.0J (Adobe Inc., Mountain View, Immediately following the presentation of and one within-factor (story). The recall
CA, USA) on the Power Macintosh 8100/ the story, they were asked to rate the scores across the three phases on the assess-
80 (Apple Computer Inc., Cupertino, CA). emotional charge of the stories on a scale ment of emotionally influenced memory was
A researcher (H.K.) next to the subjects of 1±4 (1 indicating `not emotional' and 4 analysed by using three-way ANOVA for
read the stories while the photographs were indicating `highly emotional'). repeated measures, with one between-factor
shown. After rating the emotional charge of (group) and two within-factors (story and
Both types of story consisted of three the stories, and 5 minutes after the end of phase). To specifically elucidate the effect
phases. For the first four of the 11 photo- the presentation of the photographs, the of emotional arousal on memory we carried
graphs (phase 1), the narrations in the subjects were given an 11-item recall test. out two-way ANOVA for repeated measures
arousing story were identical to those in the We did not use the standard methods of with two within-factor (story and phase)
neutral story. In this phase, both stories de- the recall test, because the Alzheimer's and a post hoc Tukey honestly significant
T
Table
able 2 Demographic and cognitive characteristics of subjects in four groups
AD ^AN: Alzheimer's disease patients who were first read the arousing story and then the neutral story. AD ^NA: Alzheimer's disease patients who were first read the neutral story
and then the arousing story. NC^AN: normal controls who were first read the arousing story and then the neutral story. NC^NA: normal controls who were first read the neutral
story and then the arousing story.
344
E M OT I ON A L LY I NF LU
LUEENC E D ME M
MOO RY IN A L ZH E I M E R ' S D I S E A S E
Fig. 2 Results of the recall memory test for the three phases of the arousing and neutral stories in patients
difference test. The statistically significant with Alzheimer's disease and normal controls. *, Alzheimer's patients read the arousing story; &, Alzheimer's
level was set at P50.05. patients read the neutral story; *, normal controls read the arousing story; &, normal controls read the neu-
tral story. Error bars represent standard error of the mean.
RESULTS
Ratings of the emotional charge action (F
(F(2,84) 0.48,
0.48, P0.62)
0.62) were not emotional impact which influenced
of the stories significant. memory retention, such as the content,
The ratings of the emotional charge of the The two-way ANOVA for the Alz- complexity and comprehensibility of the
stories are illustrated in Fig. 1. The mean heimer's group revealed a significant story target events, and the style and time of
(s.d.) rating of the emotional charge of the effect (F (F((1,34)24.9,
((1,34) 24.9, P50.001), a exposure to them. In addition, because the
arousing story for the Alzheimer's disease significant phase effect (F (F(2,68)14.8,
(2,68) 14.8, current paradigm was a more natural one,
patients was 2.4 (0.9); that of the neutral P50.001), and a significant story6
story6phase involving a connected series of pictured
story for the Alzheimer's patients 1.5 (1.1); interaction (F
(F(2,68)37.5,
(2,68) 37.5, P50.001). The events, rather than a randomly ordered
that of the arousing story for the normal con- post hoc test showed that the recall scores series of photographs, potential artefacts
trols 3.0 (0.9); and of the neutral story for in phase 2 were significantly worse for the due to presenting a random selection of
the normal controls 1.8 (1.2). The two-way neutral story than for the arousing story pictures were eliminated. Therefore, not
ANOVA revealed a significant story effect (P50.001), while the recall scores in only was the current paradigm a strictly
(F(1,42)21.4,
(1,42) 21.4, P50.001). But group effect phases 1 and 3 of the two stories were com- controlled one, but it was able to assess
(F(1,42)2.60,
(1,42) 2.60, P0.11)
0.11) and group6
group6story parable. The analysis for the NC group the enhancing effect of emotional arousal
interaction (F(F(1,42)0.61,
(1,42) 0.61, P0.44)
0.44) were revealed a significant story6
story6phase inter- on declarative memory in a condition close
not significant. Thus, both the Alzheimer's action (F
(F(2,18)12.0,
(2,18) 12.0, P50.001), but no to daily life.
patients and the normal controls rated the significant story effect (F (F(1,9)3.25,
(1,9) 3.25,
P0.10)
0.10) or phase effect (F (F(2,18)1.8,
(2,18) 1.8, Emotionally influenced memory
arousing story more emotional than the
P 0.25). The post hoc analysis showed in Alzheimer's disease
neutral story.
