Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GCE Taking It Local UNESCO PDF
GCE Taking It Local UNESCO PDF
In partnership with
Acknowledgements
Published in 2018 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, 7, place de Fontenoy, 75352 Paris 07 SP, France
© UNESCO 2018
This publication is available in Open Access under the Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 IGO (CC-BY-SA 3.0 IGO) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/igo/). By
using the content of this publication, the users accept to be bound by the terms of use of the UNESCO Open Access Repository (http://www.unesco.org/open-access/
terms-use-ccbysa-en).
The present license applies exclusively to the text content of the publication. For use of any other material (i.e. images, illustrations, charts) not clearly identified as
belonging to UNESCO or as being in the public domain, prior permission shall be requested from UNESCO. (publication.copyright@unesco.org)
The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO
concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors; they are not necessarily those of UNESCO and do not commit the Organization.
Printed by UNESCO
Printed in France
13
Table of contents
1. Introduction 2
3. Conclusion 9
4. Looking forward 11
5. Annex 12
About the document 12
Acknowledgements 13
1
1. Introduction
2
2. A tour of the world through local concepts
Contemporary relevance to
education - The Charter of Manden is
highly respected within Mali, promoting
a message of respect, love, peace and
fraternity which has been cherished
▶▶ Mali, West Africa: Islamic Koranic School through the ages. It is widely seen to
robertonencini/Shutterstock.com
form the foundations of the values at
Explanation - Dating from the 12- respect for human life, the right to the heart of Malian society. In 2011,
13th centuries and established under life, the principles of equality and the Malian government decreed the
the rule of Emperor Sundiata Keita non-discrimination, women’s rights, Charter to be part of the national
of the Mandingo Empire, the Charter individual freedom, justice, equity and cultural heritage of Mali. Also known
of Manden is one of the oldest solidarity. Passed down through oral as the “Kouroukan Fouga Charter”, it is
recorded references to fundamental tradition, there are two versions of the now included in the law syllabi of West
rights, including the concepts of Charter, which advocates for social African universities.
Explanation - Ubuntu is a humanist on the basis of care and respect, which GCED notion within Ubuntu, where
concept that means “I am because we is developed through the conviction South Africans learn from childhood
are, we are because I am”, speaking to that a person’s actions have impact on about the oneness of humanity based
how a person is a person through his/ others and vice versa, and points to the on biological oneness, spiritual oneness,
her relation to and respect for others. notion of mutual responsibility. The and the recognition of a common
This refers to an ethos for living together idea of shared humanity is the strongest destiny. In addition, the concept
3
evokes respect for cultural diversity,
peace and non-violence, as well as
human rights, through focusing on the
interconnectedness and dignity of all
women and men.
Contemporary relevance to
education - The values of Ubuntu were
incorporated into South Africa’s 1993
interim Constitution and its 2011 White
Paper on Foreign Policy, "Building a
Better World”. It is also referred to in the
Department of Basic Education’s 2010
Guide for Teachers: Building a Culture
▶▶ Children perform at the "South African Welcoming Ceremony" for the 2002 World Summit on
of Responsibility and Humanity in our
Sustainable Development at Ubuntu Village (Johannesburg, South Africa).
Schools. © UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
Contemporary relevance to
education - The concept originates
from the Quran. Shura is also referred
to in the Preamble of the Constitution
(1996, and its 2011 amendments). In
civic education, Shura is expressed as
Oman’s political model. As detailed in
▶▶ Nizwa, Oman: an accountant registers sales in a cash book at the goat market surrounded by clients in Oman’s Ministry of Education Philosophy
traditional dress.
of Education Guide, and in the 12th grade
Heide Pinkall/Shutterstock.com
curriculum of civic education, Shura
Explanation – Shura is a form of public house of parliament. It places value is reflected in the promotion of the
consultation and decision-making on taking a diversity of views into broad goals of ’international peace and
inspired from Islamic practices. It refers account, thereby promoting the notion understanding’, and ‘the world and its
to both a process and an institutional of the people's participation in the contemporary challenges’.
structure, namely the ‘Majlis Al Shura’ governance of public affairs. There
(Consultative Council) that is the lower is a long history of religious pluralism
4
Hurriya, Karama, Aadala, Nithaam (in Tunisia): “Freedom, Dignity, Justice, Order”
Explanation - The concept of Gross (8) ecological diversity, and (9) living
National Happiness (GNH), pioneered standard - relating most strongly to
by Bhutan, permeates every aspect the core GCED notions of solidarity and
of its national policy, underscoring shared humanity.
