Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By :
Maret 2020
INDIVIDU : D3KEPMA2A_DINI HAIRUN ‘ILMI WIJAYA_P17210181005
A. ASSIGNMENT 1
1. Journal
Introduction
Maternal-fetal attachment describes the
relationship between mother and her fetus
and is an emotion toward the unborn child, age, parity, mothers mental imagine of
which starts from the beginning of herself, obstetric and medical problems
pregnancy and reaches its peak during the during pregnancy, social support, maternal
second and third trimesters of pregnancy anxiety and psychiatric status, accepting
(1, 2). This feeling is influenced by the pregnancy, and unwanted pregnancy
maternal age, educational level, (3, 4).
socioeconomic status, marital status, Anxiety in pregnant women, especially
gestational in nulliparous women who are not ready
for motherhood, reduces maternal-fetal
attachment,
and mother's ability to assume maternal of anxiety and depression that can lead to
role (5). In a study by Ossa et al. (2011), adverse pregnancy outcomes (8).
maternal- fetal attachment was significantly The results obtained by Kelly (2001)
higher in women with intended pregnancy revealed that maternal-fetal attachment is
compared to those with unintended directly associated with health training (11).
pregnancy (6). In addition, in a study by Belleini et al. (2007) in a study showed that
Ustunsoz et al. (2010), the maternal- fetal training courses during pregnancy have a
attachment score was higher in planned positive impact on maternal-fetal attachment
pregnancies than unplanned ones (7). (12). Ample studies have been performed so
However, in a study by Torshizi et al. far in the field of maternal-fetal attachment
(2012) performed in Birjand, mean score of including training of attachment behavior to
maternal-fetal attachment was not fetus, touching the fetus, counting fetus’s
significantly different between wanted and movements, and relaxation training (3, 4, 10,
unwanted pregnancies (8). 13, 14).
Maternal-fetal attachment plays an Relaxation is a coping strategy for stress,
important role in accepting maternal role, and in behavioral and alternative therapies and
child's growth and development, increasing simple medical treatments, relaxation and
tendency to breast- feeding (9), promoting maternal-fetal attachment are practiced after a
mothers' confidence in playing maternal brief training program (10, 15, 16). There are
role, and causing the mother to show more various techniques for relaxation including
compatibility with postpartum period and guided imagery, hypnosis, massage,
give positive response to infant's behaviors meditation, muscular progressive relaxation,
(4, 10). In addition, mothers with higher and yoga (15). Some studies have shown that
fetal attachment have stronger interaction guided imagery leads to relaxation, reduced
with their infant (4). Mothers with weak anxiety, and fetal attachment (16-19).
attachment to their fetus reported high levels Guided imagery during pregnancy can
improve the feeling of mothers toward guided imagery on maternal-fetal
their fetus and help them comply with their attachment in nulliparous women with
role (10). Deutsch et al. reported that unplanned pregnancy in Mashhad health
women who imagine themselves as able centers.
mothers during pregnancy
Guided imagery as a mind-body
technique is based on the assumption
that the mind and body are linked and
reinforce each other)12( . This method
can be learned by an instructor or self-
training books or tapes and can be used
at times of pain or anxiety and mental
stress (22). Zahourek (1988) suggests
Materials and Methods
that guided imagery affects physiologic
This study is a clinical trial with a
and psychological status and behaviors
pretest- posttest design that was performed
of a person, promotes health, reduces
on 67 nulliparous women (35 in the
stress, and enhances positive feelings
intervention and
(19). Rogers (1983) believes that
32 in the control groups) with unplanned
humans and environment are energy
pregnancy and gestational age of 33
fields, which are continuously
weeks, who were referred to 10 health
interacting, such that change in one
centers of Mashhad, Iran, during August-
leads to transformations in the other.
