Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Under MoUD Scheme (Extended JnNURM) For
Purchase of Buses
PATIALA, PUNJAB
OCTOBER,
2013
Purchase of Buses
Patiala
2
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
3
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Table of Contents
4
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
5
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
List of Tables
6
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
List of Figures
7
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
List of Annexure
8
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
9
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
10
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Preface
Efficient mobility of people is one of the key factors for the progress and prosperity of a society
and a nation. Effective public transport is the need of every major city. For various cities that are
growing at a rapid pace, it becomes the most essential vehicle for sustaining growth.
The available public transport modes typically offer poor levels of services marked by improperly
maintained shabby vehicles, un-ergonomic design of buses for city transport, un-responsive staff,
and lack of proper systems oriented towards consumer satisfaction. The poor quality of services
lead to higher use of personal vehicles for transport causing congestion on roads and rise in air
pollution levels. It is therefore imperative that effective and efficient mass public transport
services are provided in various cities in order to increase the share of public transport. The traffic
and transport situation in most cities clearly point towards an urgent necessity for an efficient,
reliable and cost effective public transport solution.
In this context, the Ministry of Urban Development (MoUD), Government of India (GOI) had issued
policy circular Do. No. K-14011/48/2006-UT (Pt.) on 12th January 2009 under which the second
Stimulus Package was announced by the Government and the States were provided assistance
under the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JnNURM) for the purchase of buses
for their urban transport systems. A total of 15,260 buses were sanctioned during 2009 to 2012
which have made a big contribution to urban transport in India. As per the Annual Budget Speech
by Hon’ble Finance Minister for the FY 2013-2014, JnNURM is being continued in the 12th Plan
with Rs. 14,873 crores allocated for the current year of which “a significant portion will be used to
support the purchase of upto 10,000 buses, especially by the hill States”.
In order to strengthen the public transport share in the Patiala, city authority have decided to
implement a city bus services for Patiala under the extended JnNURM scheme. Since, the initiative
has been well taken by the citizens which has been reflecting in increased patronage in the other
cities of Punjab, it is expected to have similar kind of outcomes for Patiala. In order to cater to
increase in passenger demand combined with future requirement, the Municipal Corporation
intends to introduce the new fleet and avail the funds under the aforesaid MoUD scheme. To avail
the funds available under the Scheme, the parastatals/ ULBs have to submit a Detailed project
Report (DPR). This DPR is being submitted by “Municipal Corporation of Patiala” to avail funds
under the aforesaid scheme.
11
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
1.1. Background
Patiala is one of the erstwhile princely cities of Punjab. Located in the south eastern part
of the state, 65 kms from the state capital of Chandigarh, it lies between 29o 49’ and 30o
47’ north latitude, 75o 58’ and 76o 54’ east longitude and 25 kms away from the Grand
Trunk Road (i.e National Highway 1) and it is about 250 kms from Delhi.
12
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Singh. Maharaja Narendra Singh (1845-1862) fortified the city of Patiala by constructing
ramparts and ten gates around the city.
Patiala’s sway over the Malwa area extended beyond merely political influence. Patiala
was equally the set of religious and cultural life. Educationally Patiala was in the forefront.
Patiala was the first town in this part of the country to have degree collage – the
Mohindra Collage in 1870. The famous printing of Munshi Nawal Kishore is also
established here in the seventies of the 19th century. Patiala has a culture of its own,
evolving into distinct “Patialavi” culture. Patiala has also seen evolution of distinct style of
architecture. Borrowing from the Rajput style, it beauty and elegance are, however,
moulded according to the local coloring. With the active patronage of the erstwhile rules
of Patiala, a well established style of Hindustani music called the “ Patiala Gharana” came
into existence and has held its own upto the present times. This school of music has had a
number of famous musicians, many of whom came to Patiala after the disintergration of
the mughal court in the 18th century. This school of music continues to get the patronage
of the state through the North Zone Culture Center, established in Patiala.
Patiala with its population of 3.03 lakhs is the fourth largest city of Punjab and also it is
one of the counter magnets considered outside National Capital region (NCR) other than
Bareily, Hissar, Gwalior and Kota in order to reduce the pressure on Delhi. On account of
13
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
1.3. Climate
Patiala is part of the great plains of North India. It has a mean elevation of about 256 m
and gently slopes from north east towards south west. The terrain here is flat and
featureless. Being alluvial in origin, its soils are well drained and are very fertile. The
Climate here is typical of Punjab plain i.e. very hot in summer and very cold in winter. The
city is generally dry and hot, with monsoon lasting three months. Both summer and
winter are severe. The annual average rainfall is 688mm. On an average there are 61 rainy
days. The variation in rainfall is appreciable. The month of May is the hottest with the
mean monthly maximum temperature of 43.1oCelsius. January is the coldest month with
mean monthly minimum temperature of 2.1oCelsius.
14
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The city is well connected to other parts of the country by road, rail and air transport.
By Air: Patiala has a airport which is not operational, the nearest airport is
Chandigarh Airport (62kms) is has scheduled commercial flights to major cities of
India including New Delhi, Mumbai, Indore, Jaipur and Srinagar.
By Rail: Patiala has a single railway line, which is a branch line of Rajpura railway
line, further the nearest railway station is Chandigarh & Ambala Railway Station
lies in the Northern Railway zone of the Indian Railway network. Scheduled trains
connect Patiala to Delhi, Ambala, Rajpura, Bathinda, Panipat & Kalka amongst the
other cities.
By Road: Patiala is well connected to cities like Ludhiana, Jalandhar and Amritsar,
on NH 1 via State Highway no. 8 till Sirhind, which is situated on NH 1. Patiala is
well connected to Delhi by road as well as by rail. NH 64 (Zirakpur - Patiala -
Sangrur - Bhatinda) connects Patiala with Rajpura (situated on NH 1 and very well
connected to Delhi) and Zirakpur (near Chandigarh).
