Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Knowledge management and knowledge assets have gained much prominence in recent years and are said to improve
organizational performance. However, the effects of knowledge management practices on organizational performance are
not well known, particularly with respect to the newly established universities in the East African region. The aim of
this study was to investigate the effects of knowledge management practices on organizational performance at selected
campuses of Kisii University in the South-western part of Kenya. The knowledge management practices identified were
knowledge capture and acquisition, knowledge sharing, and knowledge management policies and strategies. The study
established that knowledge management practices have a strong and positive effect on organizational performance.
Hoarding of knowledge by members of staff was the major knowledge management challenge identified. Recommendations
and areas for further studies are indicated.
Keywords: Knowledge Management, Organizational Performance, Kisii University, Higher Learning Institutions, Kenya
what we now call “knowledge management”, for instance Wamundila28, identified knowledge management
the creation, collection, preservation and dissemination practices at University of Zambia which included
of knowledge. knowledge transfer practices, knowledge acquisition
In Kenya, higher education has largely been in the practices and knowledge retention practices. However,
public sector since independence, but due to liberalization there is a dearth of literature on the effects of knowledge
of the education sector, there has been an increase in the management practices on organizational performance
number of higher education institutions in the country in higher education institutions. The research problem
in the past decade. Currently, there are twenty two (22) was to investigate the effects of knowledge management
public universities and nine (9) constituent colleges. practices on organizational performance at higher
There are also fourteen (14) chartered private universities education institutions in Kenya. For the purpose of this
and twelve private universities with letters of interim study, the researcher conducted a case study of Kisii
authority. This has resulted in increased competition that University.
needs the institutions to prepare themselves better to meet
challenges confronting them. This has made university
management to think of ways to achieve success in the face
4. Objectives of the Study
of dwindling resources, especially from the Government. The main aim of the study was to investigate the effects
For the institutions to gain competitive advantage, attract of knowledge management practices on organizational
and retain high quality scholarsinnovative enough to performance at Kisii University.
develop high standard programs, universities need The specific objectives of the study were:
effective knowledge management initiatives and practices. • To establish the effect of knowledge capture and
Kidwell et al (2000) explains that knowledge management acquisition practices on organizational performance
promises better decision making capabilities, improve at Kisii University,
academic services and reduce costs. Therefore, universities • To determine the effect of knowledge sharing
are adopting knowledge management practices that practices on organizational performance at Kisii
tackle organizational development, retrenchment, University, and
amalgamation, and internal reorganization. Little research • To determine the effect of knowledge management
has been done on the effects of knowledge management policies and strategies on organizational performance
practices on organizational performance especially in at Kisii University.
higher education institutions in Kenya. This prompted
the researcher to investigate the effects of knowledge
management practices on organizational performance at 5. Literature Review on
Kisii University. Knowledge Management
Kisii University was founded in 1965 as a primary
teacher training college. In 1983, it was upgraded to a Newman16 states that knowledge management promotes
Secondary school Teacher’s College to offer Diploma an integrated approach to identifying, capturing,
Programmes. The Government of Kenya mandated retrieving, sharing, and evaluating an enterprises
Egerton University to take over the college as its campus information asset. These information assets may include
in 1994. On 23rd August 2007, Kisii University College was databases, documents, policies, procedures, as well as
established through a Government Legal Notice No. 163 the un-captured tacit expertise and experience stored in
of 2007 as a Constituent College of Egerton University individuals’ heads.
(Kisii University College 2009). On 6th February 2013,
Kisii University was awarded a charter to become the 13th 6. Knowledge Management in
public university in Kenya11.