October 2014. Based on the results of a
Women form an attachment with fetus
pilot study and the formula of comparison
during pregnancy if their energy and
of means and 99% confidence coefficient
environment are directed toward this
and power of 90%, sample size was
goal. Attachment behavior is a symbol
calculated to be 35 cases in each group.
of human-environment interaction and
In the control group, three cases (two
is a process with energy context (23).
due to failure to complete the
Maternal-fetal attachment, which is
questionnaire after delivery and one due to
lower in unplanned pregnancies, is of
lack of desire to continue participating in
great significance for desirable pregnancy
the study) were excluded from the study.
outcomes. Guided imagery triggers
The inclusion criteria were nulliparous
formation of attachment behaviors (23);
women, obtaining a score of selected as a
however, different psychological aspects
cluster. Random selection was in a way
of guided imagery have not been
that both names of two centers were
evaluated yet. Thus, this study was
written on two separate sheets and placed
performed to determine the effect of
into a draw bag, the first selected sheet
was assigned to the intervention group day before the intervention. Then, in the
and second sheet to the control group. 34th week of pregnancy, the participants
Given the number of classes, a total of in both groups completed the personal-
10 health centers were selected. family form and Cranley's and DASS 21
If nulliparous women who met the questionnaires.
inclusion criteria had unplanned The experimental group received one
pregnancy, the researcher explained the session of guided imagery regarding
aims of the study to them; London
maternal role in 34th week of gestation in
questionnaire was given to them and if
groups of four and seven. Guided imagery
they obtained a score of 0 to 3, other
was taught through training classes for the
inclusion criteria were evaluated and if
mothers at health centers that had
they met all the criteria to enter the
comfortable chairs and were sufficiently
study, informed consent form was
quiet. The techniques and the effects of
completed by them. The researcher
guided imagery were taught to the
reminded the participants the
subjects.
appointment through phone calls on the
Afterwards, the mothers were asked to take statistics (mean, standard deviation, median,
a few deep breaths, switch off their interquartile range, frequency distribution)
phones, and focus their attention on the and independent t-test, paired t-test, Chi-
CD of maternal role imagery and imagine squared, Fisher’s exact test, and Mann-
their maternal role throughout the mental Whitney U tests were run using SPSS version
imagery, which lasted for 20 minutes. 21. P-value less than 0.05 was considered
Thereafter, the researcher gave the statistically significant.
guided imagery CDs to the mothers and
Results
they were asked to perform guided
The two groups were matched for age,
imagery at home twice a week during two
husband and others' support, such that mean
weeks. The researcher followed the
ages in the intervention and control groups
subjects through phone calls in terms of
were 24.0±4.6 and 24.19±4 years,
performing guided imagery. The control
respectively (P=0.88), mean scores of
group only received the routine care.
husband's support in the intervention and
Finally, the participants completed the
control groups were
Cranley's questionnaire in the 36th week of
pregnancy. Pre-test and post-test results
were compared between the two groups.
To analyze the data, descriptive
8.23±1.6 and 8.06±2.6, respectively maternal- fetal attachment before and after
(P=0.46), and mean scores of others' training (P<0.001), the difference was also
support were 8.26±2.2 and 8.09±2.4 significant in the control group (P=0.005).
(P=0.93). Chi-squared and Fisher's exact Independent t-test reflected that mean score
tests showed that the two groups were of changes in maternal- fetal attachment
similar in terms of maternal educational was significantly higher in the intervention
level (P=0.34), socio-economic class group than the controls (P=0.004; Table 2).
(P=0.70), occupation (P=0.37), history of Moreover, using covariance analysis and
abortion (P=0.70), status of marital control of maternal-fetal attachment before
satisfaction (P=0.29), and housing status the intervention, significant differences were
(P=0.93) (Table 1). observed between the two groups in terms
Considering the results of independent of the effect of training on maternal-fetal
t-test, mean score of maternal-fetal attachment (P<0.001, t=16.14, B=94.61).