This section illustrates the demographic profile like population, population growth rate
and population density of the study area. The details for each have been explained in the
following sections
1.5.1 Population
The population of Patiala District as per 2011 Census is 18,95,689. The Municipal
Corporation of Patiala serves to a population of 405,164, which has grown at a rate of
25%. The growth rate of Patiala is average, and is comparable with India's overall
population growth, according to census 2011. The details are summarized in the table
below
Table 1-2: Decadal Population and Growth Rate of the Patiala City
S.No. Particulars Population (Year Population (Year Decadal
2001) 2011) Growth rate
15
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
(%)
1 Patiala District 1839056 1895689 2.9
2 LPA Patiala 485497 588422 21.2
3 Patiala (MC) 303151 405164 25
Source: Census of India 2001 & 2011
As per the Census 2011, Patiala has a population of 405,164, which has increased from
303,151. Total population of Patiala as per 2011 census is 405,164 of which male and
female are 215,606 and 189,558 respectively. The population and decadal growth rate are
presented in Table 1.2 above;
Figure 1-4: Comparative Decadal Growth Rate of the Patiala City
16
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Population density of Patiala according to provisional data for population in Census 2011
is 10950 /sq. km. The decadal population density per sq km of area for Municipal
Corporation of Patiala is as follows in the Table 1-3
In 2011, the city had a population of 405,164 of which male and female population was 215,606
and 189,558 respectively. The sex ratio in the Patiala stood at 879 females per 1000 males. The
average national sex ratio in India is 940 as per latest reports of Census 2011. In 2011 census, child
sex ratio was 859 girls per 1000 boys in Patiala. The percentage of children, adults as per the
Census 2011 stood at 9.6 % and 90.3% respectively for Patiala. The data has been given in Table 1-
3 below:
Average literacy rate of the Patiala in 2011 was 86.36 compared to 85.66 in 2001. If things
are looked out at gender wise, male and female literacy were 89.59 and 82.70
respectively. This data has been shown in the table below;
17
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The economy of Patiala and its LPA is based mainly on trade, commerce, agriculture and
agro based industry. City or District wise estimates of domestic products are not available.
However, education, tourism, hospitality, real estate business like multiplexes, malls and
other commercial establishments, financial and banking services etc also contribute to the
economic well being of the people of the city.
If workforce of LPA is further classified, it shows that from 1981-2001, both the no. of
cultivators and agricultural labourers decreased. The no. of cultivators which was 14880
(1981) fell down to 14389 (2001) and the no. of agricultural labourers which was 13453
(1981) dropped to 10128 in 2001.
Household Industry has been defined by Census 1991 as an industry conducted by the
head of the household at home or within the village in rural areas and only within the
18
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
As per the Census 2001, Patiala city has a very small proportion of main workers i.e. 3.36%
are engaged in cultivation, agricultural labour, planting, forestry and fishing, mining and
quarrying altogether. In comparison to main workers in transport, storage and
communication activities that involve 5222 workers, the main workers engaged in
construction activities are less in number i.e. 4460. The main workers engaged in
electricity, gas and water supply makes 4.16% of main workers.
The percentage of city population involved in wholesale and retail trade constitutes
20.83% of main workforce, the second highest number of main workers falls in this
category. 1.19% workers are engaged in business of hotels and restaurants. The total of
7306 main workers is engaged in financial intermediation, real estate renting and business
activities i.e. 7.58% of the workforce. The highest percentage in the workforce of Patiala
city is of those workers who are involved in activities like public administration and
defence, compulsory social security, education, health and social work, other community,
19
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
social and personal service activities; private households with employed persons; extra-
territorial organizations and bodies i.e. 37.70% of main workers.
The existing land use distribution determines the nature of development of a settlement
and its economic status is also reflected through the type of its physical development. The
study of existing landuse distribution helps in fixing the priorities and for evolving a
strategy for the future development of the area. The existing landuse scenario guides a
planner to allocate land for different land-uses viz., residential, industrial, commercial,
20
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
public/semi public etc rationally and optimally so as to achieve the high level of efficiency
of land which is limited. The existing land use plan for local planning area is as mentioned
in the table below.
Table 1-9: Land use Distribution
LAND USE TYPE Area (ha.) %age
RESIDENTIAL Urban Residential 2141.93 33.42
Residential Plots 212.88 3.32
Internal Road Area 245.78 3.83
TOTAL 2600.59 40.58
COMMERCIAL Retail Shopping 107.28 1.67
General Business & Commercial 27.88 0.44
District/Centers
Wholesale, Godowns, Ware Housing 47.14 0.73
Regulated Market
TOTAL 182.3 2.84
INDUSTRY Service and Light Industry 42.73 0.67
Planned Industrial Areas 70.9 1.11
Medium, Large & Heavy 92.15 1.44
TOTAL 205.78 3.21
UTILITIES Water works 10.84 0.17
Electric Grid 19.64 0.31
Sewage Disposal 0.03 -
Solid Waste 7.85 0.12
Communication 2.85 0.04
Sewage Treatment Plant 0.39 -
TOTAL 41.6 0.65
PUBLIC & SEMI Govt/ Semi Govt/Public Offices 158.15 2.47
PUBLIC Govt. Land (Use Undetermined) 49.74 0.78
Education and Research 402.6 6.28
Medical and Health 35.98 0.56
Social, Cultural & Religious 67.07 1.05
Cremation & Burial Grounds 6.26 0.1
TOTAL 719.8 11.23
TRANSPORTATION Roads 589.59 9.2
Bridges/Flyovers 3.74 0.06
Roundabouts 1.32 0.02
Parking Area 14.72 0.23
Railway Lin & Siding 27.76 0.43
Railway Station 2.07 0.03
Bus Terminus 1.97 0.03
Truck Terminus 14.6 0.23
TOTAL 655.77 10.09
RECREATIONAL Playgrounds, Stadium, Sports Complex 122.77 1.92
Parks & Gardens (Public Open Spaces) 76.74 1.2
21
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Transport network characteristics discusses about the road network, rail network, growth
of registered vehicles, traffic and travel characteristics and main issues related to city’s
transportation system.
The L.P.A Patiala is well served by roads connecting it to various cities of other districts
and within district.
1. National Highway 64 passes through the city connecting Rajpura and Sangrur.
2. State Highways 10 and 8 passes through the city of Patiala connecting Samana and
Devigarh. Major District Road 25 connects Patiala to Cheeka towards Haryana.
3. There are three scheduled roads namely Patiala-Nabha (S.R.-32), Patiala-Sirhind
(S.R.-31) and Patiala-Samana (S.R.-18).
4. Other major roads connecting Patiala are Patiala – Sanaur, Dakala, Main and
Bhadson.
The existing road network in the city is partially radial in pattern. The Nabha road also
carries the traffic of Bhadson road which merges at Thapar University Chowk and meets
Sirhind road at Gurudwara Dukhniwaran Sahib and then lead to the city. Similarly Sangrur
road also carries the traffic of Samana road which bifurcates near Bhakra main line.
