Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3.1 Introduction
3.2. Bank marketing
3.3. Marketing mix
3.4. Customer satisfaction
3.5. Analysis of performance of commercial banks.
3.6. Conclusion
3.1. Introduction
Since the inception of globalisation in India, banking sector has undergone
various changes. With the deregulation and liberalisation process in full swing,
the consequent policy changes introduced in the Indian financial system in
general and banking in particular are effecting unprecedented changes in its
functioning. Encouragement to foreign banks and private sector banks increased
competition for all operators in banking sector. There was an absolute shift from
sellers into buyers’ market, establishing the ‘customer’ as the key factor in the
market. The dictum “as the bank exists because of its customers, has become
more pronounced and relevant in the present context”. Thus, marketing
constitutes the key strategy for banks to retain good customers and also anticipate
their future demands.
During the last 40 years the changes made in the banking industry through
financial reforms, advancement of communication and information technologies,
globalisation of financial services and economic development is clearly evident
from the changes that have occurred in the financial markets, institutions and
products.These changes had a considerable effect on efficiency, productivity
change, market structure and performance in the banking industry.
And Branch
expansion
Social Banking
nationalisation
Targets
Development Banking period 1969- mid Selling orientation
1980’s
Disintermediation
Consolidation
Rising needs
operations
Banking
Customer need
creating superior
deregulation
banking services
Liberalisation
satisfaction
with customer
of business
relationship
in IT
markets
Due to the introduction of LPG policy and IT Act of 2000 the scope of the
market has enhanced. Customers' expectations are high from the service industry
like a banking industry. Only those banks will survive who will provide efficient
and customer desired services.
Kotler, (2003) suggests that the traditional marketing mix approach used in
the marketing of goods is insufficient to market and manage services effectively
because of services distinctive features. A key factor distinguishing the services
marketing from marketing of physical products is the human element. The human
factor underlines the personal nature of the services marketing. The personnel are
a powerful element of customer persuasion and a major parameter affecting the
customer’s perception on the delivered service quality. The services marketing
function in an organization is much broader than the activities and outputs of the
traditional marketing department, requiring close co-operation between marketers
and those managers responsible for operations and human resources Therefore,
the traditional marketing mix has been expanded by the addition of three new
marketing mix variables people, processes and physical evidence.
3.3.1 Product-A vital component of marketing mix, the product or service is the
basis on which customer satisfaction is created. A product is anything that can be
offered to a market for attention, acquisition, use or consumption that might
satisfy a want or a need'.(Kotler, P). The banks primarily deal in services and
therefore, the formulation of product mix is required to be in the face of changing
business environment conditions. The changing psychology, the increasing
expectation, the rising income, the changing lifestyles, the increasing domination
of foreign banks and the changing needs and requirements of the customers at
large make it essential that they innovate their service mix and make them of
worked class.
In the formulation of service mix, the banks can follow two guidelines, first
is related to the processing of product to market needs and the second is
concerned with the processing of market needs to product. In the first process, the
needs to the target market are anticipated and visualized and in the second
process, the banks react to the expressed needs and therefore we consider it
reactive. It is essential that every product is measured up to the accepted technical
standards. Technical perfection in service is meant prompt delivery, quick
disposal, and presentation of right data, right filing, proper documentation etc.
banks to provide more information to their target customers about themselves &
their products. Promotional packages are very important for financial service
industry. Thus the orientation of banks should be with a much wider focus in
relation to customer and market needs, and the consequent marketing strategies.
appeals, slogans and messages more creative. Here, creative means making the
advertisement programs distinct to the competitive organizations, which are
active in influencing the impulse of the customers and successful in informing
and sensing the customers. This requires an in-depth knowledge of the receiving
capacity of the target market for which the advertisements are designed.
3.3.2.1.5 Telemarketing:
3.3.3. People
The word ‘people’ is used in services marketing in two perspectives. One
for employees, i.e., internal marketing and the other for customers, i.e. external
marketing. In this way the term people indicate both employees and customers in
services marketing.
necessary knowledge and skill for servicing the customer better, but there is a
need to market banking products to own grassroots level people before marketing
these products effectively to customers. All people directly or indirectly involved
in the consumption of banking services are an important part of the extended
marketing mix. Knowledge Workers, Employees, Management and other
Consumers often add significant value to the total product or service offering.