that the recall scores in phase 2 were signif- In the present study, the rating of the
icantly worse for the neutral story than for emotional charge of the arousing story
Emotionally influenced memory the arousing story (P (P50.005), while the was significantly higher than that of the
test recall scores in phases 1 and 3 for the two neutral story, in both the Alzheimer's
The results of the recall memory test for the stories were comparable. patients and the normal subjects, re-
three phases of the arousing and the neutral confirming that both groups were similarly
stories for the Alzheimer's patients and the more emotionally charged by the arousing
normal controls are illustrated in Fig. 2. DISCUSSION story than by the neutral story. The Alz-
The three-way ANOVA revealed a sig- heimer's disease patients recalled less about
nificant group effect (F (F(1,42)94.0,
(1,42) 94.0, A paradigm for emotionally the stories than did the normal subjects, for
P50.0001), a significant story effect influenced memory both stories. A phase-by-phase comparison
(F(1,42)12.3,
(1,42) 12.3, P50.005), a significant Although both naturalistic and experi- of the results in each group showed that the
phase effect (F (F(2,84)6.88,
(2,84) 6.88, P50.005), mental approaches have merits, experimental arousing story was better recalled than
and a significant story6
story6phase interaction studies have obvious advantages in the con- the neutral story only in phase 2, in which
(F(2,84)30.1,
(2,84) 30.1, P50.001). But the group6
group6 trol of experimental variables and the the emotional impact in the arousing story
story interaction (F
(F(1,42)4.02,
(1,42) 4.02, P0.052),
0.052), assessment of the accuracy of memory. In was greater than that in the neutral one.
group6
group6phase interaction (F (F(2,84)30.1,
(2,84) 30.1, our strictly controlled experimental study, These results strongly indicate that the
P0.21),
0.21), and group6
group6story6
story6phase inter- we could control factors other than enhancing effect of emotional arousal on
345
K A ZU I E T A L
paradigm that was used in the current enhancing effect of emotional arousal on declarative memory in patients with
study. In our previous study we reported moderate to severe Alzheimer's disease was not established.
that emotional remote memory about a
& The long-term enhancing effect of emotional arousal on declarative memory in
terrible earthquake was significantly more
closely correlated with the volume of the patients with Alzheimer's disease was not examined.
amygdala than with the volume of the
hippocampus in Alzheimer's patients,
indicating that the impairment of the
enhancing effect of emotional arousal on
memory in these patients is related to the HIROAKI KAZUI, MD, ETSURO MORI, MD, MAMORU HASHIMOTO, MD, NOBUTSUGU HIRONO, MD,TORU MD, TORU
degree of damage to the amygdala (Mori IMAMURA, MD, SATOSHI TANIMUKAI, MD, TOKIJI HANIHARA, MD, Department of Clinical Neurosciences,
Hyogo Institute for Aging Brain and Cognitive Disorders, Himeji, Japan; LARRY CAHILL, PhD, Department of
et al,
al, 1999). That study also indicated that
Neurobiology and Behavior and Center for the Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, University of
in some Alzheimer's patients, arousal
California, Irvine, USA
material failed to enhance memory.
However, in the present study, the Correspondence: Dr Hiroaki Kazui, Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Hyogo Institute for Aging
magnitude of the enhancement of memory Brain and Cognitive Disorders, 520 Saisho-ko, Himeji, 670 - 0981, Japan.Tel.: +81 792 95 5511; fax: +81
in Alzheimer's patients by emotional 792 95 8199; e-mail: kazui@
kazui @hiabcd.go.jp
material was as good as that in normal
(First received 23 November 1999, final revision 27 March 2000, accepted 4 April 2000)
subjects.
One possible reason for this dis-
crepancy might be the difference in the
severity of dementia in the target subjects.
In the patients in the present study, for the arousing story in the normal similar memory-enhancing effects (Hamann
dementias were milder than those in our subjects, which would have artificially de- et al,
al, 1997b
1997b). In consideration of our
previous study, as rated by the CDR. The creased the degree to which the arousing finding, together with this evidence of
volume of the amygdala decreased and story enhanced their memory. Hamann et al, al, it is suggested that the
the neuropathological changes in that instructions and guidance given to
region increased with increasing CDR score Alzheimer's disease to patients may be
(Jack et al,
al, 1997; Haroutunian et al,
al, 1998). Clinical implications of emotionally easier to remember if emotionally arousing
Because more of the amygdala was prob- influenced memory actions, devices and so on are used.
