Professional Documents
Culture Documents
研究論文
In this paper, a Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation of real gas charged in accumulators is proposed. The Soave-
Redlich-Kwong equation is the most accurate real gas model for representing accumulator behavior, but it is relatively
complex mathematical equation. For simulating accumulator dynamic behavior, it has been used by combining with a
thermal time constant model. The mathematical procedure for the Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation for the adiabatic equation
is described in this paper. The Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation is discussed by comparing the van der Waals
adiabatic equation. By comparing representative gas models, the Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation is found to be
valid.
Key words:Gas-loaded accumulator, Adiabatic process, Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation, van der Waals equation, Benedict-
Webb-Rubin equation, Thermal time constant
the Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation. According to this condition, the van der Waals adiabatic
Section 2 is the nomenclature and section 3 gives equation has been founded:
( )
introduction of representative real gas models. In section 4, avdWm2
(V-mbvdW)=const ⑵
H
P+
the Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation is derived. In V2
section 5, the proposed adiabatic equation is validated by where the adiabatic exponent is expressed by:
comparing with representative real gas models. The R
H= +1 . ⑶
conclusion is made in section 6. Cv
3.2 Benedict-Webb-Rubin equation of state
2.Nomenclature
Gas pressure is related to gas temperature and gas volume
avdW : Parameter of van der Waals equation by the Benedict-Webb-Rubin equation of state11)-13) which
(
a T) : Parameter of Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation was shown to be in remarkable agreement with the data
b : Parameter of Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation published by the NBS for nitrogen14) for the entire range of
bvdW : Parameter of van der Waals equation interest for accumulator applications9). The expression of this
C : Constant equation of state is as follows:
Cv : Specific heat at constant volume
( )
C0
m2 B0RT-A0- 3
H : Adiabatic exponent mRT T2 m(b 0RT-a0)
P= + +
m : Amount of gas V V2 V3
⑷
n : Polytropic exponent m2γ -mVγ
( )
2
3
m c0 1+ e 2
6
P : Absolute pressure m a0 α V2
+ 6 + 3 2
Q : Heat energy V V T
R : Gas constant where A0, B0, C0, a0, b0, c0, α and γ are Benedict-Webb-Rubin
S : Entropy parameters.
T : Absolute temperature 3.3 Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation of state
U : Internal energy In physics and thermodynamics, the Redlich-Kwong
V : Gas volume equation of state is an empirical, algebraic equation that
v : Mole volume relates temperature, pressure, and volume of gases. It is
κ : Parameter of Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation generally more accurate than the van der Waals equation
ω : Acentric factor and the ideal gas equation at temperatures above the critical
Subscript temperature. It was presented by Otto Redlich and Joseph
0 : Initial value Neng Shun Kwong in 1949. It showed that a two-parameter,
c : Critical property cubic equation of state could well reflect reality in many
situations, standing alongside the much more complicated
3.Real gas models
Beattie-Bridgeman model15) and Benedict-Webb-Rubin
3.1 van der Waals equation of state equation that were used at the time. The Redlich-Kwong
Gas equation of state properly expresses thermal motion equation has undergone many revisions and modifications,
with considering mass of molecule. The accumulator gas is for either improving its accuracy in terms of predicting gas-
often modeled as ideal gas which does not exist. Ideal gas phase properties of more compounds, as well as in better
model fails to account for intermolecular force and molecular simulating conditions at lower temperatures, including vapor-
volume. The gas in the accumulator assumed to be ideal in liquid equilibria. The Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation fitted
many cases has shown to result in large errors9)-10). To experimental vapor-liquid data well and could predict phase
account for the volume that a real gas molecule takes up and behavior of mixtures in the critical region. The Soave-Redlich-
the intermolecular attraction, the van der Waals equation of Kwong equation of state is given by the expression:
state is formulated as mRT a T)m2 ,
(
P= - ⑸
V -mb V
( )
(V+mb)
avdWm2
⎩―⎨―⎧
P+ (V-mbvdW)=mRT where
V2 ⑴
1 9 2
avdW= vc, bvdW= RTcvc
⎩―⎨―⎧
⎩―⎨―⎧
1
R2T 2c
( )
3 8 T 2 , ⑹
a T)=0.4274
( 1+k 1-
Pc Tc
It is known that the entropy is constant in adiabatic condition.