the prime importance of societal
good over economic growth. Its Contemporary relevance to
foundation is drawn largely from education - In 2008, it was decided to
the Buddhist faith, and the concept embed GNH principles in the education
follows the tenets of Buddhism, which system. This was implemented in 2010,
include the idea that “all beings pursue with training provided to head teachers,
happiness.” Bhutan’s philosophy of GNH followed by a rollout to individual
was initially constructed to cover four schools. GNH principles are embedded
integrated pillars of (a) sustainable and in the educational system and curricula
equitable socioeconomic development; at all levels, with a focus on issues such
(b) environmental conservation; (c) as critical and creative thinking; holistic
preservation and promotion of culture; learning concerning the world; and
and (d) good governance. More recently, competencies to deal with the modern
it has been expanded into nine domains world.
beyond the original pillars, including:
(1) psychological wellbeing; (2) health;
(3) time use; (4) education; (5) cultural
▶▶ Thimphu, Bhutan: Gross National
diversity and resilience; (6) good Happiness Commission.
governance, (7) community vitality; Vladimir Melnik/Shutterstock.com
5
Hongik-Ingan (in the Republic of Korea): “To broadly benefit all humanity”
Contemporary relevance to
education - The concept of Hongik-
Ingan can be found embedded in the
National Education Act, which states
that “the objectives of education,
▶▶ Ganggangsullae - a Korean dance under the ideals of Hongik-Ingan, the
KPG Ivary/Shutterstock.com
founding philosophy of Korea, are to
Explanation - The concept of Hongik- Peninsula, the Gojoseon dynasty (2333 help all people perfect their character,
Ingan is best explained as the guiding BC–108 BC). Dangun Wanggeom, the develop a self-sustaining ability to attain
principle and ethical foundation of a founding monarch of Gojoseon, put independent lives, become responsible
Korean vision of an ideal existence. The forth the idea which directly translates citizens, participate in the makings of
concept emerged during the period of as “to broadly benefit all humanity.” a democratic state, and promote the
the oldest known dynasty on the Korean Hongik-Ingan suggests that the people prosperity of all humankind.”
Explanation - Multiculturalism is a
national policy in Canada that seeks
to ensure that “all citizens keep their
identities, take pride in their ancestry
and have a sense of belonging”. Central
to multiculturalism is the idea that
Canadians, regardless of race, ethnicity,
language or religion, are all equal. In the
province of Quebec, “interculturalism”
is most commonly preferred to the
notion of “multiculturalism”– though not
legislated in official policy – emphasising
the shared responsibility of ensuring
peaceful co-existence. Both notions
translate to a commitment to pluralism
and respect for diversity. As stated in
the Canadian Constitution, Section
▶▶ Toronto, Canada: families during the annual Santa Claus Parade
27 of the Canadian Charter of Rights
ValeStock/Shutterstock.com and Freedoms, “Multiculturalism” is a
6
part of Canada’s heritage. The 1988 Act creates an obligation for the The Western and Northern Canadian
Multiculturalism Act (MA) recognizes government to promote interactions Protocol – The common Curriculum
multiculturalism as a fundamental aspect between cultural communities (MA, Framework Grades 10-12 Mathematics).
of Canada (Article 3). All ten of Canada’s Article 3). An important aspect of Another example can be found in the
provinces and three territories have some this work is carried out through the province of British Columbia, where,
form of policy related to multiculturalism education system and the teaching of in 2008, the Ministry of Education
or human rights. other worldviews, and the cultivating of recognized multiculturalism in its policy
a sensitivity to the diversity of students’ framework for schools.
Contemporary relevance to cultures and experiences (for instance,
education - The 1988 Multiculturalism
education - As the national motto, to create unity within and respect a new moral and civic education
this phrase was written into the 1946 for differences. These principles have curriculum (Bulletin official special n°6
and 1958 Constitutions and is a part prompted the early provision (1881) in du 25 June 2015), which explicitly states
of the French ethos. Inscribed on France of free pre-primary education as that Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité are core
school buildings, coins and even tax a means to ensure equal opportunities republican values and, as such, should
forms, Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité is part for all. More recently, France instated be promoted through education.
of French identity and commitment
Explanation – The concept of Buen freedom, participation, and the ethical and spiritual conduct in relation
Vivir, or “Living well,” centres on Rights of Nature or “Pachamama”. A to our surroundings. The concept refers
the notions of solidarity, generosity, holistic approach, the concept speaks also to caring for the environment, thus
reciprocity and complementarity, to the diversity of elements that broadening the notion of social justice
related to the goal of social justice condition human thought and action, and well-being from the individual
and community, and referring to a set contributing to the search for ‘good to include the community. Rooted in
of rights related to health, education, living,’ such as knowledge, and codes of an Andean concept and found in the
7
2009 Constitution, Buen Vivir may be
interpreted as a set of principles, such
as dignity, social equity, reciprocity
and social justice, that are related to
human rights. Buen Vivir emphasizes a
broader understanding of progress and
development, with special attention
to nature. In these ways, this concept
echoes the core GCED notions of
solidarity and a shared sense of humanity.
