Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Thesis
Submitted to Letter and Humanities Faculty
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for
The Degree of Strata One
By applying the theories, the writer knows that the characters use the
politeness strategy as we know that politeness strategy have several sub-strategies
that have a different purpose. Those sub-strategies are bald on record, positive
politeness, negative politeness, off record, and don’t do FTA. They uses those
strategies relates to the context of the conversation and the situation.
i
DECLARATION
I hereby declared that this submission is my own work and that, to the best of my
another person nor the material which to substantial extent has been accepted for the
award of any other degree or diploma of the university or other institute of higher
learning, except where due acknowledgment has been made in the text.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
In the name of Allah Subhana Wa Ta’aalaa, the most Gracious and the most
Merciful.
First of all the writer would like to give all majesty and praise to Allah Subhana Wa
Ta’aalaa who is always give her strength, patients, blessing in completing this thesis.
May blessing, peace and salutation be upon the most honorable prophet and
The writer would like to express her deep and sincere gratitude to her advisor,
Sholikatus Sa’diyah, M.Pd. who had guided and supported her to accomplish this
thesis. The writer recognizes that without her guidance, critic, and constructive
comment and support during the writing of this thesis, it will not be fulfilled.
The writer would like to express her special gratitude to her beloved parents,
Abdul Azis and Kholifah, who never stop praying for her, their financial support,
their mentally support, their contribution in the writer’s life especially in finishing
this thesis. Deep gratitude also to the writer’s sister Rizki Amalia and her husband,
Hylmi Al-tamis, and also for her sister Rana El Bilqis for her support, kindness, love,
v
The writer would also like to express the deepest gratitude to many people
who given their participation and support in finishing this thesis. They are as follows:
1. Prof. Dr Syukron kamil M.Ag, the Dean of Adab and Humanities Faculty.
4. All lecturers of English Letters Department, who gave the writer knowledge
by taught and educated the writer during her studies at the English Letters
Department.
5. All the staff of main library of UIN Jakarta, PKBB UNIKA ATMAJAYA,
and Faculty of Adab and Humanities library that helped the writer in finding
so many references.
6. The writer’s group of KKN ‘GEMA PERMATA’, what a great month with
7. The writer’s best friend since junior high school Njo, Adry, Raden, Topik,
Randy, thank you for the laugh and for the unbreakable friendship. They are
8. The writer’s best friend since high school Icha, Widy, Pietrajaya, Eko,
Fauzan, thank you for sharing any thought with them, they are the real MVP.
9. The writer’s best friend in the same struggle Farah Noor Syalies, Yuni Asri
and Devita Adriani Thank you so much for being such a great companion
vi
along the way in finishing this thesis, and the laugh for previous four years
And for those that the writer could not mention one by one, for their outstanding
contribution, material and immaterial assistance, it was so great having them all.
Amin
The Writer
vii
TABLE OF CONTENT
ABSTRACT ........................................................................................................... i
DECLARATION ................................................................................................... iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT .................................................................................... v
CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION......................................................................... 1
viii
CHAPTER IV CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS .................................. 66
A. Conclusions ................................................................................................ 66
B. Suggestions ................................................................................................. 69
BIBLIOGRAPHY ................................................................................................. 71
ix
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
A. Background of Study
not only as a communication to each other, but also it uses in social aspects such
as one's relationship with others, religion, and politics, economics and culture. In
use language either. However the language used within them are certainly to
convey the purpose of the creator regardless any linguistics intention. It means
1
Didin Saefudin Buchori. Bahasa Indonesia Untuk Mahasiswa. (Bogor: Granada sarana
pustaka. 2012), P.1
2
Abdul Chaer. Linguistik Umum. (Jakarta: Rineka Cipta,2003). P. 32.
1
2
could represent the hidden intention in the film. As the part of storyline, the
usage effects the expression from the speaker, in this case is the characters.
A movie as one of the creative arts arguably has a lot of demands from
its spectacle. Especially movie are made by the foreign, precisely by Hollywood
industry which mastered cinema networks around the world. The story itself has
its own uniqueness; in this case the writer highlights a movie entitled Her. This
movie serves an extra ordinary love story, which the main female character in the
movie is only a digital voice from computer program. The story tells about the
difficult situation the main male actor and the digital voice character who are
falling in love to each other. The voice character named Samantha and the male
named Theodore. The director, succeed plays the emotion of the writer through
sake of the story regardless the linguistic element itself. In the other hands, there
also includes belief, intention (or goal), plan, and act. 3 The interpretation is based
on what we might have intended to convey and includes evaluation as „rude‟ and
became the investigation and it called politeness.4 Politeness has been triggered by
3
Georgia Green. Pragmatic and Natural Language Understanding. Lawrence
Erlbaum1989, p. 3 in George Yule. Pragmatic. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996) p. 91
4
Ibid p. 60.
5
Gino Eelen. A Critique of Politeness Theories. (Manchester: St. Jerome Publishing.
2001) pp. 2-19
3
some linguists that which are Robin Lakoff, Stephen C. Levinson and Penelope
Brown, Geoffrey Leech, Yueguo Gu, Sachiko Ide, Shosana Blum-Kulka, Bruce
Fraser and William Nolen, Horst Arndt and Richard Janney, and finally Richard
Watts.5 However, the writer chose the theory proposed by Brown and Levinson,
although not the first, Brown & Levinson‟s theory is certainly the most influential
revisions their 1987 publication has triggered, and still does.6 In their book
conversation, speaker and hearer both have positive and negative face 7, where the
face should be kept. Brown and Levinson define face as the public self-image that
every member wants to claim for himself.8 This face has two aspects: positive and
negative.
Negative face: the basic claim to territories, personal preserves, right
imposition
bald on record, (2) Positive politeness, (3) Negative politeness, (4) Off Record, (5)
Don‟t do FTA. Those strategies are applied in order to uncover the linguistics
elements within the human and the computer device character‟s interaction.
6
Ibid p. 3
7
Penelope Brown and Stephen C. Levinson, Politeness: Some Universals In Language
Usage, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), p. 59
8
Ibid. p. 61
9
Brown and Levinson. Op.cit. p. 61
4
However, the writer limited this research by only analyzing the negative
itself is redressive action addressed to the adressee‟s negative face: his want to
have his freedom of action unhindered and his attention unimpeded. In short, to
minimize the particular imposition that the FTA unavoidably effects to hearer.10
movie. We can find out when and what one's goals using politeness strategies
through the movies we watch from the characters who plays the movie through
their utterances which relates to the context and situation in the scene of the
movie. This study aimed to find out when and what strategies should be used in
any context of the conversation that if we can apply in our daily lives that will
and the hearer. His theory called solidarity and politeness. In short, the closer the
relationship between the speaker and the hearer the less politeness level and vice
versa. This theory conveyed about how the relationship of a person to another
person influenced their utterance and in this case is politeness. Wardaugh also
conveyed about address term that use in order to be polite and friendly. 11
analysis with a movie entitled Her as the research by using the Brown and
Levinson as the main theory to analysis the language phenomenon. Also theory by
10
Ibid p.129
11
Ronald Wardaugh. An Introduction To Sociolinguistics. (Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
1986) p. 251
5
accurate.
B. Focus of Study
In this thesis, the writer will focus on politeness strategy by Brown and
Levinson in Her movie. The thesis will be analyzed each scene to know what
strategy that use in the movie and how it works and why characters in the movie
C. Research Questions
formulated as follows:
1. How are the strategies used by the character in the movie Her using
politeness strategies?
2. Why do the characters in the movie Her use politeness strategies in their
utterances?
D. Significance of Study
linguistic analysis study to be more diverse and varied. In addition, this study
investigate in more depth and varying the other linguistic science. Not only
6
politeness strategy in more depth through the film that became the object of
E. Research Methodology
1. Objectives of Research
descriptive.12 The writer noted meticulously the data that in the form of
words13 and in this case is movie script. From these data, the writer
subjects.14
The Writer search data in the selected movie script then look for
scenes in the movie that is suitable as a data afterwards writer wrote on the
data card for makes analysis easier. The data has already collected is
12
Edi Subroto. Pengantar Metoda Penelitian Linguistik Struktural. (Surakarta: Sebelas
Maret University Press, 1992). p. 7
13
Ibid.
