Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/241723999
CITATIONS READS
11 6,578
1 author:
Mohan Thite
Griffith University
91 PUBLICATIONS 1,406 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Global Talent Management via Skilled Migration and Services Offshoring View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohan Thite on 17 July 2014.
To cite this article: Mohan Thite (2012): Strategic global human resource management: case
study of an emerging Indian multinational, Human Resource Development International,
DOI:10.1080/13678868.2011.646896
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation
that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any
instructions, formulae, and drug doses should be independently verified with primary
sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings,
demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or
indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
Human Resource Development International
2012, 1–9, iFirst article
PERSPECTIVES
Strategic global human resource management: case study of an
emerging Indian multinational
Mohan Thite*
Department of Employment Relations & Human Resources, Griffith University, 170 Kessels
Road, Nathan QLD 4111, Australia
Downloaded by [Griffith University], [Mohan Thite] at 21:23 31 January 2012
With the growing importance of emerging economies, researchers call for the need
to pay attention to non-Western management models with a view to developing
an integrated approach. Using a case study of an Indian multinational firm in the
IT industry, this article highlights the key ingredients of its success in managing a
global workforce, such as diffused and empowered leadership, metrics and value
driven performance and reward management and strategic mindset of the human
resource (HR) function. It recommends an adaptive approach to global HR
practice that facilitates cross-transfer of best practices.
Keywords: emerging multinationals; India; international HRM strategies;
information technology services industry
Introduction
Thanks to the knowledge economy, today Strategic Human Resource Management
(SHRM) is seen to be a key competitive advantage and taken seriously in strategic
decision making. However, most of the best practice literature on SHRM is
grounded predominantly in a Western context, particularly with regard to the
multinational companies (MNCs), ignoring the fundamental changes underway in
the global economy (Ferner 2009). For example, the growth rate of the number of
MNCs from developing countries and transition economies, referred to variously as
the ‘new, infant, third world or emerging multinationals’, over the past 15 years has
exceeded that of MNCs from developed countries (UNCTAD 2008). Reflecting the
growing importance of Asia, the Asian MNCs dominate the list of 100 largest
developing country MNCs (UNCTAD 2006). China and India are two of the most
attractive inward as well as outward foreign direct investment (FDI) destination
countries (UNCTAD 2007).
In terms of Indian multinationals, 7 of them featured in Global Fortune 500 and
20 in Boston Consulting Group’s BCG 100 new Global Challengers (Sirkin,
Hemerling, and Bhattacharya 2008). In contrast to China, Indian multinationals are
largely private owned and cover a wide range of sectors in energy-related areas,
information technology (IT) services, pharmaceuticals, engineering goods and
*Email: M.Thite@griffith.edu.au
factors, i.e. ‘the need to pursue customers for niche products – for example, in IT
services – and the lack of international linkages’ (UNCTAD 2006, 25). In terms of
global excellence, the Indian IT firms stand apart as a stellar example of Indian
ingenuity and entrepreneurship. They are seen to be at the fore front in acquiring the
highest number of quality certifications and accreditations pertaining to IT services
sector. The top Indian IT firms have also pioneered end-to-end business service
model with development and delivery centres situated in a combination of on-shore,
near-shore and off-shore models (NASSCOM 2009).
The case study in this article pertains to one such Indian IT multinational
enterprise, Alpha Computers (name changed to maintain confidentiality). It explains
why and how Alpha has been able to become a world class IT firm by keeping its
intellectual capital at the core of its business philosophy and strategy. The article
begins with a brief theoretical overview of SHRM best practice literature. It then
describes the key elements of the corporate human resource (HR) philosophy,
policies and practices of the case study organization in order to explore whether and
how they mirror the best practices in the strategic global HRM literature. The article
concludes with a discussion on the implications of the case study findings for
international HR theory and practice.
. They aim to recruit the best talent available in the market by carefully
cultivating the image of a preferred employer.
. Their remuneration system is timely, performance-based and profit sharing. It
rewards and reinforces the competencies and characters valued by organiza-
tional members.
. Their commitment to employees is demonstrated in several ways, such as
continuous training and opportunity to work on challenging tasks.
. They develop organizational structures that revolve around autonomy, self
leadership and team-based learning and problem solving.
Downloaded by [Griffith University], [Mohan Thite] at 21:23 31 January 2012
Case study
Methodology
The case study organization was part of a larger research project on Indian
multinational firms. It adopts an ‘exploratory case study approach’ involving in-
depth interviews with the business and HR leaders of the organization at its Indian
headquarters and subsidiaries in both the developed market (namely, USA) and a
developing market (namely, China). A total of 15 interviews were conducted between
the period 2008–2009 with the senior managers across the global network of the
organization, involving eight business and seven HR leaders. All the interviews were
tape recorded and later transcribed verbatim. Even though the interviews covered a
wide range of topics, such as the company’s history and internationalization process,
its business strategies in developed and developing market subsidiaries, management
control and coordination between headquarters and subsidiaries and the evolution,
philosophy, global practices and role of HR, this article presents only the findings
related to HR processes, policies and practices of the organization.
