Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Paper Chapter 2
Project Paper Chapter 2
2.0 Introduction
The internal characteristics of the organization make up critical sources for success
(Barney, 1991). Increasing attention has been paid to identifying what characteristics are vital
to organizational success and how they exert their influence on organizational outcomes.
Internal organizational context focuses on broad and relatively stable categories of
organizational characteristics such as structure, culture, and power and political
characteristics (Pettigrew, 1979). They constitute an environment where organizational
activities take place. There has been a large volume of studies that examine how the fit
between organizational context and organizational strategy explains variances in
organizational performance (Daft,1995; Robbins, 1990).
Figure 2.1 Structure follows strategy, and culture follows structure (Maria and Peter, 2017)
2.1 Projects and Organizational Strategy
Internal stakeholders are a vital component in any stakeholder analysis and their
impact is usually felt in relatively positive ways. External stakeholder groups operate in
manners that are quite challenging or even hostile to project development. Intervenor groups
defined as groups external to the project but possessing the power to effectively intervene and
disrupt the project’s development.
Among the set of project stakeholders that project managers must consider are:
Internal
Top management
Accounting
Other functional mangers
Project team members
External
Clients
Competitors
Suppliers
Environmental, political, consumer, and other intervenor groups
The special nature of the construction projects makes the stakeholder management in this
sector take into account these special factors, such as types of contracts or the nature of the
project object. The relationships between different process agents in the building construction
sector can be regulated or limited by contracts, for example between the client and the
builder. The contractual deposits or the laws about contacts with the administration limit the
strategic use of stakeholder management. For example, the obligation to finish a job within a
limited time, with budgetary targets attached, makes the stakeholders management work
effective within a pressured environment. (Carlos, 2013)
This activity goes beyond the sentence of a construction project. The users of the
facilities, clients, etc, can enjoy their interests after the building construction phase, so that
the stakeholders management extends throughout the construction lifecycle. In order to
achieve a more successful project result, the project manager should be skillful in the
management of the different stakeholders during the whole process of the project, from the
beginning until after the building of it. The regular communication with the different
stakeholders makes this inform their management of diverse stakes. (Carlos, 2013)
Users of a building
Funders
Neighbours
Regulatory bodies
General public
Figure 2.3 Contracting parties and stakeholders of a construction project. (Ng P. L., 2017)
A project deals with an investment for both external and internal clients. Client does
not in every case refer to the entire customer organization. A client firm consists of several
internal interest groups in which they have different agendas. The client for Penang Second
Bridge project is the government of Malaysia because this bridge is built to solve the
congestion problem on the first Penang bridge. Government of Malaysia hopes to ease the
congestion on the first Penang bridge by building the Penang Second Bridge as an alternative
to travel back and forth from mainland and island. Competitors can be an important
stakeholder element because they are affected by the successful implementation of a project.
For Penang Second Bridge project, there is no competitor for JKSB because JKSB is the
concessionaire appointed by government of Malaysia to design, construct, manage, operate,
and maintain the bridge. While for construction side, the competitor would be Senai Desaru
Expressway Berhad with a main contractor Ranhill Engineers & Constructors Sdn. Bhd.
which responsible for construction of Sungai Johor Bridge that began in 2005 and completed
by 2008. (Wikipedia, 2020).
Suppliers are any group that provides the raw materials or other resources the project
team needs in order to complete the project. Malaysian Industrial Geotechnical Sdn. Bhd. was
the supplier for CHEC Construction Sdn. Bhd. in supplying BSP Hammer and related
products as shown in Figure 2.4 and 2.5 below for Penang Second Bridge project. (MIG,
n.d.). PERI Formwork Malaysia Sdn. Bhd. is another supplier for CHEC Construction Sdn.