14
Ibid.
7
c. Determining of the object of the thesis and the theory to solved the
problem.
The writer is the primary instrument for data collection and analysis.15
Data have been obtained by the author are written into a card called a data
card, the data card contains data that has been taken in the script of the
film.16 Then, the data card used as instrument also besides the writer
herself.
This thesis uses movie entitled Her as the corpus which the movie
cast by Joaquin Phoenix as the main male character and Scarlet Johanson
as main female character, but her role in this movie is only a voice heard
from computer. Moreover, the genre of this movie is drama. This movie
was released in 2013. This movie won Academy Award in 2014 for best
writing original screenplay, and Golden Globe Award for Best Screenplay,
Motion Picture. These awards are very prestigious in the movie industry.
15
Sharan B. Miriam. Qualitative Research: A guide to Design and Implementation, (San
Fransisco: Jossey Bass, 2009) p. 15
16
Subroto. P. 42
CHAPTER II
THEORETICAL DESCRIPTION
A. Previous Research
Before writer doing this thesis about politeness in the movie 'Her', the
study by previous writers have been done with different units of analysis. The
writer found four writers who wrote thesis about politeness, here are previous
writers:
theories to analyzed the unit analysis, the theories are Brown and Levinson‟s
From this research, the writer found the fact that by applying the theories, the
diplomats from different states can represent their own policy and resolution
16
Yuliana Prameswari. Negative Politeness Strategy in Diplomacy Meeting at UN
Security Council Summit on Nuclear Non-Proliferation Disarmament. (Jakarta: UIN Syarif
Hidayatullah, 2012)
8
9
The differences between the thesis above and this thesis is the corpus
exist in real life and the situation is formal because the speech from the head
topic of the meeting is very important. Indeed, the utterances from the head of
government who involve in the meeting must be used politeness strategy not
only to maintain the „face‟ of the audiences who are the head of government
but also to maintain their country relationship. Besides, she also uses a
itself. Contrast, the writer uses Ronald Wardaugh politeness and solidarity as
supporting theory because she uses movie as the corpus that the character in
2. This thesis was written by Resi Novira in 2010, entitled Negative Politeness
Strategies As found in Rachael Ray Show. She used politeness strategy theory
specific analysis. She used quantitative analysis to know which strategy that
mostly used in the data. The results of this study are speakers of applying a
Hedge there are nine utterances (29,03%), strategy 3. Be pessimistic there are
FTA as a general rule there are 3 utterances (9,68%), strategy 9 and 10 there
are only one utterance (3,23%). Rachael Ray as the object of analysis mostly
used strategy 2. Question, hedge that shows speaker tend to using simple
the utterances.2
The differences between the thesis above and this thesis are in the
percentage of the strategy uses. In contrast, the writer use Qualitative method,
Potter and The Chamber Of Secret”. The aim of this research are to find out
Rowling‟s novel „Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secret‟, to know in what
situation Harry Potter used Negative Politeness, and to know with whom
Harry used the Negative Politeness. This research was conducted through
novel and analyzed the data by using technique: data reduction, data display,
and analysis according to the theory of Miles and Huberman. As the result of
this research, the researcher found the negative politeness strategy used by
Harry Potter in J.K. Rowling novel Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secret
2
Resi Novira. Negative Politeness Strategies as Found in Rachel Ray Show. (Padang:
Universitas Andalas, 2010)
11
The differences between this thesis and the thesis written by Siti
Nurzanah are this thesis is about politeness strategy but she also conducted
with Discourse Analysis, and the corpus is novel and uses Miles and
qualitative method and the result explained descriptively. And the data
The case of Requests. The aim of this journal is to present and analysis and
languages. This journal use Brown and Levinson‟s Politeness Theory, and
other supporting theories such as Whorfian hypothesis and its view on the
Austin‟s and Searle‟s speech act theory and Goffman‟s notion of „face‟, and
the major politeness theories such as Lakoff (1973), Brown and Levinson
(1987) and Leech‟s (1983). The result of this journal is the major difference
3
Siti Nurzanah. An Analysis of Negative Politeness Strategy Used by Hrry Potter in JK
Rowling’s Novel Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secret. (Cirebon: IAIN Syekh Nurjati, 2012)
12
The differences between the journal above and this thesis are this
journal is specific in request and the researcher did this research in real life
situation and the unit of analysis are the British English native speaker and
supporting theory different from the writer of this thesis, she used movie as
the corpus and related them with Politeness and solidarity which known in
sociolinguistics.
B. Concept
can affect a person to use politeness strategies and also theories to support from
1. Politeness
about what we uttered, to whom we uttered or who our partners, in a situation like
what we said so as not to offend hearer. It is necessary for us said the sentences
that polite.
In the other hand, according to Thomas, the only reason is that people
4
Rosina Marquez Reiter. Politeness Phenomena in British English and Uruguayan
Spanish: The Case of Request. (Sheffield: University of Sheffield, 1997)
13
also subject of social theory. In general, politeness relates to the idea of such
and explosion of interest over the past quarter of a century and in which empirical
which lies not in the form and the words themselves, but its function and its
harmonious relations.10
Penelope Brown and Stephen C. Levinson, better known as Brown and Levinson's
5
Jenny Thomas, Meaning in Interaction: An Introduction to Pragmatics (Edinburgh:
Longman, 1995), p. 149.
6
Helen Spencer-Oatey, Culturally Speaking: Culture, Communication and Politeness
Theory, 2nd ed. (Cornwall:Continuum, 2008), p. 2.
7
Richard J. Watts, Politeness (Cambridge : CUP, 2003), p.10
8
Leo Hickey and Miranda Stewart, Politeness in Europe (Great Britain: Cromwell Press,
2005) p.1
9
Joan Cutting, Pragmatic and Discourse, (New York: Routledge, 2002), pp. 51-52
10
Thomas. Op.cit. pp.157-158
14
equal in all speech communities in the world. Member of society have the same
face as the positive social value a person effectively claims for himself by the line
other assume he has taken during a particular contact.12 George Yule defines the
concept of face as a social and emotional sense owned by anyone and hoped to be
interaction with others.14 Brown and Levinson defines it as the public self image
that every member want to claim for himself. 15In their book entitled Politeness:
Some Universals in Language Usage suggests that in speaking, speaker and hearer
both have positive and negative face16, where the face should be kept. This face
Levinson seminal work on politeness, proposed that face is the key of motivating
11
Brown and Levinson. Op.cit. pp.61-62
12
Erving Goffman. Interaction Ritual: Essays in Face to Face Behavior (New Jersey:
Transaction Publisher, 2005), p. 5.
13
George Yule. The Study of Language, 3rd ed. (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press,2006), p.119.
14
Thomas. Op.cit. p. 169.
15
Brown and Levinson. Loc. Cit.
16
Ibid. p.59
17
Ibid. p. 61
15
force for „politeness‟, and they maintain that it consist of two related aspects,
negative face and positive face. In their model, negative face is a person‟s want to
be unimpeded by others, the desire to be free to act as s/he choose and not be
other words, negative face represents a desire for autonomy, and positive face
politeness theory; she was the first to examine it from a decidedly pragmatic
perspective. Eelen quoted Lakoff in her book that according to Lakoff, politeness
minimizing the potential for conflict and confrontation inherent in all human
19
interchange. Lakoff used politeness to point out certain weaknesses of
traditional linguistics theory, and did this by connecting politeness with Grice‟s
of using the right words in the right context as determined by conventional rules
of appropriateness.21
18
Helen Spencer-Oatey. Culturally Speaking: Culture, Communication and Politeness
Theory. (London: Continuum, 2000). pp. 12-13
19
Eelen, Op. cit. p. 2
20
George Yule, Pragmatics (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996), p.60
21
Eelen. Op. cit. p. 15
16
his book entitled Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage. In the book,
they mention that as a speaker and hearer, they both have two face that is positive
and negative that can be selected to satisfy both at the end of the conversation.