Rajpura road carries the traffic from Chotti Nadi onwards and from transport nagar it also
22
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
carries the traffic of Sanaur road, Cheeka road and Pehowa road. The National Highway 64
enters the city from two sides i.e north east and south west, and south directions.
25
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
As per the master plan LPA Patiala, a total no. of 27 road intersections have been
identified within the limits of Municipal Corporation which remain almost busy
throughout the day. The details of the intersections are given in the table below:
Table 1-12: Major Intersections in Patiala City
Sl. No. Name of the Junction Type of Junction
1 Bus Stand Battiyan Wala Chowk Signalized
2 Sirhind Gate Chowk Signalized
3 Truck Union Chowk Signalized
4 Devigarh/Sanaur Road Chowk near Bari nadi Signalized
5 Gurudwara Dukhiwaran Chowk on Rajbaha Road Signalized
6 Police Line Road near Dhillon Residence Signalized
7 Mini Secretariat Signalized
8 Thapar College Chowk Signalized
9 Civil Line Chowk Signalized
10 PRTC Workshop, Nabha Road Signalized
11 Children Memorial Chowk Signalized
12 Capital Cinema Chowk Signalized
13 State Bank of Patiala Chowk/Sheranwala Gate Signalized
14 Ranbir Marg at Bhupindra Road Signalized
15 Modi College Roundabout
16 Model Town Chowk Roundabout
17 Fountain Chowk Roundabout
18 Sewa Singh Thikriwala Chowk Roundabout
19 Y.P.S Chowk Roundabout
26
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Although, there is only one railway line i.e. branch line of Rajpura passing from the middle
of the city yet there are 10 level crossings which are all manned. This railway line has
three ROB’s located at Phatak No. 22, Phatak No. 21 and near Bus Stand which reduces
the chaotic traffic condition at the level crossings. The detail of level crossings is given in
the table:
Table 1-13: Flyovers/ROB’s in Patiala City
Sl No. Name of Level Location Status
Crossings/ROB/Underpass
1 Phatak No 15 Divn. (On Rajpura Manned
Sirhind Bye Pass)
2 Phatak No 16 Near Railway Godown Manned
3 Phatak No 17 Near Railway Station ROB
4 Phatak No 18 Infront of Bus Stand Closed
5 Phatak No 19 Lahori Gate (In Manned
Baradari)
6 Phatak No. 20 In Baradari Manned
7 Phatak No 21 Rajbaha Road ROB
8 Phatak No. 22 Bhupindra Road ROB
9 Phatak No. 23 Opposite Model Town Manned
10 Phatak No. 24 Pratap Nagar Manned
Pedestrians form a major proportion of commuters. About 35% of trips are made by Non
Motorized Transport (NMT) that include walk, cycle trips as well as trips made by cycle
rickshaws and other NMT modes. Even though walk being a predominant mode of
transportation in the city, the infrastructure available for the same is poor as well as
substandard.
27
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The CMP for Patiala plans to target to at least sustain the current share of NMT trips
(35%) in the future also as it is difficult to increase NMMT with the declining trend of its
growth important to improve these facilities making it a preferred mode for short trips.
Strategies towards NMT are to segregate them from fast modes by providing safe facilities
like designated and well maintained footpath of 1.5m width (desirable 2m). Provision of
cycle tracks along all mobility corridors and designated safe cycle zones in residential
areas.
Currently most of the roads in Patiala have free on street parking, including the core city
areas like Old GT road from PNB Chowk to Jyothi Chowk, Nehru Garden Road near PMC
Chowk. The main consequence of this is the loss in the throughput of the adjacent street
due to parking interference. As part of the principles upon which the CMP is being
developed, it is envisaged that off-street parking sites would be developed and integrated
with the Public Transport terminals to facilitate the public transport.
Increase in speeds on the road networks, freight movement; land use along the roads i.e.
schools, offices, religious places on the main roads, lack of signage & speed limits result in
an increase in the number of accidents.
Trucks, 2-wheelers and auto rickshaws are major contributors of road accidents in Patiala
accounting for around 70% of road Accidents. Pedestrians are the ones mainly affected.
Buses and cars also are the responsible mode. One of the reasons for accidents is also the
increasing number of vehicles registered and on the road.
Incidentally, the highest death rate in road accidents has been recorded in Patiala district
where 331 persons died in 551 accidents in 2007 and 206 persons lost their lives in 638
road accidents in 2008.
The average annual growth rate of vehicles in Patiala is about 7.5% substantially higher
than the population growth rate. Increase in the number of registered vehicles on the
limited road space has led to overcrowding and congestion on roads.
29
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Major transportation nodes are those which act as major passenger integration points. At
these places people often change their mode and get in to higher mode of travel in order
to travel larger distances. Places like bus and railway stations and airports often act as
transport nodes. The city has got all the three.
Bus Terminals/Depots
There is only one Inter Statae bus terminal in Patiala which is located on Patiala - Rajpura
Road. The total area of bus stand is 6 acres and a workshop of 4.2 acres. There is a
proposal for another workshop cum head office of P.R.T.C on Nabha road comprising
13.50 acres .The most preferred mode of transport in the area is bus transport as buses
from all the districts of Punjab and neighboring states on their way halt at the bus stand
and quite a few originate and terminate at the main bus stand. Bus transport is also
considered as a preferred means of transport for the daily commuters which considerably
contribute to the increasing bus traffic. There is a proper link between bus stand and
railway station that makes its location appropriate as far as the change of mode of
transportation is concerned. The over bridge on Phatak No. 17 has been developed and
heavy vehicular regional traffic has been diverted through the over bridge. There is no
cycle rickshaw stand, auto rickshaw stand or taxi stand in and around the bus stand, with
the result these are parked along road side along with rehriwallas which reduces the
effective width of road thus resulting in congestion, lowering of journey speed and
intersection delay. A proposal of shifting the bus stand to a new location with state of art
facilities is also being considered.
Railway Station:
Rail transport also plays a vital role in the traffic and transportation network of the city. A
total no. of 18 passenger trains passes through the railway line of Patiala on the route of
Patiala – Dhuri-Bathinda and Patiala – Rajpura. Both routes have equal no. of passenger
trains incoming and outgoing from Patiala. In addition to the passenger trains, goods train
also pass through Patiala.
30
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
As per the CMP for Patiala, the average monthly household income was observed to be `
13029. It had been observed that, more than 40% are in the higher income group,
followed by Middle income group and low income group with 26 and 27% respectively.
