Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EDITORIAL
902
SUICIDE BY INTENTIONAL INGESTION OF PESTICIDES 903
in industrialized countries, large-scale farming is practised by (barbiturates),27 USA (firearms),28,29 and Britain (catalytic con-
a small number of landowners, thus reducing the number of verters for car exhaust fumes).30
people with direct access to pesticides. In contrast, most people This evidence has prompted the inclusion of policies aimed at
living in rural regions of developing countries are involved in reducing access to, or the lethality of, commonly used methods
agriculture and farm small areas of land. Subsistence farmers within national and international suicide prevention strategies.31–33
keep their own supply of pesticides, commonly within, or close In Britain attention has focused on restricting the availability of
to, the household.23 A recent study in China found that 65% of paracetamol (acetaminophen)34,35 and in the USA there are
pesticide suicides used chemicals stored in the home.8 similar concerns about the ease of availability of firearms.28,29
There is general consensus that the ease of availability of The number of deaths caused by pesticides36 make Western
particularly lethal means of self-harm may influence patterns of concerns about these two methods of suicide appear somewhat
suicide. Suicidal impulses are often short lived and if time can trivial. For example, in Britain where paracetamol suicide is
be ‘bought’ allowing such impulses to pass—by making the means comparatively common,34 there are only around 200 paracetamol
of suicide less readily available—a proportion of suicides will be suicides per year (4% of all suicides).35 If a similar proportion
prevented.24 The best documented evidence of this was the of suicides were due to paracetamol worldwide (an overestimate34)
effect of the detoxification of the domestic gas supply in Britain then using the WHO’s current estimate of 849 000 suicides
in the 1960s25—this was thought to have contributed to the worldwide each year37 a maximum of 34 000 of these might be
prevention of an estimated 6700 suicides.26 Similarly, temporal attributable to paracetamol.
and geographical variations in the availability of other commonly In contrast, the WHO estimated in 1990 that there are around
used methods have influenced patterns of suicide in Australia 3 million hospital admissions for pesticide poisoning each year,
904 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY
Figure 2 Age and sex patterns of suicide. a. In China (Source: WHO), b. Sri Lanka (Source: WHO), and
c. Kaniyambadi region, S. India (Source: Joseph et al.20)
SUICIDE BY INTENTIONAL INGESTION OF PESTICIDES 905
2 million of which are as a result of deliberate ingestion, and kept in a secure facility in each geographical locality. Restricting
these result in around 220 000 deaths.36 The size of the problem availability could be achieved by either direct control of particular
is probably larger now—there have, for example, been well- pesticides (banning, requiring licences for use or prescriptions)
recognized increases in pesticide poisonings in South Asia.21 or through the promotion of practices that minimize their use.
The best evidence for estimating the global burden of suicide Such health protection approaches appear to have led to a
deaths from pesticide ingestion comes from China and South reduction in serious paracetamol poisonings in England35 and
East Asia. In 2001 there were an estimated 517 000 suicides in a decline in barbiturate suicides in Australia.27 The WHO has
developing countries in these regions37and research evidence encouraged countries to restrict the availability of more lethal
(see above) suggests pesticide ingestion accounts for over 60% pesticides32 and countries such as Sri Lanka have followed this
of these suicides. We therefore estimate there are around 300 000 approach.41 In Jordan, a steady rise in fatal pesticide poisonings
pesticide suicides each year in these regions alone. As pesticide was reversed by increased awareness of the problem, decreased
suicides from other developing nations in Africa and South America imports of some toxic pesticides, and bans on the imports of
are not included in this figure the global toll is likely to be higher. others.42 Similar effects have been observed in Western Samoa
Interventions to limit access in such settings are complex and companies. In this battle, the fact that the vast majority of
need to involve most rural adults, rather than a select few. severe and fatal pesticide cases are self-inflicted may be incon-
Second, the sale of pesticides is a multi-billion dollar business. venient to the environmentalists. If the pesticide industry can
In all, 1.5 million tons of pesticides are sold annually and sales are argue that they should not be held responsible for people who
worth an estimated US$30 billion.6 Tensions commonly exist drink pesticides, then this may be seen as undermining the
between commercial interests and population health, furthermore environmentalists’ case. People therefore want to avoid the issue
industry has not always acknowledged the impact of the easy of self-poisoning and deal with issues where the pesticide industry,
availability of lethal suicide methods on patterns of suicide.49 In and globalization in general, can be held responsible.