Thus profit in service companies depends on how well they are taking care
of their employees. Figure 3.2and 3.3 shows the three types of marketing that
takes place in service organisations and the chain of profit creation in such
organisations.
For the present study, 28 statements are drawn under 5 heads namely
Motivation, Organisational integration, Empowerment, Service orientation and
Organisational environment &supporting facilities for studying the effectiveness
of internal marketing strategy adopted in the selected banks.
(Figure3.4)
3.3.4. Price Mix:
The price for services is an important element of the marketing mix, being
an important income source for the organization. Price is the amount of money
customers have to pay to obtain the product. Zeithaml (1988) has defined price as
“what is given up or sacrificed to obtain a product”. Perceived price was defined
according to Zeithaml as “the price that is encoded by the consumer. Managers
seek customer satisfaction as a pricing policy objective as they assume a positive
link between customer satisfaction and profitability. Satisfied customers return
for purchases, buy more and help to attract new customers via recommendations,
while dissatisfaction leads to complaints, lost customers and reputational damage.
Quality of service provided has direct relationship with the fees charged.
While deciding the price mix customer services rank the top position. The value
and satisfaction cannot be quantified in terms of money since it differs from
person to person. Keeping in view the level of satisfaction of a particular
segment, the banks have to frame the pricing strategies.
3. Price reliability, i.e. whether the price is currently good value and whether
the presumed price corresponds with the actual price or contains "hidden
elements" that are not visible at first glance.
4. Price fairness, i.e. whether the price is judged to be fair and justified by the
customer.
5. Price transparency, i.e. whether the price is clear and easily understand-
able. (Matzler et al. (2007).
Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India (2009) survey on
growth and emergence of public and private sector banks in India reveals that
private sector banks are not preferred for traditional items, such as loans, as their
offers are difficult to understand and perceived rate of interest is high, whereas
public sector banks are perceived more reliable with lower rates of interest. In
Indian banking industry where differentiation is not much in terms of prices, it is
required to be fair and transparent without hidden charges.
It is to be noted that the best pricing strategies are flexible and allow a
company to respond to changes in supply or demand, new competition, changes
in technology, etc. Price strategies should constantly be evaluated and tested to
ensure the company maximizes return on sales while meeting a variety of other
goals and needs.
3.3.5. Place
The place where customers buy a product, and the means of distributing the
product to that place, must be appropriate and convenient for the customer. The
product must be available in the right place, at the right time and in the right
quantity. Place in banking services means providing banking services at right
time in convenient way. Inseparability of production and consumption is the most
intriguing characteristic of services. As income of people is rising, there is
inclination towards convenience related services.
Banking services delivered via the Internet, mobile phone interface, voice
response system, call center, automatic teller machines and via face to face in a
branch or visit at customer's home not only have various cost implications for
bank but also drastically affects the nature of service experience for the customer.
If more complexity is associated with a service purchase, customers prefer face to
face interaction with service provider. For availing loan service, customers have
to rely on personal channels. Therefore convenience of location plays important
role on customer perception regarding banking services. Customers with higher
knowledge about a service are more likely to use self-service channels like ATM
and internet banking. But, convenience is a key driver of channel choice for the
majority of consumers.
Milligan (1997) suggests that banks with an extensive branch office system
and ATM network would have the opportunity to attract customers who are in
convenience segment. These days it might appear many of us hardly use
branches. We get cash from ATMs, make payments and arrangements through
direct debits and internet banking, and we can compare hundreds of insurance
offers in moments. And yet, banks seem to be failing to realise the potential
power of the branch. Jed Mole(2013) says in a survey conducted in UK among
1,30,000 respondents, to understand how people want to communicate with their
bank , revealed that more than three-quarters of people (77 per cent) say it’s still
very important to have a local branch. He states that further examination also
pointed out regardless of differing preferences by demographics, three out of four
customers still clamour for the personal touch; there is enormous interest in
having access to a local branch network. Banks must see their branch as a fully
integrated part of the marketing mix and need to integrate customer data across
this and all touch points to avoid a schizophrenic brand experience. Armed and
informed with the right insight, created themselves and through third-parties,
bank staff can have a much more personalised conversation which is far more
likely to be helpful for the customer, but will also make selling wider services
easier; it will feel less ‘bolted on’.