„S‟ stands for „speaker‟ and „H‟ stands for „addressee‟. In this outline S
and H are MPs. In their book, MP is model person. Among MPs, it is mutual
(i) All MPs have positive face and negative face, and all MPs are rational agents
(ii) Given that face consists of a set of wants satisfiable only by the action
interest of two MPs to maintain each other‟s face. So S will want to maintain
22
Florian Coulmas.(ed.). The handbook of Sociolinguistics (Oxford: Basil Blackwell
Publishers, 2000). p. 378
23
Yule (2006). Loc.cit.
17
(iii) Some acts intrinsically threaten face: these „face-threatening acts‟ will be
(iv) Unless S‟s want to do an FTA with maximum satisfiable (defined as bald on
record) is greater than S‟s want to preserve H‟s (or S‟s) face to any degree,
(v) Given the following set of strategies, the more an act threatens S‟s or H‟s face,
the fact that these strategies afford payoffs of increasingly minimized risk:
Circumstances determining
Choice of strategy 1. Without redressive action, baldly
lesser on record 2. Positive politerness
estimation of do the FTA
risk of face loss with redressive action
3. Negative Politeness
4. Off Record
5. Don‟t do FTA
Greater
Since i-v mutually known to all MPs, our MP will not choose a strategy
less risky than necessary, as this may be seen as an indication that the FTA is
that conflict with social needs and statuses. Because of this fundamentally social
functionality, Brown and Levinson claim that their theory to the universally valid,
person.25
24
Brown and Levinson, Ibid, pp. 59-60
25
Eelen, Op.cit. p.5
18
In the other words, the concept of politeness belong two tradition: one
Levinson model. This model does not necessarily view language in term of a
polite / impolite cline but rather in term of extent to which speakers strategically
deviate from Gricean maxims in order to save their own face and/or that of the
others.26
principle that in short is the imperative sentence. In his book, Brown and
Levinson said that the strategy of bald on record can be treated like a maxim that
great. In such cases the powerful participant will often employ no indirectness at
all.28
The prime reason for using bald on record may be stated simply: in
wants to satisfy H‟s face, even to any degree, he will choose the bald on record
strategy. There are, however, different kinds of bald on record usage in different
circumstances, because S can have different motives for his want to do the FTA
26
Hickey and Stewart. Op.cit. p.3
27
Brown and Levinson. Op.cit. p.95
28
Thomas. Op.cit. p.170
29
Brown and Levinson. Loc.cit.
19
There are two main strategies that not stated as strategy, the first is cases
e.g. Help! (Compare the non urgent „please help me, if you would be so
the use of bald on record oriented to the face of speaker and hearer, for examples:
Leave it to me.
For some reason, a positive politeness technique can be used not only to
improve the FTA, but in general as a social acceleration, where S, using this
indicating that even if S cannot with total sincerity say “I want your wants”, he
In this strategy the speaker must be aware of the hearer condition such as
30
Ibid. p.103
31
Ibid. p.101
20
You cut your hair! By the way, I came to to borrow some flour.
You must be hungry; it‟s a long time since breakfast. How about some
lunch?
last night, I went to cinema, and you know what? I found my ex dated
In this strategy, S can implicitly claim that the common ground with H that
is carried by that definition of the group. These include in group usages of address
Mind if I smoke?
21
Another ways to claim a common ground with H are raising the safe topic
B: to London!
In this case, the S must be agree with H in order to main the H‟s face. The
the use of then as a conclusory marker; white lies is where S is confronted with
the necessity to state opinion want to lie rather than damage H‟s positive face; and
hedging opinions is S may be vague about his opinion in order to not to be seen
disagree.
b: barely
I‟ll meet you in front of the theater just before 8.00, then.
This strategy have several ways such as gossip or small talk is for
softening the request; point of view operations is encoded point of view by mean
22
of deixis; time switch is a tense shift from past to present tense; place switch is
use proximal (here, this, rather than there, that); avoidance of adjustment of
reports to H‟s point of view is direct quoted speech is is the very general usage;
is mutually taken for granted; presuppose knowledge of H‟s wants and attitude is
with negative question which presume yes answer is indicated that S know H‟s
want, taste, habit; presuppose H‟s values are the same a S‟s value is using of
address form like honey; presuppose H‟s knowledge is the use of in group codes-
Strategy 8. Joke
wants
H‟s wants and willingness to fit one‟s own wants with them.
I know you can‟t bear parties, but this one will be really good- do
come!
23
with H in another way. He may claim that whatever H wants, S wants for him and
S is assume that his want is H‟s want too, and H will help to obtain them.
Using inclusive form „we‟ instead of „you‟ or „me‟ when S want to doing
something.
cooperation)
S satisfy H‟s face by action, not only giving tangible gift, but also
negative face: his want to have his freedom of action unhindered and his attention
imposition that the FTA unavoidably effects.32 In this strategy, speaker should be
We should stressed that negative politeness are not the only motivation
a speaker may have for using the linguistics realizations characteristics of negative
politeness. The outputs are all forms useful in general for social distancing, not
like positive politeness realization are forms for minimizing social distance, they
are therefore likely to be used whenever when speaker wants to put a social brake
Speakers must express his desire indirectly to the hearer. In this strategy a
speaker faced with opposing tensions: the desires to give hearer and „out‟ by
being indirect and he desires to go on record. Indirect speech acts are certainly the
32
Brown and Levinson. Op.cit. p. 129
33
Ibid. p.130
25
can you pass the salt? (which can be only indirect request an not
This strategy is using almost the same question as indirect speech and also
phrase'. Modification can be expressed level or more correct and more complete
Strategy 3: Be Pessimistic
If the previous strategy, speaker must be optimistic about the response of
the hearer, the speaker's strategy this time should be pessimistic about the hearer's
response.
could you do X?
34
Ibid. p. 132
35
John Searle, Indirect speech act. In: Cole & Morgan (Eds.). Syntax and Semantics:
Speech Act (Vol.3). New York Academic press, 1975, p.53
36
Ibid. p. 52
26
speaker, it means that the speaker was 'impose', as if the speaker gives hearer
I just want to ask you if you could lend me a single sheet of paper.
Strategy 6: Apologize
Apologized before revealing the real purpose to the hearer, Apologizing does
not always explicitly with the words 'forgive' or 'apologize', but also implicitly by
using a verb.
someone to do something.
27
passengers will please refrain from flushing toilets on the train (you will
Strategy 9: Nominalize
favorably.
Here, (c) a more formal look like a formal letter from the (b), and (b)
This strategy uses indirect language and removes the speaker from the
potential to be imposing. Off the Record itself is the strategy of politeness on the
application, the speaker does not explicitly say the words, and the hearer can
the hearer.
28
The notion of Off Record is refers not simply to formal types of indirection
but rather to such linguistic strategy in context. Clearly, many of the classic off
often actually on record when used, because the clues to their interpretation (the
kinesic clues to the speaker‟s attitude; the clues derives from conversational
speaker say “it‟s cold in here. (c.i. Shut the window). Make someone doing
Strategy 3. Presuppose
last week).
37
Ibid. p.212
29
Strategy 4. Understate
Strategy 5. Overstate
war is war
Strategy 8. Be ironic
It‟s a nice and comfortable room, isn‟t it? (in a messy room)
30
harry is real fish (c.i. he (drinks/ swims/ is slimy/ is cold blood) like
a fish)
means.
