Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Desalination: V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari
Desalination: V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari
Desalination
j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w. e l s ev i e r. c o m / l o c a t e / d e s a l
Experimental validation of thermal model of a double slope active solar still under
natural circulation mode
V.K. Dwivedi a,⁎, G.N. Tiwari b
a
Krishna Institute of Engineering and Technology, Ghaziabad (U.P), India
b
Centre for Energy Studies, Indian Institute of Technology, New Delhi110016, India
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this paper, thermal modeling of a double slope active solar still has been carried out on the basis of energy
Accepted 28 June 2009 balance of east and west glass covers, water mass and basin liner under natural circulation mode. The
Available online 14 October 2009 thermal model of distillation system has been validated for hourly data for inner and outer glass cover
temperatures, water temperature and the yield. The hourly thermal and exergy efficiency of active solar still
Keywords:
have also been evaluated for 0.03 m water depth. It has been observed that the thermal efficiency of double
Solar distillation
Thermal modeling
slope active solar still is lower than the thermal efficiency of double slope passive solar still. However, the
Heat and mass transfer exergy efficiency of double slope active solar still is higher than the exergy efficiency of double slope passive
solar still. All numerical calculations have been performed for a typical day in the month of March 2008 for
the composite climate of Ghaziabad (28°40′N, 77°25′E), U.P, India.
© 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction of basin type solar still integrated with flat plate collector. Tripathi and
Tiwari [12] conducted outdoor experiments to study the effect of water
Wilson (1972), a Swedish engineer, was the first scientist who depth on internal heat and mass transfer for active solar distillation
developed a solar still for supplying pure water to a nitrate mining systems. Recently, Tiwari et al. [13] have studied the comparative
community in Chile, which was very popular and was in operation for performance evaluation of an active solar distillation system and tried to
more than 40 years. Dunkle [1] has derived the relation for convective evaluate theoretical yield from the active solar stills integrated with FPC,
and evaporative heat transfer coefficient for an air–water system which concentrating collector, evacuated tube collector with and without heat
is useful even these days. Cooper [2] discussed about the absorption of pipe. Dincer [14] reported the linkages between energy and exergy,
solar energy radiations in solar stills. Review of passive solar distillation exergy and the environment, energy and sustainable development and
systems were done by Malik et al. [3]. Further, Tiwari [4] reviewed the energy policy making and exergy in detail. In the field of solar distillation
work done on passive and active solar stills until 1992. Eduardo Rubio et many scientists have reported that the passive solar distillation system
al. [5] proposed a new mathematical model to study the performance of is a slow process for purification of saline/brackish water. Many options
a double slope passive solar still by considering the effect of heat such as use of plastic condensing covers, solar still integrated with
capacity of condensing covers and bottom insulation. Tiwari and Tiwari parabolic concentrator, evacuated tube collector (ETC) and flat plate
[6] have conducted an experiment for performance analysis and thermal collectors (FPC) have been tried by various scientists to enhance the
modeling of single slope passive solar still for different inclination of daily yield. Out of these options flat plat collector is popular due to its
condensing covers. Aybar [7] developed a mathematical model for an low maintenance cost and simple design. When flat plate collector is
inclined solar water distillation system. Dwivedi and Tiwari [8] have integrated with solar still, extra thermal energy is supplied to the basin
carried out energy and exergy analyses of single and double slope water and hence rise in water temperature is more as compared to
passive solar stills on the basis of annual experimental data for water passive solar still. Recently, Tiwari and Tiwari [6] have reviewed the
depth of 0.01, 0.02 and 0.03 m. Zaki et al. [9] experimentally investigated work carried out by various scientists till 2006 [17]. The objectives of the
an active single slope solar still integrated with a flat plate collector present studies are
under thermosyphon mode of operation and found that the maximum
increase in the yield was up to 33%. Tanaka et al. [10] developed a highly (a) Thermal modeling of double slope active solar still under
productive basin type-multiple effect coupled solar still generally natural circulation mode without considering the heat capacity
known as active solar still. Soliman [11] had studied the performance of condensing cover and thermal insulation.
(b) To compare the hourly thermal and exergy efficiency of double
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: +91 9899132284; fax: +91 11 26862037.
slope passive and active solar stills (Table 1) and
E-mail addresses: vkdwivedi@kiet.edu, vkdwivedi94@gmail.com (V.K. Dwivedi), (c) Experimental validation by considering the inner condensing
gntiwari@ces.iitd.ernet.in (G.N. Tiwari). cover's temperature.
