Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT: The use of thermo-active geo-structures has been recognised to be a sustainable engineering
solution that can reduce carbon emissions from civil infrastructure. Physical modelling in a geotechnical cen-
trifuge has been increasingly used to study the behaviour of this kind of geo-structures and their interaction
with the surrounding soil under cyclic heating/cooling loads. Previous studies have been limited by the choice
of materials used to model thermo-active geo-structures (such as aluminium and conventional concrete), due
to inaccurate scaling of the thermal properties and the inability to capture the quasi-brittleness and strength
properties of reinforced concrete (RC) due to improper scaling of aggregate sizes. The paper aims to develop a
new thermally-enhanced plaster-based model concrete which can realistically reproduce both the thermal and
mechanical properties that are representative of concrete at prototype scale. The new model concrete, combined
with steel wire reinforcement (i.e. geometrically scaled reinforcing bars and stirrups), was then used to create
1:20 scaled RC thermo-active piles. Effects of temperature on their thermomechanical behaviour, including the
coefficient of thermal expansion, moment capacity and flexural stiffness, were investigated. The suitability of
using the newly-developed RC thermo-active piles for future centrifuge testing is discussed.
37
which Stewart and McCartney (2014) adopted in their
centrifuge tests, the prototype diameter of the gravel
was 144 mm, which was 7 times larger than the diam-
eter of coarse aggregates in prototype concrete. This
size effect would potentially lead to an over-strength
of RC (Litle and Paparoni, 1966, Belgin and Sener,
2008). This modelling method is thus limited to rela-
tively low scaling factors (or g-level) to minimise any
over-strength of RC.
In order to more realistically capture the nonlin-
ear quasi-brittleness feature and failure mechanisms
of concrete in centrifuge at higher scaling factors,
Knappett et al. (2011) developed model concretes
using plaster-based mortars. In the mortar mix, fine sil-
ica sand was used to geometrically scale the aggregate Figure 1. Particle-size distribution of silica sand and copper
found in concrete. Such model concrete was shown to powder.
have representative mechanical strengths, in terms of
unconfined compressive strength and modulus of rup- distribution of the silica sand and copper powder were
ture. The model concrete has been successfully used measured using a laser diffraction analyser. The results
for modelling various engineering structures such as are compared in Fig. 1. It can be seen that both the sand
piles (Al-Defae and Knappett, 2014) and bridge piers and copper powder were uniformly graded, and that the
(Loli et al., 2014) in the centrifuge where simultane- size of copper powder was finer than that of the sand.
ous modelling of stiffness and strength are crucial.
For modelling thermo-active RC geo-structures, this
type of model concrete requires further modification 2.2 Thermomechanical properties of the new
to ensure correct scaling of the thermomechanical model concrete
properties.
In order to investigate the effects of the copper pow-
This study aims to develop a new type of model
der content on the thermal conductivity of the model
concrete that can realistically scale the mechanical
concrete, a series of laboratory testing was carried out
and thermal properties of real concrete for future
using a hot-box apparatus developed by Jones et al.
centrifuge testing of concrete energy geo-structures
(2007). It is an apparatus that can create a temperature
for larger scaling factors. An application of the new
gradient across a slab-shaped specimen (45 mm width,
model concrete to produce RC thermo-active piles
150 mm long and 150 mm height) and also can mea-
is presented. Temperature effects on thermomechan-
sure the corresponding heat flux. At the steady state,
ical properties, including the coefficient of thermal
the thermal conductivity of the specimen can be deter-
expansion, moment capacity and flexural stiffness, of
mined by dividing the heat flux by the temperature
a model pile were tested. By comparing the model and
gradient, according to Fourier’s law.
prototype properties, the suitability of testing this type
Model concrete mixed with five different percent-
of new RC model pile in centrifuge is discussed.