I‟m going ( you-know-where/ down the road for a bit. (c.i. to the
local pub)
Rule instantiation may leave the object of the FTA vaguely off record:
S redress an FTA to whom it would not threaten in order to the real target
will know that he is the actual target who FTA aimed to him. For example, teasing
(asking someone to go out) would you rather get your foot stuck in
Leaving the FTA undone, S can leave the implicature hanging. And this
oh sir, a headache…
This strategy is simply that speaker avoids offending hearer at all with this
3. Sociological Variable
Besides the strategy above, to apply the politeness strategy in the real life,
Thus these are not intended as sociologist‟ rating of actual power, distance,
38
Ibid. p. 72
39
Brown and Levinson. Op.cit. pp. 75-76
32
FTA. Brown and Levinson have calculated the weightiness of FTA. For each
risk to S‟s face and risk H‟s face, in a proportion relative to the nature of the FTA.
Thus apologies and confession are essentially threats to S‟s face, and advice and
orders are basically threats to H‟s face, while request and offers are likely to
threaten the face of both participants. The weightiness of FTA is calculated thus:
Wx = D(S,H) + P(H,S) + Rx
FTA x, D(S,H) is a measure of the power that H has over S, and Rx is a value that
measures the degree to which the FTA x is rated an imposition in that culture.
and H stand for the purpose of this act. It is based on an assessment of the
sense. That is, P(H,S) is the degree to which H can impose his own plans and his
degree to which they are considered to interfere with an agent‟s want of self-
and solidarity. In his book, Wardhaugh write about solidarity and politeness, he
suggests that politeness is associated with closeness between speaker and hearer.
In short, the closer relationship between speaker and hearer makes them having
less polite and vice versa if the far relationship the more polite the utterances.
Moreover, in his book Wardhaugh also cites studies from Ford and
Brown were conducted in 1961 that the practice of naming in English, based on
the analysis of modern plays. They reported that the use of the title, last name, and
first name indicates equality in strength or power, that the use of title and last
name indicates inequalities and lack of intimacy, while the use of first names
indicate the similarities and familiarity. For example: for the title and the last
name of Mr. Smith or such a degree as Professor and Doctor. Then, for the next
In English, we can eliminate the use of first names with no title at all. We
can utter such good morning like good morning Sir/ Madam/ Mr Smith. But in
other language, for example French, we cannot separate address term with name
because it is not polite in French. For example, we cannot simply utter Bonjour,
Au Revoir, Merci or Pardon without address term, for example Merci Pierre,
Bonjour Monsieur.
closeness deeper.
intimate or close and polite. One simple test to separate the closeness, the
informal term of address polite and formal in the English language can be seen
from conjunctions with informal and formal greeting and farewell. For example,
Hi, Bye, and So long in comparison with a Good Morning and Goodbye. Hi Sally,
Bye Honey, and So long, just like Good Morning Mr Smith and Goodbye sir.
40
Wardhaugh. Op.cit. pp. 251-261
CHAPTER III
DATA ANALYSIS
A. Data Description
The data for this thesis was collected from utterance who uttered by
characters in the movie. Movie 'Her' was produced, directed, written by Spike
Jonze. The film, released in 2013 this genre of romantic drama starring Joaquin
famous Hollywood actresses like Amy Adams, Rooney Mara, and Olivia Wilde.
With duration of 125 minutes, the film tells the story of an unusual love between
Theodore, who was divorced from his wife Catherine but refused to sign a letter
of divorce, with Samantha that only a woman's voice heard from the computer
The writer analyzes the data to find the meaning and what strategy that
used in the data and what the purpose of the speaker use those strategy. Below are
the utterances that writer found in the script that implied politeness strategy.
B. Data Analysis
These data will be analyzes one by one in more depth by each scene, that
involved main character, Theodore, with other characters. These are the following
analysis:
1
An operating system (OS) is software that manages computer hardware and software
resources and provides common services for computer programs. The operating system is an
essential component of the system software in a computer system. Application programs usually
require an operating system to function. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operating_system, accessed
March 18, 2015. 1:27pm)
35
36
DATA 1
Scene 1
Theodore walks through the reception area. The office is almost empty except for
him and receptionist, Paul. Theodore begins to scan each letter through a scanner
on the front desk, then puts them in the outgoing mailbox.
Paul is sitting at a desk across the room, reading handwritten letters on a computer
monitor.
Paul : (lighting up) oh, thank you. I just got it. It reminded me of
someone suave.
Theodore : well, now it reminds me of someone suave. Have a good night,
paul.
Paul : Buh-bye.
Analysis
gives compliment to Theodore about the letter that he wrote was really good, but
Theodore answers modestly and tries to change the topic of the conversation by
talk up about Paul‘s shirt and the conversation become chit chat and it is also
Theodore‘s strategy to cut the conversation but in polite way, in this conversation
37
Theodore also uses the last strategy Don‘t Do FTA to keep Paul‘s face and tries
DATA 2
Scene 2
Theodore, carrying a bag and a smoothie, enters the lobby and is greeted by a
couple in their 30s, Amy and Charles, who are waiting for the elevator.
Charles : (proselytizing) by juicing the fruits, you lose all the fibers, and
that‘s what your body wants. That‘s the important part. Otherwise,
it‘s just all sugar, Theodore.
Amy : I have a little bit cut together but I haven‘t touched it in a few
months.
Theodore : I‘d love to see what you got sometime.
Charles : you know it‘s always hard to find balance between a full-time
career and a hobby. It‘s important to prioritize.
Theodore : yeah. I can‘t even prioritize between video games and internet
porn.
Amy : I would laugh if that weren‘t true.
Analysis
In this scene, Amy and Charles stand in front of elevator. Then, Theodore
comes and greets them. Amy asked Theodore why he didn‘t call her back last
week. In this case, Amy uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy
number 13: Give (or ask) reason. Then Theodore replies with positive politeness
strategy with sub-strategy number 8: Joke, in this situation Theodore avoid FTA
from Amy and also makes a joke in order to blur his real reason why he does not
call Amy back. Then, Amy answers with ‗that sounds about right‘, Amy uses
specifically impersonal verb, by uses the strategy, Amy minimize threaten face of
After the conversation between Amy and Theodore, Charles ask Theodore
about he went shopping and is he get anything good, in this sentence Charles use
buy, and Charles give his opinion about that, and as if he patronizes Theodore,
Amy cut the conversation and says ‗or maybe he just like the way it tastes and if it
gives him pleasure, that‘s good for his body, too‘, in this case Amy use off record
strategy with sub-strategy number 14: Displace H, Amy redress and FTA to
Charles but in polite way. Then Charles replies with ‗am I doing it again?‘, he
feels the FTA from Amy and she replied ‗maybe‘, in this situation, Amy uses
Amy blur her real opinion about Charles to kept Charles‘ positive face.
Afterward, Theodore tries to break the tension of the situation and switch
the topic about their documentary project and make some jokes to warms up the
DATA 3
Scene 3
Amy : it‘s not where it should be, where it‘s going to be.
Theodore : obviously, I know.
Amy : okay, but I don‘t even know if this is the one. I‘ve tried like six
years, but… I don‘t know. Whatever.
Theodore and Charles stare at the monitor, waiting for something more to happen.
It doesn‘t.
Analysis
I this scene, Amy says ‗it‘s not where it should be, where is it going to be.‘
answer, then Amy replies with positive strategy with sub strategy number 6:
Avoid disagreement, in this situation, Amy tries to keep Theodore positive face
because in her first statement to Theodore, she doing FTA that makes Theodore
face is lost. Therefore, she uses positive politeness strategy to keep the relation
Then, after the awkward situation, to break the ice between them,
Theodore said ‗I‘m going on a date‘, in this statement Theodore uses positive
melt down the situation, he also want to share about what he is going to do. Then,
Amy replied with off record strategy with sub-strategy number 15: Be
incomplete, use ellipsis. In this sentence, Amy shows her surprise about what
Theodore says.