0011-9164/$ – see front matter © 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.desal.2009.06.060
50 V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari / Desalination 250 (2010) 49–55
Fig. 1. a: Schematic diagram of a double slope active solar still. b: Photograph of double slope active solar still installed in the campus of Krishna Institute of Engineering and
Technology, Ghaziabad, (U.P) India.
V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari / Desalination 250 (2010) 49–55 51
collector plate faces south and is inclined at 30° to receive the where,
maximum possible solar radiation. The collector plate absorbs solar
energy and transfers that energy to water flowing through tubes. The
htW = hcwW + hewW + hrwW :
bottom surface of the solar still was painted black to have a high
absorptivity of solar radiation. Solar still and flat plate collector are
mounted on iron stand as shown in the Fig. 1b. Outdoor experiments Energy balance for basin liner:
are conducted in the campus of Krishna Institute of Engineering and The energy balance for basin liner is
Technology, Ghaziabad (U.P), India starting from January 2008
′
onwards at the water depth of 0.03 m in the basin of solar still for αb ðIE + IW Þ = 2Ubw ðTb Tw Þ + 2Uba ðTb Ta Þ: ð5Þ
both passive and active mode. Experiments started at 7 a.m. in the
morning and hourly ambient air temperature, inner and outer Energy balance for water mass:
condensing cover temperature, water temperature, solar intensity on The energy balance for basin water is
the glass covers and distillate yield are measured for continuous 24 h.
dTw ′
ðMCw Þ = ðIE + IW Þαw + 2Ubw ðTb Tw Þ
3. Energy balance equations for modeling double slope solar still dt ð6Þ
•
htE ðTw TciE Þ htW ðTw Tciw Þ + Ou
The following assumptions were taken into consideration for
writing energy balance equations for different components of a where, the rate of thermal energy available from flat plate
double slope active solar still collector is given by
1. Thermal capacity of glass covers and insulating material of wall of •
′
solar still has been neglected. Q u = AC F ½ðατÞIC UL ðTW Ta Þ: ð7Þ
2. There is no temperature gradient in the water inside the basin.
3. The system is under quasi-steady state condition. With the help of above equations [1–7], one can get the following
4. The average temperature of water column in the basin is equal to first order differential equation as,
the average temperature of water in upper and lower header of flat
plate collector. dTw
+ aTw = f ðtÞ ð8Þ
5. The connecting pipe between the solar still and flat plate collector dt
are perfectly insulated.
where,
Energy balances on east condensing cover:
The energy balance for inner and outer surfaces of east condensing 1 2Ubw Uba ðp A2 ÞhtE ðp B2 ÞhtW ′
a= + + + AC F UL
cover are as follows ðMCÞw Ubw + Uba p p
(a) Inner condensing cover
and,
Kg " !
′
αg IE + htE ðTw TciE Þ UEW ðTciE TciW Þ = ðT TcoE Þ 1 ′ α′b Ubw ′
Lg ciE f ðtÞ = αw + ðIE + IW Þ + AC F ðατÞI:C
ðMCÞw Ubw + Uba
ð1Þ
htE A1 + htw B1 ′ 2Ubw Uba
+ + AC F UL Ta + T
and, p UbW + Uba a
(b) Outer condensing cover
In order to obtain an approximate solution of Eq. (8) the following
Kg assumptions have been made:
ðT TcoE Þ = haE ðTcoE Ta Þ ð2Þ
Lg ciE (i) The time interval Δt (0<t<Δt) is small.
―
(ii) The function f (t) is constant, i.e. f(t) = f ðtÞ for the time
where, interval Δt, and
(iii) ‘a’ is constant during the time interval Δt.
htE = hcwE + hewE + hrwE : (iv) The internal convective (hcw), evaporative (hew) and radiative
(hrw) heat transfer coefficients for east and west condensing
cover have been evaluated at initial (t = 0) water (Tw0) and
Energy balances on west condensing cover: inner condensing cover (Tci0) temperature and assumed to be
The energy balance for inner and outer surfaces of west con- constant over 0-t time interval. Hence, htE and htW have been
densing covers is as follows considered constant over 0-t time interval.