RTc where
b=0.08664 , and ⑺
Pc
⎩―⎨―⎧
⎩―⎨―⎧
1 1
kR2Tc T - 2
( ) ( )
∂a(T) T 2 . ⒄
k=0.480+1.57ω-0.176ω . 2
⑻ =-0.4274 1+k 1-
∂T Pc T c Tc
The Pitzer’s acentric factor ω of nitrogen gas is assumed as
0.04. The super-critical cohesion parameters for the Soave- Combining Otis’s model of Eq.(15)with Eq.(16)and(17)
, it
Redlich-Kwong equation of state were adjusted by fitting is possible to mathematically analyze the accumulator gas
cohesion parameters to the reliable Joule-Thomson inversion charge and discharge processes by numerical integration.
curve data by Mehdi Ghanbari and Gholam Reza Check16):
4.Derivation of adiabatic model of SRK
⎩―⎨―⎧
T 2
0.480+1.57ω-0.176ω; ≤ 1 The Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation is derived in
Tc
k= ⑼
11 2 T this section as follows. First law of thermodynamics is
(0.480+1.57ω-0.176ω );T >1
15 c
expressed as:
The modified parameter k was fit with a coefficient of 11/15 dU=dQ-PdV. ⒅
for super-critical region. For the nitrogen gas using in gas- The entropy is defined as:
loaded accumulator, the operating temperature is commonly dQ .
ds= ⒆
larger than its critical temperature (126.2K)
, thus, the T
function of k with 11/15 is employed in this paper. Combining Eq.(18)and Eq.(19)yields:
3.4 Thermal time constant model dU=Tds-PdV. ⒇
The Otis’s thermal time constant model introduced a The volume partial differential of Eq.(20)under constant
thermal time constant τ to express the functional relation of temperature is:
( )
T T
dT T -T T ∂P dv ,
= wτ - c
dt v ∂T v dt ⑽
From Maxwell relations, we know that
(∂P/∂T)
v in the second part of the right side of Eq.(10)
. For Substituting Eq.(16)and the Eq.(5)into Eq.(23)yields:
the nitrogen gas sealed in accumulator, the mole number of
( )∂U m2a(T) Tm2 ∂a(T)
= -
nitrogen gas m is constant. Because the mole volume is ∂V T V(V+mb) V (V+mb) ∂T
defined as: The total differential of internal energy is expressed by:
(∂T
∂U
)dT+(∂V
∂U
) dV.
V
v= m , ⑿ dU=
V T
( )
dv 1 dV . 1 ∂U
⒀ Cν=
m ∂T V
= .
dt m dt
The condition of constant mole volume is identical to the Substituting Eq.(24)and Eq.(26)to Eq.(25)yields:
constant volume condition. Hence,
dU= (∂T
∂U
)dT+(∂V
∂U
) dV
(∂T
∂P
)=(∂T )
∂P . V T
⒁ 2
v V
m ∂a(T) dV
=mCνdT+ -T
a(T)
Then the Otis’s model can be written as: (V+mb)
V ∂T
1 ∂a(T)
mCν 1 m2
( )
-
dS= dT+ P+ V bCν ∂T
.
T T (V+mb)
V Z=
V+mb
( )
∂a(T) For calculating charge and discharge processes by the
× a -T
(T) dV
∂T Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation, it is necessary to
Substituting the pressure P of Eq.(5)into Eq.(29)yields: calculate temperature during the processes. To calculate the
mCν mR temperature, a function can be built by the Soave-Redlich-
dS= dT- dV
T V-mb Kwong equation:
( ) ( )
1 m2 m ∂a
(T) V-mb a(T)m2
+ - dV g(T)=T- P+
V V+mb b ∂T mR (V+mb)
V
Integrating both sides of the above equation yields: The temperature value can be obtained by computing the
1 ∂a(T)
root of the nonlinear equation:
⎩―⎨―⎧
⎩―⎨―⎧
R -
( ()V+mb )
bCν ∂T
V
+S0 ( =0
g T)
Cν
S=mCν ln T
(V-mb)
T=
V-mb
mR ( P+
V
(T)
a m2 .