The household monthly expenditure is nearly 50% and the expenditure on transport
accounts to 20% in the Patiala city. Most of the areas in Patiala belongs to High Income
and Middle Income Groups and the expenditure ranges between 60% -70% and
expenditure on transport is between 15-25%.
Purpose of Journey
It is observed from the table below that about 79.7% of the trips are performed for work
and business purpose together, where as 11.9% trips are other trips and about 2.2 % for
shopping and Religious trips.
31
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The Comprehensive Mobility Plan of Patiala is an initiative to address the growing traffic
congestion in the study area. The scope called for identifying the capital investment
required to reduce the congestion and to derive a set of potential strategies to address
the future demand.
Congestion, parking problems and in accessibility to the public transport system with
obsolete technologies and aged fleet are some of the common issues of Patiala. As per the
CMP, some of the issues and problems of the existing transportation infrastructure
in Patiala are as hereunder:
Road Infrastructure
Patiala has a total road network of 200 km (excluding local network). The major
roads and NH’s constitute up to 73 km. Approximately, 60% of the roads are two
lane roads and 20% of the roads are 4 lane. Though the surveyed 4 lane roads are
20%, parking and encroachments on carriageway has led to under utilization of the
road capacity.
Due to the spatial disparity in growth, traffic movement is from the periphery to
the core city. The radial roads especially in the periphery are inadequate, with the
absence of more circumferential roads connecting radial roadway system.
The roads in and around old city are congested due to unauthorized/designated
parking stretch irregular intervals, hawkers encroachments and traffic indiscipline.
Sufficient road space is now available inside the core city areas like Dharampura
Bazar, Anardhana Chowk, Arna Barna Chowk, Dwakoli Bazar, Arya Samaj Chowk,
but if there is a lack of planning for decentralization of core area, there is a chance
for creation of haphazardness in near future. The cloth market areas and mall road
markets will expand with time.
Personalized Transport
The average annual growth rate of vehicles in Patiala is about 7.5% substantially
higher than the population growth rate. Increase in the number of registered
vehicles on the limited road space has led to overcrowding and congestion on
roads.
33
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Traffic
Traffic volume is very high in the vicinity of old city. Volume-Capacity ration is found
to be more than 1 during the peak periods.
Many junctions are congested during peak hours.
Some junctions are not up to geometric design standards. Low sight distance and
turning radius prevail at many junctions.
Bus stops and access to minor roads are located closely to many junctions.
Intermediate transport modes like auto-rickshaws, cycle rickshaws and animal carts
are prevalent in the core city areas.
The average speed in the commercial areas of the city is 15 kmph during peak hour.
Parking
Absence of the off-street facilities results in haphazard parking along the roads,
leading to congestion on roads in the core city area.
About 70% of the vehicles are parked for duration of 30 mins or less
Highest parking demand is recorded in and around the old city area.
Safety
Incidentally, the highest death rate in road accidents has been recorded in Patiala
district where 331 persons died in 551 accidents in 2007 and 206 persons lost their
lives in 638 road accidents in 2008.
Other Issues
Lack of enforcement of traffic rules, especially inside the old city.
Non-Motorized Facilities
The share of non motorized trips is 40%. Of which about 35% are walk trips. There
is significant usage of cycle rickshaws and bicycles in the city especially near core
area.
Lack of organized NMT facilities like pedestrian crossings, cycle rickshaw stands,
bicycle lanes etc.
Patiala city municipal corporation (PMC) plays a major role in city management and
governance. All public utility services are under PMC. Road transport is managed and
operated by Punjab Road Transport Corporation (PRTC), Punjab Roadways and other
public and private transport operators.
Table 1-17: Institutional Responsibility Matrix
Planning Implementation Operation and
Sector Maintenance
Land-use / Master Plan/ PMC, PUDA PMC, PUDA PMC, PUDA
Building Byelaws
Water Supply PMC PMC PMC
Sewerage PMC PMC PMC
Roads/ Bridges/ flyovers/ PMC PMC PMC
RoB/Multilevel Parking
Traffic Control and PMC, Traffic Police PMC, Traffic Police PMC, Traffic Police
Management Systems
City Public Transportation Private Operators Private Operators Private Operators
Street Lighting PMC PMC PMC
Storm Water Drainage PMC PMC PMC
Solid Waste Management PMC PMC PMC
Parks / Playground/ golf PMC PMC PMC
course/ beautification of road
intersections/ urban forest
Source: Respective Government Organizations
35
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
2.1. Introduction
The main modes of public transport facilities in the city are local train and city buses.
These two modes cover almost each and every major corridor in the city connecting
important areas. City bus services provide services for long and short distances, which
have very good image in users as a very reliable in service. Intermediate Public Transport
system is also present there in forms of auto, tempo, taxi, mini buses and cabs. They
provide services within city, outside the city and also act as feeder to local trains and city
bus services.
2.1.1 Mass Rapid Transit System & Bus Rapid Transit System
Patiala is a small city with a population of 4.8 lakhs. Hence, there is no demand for a Mass
Rapid Transit System or Bus Rapid Transit System for Patiala city.
Public Transport system is not very much developed in Patiala City. Increased no. of
private vehicles like cars, motorcycles, scooters, light weight scooter etc, have reduced
intra city distances. In walled city mainly hand driven rickshaws are used. Local bus service
has few buses and connects Patiala to some localities as well as villages located on the
periphery of Municipal Limits of Patiala. Buses of the various educational institutes like
Punjabi University, RIMT, Bhai Gurdas Engineering College, Desh Bhagat Group of
Institutes, Chitkara and other engineering colleges, nursing colleges and educational
colleges of the nearby towns, as well as school buses also contributes towards the bus
traffic of the Patiala city.
PRTC buses connecting the nearby areas & the regions have the main bus stand and
workshop in the CBD area of the city (as located on the figure 2-2) near railway station. It
has been proposed that the PRTC workshop be shifted to the outskirts of the city.
36
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The total area of the bus stand is 6 acres and the workshop is 4.2 acres, and another workshop
cum head office of PRTC on the Nabha road spread over an area of 13.50 acres. Regional buses are
connecting Patiala with Chandigarh, Ambala, Panipat, Kalka, Ludhiana, Amritsar, Bathinda and
37
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
other places in the district. These buses run cover up some area within the city limit also. People
can board & alight at few stops within city.