Bhd. in supplying PERI systems for construction of pylons and piers as shown in Figure 2.6
below. (PERI, n.d.). Top management is the body that authorizes the development of the
project through giving initial “go” decision, sanctions additional resource transfers as they are
needed by the project team, and supports and protects project managers and their teams from
other organizational pressures. The top management for Penang Second Bridge project is
Malaysian Highway Authority which it has the authority to do decision and sanctions
additional resource transfers.
Accountants support and actively monitor project budgets and maintaining cost
efficiency of the project teams. The accountant in Penang Second Bridge project is Ministry
of Finance as Ministry of Finance deal a loan of RM2.7 billion with China and also
responsible in the budgeting of different package in construction of this project. (Mazwin,
2007). Project team members has a tremendous stake in the project’s outcome. For Penang
Second Bridge project, there are a lot of team members involved as this is a big project
initiated by government of Malaysia. To give a few examples, LLOYD’S Register of
Shipping (M) Bhd. is the ISO Accreditation, FANLI Marine and Consulting Sdn. Bhd. is the
fisheries impact assessment consultant, CHEC Construction Sdn. Bhd. and UEM Builders
Bhd. are the design and build contract for package 1 and package 2 respectively and Cergas
Murni Sdn. Bhd. is the contractor for package 3A. (Ismail, 2011).
Next, identify the goals of the principal actors. A project manager should attempt to
paint an accurate portrait of stakeholder concerns. Project teams must look for hidden
agendas in goal assessment. It is common for departments and stakeholder groups to exert a
set of overt goals that are relevant, but often illusionary. Organizations must consider what
they do well and project team must understand their own capabilities and capacities. Not
everyone has the contacts to upper management that may be necessary for ensuring a steady
flow of support and resources. If you realistically determine that political acumen is not your
suit, then the solution may be to find someone who has these skills to help you.
We must seek to define problems both in terms of our own perspective and in
consideration of the valid concerns of the other party. The key to developing and maintaining
strong stakeholder relationships lies in recognizing that different parties can have very
different but equally legitimate perspectives on a problem. For Penang Second Bridge
project, one of the issues identified is hairline cracks appeared in all Package 1 piers due to
Package 2 SBG launching works and eccentricity of launching gantry legs. Package 1 pier
design consider no eccentricity. Next, developing solutions means precisely that creating an
action plan to address, as much as possible, the needs of the various stakeholder groups in
relation to the other stakeholder groups. It is necessary that we do our political homework
prior to developing solutions. So, the solution for the issue mentioned is JKSB decided to
adopt High Damping Rubber Bearings in lieu of Mechanical Pot Bearings for Package 2 to
cater for the 2500 years period earthquake with ‘no collapse’ criteria for Package 1 piles.
Implementing the solutions implies acknowledging that the project manager and team
are operating under imperfect information. In testing and refining solutions, the project
manager and team should realize that solution implementation is an iterative process. An
alternative, simplified stakeholder management process consists of planning, organizing,
directing, motivating, and controlling the resources necessary to deal with the various internal
and external stakeholder groups. The various stakeholder management functions are
interlocked and repetitive, this stakeholder management process is really best understood as a
cycle. For Penang Second Bridge project, Independent Checking Engineer (ICE) site audit
will be conducted once every 2 months to ensure the quality of the construction meets the
international standard specifications. As the environment changes or as the project enters a
new stage of its life cycle, you may be required to cycle through the stakeholder management
model again to verify that your old management strategies are still effective.
Second is product, which is grouping people working on similar product lines into
departments, third is geography, which is grouping people within similar geographical
regions or physical locations into department and fourth is project, which is grouping people
involved in the same project into a department. For the last point, organizational structure
includes the design of systems to ensure effective communication, coordination, and
integration of effort across departments. This refers to the supporting mechanisms the firm
relies on to reinforce and promote its structure. For Penang Second Bridge project, an
effective communication is very important as this is a huge project that involved many team
members, miscommunication will lead to the delay in the construction and may be put the
safety of their workers on risk.
