Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 - Design Against Creep PDF
2 - Design Against Creep PDF
Siraj Ahmed
Professor
Department of Mechanical Engineering
MANIT Bhopal
Contents
• Introduction
• Creep Test
• Presentation of Creep Data
• Stress Rupture Test
• Time to Rupture
• Creep under Bi-Axial Stresses
• Parameter Methods
• Larson-Miller Parameter
• Sherby-Dorn Parameter
• Manson-Haferd Parameter
• Stress Relaxation
• Creep Resistant Alloys
rupture is a burst, split, or break
Elastic
deformation Creep Chemical / Physical
Fatigue Electro-chemical degradation
Fracture degradation
Slip
Microstructural
changes
Wear
Twinning
Erosion
Phase
transformations
Grain growth
Particle
coarsening
An external force makes parts of the crystal lattice glide along each
other, changing the material's geometry.
Modes
of Torsion
Deformation
Bending
Mode I
Modes
of Mode II
Fracture
Mode III
The Tensile Stress-Strain Curve
Tensile specimen
Gauge Length → L0
P L
s= e=
A0 L0
0 → initial
Subscript
i → instantaneous
True Stress () and True Strain ()
P
=
Ai
L0 + L
L
dL L
= = ln = ln = ln(1 + e )
L0
L L0 L0
Due to collective motion
Yield point of many dislocations
Necking begins X
UTS
→
s →
e → →
Elastic region
Usually expressed as (for plastic)
Elastic + Plastic region
plastic = K
X Fracture n
plastic
UTS- Ultimate Tensile Strength
Variables in plastic deformation , , , T
= K n
K → strength coefficient
n → strain / work hardening coefficient
◘ Cu and brass (n ~ 0.5) can be given large plastic strain more
easily as compared to steels with n ~ 0.15
= A m
A → a constant
m → index of strain rate sensitivity
◘ If m = 0 stress is independent of strain rate (stress-strain
curve would be same for all strain rates)
◘ m ~ 0.2 for common metals
◘ If m (0.4, 0.9) the material may exhibit superplastic behaviour
◘ m = 1 → material behaves like a viscous liquid (Newtonian flow)
Plastic Deformation in Crystalline Materials
Dislocation climb
Vacancy diffusion
+ Other Mechanisms
Creep
Progressive deformation under constant load or stress at elevated temperature
Stress
Strain
Time
Introduction
Creep
progressive (time dependent) deformation of material
under constant load (constant stress)
under high or elevated temperature
Q
−
= Ae kT Q
d
= → Strain rate
dt Equilibrium positions of a dislocation
Time to
Rupture
Creep Behaviour
Primary Stage
• Movement of dislocation is very rapid
• Any barrier to movement caused by
work-hardening being overcome by the
recovery process at a decreasing rate
• Initial creep strain rate is high but it rapidly
decreases to a constant value
Creep Behaviour
Secondary Stage: Steady State
Work-hardening process of dislocation climb
and cross-slip shows straight line relationship
Slope of curve or
secondary creep rate
d s
s =
dt
Creep Behaviour
Time period during secondary creep stage is
very large in comparison to primary and
tertiary stages
• Shape of the creep curve for any material will depend upon
the temperature and stress level of the test
Cross-slip
Dislocation climb
Creep
Vacancy diffusion
Flow of vacancies
Secondary Stage
Arrhenius Equation
secondary creep rate
d s
s = = Ae − H / RT
dt
Combined Equation,
s = K e
n − H / RT
Effect of Increasing Stress or
Temperature on Creep Curve
Shortening
of
secondary
creep stage
and earlier
onset of
tertiary
creep
Effect of stress
Strain () →
Elastic strains
→
Increasing stress
0 increases
→ 0
0 0''
'
0 t →
Effect of temperature
Strain () →
E↓ as T↑
→
Increasing T
0 increases 0
→
t →
0 0' 0''
0.025(100)
Maximum percentage Creep Strain = 250
= 0.01 %
0.01
Minimum Creep Rate = 10000
= 1.0 x 10-6 per hour.
s
Example
Secondary creep strain rate data was recorded for lead
specimens during creep testing at a constant stress level of
1.3 N/mm2
Creep strain s = t n
= 87600 x 26 x 10-12x3.566
= 4.637 x 10-3
Total Elongation = s l = 4.637 x 10-3 x 1500 mm
= 6.96 mm
Example
Creep tests carried out on an alloy steel at 6000 C and
following results are observed:
Stress, Minimum Creep Rate,
kN/m2 % per 10000 h
10.2 0.4
13.8 1.2
25.5 10
A rod, 150 mm long and 625 mm2 in cross-section,
made of similar steel and operating at 6000C, is not to
creep more than 3.2 mm in 10000 hours. Calculate the
maximum axial load which can be applied.