Higher Education Institutions
3. Statement of the Problem Higher education is faced with continuous need for
improvement in efficiency, knowledge management,
How do knowledge management practices affect and redefinition of role and function because of external
organizational performance in higher education forces exerted by market competition, virtualization and
institutions, specifically in the case of KSU? Reviewed internalization and financial cuts5. To survive universities
literature reveals a number of knowledge management must not only acknowledge the significance thereof
practices in higher education institutions. For instance but also implement good knowledge management
practices strategically5,21. The improper management to knowledge management practices is a critical success
of data, information and knowledge available in the factor.
universities hinder efficient sharing and reuse to
generate new knowledge21. However when knowledge
is well managed, researchers observe benefits such as,
9. Challenges facing HEIs in
more informed decision making, avoiding wasteful Managing Knowledge
duplication of resources, avoiding loss of commercial
opportunity and loss of knowledge when staff exits, Peyman et al20 conducted a research to determine the
increasing accessibility to the organizations recorded factors that lead to failure of knowledge management
internal knowledge, improving information literacy systems. Peyman focused on the following factors;
of researchers, among others flow into the university focusing KM efforts only within organizational
system22,25,28 (Kidwell et al, 2000). boundaries, failure to understand and connect KM into
individuals daily work activities, creation of repositories
without addressing the need to manage content,
7. Knowledge Capture and resistance towards change, organizational culture, lack of
Acquisition Practices familiarity of top management with dimensions of KM
and its requirements and failure to align KM efforts with
Knowledge acquisition is the process of extracting, organizations strategic objectives. Ambrosio (2000) as
structuring and organizing knowledge from human cited in Peyman et al20 says that the most common
experts so that it can be captured and transferred into error in implementing knowledge management system
machine readable form (Liou 1990 as cited in Wamundila28) is failing to coordinate efforts between information
whereas knowledge capture is organizational ability of technology and human resources.
ensuring that knowledge available in the organization is
stored for future reference in either databases or manuals.
Organisational practices that facilitate capture and 10. Review of Previous Studies
acquisition of knowledge include recruitment according
It is acknowledged that knowledge management
to Edwards and Rees (2006), Training4, brainstorming
processes4, intellectual capital, culture and strategy
(Liou 1990 as cited in Wamundila28), expert system and
are key factors in knowledge management while to
mentoring. Several Scholars have written on strategies
Darroch6 knowledge creation and acquisition, knowledge
that enable knowledge sharing practices7 (Ismail and
dissemination and responsiveness to knowledge are
Chua 2005, Hamid (2008), Hawamdeh 2005). Job rotation
the main components of knowledge management
and communities of practices that connect professionals
practice. Thomas et al26 suggests four critical stages
encourage knowledge sharing and transfer on a large
of knowledge management of a firm’s knowledge as
scale according to Wamundila28; creation of knowledge
being knowledge creation and acquisition, knowledge
repository8 internet and web technologies, organisation
transfer, interpretation of the knowledge to serve
culture1 are just a few of several sharing channels.
organizational goals and application of knowledge to
achieve organizational goals. This study will focus on
8. Knowledge Management knowledge capture and acquisition, knowledge sharing
and knowledge management policies and strategies.
Policies and Strategies At the University of Zambia, knowledge acquisition
Ruschcliffe Borough council (2005) and New Jersey State occurred through recruitment, training and development
University (1995) suggest that organisations need a set of and shared through departmental meetings, informal
guiding principles intended to influence decisions and and formal workshops, knowledge exchange seminars,
actions that reflect on agreed practice (policy) and a well- summary reports, brainstorming, mentoring, notice
designed approach for implementing it (strategy) s (cited boards, emails and face to face interactions28.