(c) Inner condensing cover
After making the above assumptions, Eq. (8) becomes first order
simple differential equation. The solution of Eq. (8) with initial
′
αg IW + htW ðTw TciW Þ + UEW ðTciE TciW Þ ð3Þ condition, Tw = Tw0 at t = 0, becomes
Kg
= ðT TcoW Þ ―
Lg ciW f ðtÞ
Tw = ½1 expðaΔtÞ + Tw0 expðaΔtÞ: ð9Þ
a
and,
And inner and outer glass cover temperatures obtained from
(d) Outer condensing cover
Eqs. (1)–(7) are:
Kg A1 + A2 T w
ðT TcoW Þ = haW ðTcoW Ta Þ ð4Þ TciE = ð10aÞ
Lg ciW p
52 V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari / Desalination 250 (2010) 49–55
•
The exergy input to passive solar still (E xin ):
•
Kg The exergy input to passive solar still (E xin ) is given by Expression
Lg TciW + haW Ta
TcoW = Kg
: ð11bÞ (15a), Petela [19]
Lg + haW
• • 4 Ta + 273 1 Ta + 273 4
E xin = E xsun = As × IðtÞ × 1 × + × :
3 Ts 3 Ts
The obtained values of water and inner condensing cover ð15aÞ
temperature become initial temperature for next set of calculations.
•
Similarly this procedure has been adopted for other set of time The exergy input to active solar still (E xin )
•
interval. The exergy input to active solar still (E xin ) is the sum of exergy
The constants of Eqs. (10a) and (10b) and (11a) and (11b) are input to solar still [19] and exergy input to flat plate collector [13]
given in the appendix. and is given by Eq. (15b).
The evaporative heat transfer rate from east and west side of a
double slope solar still is given by • •
Exin = E xsun ðsolar stillÞ + Exsun ðFPCÞ ð15bÞ
•
qewE = hewE ðTw TciE Þ ð12aÞ
where,
and,
•
• T + 273
•
qewW = hewW ðTw TciW Þ ð12bÞ E xsun ðFPCÞ = Qu × 1 a ð15cÞ
Tw + 273
•
• qewW × 3600
mW = ð13bÞ
L 4. Results and discussion
(b) The overall thermal efficiency of an active solar still is given by and
•
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
∑ mew × L ∑ðei Þ
2
ηactive = : ð14bÞ e= ð18Þ
∑ðIðtÞs × AS × 3600Þ + ∑ðIÞC × AC × 3600 N
V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari / Desalination 250 (2010) 49–55 53
Table 3
Value of coefficient of correlation (r) and root mean square percent deviation between
theoretical an experimental values of inner and outer condensing cover temperature,
water temperature and yield.
Parameter r e
Parameters Value
5. Conclusion
The constants of Eqs. (10a) and (10b) and (11a) and (11b) are as
follows
2
p = U1 U2 UEW
Kg haE
UaE =
Kg + haE Lg
Fig. 5. Hourly variations of theoretical and experimental outer glass cover temperatures Kg haW
for 0.03 m water depth for east and west sides of a double slope active solar still for the UaW =
month of March 2008. Kg + haW Lg
A1 = R1 U2 + R2 UEW
B1 = R1 UEW + R2 U1
′
R1 = αg IE + UaE Ta
′
R2 = αg IW + UaW Ta
Fig. 6. Hourly variations of theoretical and experimental yield for 0.03 m water depth of Heat transfer relationship used in thermal modeling
a double slope active solar still for the month of March 2008.
External heat transfer coefficient
Internal heat transfer coefficient [15] A. Hepbalsi, A key review on exegetic analysis and assessment of renewable
energy sources for a sustainable future, Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews 12 (3) (2008) 593–661.
The convection, evaporation and radiation are the mode of heat [16] S. Syahrul, F. Hamdullahpur, I. Dincer, Exergy analysis of fluidized bed drying of
transfer from water mass to inner glass cover. Dunkle's equation for moist particles, Exergy International Journal 2 (2002) 87–98.
[17] G.N. Tiwari, A.K. Tiwari, Solar Distillation Practice in Water Desalination Systems,
convective heat transfer coefficient is Anamaya Publication Ltd, New Delhi, India, 2007.
[18] S.C. Chapra, R.P. Canale, Numerical Methods for Engineer, McGraw-Hill, New York,
1
ðPw PciE ÞTw 3
1989.
hcw = 0:884 Tw TciE + [19] R. Petela, Exergy of undiluted thermal radiation, Solar Energy 74 (6) (2003)
268:9× 103 Pw 469–488.