Solution
3.2(100)
percentage creep stain = 150
= 2.13% per 10000 h
l n l n s
2.3224 -0.9163
2.6247 0.1823
3.2387 2.3026
Solution
For creep strain rate 2.13 percent, l n s = 0.7561
1 2 3 4
Isochronous Stress–Temperature
Diagram
Stress – Temperature Curves
Stress-Rupture Test
• fracture may be expected to take a very long
time
• creep test is usually terminated during steady
state of creep to produce a sufficiently
accurate value of the secondary creep rate
• when life is important design parameter, then
test is carried out upto destruction and this
kind of test is known as a stress rupture test
Creep Rupture Method
• When rupture (catastrophic failure) is the only
concern (eg boiler tubes) a simpler method
will do
Strain rate d 1 dL
= =
dt L dt
KP n e − H / RT dt = − A n −1 dA
for original conditions of cross sectional area of specimen
A0 to final Af from time t = 0 to tr (At rupture Af = 0)
tr Af
dt =
n − H / RT
KP e − An −1dA
0 A0 H
RT
e
for calculating time to rupture
tr =
for the given values of temperature
stress level and material constants nK n
Creep under Bi-Axial Stresses
equivalent stress
1
e = ( xx2 + yy2 − xx yy + 3 xy2 ) 2
Creep under Bi-Axial Stresses
Equivalent Strain rate = K n
e e
H
RT
e
Time to rupture t r =
nK e
n
Example
For an alloy steel with 2.25 percent Cr and 1.0 percent Mo,
two sets of creep data are recorded:
tr =
e RT H nK= B
=A
nK 0n R
A
ln t r = − ln( B n )
T
A
ln(0.1) = − ln( B n )
888
A
ln(100) = − ln( B n )
763
A = 1.62(10 4 )
A 1.62(10 4 )
= = 17.61
T 650 + 273
m
log10 t r + C =
T
m is a function of stress
P1 = f ( )
parameter is defined
P1 = T (log10 t r + C ) 1
constant C is intercept when log10 t r plotted again T
ferrous materials C varies from 15 to 30
Larson-Miller Parameter
Sherby-Dorn Parameter
function of stress
P2 = f ( )
P2 = log10 t r −
T
Example
Nimonic 90 turbine blades tested for different
stress level and temperature are lives are
recorded as below:
Stress (MN/m2) Temperature (0C) (0K) Life (h)
180 750 1023 3000
180 800 1073 500
300 700 973 5235
350 650 923 23820
P = T (log10 t r + C )
1023 (log10 3000 + C) = 1073 (log10 500 + C)
C = 30.44
P1 = 1023 (log10 3000 + 30.44) = 39333
P2 = 1073 (log10 500 + 30.44) = 39333
P3 = 973 (log10 5235 + 30.44) = 37950
P4 = 923 (log10 23820 + 30.44) = 37398
when stress equals 250 N/mm2
38525 = 1023 (log10 tr + 30.44)
tr = 1365 hours
Manson-Haferd Parameter
• For a material under different stress and
temperature conditions, a family of lines was
obtained which intercepted at a point when
log tr was plotted against T
T − Ta
P =
log10 tr − log10 ta
P = f ( )
Stress Relaxation
Time-dependent decrease in stress under
constant strain conditions under high
temperature
Example
cylinder-head bolts
rivets in pressure vessels
Stress Relaxation
i = e − c
d i d c
=−
dt dt
i =
E d i 1 d
=
dt E dt d c
− = − n 1 d
dt = − n
E dt
Stress Relaxation
d
n
= − E dt
1
− = − E t + C
( n − 1) n −1
1 constants and n
C=− n −1
( n − 1) i 1 1
depend
on temperature
= + E (n − 1)t
n −1
i n −1 and nature of
material
Example
The secondary creep rate for steel is given by
s = n A steel bolt is clamping two rigid
plates together at a temperature of 10000C.