On the other hand the bus stand is not in a very good condition. This is compromised by an
enquiry counter. No well defined place for bus bays and platform centers. Other problems at the
bus stand observed are, no waiting area, lack of dustbins, leading to unhygienic conditions.
Lack of PT system in city giving large scope to IPT. The number of IPT services have increased to 5-
6% over the past 10 yrs.
The IPT runs on individual basis or shared basis. Generally the bigger autos are used for shared
purpose.
Within city rickshaws share almost the same routes with the private and public transport buses,
but unlike the buses waiting time for shared auto is on an average 2-5 mins. Minimum fare for the
shared auto is Rs 7 & for individual auto is Rs 15.But overcharging happens often.
Commonly these autos are overcrowded. Passenger capacity of standard Rickshaw is 3 where as
its average occupancy observed is 4, and for the shared auto the capacity is 7 but the average
occupancy is 11 to 13, lowering the level of service.
But looking at the wider picture, City stretches are easily covered by IPT and it is convenient
because of the drop off points.
City transportation operated by Public and Private Operators. City consists of a well-developed bus
terminal in the centre of the city, buses are usually entering to city using By-pass roads. City has
road network of 89.09 km. The headway of each bus would be 15-20 minutes. In the city people
used to travel by 3 seater autos, 7-seater autos and two-wheelers.50-60% of share in the transport
are 2W vehicular. IPT stations, attracts the people by low rate fares. Roads in the city centre are
narrow and during the day time it has been fully compacted.
Support infrastructure for city bus services such as Bus Q shelters, depots, terminals and ITS
facilities are essential for any city bus service to operate successfully. Without these support
38
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
facilities, the system is incomplete and fails to attract the commuters. The details for each have
been provided in the sections below.
There are three Bus Q Shelters as mentioned below within the Patiala City area,
Municipal Corporation of Patiala has decided construct new Bus Q shelters and upgrade the
existing ones through a public private partnership mode.
There is one bus depot/workshop located within the Patiala MC limits, which is proposed to be
relocated to the PRTC workshop cum head office along the Nabha Road.
There is a 17 acres (approximately) of land available with the Municipal Corporation near Sheesh
Mahal Enclave along the Sanaur Chowk, of which 5 acres of land is being allotted for the
depot/workshop for the city bus services.
2.4.3 Proposed Depot, Terminals and Bus Shelters for JNNURM buses
A bus depot is an essential part of support infrastructure for smooth and efficient
operations of city bus services. Bus depot not only serves as an idle parking facility for
buses but also houses facilities for day to day servicing, repair and maintenance of buses
besides providing space for administrative and operations planning, monitoring and
control activities.
39
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
A standard bus depot shall constitute the administrative building, workshop or bus
engineering facilities, bus parking area, adequate circulation area and other facilities such
as fuel sheds, cleaning sheds, washing sheds etc. which are explained below:
The size of the depots depends greatly on the numbers of vehicle parking and the number
of vehicles likely to need repairs. The configuration of the parking area can be trade-off
between parking efficiency and ease of entry. The internal layout and design of the depot
area shall allow for a logical movement of vehicles based on their typical requirements.
Vehicles shall enter the depot as they are instructed by the control centre to temporarily
come out of service. Ideally, the entry and exit shall be at two different points connecting
the approach road but in some cases, it may be at same locations as per the site
conditions. The general checking area, inspection ramp/area, re-fuelling area, major and
minor pits, cleaning area and washing area shall be designed to facilitate easy access to all
parts of the vehicle. The suggestive typical layout for a depot is shown below:
40
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
41
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Identification of Bus Depot Locations – the detailed information for the proposed new
depot is as mentioned in the Table and Figure below
The important facilities (bare minimum and variable as per number of buses),
components, area requirements for each facility and other information for
Seesh Mahal depot have been explained below:
The location of proposed depot has shown in the Map given in next.
42
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
ITS increases the efficiency of the service of bus system, enable operators to offer a
reliable and high quality service and provide the bus user information.
ITS needs for the system would broadly fall into the following categories:
PMC and its transport wing will have to develop a Control center equipped with all
necessary machines and tools at the City Bus Depot with AMC for the same.
Passenger Information Systems (PIS)
Global Positioning System (GPS)
43
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Objectives:
Harness currently available technologies, with convergence and relevance for the
period of the ‘Plan’ and beyond.
Provide a clear and perceptible upgrade over 2008 specifications incorporating the
various feedback of the past implementation.
Enhance commuter experience and quality/ substance of visual displays
Make vehicle more driver friendly
Enhance vehicle and customer safety
Improve operating efficiency by reducing variable costs such as fuel, brakes and
human resource
Increased usability ,reliability and life with value for money
Standardize, with minimum subjectivity, requirements and responsibilities of
various stake holders namely OEMs, purchasers/operators, equipment suppliers,
certifying agencies like ARAI and CIRT
Empower purchasers/operators with adequate information and details for
tendering
Serve as a guideline for purchaser/operator to design ITS based infrastructure at
respective control centres and/or depots for enhancing operating efficiencies
In terms of coverage, mechanism for maintenance and operations and future proposals
for expansion, vis-à-vis the following may be adopted:-
Ticketing systems.
Central control facility/rooms.
In order to achieve a higher degree of efficiency and comfort of use for the city bus system
using the proposed fleet augmentation it shall be essential to integrate various
components of ITS with the city bus system as stated above. ITS include telematics and all
types of communication in vehicles, between vehicles and between vehicles and fixed
locations.
ITS are advanced applications which aim to provide innovative services relating to
different modes of transport and traffic management and enable various users to be
better informed and make safer, more co-ordinated use of transport.
45
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
At each terminal
At about 1 - 4 prominent points in the terminal area (depending on size and layout of
the terminal)
Arrival/Departure schedule for buses over the next 30 minutes, updated every 15
seconds
Route numbers of each of the above buses, updated every 15 seconds
Bay number from which/at which each of the above five buses will depart/arrive,
updated every 15 seconds
Kilometre reading at each bus stop, traffic light point and any other point at which
bus stops for more than 5 seconds.
Kilometre reading at the end of the bus trip
No. of passengers boarding and alighting at each stop
Tickets sold and fare collected between each bus stop and its previous stop
Total fare deposited at the end of each bus trip ( or each day of operations by a
bus)
Traffic light violations, if any
Over speeding at any point.
