194 200 24251
Journal of Hospital Infection
Review
Persistence of coronaviruses on inanimate surfaces and
their inactivation with biocidal agents
G. Kampf", D. Todt, S, Pfaender”, E. Steinmann?
* uivesey Medicine Geena, Intute for Hygiene ond Environmental Medicine, Ferdinand Saveronuh-Sroe, 17475
Grefoate, Germany
Department of Molecular and Media! Vly, Ruby Unveity Bochum, Universitatea So, 4901 Bochum, Gemany
Bedeniage Garey Se merges avo has coarviy RACO, Tones gal
Decepted 31 Janaty 2020 Usamistor have en casein
ao fatre a0 lt avlaste formation about We pesstence of hunen and weternary
er on marimate turner at wall ar craton aeons get
Remora ‘es. nesthcareTacives. Thana of 72 set
Corman feveale shat nan cororavses ach Severe Acts Resortary Spon aR
Perstence avin, ede ask Rexpratry Syndrome (HRS) crerai or sneer Manan
‘Chemical inactivation ‘but can be eficlenty activated by surface disinfection procedures with 62—71%
Bia ages fal 3.8 nyone eroaeo sadm yaar hin | Pe:
Introduction spread in the public and healthcare stings. Fransmsson of
‘A novel coronavius SARS-COV.) has recently emerged
‘rom China wth 9 ttal of 4517 confirmed exter of pro
trons (ar of February 12,2029) (1 Together wit Seve
este Respiratory Synarome (S435) coronavrur and Milo
East Respiratory Syncomme ERS) coronvins [2], OSs the
third highly pathoterc Nanan coronevi that hos neta
Inthe tas two cecadee Prson-to-peson EAaSMsion Mas
Seen described both ir hospi! and amily Settings [is
Ahrefore of umost Importance to prevent any fer
romper 6 Kamp
eis aan 01.2
Dortuated nein stnaclaion of mucour membranes
iF the note eyes mouth [és], emphasing the impo
{ince ofa cea uncertandng of corenavi perstence
cents surtces [ vars pe of Noa aes
Berzalkonun chlonde are wsee wortwae for Sahecton,
ry nena tg Tn ti of he even
oF al cornaruss nly eneing SARS-CoV a HERS
CoV as wll ar veterinary coronaire sich a anenierble
Ssvoenterts veut {TEE}, mouse hepetits vrs HY)
Sha canine coonevror (2A). an erent per oF
eller fctin Sct, Pale by Eerie sed6. Map e al Jourel of Hosa Infection 106 (2020) 246-251
Blocial agents tsee sm surface esnectans against
Method
folowing seert were ured, aye fe combination with
"aronaas", "GEV", "Mor "CCV" sual sua (68
pesstencenandi8/0/3/ his, survvathand 22/0731
ta surraakin(8/0/0/ 1M} ersterceshn (0/0.
Th) vrocda 233/37 nes: remielractratn 23 7
07 6/1) suaperson test (180707 ON ander a (17
141 01 Oe. Pobleatant wore icles td reste wore
“enuactd gen they peovoed egal deta on caveats ob
parton faces, materia) td raciation by boat
[gens wed for dsinvcton (uspension tests, camer at,
finan sts). ata with eommertl products sre of
‘nor serene typer of lecda agent were excldes
within tn spe ofthis revi.
THpeot aria Tne a Fae
amie Rey Ste2¥¢ argc
oe saas.coy sean
Key Sea 29
Surge aave (ates) HESY Sans 229 and 0C43
connie Fev stan me
Results
Persistence of coronavirus on inanimate surfaces
est data were decree with the endemic hunan core:
sais eas HC] 229 On dere pe of atl e
an remain irfectus for fom 2 hous up f09 days A Maer
persistence of Why pathogenic MERS-CoV, TGEV and MAY.
Honea acpesence G8 nd WV ce ese
Inet at prtence was oper wh ahr ecla
{Tate lh tddon was shown a oun temperate ts
Scav.ae peste betr at S08 compared vo 30 rete
mara
Inactivation of corenaviruses by biocidal agents in
suspension tests
ane (74-95%), 2-propano 70-1008), the combination
of 45H Dprapanal ite JO” ‘repel, sluardaldenyee
TOsc2sk), formaldehyde (O7A18) are poveone taahne
1° We Tr
ve
0 ey
we ry
Seo ba
ie ts
° bs
wo ts
fa ba
e
i
ia ba
ie Gy
i ba
wo ta
fa bo
e Pa
o ba
wo ty
fy by
Se ta
e ba
e
i
e ae we
@ re (3
Tens = mee Ei Repro Spine, Heo = punan cwerean TOV
Stas Severe ass Reprnny sya! AT ~ ann angesoa 6, Kamp el arnt of Hostal Infection 1042020) 246-251
tae me vas Suen iste Bgaiwetine—_teaicioneT
oes
mx coy Sant tom 333 bo
2reparal fox Eatecoy sate et a! 533 by
me Saco hottest wos 54 ba
ES NeKScov Stan ae 2 ao ba,
hos Sanecev te Pt ee 33 ba.
om av Stara 2 fomn 537 bay
sox coy Sant tom 337 ba.