ages of copper powder (by volume), 0%, 1.5%, 3%,
6% and 12% were tested. The test results depicted in
Fig. 2 show that the thermal conductivity of the model
2 NEW MODEL CONCRETE
concrete originally designed by Knappett et al. (2011)
was 0.4 W/(m·K), which was lower than the typical
2.1 Constituents of the model concrete
range of concrete (i.e., 0.9 to 1.1 W/(m·K); Kanbur
The new model concrete developed in this study et al. (2013)). When copper powder was added, there
is based on the design previously proposed by was almost a linear increase in the thermal conductiv-
Knappett et al. (2011). The original design consisted of ity with the amount of copper added. This shows that
a mixture of β-form surgical plaster (manufactured by the addition of copper powder was effective to enhance
Saint Gobain), water and fine silica sand (Congleton the thermal properties of the model concrete. In par-
HST95). The sand was used to geometrically scale and ticular, 6% and 12% copper powder contents appeared
approximate the size of aggregates found in concrete. to match the prototype range reasonably well.
Knappett et al. (2011) suggested that a water/plaster Although adding copper powder could significantly
(W/P) ratio of 0.9:1 and a sand/plaster (S/P) ratio of improve the thermal properties of the new model con-
1:1 would result in a model concrete that can realisti- crete, one concern is any detrimental effects of such
cally mimic the mechanical properties of concrete in addition on the mechanical properties. For this pur-
prototype. pose, a series of four-point bending (FPB) tests were
In order to properly scale and mimic the thermal conducted to measure the modulus of rupture (fr ) of
properties of prototype concrete, a new constituent, prismatic specimens (25 × 25 × 250 mm) when differ-
copper powder (manufactured by Phoenix Scientific), ent percentages of copper powder were added to the
was added to the design mix to enhance the thermal model concrete. The testing procedures outlined by
conductivity of the model concrete. The particle-size Knappett et al. (2011) were adopted.
38
due to the rapid evolution of the pore structure during
the hydration process (Song et al., 2009).
Fig. 4(c) shows the model concrete mix at × 300
where both the sand and copper particles are visible.
There was a gap between the irregular-shaped sand
particles and plaster, hence creating some weakened
interfaces. However, such gapping was not found for
the copper particles. It must be pointed out that no
chemical bonding was formed along the plaster, sand
and copper particles after the hydration process. These
constituents were bonded physically through weak
inter-particle van der Waal force. Such physical bond
is an important feature of the model concrete to real-
istically mimic the non-linear quasi-brittleness nature
Figure 2. Effects of copper powder content on thermal con- of concrete in prototype, which cannot be captured
ductivity of model concrete. Error bars represent standard by existing elastic model piles made of aluminium,
errors (n = 3). and which avoids the potential over-strength of using
cement as the binder.
39
Figure 5. Cross-section and reinforcement details of a 1:20
model RC thermo-active pile.
40
was allowed to cure for 28 days in a room maintained
at an ambient temperature of around 20◦ C.
In order to heat and cool the model pile, a heating
system (Julabo Ltd; Model F12) that can control and
maintain constant water temperature between 1 and
99◦ C was connected to the silicon pipes. Change in
pile temperature was monitored by the three thermo-
couples embedded in the model pile.
41
Table 1. Summary of the CTE test.
A 1 0 15.7
B 1 6 16.5
2 15.3
C 1 6 16.0
2 15.5
42
the properties of a prototype thermo-active pile. At Al-Defae, A. H. & Knappett, J. A. 2014. Centrifuge Mod-
6% copper powder content, the effects of temper- eling of the Seismic Performance of Pile-Reinforced
ature on the mechanical properties, including both Slopes. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental
Mult and EI may be practically negligible (see Fig. Engineering, 140.
Balendran, R., Zhou, F., Nadeem, A. & Leung, A. 2002.