47
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The proposed Fare Collection System for bus operations shall broadly comprise sub-
systems discussed here under:
Additional ticket issue centers: Ticket office Terminals (TOT) and Smart Card
distribution centers are proposed to be provided at TMC Bus Terminals and the
depots, interchange points, Central Control Stations, pass issue center.
49
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
3.1. Background
Lack of PT system in city giving large scope to IPT. The number of IPT services have
increased to 5-6% over the past 10 yrs.
The IPT runs on individual basis or shared basis. Generally the bigger autos are used for
shared purpose.
Within city rickshaws share almost the same routes with the private and public transport
buses, but unlike the buses waiting time for shared auto is on an average 2-5 mins.
Minimum fare for the shared auto is Rs 7 & for individual auto is Rs 15.But overcharging
happens often.
But looking at the wider picture, City stretches are easily covered by IPT and it is
convenient because of the drop off points.
3.2. Approach
One of the objectives of National Urban Transport Policy is to encourage greater use of PT
through central financial assistance. The need has been identified observing recent
50
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
vehicular growth trends and increasing congestion. Also increase use of personal vehicle
has increased pollution.
Small cities have an opportunity to transform its transit culture and limiting shift to private
mode by introducing high quality public transit services. Patiala Municipal Corporation had
taken a step ahead to transform its transit facilities and provide high quality transit service
levels to society. Following sections in the report identifies the methodology for assessing
feasibility of PT proposal in Patiala.
Currently, Patiala has a proposal for City Bus Service. Existing IPT routes are functional on
the main roads. The city Existing IPT routes and travel pattern of passengers focused on
proposed city bus service. Importantly IPT system and system integration considering sub-
urban areas through their network.
In absence of existing bus services passenger demand for base year needs to be derived
considering optimum modal shift of existing commuters. As per the Comprehensive
Mobility Plan for Patiala, 2012 the city’s modal share was 65% by the private vehicles and
35% by the non motorized modes and the public transport share in the Patiala city is
completely nonexistent.
In similar case of Patiala, it has been assumed that 17% shift from the IPT & NMV services
and 8% shift from 4 wheelers and 2 wheelers respectively, with an average of 10%. The
assumptions are as stated below:
Mode Shift from 4- Mode Shift from 2- Mode Shift from IPT & NMV
wheelers wheelers Modes
8% 8% 17%
Modal shift from 4-wheeler, 2-wheeler and IPT (3-seater auto and 7-seater auto) is shown
in table below. The passengers are measured based on the estimates from the CMP for
Patiala.
51
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Table 3-1: Proposed Shift from Private Modes to Public Transport Systems
Name Length From CMP, 2012 Proposed Shift
(kms) Car Two IPT Total Car Two IPT Total
wheeler wheeler
Bhadson Road 10.98 360 4292 1421 6072 29 343 242 614
Bhupinder Road 2.09 683 8369 2742 1179 55 669 466 1190
3
Mall Road 1.59 180 2181 720 3081 14 174 122 311
Nabha Road 7.89 378 4718 1510 6605 30 377 257 664
Ghanaur - Patiala 29.53 255 2739 909 3903 20 219 154 394
Road
SH 8 (Sirhind 18 838 10107 3306 1425 67 809 562 1438
Road) 0
Stadium Road 1.26 523 6572 2163 9257 42 526 368 935
The passenger flows show link passenger volumes of around 300 to 1400 per day in one
direction. To support demand assessed for each link supply was calculated based on
modal shift calculated in previous section. Supply is measured in terms of buses required
per hour in each link and converted into headway. Capacity of the bus is considered
according to urban bus specification for Midi which is 40. The departures required are
calculated in assumption with 0.65 load factor. Table below illustrates the requirement in
each link.
Table 3-2: Total City Buses required per hour on each link and headway
Name No. of departures Headway required in
required per hour minutes
Bhadson Road 3 20
Bhupinder Road 6 10
Mall Road 4 15
Nabha Road 3 19
Ghanaur - Patiala Road 4 15
SH 8 (Sirhind Road) 7 9
Stadium Road 4 13
Route Identification
Commuters look for connectivity with their origin and destination. Major landmarks and
destinations are marked along the corridor after conducting reconnaissance survey. The
routes are also designed to provide connectivity across city, to city center as well as to
connect regional transit nodes.
52
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The destinations and connectivity were discussed in association with Patiala Municipal
Corporation.
Table 3-3: Identified Bus Routes for Patiala City
Route No. Origin Destination Route Length (kms)
1 Bahadurgarh Police Stataion Passiana 20.2
2 Bahadurgarh Jhill 11.1
3 Hassanpur Police Stataion Passiana 12.9
4 Phewa – Kathal Nabha Road 13.9
5 Bhadson Phewa - Kathal 17
6 Bus stand Seona Chowk 7
7 Bus Stand Bus Stand 13.3
8 Phatak No. 24 Bus Stand 7.3
53
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
To improve the coverage of the city bus service Patiala Municipal Corporation proposes to
introduce 8 new bus routes. On new routes also, PMC proposes to have minimum
headway of 15 minutes, maximum 20 minutes and average 17.5 minutes. The details of
calculation of the fleet required are given below in Table 3-4.
Table 3-4: Fleet Estimation of the proposed routes for Patiala city
Route Origin Destination Route Running Headway No. of
No. Length Time (mins) Buses
(kms) (one Peak Off Require
way) Peak d
1 Bahadurgarh Police Stataion 20.2 48.48 15 20 8
Passiana
2 Bahadurgarh Jhill 11.1 26.64 15 20 5
3 Hassanpur Police Stataion 12.9 30.96 15 20 5
Passiana
4 Sangrur Nabha Road 13.9 33.36 15 20 6
5 Bhadson Sangrur 17 40.8 15 20 6
6 Bus stand Seona Chowk 7 16.8 15 20 4
7 Bus Stand Bus Stand 13.3 31.92 15 20 3
8 Phatak No. 24 Bus Stand 7.3 17.52 15 20 4
9 Sular Road Guru Baksh 12.8 30.72 15 20 5
Colony
45
No. of buses = 2 x (run time for one side + 10 minutes of layover time)/headway
In order to operate all the routes with desired frequency levels, the total fleet
requirement for new routes works out to be 45. With these frequencies, the passengers
shall have assured supply within reasonable waiting time. It will ensure good ridership on
the Bus System. It has been emphasized that an additional 10% of the buses (5 buses) be
the spare fleet.
Hence, from the proposed method for the new buses the total number of proposed
buses required for Patiala is 50 buses.