3.3.6 Process
Decors and artifacts: Sign, symbol, reports, punch lines, other tangibles,
employee’s dress code etc. are important component of decor. The company’s
financial reports are issued to the customers to emphasis credibility. Even some
of the banks follow a dress code for their internal customers. This helps the
customers to feel the ease and comfort.
Signage: Each and every bank has its logo by which a person can identify the
company. Thus such signages are significant for creating visualization and
corporate identity.
Punch lines: Punch lines or the corporate statement depict the philosophy and
attitude of the bank. Banks have influential punch lines to attract the customers.
The quality of the services provided determines in great extent the level of
customer satisfaction and analysing the latter can help banks identify their weak
points and act as a wake-up call for management and employees alike. For this
reason most banks consider customer satisfaction as the primary criterion in their
strategic planning since it is directly related to the institutions’ profitability.. New
technologies are being introduced and there is always a fear of economic
uncertainties. Fierce competition, more demanding customers and the economic
uncertainties have presented an unparalleled set of challenges. In such a
competitive scenario, it is extremely important that banks are able to retain a
loyal base of customers. To attain this and to improve their market and profit
positions, banks in India have to formulate their strategies and policies towards
increasing customer satisfaction levels. Banking institutions all over the world
have recognized the importance of customer satisfaction and of developing and
maintaining enduring relationship with their customers as two crucial parameters
leading to increased business performance.
Range of products and services-This include the product variety to suit the
diversified needs of customers. Banks offer products with different features
for meeting the needs of different segments of customers. The bank products
are deposits, loans or other value added services.
considered by Ernst &Youngin the financial express ‘Best Bank Survey’. All
the major indicators which influence the managerial productivity of the bank are
included under the head productivity. This head includes 8 ratios which are
described under three sub heads namely managerial capability (4 ratios), staff
productivity (2ratios) and branch productivity (2ratios). The major factors which
had an impact on the profitability of the banks are included under the head
profitability. This head include 6 ratios which are described under three heads
namely operational performance (2 ratios),source of earnings (2 ratios)and cost
effectiveness (2 ratios). Growth in key variables is required for an all-round
development and sound performance of the banking sector. Hence growth is
considered as an important parameter in this study and 6 ratios are described
under this head.
Productivity
The most important factor responsible for the efficient functioning of a
bank is the productivity or efficiency of its management. It is not possible for a
bank to run smoothly if its assets, liabilities, incomes and expenses are not
properly planned and managed. The management of the bank takes crucial
decisions depending on its risk perception. It sets vision and goals for the
organization and sees that it achieves them. The performance of Management
capacity is usually qualitative in nature and can be understood through the
subjective evaluation of Management systems, organization culture, and control
mechanisms and so on. However, the efficiency of the management of a bank can
also be gauged with the help of certain ratios of off-site evaluation of bank, which
is related to the capability of the management to deploy its resources aggressively
to maximize the income, utilise the facilities in the bank productively and reduce
costs, etc.
The productivity has been explained with the help of various ratios. These
ratios are described under 3 heads. These are managerial capability, employee
productivity and branch productivity.
Spread to total assets (net interest income to total assets) - NIM, being the
difference between the interest income and the interest expended as a
percentage of total assets, shows the ability of the bank to keep the interest
on deposits low and interest on advances high. It is an important measure of
a bank's core income (income from lending operations). A higher spread
indicates the better earnings given by the total assets. The interest income
includes dividend income and interest expended includes interest paid on
deposits, loan from the RBI, and other short-term and long-term loans. The
higher the ratio, the better is the profitability position of the bank.
