You are on page 1of 5

Demolition of

concrete structures
Bringing it down—safely
BY HAL T. HUDGINS
PRESIDENT
HUDGINS & COMPANY, INC.
DEMOLITION SPECIALISTS
ATLANTA, GEORGIA

wrecking ball, weighing up to 13,500

T
he demolition contractor is a
specialist in wrecking or de- pounds, which is either dropped
stroying buildings safely. With onto or swung into the element to
careful planning, he can make the be demolished (Figure 1). Concrete Figure 1. Wrecking balls weighing as
job look easy, and by selecting the members can be broken into small much as 13,500 pounds can be used
pieces, but secondary cutting of re- to demolish structures as high as 20
right demolition method he also
inforcing may be necessary. stories. Controlling the swing of the
makes the job profitable. ball is important; missing the target
Most contractors, even though The ball and crane method of de-
may tip or overload the crane and a
not demolition specialists, will have molition has certain disadvantages: mild swing-back may cause the ball to
to demolish portions of stru c t u re s • it demands a great deal of skill hit the crane boom.
as part of their repair and remodel- from the crane operator
ing business. Knowing which
method or combination of methods • the height of a building that can
be demolished is limited by crane the crane and a wild swing-back
to use for demolition of reinforced may cause the ball to hit the boom.
or prestressed concrete stru c t u re s size and working room; howe ve r,
buildings as high as 20 stories The safety hazards of cranes oper-
is essential for a safe and profitable ating near electrical wires are well
job. have been demolished
known. The absolute limit of ap-
Because of the difficulty of esti- • the breakup process can cause proach for a crane boom near a
mating the costs of demolition of considerable dust, vibration and power line is 10 feet. A signalman
concrete, the general contractor is noise which may be objection- must be assigned to warn the oper-
usually well-advised to engage the able. ator when he is nearing the limit of
services of a competent demolition The National Association of De- approach.
contractor when his job requires a molition Contractors provides guid-
significant amount of demolition. ance for the safe operation of a Dismantling
Selection of the best method or crane using a wrecking ball. The ball Selective or complete demolition
methods depends partly on time weight should not exceed 50 per- of concrete structures is possible by
and money available and on the cent of the safe load of the boom at cutting elements and then removing
surrounding environment. The fol- maximum length or angle of opera- them with a crane. The cutting
lowing discussion of methods used tion, or 25 percent of the nominal process may be by sawing, water jet-
is based primarily on my own expe- breaking strength of the supporting ting or thermic lance. Because the
rience, but I have also relied upon line, whichever is less. The demoli- surface of the cut concrete is
the experience of others and data tion ball should be attached to the smooth and relatively regular, these
provided by manufacturers of de- load line with a swivel-type connec- methods have particular applica-
molition equipment. tion to prevent twisting of the load tion when the objective is partial de-
Ball and crane line. Taglines may help control the molition, for instance in the cre-
ball during the swinging operation. ation of openings in walls and slabs.
This is one of the oldest and most Smoothness in controlling the In the case of the lance, howe ve r, ex-
commonly used methods for build- swing of the ball is important; miss- cessive heat causes some deteriora-
ing demolition. A crane uses a ing the target may tip or overload tion of the concrete adjacent to the
cutting jet. Cutting with a water jet d e l i ve ring 100 to 20,000 foot-
minimizes dust and eliminates vi- pounds of energy at a frequency of
bration and fire hazards. An abra- 300 to 800 blows per minute (Figure
sive and water-catching system is 3). The advantages of a machine-
required to clean up during the jet- mounted breaker may include a
ting process. telescoping boom for easy reach
The water jet can be used not on- and maneuve ra b i l i t y, remote con-
ly for cutting straight lines but also trol operation and underwater de-
contours, a useful feature for cutting molition capabilities. Some of the
access manholes. Straight-line cut smaller remote-controlled ma-
rates on the order of 1 inch penetra- chines can be lifted through window
tion per minute are possible for re- openings and used inside a building
inforced concrete slabs. to demolish floors and walls.
