Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Lynn BabcockCimpello,MD,
DavidL. Goldman,MD,and Hnin Khine,MD
BRONX,NEWYORK
Normothermia
pathogens2 The antimicrobial action of fever ap- Acute phase reactants consist of a series of pro-
pears to be in part related to its effects on iron teins that are synthesized during infection and in
metabolism. Iron is an essential cofactor for many response to other injuries to the body. Increased
metabolic processes for both humans and patho- synthesis of acute phase reactants occurs in the
gens. To this end, pathogens have evolved liver within 8 to 12 hours of infection. Acute phase
elaborate mechanisms to obtain iron from the host. proteins (APP) include ceruloplasmin, haptoglobin,
Fever can increase the iron requirements of certain C-reactive protein (CRP), amyloid A, complement,
pathogens and at the same time inhibit their ability and fibrinogen. Concomitant with an increase in
to obtain iron from the host20 Fever decreases the the production of APP is a decrease in the
produc-tion of siderophores by bacteria. synthesis of certain proteins, such as albumin. The
Siderophores are molecules secreted by bacteria synthesis of APP is regulated by hormones and
that act as iron scavengers. In addition, the febrile cytokines, some of which are endogenous
response in-volves the production of acute phase pyrogens, (eg, inter-leukin-6 [IL-61 and tumor
reactants that decrease the availability of free iron necrosis factor [TNF]). During the febrile response,
to the invading microbe. serum levels of some APP are increased by only
Despite these observations, clinical evidence to several-fold (haptoglobin and ceruloplasmin),
support the hypotheses that fever is beneficial dur-ing whereas other APP serum lev-els can be
infection and that fever reduction is harmful remain increased by l,OOO-fold (CRP and amy-loids A).
elusive. There are several possible explana-tions for this. The functions of APP are incompletely under-stood.
Fever is only part of a complex re-sponse that has a CRP was initially identified for its ability to bind the
variety of redundant mechanisms, therefore, the clinical polysaccharide capsule of pneumococcus and can act as
effects associated with elim-ination of fever may not be an opsonin. CRP can be easily mea-sured in most
significant. Further-more, certain pathogens are more laboratories and is often used as a marker of disease
susceptible to temperature elevation than others. Fever process. Another marker of dis-ease processes, the
may be especially beneficial in infections caused by erythrocyte sedimentation rate,
these pathogens. On the other hand, fever may actually is a result of increased plasma concentration of
be detrimental to the hosts in certain circum-stances. APP, glycoproteins, and globulins. APP help the
Sustained increases in body temperature result in a body to destroy damaged tissue structures, control
dramatic increase (10% to 12% percent per degree infection, and aid in wound healing. APP also prob-
centigrade) in metabolic activity that is associated with ably help contain pathogens and their toxins, inac-
increases in oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide tivate both microbial proteases, and highly reactive
production. Fever is also asso-ciated with a substantial oxygen metabolites. Some APP bind to divalent
increase in heart rate (ap-proximately 10 to 15 beats per cat-ions, such as zinc and iron, and lead to
minute/degree cen-tigrade).*iJ2 These physiologic decreased levels of the cations in the plasma.
changes could be potentially detrimental to patients with During the febrile response, organs such as
pre-existing pulmonary or cardiac conditions or patients mus-cle and bone undergo catabolism. The overall
that are in extremis. pro-cess results in a negative nitrogen balance and
weight loss. Amino acids liberated from proteolysis
are channeled toward gluconeogenesis, and the
synthesis of APP and reparative proteins. In addi-
tion to these metabolic changes, the acute phase
AcutePhaseChanges
response is often accompanied by glucose intoler-
ance and the reduction of lipolysis as a result of a
In addition to the production of an elevation in body reduction in lipoprotein lipase synthesis in the liver.
temperature, the febrile response is associ-ated with a Fever also increases oxygen consumption and
cascade of physiologic changes known as acute phase carbon dioxide production, along with increases in
changes. These changes occur in response to a variety requirements of fluids and calories.
of stressful situations, includ-ing infection, burns, The activation of stress responses by the host
inflammatory conditions, and neoplasia. The role of organism is also part of the febrile response. This
these changes remains to be clearly defined. is associated with an increase in corticotropin
Nevertheless, evidence suggests that this response can releas-ing hormone secretion, which in turn
enhance the host’s ability to eradicate infection. These increases corticotropin and subsequently
changes include the pro-duction of acute phase glucocorticoid se-cretion. Increases in secretion of
reactants, alterations in me-tabolism, and alterations in growth hormone and aldosterone occur, along with
endocrine function.23 decreases in se-cretion of vasopressin.