An ‘inductive’ data analysis method was employed by extracting research
findings from the dominant themes that emerged from raw data. It involved three
steps: data reduction, data display and reaching conclusion via verification (Miles
and Huberman 1994). The research design employed adds value to international
HRM research by giving ‘equal weight to both the subsidiary level and to corporate
headquarters within a firm’ (Ferner 2009) as well as covering sectoral variables
(Colling and Clark 2002) by looking at different industry segments that the
organization operates in globally.
Please note that some sections of the data presented below are reproduced or
adapted from Thite, Wilkinson and Shah (forthcoming).
4 M. Thite
Overview of Alpha
Alpha was established as a private limited company in India in 1987 but today is a
publicly listed company both in India and New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). In
2010, Alpha was one of the top five Indian consulting and IT services companies
with a turnover of about US$ 2.5 billion from its operations in over 44 countries that
employ around 45,000 professionals. Alpha’s operations cover three business
segments, namely, IT services, business process outsourcing (BPO), and software
products, catering to a wide range of industry segments. It aims to be one of the most
valued global integrated IT services companies.
It derives its overseas revenue from the North America (59%), Europe (21%) and
Downloaded by [Griffith University], [Mohan Thite] at 21:23 31 January 2012
the Asia Pacific region (20%). The company has been aggressively diversifying to
other regions as well to spread its geographical diversification. It has its software
development and delivery centres in India, North America, UK, Brazil, Hungary,
Egypt, UAE, China Malaysia, Singapore and Australia.
The breadth and depth of Alpha’s world class organizational, technological and
people management excellence are demonstrated by a number of international
awards, accolades and quality certifications that include SEI CMM Level 5
Certification, ISO9001:2000, several national and international awards, such as Best
Employer and training excellence award from the American Society for Training and
Development (ASTD).
HR philosophy
In line with Alpha’s policy of decentralization, distributed leadership, employee
empowerment and non-hierarchical work environment, every employee in the
organization is known as an ‘associate’. Its leadership motto is ‘every Alphaite is a
leader’. Everything that the organization does is underpinned by its philosophy of
enabling leadership which has come to life around the core concepts of ‘full life cycle
business’ (FLCB) and ‘full life cycle leaders’ (FLCL). Alpha encourages employees
to ‘think like CEOs’ and accordingly they are expected to run their ‘business’ as any
CEO would do to achieve a reasonable return on investment in time, efforts and
money. As a consequence, the same performance metrics apply to every employee
and position, as explained later.
Collectively, it is known as the ‘AlphaWay’ of doing business. The AlphaWay is
more than a handbook that is distributed to every new employee. It is embedded in
the corporate DNA of the organization and is the common currency that circulates
across the length and breadth of the organization in its day-to-day life. Recognizing
that the greatest motivation for people comes not from monetary rewards but from a
sense of achievement, Alpha believes that by empowering every employee to be and
act like the CEO of their own world of work, it can retain people and engage them to
their full potential.
The Alpha School of Leadership brings this vision to fruition through continuous
learning programmes at its sprawling corporate training centre in India as well as at
its units throughout the world. Its mission is to develop 80% of the leadership
requirements from within. In the words of the Head of Leadership Development, ‘at
Alpha, the reward for a good job is a bigger job’, reflecting the organization’s desire
to enable and encourage employees to achieve their full potential. Alpha believes
that it is the ordinary people of the company who are capable of doing extraordinary
Human Resource Development International 5
things provided their talent is recognized, nurtured and rewarded. It uses star
performers to act as role models and spread best practices so that their collective
wisdom is distilled, institutionalized, automated and then spread across the
corporate DNA.
In order to produce these outcomes, the built measures ask the questions about
look beyond the boundaries of their tasks and departments in the interests of the
overall organization.
Flexibility is built into the metrics system to ensure that it is not rigidly
implemented irrespective of the situation. Employees have a say in what measures
apply to their position, why and how. The collaboration meetings take place across
different levels, and functions to achieve consensus before performance targets are
agreed upon both in terms of soft and hard deliverables.
Alpha is taking its metrics driven business approach beyond organizational
boundaries by involving customers and suppliers as part of its eco-system. The
customers are given access to the live performance monitoring database for all of
their projects. Similarly, suppliers are trained in how the same metrics can be applied
Downloaded by [Griffith University], [Mohan Thite] at 21:23 31 January 2012
Global staffing
Alpha believes that with over 45,000 employees spread over 40 countries, it is poised
to reach the next level in becoming a truly global company with firm local roots. The
statement from Alpha’s Head of HR in China that ‘Alpha wants to be a Chinese
company in China but provide the same global experience to clients, no matter where
the operations are carried out’ reflects this ambition. At lower levels, Alpha is
Human Resource Development International 7
committed to localize the workforce in its overseas offices to the extent possible but
this effort is somewhat hampered by many reasons, such as the need for cost
effectiveness in an offshored business model necessitating the bulk of project
execution in India, the diminishing attractiveness of IT as a career in the developed
world with fewer people opting to study IT courses and in some countries, the poor
perception of Indian companies as employers of choice.