A thermic lance is created by Productivity can vary greatly de-
packing a seamless mild steel tube pending on hammer size, type of
with low carbon rods and passing concrete, amount of reinforcing and
oxygen through the tube. Once the working conditions. For unrein-
lance is ignited, fusion will take forced concrete, breakout rates may
place creating a temperature be- be as low as 10 cubic yards to as high
tween 4000 and 7000 degrees F as 1000 cubic yards per 8-hour day.
which is capable of burning through Breakout rates for reinforced con-
concrete up to 12 feet thick. A 2- crete (larger hammer required for
inch-diameter horizontal hole can reinforced versus unreinforced con-
be bored in concrete at a typical rate crete) vary from 13 to 750 cubic
of 2 to 3 inches per minute. yards per 8-hour day. The Dodge
Figure 2. A special 72-inch-di-
The presence of reinforcing steel Public Works and Cost Guide indi-
ameter saw was manufactured
is an advantage for thermic demoli- cates a productivity of 12 cubic
to dismantle the 33-inch-thick
tion, since this provides extra steel yards per 8-hour day using hand-
beams of this cantilevered sky-
that can be oxidized to melt the con- held breakers (jackhammers).
walk. Each dismantled seg-
c re t e. Work may also be facilitated Machine-mounted breakers are
ment weighs 7 tons.
by following the path of re i n f o rc e- usually noisy, generate dust and vi-
ment. While this method eliminates bration and may be restricted in ar-
vibration and dust problems, it cre- eas of limited work space. To keep
cut. Whatever the method used, the
ates other hazards associated with vibrations at a safe level, one Corps
cutting process isolates a particular
smoke and fire danger. of Engineers office places a 150 foot-
element so that it may be lowered to
Whether sawing, jetting or lanc- pound limit on the hammer energy
the ground for further breakup or
ing is used to dismantle the struc-
transportation to the dump site.
ture or its components, each ele-
Most objectives of controlled de-
ment must be safely lowered to the
molition can be achieved using
ground. Lifting hooks or special rig-
standard concrete sawing tech-
ging should be adequately secured
niques and equipment, including
to dismantled members. If existing
diamond tipped blades to cut rein-
lifting hooks or loops are found to
forcement. Specialized saws may be
be in good condition then they
developed to handle unusual pro-
should be used.
jects (Figure 2). Although sawing
produces negligible vibration and Pneumatic and hydraulic
dust, it may be noisy and require breakers
equipment to supply and clean up
A common piece of equipment
the large quantity of water used to
used for demolishing bridge decks,
cool the saw.
foundations and pavements is a hy-
Concrete up to 3 feet thick may be
draulically or pneumatically operat-
cut with an abrasive water jet. The Figure 3. A boom-mounted remote-
ed, boom-mounted breaker. Al-
heart of the abrasive-water-jet cut- controlled hydraulic breaker reduces
though small hand-operated
ting system is a small nozzle in the slab section prior to lifting with a
breakers are still used, in many cas-
which water is pre s s u ri zed up to crane. The slab section has been
es they have been replaced by ma- sawn free on two sides while it rested
60,000 psi and combined with solid
chine-mounted breakers capable of on shoring.
a b ra s i ves to create a high-velocity
and the subsequent hydraulic pres- then charged with an explosive
sure forces the wedge against the which is electrically detonated. Em-
two feathers. pirical judgment based on the skill
Forces as high as 410 tons can be and experience of the operator is
exerted against the feathers, which the basis for blasting design. Recent
expand and force the concrete to advances in blasting design include
split. Controlling the crack direction the utilization of recognized formu-
and the movement of the demol- las and calculations which deter-
ished mass may be difficult using mine the position, angle and depth
mechanical bursting tools. Addi- of the borehole, as well as the size of
tionally, when reinforced concrete is the charge.
being split, it is almost always nec-
essary to utilize a hydraulic or pneu-
matic breaker, either hand-held or
machine-mounted to expose the re-
inforcing bars for cutting. Figure 4
shows how to use a splitter to break
a reinforced concrete wall.
Although they are more costly,
chemicals may be preferred for
p re s s u re bursting. An expansive
agent when correctly mixed will un-
Figure 4. The demolition of reinforced
concrete requires that both the dergo a large increase in volume
concrete and bond between the over a period of time. By placing the Figure 5. This bridge pier was cracked
concrete and steel be broken. The expansive slurry into boreholes that by nonexplosive demolition material,
splitter can be used on reinforced are located in a predetermined pat- an expansive powder added to water
concrete walls to break pieces at a tern, concrete can be split in a con- and poured into predrilled holes.
45-degree angle, providing access to trolled manner for removal (Figure
cut the reinforcing steel. 5). Within 10 to 20 hours, cracks are
generated by an expansive pressure
that can exceed 4300 psi. A simpler but far less effective
allowed for concrete removal on its The chemical agent is formulated method of blasting is to lay the ex-
locks and dams. to be used at a certain temperature; plosive charge on the element to be
any deviation from this temperature demolished and cover it with sand-
Pressure bursting will reduce the expected expansive bags. Another method, particularly
This method of demolition can be p re s s u re. Freezing the chemical useful for containers, is to fill the
classified into two categories, me- agent will greatly reduce its effec- s t ru c t u re with water and detonate
chanical and chemical bursting. tiveness. an explosive charge which has been
Pressure bursting with mechanical suspended at the center. The water
tools is fairly inexpensive, quiet, and Explosives transmits shock waves to the sur-
doesn’t cause vibration; but the Blasting methods employ rapidly rounding walls. Shaped charges for
drilling of holes for the insertion of expanding gases confined within a the directional cutting of elements
the splitter does produce noise and series of boreholes to produce con- are also available.