(V+mb)
) (
P
C= 0+
V(V
0
a(T0)
0
m2
+mb)
H
(V0-mb)
)
(
1 ∂a(T)
)
( )
-
Substituting Eq.(32)into Eq.(31)yields: V0 bCν ∂T T=T0
×
V0+mb
( )
⎩―⎨―⎧
R
1 (T)
a m2 1+
Cν
S=mCν ln P+ (V-mb) Eq.(35)can be rewritten as:
mR (V+mb)
V
a(T)m2 C
=
⎩―⎨―⎧
1 ∂a(T) P+
( )
-
V
×
bCν ∂T V(V+mb) 1 ∂a(T)
+S0
( )
-
V+mb H V bCν ∂T
(V-mb)
V+mb
It is known that the entropy is constant for adiabatic The pressure P is expressed by:
condition. In Eq.(33)
, the constant entropy means that the a(T)m2 C
∴ P=- +
term inside the natural logarithm brackets is constant. V(V+mb) 1 ∂a(T)
bCν ∂T
( )
-
H V
According to this condition, the following formula is founded (V-mb)
V+mb
for adiabatic process: Combining the solution of the Eq.(38)for temperature, it is
possible to calculate the pressure of adiabatic process if the
( )
1 ∂a(T)
( )
R -
2 1+ V bCν ∂T
P+ ( a T)m corresponding volume is known.
Cν
(V-mb)
V+mb
(V+mb)
V
5.Considerations
=const
According to this expression form and substituting the Calculation of adiabatic process by the Soave-Redlich-
definition of adiabatic exponent H of Eq. (3) into above Kwong adiabatic equation proposed in this paper is carried
equation, the Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation can be out and the results are shown in Fig. 1. As an assumption of
written as: the calculation, it is assumed that the initial condition at the
( )
1 ∂a(T) point A is 34MPa, abs. in gas pressure, 2.67×10-3m3(2.67L)
( )
2 -
(T)m
a H V bCν ∂T
P+ (V-mb) =const in gas volume, and 293.5K in gas temperature. The top plot
(V+mb)
V V+mb
presents gas absolute pressure as a function of gas volume.
The volume term of the Soave-Redlich-Kong adiabatic By gas expanding, the gas pressure decreases to the point B.
equation(V-mb) is identical to that of the van der Waals In the middle plot, gas absolute temperature is shown. It is a
H
adiabatic equation. The pressure term of the Soave-Redlich- discharge process and gas absolute temperature also
Kwong adiabatic equation is slightly different from the decreases. In the bottom, the additional term Z of Eq.(36)is
pressure term of the van der Waals adiabatic equation. plotted. The term Z shows around 0.9 during this process.
However, both adiabatic equations include the product of a Parameters ( , b, and ∂a
a T) (T)
/∂T of the Soave-Redlich-
pressure term and a volume term. In the Soave-Redlich- Kwong equation are plotted in Fig. 2. In the figures, the
Kwong adiabatic equation, an additional term Z is included: parameter values of the van der Waals equation are noted.
During the discharge process, while the van der Waals
References
to be 15 seconds for the Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation and 7
seconds for the Benedict-Webb-Rubin equation. The value of τ 1)Wasbari, F., Bakar, R.A., Gan, L.M. et al.:Pre-charge
was also determined referring to experimental results. In this pressure effects on isothermal and adiabatic energy
discharge case, thermal time constant values of the Soave- storage capacity for dual hybrid hydro-pneumatic
Redlich-Kwong equation and the Benedict-Webb-Rubin are passenger car driveline, Proceedings of Mechanical
different, because of curve fitting. By discharge, the gas Engineering Research Day 2017,(2017:3-4)
(2017)
,
volume increases and the gas pressure decreases. The 2)Japan Hydraulics & Pneumatics Society:New hydraulics
calculated results of the Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic & Pneumatics handbook(in Japanese)
, Ohmsha, p. 350-
equation show a good agreement with the other 351(1989)
representative gas models. 3)Mohamed, K., Paraschivoiu, M.:Real gas simulation of
The Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation shows hydrogen release from a high-pressure chamber,
accurate calculated results of charging and discharging International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, Vol. 30, No. 8,
processes. From comparison of these results, the proposed p. 903-912(2005)
Soave-Redlich-Kwong adiabatic equation is successfully 4)Van der Waals J D.:The equation of state for gases and
validated. liquids, Nobel lectures in Physics, Vol. 1, p. 254-265(1910)
In the thermal time constant model, heat transfer is 5)Redlich, O., Kwong, J.N.S.:On the thermodynamics of
considered. Therefore, this model cannot simulate pure solutions; an equation of state; fugacities of gaseous
adiabatic process. Adiabatic assumption of gas equation of solutions, Chem. Rev., Vol. 44, No. 1, p. 233-244(1949)
state, which describes gas thermodynamic properties without 6)Soave, G.:Equilibrium constants from a modified Redlich-
transfer of heat, provides a conceptual basis in Kwong equation of state, Chem. Eng. Sci., Vol. 27, No. 6, p.