19. Madison H, Jayne T, The Purpose of Mission and Vision Statements in Strategic
Planning. (2019, March 25). Retrieved from https://smallbusiness.chron.com/purpose-
mission-vision-statements-strategic-planning-13161.html
20. Jambatan Kedua Sdn. Bhd. (2018). Company Vision and Mission. Retrieved from
https://www.jambatankedua.com.my/mission-vision
21. Shafii, M., & De Smedt, F. (2009, May 17–21). Multi-criteria decision-making under
uncertainty in rainfall-runoff calibration: A fuzzy compromise programming approach
based on alpha level sets. In World Environmental and Water Resources Congress
2009, Kansas City, MI, USA.
22. Mohammadreza Yadollahi, Reza Ansari, Muhd Zaimi Abd Majid & Chong Heap Yih.
(2015). A multi-criteria analysis for bridge sustainability assessment: a case study of
Penang Second Bridge, Malaysia, Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 11:5, 638-
654, DOI: 10.1080/15732479.2014.893002
23. Team Clarizen. (2018). What Are the Objectives of Project Management? Retrieved
from https://www.clarizen.com/objectives-of-project-management/
24. Ismail, b. M. T. (2011). The Second Penang Bridge: Planning, Design, and
Construction [PowerPoint Slides]. Retrieved from
https://www.scribd.com/document/127499612/the-second-penang-bridge
25. Audrey Dermawan. (2018). Four years on, Second Penang Bridge has yet to ease
traffic congestion. New Straits Times. Retrieved from
https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2018/08/398643/four-years-second-penang-
bridge-has-yet-ease-traffic-congestion
26. Vogwell, D. (2003). Stakeholder management. Paper presented at PMI® Global
Congress 2003—EMEA, The Hague, South Holland, The Netherlands. Newtown
Square, PA: Project Management Institute.
27. Carlos J. P. (2013). Stakeholder Management in the Construction Sector. Salinero
Pampliega Project Management. Retrieved from
http://salineropampliega.com/2013/10/stakeholder-management-in-construction.html
28. Ng, P.L. & Banaitis, Audrius. (2017). Construction mediation and its hybridization:
the case of the Hong Kong construction industry. Organization, Technology and
Management in Construction: An International Journal. 9. 1528-1536. 10.1515/otmcj-
2016-0015.
29. Wikipedia. (2020). Sungai Johor Bridge. Retrieved from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sungai_Johor_Bridge
30. Malaysian Industrial Geotechnical Sdn. Bhd. (MIG). (n.d.). Penang Second Bridge.
Retrieved from http://mig-asia.com/project/penang-second-bridge/
31. PERI Formwork Malaysia Sdn. Bhd. (n.d.). Penang Second Crossing Bridge.
Retrieved from https://www.perimalaysia.com/projects/civil-
engineering/penangsecondcrossingbridge.html
32. Mazwin N. A. (2007). Penang Bridge loan deal signed. TheStar. Retrieved from
https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2007/07/14/penang-bridge-loan-deal-signed
33. Jan B. (2019). Forms of Organizational Structure. azcentral. Retrieved from
https://yourbusiness.azcentral.com/forms-organizational-structure-3002.html
34. Raksha T. (n.d.). Project Organisation: Definition, Merits and Limitations. Retrieved
from http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/business/project-organisation-definition-
merits-and-limitations/69800
35. ITM Platform. (2016). Choose the right type of PMO for your business model.
Retrieved from https://www.itmplatform.com/en/blog/choose-the-right-type-of-pmo-
for-your-business-model/
36. Needle, David (2004). Business in Context: An Introduction to Business and Its
Environment.
37. Schrodt, P (2002). “The relationship between organizational identification and
organizational culture: Employee perceptions of culture and identification in a retail
sales organization”. Communication Studies 53: 189–202.
38. Florida Tech. (n.d.). The Importance of Organizational Culture to Project
Management. Retrieved from https://www.floridatechonline.com/blog/business/the-
importance-of-organizational-culture-to-project-management/