Afterwards, Charles walks in held a mug and ask what they did. And
Theodore replies but Amy cut Theodore statement and says that she is force by
42
Theodore to show him a footage that she has shot. Then, Charles protests that he
never show by Amy and he want to see. In this situation, Charles uses positive
Theodore tells Charles that he is going on a date but Charles just replies
with non-verbal action. In the other hands, Amy stuck with her monitor. After
that, the monitor works and in the monitor they seen Amy‘s mother sleep, Charles
and Theodore stares at monitor and nothing happen with Amy‘s mother that they
saw on the monitor. Theodore and Charles asked is her mother wake up or do
something and it makes Amy‘s face loss because Charles did FTA. Amy annoys
Question, hedge. In this situation, Amy use tag question ‗does it?‘. It is shows that
Amy look unfriendly because her project does not work properly, then Amy
statement seems as if her project is terrible. After that, Theodore replies gently
and H, in order to keep Amy‘s positive face. Then, Charles gives his opinion
about her project and tries to give alternative about Amy‘s project, in this
statement Charles uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15:
to be rude and pick up the device and step away from them. Samantha voice heard
and she tells that he get three emails and its seems urgent because it is about
Catherine his ex-wife. And then, Theodore says sorry to Amy because he need to
43
grab the email because it is urgent, in this situation, Theodore uses negative
DATA 4
Scene 4
Blind date : this place is amazing. I‘ve wanted to come here for so long. I love
Asian-fusion!
Theodore : yeah, me too.
Blind date : really? It‘s the best. And the bartender here is supposed to be
incredible.
Theodore : yeah, you took a mixology course, right?
Blind date : (surprised) I did, I did. Did you look that up? That‘s so sweet.
You‘re so romantic.
He smiles awkwardly.
They‘re both pretty drunk now. There are lots of food dishes and drinks on the
table.
Theodore : so I‘m trying to get this little alien kid to help me find my ship so
I can get off the planet and go home. But he‘s such a little fucker, I
want to kill him.
Blind date : aw, no!
Theodore : but at the same time I really love him. He‘s so lonely. It feels like
he doesn‘t have any parents or anyone to take care of him.
He laughs at himself. She laughs flirtatiously. She grabs his hand and her
fingernails press slightly into his skin. He studies her long, painted fingernails.
Blind date : you‘re like a little puppy dog. You are – you‘re just like this little
puppy I rescued in Runyon Canyon last year. And he was so
44
fucking cute, and he just wanted to be hugged all the time. He was
so cuddly.
(whispering)
But so horny! But anyway, what kind of animal am I?
Theodore : umm… tiger?
Blind date : a tiger, really. (she growls) I‘m sorry, am I being crazy?
Theodore : yes
Blind date : am I? I‘m sorry! I‘m just a little drunk and I‘m really having a
good time with you. I‘m having a really lovely evening.
Theodore : me too. I‘m a little drunk, and I‘m having a really good – yeah.
(beat) wait a second, I don‘t wanna be a puppy. That‘s like being a
wet noddle or something.
Blind date : fuck you, puppies are good.
Theodore : no, fuck you, I wanna be a dragon that can rip you to pieces and
destroy you… but I won‘t.
Blind date : no, don‘t! I don‘t. you can be my dragon.
OVERPASS – EVENING
They walk up a pedestrian overpass overlooking cars and city lights. She bumps
into him lightly. He bumps back. She bumps again and suddenly he grabs her and
lifts her off her feet, spinning her around. She squeals, laughing. He kisses her.
After a minute of making out, she stops and looks at him.
They resume making out. Theodore tries not to use his tongue.
Blind date : use your tongue a little bit. But mostly your lips.
He pushes her against the fence and takes the dominant position. He tries kissing
her better/more with his lips. Pulls her hair.
She slides her hand down his pants. He likes it. She looks at him and stops.
Blind date : wait, you‘re not gonna fuck me and then not call me like the
other guys, are you?
Theodore : no, not at all… I…
Blind date : when am I gonna see you again?
Theodore : um, I have my god-daughter‘s birthday next weekend, but…
um.
They stand there awkwardly, her lipstick smeared on his face.
45
Blind date : you know, at this age, I feel like I can‘t let you waste my time if
you don‘t have the ability to be serious.
Theodore : I don‘t know.
Long beat
Theodore : umm… maybe we should call it a night. I‘m, I‘ve had such an
amazing time with you, you‘re great.
She looks at him slightly disgusted
Blind date : you‘re a really creepy dude.
Theodore doesn‘t know what to say.
Theodore : (worried she‘s right) that‘s not true…
Blind date : yeah, it is. I have to go home.
Theodore : well, I‘ll walk you.
Blind date : no, don‘t.
Analysis
This scene takes place in Asian-Fusion Restaurant and this scene tells
about Theodore makes a date with woman. They are drunk. In the first Theodore
Intensify interest to H. in this situation, Theodore shows his interests to her and
makes conversation to get closer with her. After the senseless conversation
because they were drunk, at the pedestrian they takes a walk and they starts flirt
each other. And makes out for a moment. Suddenly, the woman stops and looks at
Theodore‘s eyes and asks a question that quiet shocking for Theodore. She said
‗wait, you‘re not gonna fuck me and then not call me like the other guys, are
you?‘.in this statement, the woman uses negative politeness strategy with sub-
strategy number 2. Question, Hedge. She is ensures that Theodore does not leave
her like the other guys. Then, he replies with off record strategy with sub-strategy
46
number 15. Be incomplete, use ellipsis. This statement shows that Theodore does
not sure if he does not like the other guy, and blurs his thought about his
relationship with the woman. After that, woman asks more when she will see him
again but Theodore still cannot makes promise because his daughter birthday next
weekend, he uses off record strategy with sub-strategy number 15. Be incomplete,
use ellipsis, he leaves his statement hanging. And his statement makes her face
loss, unconsciously Theodore has done FTA and the date was so terrible.
DATA 5
Scene 5
THEODORE‘S OFFICE – DAY
Theodore is dictating a love letter. On the screen there‘s an image of a couple with
an arrow to the man saying ―Roberto – I‘m so happy he‘s in my life. I just want
him to know.‖
Theodore : Roberto. Will you always come home to me and tell me about
your day? Will you tell me about the boring guy who talked too
much at work? And the stain you got on your shirt at lunch. Tell
me about a funny thought you had as you were waking up, but
had forgotten about. Tell me how crazy everyone is. We can
laugh about it. Even if you get home late and I‘m asleep already,
just whisper in my ear one little thought you had today. Because
I love the way you look at the world, and I‘m so happy I get to be
next to you and look out at the world through your eyes. Love,
Maria.
Theodore finishes the letter and looks at it proudly. Paul is standing behind
Theodore, leaning on a cubicle.
Paul : (emphatically) that‘s beautiful!
Theodore, jumps, startled, not knowing that anyone was there.
Theodore : thank you.
Paul : I wish someone loved me like that! I‘d be stoked to get a letter
like that. I mean, if it was from a chick. But if it was written by a
dude, but from a chick, it would still be sick. But like a sensitive
47
dude like you. You‘re part man and part woman, like an inner
part woman.
Theodore : (unsure, but flattered) thanks.
Paul : it‘s a compliment.
Analysis
In this movie, Theodore is letter writer, the letter that he wrote is for
people who want to shows whatever they feel about someone special but they
could not wrote as deep as Theodore wrote. In this scene, Theodore just finished
After finish the letter, Paul appears and said ‗that‘s beautiful!‘ in this
statement, Paul uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15.
compliment about Theodore‘s letter. Theodore replies with ‗thank you‘ and Paul
Exaggerate (interest, approval, sympathy with H), Paul replies exaggerate because
DATA
Scene 6
Close on Amy entering the lobby in the foreground. She looks heavy and
burdened. Theodore enters the lobby behind her.
Theodore : I‘ve been seeing this girl. It‘s not serious, it just feels good to be
around someone who has an excitement about the world. You
know I kind of forgot that existed.
Amy : that‘s really great, Theo.
The door opens. She steps out and holds the door.
Amy : (trying to hide her emotion with a smile) Charles and I split up.
Theodore : (shocked) what? Really? Oh my god, I‘m so sorry.