54
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Since there is no city bus services in Patiala, the operation of the city buses is to be done
by a SPV formed under the Patiala Municipal Corporation.
Based on the preliminary analysis, at present, there are no city bus services, hence, people
are extremely dependent on shared auto, auto and NMT modes of travel. They cover each
and every internal/local area of the city. These services can act as feeder to the proposed
city bus system to improve the overall PT system and operational efficiency of bus system.
For proposed number of buses, the category wise fleet distribution is given in Table 3-9
below
Table 3-5: Category wise Distribution of buses
S. No. Types of bus % of Total buses Proposed no. of
buses
1 Midi-Diesel- AC 30% 15
2 Midi-Diesel-Non AC 50% 25
3 Mini Diesel Non AC 20% 10
100% 50
The new additional buses shall be procured as per the latest urban bus specifications of
ministry of urban development/ ‘Code of Practice for Bus Body Design and Approval’ of
AIS 052 standards and prevailing Central Motor Vehicle Rules. It shall be designed to carry
passengers with ease of boarding and alighting especially for ladies, children, senior
citizens and physically challenged persons.
55
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Bus specifications for proposed buses will be as per Urban Bus Specifications – II by
Ministry of Urban Development, Government of India.
The bus design would be eco-friendly, energy efficient, safe and comfortable with exhaust
emissions conforming to the latest Bharat Stage norms, if any or any further standards as
imposed by law and further improved standards as applicable on the date of manufacture.
To ensure compliance type approval certificate from approved test agency under CMVR
has been made necessary for the complete bus.
Buses are proposed to be operated and maintained through a private operator as per
service quality parameters laid out by the SPV:
a. Buses could be operated on “Gross Cost Model”/ “kilometres operation” basis (km
scheme) - wherein the bus operator, operates and maintains it at his cost besides
meeting all statutory, regulatory and legal requirements associated with the bus
operation. He shall operate the buses on routes, schedules, and terms/ conditions
as stipulated by the SPV. The bus operator shall be paid for his services on the
basis of kilometres operated by his buses. His payments shall also be linked to daily
fare box revenues. Ownership of the buses will be transferred to the operator on
nominal fee after completion of concession period. Such terms and conditions shall
be incorporated in the tender documents / agreements prepared for engagement
of bus operations in a transparent manner.
Fare revenue collection for the aforesaid operations could either be arranged by
the SPV staff or outsourced through open tenders from a third party. As in-house
fare revenue collection is fraught with problems of over-staffing, absenteeism,
inefficiency and high labour costs, it shall be better to outsource this operation.
Outsourcing charges could be fixed at either per passenger ticket issued basis or as
a fraction of revenue collected. The service provider shall be engaged through a
competitive and transparent process on a least cost basis. It shall also help in
providing integrated ticketing arrangement between trunk line and feeder line bus
56
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
operation so that the passenger is required to buy the ticket only once for his
journey. It shall also help in trouble free / dispute free apportioning of revenue
collected from multiple journey tickets and or monthly / seasonal travel passes.
Maintenance Strategy
57
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The capital cost of the buses to be procured comes to ` 16.24 Crores as shown in Table 4-
1 below:
The cost for depot development and proposed ITS/PIS facilities are given in Tables 4-2 and
4-3.
58
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Units (Rs.)
1 Video wall, servers etc 1 1500000 1500000
2 60” LCD Display 2 400000 800000
3 Display at Terminals 2 250000 500000
4 ETVMs 100 20,000 2000000
5 UPS 1 300000 300000
Total for Hardware (H) 5,100,000.00
ITS/PIS Software
Sr. No. Items No. of Rate per Total Amount(`)
Units Unit (`.)
1 AFCS Software 1 25,00,000 25,00,000
AVLS Software 1 30,00,000 30,00,000
2 Financial Management System 1 15,00,000 15,00,000
3 Terminal Management System 1 10,00,000 10,00,000
4 Incident Management System 1 10,00,000 10,00,000
PIS Management System 1 20,00,000 20,00,000
Total for software (S) 11,000,000.00
The total cost of the project including Bus cost, depot development cost, ITS and PIS cost
is estimated at ` 24.90 crores.
The analysis shows that the investment of ` 24.90 Crores, in augmenting the fleet will
significantly increase capacity and thereby the ridership. It will help amortize the fixed
costs over a larger quantum of supply. However, its major benefit will be in improved
ridership, partly due to increased supply and partly due to more attractive and convenient
vehicles.
59
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The objective of this initiative is two-fold. First, it seeks to enhance the number of buses in
the city in order to meet the increasing demand for public transport. Second, it seeks to
bring about a significant improvement in the quality of the public transport system, so
that a section of the personal motor vehicle users is also attracted to public transport. This
two- pronged approach would help in reducing the level of congestion by getting more
people to use the buses. The fact has been taken into account in assessing the financial
viability of the system.
PMC /SPV would continue to have a gap in its operating income and costs. However,
through additional revenue mobilization from advertising and commercial exploitation of
its property, it would be able to turn around and become financially sustainable.
The total cost and funding pattern of the all types of buses is given below in the Table 4-4:
Table 4-4: Project Funding Pattern for all three types of buses
Bus Types JnNURM/GoI State/UT ULB Total (`
Crores)
Midi-Diesel- AC 80% 20% 0% 100%
` 3.96 Cr ` 0.99 Cr ` 0 Cr ` 4.95 Cr
Midi-Diesel-Non 80% 20% 0% 100%
AC ` 5.6 Cr ` 1.40 Cr ` 0 Cr ` 7.00 Cr
Mini Diesel Non 80% 20% 0% 100%
AC ` 2.00 Cr ` 0.50 Cr ` 0 Cr ` 2.50 Cr
Total ` 11.56 Cr ` 2.89 Cr ` 0 Cr ` 14.45 Cr
Hence the total share under JnNURM or Govt. of India is `. 12.56 Crores.
A detailed finance model has been prepared considering the main assumptions such as
bus cost, interest rate, loan tenure, life of the bus, mileage, depreciations, operations in
60
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
years, operations in km per day per bus, cost of spare parts, tyres, operations hours, man
power cost, other cost. The model describes the revenue parameters and cost parameters
calculating the total annual surplus or deficit. The assumptions and outcomes have been
explained in sections next.
Various assumptions have been taken for carrying out the financial analysis of the
proposed system based on which all the calculations are done. Table 4-5 below presents
the details of the same.
