You are on page 1of 7

Leadership

DIMENSION

Spirituality as a Coping
Mechanism
Jacinta Kelly

Spirituality as a coping mechanism can be observed to be a powerful resource in the


provision of comfort, peace, and resolution for patients confronted with critical ill-
ness. While the exact machinery of spirituality in adaptation and adjustment to ill-
ness is enigmatic, the complementary benefits are clearly illustrated in the analysis
of recounted personal experiences. Analysis of interactions with patients living the
experience of coping with critical illness provides nurses with a means of reflection
and transformational learning which improves and preserves the spiritual heritage
of nursing care. Key word: Spirituality. [DIMENS CRIT CARE NURS. 2004;23(04):162-168]

Espousing to holism, nurses are philosophically disin- ity of patient care. Williams6 suggested that self-con-
clined to be wholly responsible for a part or partly sciousness (reflection) and continual self-critique (criti-
responsible for a whole, but rather view the person as cal reflection) are crucial to competence.
an integration of mind, body, and soul (Figure1). Wat-
son1 affirmed that health is unity and harmony of these DEFINITION OF SPIRITUALITY
three spheres and disharmony can extend to become The nebulous and complex nature of the concept of spir-
disease. Florence Nightingale2 emphasised that the ituality has made an agreed definition of the spiritual
needs of the spirit are as critical to health as those indi- dimension of care elusive.7 McSherry4 conveyed spiritual-
vidual organs, which make up the body. Regrettably, in ity as subjective, unique, universal, and mysterious. Caw-
nursing practice the spiritual needs of the patient are ley8 deemed it impossible to devise a standard definition
often neglected.3 However, spirituality is returning to due to the plethora of individual perceptions and inter-
healthcare because people believe in it and seek it as pretations. Wright9 affirmed that spirituality is not an
part of their treatment.4 Reflecting on a series of per- intellectual exercise; but a lived experience.
sonal interactions, this article analyzes the triad of spir-
ituality and the nurse-patient relationship in the context MEANING
of coping mechanisms in adaptation and adjustment to McSherry4 described spirituality as the desire to identify
illness. The anonymity of the persons subsequently some meaning and purpose in our lives and existence that
described is rigorously preserved. will assist us in generating motivation or purpose, which
will lead to a sense of fulfilment. Others10 have embraced
CRITICAL INCIDENT a liberated view of spirituality as whatever a person takes
Critical incident analysis enables practitioners to use an to be the highest value in life. Consequently, a dislocation
incident from practice, reflect upon it, and analyze it.5 or disconnection from one’s source of meaning in life can
It is thought that critical reflection may promote trans- result in a state of spiritual distress. Burnhard11 postulated
formational learning and ultimately improve the qual- that spiritual distress will possibly result from an inabil-

162 Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing Vol. 23 / No. 4


Spirituality

Figure 1. Integration of mind, body,


and soul.

ity to invest life with meaning; it can be demotivating and demonstrating that nurses on identification of patient’s
painful. spiritual needs, adopted a procedural and logical step
An elderly man hemorrhaged tears unashamedly taking approach.3 Prioritizing the concern of his angina
when I asked him if he was married. Struggling in his I was secure in viewing his care in a reductionist man-
anguish to be coherent he replied, “My wife died ner; all the while undermining the equal merits of his
recently of a heart attack in the car as I took her to the spiritual needs. Nicholls and Warner advised that work-
hospital.” He described his life as empty, pointless. ing with people as unique individuals rules out the pos-
Concerned with aggravating his angina I encouraged sibility of hiding behind uniforms and diagnostic
him to be calm; I skilfully changed the subject. I thought labels.13 Clearly the patient sensed my lack of spiritual
it was the safest option. Not wanting to impose, he obe- ‘where with all’ and retreated demurely. Existentialists
diently tidied his tears. described spirituality as a universal phenomenon and
suggested that the capacity for spirituality belongs to all
SPIRITUAL DISTRESS of us. I needed to develop skills to help patients in spiri-
Greenstreet7 described spiritual pain as manifested by a tual “dis-ease.” Waldfogl14 maintained that nurses need
deep sense of hurt stemming from feelings of loss, or sep- personal and spiritual maturity to help patients engage
aration from the individual’s source of spiritual suste- in the spiritual realm so that they provide better and
nance. The intense torment exhibited by the patient richer support to patients.
recalling the loss of his soul mate, summoned a need for
his spiritual dismay to be addressed. Fry12 lists the neces- SPIRITUAL AWARENESS
sary skills for delivering spiritual care as including active Neuman15 stated that spirituality permeates all aspects of
listening, attentiveness, genuineness, and comprehending a person, regardless of whether spirituality is acknowl-
the experience. Instead, I chose to distract the subject. edged or developed. Spiritual awareness may be sup-
pressed, remain underdeveloped, or lay dormant.16-18
SPIRITUAL IMMATURITY Thoresen19 believed that spirituality is inherent to the
Excusing my course of action with a barrier of medical human condition and as such is an inescapable part of
rationale I engaged an inauthentic and procedural our identity. Govier20 espoused the importance for nurses
mode. Narayanasamy and Owens presented studies to understand their own spirituality in order to assist oth-

