Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The journal has had 4 points in Ministry of Science and Higher Education of Poland parametric evaluation. Part B item 683.
Abstract:
Introduction and aim: Stress is usually a precursor to anxiety and anxiety is usually a precursor
to depression, can reduce the efficiency of healthy individuals. This study is aimed to observe the
levels of depression, leads to stresses and its effect on vital parameters during academic
curriculum.
Materials and Methods: A prospective cross-sectional study is designed which conducted at Sri
Aurobindo Medical College and P. G. Institute, Indore, (M. P.) India. 132 final year MBBS and
Physiotherapy students of academic year 2012-13 were selected as subjects. The height, weight,
pulse rate and blood pressure were taken before and during pre-university examination. Zung’s
scale was used for assessment of depression.
Results: There was highly significant difference in vital parameters [PR (t=7.86, P<0.001), SBP
(t=5.39, P<0.001) and DBP (t=3.92, P<0.001)] during examination. The depression level was
high as Extreme major depression was observed in 7.9% of boys and 11.8% of girls from MBBS
and 10.7% of girls from Physiotherapy. SDS Index of depression was more in girls as compared
to boys.
Conclusion: It was observed that academic examinations for Medical and Para-medical students
are stressful and produce changes in vital parameters which affected their academic performance.
Academics and examinations are the most powerful stressors in Medical and Para-medical
students.
ACADEMIC STRESS DUE TO DEPRESSION AMONG MEDICAL ……..
Key Words: Depression, Stress, Anxiety, Stressor, Pulse rate and Vital Parameters.
Abbreviation: PR-Pulse Rate, SBP- Systolic Blood Pressure, DBP-Diastolic Blood Pressure
and SDS-Standardized Depression Scale
These changes include increase in pulse rate Index). SDS Raw Index=(Raw Score/80 total
and blood pressure. The present study was points)x100 and SDS Index=SDS Raw
aimed to assess the stress due to depression Index*1.25.The score obtained was analyzed
and its effect on vital parameters during by using scale of depression according to
academic examination in final year medical Zung’s categorization as <50 is Normal, <60
and paramedical students. is Mild Depression, <70 is Moderate or
Marked Major Depression and >70 is Severe
Materials and Methods: A prospective cross- or Extreme Major Depression. Pre readings
sectional study is design to assess the levels of (before examination) for Pulse Rate, Systolic
depression, leads to stresses and its effect on Blood Pressure and Diastolic Blood Pressure
vital parameters during academic curriculum. were compared with post readings (at the time
The study was carried out at Sri Aurobindo of examination). Body Mass Index was
Medical College and P. G. Institute, Indore, calculated for all the students [20].
(M. P.) India. The final year MBBS and
Physiotherapy students of academic year Statistics: The Data were entered into the
2012-13 appearing for university examination computer database. The responses of
were selected as subjects. There were 148 frequencies were calculated and analyzed by
students out of which 132 participated in the using statistical software SPSS version 11.0.
study. Ethical approval was obtained from Prevalence of an outcome variable along with
Institutional research and ethical committee. 95% confidence interval was calculated.
Two months prior to the academic Student’s t-test for paired samples was used to
examination height (cm), weight (kg), Pulse compare the mean values of study variable in
rate and Blood Pressure were recorded and relation to depression. The descriptive
again during academic examination the same statistics like mean and standard deviation of
was repeated. The observed mean age of different study variables was calculated. The
student was 21.00±2.54 years. Sixteen Zung’s self rating depression scale [19] was
students were excluded from the study as they analyzed by categorization of the three levels
were absent during examination. After (Mild, Moderate or Marked Major and Severe
explaining the purpose of the study a or Extreme Major Depression) of depression
questionnaire was provided to one student at a as presence of depression. The probability
time just before the start of viva-voce and was value p<0.05 was considered as significant,
asked to answer (fill up) the questions in p<0.01 and p<0.001 were considered as highly
prescribed format so as to assess their significant.
depression level.