FEVER PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
CIMPELLO, GOLDMAN, AND KHINE 87
4
ENDOGENOUS PYROGENS
IL-l, IL-6, TNF, IFN
+
CIRCULATION
f
PREOPTIC AREA OF THE
ANTERIOR HYPOTHALAMUS
I”:“““:“”
Via physiological and behavioral responses
biological activities, including the regulation of the acute fied. Both of these cytokines show extensive biolog-ical
phase and inflammatory responses.24 The pro-tean activities and possess considerable proinflam-matory
effects of EPs highlights the intricate connection properties. Early investigators were unclear as to
between fever and the host immune response. A va-riety whether the pyrogenic properties of IL-l were related to
of inflammatory cells, in particular circulating monocytes impurities, but the availability of recom-binant IL-1 has
and tissue macrophages, produce EPs. In the brain, helped resolve this issue. When human subjects are
astrocytes and microglia are responsible for the injected with either form of recombinant IL-l, fever and
production of EPs. The regulation of EP produc-tion is chills occur in nearly all subjects.26 IL-1 is an extremely
complex and contains both positive and nega-tive potent pyrogen, producing fever in humans at a dose as
feedback systems. Individual EPs can regulate their own low as 1 rig/kg. The febrile response to IL-1 is dose-
expression as well as the expression of other EPs. EPs related and at high doses, significant hypotension can
exert their effects through interactions with their own oc-cur.27,2s Some of the other physiological responses
specific receptor. Recently, a common receptor known seen after injection with IL-1 include increases in
as gp 130 has been described to in-teract with a group
of EPs. cortisol, adrenocorticotropic hormone and thyroid-
The first EP to be identified, IL-l, was initially isolated stimulating hormone levels, and decreases in
from activated leukocytes in a rabbit model of sterile serum glucose and testosterone level.28 Table 2
peritonitis.25 More recently, two forms of interleukin-1 shows some of the immunologic properties of IL-l.
(IL-la and IL-l@ have been identi- TNF is also a productof activated macrophages
FEVER PATHOPHYSlOLOGYI CIMPELLO, GOLDMAN, AND KHINE 89
and was initially identified for its direct toxic effects diotropin, and oncostatin M. Among these cyto-
on certain tumor cells and its ability to induce kines, the greatest amount of data exists for IL-6.
cachexia. TNF shares many of the biological/proin- IL-6 injection produces fever in rabbits but at much
flammatory properties of IL-l (Table 2) including the higher concentration than IL-l. IL-6 expression is
ability to induce fever. Nevertheless, TNF and IL-l greatly enhanced by TNF and IL-l. Elevated levels
do not share significant amino acid sequence of IL-6 have been found in various body fluids,
homology and bind to different receptors. The fever including plasma, cerebrospinal fluid, and joint fluid
pattern produced by injection of recombinant TNF of patients with arthritis, septic shock, infec-tious
is indistinguishable from that of IL-1.29 Both in vitro diseases, kidney transplants, and burns.34335 In
and in vivo studies indicate that TNF can induce IL- contrast to IL-l and TNF, IL-6 does not appear to
1 production and that IL-l can induce TNF possess proinflammatory properties. Nevertheless,
production, leading some to suggest that these IL-6 appears to play a central role in inducing the
cytokines work synergistically to produce fever.30 production of acute phase reactants.35,36
Interferons were initially recognized for their an-tiviral IL-2 has also been implicated as an EP. Admin-
activities31 and were the first cytokines to be used istration of recombinant IL-2 causes fever in
therapeutically in humans. Fever is noted con- humans,37 as well as increases in levels of
sistently with the administration of recombinant adreno-corticotropic hormone, prolactin, and
interferon (IFN) to humans. All subtypes of IFN, (a, growth hor-mone.3s The half-life of IL-2 is very
p, -y) have been shown to possess varying short and serum levels may be very low and are
degrees of pyrogenic activities.z2 The fever pattern generally undetect-able by the time the fever is
induced by IFN (eg, rate of rise and time of peak present. IL-2 may induce fevers indirectly, possibly
temperature elevation) differ from that of IL-l and through other cy-tokines such as IL-l and TNF.
TNF, but all are considered EPs.