vibration. This can be overcome by trolled fractures which provide for Explosives are versatile and have
coring the holes with a diamond- easy concrete removal. In general, great flexibility in terms of work out-
tipped coring machine, but at far blasting methods are efficient put. Howe ve r, excessive ground vi-
greater cost. means of removing large volumes of bration may damage adjacent struc-
Mechanical bursting is done with distressed or deteriorated concrete. tures and air blast may cause
a hand-held splitting machine that But, due to dangers inherent in han- superficial damage such as window
operates on hydraulic pressure pro- dling and usage, blasting is consid- breakage elsewhere. The National
vided by a small motor. The splitting ered most dangerous and re q u i re s Association of Demolition Contrac-
end of the device is a steel wedge or more stringent controls than any tors states that the use of explosives
plug positioned between two hard other methods of demolition. to demolish entire buildings or por-
metal shims called feathers. Holes For the demolition of concrete tions thereof shall not be permitted
ranging from 1 to 2 inches in diam- structures it is usual to drill holes at unless there is sufficient clear space
eter are drilled into the concrete. a predetermined angle into the con- in all directions equal to 75 percent
The wedge is inserted into the hole crete to be removed. The holes are of the height of the building being
demolished. Precautions should be stances should walls be left stand-
taken to stop flying debris and in all ing overnight if they are not plumb
circumstances strict site control and strong enough to resist toppling Demolition of
must be maintained to ensure the by wind pressure. If wall stability is Prestressed Concrete
safety of workers and the general questionable, demolition should Demolishing prestressed con-
public. continue down to the nearest struc- crete structures can be more diffi-
tural cross member, or temporary cult than demolishing reinforced
Safety checklist shoring should be erected. In gener- concrete because of the energy
Whatever the demolition method al, no section of wall more than one stored in the prestressing tendons.
chosen, or the size of the job, safety story high should be left standing Prestressing tendons are like
is of prime importance. Fo l l ow i n g unsupported at any time unless it stretched rubber bands, with ener-
are some key factors to consider. was specifically designed to stand gy stored in the stretching process.
Services. Gas, water, electricity higher. The release of the stored energy in
and other services to the structure Structural members. When de- a rubber band causes it to sail
must be properly capped where molishing a structure from the top through the air. Likewise, the re-
necessary. Electricity or other lines down, no supports at a lower level lease of stored energy in a pre-
needed to aid demolition must be of should be cut or removed until de- stressing tendon may cause it to
approved heavy-duty construction molition at the upper level is com- sail through the air—as a danger-
and must be kept adequately pro- plete. Particular care should be ex- ous missile—threatening the lives
tected along a known path. ercised in removing load-bearing of workers. While a rubber band
Access. All movements of people beams and columns which tie into carries only small forces, a pre-
within the structure should be along party walls. When beams and stressing tendon commonly trans-
designated routes, that is, through columns are cut they should always mits forces in excess of 125,000
agreed doorways and stairways, or be well secured with wire rope or pounds.
along specially constructed walk- chains. If a large amount of debris
ways with fixed ladders. Removal of is expected it may be desirable to in- Methods of prestressing
debris should also follow an agreed crease the volume of ground-floor Two basic methods of prestress-
route. All other openings, horizontal space into which waste can be ing are in use:
and vertical, should be blocked off dumped.
• Pre-tensioning, in which the
completely to avoid danger from Worker protection. Workers must
steel is tensioned before the con-
falling material. Even openings always stand on a firm base while
crete is cast, transfers the pre-
needed for debris removal should carrying out demolition. Free ends
stressing force to the concrete by
be blocked when not in use. of cut members may be needed as
bond.
Loadings. Demolition may seri- work platforms and must therefore
ously change loadings from those be shored. • Post-tensioning, in which the
for which the structure was original- Other hazards. All glass and com- tendons are tensioned after the
ly designed. Any wall or floor that bustible material should be re- concrete has been cast and al-
will be required to carry the excess moved from a structure before de- lowed to harden, transfers the pre-
weight of stored material, or which molition begins. Removal of stressing force by means of end
will be subject to undue pressure asbestos and polyc h l o ri n a t e d anchors.
from waste, must be adequately biphenyls (PCBs) must be done in Pre-tensioning is used primarily
shored to withstand the extra load- accordance with regulations set by for factory-made units. These may
ing. At no time should debris be al- the Occupational Safety and Health be subsequently post-tensioned
lowed to accumulate to a weight Act (OSHA) and the Environmental on site with additional tendons.