Contemporary relevance to
education: The concept of Buen
Vivir shapes the vision and mission
of the Ministry of Education, with all
policies aimed at guaranteeing quality
education for all that supports the
well-being of the community. This vision
has contributed to the development of
▶▶ Various colourful fruit and vegetable shops at Tupiza market in Bolivia
Shutterstock.com/Aostojska
a Base Curriculum of the Plurinational
Educational System, the elaboration indigenous and non-indigenous the Ministry of Education developed the
of regionalized and diverse curricula, peoples, and the training of teachers Sectorial Plan of Integral Development
together with the participation of and education workers. Furthermore, of Education for Buen Vivir 2016 – 2020.
8
3. Conclusion
●● The concepts explored here echo ●● “Respect for diversity” is addressed, include solidarity with nature. “A
ideas found in GCED, most notably for instance, through the concept of shared sense of humanity” comes
three core notions that distinguish it multiculturalism. “Solidarity” can be through clearly in the concept
from other educational approaches: identified in several related concepts of Ubuntu, and is found in the
(i) “respect for diversity”, (ii) “solidarity”, around the world, including in the concept of Sumak kawsay, with its
and (iii) a “shared sense of humanity”. idea of Fraternité, as well as in the emphasis on the community and
concept of Hongik-Ingan and Buen interconnectedness.
Vivir, which extends the notion to
Generosity
Respect for
DIVERSITY SOLIDARITY
Integrity
3
of the CORE
NOTIONS OF Equitable
motherland
GCED socio-economic
development
Shared sense of
HUMANITY
Harmony with
Food security the natural
environment
9
●● At the same time, there are variations ⎯⎯ Othervariations are found in the not negate one or more of the three
in the way these core notions are put emphasis on the idea of hospitality GCED notions.
into practice. and generosity, harmony with the
natural environment, food security
●● Overall, this study provides evidence
⎯⎯ Forexample, several concepts and integrity of the motherland that the core notions of GCED are
underline, in different ways, the shared among a wide range of
importance of nurturing peaceful ●● This study also highlights several countries, with different contextual
social relationships, which is not as GCED notions that do not seem specificities that are reflections of how
explicit in common understandings to emerge explicitly in these local each society has strived to ensure
concepts, including the notions of peaceful co-existence throughout
of GCED. The concept of Sumak
“international understanding” and history in complex and diverse
kawsay focuses on reciprocal,
“non-discrimination”. environments.
complementary and cooperative
relations, while the concept of Gross ●● The variations, commonalities and ●● All of this strengthens the call for
National Happiness (GNH) and Buen gaps identified above raise a question greater national and local ownership
Vivir underline the importance about the extent to which local of GCED, regardless of what name
of valuing both community and concepts may be useful as entry it is given. This is important for two
individual relationships. points to promote the full range of reasons: (1) as a means to anchor
values, attitudes, skills and behaviours education in local and national
⎯⎯ Another noteworthy variation that are at the core of GCED. To be values and traditions that uphold
is the relative importance given considered as vehicles for GCED, the principles of respect for diversity,
to equitable socioeconomic local concepts should echo at least solidarity and a shared sense of
development as a key principle, one, and at best all three, of the core humanity, and to (2) ensure deeper
such as in the cases of the Charter of GCED notions. At the very least, to be local and national relevance of GCED
Manden and the concept of GNH. considered, a local concept should notions.
10
4. Looking forward
3 4
the local and the global” when community, as well as beyond
possible, rather than on the idea local and national contexts in
of “global”, which is often viewed order to demonstrate a shared
as not relevant at the local level. sense of humanity.
11
5. Annex
12
Acknowledgements
13
Global Citizenship Education:
Global Citizenship Education:
Taking it local
Taking it local
UNESCO is leading global efforts on Global Citizenship Education (GCED), which is at
the core of Target 4.7 of Sustainable Development Goal 4 on Education. To address the
perception that the concept of GCED is concerned mainly with global matters and maybe
dissociated from local needs and realities, UNESCO has identified local/national/traditional
precepts and concepts that are similar to the UNESCO understanding of global citizenship.
As culturally relevant expressions of GCED and to contribute to building peace through the
implementation of GCED, the concepts identified here can serve as entry-points to teach
and learn about GCED in more locally relevant ways.
In partnership with