in Wamundila28). Knowledge management policies and Several studies have established a positive correlation
strategies have been adopted by University of Edinburgh between knowledge management and organisation
and Kings College London (Kings College London 2005) performance. Zahidul et al29 found that knowledge
to enhance fulfilment of university mission, support management practices mediated the relationship between
teaching, administration and sharing of knowledge, e.g., organisational context and effectiveness among selected
Zahidul et al29 adds that top management commitment Malaysian Multinational companies while 222 Spanish
firms in biotechnology and telecommunication industries inconsistent observations indicate that KM’s effects on
that implemented KM performed better in terms of firm performance are not yet well understood and still
profitability, growth, efficiency, stakeholder satisfaction, open for investigation24. None of these studies focused
and competitive position in a study conducted by Marques on the effect of knowledge management practices
and Simon (2006). Lyles and Salk14, Asli et al2, Ngah and on organizational performance in higher education
Razak17, Waheed et al27, all found similar effects with the institutions. The present case study investigated the effects
previous researcher cited here. of knowledge management practices on organizational
Lee13 conducted a study on the impact of knowledge performance at Kisii University. Data were collected
management practices in improving students learning through interview schedules and questionnaire whereas
outcome in Singapore polytechnic and Wamundila28 the other studies were surveys on the effects of knowledge
focused on the identification of knowledge management management practices on organizational performance.
practices at University of Zambia with the main purpose
of developing a knowledge retention framework. The
research only studied knowledge retention, transfer and
11. Conceptual Framework
acquisition practices leaving out several other knowledge The conceptual framework is depicted in Figure 1. This
management practices. framework was used in this study for analyzing the effects
However, studies have also shown contradictory of knowledge management practices on organizational
results pointing out that KM fail to result in improved performance. The conceptual framework is a
task outcomes in organizations23. Mills and Smith15 diagrammatic representation of how the constructs of the
studied the impact of knowledge management resources independent variable (namely, Knowledge Management)
on organizational performance and found that knowledge affect the construct of the dependent variable (namely,
resources for instance structure and acquisition were organizational performance from local ranking).
directly related to organizational performance while other Independent Variables Intervening variables Dependent
knowledge resources such as culture and technology variable
were not related to organizational performance. These
policies on meetings, employee training, and workshops the intercept coefficient this represents the average value
were high while job rotation, mentoring and communities of the benchmark/base variable job rotation. It shows
of practice received a low positive response of less than the average influence of job rotation on organizational
50%. These policies were not located in a central place for performance. βi denotes the differential intercept
employees to access as indicated by Figure 3. coefficients; they show how much the value that receives a
1 or Yes differs from the intercept coefficient (α). Effect of
Does your department have a KM policy
job rotation has been treated as the benchmark category
for this analysis.
100
88.37%
Table 6. Correlation matrix
80 knowledge management
policies and strategies
Percentage
60
Y
40
Y 1
D1 0.79
20
D2 0.83
11.63%
0
D3 0.72
Yes No D4 0.82
KM Policy or Strategy
D5 0.76
Figure 2. Availability of a KM Policy or Strategy. Source: Research Data
Source: Primary data Though other factors might influence by 19%
(R=0.90), there is a strong positive correlation between
All operational policies are located in a central place knowledge management policy and Kisii University
performance since the correlation coefficient of the tested
60 variables (employee training, mentoring, workshops,
50
54.07% employee groups and meetings) is positive and above 0.50
45.93% explainable at 81% (R2=0.81) as indicated in the model
40 output Table 7.
Percentage
by percentage were that the university should Organize policies and strategies on organizational performance
workshops on available policies to increase awareness at Kisii University. Though explicit knowledge
(23.7%), improve terms of service for employees (9.3%), Policies were non-existent, related policies and
develop policies that favour employees at all levels strategies at KSU included recruitment policy,
(29.07%), shorten policy development time (27%), source training policy, ICT policy, and a mentoring policy.
for financial partners to support KM programs (8.72%), Analysis (R= 0.90 and R2= 0.81) prooved that a strong
develop policies that are more understandable (30.23%), and positive relationship exists between knowledge
and train employees on policies at work place (18.6%). policy and strategy and organisational performance.