July/August 2004 163


Spirituality

Figure 2. Observing boundaries (Adapted from Sheets, 2001).

ers. McSherry4 recommended methods to generate self- VULNERABILITY


awareness such as reflection, critical analysis and Relishing this experience, I regretted the many missed
appraisal of oneself and experiences. opportunities of connectedness that I prohibited into
my consciousness. Caring for the spirit implies relying
CONNECTEDNESS on the ability to stay with all that is weak and vulnera-
Burkhardt found that spirituality is experienced ble in the other-self and in oneself. I observed that by
through caring connectedness with self and others.21 giving more of myself I actually received much more.
Others have suggested that meaning can be found The therapeutic essence of caregiving is not a restricted,
through relationships with other people.10 one-way dynamic; quite simply, in giving, nurses also
Overwhelmed by the exhaustive nature of heart fail- receive.25 Nonetheless, I was conscious of the need to
ure the patient slumped defeated into her chair. She was maintain a healthy distance. While the therapeutic rela-
a farmer’s wife and scorned the title as it implied it tionship between nurse and patient creates an opportu-
earned her no recognition. I wondered at her wisdom. nity for nurses to connect, it also creates potential for
She smiled at my obvious grasp. I returned the senti- misuse, abuse, or taking advantage of the patient.26
ment. Feeling the trials of the morning wash she was too Observing situational boundaries I entered the patient’s
weary to talk; she reposed. I lingered, sitting silently by zone of helplessness moderately right of centre on the
her. It was momentary and rich. underinvolvement/overinvolment continuum (Figure 2).
Crossing a boundary to meet patient needs can be ther-
TRUST apeutic.
Brown and Pedder22 stated that seeking help from a
stranger is bound to arouse anxieties. Relinquishing the DEATH AND DYING
privacy of tending to independent personal hygiene dic- The severity of this patient’s illness hastened the need to
tated the need for a trusting relationship between this address her fears of death and dying. McClement27
patient and her nurse. This trust was not implicit. believed that caregivers need to risk involvement with
McSherry4 observed that trust will only be established if dying patients and their family, even if they are not sure
the nurse is both reliable and dependable. I established what to say or do. I associated a patient’s impending
trust and connectedness by making time for this indi- death as a professional defeat. Intensive care units are
vidual and engaging in simple exchanges. Spiritual com- designed to maintain life and it may be difficult for
fort gained by sharing with others, harmonious rela- nurses who equate the inability to cure with profes-
tionships, touch, security, and love can prevent isolation sional failure. Nonetheless, I felt that avoidance behav-
and loneliness.23 Due to the extent of her illness I knew ior would result in neglect. I was encouraged to view
the most potent medicine available to her was hope. her demise as a life event that is mutually inevitable.
Dyson, Cobb, and Forman10 stressed that developing The harmonious connectedness that I experienced
relationships of trust and mutuality can promote hope with this patient provided an informal bond that could
and inner strength. surmount the vicissitudes of life. More critically, care-
giver failure to drop the mask of professionalism has
MINISTRY OF PRESENCE been characterised as tantamount to inhumane treat-
I recognized that through a spirit of understanding the ment of the dying.28 Endeavoring to further enrich her
ubiquitous service of intimate care culminated in com- spiritual support I offered the patient the services of the
panionship. Wright24 concurred that ministering to chaplain. Kuuppelomaki29 recommended that the chap-
patients’ spiritual needs is not about performing rituals lain’s services are of crucial importance with respect to
with them, but learning to understand their belief sys- a dying patient’s spiritual needs and responding to those
tems so that you can say or do the right thing at the needs.
right time.24 I acknowledged an unstilted silence, an
opportunity simply to “be there,” to minister presence. TRANSCENDENCE
McSherry4 observed that it only takes a minute to sow Tanyi30 clarified the benefits of spirituality/religion as
the seeds of trust and respect. an awareness and acceptance of hardship and mortal-