attachment was similar in the two groups According to independent t-test results,
before training (P=0.966), while it was mean depression score before training was
significantly different post- intervention similar in the two groups (P=0.744), but it
(P=0.046). Based on paired t-test results, was significantly different after the
in the intervention group, there was a intervention (P=0.004). Based
significant difference in mean scores of
Table 2. Mean score of maternal-fetal attachment before and after training during pregnancy
in the intervention and control groups
Group
Independ
Maternal-fetal Intervention Control
ent t-test
attachment
Mean±S N Mean±SD N results
D
t=0.04
Before training 88.40±8. 22 88.50±10.7 25 df=52
4 P=0.9
66
t=-2.01
After training during 94.26±6. 22 90.22±9.5 25 df=5
pregnancy 7 2
P=0.0
46
Changes in mean score t=-
intervention df=52,
P=0.0
04
Paired t-test result t=-4.79 t=-2.99
df=23 df=23
P>2.223 P=
0.005
Table 3. Mean depression score before and after training during pregnancy in the intervention
and control groups
Depression Group Independen
Intervention Control
t
t-test result
Mean±SD N Mean±SD N
4.63±3.5 35 4.34±3.5 32 t=-0.328
Before training df=52
P=0.744
4±2.1 35 6.19±3.4 32 t=3.06
After training during df=52
pregnancy
P=0.004
t=1.46 t=-6.11
Paired t-test result df=23 df=23
P=0.151 P<0.001
Table 4. Mean score of stress before and after training during pregnancy in the intervention and
control groups
Stres Group Independ
s ent t-test
Intervention Control
result
Mean±SD N Mean±SD N
t=-1.04
Before training 8.03±3.8 35 7±4.1 32 df=52
P=0.300
t=3.27
After training during 4.9±2.2 35 7.5±4 32 df=52
pregnancy P=0.002
t=6.13 t=-1.76
Paired t-test result df=2 df=23
P>0.0 P=0.088
01
on paired t-test, in the intervention group, difference between the mean depression scores
there was no statistically significant pre- and post- intervention (P=0.151);
however, the difference was statistically significant in the control
group (P<0.001; Table 3)
According to independent t-test, mean
scores of stress before training were
similar in
the two groups (P=0.300), but the before and after the intervention
difference was statistically significant after (P<0.001), but the difference was not
training (P=0.002). Based on paired t-test significant in the control group (P=0.88;
results, in the intervention group, Table 4).
statistically significant differences were
noted between stress scores
Table 5. Mean anxiety score before and after training during pregnancy in the intervention and
control groups
Group Independ
Anxie Intervention Control
ent t-test
ty
Mean± N Mean±SD N results
SD
t=-1.48
Before training 5.97±3.3 22 4.75±3.3 25 df=52,
P=0.142
t=3.99
After training during 3.91±1. 22 6.34±3 25 df=52,
pregnancy 8 P>0.001
t=5.38 t=-6.01
Paired t-test result df=23 df=2
P<0.0 3
01 P<0.0
01
couples in America revealed that guided The study of Akbarzadeh et al. (2011)
fetal attachment, but caused no significant fetal attachment behaviors in the third
our findings. In the study by Kim, the attachment (13) that was consistent with
subjects were primiparous and multiparous the results of the current study. In the
women, who had gestational age of 30 study of Akbarzadeh, all the subjects had
weeks and attended childbirth classes and planned pregnancy and training course
that study, the training program included maternal- fetal attachment behaviors. The
mean score of maternal-fetal attachment than that of the present study, showing that
in the study of Akbarzadeh was lower maternal-fetal attachment
in the subjects of that study was lower Khoramrodi's study is their single-blind design.
than maternal-fetal attachment in this Abbasi et al. (2010) evaluated the effect of
study, this difference can be attributed to training attachment behaviors on maternal-fetal
difference in type of pregnancy. attachment in primiparous women in Sari and
Abbasi et al. (2010) evaluated the effect found that four sessions of training attachment
of fetal movement counting by mother on behaviors during one month significantly
maternal-fetal attachment in primiparous increa- sed maternal-fetal attachment (4). Toosi
women and concluded that fetal movement et al. (2012) carried out a clinical trial to
counting ameliorates maternal-fetal compare the effect of training attachment
attach- ment (3). The results of Abbasi's behaviors and relaxation on maternal-fetal and
study were consistent with the outcomes of maternal- neonatal attachment in primiparous
this study. In the study of Abbasi, the women and noted that training attachment
majority of subjects had planned behaviors and relaxation can strengthen
pregnancy and training, which included maternal-fetal and maternal-neonatal
only fetal movement counting, was attachment (10), which is consistent with this
performed in the 32th week of gestation. study. In the study by Toosi, post-test was
Khoramrodi et al. (1999) in a study that performed one month after the start of training,
investigated the effect of touch on maternal- and training included four 90-minute sessions.