ably preserved in the patients in this study The finding that emotional arousal The present finding also implies a
than in those in our previous study, those enhanced memory in Alzheimer's disease potentially useful strategy for memory
in the present study might have had a has implications for the management of rehabilitation. Furthermore, the fact that
greater memory for emotional material. people with dementia. It directly suggests emotional arousal enhances memory raises
Another possible reason for this that they should be treated gently, to avoid the possibility of enhancing memory
discrepancy might be the easiness of the eliciting strong negative feelings. Although without emotional arousal, by using agents
current recall test. The recall test in the Alzheimer's patients forget less emotional such as the b-adrenergic receptor agonist
present paradigm was made easier to events, they have a better memory for and the corticosterone receptor agonist,
enable us to assess the memory function emotionally negative events, and this which involve the final emotion±memory
fairly and to avoid the floor effect in might damage the caregiver±patient pathway (Cahill et al,
al, 1998). Clearly, more
Alzheimer's disease. Consequently, the relationship, for example. Although the research is needed to determine the associa-
recall test might have become too easy emotional arousal used in the present tion between emotion and memory and to
for the normal subjects, and a ceiling study was negative in nature, both positive develop a useful strategy for memory
effect might have occurred in phase 2 and negative emotional arousal have enhancement.
34 6
E M OT I ON A L LY I NF LU
LUEENC E D ME M
MOO RY IN A L ZH E I M E R ' S D I S E A S E
REFERENCES National Academy of Sciences of the United States of Hughes, C. P., Berg, L., Danziger,W. L., et al (1982) A
America,
America, 93,
93, 8016^8021. new clinical scale for the staging of dementia. British
Journal of Psychiatry,
Psychiatry, 140,
140, 566^572.
Adolph, R., Cahill, L., Schul, R., et al (1997) Impaired Folstein, M. F., Folstein, S. E. & McHugh, P. R. (1975)
declarative memory for emotional material following `Mini-Mental State'. A practical method for grading the Ikeda, M., Mori, E., Hirono, N., et al (1998) Amnestic
bilateral amygdala damage in humans. Learning and cognitive state of patients for the clinician. Journal of people with Alzheimer's disease who remembered the
Memory,
Memory, 4, 291^300. Psychiatric Research,
Research, 12,
12, 189^198. Kobe earthquake. British Journal of Psychiatry,
Psychiatry, 172,
172,
425^428.
Bradley, M. M., Greenwald, M. K., Petry, M. C., et al
Hamann, S. B., Cahill, L., McGaugh, J., et al (1997a
(1997a)
(1992) Remembering pictures: pleasure and arousal in Jack, C. R., Jr., Petersen, R. C., Xu,Y. C., et al (1997)
Intact enhancement of declarative memory for
memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Medial temporal atrophy on MRI in normal aging and
emotional material in amnesia. Learning and Memory,
Memory, 4,
Memory, and Cognition,
Cognition, 18,
18, 379^390. very mild Alzheimer's disease. Neurology,
Neurology, 49,
49, 786^794.
301^309.
Cahill, L. & McGaugh, J. L. (1995) A novel McKhann, G., Drachman, D., Folstein, M., et al
_ (1997b) Emotional perception
, _ & Squire, L. R. (1997b (1984) Clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease: report
demonstration of enhanced memory associated with
and memory in amnesia. Neuropsychology,
Neuropsychology, 11,
11, 104^113. of the NINCDS-ADRDA Work Group under the
emotional arousal. Consciousness and Cognition,
Cognition, 4,
410^421. auspices of Department of Health and Human Services
_ , Ely, T. D., Grafton, S. T., et al (1999) Amygdala
Task Force on Alzheimer's Disease. Neurology,
Neurology, 34,
34,
& _ (1998) Mechanism of emotional arousal and activity related to enhanced memory for pleasant and
_ 939^944.
lasting declarative memory. Trends in Neurosciences,
Neurosciences, 21,
21, aversive stimuli. Nature Neuroscience,
Neuroscience, 2, 289^293.
294^299. Mohs, R. C., Rosen, W. G. & Davis, K. L. (1983) The
Rosen,W.
Haroutunian,V., Perl, D. P., Purohit, D. P., et al (1998) Alzheimer's Disease Assessment Scale; an instrument
_ , Prins, B.,Weber, M., et al (1994) b-Adrenergic Regional distribution of neuritic plaques in the for assessing treatment efficacy. Psychopharmacology
activation and memory for emotional events. Nature,
Nature, nondemented elderly and subjects with very mild Bulletin,
Bulletin, 19,
19, 448^450.
371,
371, 702^704. Alzheimer disease. Archives of Neurology,
Neurology, 55,
55, 1185^1191.
Mori, E., Ikeda, M., Hirono, N., et al (1999)
_ , Haier, R. J., Fallon, J., et al (1996) Amygdala Heuer, F. & Reisberg, D. (1990) Vivid memories of Amygdalar volume and emotional memory in
activity at encoding correlated with long-term, free emotional events: the accuracy of remembered Alzheimer's disease. American Journal of Psychiatry,
Psychiatry, 156,
156,
recall of emotional information. Proceedings of the minutiae. Memory & Cognition,
Cognition, 18,
18, 496^506. 216^222.
347