8). This is consistent with the BS EN 1992-1-2:2004 Influence of steel fibres on strength and ductility of nor-
Clauses 3.2.2 and 3.2.3, which respectively state that mal and lightweight high strength concrete. Building and
any temperature effects on the mechanical properties environment, 37, 1361–1367.
of concrete and steel are negligible when the tempera- Belgin, C. M. & Sener, S. 2008. Size effect on failure
ture is below 100◦ C.A study reported by Li and Purkiss of overreinforced concrete beams. Engineering Fracture
(2005) also shows that theYoung’s modulus of concrete Mechanics, 75, 2308–2319.
is reasonably constant for temperatures between 20 Bourne-Webb, P. J.,Amatya, B., Soga, K.,Amis, T., Davidson,
and 60◦ C. C. & Payne, P. 2009. Energy pile test at Lambeth College,
London: geotechnical and thermodynamic aspects of pile
response to heat cycles. Geotechnique, 59, 237–248.
6 CONCLUSION Brandling, H. 2006. Energy foundations and other thermo-
active ground structures. Geotechnique, 56, 81–122.
A new type of model concrete that is highly suitable British Standards Institution. 2004. Eurocode 2: Design of
Concrete Structures. London, BSI.
for realistically modelling thermo-active energy geo- BS EN 1992-1-2:2004: Eurocode 2: Design of concrete struc-
structures in centrifuge testing is developed. The new tures. Part 1.2: General rules – Structural fire design.
model concrete is a mixture of plaster, silica sand, British Standards Institution, London, 2004.
water and copper powder, which results in a material Cecinato, F. & Loveridge, F. A. 2015. Influences on the ther-
that has both mechanical and thermal properties scaled mal efficiency of energy piles. Energy, 82, 1021–1033.
simultaneously. The test results showed that adding 6% Choi, J. H., & Chen, R. H. L. 2005. Design of continu-
or 12% copper powder content to the new model con- ously reinforced concrete pavements using glass fiber
crete could increase the thermal conductivity to a value reinforced polymer rebars. Publication No. FHWA-HRT-
close to those found in prototype concrete. Such an 05-081. Washington, D.C.
Davis, J. R. 2001. Copper and copper alloys, ASM interna-
addition was shown not to cause significant changes tional.
in modulus of rupture. Goode III, J. & McCartney, J. 2015. Centrifuge modeling
This study also demonstrated an application of this of end-restraint effects in energy foundations. Journal of
type of new model concrete to create 1:20 model rein- Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE,
forced concrete (RC) thermo-active piles. The effects DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)GT.1943-5606.0001333.
of copper powder content (ranging from 0% to 12%) Hayward, T., Lees, A., Powrie, W., Richards, D. & Smethurst,
on the thermomechanical behaviour of the model RC J. 2000. Centrifuge modelling of a cutting slope stabilised
pile were quantified. It was found that copper powder by discrete piles, Transport Research Laboratory.
content of 6% is an optimum amount that would pro- Huurman, M. & Pronk, A. 2009. Theoretical analysis of the 4
point bending test.AdvancedTesting and Characterization
vide the model pile with a highly representative value of Bituminous Materials, A. Loizos, MN Partl, T. Scarpas,
of the coefficient of thermal expansion as compared and IL Al-Qadi, eds., CRC Press, Boca Raton, 749–759.
to prototype. At this percentage of addition, effects of Hyer, M. W. 2009. Stress analysis of fiber-reinforced
pile temperature between 20 and 50◦ C on pile bending composite materials, DEStech Publications, Inc.
moment capacity and flexural stiffness are practically Johnson, W. H. & Parsons, W. H. 1944. Thermal expansion
negligible. This correctly models the thermomechani- of concrete aggregate materials, US Government Printing
cal behaviour of prototype RC piles. Such a model RC Office.
thermo-active pile was also capable of mimicking the Jones, M. R., Zheng, L., McCarthy, A., Dhir, R. K., &
nonlinear quasi-brittle nature of real concrete, which is Yerramala A. 2007. Increasing the use of foamed concrete
incorporating recycled and secondary aggregates. WRAP
a key feature that is not achievable using elastic model Project Report:AGG79-001.