164 Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing Vol. 23 / No. 4


Spirituality

ity, a heightened sense of physical well-being, and the in which language is regarded as the highest form of
ability to transcend beyond the infirmities of existence. communication.36 I sensed that the spoken form of com-
In adopting a transcendent approach, spirituality could munication, though physically possible, was not avail-
be argued to provide a mental attitude that promotes able to the patient in this uncaring environment. To
health.31 Spiritual coping strategies such as relationship transcend her spiritual vulnerability the patient sang.
with friends, family, God/nature may help the individ- Evans suggested that while the evidence is limited music
ual to transcend beyond the self to reach a higher appears to improve mood and tolerance and it may act
power, resulting in self-empowerment and ability to as a distracter during unpleasant procedures.37 My will-
cope with the stressful situation.32 ingness to allay her fears was vocalized as we chanted.
Miller38 stated that nurses need to be self-aware and to
identify our own style of communication and under-
The nebulous and complex nature of the stand how to modify it for our interactions with
concept of spirituality has made an patients when necessary.
agreed definition of the spiritual Religion
dimension of care elusive. Matthews defined religious commitment as the partici-
pation in, or endorsement of practices, beliefs, attitudes,
or sentiments that are associated with an organized
SPIRITUAL CRISIS community of faith.39 The secularization of Western
Wilkinson33 affirmed that nursing is not just technical society has contributed to a view that sees any signs of
rationality. However, the emphasis of this patient’s care religious belief as purely and simply symptomatic of
was placed on the task of repositioning.33 Mitchell madness.13 Florence Nightingale believed that spiritual-
argued that to provide spiritual care, nurses need to be ity is intrinsic to the human experience, in contrast to
less mechanical and more compassionate.34 A dearth of psychiatrists such as Freud who viewed religion as
empathy was clearly evident to me. Wright documented pathological.40 Nonetheless, intrinsic belief-related
high levels of stress and burnout among healthcare pro- aspects of religion and the extrinsic participatory and
fessionals, especially nurses.24 Turner attributed com- social aspects, might be important elements of people’s
passion fatigue to the constant exposure to tragedy and lives.41 Religious belief or spirituality can be part of find-
human frailty that desensitises us and we become emo- ing that “center” of calmness and peace which is vital
tionally anaesthetised.35 Alternatively, I considered com- to recovery.13
passion fatigue to be a spiritual crisis. Wright illustrated Having sustained multiple injuries a young Jehovah
spiritual crisis in our work as a crisis of meaning where witness refused blood products and complicated the
so many values seem to be turned on their heads, such course of his illness. Though his illness was protracted,
as throughput and cost effectiveness, overtaking, car- his mood was never somber or subdued. His resilience
ing, and compassion.9 In a high-tech environment atten- to pain was remarkable; his complacency arresting. His
tion to machines and alarms often takes precedence. family prayed with him at his bedside. Although both
McSherry23 observed that with the numerous advances his legs were amputated, he felt fortunate that he could
in scientific and medical technology nursing has become still join his hands in prayer. A psychiatric review was
more complex and the relevance of spirituality has obtained.
tended to be diluted and sometimes lost. McSherry
observed that the technological aspects of care some- PRAYER
times overshadow the concerns for spiritual and Due to the extent of his injuries I had a rational expec-
humanitarian need. Of course I accepted that nurses tation that this patient would experience pain. How-
must have the technical skills to care for their patients, ever, Neuman explained that spirituality controls the
but others have implied that if they go beyond simply mind and the mind controls the body.15 Because of his
performing tasks and make an effort to recognize the disfigurement I expected the patient to be depressed
individuality and value of each patient, the spirituality and angry. Yet, despite his suffering due to his disfig-
of both will be enhanced.18 urement he showed more resolve in his religious con-
victions. I viewed his response as inappropriate. Alter-
COMMUNICATION natively, Hilton proposed that religious beliefs might
Greenstreet contended that it is through communica- influence one’s perception of their illness and their abil-
tion skills that nurses will access their patients’ spiritual ity to cope with it.42 As I observed his community
needs.7 However, Allan added that we live in a culture prayer at his bedside, like Holt-Ashley and Lindquist, I