Analysis
In this scene, Amy enters her apartment lobby and Theodore enters behind
her. She looks heavy and burden. Theodore greets Amy and she tries to keep her
on a bright face. Amy seems like something bad happens to her but she keep
listen to Theodore and respond all Theodore‘s statement like nothing bad happens
to her. Theodore tells Amy about a woman that he find interesting, in his
Intensify interest to H. Later, Theodore realizes that it was not Amy as usual.
49
After that, Theodore ask why Amy sad. She replies ‗yeah I‘m fine..actually no,
I‘m not fine at all‘. In this statement, Amy use off record strategy with sub-
strategy number 7. Use contradiction, she unsure about what she feels, she want to
hide from Theodore but she cannot. Then, Theodore asks for further story about
what happens to her. In this statement, Theodore uses positive politeness strategy
cooperation) Theodore shows his sympathy as a friend. Then, Amy replies but
tries to hide her emotion with smile and tells Theodore that she and Charles are
split up. Theodore is really shocks and does not believe what he heard, and his
statement to Amy uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15.
Give gift to H (goods, sympathy, understanding, cooperation). Amy really sad and
DATA 7
Scene 7
Amy : I cannot believe after eight years how actually ended it. We
came home and he asked me if I‘d put my shoes next to the door
where he likes to put the shoes. I don‘t want to be told where to
put my shoes. I want to just sit on the sofa for a minute and relax.
And so we argued for ten minutes about that and about how he‘s
just trying to make our house a home. I say he‘s overwhelming,
he says I‘m not trying hard enough. I say that‘s all I‘m doing is
trying, but I‘m just not trying the way he wants me to. He‘s
trying to control the way I‘m trying. And I think we must have
had this argument hundreds of times before and I finally had to
stop because I couldn‘t be in that situation anymore where we
50
were making each other feel bad about ourselves. So I said I‘m
going to bed and I don‘t want to be married anymore.
Theodore : wow
Amy : I‘m a bitch, huh?
Theodore : no, not at all. Amy, no.
Amy : oh shit. I have to work tonight. We‘re shipping a beta of a new
game out tomorrow.
Theodore : well, how‘s that? How‘s work at least, is that any better?
Amy : no, it‘s terrible. I know I should leave, I‘ve been thinking about
leaving. But you know, only one major life decision at a time.
Theodore : well, I‘m glad things are looking so up.
Analysis
In this scene, Amy talks about how she and Charles split up; Theodore
does not know what to say. Their conversation about Amy problem is not long
and Amy realizes that she have to work that night and Theodore asks Amy about
how she continue her life, Amy replies his question with bright answer, then
Theodore replies with positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15.
DATA 8
Scene 8
Close on a video game on a screen. There‘s a mom rushing to get her kids fed,
getting points deducted for feeding them sugar cereal and non-organic eggs. Cut
out to reveal Theodore playing the game as Amy eats lunch at an editing console.
Onscreen, the mom hurries the kids to their car safety seats, and drives them to
school, arriving before anyone else.
Theodore : I see.
Amy : the point is to get there first – then you get extra perfect mom
points because the other moms then know you‘re a perfect mom.
Theodore : okay.
Amy : oh, did you bring cupcakes? You did. You‘re class mom.
You‘re class mom! Good job.
Theodore : yay
Amy : don‘t let it get to your head.
Theodore : I got that email that Charles sent to everyone. So he‘s taking a
vow of silence?
Amy : yeah, for six months. He said he is feeling very clear about it.
She pulls up a photo of Charles on her computer. He‘s in a monastery – his head
is shaved, and he‘s wearing robes.
Theodore : for the next ten minutes, if you say anything that sounds
remotely like guilt, I‘m gonna stab you with this.
Amy : (smiling) okay, I‘ll try. (beat) I feel relieved. I have so much
energy, you know? I just wanna move forward and I don‘t care
who I disappoint. And I know that makes me an awful person –
now my parent are all upset because my marriage is falling
apart, and they‘re putting it all on me.
Theodore : yeah, you‘re always gonna disappoint somebody.
Amy : exactly (beat) so fuck it. I feel good. Ish. For me, I feel good. I
even made a new friend, I have a new friend. And the absurd
thing is she‘s actually an operating system. Charles left her
behind, but she‘s totally amazing, you know. She‘s so smart.
She doesn‘t see things in only black and white. She sees this
whole gray area and she‘s really helping me explore it. You
know, we bonded really quickly and at first I thought it was
because she was programmed to be that way, but I don‘t think
that‘s how they work. There‘s this guy I know who keeps hitting
in his and getting rebuffed.
Theodore : yeah, I was reading an article the other day that romantic
relationship with OS‘s are statistically rare.
52
Amy : yeah? Well, there‘s this woman in my office who‘s dating and
OS and the weird thing is, it‘s not even hers. She pursued him
and he‘s somebody else‘s OS
(beat)
It‘s just so, like, weird, that I‘m bonding with an OS. Is that
weird?
Theodore : I don‘t think so. Actually the woman I‘m seeing, Samantha, I
didn‘t tell you before, but she‘s an OS.
Amy : really? You‘re dating an OS? What‘s that like?
Theodore : actually, it‘s great. I feel really close to her. When I tak to her I
feel like she‘s with me. I don‘t know, even when we‘re
cuddling, like at night when we‘re in bed and the lights are off, I
feel cuddled.
Amy : so wait – do you guys have sex?
Theodore : (laughing) well, so to speak, yes. She really turns me on. And I
think I turn her on. I don‘t know, unless she‘s faking it.
Amy : anyone that has sex with you is probably faking it.
Theodore laughs.
A big, irrepressible grin crosses his face as he think about what to say.
Analysis
This scene takes place on Amy‘s office in the afternoon. Theodore plays
game and Amy eats her lunch at an editing console. Theodore asked Amy about
what happened with the games because he never played that, and Amy giving
After that, Theodore says to Amy that he get an email from Charles that
asks is Charles taking a vow of silence to Amy and she shown a picture of Charles
53
that he is in a monastery, his head is shaved and he is wearing robes. And Amy
starts down-graded herself but stops at the moment, she uses off record with sub-
strategy number 15. Be incomplete, use ellipsis, she leaves her statement hanging
and Theodore replies quickly and reminds her to not to start to humiliates herself,
necessary in the statement. Although, he did FTA but he want Amy to not think
about her problem. But Amy still continue her statement that down-graded herself
but she leave her statement hanging, in this statement, Amy used off record with
a plastic knife and says if Amy say anything that sounds guilty herself, he will
stab her with the knife, in this statement, Theodore not only used positive
politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15. Give gift to H but also strategy
number 8. Jokes, he givessympathy to Amy but also makes a joke in order Amy
forget about her problem and encourage her. Replies Theodore statement with
smile, but Amy still talking about what happened to her. Then, Theodore
answered Amy with positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15.
Give gift to H, he encourages Amy that people must be ever doing wrong things.
Afterwards, they changes the topic into a relationship with an OS, Amy
asks about how that is like, and Theodore tells that his relationship with Samantha
are like real relationship and he feels that Samantha as if alive and when they in
the bed at night, Theodore feels cuddles with her. And suddenly Amy asks that
they have sex and Theodore replied ‗(laughing) well, so to speak, yes. She really
54
turns me on. And I think I turns her on. I don‘t know, unless she‘s faking it.‘ And
Amy replied ‗anyone that has sex with you is probably faking it.‘.in Amy
statement, she uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 8.Jokes.
Theodore laughs and says ‗yeah, it‘s true.‘, in Theodore statement, he usespositive
politeness strategy with sub strategy number 5. Seek agreement, not only agree
with Amy, Theodore also want to makes a jokes because the situation are really
knows more about what Theodore feels. And Theodore replies with answer too,
he asks does that make him freak. But Amy encourage him that it is not a big deal
this statement, Amy uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 6.
Avoid disagreement. Theodore smiles and excitement came out in his eyes.
DATA 9
Scene 9
Theodore sits alone in the back of a quite restaurant, a large stack of papers in
front of him. We hear his breathing. He waits. Catherine, elegantly dressed,
approaches. Theodore stands to greet her. They hug and sit down.