The value of n = 3.0 and s
= 0 . 7 X 10 −9 −1
h for
constant stress level of 28 N/mm2. Determine
the remaining stress in the steel bolt after
9000 h if the initially tightened stress level was
70 N/mm2. Take E = 200x103 N/mm2.
Solution
0.7 X 10 −9 = ( 28) 3
= 3.18 X 10 −14
1 1
= + E (n − 1)t
n −1
i n −1
1 1 −14
= + 200(10 3
) 3 . 18 X 10 2(9000)
2 (70) 2
= 56 N/ mm2
Example
s = n
n = 2.23 = 1.525 x
1 1 1 1
= + E (n − 1)t = + 1 . 7 X 10 5
X 1 . 525 X 10 − 21
X 1.23t
n −1 i n −1 (34)1.23 (68)1.23
❑ Cost, fabrication ease, density etc. are other factors which determine
the final choice of a material
❑ Commonly used materials → Fe, Ni, Co base alloys
❑ Cost, fabrication ease, density etc. are other factors which determine
the final choice of a material
❑ Commonly used materials → Fe, Ni, Co base alloys
❑ Precipitation hardening (instead of dispersion hardening) is not a good
method as particles coarsen (smaller particles dissolve and larger
particles grow interparticle separation ↑)
❑ Ni-base superalloys have Ni3(Ti,Al) precipitates which form a low
energy interface with the matrix low driving force for coarsening
❑ Cold work cannot be used for increasing creep resistance as
recrystallization can occur which will produced strain free crystals
❑ Fine grain size is not desirable for creep resistance →
grain boundary sliding can cause creep elongation / cavitation
► Single crystals (single crystal Ti turbine blades in gas turbine
engine have been used)
► Aligned / oriented polycrystals
Creep-Resistant Alloys
• movement of dislocations are hindered to a greater extend in an alloy
rather than in a pure metal.
• atomic size and valency are different for alloying elements and
parent metal.
❑ At low temperatures the grain boundaries are ‘stronger’ than the crystal
interior and impede the motion of dislocations
❑ Being a higher energy region, the grain boundaries melt before the crystal
interior
❑ Above the equicohesive temperature grain boundaries are weaker than
grain and slide past one another to cause plastic deformation
Creep-Resistant Alloys
• secondary creep rate is inversely proportional
to the square of the grain size
KD
K constant
= 2
d T
σ applied stress
D coefficient of self diffusion
d grain size
T temperature
Creep-Resistant Alloys
• Grain boundary strengthening by introduction of
grain boundary carbide precipitates is helpful to
prevent grain boundary sliding.
• Therefore control of grain size becomes significant
for elevated temperature application
• The components with very high integrity may be
produced from a single crystal so that its strength is
significant even at elevated temperature for
Example: blades of gas turbines
Super Alloys
• Super alloys are based on nickel (Tm 1453 oC) and
contain many other alloying elements
• These are complex in atomic structure. Some alloying
elements will enter solid solution and strengthen the
material matrix. While some alloying elements tend to
form inter-metallic compounds and carbides.
• It is possible to align crystal grains in the micro
structure in a direction of maximum direct stress such
as for centrifugal stress for the development of
directional solidifications of turbine blades made from
casting. Therefore very few grain boundaries will be
oriented normal to the direction of maximum stress.
• The viscous flow across the grain boundary at very high
temperature becomes a major factor in creep
deformation.
Super Alloys
• stress-rupture characteristic curve for some
of alloys for high temperature applications for
1000 hours life
Stress Rupture in Single Crystals
1. Diffusion Creep
2. Dislocation Creep
Creep Mechanisms
Diffusion Creep
• Diffusion creep occurs by transport of material via diffusion of
atoms within a grain. Like all diffusion processes, it is driven by a
gradient of free energy (chemical potential), created in this case by
the applied stress.