July/August 2004 165


Spirituality

Figure 3. Spiritual journey to self-actualization.

had to concede that prayer as a complimentary prac- their patient.23 By contrast, the family took my hand in
tice was healing and comforting.43 Prayer can offer gratitude and I knew that indirectly I had given spiri-
solace, inner strength, and resolution to deal with chal- tual support.
lenging situations. Wright stated that upward of 60%
of the population pray regularly to worship, to request FAITH AND HOPE
and most commonly to move closer to God.24 I was Nurses are fairly good at dealing with the ritualistic
concerned that the other patients might view this pray- aspects of religions. I respected his wish not to receive
ing as proselytizing. Holt-Ashley and Linquist argued blood products. However, Ameling and Povilonis high-
that spirituality should not be relegated to churches, lighted the point that to know a person’s religion does
temples, and mosques but should be an integral part of not necessarily reveal all there is to know about their
the work environment.43 The International Code of spiritual selves or how they find meaning in life.45 While
Ethics (ICN) agreed that in providing care, the nurse I viewed his rigid religious beliefs as self-destructive, I
should promote an environment in which human appreciated his faith as a means of self-actualization
rights, values, customs, and spiritual beliefs of the indi- (Figure 3). McSherry contended that it is the nurse’s role
vidual, family, and community are respected.44 I to assist individuals to make sense and find meaning in
motioned his family and friends to pray with the times of crisis.4 I was assured that his strong family sup-
patient. McSherry affirmed that nurses feel inade- port reinforced his faith. Kuuppelomaki argued that not
quately prepared to address the spiritual concerns of all patients want to receive spiritual support from the