Results: The findings reported that in MBBS
Zung’s scale was used to assess the depression the boys and girls are equally distributed
level [19]. The questionnaire consists of whereas in physiotherapy 93% were girls.
twenty questions where Likert Scale Format is This may be because of more number of girls
used for assessment and scoring of depression opting for physiotherapy course.
level. Ten questions based on positive answers
and ten negative are included. Each question Table no 1 revealed the weight and height of
has answer score from 1 to 4. The option for students of MBBS and Physiotherapy course.
each question is (a) None or a little of the time The table 2 showed that of the total selected
(b) Some of the time (c) Good part of the time subjects most of the students (58.3%) had
and (d) Most or all of the time. The raw score normal weight, 19.7% were overweight (pre
is converted to 100 point scale (SDS Raw obese increased category-I), 10.6% in
underweight category and 3.8% were in girls as compared to boys during their
obesity. Major proportion of boys (68.4%) and academic examination. There was no
girls (58.8%) from MBBS course and (51.8%) difference between Mean Depression Score
of girls from physiotherapy course were (SDS Index) in the students of MBBS and
normal weight. 28.9% boys and 17.6% girls Physiotherapy course during their academic
from MBBS course and (30.4%) of girls from examination (Table-3). It is confirmed from
physiotherapy course were in pre obese table 4 that there is a highly significant
increased category-I. 23.5% and 8.9% girls difference between before and at the time of
from MBBS and physiotherapy course examination observations in vital parameters
physiotherapy course were found to be such as Pulse rate (p<0.001; two tailed),
underweight respectively. It was also observed Systolic Blood Pressure (p<0.001; two tailed)
that 8.9% of girls from physiotherapy course and Diastolic Blood Pressure (p<0.001; two
were obese. The mean Body mass index for tailed) due to examination stress in all the
boys was 23.01 kg/m2 and girls 21.44 kg/m2 students from MBBS and Physiotherapy
of MBBS course and 24.05 kg/m2 for boys course (Table-4). Mean pre-readings in all the
and 23.95 kg/m2 for girls of physiotherapy students from MBBS and Physiotherapy
course while 23.03 kg/m2 was observed in the course for Pulse rate, Systolic Blood Pressure
total population. and Diastolic Blood Pressure were
77.52 7.75 per minute, 120.29 9.66 mm of
The scale of depression according to Zung’s Hg and 81.07 8.71 mm of Hg respectively
categorization is; <50 is Normal, <60 is Mild and Mean post readings at the time of
Depression, <70 is Moderate or Marked Major examination for Pulse rate, Systolic Blood
Depression and >70 is Severe or Extreme Pressure and Diastolic Blood Pressure were
Major Depression. It is observed in the table 3 84.73 11.24 per minute, 124.76 10.41 mm
that 18.4% of boys and 35.3% of girls from of Hg, 83.76 8.03 mm of Hg respectively
MBBS course and 25% of girls from (Table-4).
Physiotherapy were normal. It is also seen that
more than half (60.5%) of boys and more than Table no. 5 shows that there was highly
one-fourth (26.5%) of girls from MBBS significant difference in pulse rate among
course and exactly three-fourth (75.0%) of boys before and during the time of
boys and approximately one-third (30.4%) of examination (p<0.001) in MBBS course and
girls from Physiotherapy had mild depression in girls of both MBBS (p<0.001) and
whereas 13.2% of boys and 26.5% of girls physiotherapy course (p<0.008). The systolic
from MBBS course and 25% of boys and blood pressure was found to be highly
33.9% of girls from Physiotherapy had significant statistically among boys (p<0.001)
marked major depression. 7.9% of boys and in MBBS course and in girls (p<0.001) of
11.8% of girls from MBBS course and 10.7% physiotherapy course. The diastolic blood
of girls from Physiotherapy suffered from pressure also showed highly significant
extreme major depression (table3). difference among girls (p<0.006) in MBBS
course and in girls (p<0.001) of physiotherapy
The Mean Depression score (SDS Index) for course.
boys was 56.50 and girls 56.29 from MBBS
course and 56.25 for boys and 58.96 for girls Discussion-The present study showed that
from Physiotherapy course while 57.48 was there was significant difference in vital
observed in the total population. It was also parameters (Pulse rate, Systolic Blood
observed from the table 4 that the Mean Pressure and Diastolic Blood Pressure) during
Depression Score (SDS Index) was more for
Journal of Health Sciences (J of H Ss) 2013; 3(5) Page 32
ACADEMIC STRESS DUE TO DEPRESSION AMONG MEDICAL ……..