Theodore : I signed all the papers and I brought them for you to sign.
Catherine : (with a sly smile) what‘s the rush?
Theodore : (smiling) I‘m a really slow signer. It took me three months just
to write the letter T.
She laughs.
Theodore : it‘s marked where you need to sign, but you don‘t have to do
that right now.
Catherine : oh, I may as well. We can get it out of the way.
She opens the documents, pulls out a pen and starts to read. She‘s about to start
signing, but then stops. We can see her filling with emotion, but not wanting to
show Theodore. She swallows and recovers. She looks up at Theodore, giving
him an ‗everything‘s fine‘ smile, but it‘s not.
Beat
Theodore : well, her name‘s Samantha, and she‘s an operating system, and
she‘s really complex and interesting. I mean it‘s only been a
few months, but -
Catherine : wait. You‘re dating your computer?
Theodore : (defensive) she‘s not just a computer. She‘s her own person.
She doesn‘t just do whatever I want.
Catherine : I didn‘t say that. (beat) but it does make me sad that you can‘t
handle real emotions, Theodore.
Theodore : they are real emotions. How do you know—
Catherine : what? Say it. Am I really that scary? Say it. How do you know
what?!
Analysis
This scene takes place in a restaurant; he sits alone and waits for
Catherine, her ex-wife. Catherine came, Theodore stands to greets and hugs her,
and they sit down. Theodore asks about basic things, but they are little nervous
but tries to be warm. And Theodore says that he has signs all the papers and he
brings them for Catherine to sign. Catherine asks why he takes too long to sign all
57
the papers, in her statement, she uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy
number 13. Give (or ask) for reason. And Theodore replies ‗I‘m a slow signer. It
took me three months just to write the letter T‘, in his statement he uses positive
politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 8. Jokes, not only for breaks the
intention, but also to blurs the actual reason why does he takes so long to signs all
the papers. And it works, Catherine laughs. Theodore shows where Catherine
have to sign, but Theodore does not force her to signs now. But Catherine refuses
and signs all the papers, she opens the documents, pulls out and read. Catherine
tries to hide her emotion and gives ‗everything‘s fine smile‘ but it is actually not.
After that, Theodore and Catherine enjoys the food and talks about what
they do. Theodore asks about Catherine‘s new book, and admires her works, in
number 15. Give gift to H and strategy number 2. Exaggerate at the same time
because he says ‗even that paper our wrote on synaptic behavioral routines made
me cry‘. Catherine replied ‗yeah, but everything makes you cry.‘.in her statement,
Catherine says more than is necessary and exaggerated. Then, Theodore replied
‗everything you makes me cry‘, he uses positive politeness strategy with sub-
strategy number 5. Seek agreement, he agree with Catherine statement and stress
by repeating what she said. After that Catherine asks if he dating someone, and
Theodore replied ‗ yeah, I am.‘ And that was makes Catherine smiles but conflicts
inside but still tries to be warm. Catherine answers sober but Theodore still
talking about his date, in his statement, Theodore uses positive politeness strategy
Catherine hide her emotion, her heart hurts but she still tries to be fine, he replied
‗oh good, excited‘s great‘, in this statement Catherine uses two strategy at once,
off record strategy with sub strategy number 8. Be ironic, she avoid disagreement
about Theodore statement but also be ironic because what he feels contradicts
with what she says. But Theodore tries to clarify because Catherine seems not
happy about that, to clarify what he said, he uses positive politeness strategy with
face loss. But Catherine replies by tease him politely, she uses off record strategy
with sub-strategy number 14. Displace H, she teased Theodore in order that
Theodore. But Theodore refuses what Catherine says, he uses positive politeness
Afterwards, Catherine asks how is the Theodore‘s date like, and he replies
that she is an OS and her name is Samantha. Then, Catherine cut Theodore and
says ‗you‘re dating your computer?‘, but Theodore defends, he said that Samantha
is not just a computer, in his statement, Theodore use two strategy at once, off
record strategy with sub-strategy number 14. Displace H and positive politeness
says that he date his computer Samantha is not just doing what he want but more
than that, Samantha seems like person, he also avoid disagreement about
more than just a computer. But Catherine sound unhappy about Theodore who
dates a computer, she uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number
6. Avoid disagreement, she tries to convey Theodore that is not she thought about
Samantha but that makes she sad that Theodore date a unreal person, and she said
that he could not handle his real emotion. But Theodore still defends, he said that
what he feels is real emotion, and asks how Catherine know but Theodore stops
himself and leave his statement hanging, he used off record strategy with sub-
strategy number 15. Be incomplete, use ellipsis, he do not want to hurt Catherine
with his statement because the situation getting worse. And Catherine replies
angrily, asked what she did not know because Theodore statement undone, she
uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 13. Give (or ask) for
reason.
Theodore does not say anything. And then, the waitress walks up and asks
how they were done. Catherine replies but teased Theodore ‗fine. We used to be
madly in love with his laptop.‘, in her statement, she uses off record strategy with
The waitress does not know what to say, she just stand near them.
Theodore tries to clarified what he means but Catherine cut his statement, and the
situation getting worst. The waitress tries to get out from the situation and says
DATA 10
Scene 10
Everyone has gone. Theodore walks through the empty office into the reception
area. He scans and drops his letters into the outgoing mailbox. Paul is at his
reception desk with a young, pretty, sophisticated girl sitting on his lap.
60
Paul : Theodore!
Theodore : hey, Paul.
Paul : hey, I talked to your girlfriend, Samantha. She called earlier to
make sure your papers were picked up. She‘s funny, man. She
was cracking me up. She‘s hilarious. I had no idea.
Theodore : (not knowing what to say) yeah.
Paul : this is my girlfriend, Tatiana. She‘s not funny. She‘s a lawyer.
Tatiana : hi!
Theodore : nice to meet you.
Tatiana : you‘re the writer paul loves. He‘s always reading me your
letters. They‘re really beautiful.
Theodore : thanks.
Paul : we should all hang out one night. You bring Samantha –
double date!
Theodore walks to the elevator and presses the button and waits. He calls back to
them down the hall.
Analysis
61
This scene takes place in Theodore office. He walks into scanner and
drops his letters into outgoing mailbox. Paul and his girlfriend Tatiana are at
reception desk. Paul greets Theodore and Theodore replies. Then, Paul
tellsTheodore that Samantha calls him to ask if Theodore‘s letters are picks up,
Paul admires Samantha, in his statement, he uses three strategies at once, positive
wants, needs, goods), strategy 2. Exaggerate, and strategy 15. Give gift to H.
When Theodore came, he notices that Samantha call him then he told Theodore.
After that, not only exaggerate what he says about Samantha but also gives
Samantha compliment. Theodore replied simply with ‗yeah‘ because he does not
know what to say, he also used positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy
number 6. Avoid disagreement to maintain the Paul‘s face. And then he introduce
his girlfriend, Tatiana, to Theodore. And they shake hands and greet each other.
Tatiana admires his letter and Paul also loves his letter, in her statement, Tatiana
uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy number 15. Give gift to H,
double date, Paul with Tatiana and Theodore with Samantha, Theodore just stands
without saying anything because Samantha just an OS. Theodore tells Paul that
Samantha was just an OS, but for Paul and Tatiana that was not a big deal if
DATA 11
Scene 11
Theodore : (full of angst) fuck, will you just punch me in the face? Or
smash my skull into the corner of your desk?
Amy : (sympathetic, but also acknowledging how intense the night
was) oh Theo… that sounds like rough night. Shit.
Theodore : I don‘t know what I want… ever. I‘m just always confused and
– she‘s right, all I do is confuse and hurt everyone around me.
Theodore sits and thinks about this for a minute, not convinced.
Theodore : yeah, but… am I in this because I‘m not strong enough for real
relationship?
Amy : (surprised) oh, you don‘t think it‘s a real relationship?
Theodore : I don‘t know. What do you think?