166 Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing Vol. 23 / No. 4


Spirituality

nursing staff.29 Nonetheless, it was evident that I needed was exemplified by the disportionate attention dedi-
a daily measure of his and his family’s faith to ensure cated to the technical aspects of patient care, cascading
that hope was sustained. Although hope has long been in a spiritual crisis for both patient and nurse. Religion
recognized as a significant factor in patient recovery and and prayer were expressed as formal spiritual resources
survival, the phenomenon receives little attention until and were shown to be instrumental in providing the
the patient becomes hopeless. Faith is the inseparable family with a means to petition and intercede for their
companion of hope, without faith there is no hope and loved one. Faith in a higher God or divine power was
where there is no hope, faith disintegrates.46 demonstrated to culminate in the patient and family’s
self-actualization of hope.
IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE In this article, reflection provided a means of
• Understanding the spiritual dimension of human achieving a patient-centered approach by improving
experience is paramount to nursing, because nursing and developing the synergistic relationship between
is a practice-based discipline interested in human con- nurse and patient. Furthermore, it was demonstrated
cerns. that interactional analysis can weave theory to practice
• Spiritual needs should be assessed, directly, through effecting transformational learning; ensuring the
questioning, and indirectly, through observation. integrity of nursing’s spiritual and holistic heritage, and
• Spiritual assessment must be an ongoing, continuous ultimately improving the quality of patient care.
process.
• While spiritual care is not an added extra, rather an
essential part of care; it also has to be respected that References
not all patients need or want spiritual care. 1. Watson J. Human Science and Human Care. New York, NY:
National League for Nursing; 1988.
• Patients may be self-sufficient, or may have called on 2. Nightingale F. Notes on Nursing: What it is and What it is
friends and family for help with their concerns. Not. East Norwalk, Ct: Appleton and Lange; 1846.
• A greater appreciation of the diversity of religious 3. Narayanasamy A, Owens J. A critical incident study of nurses’
responses to the spiritual needs of their patients. J Advan Nurs.
beliefs is required to interact positively with patients. 2001;33(4):446-455.
• Stereotyping of patients in terms of religious and cul- 4. McSherry W. Making Sense of Spirituality in Nursing Practice:
tural needs may lead to the rigid application of reli- An Interactive Approach. London, England: Churchill Living-
stone; 2000.
gious practices. Therefore, there is a move away from 5. Burns S, Bulman C. Reflective Practice in Nursing. The
emphasis on religiosity to increased awareness of Growth of the Professional Practitioner. 2nd ed. London, Eng-
individuality in spiritual care. land: Blackwell Science; 2000.
6. Williams B. Developing critical reflection for professional
• There is a need for multidisciplinary involvement practice through problem-based learning. J Advan Nurs.
between chaplains, doctors, and allied health profes- 2001;34(1):27-34.
sionals. 7. Greenstreet WM. Teaching spirituality in nursing: A literature
review. Nurse Educ Today. 1999;19:649-658.
• The challenge of burnout is to treat it for what it is— 8. Cawley N. An exploration of the concept of spirituality. Int J
a spiritual crisis. The effective treatment may call for Palliative Nurs. 2000; 3(1):31-36.
spiritual renewal or awakening of the soul. 9. Wright SG. Faith, hope and clarity. Nursing Standard.
2002;17(6):22-23.
10. Dyson J, Cobb M, Forman D. The meaning of spirituality: a
CONCLUSION literature review. J Advan Nurs. 1997;26:1183-1188.
While complexities regarding the concept of spirituality 11. Burnhard P. Spiritual distress and the nursing response: theo-
retical considerations and counselling skills. J Advan Nurs.
were acknowledged, the complimentary benefit of spiri- 1987;12:377-382.
tuality in adaptation and adjustment to illness was 12. Fry A. Spirituality, communication and mental health nursing:
shown to be irrefutable. Analysis of the issues indicated the tacit interdiction. Australian and New Zealand Journal of
Mental Health Nursing. 1998;7: 25-32.
that spiritual distress was devastating and required 13. Nicholls V, Warner L. Spirit of understanding. Mental Health
deliberate and insightful attention from a spiritually Nurs. 2000;20(1):9-10.
mature practitioner. The evidence clearly suggested that 14. Waldfogel S. Spirituality in medicine. Compliment Alternat
Ther Primary Care. 1997;24:963-975.
harmonious connectedness achieved through trust 15. Neuman B. The Newmans Systems Model, 3rd ed. Norwalk,
building, presencing, and effective communication for- Ct: Appleton Lange; 1995.
tified the patient’s personal coping reserves. 16. Carson VB, Soeken K, Shanty J, Terry L. Hope and spiritual
well-being: essentials for living with AIDS. Perspect Psych
Realization that nurses and patients possessed the Care. 1990;26(2):28-34.
common predisposition to vulnerability and mortality 17. Watson J. The Philosophy and Science of Caring. Boston,
lent a deeper sense of empathy to the patient’s experi- Mass: Little Brown, 1979.
18. Cavendish R, Kraynyak L, Horne K, et al. Opportunities for
ence. Transcendence was described as a means to over- enhanced spirituality relevant to well adults. Nurs Diag.
come discordant encounters. Spiritual aridity in nurses 2000;11(4):151-156.

