Bipolar ionisation:
could it be an energ,
¥=
efficient IAQ alternative?
Air cleaning performed with Plasma Bipolar
ionisation could reduce an anticipated energy-heavy l
need to ensure ventilation systems are running on full
external air in light of Covid-19, says Adam Taylor
rying to save energy
hy demand controlling
ventilation rates purely
‘on CO, concentration
is not an appropriate
solution for much of
the built environment, CO, is not
dangerous until levels exceed
around 30,000ppm, and yeti is
regarded as the primary indoor
air contaminant by many in the
HVAC industry. Tis is because it
is not widely understood that CO,
is primarily a proxy for acceptable
indoor air quality.
Providing good IAQ by ventilating
buildings with large quantities of
outdoor air results in significant
energy being used. In addition, the
quality of outdoor air is decreasing
to the point where it can seldom be
called “fresh”.
ASHRAE defines acceptable
indoor air quality as: “Air in which
there are na known contaminants
atharmful concentrations as
determined by cogniscent authorities
and with which a substantial
majority (80 per cent or more) of
the people exposed do not express
dissatisfaction”.
During the 1979 oil crisis,
ASHRAE developed the 62.1
standard. The standard defines two
‘methods for determining the outdoor
air rate required in order to provide
acceptable indoor air quality.
Option one is the ventilation rate
procedure (VRP). This calculates the
amount of outdoor air required to
dilute the contaminants to acceptable | Bipolar ionisation
levels.
‘The second option is based around
using air cleaning systems and is
called the TAQ procedure, The [AQ
procedure allows engineers to model
the concentration of indoor pollutants
once the airs cleaned by an air
purification technology.
Ifthe calculations show that the
Jevel of contaminants of concern are
lower when using the IAQ procedure
when compared with the VRP, then
the lower outdoor air flow rates from
the IAQ procedure may be used.
‘The selection of lower outdoor
air flow rates at design stage reduces
plant size and the reduction in
heating, cooling and dehumidification
will result in significant energy savings,
technologies can
be retrofitted onto
existing systems
If ar cleaning is utilised as
alternative to opting fo fl ong
supply during peak emperte
it may be possible to design
‘cooled building when using the
procedure, compared to having in
utilise mechanical coting wh wg
the VRP. Heating requirement yt
also be drastically reduced,
The Plasma Air approach
Plasma is the fourth sute ofmaner
— the most prevalent state in the
universe. There area variety of
‘ways to employ it when looking
to improve IAQ. For example,
technology from Novaers pases
contaminated air directly thous
plasma field, giving incredibly igh
destruction rates for pathogens,
virtually nothing survives the poss
‘As you can imagine, tis iil ie
hhigh-risk areas such as ospts.
Tis impractical to coverlarge
spaces with any kind of standalone
pass-through air cleaners as the Clee
Air Delivery Rate (CADR) from ist
types of system are too low ineasst
4 good air exchange. Integrating
improvement systems into the HV
system is thus more appropriate
‘most types of building.
Bipolar plasma generating
release a stream of positively amt
negatively charged ionsint
building. Those ions then GS
room pollutants, including the 7a
being generated in the rane a
ions collide with particles
they pass over thei
SEER
28 | JULY 2020 / hvnplus.co.uk‘AUK case study
‘4 £350m-tumover FM contractor
based in Kent was looking to improve
the ualltyof the airin ts head office
longbefore the spread of Covid19,
AQ Consulting was commissioned
tocarry out an HVAC and air quality
survey ofthe building. The top three
floors of the building are heated and
cooled by fancollunits and on the
ground floor by ceiling cassettes.
Natural ventilation is provided via
‘opening windows. Unfortunately,
‘onthe top three floors, the opening
height ofthe windows at 950 mm
{AFFL means thatif they were used
to provide ventilation, they might
immediately cause uncomfortable
draughts. The air quality
measurements showed peaks ‘of CO,
‘of up to2500 ppm with high levels of
VOCs.
Poor indoor air quality has been
highlighted as a risk factor for
airborne Covid-19 transmission.
Increasing ventilation rates to
dilute viruses shed by occupants
has been recommended by the likes
of CIBSE, REHVA and ASHRAE. In
some buildings this may be a simple
strategy to implement and may work
outside of peak heating and cooling
periods.
This building is thus an example
‘of where an alternative strategy is
‘appropriate, particularly outside
‘of mid-season, Bipolar ionisers are
being fited to all the fan coisin the
1g to reduce odours, VOCs and
Particulates - and to give protection
against Covid-19,
0 you end up with all the particles
being arracted to each other. This
‘in turn causes them to form larger
clusters those clusters then fall out of
the breathing zone,
‘The results a reduction in
Particles normally missed by filters,
(PMI and PM2.5) as well asa drop
in TVOC concentration (due to
oxidation) and a reduction in the
‘eral bioburden (mould spores,
bacteria and viruses etc),
Ifyou have high levels of VOC,
and ultrafine particulates, this is a
cost-effective way of dramatic
improving the TAQ in whole buildings,
‘This consideration is of heightened
importance as buildings are now
‘being prepared to once again house
workers in line with new operational
and space requirements of Covid-19,
The Covid-19 challenge
One of the most debated aspects.
of Covid-19 is whether the virus is
airborne or not
According to the WHO, whether a
‘Virus is defined as airborne is related
to the size of particles typically emitted
by an infected person that contain
the virus and therefore how long that
sized particle is able to be suspended
in the air for. Low humidity has
been identified as causing increased
airborne transmission of Covid-19, as
large infection droplets (>5micron)
quickly dry out in buildings to become
infectious droplet nuclei (