Complicated policies, lack of stakeholders’
involvement and awareness were the major challenges
22. Summary that would be overcome by organizing meetings
Faced with increasing competition and dynamic and workshops, improving terms and service
environments, organizations are beginning to realize that for employees, shortening policies and strategy
there is a largely untapped asset within the organization- development time and training employees on policies
knowledge Gupta, et.al10. The benefits that organisations available at work place.
get from good knowledge management have been
elaborated in several studies such as Wamundila28, 23. Recommendations
Kidwel et al (2001), among others. The effect of
knowledge management practices (knowledge capture Brainstorming, subject matter experts, expert systems/
and acquisition, knowledge sharing and knowledge knowledge bases and after action reviews should be
management policies and strategies) on organizational formalized knowledge capture practices articulated in a
performance was studied with three objectives: policy.
• To establish the effect of knowledge capture and These important knowledge sharing practices should
acquisition practices on organizational performance. be implemented: succession planning, communities of
The findings show that training, meetings, seminars practice, storytelling, mentorship, phased retirement,
and workshops, and recruitment practices at Kisii coaching and orientation.
University had a strong positive effect quantitatively Kisii University should develop a knowledge
analysed at R=0.86 and 0.76. There were several management policy and locate policies in central locations
challenges that the university encountered such as for easy access.
inadequate facilities, financial constraints among The Government of Kenya should increase funds to
others however these would be minimized by Kisii University in order to enable it to effectively support
procurement of required facilities, sensitisation of knowledge management initiatives with the aim of
members of staff, increasing budget for workshops improving organizational performance.
and seminars among others.
• To determine the effect of knowledge sharing practices
on organizational performance. Knowledge was
24. Areas for Further Research
shared through various channels including, meetings, From the research findings, the following areas need to
workshops, seminars and the use of notice boards be studied further. A comparative study on the effects
and mobile phones. Although the university faced of knowledge management practices on organizational
challenges such as financial constraints, hoarding performance should be conducted in different universities.
of knowledge, inadequate training and lack of As study on the challenges in knowledge management
cooperation among members of staff, there was a in higher education institutions in Kenya should be
strong positive effect found between knowledge conducted, particularly in the wake of a highly dynamic
sharing and organisation performance as in study and fast changing technological dispensation.
by Ngah and Razak17 calculated qualitatively
with R=0.93 and R2=0.86. There is a need to hold
regular meetings, encourage members of staff to 25. References
share knowledge, facilitate knowledge sharing, seek 1. Armbrecht, F.; et al. (2001). Knowledge Management in Re-
partners to support knowledge sharing programmes search and Development, Research Technology Management,
and support by management. 44(4). Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. http://www.iriweb.org
• To determine the effect of knowledge management
2. Asli, M., et.al. (2013). Investigating the Influence of Knowl- Sharing on Organizational Performance in Small and Medi-
edge Management on Organizational Performance. Acta um Enterprises. Retrieved from http://www.kmice.cms
Polytechnica Hungarica, 10(2). 18. Nonaka, I (1994). A Dynamic Theory of Organizational
3. Choo, C; and Bontis (2002). The Strategic Management of In- Knowledge Creation. New York: Oxford University Press.
tellectual Capital and Organizational Knowledge: New York: 19. Prusak, L (2001).Where did knowledge management come
Oxford University Press. from? IBM Systems Journal, 40(4):1002-07. Retrieved on
4. Chong, C and Choi, Y (2005). Critical Factors in the Suc- 23rd March 2012. http://researchwebcom
cessful Implementation of Knowledge Management. Journal 20. Peyman, A; et al (2005). Exploring Failure- Factors of Im-
of Knowledge Management Practice, 23(6). Retrieved on 23rd plementing Knowledge Management Systems in Organi-
March 2012. http://www.tlainc.com zations. Journal of Knowledge Management Practice, 40(6).