describing Western Samoa’s preventive considerations following the This need not be true. An overall assessment of public health,
epidemic rise in pesticide suicides in that country Bowles noted: environmental and agricultural factors should determine
regulatory actions, not simply their political appropriateness.
There was at that time a contentious debate about actually Pesticide self-harm is just as important as occupational poison-
banning paraquat [(the pesticide)] entirely. We knew however ing for regulatory issues and, in some countries, regulatory
Third, the issue of pesticide self-poisoning has never been taken Conclusion
up as a campaign issue by any of the international organizations. Pesticide self-poisoning is a major contributor to population
The WHO is the pre-eminent public health organization and patterns of morbidity and mortality in developing nations. The
its Department of Mental Health and Substance Dependence use of pesticides for self-poisoning may distort conventional
(MNH) is responsible for suicide prevention.50 It has managed epidemiological features of suicide in these countries and con-
to successfully draw mental health up the worldwide political tribute to their excess premature mortality. We estimate there
agenda over the last 10 years.32 It has also emphasized the global are around 300 000 self-inflicted pesticide deaths worldwide
health importance of suicide, organizing workshops across the each year. Research dating back over 30 years has documented
world to discuss strategies for reducing self-harm, but it has not the size of this problem and yet contemporary research bears
taken up pesticides as a central issue. Recent WHO publications witness to its continuing impact.
with major input from the MNH32,51 have put greater emphasis Research to identify the most acceptable means of restricting
on psychiatric and social models of self-harm aetiology. While the availability of pesticides within rural communities is urgently
pesticide self-poisoning was mentioned in both reports, it received required together with randomized controlled trials to determine
much less attention than its importance warrants. the best means of treatment and cost-effectiveness of possible
The International Programme on Chemical Safety (IPCS) is interventions. Some of this research is now underway (M Eddleston,
the major WHO programme dealing with pesticides.52 It was set unpublished). Preventive measures must take account of the
up in 1980 by the United Nations Environment Programme, the local needs and context and should be rigorously evaluated.
International Labour Organization, and the WHO, to establish Thus far there has been no global leadership to respond to the
the scientific basis for safe use of chemicals and to strengthen problem. Engagement of national governments and leadership
national capabilities for chemical safety. Current IPCS activities of the WHO, in particular the MNH and IPCS sections, on the
aim to increase knowledge of the epidemiology of pesticide poison- issue is essential. Commitment from industry and the need for
ing and to encourage the setting up of poisoning information them to acknowledge their responsibility for some of these deaths
centres.52,53 The IPCS has not, however, actively taken up the is vital (Table), as is the need to ensure they understand the
issue of intentional pesticide self-poisoning, concentrating instead scale, importance, and preventability of the problem. Reducing
on occupational and environmental poisoning.54 This is unfortu- the number of pesticide deaths by 50% could rapidly reduce the
nate since its own studies have indicated the great importance number of suicides worldwide by 150 000. This is quite possible.