Employee productivity
Employee productivity signifies how far the employees of the bank are
capable of increasing the business and profits of the bank. Employees are
persons who are in direct contact with the customers and, so, the
ambassadors of the bank. Employee productivity is studied through two
indicators, namely, Profit per Employee (PPE) and Business per Employee
(BPE).
Branch productivity
With the objective of garnering deposits and penetrating under banked areas
and population Indian banks are increasing their branch network .The
productivity of the branch is measured in terms of the profitability and the
business earning capacity of the branches of a bank. Ratios used for studying
branch level efficiency were:
Table-3.1
Managerial efficiency ratios (Productivity Ratios-) : criteria for analysis
Profit is the very reason for the continued existence of every commercial
organization. The rate of profitability and volume of profits are therefore,
rightfully considered as indicators of efficiency in the deployment of resources of
banks. Profitability indicates earning capacity of the banks. It also portrays work
culture and operating efficiency of the bank. The concept of profitability in banks
assumes greater significance in the present day context. Like any other business
institution, profit is necessary to the banks for their survival. A viable and profit
making bank reflects operational efficiency and effective and efficient resource
management. It is very difficult for a firm to survive without prospects and ability
to earn adequate profits. Profits and Profitability are, therefore, the nerve and
knot of a business. Lord J.M. Keynes remarked “Profit is the engine that drives
the business enterprises”. The profit earned by an organisation over the years is a
barometer reflecting organisational performance.
TABLE-3.2
Profitability Ratios:criteria for analysis
S.No Ratios Criteria
1 Net profit to Average Higher ratio is
Assets(ROA) better Operating
2 NNPA to Net advance(NET Lower ratio is performance
ADV.) better
3 Yield on Advances(RET ADV.) Higher ratio is
better Source of
4 Yield on investments(RET IN) Higher ratio is earnings
better
5 Cost of Deposits(COD) Lower ratio is
better Cost
6 Cost to Income(CI) Lower ratio is effectiveness
better
Source-Ernst &Young-Best bank Survey
• Operating performance
Net NPA to Net Advance-– Net NPA is the amount of gross NPAs
less (1) interest debited to borrowal and not recovered and not
recognised as income and kept in interest suspense (2) amount of
provisions held in respect of NPAs and (3) amount of claim received
and not appropriated. A lower ratio indicates better management of the
quality of assets.
Cost effectiveness
One of the major objectives of banking sector reforms initiated since
the early 1990s has been to improve the operating efficiency and
profitability of banks. Reduced costs basically translate to higher profit
margins. If banks can reduce costs, it can go a long way in increasing
profits. Cost effectiveness is analysed with the help of two ratios
namely Cost of deposits and cost to income.
lower the ratio, the more efficient are the operations of the banking
sector and vice versa.
Cost to income measures the income generated per rupee cost. That is
how expensive it is for the bank to produce a unit of output. The lower
the C/I ratio, the better the performance of the bank.
Growth
The aim of every organisation is to grow. Indian banking sector has
witnessed a high growth rate in all the important performance
indicators during the post liberalized era. Growth in key variables is
required for the sound performance of the banking sector. Increasing
market share in deposits is required to fuel the funding requirements
which will lead to increasing profits, assets and equity. Thus growth is
considered as an important parameter in the performance of banks. Six
ratios are included under the head Growth -Growth in deposits,
advances, Assets, Networth, Net profit and Net interest margin.
3.6. Conclusion
This chapter describes the importance of marketing in banking and
performance analysis in the present day competitive world. Bank marketing deals
with providing services to satisfy customers' financial needs and wants. To satisfy
these financial needs, customers want specific services. Service marketing mix
plays an important role in bank marketing. It consists of the various elements of a
marketing programme which need to be considered in order to successfully
implement the marketing strategy and positioning in the markets. All the service
marketing mix elements revolve around customers. Differentiating the services
from competitors is the principal requirement of every service organization.
Knowing customers' perceptions regarding services offered to them will help to
know their feeling about service marketing mix and relationship of these factors
with satisfaction will help marketers to decide marketing strategies for their
customers.