Amy : I don‘t know, I‘m not in it. But you know what, I can over-
think everything and find myself. But since Charles left I‘ve
been thinking about that part of me, and I realized I‘m here only
briefly. And in my time here, I want to allow myself… joy.
(beat, smiling at him) so fuck it.
Theodore lies on a couch in the back of Amy‘s office, deep in thought. Amy talks
with Ellie as she works on the prefect mom video game. Her device is standing
before her.
Amy : I can‘t believe that crack you up every time! Ellie, I thought
you were a genius… okay, you little perv, I‘ll do it one more
63
Amy makes the perfect mom hump the refrigerator. Amy laughs at how much
Ellie is laughing. Theo watches Amy closely, taking in her joy.
Amy : okay, there you go. Are you happy now…? Okay good, that‘s
all I wanted. I‘m gonna grab some coffee… alright, bye.
Theodore, still heavy with thought, is touched by his friend‘s happiness. Amy
stands to exit.
He smiles at her and continues laying there, thinking, taking it all in.
Analysis
This scene takes place in Amy‘s office at night. Amy is sitting at her desk
but turns away from her computer and face Theodore who slumps in the chair.
Theodore talks angrily, and asks if Amy will punch him in the face or smash his
skull into the corner of the desk because he and Samantha just fight because
Samantha want to involve surrogate date in order to feel more ‗real‘ relationship,
but Theodore feel strange about that and their relationship getting complex. Then,
Amy replies sympathetic and uses positive politeness strategy with sub-strategy
number 15. Give gift to H. Theodore tells Amy about what he feels and what
happens to him, and Amy gives her opinion and encourage Theodore until
Theodore says ‗yeah, but… am I in this because I‘m not strong enough for real
relationship?‘. Amy surprises and asks ‗oh, you don‘t think it‘s real relationship?‘.
Therefore, Amy gives her opinion about what happens to Theodore and tried to
understand what he feels, in this statement, Amy used positive politeness strategy
64
with sub-strategy number 15. Give gift to H, Amy encourages Theodore by telling
relationship with Samantha, Amy talks to her device that named Ellie. In the
middle of her conversation with Ellie, Amy talks about she wants grab some
coffee and then finish the conversation with Ellie. And then she asks Theodore
‗Theo, you want some?‘ and Theodore replies ‗no, that‘s okay.‘, in her statement
we knows that Amy uses off record strategy with sub-strategy number 2. Give
association clues, Amy and Theodore shares mutual knowledge to each other, so
Amy does not need said ‗do you want some coffee?‘ but Theodore knows that
DATA 12
Scene 12
Amy : hey
Theodore : Hey
Amy :Did Samantha leave, too?
Theodore : yeah.
Amy : I‘m sorry.
Theodore : will you come with me?
He takes her hand and leads her down the hall into a stairwell.
Analysis
In this scene, Samantha is leaves Theodore, he feels sad about that, he
knocks on Amy apartment door, he heard footstep. Amy sad, too. Amy greets and
65
asks ‗did Samantha leave, too?‘ and Theodore simply replies ‗yeah‘, Amy feels
sorry about that, then Theodore asks if Amy will come with him, in his statement,
indirect, Theodore usesthis strategy in order to blur his desire by being indirect
than being on record because he knows that Amy is upset. Amy does not reply
him with verbal but Theodore takes her hand and leads her down the hall into a
stairwell.
CHAPTER IV
A. Conclusion
strategy use as social acceleration, this strategy use to get closer to the hearer;
negative politeness strategy use as social brake, someone use this strategy to keep
distance to the hearer; off record strategy use as indirect language and removes the
speaker from the potential to be imposing, it is also use to say hidden intention
implicitly; don’t do FTA is simply strategy that there are no strategy here, it is
simply avoid offending and imposing the hearer. From the analysis in the previous
chapter, it is known that a character in the movie uses the theory of politeness in
various occasions, although not all sentences are uttered politeness strategies but
scene that suitable applied if it is associated with the situation in the context of the
scene. As described in chapter 2, that each strategy has its own purpose even
though the core of the strategy is to keep all the positive face from the hearer, but
There are 12 scene that analyzed by the writer. In every scene, contain
politeness strategies. For example in scene 1, this scene involved Theodore and
66
67
Paul, Paul mostly uses positive politeness while Theodore replied with Don’t do
FTA. Paul try to getting closer to Theodore but he seems do not want to talk much
and try to end up the conversation in polite way with Don’t do FTA strategy to
keep Paul’s positive face. Those strategy uses in casual situation, with person that
4, this scene involved Theodore and his blind date, from the situation of this scene
we know that Theodore date a woman. From the scene, we know that in such
situations, when two new people get acquainted, they use a lot of positive
politeness strategy, this strategy is used to come closer to each other. Besides
positive politeness, in this scene Theodore and blind date also frequently use off
record strategy that shows the hidden intentions of each other. But when the blind
date asks for next step of their relationship and Theodore cannot answers clearly,
then the situation is not conducive, the blind date’s utterance become not polite,
not to mean to be rude but the blind date’s utterance get straight forward and not
uses politeness strategy but Theodore still explain what he means but it is useless
because the blind date already disappointed with Theodore. From the scene, we
can learn how if someone mad at us and how to face them with politeness
strategy.
strategy, as Amy friend he try to cheer up Amy by listen and give his sympathy to
68
her and try to understand what Amy feels. This scene teach us how to do when
From all the explanation above and the analysis in previous chapter, we
know that politeness strategy can be use relates to the situation or context of the
conversation. Not only the politeness strategy but also the address term, the
relationship between the characters not use address term, and they still be polite
even though their relationship is close. This is evidence that emotional closeness
does not necessarily make someone use the address term in this case is in-group
identity markers.
when the relationship between two people or more are very close then the
utterance was less polite, and if both are not quite intimate relationship then
utterances used more polite. In fact, in this movie, the character ever uttered swear
words, it is not the main reason that their relationship is close; they uttered them
when they are in conflict or when they are in sad situation and mock themselves
like Amy did when she told Theodore that they split up. And it is fact that the
relationship closeness is not necessarily less polite, they did polite and still get
close.
As can be seen politeness does not mean to say politely with a choice of
good words and do not use words that are rude and vulgar, but the strategy of
politeness in question is the strategy to maintain 'face' of the hearer, face in here is
not face as a literal meaning but public self image that every member want to
claim for himself using various strategy formulated by many linguists one of them
69
is brown and Levinson. As in the script of this film, some using swear word and
are not necessarily rude but when seen from sociolinguistics side that had
described in previous chapter, shows the close relationship among the characters
in this film.
strategies well to everyone, regardless the social distance it is because the director
depicts him as introvert, it shows from the story that Theodore does not have
much friends, his close friend only Amy. His relation with Amy are really close
but they seldom utter swear word. They uttered swear word when Amy tells him
that Charles and her are split up, she mocks herself.
All the characters in this movie are polite, but sometimes they do FTA but
still uses politeness strategy likes in scene 9, Catherine do FTA tease Theodore by
uses off record strategy. Furthermore, they utter swear word when they are makes
a jokes but not all the jokes they makes utter swear words.
B. Suggestion
For further research, the writer suggests the research on politeness strategy
real life situation as object, she suggests for the next researcher could be use real
life situation to be analyzed because it will be more natural. But movie could be a
good example of politeness strategy uses and this research could be a good
learning media for the next research. And politeness strategy is one that is very
70
BOOKS
Chaer, Abdul. Linguistik Umum (cet VI). Jakarta: Rineka Cipta, 2003.
Goffman, Erving. Interaction Ritual: Essay in Face to Face Behavior. New Jersey:
Transaction Publisher, 2005.
Hickey, Leo and Miranda Stewart. Politeness in Europe. Great Britain: Cromwell
Press, 2005.
Searle, John. Indirect speech act. In: cole and Morgan (Eds.). Syntax and
Semantics: Speech Act (Vol.3). New York: Academic press, 1975.
71
72
JOURNALS
THESIS
WEBSITES