5. Cranfield, D (2011). Knowledge Management and High- Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. www.ejkm.com
er Education: A UK Case Study Using Grounded Theory. 21. Raja, S (2008). The Relationship of Knowledge Management
University of Southampton. Retrieved on 22nd March 2012. Practices, Competencies and the Organizational Perfor-
http://eprints.soton.ac.uk mance of Government Departments in Malaysia. Interna-
6. Darroch, J (2003). Developing a Measure of Knowledge tional Journal of Human and Social Sciences, 5(4). Retrieved
Management Behaviours and Practices. Journal of Knowl- on 10th June 2012. http://www.waset.org
edge Management, 7(5). Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. 22. Rumesh, K (2003). Managing Knowledge in Turbulent Busi-
www.emeraldinsight.com ness Environments: An Empirical Study in the Malaysian
7. Davenport, T and Prusak, L (1998). Working Knowledge. Context’. Malaysian Management Review, 38(3). Retrieved
Boston: Harvard Business School Press. on 23rd March 2012. http://www.mim.org.
8. DeLong, DW (2004). Lost Knowledge: Confronting the 23. Sabherwal, R and Becerra-Fernandez, I (2003). An Empiri-
Threat of an Aging Workforce. New York: Oxford Univer- cal Study of the Effect of Knowledge Management Processes
sity Press. at Individual, Group, and Organizational Levels. Decision
9. Israel, G (2012). Determining Sample Size. IFAS Extension: Sciences, 4(1). Retrieved on 10th June 2012. www.decision-
University of Florida. Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. http:// sciencesjournal.org.
edis.ifas.ufl.edu 24. Smith, H. and McKeen, D (2005). Developments in Practice
10. Gupta, B; et al (2000). Knowledge Management: Practices XVII: A Framework for KM Evaluation. Community. Asso-
and Challenges. Industrial Management and Data Systems, ciation Information System, 32(7). Retrieved on 23rd March
100(1):17-21. Retrieved on 10th June 2012. http://www.em- 2012. http://start.aisnet.org.
eraldinsight.com 25. Stankosky, M (2005). Advances in Knowledge Management:
11. Kisii University (2013). Kisii University Strategic plan 2009- Creating the Discipline of Knowledge Management. Wash-
2019. Retrieved on 23rd March 2012 from http://www.kisii- ington, Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann.
university.ac.ke 26. Thomas, JB; et al. (2001). Understanding “Strategic learn-
12. Kothari, C (1990). Research Methodology: Methods and ing”: Linking Organizational Learning, Knowledge Manage-
Techniques. University of Rajasthan. Wishwa Prakashan. ment and Sense making. Organization Science, 12(3):331-
13. Lee, S (2010). The Impact of Knowledge Management Prac- 45. Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. http://orgsci.journal.
tices in Improving Student Learning Outcomes. Durham informs.org.
University. Retrieved on 20th June 2012 .http://etheses.dur. 27. Waheed; et al. (2011). The Effects of Knowledge Manage-
ac.uk ment Practices on Organizational Performance. A Con-
14. Lyles, M and Salk, J (2006). Knowledge Acquisition from ceptual Study. African Journal of Business Management,
Foreign Parents in International Joint Ventres: An Empirical 5(7):2847-53. Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. http://www.
Examination in the Hungarian Context. Journal of Interna- academicjournals.org.
tional Business Studies, 27(1). Retrieved on 23rd March 2012. 28. Wamundila, S (2008). Developing Guidelines for a Knowl-
http://som.utdallas.edu/fti/docs. edge Management Policy to Enhance Knowledge Retention
15. Mills, A and Smith, T (2011). Knowledge management and at University of Zambia. Research Theses, University of
organizational performance: a decomposed view. Journal of South Africa.
Knowledge Management, 15(1):156-71. 29. Zahidul, I; et al. (2007). The role of Knowledge Management
16. Newman, WB (2000). Knowledge Management Research Practices on Organizational Context and Organizational Ef-
and End User Work Environments. INSPEL, 34(2):76-79. fectiveness. ABAC Journal, 28(1):42-53. Retrieved on 23rd
Retrieved on 23rd March 2012 http://www.ifla.org March 2012. http://www.journal.au.edu.
17. Ngah, R and Razak, A (2010). The Effect of Knowledge