Numerous other cytokines have been implicated
in fever production. Recently, a common receptor, The Hypothalamusin FeverProduction
gp 130, which can bind a group of pyrogenic cyto-
kines has been discovered.33 The gp 130 receptor Circulating EPs do not readily cross the blood-
triggering cytokines include IL-6, IL-2, leukemic brain barrier. Instead, EPs are believed to act indi-
inhibitory factor, ciliary neurotropic factor, car- rectly on the thermoregulatory set point by their
90 FEVER PATHOPHYSlOLOGYI CIMPELLO, GOLDMAN, AND KHINE
actions within the organum vasculosum of the lam- the hypothalamus and the brain stem to achieve
ina terminalis (OVLT).39-40 This region of the hy- an integrated response. The rapid speed at which
pothalamus is located near the preoptic area and is fever occurs after injection of cytokines suggests
a circumventricular organ. Fenestrated capillaries that it occurs by intrinsic neuronal pathways rather
that supply blood to this area of the brain allow the than diffusion of PGE, or other mediators.49
neurons of this region to be in close contact with
cytokines in the circulation. Injection of EPs into
the OVLT of cats and rabbits produced fever.41,4*
The UpperLimit of Fever
Ablation of this area reduced the ability of these
animals to produce fever after injection with endo- Although mild to moderate elevations in body
toxin or EPs.43~44 temperature can be beneficial to the host, severe
Within the OVLT, arachidonic acid metabolites elevations are likely to be detrimental. It is not
especially prostaglandin E, (PGE,), have been surprising that the body possesses mechanisms to
impli-cated for their role in producing fever (Fig 2). down-modulate fever and to limit the maximal tem-
PGE, levels are consistently elevated in the brains perature associated with the febrile response. Sev-
of ani-mals injected with EPs.45 Glial cells and eral clinical and laboratory observations support
neurons around the site of OVLT produce the the notion of an upper limit to the febrile response,
enzyme cyclo-oxygenase which is involved in the however the exact limit in humans has not been
production of PGE2.46 The greatest number of precisely defined. In the preantibiotic era, it was
PGE, receptors within the brain is found near the rare to see a patient’s temperature rise above 42”C.j’J
OVLT.47 Additional evidence supporting the role Today, with the advent of antimicrobial therapies and
of PGE, in producing fever comes from the antipyretic agents it is rare to see a patient’s temperature
observation that inhibition of cyclooxygenase by persist above 41°C with most febrile illnesses. Most of
the administration of agents such as aspirin and the clinician’s understand-ing of the effect of extreme
acetominophen result in the reduction of fever. temperature elevations in humans has been
The exact mechanism by which PGE, produc- extrapolated from fatal cases of heatstroke. In patients
tion results in fever is uncertain. It is believed that with heatstroke, tempera-tures can rise as high as 45°C
PGE, probably modifies the activity of the thermo- due to a failure of the
sensitive neurons in the OVLT to raise the set thermoregulatory center and heat loss mecha-
point. It is not clear if PGE, acts directly or through nisms. Temperature elevations of this extreme pro-
another neurotransmitter such as cyclic adenosine duce widespread organ dysfunction and damage
monophosphate, which is induced by PGEa.48 Once the including acid-base disturbances, disseminated in-
set point is raised, the hypothalamus is respon-sible for
travascular coagulation, thrombocytopenia,
coordinating the autonomic, endocrine, and behavioral hemor-rhage, and organ congestion.51
components of the febrile response. This requires Several mechanisms of maintaining an upper limit to
sending signals to different parts of the febrile response have been proposed including the
production of antipyretics, also known as endog-enous
cryogens. The existence of endogenous cryo-gens was
initially suggested by studies with pregnant ewe and their
offspring. 52 These animals were found to have blunted
Membrane Phospholipids febrile responses to endotoxin in as-sociation with high
levels of circulating arginine vaso-pressin (AVP).j3
Subsequent studies support the role of AVP as an
endogenous cryogen, although the mechanism of action
jLipoxygenase[ of this peptide remains un-known. Microinjections of AVP
into the ventral septal area of sheep’s brain results in a
\ reduction of endo-toxin-induced fever.54 Conversely,
Leukotrienes
conditions that cause decreased levels of AVP are
associated with increased fevers.55
Prostacyclins
*m--es
Another proposed endogenous cryogen is a-MSH, a
small peptide which is found in various regions of the
Figure 2. Pathway describing the production of brain. Injections of (-w-MSHattenuate the pyrogen-
prostaglandins by endogenous pyrogens. induced febrile response in animals.56 Furthermore,
injection of rabbits with antiserum to
FEVER PATHOPHYSIOLOGY/
CIMPELLO, GOLDMAN, AND KHINE 91