of self-poisoning in the Asia Pacific region.53 The interests of its
parent organizations may be the reason for this lack of advocacy
for the problem of intentional poisoning. Acknowledgements
Fourth, the self-inflicted nature of suicide, together with the fact We thank Shah Ebrahim, John Haines, Flemming Konradsen,
there are fewer suicide deaths than deaths from other global health and Mark van Ommeren for helpful comments and suggestions
problems such as human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)/AIDS, and Nicos Middleton, Davidson Ho, and Sanjay Kinra for obtain-
tuberculosis, and malaria, may have lead to policy makers giving ing some of the suicide statistics. Hospital Episodes Statistics
it lower priority than the number of premature deaths warrant. (HES) data were made available by the Department of Health to
Fifth, pesticide self-poisoning is ideologically and politically the authors courtesy of the HES National Service Framework
inconvenient. Pesticide use has adverse effects on the environ- project (Prof. Shah Ebrahim and colleagues), funded by a South
ment and human health.55–57 This has become a major global and West Regional project R & D grant. The Medical Research
political issue. Many of the adverse effects of pesticides are con- Council (MRC) Health Systems Resource Centre are data custodians
sidered to result from their overuse and poor treatment of workers and also fund some of the support costs. The Department of
and communities due to globalization58—in which pesticide Social Medicine is the lead Centre of the MRC Health Services
corporations are major participants. The issue has been taken Research Collaboration. ME is a Wellcome Trust Career
up by numerous national and international non-governmental Development Fellow in Tropical Clinical Pharmacology, funded
organizations (NGO), in continual ‘battle’ with the pesticide by grant GR063560MA.
908 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY
References 24 Clarke RV, Lester D. Explaining choice of method. In: Suicide: Closing
1 NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Deliberate self-harm. the Exits. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1989, pp. 85–95.
25 Kreitman N. The coal gas story. United Kingdom suicide rates,
Effective Healthcare Bulletin 1998;4:1–12.
2 Gunnell DJ, Brooks J, Peters TJ. Epidemiology and patterns of 1960–71. Br J Prev Soc Med 1976;30:86–93.
26 Suicide and Deliberate Self Harm. Office of Health Economics. White
hospital use after parasuicide in the south west of England. J Epidemiol
Community Health 1996;50:24–29. Crescent Press Ltd, 1981, pp. 1–56.
3 Michel K, Ballinari P, Bille-Brahe U et al. Methods used for para- 27 Oliver RG, Hetzel BS. Rise and fall of suicide rates in Australia:
suicide: results of the WHO/EURO Multicentre Study on Parasuicide. relation to sedative availability. Med J Aust 1972;2:919–23.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2000;35:156–63. 28 Anon. As easy as buying a toothbrush. The Lancet 1993;341:1375–76.
4 Gunnell D, Ho DD, Murray V. Medical management of deliberate drug 29 Miller M, Azrael D, Hemenway D. Household firearm ownership and
overdose—a neglected area for suicide prevention? Emergency Med J suicide rates in the United States. Epidemiology 2002;13:517–24.
2003 (In press). 30 Amos T, Appleby L, Kiernan K. Changes in rates of suicide by car
5 Owens D, Horrocks J, House A. Fatal and non-fatal repetition of self-
exhaust asphyxiation in England and Wales. Psychol Med 2001;31:
51 Krug EG, Mercy JA, Dahlberg LL, Zwi AB. The world report on 55 Bull D. A Growing Problem: Pesticides and the Third World Poor. Oxford:
violence and health. Lancet 2002;360:1083–88. Oxfam, 1982.
52 About the International Programme on Chemical Safety. http://www. 56 Dinham B. The Pesticide Hazard. A Global Health and Environmental
who.int/pcs/pcs_about.html. 2003. Audit. London: Zed Books, 1993.
53 World Health Organization. Pesticide poisoning database in SEAR 57 Murray DL. Cultivating Crisis. The Human Cost of Pesticides in Latin
countries. Report of a regional workshop. New Delhi: WHO, Document America. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, 1994.
SEA-EH-534, 2001, pp. 22–24. 58 Sass R. Agricultural ‘killing fields‘: the poisoning of Costa Rican
54 Report of the Second Meeting of the Advisory Group of the Epidemiology of banana workers. Int J Health Serv 2000;30:491–514.
Pesticide Poisoning Project. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2001.