fetal and neonatal attachment behaviors in The mean score of maternal-fetal attachment in
primiparous women referred to health care the study by Toosi was less than that obtained
weeks of touching fetus was not effective in In the study of Akbarzadeh et al. (2011),
maternal-fetal attachment, but was effective training attachment behaviors and relaxation
was inconsistent with the current results. primiparous women in the third trimester of
One of the differences of Khoramrodi's pregnancy (13), which was consistent with
study with present work can be the subjects our results. One of the inclusion criteria for
and training content. The benefit of this study was wanted pregnancy, and the
Spielberger questionnaire was applied to all the subjects had unplanned pregnancy
assess anxiety. Training was presented in (unwanted and mistimed).
four sessions during the third trimester of Delaram et al. (2011) proposed that
pregnancy. In the study of Akbarzadeh et al. consultation during the third trimester of
(2012), training attachment behaviors and pregn- ancy reduced anxiety in primiparous
relaxation lowered anxiety in primiparous women (28), which was consistent with this
women in the third trimester of pregnancy study. In the study of Delaram, Hamilton
(9) that was consistent with this study. In questionnaire was used to assess anxiety.
the study by Akbarzadeh, all subjects had Malekpour-Afshar et al. (2005) showed
wanted pregnancy and the Spielberger that training on labor preparation results in
questionnaire was used to evaluate an overall reduction of anxiety in
anxiety. In a study by Bazrafshan et al. primiparous women (29), which is in
(2010), backstroke massage reduced agreement with this study. In their study,
anxiety in primiparous women Cattell test was used to assess anxiety. In
(5) that was congruent with our the study by Toosi et al. (2011), attachment
outcomes. In the study of Bazrafshan, behavior training reduced anxiety and
the Spielberger questionnaire was elevated maternal- neonatal attachment in
applied to assess anxiety, and massage primiparous women (2), which was
was performed in the third trimester of consistent with this study. In the study of
pregnancy. Toosi, all the subjects had wanted
In a study by Seyed Ahmadi Nejad et pregnancy and Spielberger questionnaire
al. (2014), progressive muscle relaxation was employed.
decreased anxiety, depression, and stress One of the limitations of this study was
in primiparous women (27) that was in that although the participants were
line with this study. In a study by Seyed homogenous in terms of social and
Ahmadi Nejad, DASS 21 questionnaire economic status and other demographic
was employed and 14.7% of pregnant factors to minimize individual differences
women had wanted pregnancy and 11.5% and important stressful events were
mistimed pregn- ancy, while in this study, accounted for, daily stressful events were
not
considered. One of the strengths of this
study was sampling in five health centers in
Mashhad with different socio-economic
classes.
Conclusion
In this study, guided imagery training
enhanced maternal-fetal attachment; thus, it
is recommended to consider guided imagery
training during prenatal care, especially for
women with unplanned pregnancy. References
1. Pillite A. Maternal & child health nursing:
Acknowledgements
care of the childbearing & childrearing
This study was derived from an MSc
family. 4th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott
thesis approved by Mashhad University of
Williams and Wilkins; 2003.
Medical Sciences with proposal code of
2. Tossi M, Akbarzadeh M, Zare N, Sharif F.
930063 and IRCT code of IRCT
Effect of attachment training on anxiety and
2014060117948N1. We
attachment behavior of first time mothers.
would like to thank the Deputy of
Journal of Hayat. 2011; 17(3):69-79
Research for their financial support and
(Persian).
staff of Mashhad health centers for their
3. Abasi E, Tafazoli M, Esmaeili H. The effect
cooperation.
of foetal movement counting on primipara
Conflicts of interest maternal foetal attachment. Journal of
The authors declare no conflicts of Mazandaran University Medical science.
interest. 2010; 20(77):53-60 (Persian).