greater than a floor can carry. High Protection Agency (EPA). Each of Generally post-tensioning is ap-
impact loads from falling debris can these materials can be extremely plied to cast-in-place concrete in
be another source of unsafe load- dangerous to workers. which ducts are formed within the
ing. In general, no area of wall or members. The tendons are insert-
slab greater than 10 square feet ed in these ducts and then stressed
should be allowed to fall on any and permanently anchored.
floor at one time. The lower walls of Post-tensioned tendons can be
a building within which waste is al- bonded or unbonded. After the
lowed to pile up are particularly sus- tendon is inserted into the duct,
ceptible to the effects of a destruc- the space between the tendon and
tive loading for which they were not PUBLICATION #C870024 duct may be grouted for the full
designed. Wind loadings must also Copyright © 1989, The Aberdeen Group length of the member. This grout-
be considered. Under no circum- All rights reserved ing bonds the tendon to the duct
The demolition of prestressed
and the surrounding concrete, structures requires a thorough
hence the name bonded. Tendons understanding of the
for which the duct is filled with fundamentals of prestressing.
grease (to prevent corrosion) The underside of this slab
rather than grout are considered illustrates the prestressing
unbonded. force released by cutting the
Demolition of prestressed pre- tendons. Shoring is in place as
tensioned structures a safety precaution.
The total demolition of a pre-
stressed pre-tensioned structure is
no more difficult than the demoli-
particularly if the tendons are un- tendon and reinforcing bars
tion of a cast-in-place re i n f o rc e d
bonded. As this is a relatively new are located using magnetic detec-
concrete structure. Pre s t re s s e d
type of construction, few post-ten- tion devices. Once this is done,
pre-tensioned members are usual-
sioned buildings have been de- careful drilling, chipping or sawing
ly designed to resist applied load-
molished. Safe, uneventful demo- may be used to expose the pre-
ing in only one direction. Because
lition of relatively low stru c t u re s stressing tendons (Photo B). Then
of this, the members will fail rather
using a crane and a ball has been a hydraulic tensioning device is
easily if a force can be applied in
accomplished where there is ade- used to detension the tendon, re-
an opposite or lateral direction.
quate surrounding work space. leasing its force and allowing the
The partial demolition of a pre-
Howe ve r, the majority of experi- concrete member to rest on the
stressed pre-tensioned structure
enced contractors and engineers shoring.
requires more care than a similar
familiar with the problems and po- The concrete can then be broken
operation on a cast-in-place struc-
tential dangers of post-tensioned with either hand-held or machine-
ture. More attention must be giv-
structures suggest that they be dis- mounted breakers, or once com-
en to proper placement of ade-
mantled a floor at a time. This is pletely severed, reduced to a size
quate shoring, careful rigging and
true whether the structure is of which may be lifted and lowe re d .
lifting, and the avoidance of im-
cast-in-place concrete with subse- Because the concrete may contain
pact loads to the structure below.
quent post-tensioning, or of pre- no reinforcing steel, or only top re-
Pre-tensioned slabs and beams, or
cast, prestressed members which inforcing, the section must be
smaller dismantled portions, may
were also post-tensioned. rigged such that it can be lifted and
be lifted and lowered to the ground
Disassembly or from-the-top- lowered without causing the con-
as complete units (Photo A). Gen-
down demolition requires a large crete section to rupture from its
e ra l l y, any necessary shoring and
amount of shoring which must be own dead weight.
subsequent lifting should be from
installed along the entire length of Careful planning by competent
points near the ends of the units.
the members, unless intermediate persons experienced in post-ten-
Demolition of prestressed tendon anchors were installed sioning is essential before at-
post-tensioned structures during construction. Once shored, tempting partial demolition of
the slab and beams can be deten- post-tensioned structures.
The total demolition of a pre-
sioned—in reverse order in which
stressed post-tensioned structure
they were tensioned. Then the
presents a very different problem,
slabs and beams can be demol-
ished using those methods previ-
ously described, with the excep-
tion of the ball-and-crane method.
Partial demolition of post-ten-
sioned structures
The partial demolition of an un-
bonded post-tensioned structure
can be very complicated and haz-
a rd o u s. If “as-built” drawings are
not available, this operation can be
Photo B. Detensioning the tendon
even more complex. The original
releases its force and allows safe
s t ru c t u re drawings are used as a removal of post-tensioned concrete
Photo A. Sections of this precast, guide for the proper placement of sections. Here a laborer is chipping
prestressed double tee unit were shoring under each member. grout out of an anchorage pocket to
shored, sawed and lifted out. After the shoring is in place, the allow access for a hydraulic

You might also like