−3 Pw PciE
hew = 16:276 × 10 hcwE Glossary
Tw TciE
As: Surface area of condensing cover (m2)
Radiative heat transfer coefficient is calculated by AC: Surface area of flat plate collector (m2)
e: Root mean square of percent deviation
2 2 F′: Flat plat collector efficiency factor
σðTw + TciE ÞðTw + TciE Þ ht: Total internal heat transfer coefficient (W/m2 °C)
hrw =
ε + ε 1
1 1 hcw: Internal convective heat transfer coefficient (W/m2 °C)
w g
hew: Internal evaporative heat transfer coefficient (W/m2 °C)
hrw: Internal radiative heat transfer coefficient (W/m2 °C)
Radiative heat transfer between east and west surfaces has also ha: Heat transfer coefficient between outer condensing cover and ambient air (W/m2°C)
been considered. The radiative heat transfer coefficient between two I: Solar intensity on the condensing cover (W/m2)
Kg: Thermal conductivity of condensing cover (W/m°C)
glass surfaces is given by Lg: Thickness of condensing cover (m)
L: Latent heat of vaporization (J/kg)
2 2
UEW = 0:034σ ⌊ðTciE + 273Þ + ðTciW + 273Þ ⌋½TciE + TciW + 546: M: Mass of water in the basin of solar still (kg)
•
m: Hourly distillate yield (kg/m2)
P: Partial saturated vapor pressure (N/m2)
•
Q U : Useful thermal energy gain from the collector (W/m2)
References q•ew: Evaporative heat transfer rate (W/m2)
T: Temperature (°C)
[1] R.V. Dunkle, Solar water distillation, the roof type solar still and a multi effect UL: Overall heat transfer coefficient for flat plate collector (W/m2 °C)
diffusion still, International developments in heat transfer, A.S.M.E, Proceedings of UEW: Internal radiative heat transfer coefficient between east and west condensing
International Heat transfer, vol. 5, University of Colorado, 1961, pp. 895–902. cover (W/m2 °C)
[2] P.I. Cooper, The absorption of solar energy radiation in solar stills, Solar Energy 12 Ubw: Heat transfer coefficient between basin liner and water (W/m2 °C)
(1969) 333–346. Uba: Heat transfer coefficient between basin liner and ambient air (W/m2 °C)
[3] M.A.S. Malik, G.N. Tiwari, A. Kumar, M.S. Sodha, Solar distillation, 1st edn, Ua: Overall heat transfer coefficient between outer condensing cover and ambient air
Pregamon Press, UK, 1982. (W/m2 °C)
[4] G.N. Tiwari, Recent advances in solar distillation, Contemporary Physics-Solar V: Air velocity (m/s)
Energy and Energy Conservation, Wiley Eastern Ltd, New Delhi, India, 1992, Xi: Theoretical or predicted value
(Chapter II). Yi: Experimental value
[5] Rubio Eduardo, L. Jose Fernandez, A. Miguel Porta-Gandara, Modeling thermal
asymmetries in double slope solar stills, Renewable Energy 29 (2004) 895–906. Subscripts
[6] A.K. Tiwari, G.N. Tiwari, Annual performance analysis and thermal modeling of
passive solar still for different inclination of condensing cover, IJER 31 (14) (2007) E: East side
1358–1382. W: West side
[7] H.S. Aybar, Mathematical modeling of an inclined solar water distillation system, C: Collector plate
Desalination 190 (2006) 63–70. w: Water
[8] V.K. Dwivedi, G.N. Tiwari, Energy and exergy analysis of single and double slope ci: Inner condensing cover
passive solar still, Trends in Applied Sciences and Research 3 (3) (2008) 225–241. co: Outer condensing cover
[9] G.M. Zaki, A. Al-Turki, M. AI-Fatani, Experimental investigation on concentrator a: Ambient
assisted solar stills, Solar Energy 11 (1992) 193–199. b: Basin liner
[10] H. Tanaka, T. Nosoko, T. Nagata, A highly productive basin type multiple effect
coupled solar still, Desalination 130 (2000) 279–293.
Greek Letters
[11] H.S. Soliman, Solar still coupled with a solar water heater, vol. 43, Mosul University,
Mosul, Iraq, 1974.
α′g: Fraction of solar energy absorbed by glass cover
[12] R. Tripathi, G.N. Tiwari, Effect of water depth on internal heat and mass transfer for
α ′b: Fraction of solar energy absorbed by basin water
active solar distillation, Desalination 173 (2005) 187–200.
εg: Emissivity of glass cover
[13] G.N. Tiwari, Vimal Dimri, Usha Singh, Arvind Chel, Bikash Sarkar, Comparative
εw: Emissivity of water
thermal performance evaluation of an active solar distillation system, IJER 31
(ατ): Effective absorptance– transmittance product
(2007) 1465–1482.
[14] I. Dincer, The role of exergy in energy policy making, Energy Policy 30 (2002)
137–149.