July/August 2004 167


Spirituality

19. Thoresen CE. Spirituality and health: Is there a relationship? J 35. Turner T. Faith, hope and clarity. Nurs Standard. 2002;17(6):
Health Psychol. 1999;4(3):291-300. 22-23.
20. Govier I. Spiritual care in nursing: a systematic approach. 36. Allan K. A sense of possibility. Mental Health Today. 2002;
Nurs Standard. 2000;14:32-36. 4(7):218-221.
21. Burkhardt MA. Becoming and connecting: Elements of spiri- 37. Evans D. The effectiveness of music as an intervention for hos-
tuality for women. Holistic Nurs Pract. 1994;8:12-21. pital patients: a systematic review. J Advan Nurs. 2002;37(1):
22. Brown D, Pedder J. Introduction to Psychotherapy. An Out- 8-18.
line of Psychodynamic Principles and Practice. London, Eng- 38. Miller L. Effective communication with older people. Nurs
land: Routledge; 1996. Standard. 2002;17(9):45-50.
23. McSherry W. Nurses’ perceptions of spirituality and spiritual 39. Matthews DA, McCullough ME, Larson DB, et al. Religious
care. Nurs Standard. 1998;13:36-40. commitment and health status: a review of research and impli-
24. Wright SG. Examining the impact of spirituality on nurses and cations for family practice. Arch Family Med. 1998;7:118-124.
health care provision. Professional Nurse. 2002;17(12):709. 40. Weaver A. An analysis of research on religious and spiritual
25. Kendrick KD, Robinson S. Spirituality: its relevance and pur- variables in three major mental health nursing journals. Issues
pose for clinical nursing in a new millennium. J Advan Nurs. Mental Health Nurs. 1998;19(3):263-276.
2000;9(5):701-705. 41. Cutlcliffe JR, Herth KA. The concept of hope in nursing: hope
26. Sheets VR. Professional boundaries: staying in the lines. and critical care nursing. B J Nurs. 2002;11(18):1191-1195.
Dimens Crit Care Nurs. 2001;20(5):36-40. 42. Hilton C. Religious beliefs and practices in acute mental health
27. McClement S. Expert nursing behaviors in the care of the patients. Nurs Standard. 2002;16(38):33-36.
dying adult in intensive care unit. Heart Lung: J Acute Crit 43. Holt-Ashley M, Lindquist R. Nurses pray: use of prayer and
Care. 1995;24(5):408-419. spirituality as a complimentary therapy in the intensive care
28. Ufema J. Dare to care for the dying. AJN. 1976;76:88-90. setting. Compliment Alternative Ther. 2000;11(1):60-67.
29. Kuuppelomaeki M. Spiritual support for terminally ill 44. International Code of Ethics. Code of Ethics for Nurses.
patients: nursing staff assessments. J Clin Nurs. 2001:10:660- Geneva: ICN; 2000.
670. 45. Ameling A, Povilonis M. Spirituality, meaning, mental health
30. Tanyi RA. Towards clarification of the meaning of spirituality. and nursing. J Psychosoc Nurs. 2001;39(4):15-20.
J Advan Nurs. 2002;39(5):500-509. 46. Benzein E, Norberg A, Saveman BI. Limitations of the coher-
31. Coyle J. Spirituality and health: Towards a framework for ence scale in Swedish Pentacostal population. Scandinavian J
exploring the relationship between spirituality and health. J Caring Scien. 1998;11(3):139-144.
Advan Nurs. 2002;37(6):589-597.
32. Baldacchino D, Draper P. Spiritual coping strategies: a review
of the nursing research literature. J Advan Nurs. 2001;34(6): ABOUT THE AUTHOR
833-841. Jacinta Kelly is presently completing a post-graduate course in criti-
33. Wilkinson J. Implementing reflective practice. Nurs Standard. cal care studies at Waterford Regional Hospital in Waterford, Ireland.
1999;13(21):36-40.
34. Mitchell V. A loss of compassion. Nurs Standard. 2003: Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Jacinta Kelly, Bridge
17(18):23. Street, Cahir Co, Tipperary, Ireland (Amnesia104@hotmail.com).

How
To Reach Us
Have comments, questions, or reactions to articles in Dimensions of Critical
Care Nursing? Write to us at 530 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, PA 19106-3621 or send
e-mail to Vickie Miracle, RN, EdD at vmiracle@aol.com. Please include your mailing
address.
Want to submit a manuscript? See author guidelines on
http://www.dccnjournal.com, our Web site. If you have questions about a topic, send a
topic query letter to Vickie Miracle, RN, EdD at 424 Eastgate Village Wynde, Louisville,
KY 40223 or e-mail at vmiracle@aol.com.
Subscription inquiries? Call 1-866-588-3751.
Want to see our Web site? Visit us on the Internet at http://www.dccnjournal.com to
access a variety of useful information.
Thanks for your interest in Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing. We’ll make every
effort to be sure you’re satisfied with the service you get from us.

168 Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing Vol. 23 / No. 4

You might also like