Professional Documents
Culture Documents
冉 冊
liner models to the readily available liners showed that the comple-
tion skin factor can vary by as much as 40%, depending on the k q
Fo,w = , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (2)
detailed characteristics of the slots or perforations in the liner (slot 2rwL
or perforation size, density, and distribution). The example showed or, in oilfield units,
冉 冊
that optimizing the performance of the completion can increase
k q
well productivity at little or no cost and with no loss in liner Fo,w = 1.64 × 10−16 , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (3)
mechanical strength. rwL
in which the geometrical factor 2 has been absorbed into
Introduction the constant.
The rate-independent skin and turbulence scale factors are ob-
The optimization of well completions to improve the inflow per- tained by integrating the Forchheimer equation along a flow path
formance of horizontal wells is a complex but very practical and for the particular flow field. Based on extensive 3D finite-element
challenging problem. What is needed is a means for engineers to simulation studies, the flow field is approximated by a series of
predict the skin values in wells under various conditions and to linear, radial, and hemispherical flow geometries, and analytical
suggest techniques to minimize skins and, therefore, maximize skin expressions are then obtained. Furui (2004) has presented
details of this derivation for various types of well completions.
Perforation Performance in Horizontal Wells
* Now with ConocoPhillips
** Now with Texas A&M U. The major difference between horizontal and vertical perforated
wells is the influence of permeability anisotropy and perforation
Copyright © 2007 Society of Petroleum Engineers
orientation on perforated well performance in the case of the hori-
This paper (SPE 90579) was first presented at the 2004 SPE Annual Technical Conference zontal completion. The perforation skin model developed in the
and Exhibition, Houston, 26–29 September, and revised for publication. Original manuscript
received for review 15 June 2004. Revised manuscript received 3 October 2006. Paper authors’ previous work (Furui et al. 2002) shows that perforations
peer approved 6 October 2006. should be oriented parallel to the direction of minimum perme-
ability to give the minimum perforation skin factor (the maximum Minimizing Formation Damage Effects for Perforated Wells.
perforation productivity). For most horizontal wells, this means Fig. 2 shows guidelines for minimizing the effect of formation
that perforations should be vertical, extending from the upper and/ damage for cased and perforated wells. The most important thing
or lower sides of the wellbore. 180° perforation phasing will be the is to perforate in the direction of minimum damage radius, rs(␣).
best completion technique for horizontal perforated wells, because Formation damage caused by drilling-mud filtration may be dis-
all the perforations can be orientated in the direction of minimum tributed elliptically in anisotropic formations. In previous studies
permeability. As a result, multidirectional perforation techniques (Furui et al. 2002, Furui et al. 2003; Frick and Economides 1993),
(e.g., 60, 90, or 120° perforation phasings) applied to anisotropic the minimum-damage penetration is assumed to be parallel to the
formations may not be efficient, unlike the situation for isotropic direction of minimum permeability (i.e., in a vertical direction).
formations. However, with sufficient perforation shot densities, a Perforating the upper or lower sides of the well can provide
multidirectional perforation technique can provide skin factors al- chances to bypass the damage zone, which minimizes the effect
most as small as a 180° perforation phasing. Multidirectional per- of formation damage. This is a significant advantage of cased
foration phasings may be preferable to 180° phasing because in the and perforated well completions compared to openhole and
former case the skin factor is independent of perforation orienta- liner completions.
tion, resulting in less risk because the perforating guns do not need Even if all the perforations are terminated inside the damage
to be oriented exactly. zone, the effects of formation damage can be less than those in
Fig. 1 illustrates a guideline for perforating horizontal wells. It openhole completions. The skin factor for perforations terminated
shows that the selection of perforation phasing depends greatly on inside the damage zone is (neglecting the crushed zone effect)
the degree of formation anisotropy. For highly anisotropic forma- (Furui et al. 2002):
tions, all the perforations need to be oriented in the direction of
minimum permeability to give the maximum perforation produc- k 0 s
sP = sfo + s + f F , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (4)
tivity, and hence 180° phasing will be the best completion tech- ks P  t,P o,w
nique. On the other hand, for slightly anisotropic formations, mul-
tidirectional phasings will provide higher perforation productivity where s0P is the perforation geometry skin factor and ft,P is the
than 0° and 180° phasings, a result similar to that for perforated turbulence scale factor caused by the convergent flow to perfora-
vertical wells. tions. Effectively perforated wells (i.e., s0p<0) provide a larger
冉 冊 冉 冊
crushed zone around a perforation is a region of reduced perme-
ability around the perforation tunnel created by the perforating h 公kykz 0.5
1 公10 0.5
process itself. Fig. 3 shows guidelines for minimizing crushed- hDe = = = 1.12 . . . . . . . . . . . . (9)
lp kx 0.5 10
zone effects for cased and perforated wells. As shown by Furui
et al. (2002), the crushed-zone effect can be expressed as, for and
冉 冊
perforations extending beyond the damage zone,
冉 冊
k rcz
k rcz scz = hDe − 1 ln = 1.12共10 − 1兲ln3 = 11.07. . . . . . . . (10)
sP = ŝ 0p + hDe − 1 ln , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (5) kcz rp
kcz rp
For 0° and 180° perforation phasings with perforations oriented in
and for perforations terminated inside the damage zone, the vertical direction (␣⳱90°),
sP = sfo +
k 0
s + hDe
ks p 冉
k k
−
kcz ks
rcz
冊
ln , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (6)
rp hDe =
h
lp公共kx Ⲑ kz兲sin2␣ + 共kx Ⲑ ky兲cos2␣ 0.5公10
=
1
= 0.63
冉 冊
Tariq 1991; Furui et al. 2002). The dimensionless perforation spac-
ing hDe is defined by, for 0° and 180° perforation phasings, k rcz
scz = hDe − 1 ln = 0.63共10 − 1兲ln3 = 6.23. . . . . . . . . (12)
kcz rp
h
hDe = , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (7)
lp公共kx Ⲑ kz兲sin2␣ + 共kx Ⲑ ky兲cos2␣
Using the 0° and 180° perforation phasings and perforating in the
vertical direction, skin caused by a crushed zone is reduced by
and for multidirectional perforation phasings, about 40%. Orienting all the perforations parallel to the direction
of minimum permeability increases the effective perforation length
hDe =
h
lp
冉公 冊 kykz
kx
0.5
, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (8)
and lowers the skin factor.