As a policy, Alpha strives to staff locally at least 20% of all positions in all of its
overseas operations, 50% of entry level positions and 90% in its non-English
speaking geographies, such as China, where possible. With regards to lateral
recruitment (of experienced people), Alpha prefers local managers for their
knowledge of the local market and environment.
Downloaded by [Griffith University], [Mohan Thite] at 21:23 31 January 2012
Discussion
As can be seen from above, Alpha is well on its way to become a truly globalized
MNC with best in class organizational capabilities in its corporate strategy,
leadership vision, organizational structure and HR policies and practices. Alpha’s
process driven performance and reward management systems, global mindset and
strategic positioning of HR auger well in its evolution. Despite the liabilities of
foreignness, country of origin, newness and smallness that firms from emerging
economies face (Thite, Wilkinson, and Shah forthcoming), Alpha’s internationaliza-
tion process shows an ‘adaptive or polycentric approach’ in learning from and
embedding the best practices from its subsidiaries in global markets, particularly in
advanced countries.
8 M. Thite
voice’ which is the true reflection of the effectiveness of the HR function is missing.
After the data collection ended, a senior leader of Alpha was embroiled in financial
irregularities which severely dented the image of the organization and even though
the company bounced back later to regain its standing in the market place under new
management, it illustrates how shaky the foundations of a firm can be but at the
same time, it attests to Alpha’s resilience to emerge relatively unscathed from
unexpected shocks. Despite the above limitations, the case study illustrates that the
managers in the emerging economy firms are ‘mixing and matching’ progressive HR
policies and practices in a multi-polar world that only stands to benefit from cross-
integration of emerging business and people management models.
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by a grant from the SHRM Foundation, USA. However, the
interpretations, conclusions and recommendations are those of the author and do not
necessarily represent the views of the SHRM Foundation. The author would also like to thank
Alexandre Ardichvili for her helpful comments in the revision of this article.
References
Cappelli, P., H. Singh, J. Singh, and M. Useem. 2010. The India way: Lessons for the U.S.
Academy of Management Perspectives 24, no. 2: 6–24.
Colling, T., and I. Clark. 2002. Looking for ‘‘Americanness’’: Home-country, sector and firm
effects on employment systems in an engineering services company. European Journal of
Industrial Relations 8, no. 3: 301–25.
Ferner, A. 2009. HRM in multinational companies. In The Sage handbook of human resource
management, eds. A. Wilkinson, N. Bacon, T. Redman and S. Snells, 539–58. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage.
Gurjar, N. 2009. A practitioner’s perspective on the Indian info-services industry. In The next
available operator: Managing human resources in Indian business process outsourcing
industry, eds. M. Thite and R. Russell, 115–44. New Delhi: Sage.
Hamm, S. 2007. Bangalore tiger: How Indian tech upstart Wipro is rewriting the rules of global
competition. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Harvey, M., M. Buckley, and M. Novicevic. 2000. Strategic global human resource
management: A necessity when entering emerging markets. Research in Personnel and
Human Resource Management 19: 175–242.
Jonsson, S. 2008. Indian multinational corporations: Low-cost, high-tech or both? Ostersund,
Sweden: Swedish Institute for Growth Policy Studies.
Khavul, S., G.S. Benson, and D.K. Datta. 2010. Is internationalisation associated with
investments in HRM? A study of entrepreneurial firms in emerging markets. Human
Resource Management 49, no. 4: 693–713.
Miles, M.B. and A.M. Huberman. 1994. Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Human Resource Development International 9
NASSCOM. 2009. National Strategic Review, 2009. National Association of Software &
Services Companies. http://www.nasscom.in/upload/60452/Executive_summary.pdf (ac-
cessed December 21, 2011).
Pradhan, J.P. 2005. Outward foreign direct investment from India: Recent trends and
patterns. In GIDR Working Paper No. 153. Ahmedabad: Gujarat Institute of
Development Research.
Ramamurti, R., and J.V. Singh. 2009. Indian multinationals: Generic internationalization
strategies. In Emerging multinationals from emerging markets, eds. R. Ramamurti and J.V.
Singh, 110–66. London: Cambridge University Press.
Sirkin, H.L., J.W. Hemerling, and A.K. Bhattacharya. 2008. Globality: Competing with
everyone from everywhere for everything. London: Headline.
Thite, M. 2004. Managing people in the new economy. New Delhi: Sage.
Thite, M. 2010. All that glitters is not gold: Employee retention in offshore Indian information
technology enabled services. Journal of Organisational Computing and Electronic
Downloaded by [Griffith University], [Mohan Thite] at 21:23 31 January 2012