4. Abasi E, Tafazoli M. The Effect of training
attachment behaviors on primipara maternal
fetal attachment. Scientific Journal of
Hamadan Nursing & Midwifery Faculty. 6(4):14-23 (Persian).
2010; 17(12):35-45 (Persian). 10. Toosi M, Akbarzadeh M, Zare N,
5. Bazrafshan MR, Ghorbani Z. The effect Sharif F. Compare the effects of
of slow stroke back massages on attachment behavior with relaxation
anxiety among primigravid women. training on maternal fetal attachment
Journal of Hayat. 2010; 16(1):34-40 and infant in prime pregnant women.
(Persian). Journal of Fundamentals of Mental
6. Ossa X, Bustos L, Fernandez L. Prenatal Health. 2014; 17(3):69- 79 (Persian).
attachment and associated factors during 11. Lindgren K. Relationships among
the third trimester of pregnancy in maternal fetal attachment , prenatal
Temuco, Chile. Midwifery. 2012; depression, and health practices in
28(5):e689-e696. pregnancy. Research in Nursing &
7. Ustunsoz A, Guvenc G, Akyuz A, Oflaz Health. 2001; 24(3):203-217.
F. Comparison of maternal- and paternal- 12. Bellieni CV, Ceccarelli D, Rossi F,
fetal attachment in Turkish couples. Buonocore G, Maffei M, Perrone S, et al.
Midwifery. 2010; 26(2):e1-e9. Is prenatal bonding enhanced by prenatal
8. Torshizi M, Sharifzadeh G. Maternal- education course? Minerva Ginecologica.
fetal attachment and associated factors in 2007; 59(2):125-129.
pregnant women referred to Birjand 13. Akbarzadeh M, Tossi M, Zare N,
health centers (2012). Journal of Birjand Sharif F. Effect of learning attachment
University of Medical Sciences. 2013; behaviors on anxiety and maternal
20(3):279-287 fetal attachment in first pregnant
Keyword
Relaxation visualitation
Relaxation it can be done anyplace dan anytime
Close your eyes and let a wave of peace move through you
Notice your breath does it feel short choppy shallow or is it deep and relaxed
Now lengthen your breath slowly
Try to feel the breath through your body
Releasy any activity you want to get rid of just as you breathe out
If you feel the need to return to a relaxation state you can do that simply by
focusing on your breathing
Enjoy the sensation of this energy the peace and the relaxation this brings
Comments
In my opinion this is a short video about relaxation for shortness of breath. I think
this video is interesting to apply to us especially nurses to do this simple therapy to
patients in need. The audio from this video agrees in my opinion. And I commented
on the images contained in the video, images that did not make it relaxed for use as
relaxation. True from this video that relaxation can be done anywhere and anytime.
C. ASSIGNMENT 3
Nurse D : Good morning, Miss. I’m Nurse Dini. Can you spell your name and birth day?
Rara : Yes, good morning My name is Rara and I was born on July, 24th.
Rara : Umm, yes. I am a college student, and this is my fourth year here. These past
years, of course there are many pressures, and had so many hard times. But these
doesn’t meaning so much to me. I think that was very normal for a college student
like me. But, lately, I feel more anxious. This is my last semester and I have to do
the final project. I haven’t did this before, so I have to concentrate and finish this
before the due time.
Nurse D : Alright, Miss. I understand. I’ve been there too. That was very tiring. And then,
what do you feel?
Rara : These past month, maybe 3 or 4 months, I feel like a half dead-half alive. I feel
very pressured by this thesis and want to finish this immediately. But, every time I
remember about this thesis, I feel stressed. Tremors too, cold sweat, and I can’t
sleep all night.
Nurse D : Okay, Miss. I understand what you feel. That feelings aren’t comfortable for you,
right?
Nurse D : I suggest you to do the guided-imagery therapy. In this therapy, you just have to do
the relaxation, inhale-and-exhale with imaging some places, or some time that calms
you. With guided, of course. So, you won’t do this independently.
Nurse D : Anytime, as you wish. Or, maybe you wanna try now?
Nurse D : Wait a minute, I’ll give you some relaxing music and images, please follow the
directions
Nurse D : I’m glad to hear that. Of course, you can. You can did this everytime you want.