Summary of the findings: The study this study. A prospective study could be
reflected that level of depression was more in carried out with a cohort of all year students in
girls as compared to boys. The main stressor all the medical and paramedical colleges in the
was related to academic examinations. An territory of Madhya Pradesh to look at the
attempt has been made to identify the different levels of academic stress related to
depression and related stress profile of final depression.
year medical and physiotherapy students at the
time of academic examinations. As it is Implications of the study: A high depression
confirmed the general impression that there is level may affect not only academic
a considerable amount of depression which performances but also all aspects of student
leads to stress and produces changes in vital physical health. The stressors should be
parameters in final year Medical and Para- identified and discussed with individual
medical students and it is common and students. As depression which impacted these
process oriented. stress in colleges cannot be eliminated. It is
worth advisable that teachers can and should
Limitations of the study: Authors do a better job and provide review of
acknowledge that this is a study with sample academics and exam schedules, more leisure
of only final year Medical and Para-medical time activities, better interaction with the
students appearing for university examination faculty and proper guidance, advisory services
drawn from only one medical college. and peer counseling could do a lot to reduce
Furthermore, the findings of this study are the depression. Interventions like reduction of
based on self reported information provided levels of depression, perceived by students
by students and some potential for reporting approaching exam can be planned while
bias may have occurred because of student’s laying more emphasis on regular, day by day
interpretation of the questions or simply reading, mock examinations and use of
because of inaccuracies of responses or desire question banks could alleviate the fear,
to report their emotions in a certain way. It depression and anxieties associated with the
could be considered as one of the limitation of university examination.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License
which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original
author(s) and source are credited.
References
[1] Hans Selye: The stresses of life. MC Graw Hill, New York; 1956. 523-567.
[2] Dehaan RL, Venkatnarayan KM : Education for innovation. Rotterndam: Sense Publishers; 2008:13-14
[3] Mannapur B, Dorle AS, Hiremath LD, Ghattargi CH, et al.: A study of psycological stress in undergraduate
medical students at S. N. Medical college, Bagalkot, Karnataka. J clini Diag research 2010; 4 (4): 2869-
2874.
[4] Omigbodun OO, Odukogbe AT, Omigbodun AO, Yusuf OB, Bella TT, Olayemi O. Stressors and psychological
symptoms in students of medicine and allied health professions in Nigeria. Soc. Psychiatr Epidemiol
2006; 41: 415-21.
Table-4: Comparison between Pulse rate, Systolic Blood Pressure and Diastolic Blood Pressure before and at
the time of examination
Before At the time of Mean
Parameters p LOS
examination examination Difference
Pulse rate 77.52 7.75 84.73 11.24 7.21 3.49 7.86 P<0.001
Systolic Blood Pressure 120.29 9.66 124.76 10.41 4.47 0.75 5.39 P<0.001
Diastolic Blood Pressure 81.07 8.71 83.76 8.03 2.69 0.68 3.92 P<0.001
The mean difference is highly significant at the 0.001 level for 131 degrees of freedom. [LOS-Level of
Significance]
Table-5 : Sex-wise comparison between Pulse rate, Systolic Blood Pressure and Diastolic Blood Pressure
before and at the time of examination
Course Sex
Before At the time of
Parameters p LOS
examination examination
The mean difference is highly significant at the 0.001, 0.006 and 0.008 levels of significance. * The mean
difference isn’t significant (insignificant) at the 0.05 level. [LOS-Level of Significance]
This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non
Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted, non commercial
use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.
Received: 15.02.2013.
Revised: 15.03.2013.
Accepted: 19.05.2013.
Correspondence to:-Dr. Balkishan Sharma, Ph. D., Dept. of Community Medicine, Sri Aurobindo Medical College
and P. G. Institute, Indore, (M. P.) India. Mob: 9926049820, Fax:(0731) 4231010 E-mail :
bksnew@rediffmail.com