piles. Kanbur, B. B., Atayilmaz, S. O., Demir, H., Koca, A. &
Gemici, Z. 2013. Investigating the thermal conductivity
of different concrete and reinforced concrete models with
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
numerical and experimental methods. Recent Advances in
Mechanical Engineering Applications, Recent Advances
The authors would like to acknowledge the stu- in Mechanical Engineering Series, 95–101.
dentships and the research cost supported by the Karihaloo, B. L. & Huang, X. 1991. Tensile response of
Energy Technology Partnership (ETP), Scottish Road quasi-brittle materials. Pure and Applied Geophysics, 137,
Research Board (SRRB) from Transport Scotland and 461–487.
the EPSRC Doctoral Training Award. Kell, G. S. 1975. Density, thermal expansivity, and com-
pressibility of liquid water from 0. deg. to 150. deg..
Correlations and tables for atmospheric pressure and satu-
REFERENCES ration reviewed and expressed on 1968 temperature scale.
Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data, 20, 97–105.
American Association of State Highway and Transporta- Laloui, L., Nuth, M. & Vulliet, L. 2006. Experimental
tion Officials 2007. Provisional Test Method for the and numerical investigations of the behaviour of a heat
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion of Hydraulic Cement exchanger pile. International Journal for Numerical and
Concrete. Washington DC, AASHTO. Analytical Methods in Geomechanics, 30, 763–781.
43
Lee, H.-Y., Lee, S.-H., Kim, J.-B. & Lee, J.-H. 2007. Creep– pile performance in saturated sand. Canadian Geotechni-
fatigue damage for a structure with dissimilar metal welds cal Journal, 52, 1045–1057.
of modified 9Cr–1Mo steel and 316L stainless steel. Rashid, M. & Mansur, M. 2005. Reinforced high-strength
International Journal of Fatigue, 29, 1868–1879. concrete beams in flexure. ACI Structural Journal, 102,
Li, L.Y. & Purkiss, J. 2005. Stress–strain constitutive equa- 462–471.
tions of concrete material at elevated temperatures. Fire Rotta Loria, A. F., Gunawan, A., Shi, C., Laloui, L., &
Safety Journal, 40(7), 669–686. Ng, C. W. W. 2015. Numerical modelling of energy piles
Litle, A. W. & Paparoni, M. 1966. Size Effect in Small- in saturated sand subjected to thermo-mechanical loads.
Scale Models of Reinforced Concrete Beams. Journal Geomechanics for Energy and the Environment, 1, 1–15.
Proceedings, 63. Song, K.-M., Mitchell, J. & Gladden, L. F. 2009. Observ-
Loli, M., Knappett, J. A., Brown, M. J., Anastasopou- ing microstructural evolution during plaster hydration.
los, I. & Gazetas, G. 2014. Centrifuge modeling of Diffusion Fundamentals, 10, 22.1–22.3.
rocking-isolated inelastic RC bridge piers. Earthquake Stewart, M. A. & McCartney, J. S. 2014. Centrifuge Modeling
Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 43, 2341–2359. of Soil-Structure Interaction in Energy Foundations. Jour-
Loveridge, F.A. & Powrie, W., 2013, April. Pile heat exchang- nal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering,
ers: thermal behaviour and interactions. Proceedings of ASCE, 140.
the Institute of Civil Engineers: Geotechnical Engineering Vasiliev, L. 2008. Micro and miniature heat pipes–Electronic
(Vol. 166, No. 2, pp. 178–196). component coolers. Applied Thermal Engineering, 28,
Murphy, K. D. & McCartney, J. S. 2015. Seasonal Response of 266–273.
Energy Foundations During Building Operation. Geotech- Yavari, N., Tang, A. M., Pereira, J.-M. & Hassen, G. 2014.
nical and Geological Engineering, 33, 343–356. A simple method for numerical modelling of energy
Ng, C. W. W., Shi C., Gunawan, A., Laloui, L. & Liu, H. L. pile’s mechanical behaviour. Geotechnique Letters, 4,
2015. Centrifuge modelling of heating effects on energy 119–124.
44