2erparal and UShane HX SARS-COV late mt a 2a bo
propa! Saco hatte Pact wee 228 rat
enalonin corde 0.28 Ney aTceRIS9 omin oo ba
58 wav Sta 2 toms > 37 bo.
ons coy Sant tom a7 bal
Sanne Gey Sansire uM ao by
Daccyemotns. Sams Ey Stan PE a4 24a ba
chanendine oom mw sansa tom bal
om co fino tome pol
Seatum hpacionte 0218 iy Stam te wes ba
oa ft Semana tome ba,
Hsosen pede 0.58 Hey stan 2 tine oe
025% SARS-COV tn 40
[aS sr tae Rao aOR MENS = leae a
sa
aaat 7 [San SScL EE HE cs 7
a ‘kon u/minaract ean da ba
5 2 er im = is # th
= 2 ec oe i fe He
= toe Barmera erm a
vewtonncinnie Soa me Sem, Seem ie ‘a
compa O88 REE BAVeeoes ess im S38 i
othe ‘Mey Baruyr eae i
om Stee see me imo a
cwensinee fo AE Bavaees Gemini ii 8
Sree Fase Sa ecm se is ce mS
on Mw oom Styl /anmesstect Nene se 0 by &
a SS TS '250 6. Mampy et Journal of Hostal Infection 1042020) 246-251
(022-754) readty facthated coroavis infectivity by
approximately $topic or more. (a=) Socian hypecnore
‘eguved @ minal concetaion of at leat OFT to be
fective. Hyrogen peronde was effecive with 2 concen
tat of 3% ant cibation reo Yin Da obtalned
‘wn bonetenkum elage at restorableconact tires wore
ating With 10 min a ceentabon of 0.2% reveated no
‘tfeny agar carnavins whereas concentration af 0.05%
vine ste effete, 0.02% chomhenidne.dpuconte wae
Basel tnttective Tab).
Inactivation of coronaviruses by biocdal agents in
carrier tests
Ethanol at concentrations betwesn 628 and 71X reduced
corona tethy win tin expasre ine by 20-40
logy. concertation of, -0.58sacum hypochiate and 28
sdaidalaehyce were ao que eectve wi 3.0 ee
Feuer sn vial tre. Ir contas, 004% Berzaeonm
horde, 000% sedium hypecNorte and 05% orth.
prtalaldehyde were tea tect (72 lh.
Discussion
Human cernavres can remaia fective 07 inanimate
safes arom temperature or up 109 day. At 8 tee
‘tire of °C er mare te durations perestence store
‘Veterinary coronas nave beer shown to pest eves
longer fo" 28 Contamination of frequent tosh maces 9
heatrcare setngs are erefore a ater Source ef ir.
UWarsmasion Daan the rani crores rom
“ontamatee surfaces fo hance were nt found. Howeve’, i
Ianster 3.68 of the wa oat the hance]. Te tranaer
iflene was ower (158) with peaauenea vs Sanda 53
“antaet between the rfce and he hands], han bee
‘ational stay twas sero Bat student ou he ace
‘on oe own tars ah average 73 tes per hy with cotact
‘ost fo tho skin (43), flowed by mouth (64), rose OTS)
Sheejes 3%)" Although the val ed of arenas on
‘tanimate earacere ot known dorng an outbrearstntion
sce plas to recuce the vial lad on suraces by di
Infectan, especialy of fequenty toached surfaces in the
Inmeclte sent suroucing where he highestvra aden
bbe expected. The WHO rearmands "to emu tat enor
imental clear and. denfecten procedwrer re followed
anatenty and correctly. Tarogty cleans envionment
Surfaces wh water ang cetergent ng appinng commeniy
{sed nepal evel cfectars such as soctum pect)
Be effective ana sufitont procedures." [12] The tpl we
‘ot beach fat 3 tion of 1:10 of 5k soclun hypechrte
‘eauling nara concentration of 0.058. Cursumnar zed
‘ata wth crcraveuss sages tata cncentration of 155
tlc isis). TRak why escems appropriate
{errcomanc alin 150 of standard leach the cos
‘aves Sling. Far te dsecton of sal surfaces ethane
(Ga=7ix; caror toms) reveseg a sma effeny agsinet
‘mended by the WHO for einfocting sal suraces
No dita were found to describe the frequency of hands
‘econ contaminated with erona, or he va ado
hands either, after patient contactor after touring ca
{aminated surface, Tne WHO reconenendr fo preferably apy
‘Scthactased hand rubs fr the decantarnation of hand,
Sig after romowng gover, Two WHO recommended fo.