thermodynamics. In some cases, the thermodynamic 1197-1203(1972)
properties vary very similarly as adiabatic process, the 7)Otis, D.R.:New developments in predicting and modifying
physical process occurs so rapidly that there is no enough performance of hydraulic accumulators, National conference
time for the transfer of energy, thus the Soave-Redlich- on fluid power, p. 473-483(1974)
Kwong adiabatic equation can be employed to express the 8)Tanaka, Y., Nakano, K.:Energy balance of bladder type
assumption models. In this paper, as the comparison of the hydraulic accumulator(1st Report:Experimental investigation
Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation with thermal time constant of thermal time constant)
, Journal of the Japan hydraulic &
model shows, this equation can be used as a reference to pneumatics society, Vol. 22, No. 6, p. 666-672(1991)
study thermal time constant model combined with various 9)Pourmovahed, A., Otis, D.R.:An algoritm for computing
gas models. nonflow gas processes in gas springs and hydropneumatic
accumulators, Transactions of the ASME, Journal of
6.Conclusion
Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control, Vol. 107, p.
For commercial applications, according to equation of state 93–96(1985)
and operating conditions, accurate prediction of accumulator 10)Mohamed, K. Paraschivoiu, M.:Real gas simulation of
performance and design of accumulator size for efficient hydrogen release from a high-pressure chamber,
International journal of hydrogen energy, Vol. 30 No. 8, p. for fluids. I. Application to gaseous ethyl ether and
903-912(2005) carbon dioxide, Journal of the American Chemical
11)Benedict, M., Webb, G.B., Rubin, L.C.:An empirical Society, Vol. 49, No. 7, p. 1665-1667(1927)
equation for thermodynamic properties of light 16)Ghanbari, M., Check G.R.:New super-critical cohesion
hydrocarbons and their mixtures I. Methane, ethane, parameters for Soave-Redlich-Kwong equation of state
propane and n - butane, The Journal of Chemical by fitting to the Joule-Thomson Inversion Curve, The
Physics, Vol. 8, No. 4, p. 334-345(1940) Journal of Supercritical Fluids, Vol. 62, p. 65-72(2012)
12)Cooper, H.W., Goldfran, J.C.:BWR constants and new 17)Pourmovahed, A., Otis, D.R.:An experimental thermal
correlations, Hydrocarbon Processing, Vol. 46, No. 12, p. time-constant correlation for hydraulic accumulators,
141(1967) Journal of dynamic systems, measurement, and control,
13)Kerr, C.P.:Procedure Estimates Benedict-Webb-Rubin Vol. 112 No. 1, p. 116-121(1990)
Constants, Oil Gas J.;(United States)
, Vol. 84, No. 13, 18)Asami, T.:New method to determine the BWR
(1986) coefficients in saturated regions. Cryogenics, Vol. 28, No.
14)Jacobsen, R.T., Stewart, R.B., Hanley, H.J.M., et al.: 8, P 521-526(1988)
Thermophysical properties of nitrogen from the fusion 19)Miyashita, S., Zhang, S., and Sanada, K.:A study on a
line to 3500R(1944K)for pressures to 150,000psia(10342 mathematical model of gas in accumulator using van der
5 2
×10 N/m )
, US. Nat. Bureau Stand., No. NBS-TN-648, Waals equation, The 15th Scandinavian International
(1973) Conference on Fluid Power, SICFP’17. Linköping,
15)Beattie J. A., Bridgeman O.C.:A new equation of state Sweden:Linköping University Electronic Press(2017)