‘ruaton (aceon 6 ethanol” 7K Z-propara) have been
‘raat ln sispnsion tests apt SARS-COV ar MENS,
Se both ware ezerbed tobe very etfectve (1) No no
date were found on the eesey of hd wating apt
“ornavr contamination on hansen Tata, Powerer,
ras decribed tha taling hand wash stain the emer
{oncy department wnt the ony infection control measure
Vehen was sigfeany assocted Wty the potecton Tamn
Fealtheare workers fram aeqitg the SARSCOY, naeatng
{hat hand hygiene can havea pretectvee'fect [5] Corr
Dilance it hand hygiene can be sgieaty ges fn an
‘Sutbeak stain buts rel to remain an bstcl expetaly
Song prin [e~2] Taramison in heats et gt
‘ane Focersdly preverte when appreaate mesures are
‘sitenty performed [9,2
Conclusions
Human corrarses can rein infective on ranenate
sree or upto days. Surface dafcton with. sodium
Iypechionte er 62-71X etanal gran reduces corona
‘ie lfectvty on surfaces tnt min exposure te. Me
fexseet sa effect agains he SARS-COV
Conic of interest statement
None eecared
Funding Sources
References
1m ne, coma Bese 209 fom WHO 228 Stn
Ret
Day Set an Oaremaien Warr 8 rer VSS nd
Se eet nee rewrite
1] En 5 Th Yt a aa
inca perro Caran a yf fy
Sener anet Ie. hep ee oto ea
1m ter Si, Socey , Yea, Ontbwake , Goldener 5,
1B] Domes sr, Sinmerman JM, Cra 00, Wu, chaorevanich A
Ia sa se seen yoo coe
(0 ter arava RE. ean cee: he
1 Farstcanept stewart Bocce etree 2 eal
fnpcane chan Speer neta snes 08
1 Set StS rg
Convio wes ha
wi She BSB Pee A, Cavin6, Kamp eal ural of Hospital Infection 104 (2070) 246-251 ast
10 oat Sk, Se Ns Sa A ae aba
1 Roa Ys to ea Fae tung a agar ae
{hot ha imtaten ar hard yen rn es Cote
fitter pevertin a coal ic heat cre when
tet Cori cin ope. Wi,
09 Wr, Won an eect sed ap ene.
Se pin te cn cr prec pere
(a Bw ne vt tana Fed
on ncn ene
[16] Ashammani te, Reynolds KA, Vorhougstracte M, O'Rourke Mt
Sees eer ren caee
ee eee
in es etre i htt
eg eee
1 Se annie re doer
ms meaeeae ocean tones eas
ee eee
[20] 0, Han 5K, Son 46, Park SO Rk of wana va medial
Poeneiipeiera ae omcaa
hacocrarn ner
[BM] van Berean H, BushraberT, Master V3, Sabity of mie
amie haere LS
Seeetama reer
oa inns etack nna
See res eeataeeenre e
sorta
vas a BERET are ee
(Bay Sian 3, Yu mw, Tbr
ea
se ang an acon spss
(tn ge
cen Eee ahaa Wace at
pas Satta dacs tes
on S's haan ea aw he
a or WSs ane acai of SH coo hed
saben a Gy Sea Der tency of vis
BO) Sok
el cnet to engenaeane
Set
Caan deat eeeaiiee
|B] Desianno C, Vous @, Boesenborg B. The antiviral action of com-
soanhoeaiety mule acts
(24 omni star sad nei messi
conic saa ows ae
pata enie oen S
rections. 3 Hoy wee
‘eeaisl isc Smczaana) Re RN
(BM Lggen Ekman, Zor J, Rapid ae ec Va
‘lyst Porconane Prost An Me a Sep
{str Sarone Caen NERS Co reefs Voce
Via ar pi ase De her 235 -494-S
(Bm ges he fabeertsen Eckman Zor Vise
‘esr ard Vr tfcacy of Povaonene Cage
enn ast penta OT abe Ht
(Bm ther Ry Csarora UM, Rtn WA, Weber Sey HO.
Inetan st surapts cevan sno curtsr sy eh
1) pra arn Lae, onc
‘peed rian ene ter epee
(48 Ga
‘Mayorconn peracid apr Maple