Table 4-5: Assumption for financial analysis
4.3.2 Outcomes of Financial Analysis (profit – loss / IRR /viability gap funding
required)
The financial model is prepared to analyze the need for funding assistance based on the
IRR value. The financial sustainability of operation and maintenance was analyzed by
building two scenarios viz. with and without funding assistance from the ministry. Table
4.6 shows the IRR value with and without grant.
61
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The IRR values clearly indicate improved rate of returns when funding would be provided
under MoUD schemes. IRR has increased from -9% to 13% with the introduction of the
JnNURM grant. This justifies need of financial support for purchasing new buses.
62
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
It is recommended that the present PPP based bus operations shall continue in the future
also for the additional requirement of buses proposed.
Ability to recover cost of operations from fares depends on a number of factors such as
availability of competing modes of transportation, quality and coverage of the network,
population density, presence of feeder network and last mile coverage. Fare-box revenue
is likely to be the major source of income for city bus project and it is critical to set fares at
a suitable level to ensure recovery of costs.
License fee from business activities: City bus projects can give rise to a number of
business activities. These include development and management of parking areas around
stations, food stalls, book-stores, banking services such as ATMs etc. Such location-based
economic rent can be suitably captured by auctioning the right to use the facility among
competing private parties.
Real estate development rights: The right to develop property at certain points along the
corridor and at the stations may be bundled with the city bus project to make it viable.
However, it depends on availability of government land along the corridor. Further, the
potential depends upon the demand for commercial real estate in different parts of the
city.
63
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The following reforms shall be mandatory in respect of cities with population as given
below.
It is proposed that a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) shall be created to look after
operations and management of new buses at the cluster level. It has been decided that
the Municipal Corporation of Patiala is to create an SPV and the operation of the new
buses is to be outsourced to a private agency. The structure for the same are proposed as
shown below.
Mayor
Municipal Commissioner
Transport Manager
Deputy Transport Manager
General Body of Patiala Municipal Corporation
Standing Committee
64
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The key functions and responsibilities of the proposed SPV are listed below.
1) To serve as a single overarching agency which will facilitate, coordinate, control
and monitor the activities of various public and private partners that are an
integral part of the BTS planning, implementation and operational
2) To serve as a Bus Transport System-centric regulatory agency, this will oversee the
entire life cycle of Bus Transport System operations.
3) To develop the legal and structural framework for enabling the Special Purpose
vehicle as the primary operational entity.
4) To Finance, Oversee, Design, Plan, and Develop Detailed Project Report(s)
incorporating:
5) Transportation studies leading to Travel demand Analysis.
6) Comprehensive Mobility Plans with focus on moving PEOPLE and not vehicles.
7) Bus Rapid Transport Design including identification of corridors, assessment of
types of vehicles, services and integration of Bus Transport System with other
transit services, design of feeder network and infrastructure etc.
8) Integrating land use and transportation and using land as a resource for planning,
design and development of Bus transport System terminals and parking facilities,
implementation of Intelligent Transport System and Passengers Information
System.
9) To plan, design, fund, develop and own Fixed Assets essential for the operation of
Bus Transport System.
10) Explore all possible avenues such as the Public Private Partnership (PPP) and the
Build Operate Transfer (BOT) models for owning, developing, maintaining and
operating the infrastructural ancillary components such as Bus Depots, Bus
terminals, Parking facilities, commercial space, Bus Rapid Transit System, rolling
stock, Advertising etc.
65
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
11) To procure Bus Transport System Operators under Public Private Partnership mode
and to monitor and control their activities with regard to all aspects of operations
of Bus Transport System so as to enable a high degree of satisfaction for the
commuters and at the same time commercial viability for the operator.
12) To monitor the functioning of the Bus Transport System and ensure seamless,
continuous, comfortable, convenient and affordable Mass Transit Systems.
As cities and towns are the generators of national wealth, there is a growing recognition
that the resources needed for urban development should be generated from the urban
economies by use of principles like "beneficiaries pay", "users pay" and "polluters pay".
Provision of public transport/transit facilities act as ‘facilitators’ and go a long way in
triggering the multiplier effect in the city economy. As per the guidelines of National
Urban Transport Policy, an Urban Transport Fund is desired to be set up to sustain and
expand the transit operations (city buses) and to develop the transit infrastructure (bus
stands, terminals, inter-changes, depots, workshops etc).
In this regard, "Urban Transport Fund" is proposed to be set up for implementation of the
transit system in the State by the State Government. The UTF is proposed to be set up at
state and cluster level. The funds shall be generated by cess to be levied on various taxes
collected in the city. Following are the sources of the UTF, which shall be explored for
Urban Transport Fund:
5.1.3 Application
Advertisement rights generate significant revenues for the city administration. In order to
raise resources to part finance the investments in urban transport infrastructure and bus
services, a policy framework shall be essential. This framework shall aid in deciding the
nodal agency to manage advertisement works, fixing advertisement rates on public
transport infrastructure, the apportionment of the generated revenues among various
stake holding agencies, etc.
Various identified sources for advertisement revenue are bus shelters, foot over bridges,
pedestrian subways, bill boards, bus body (Exterior & Interior), tickets, IPT modes, the Bus
Terminals, electric poles(poll kiosks), railings and overhead signage-gantry sign boards.
These advertisements could be either print or audio-visual type.
The advertising policy shall give careful and high consideration to the ambience of
an area, the architectural character of the area or building in particular and to
issues of road safety. This would require the policy to consider location, size,
design, and type of sign, where the potential for creation of visual clutter and
conflicts with traffic safety is minimal.
It shall require enforcement measures to ensure that hoardings follow these
stipulations.
67
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The guiding principles for framing the Advertisement Policy shall be as follows:
Advertisement revenues help in upkeep of the facilities, also making them
relatively safe zones for pedestrians/road users.
The role of professional management agency rather than conventional
government set-up and system is crucial in bringing in more revenues.
Revenues from advertisements on public transport vehicles and public transport
stations, depots, terminal (including both, the existing and new created facilities)
etc. should be used entirely for part financing the public transport system
Advertisements on auto-rickshaws, taxis and cycle rickshaws should be used for
financing a mechanism for the scientific management of such vehicles that also
ensures the health and well being of the drivers/pullers.
New areas for allowing advertisement rights to be explored and allowed so that it
adds to revenues for investments in urban transport. However, such new areas
should not lead to undue clutter.
The quality of advertisement displays has to be monitored so as it is neither
indecent nor visually disturbing.
The details are further given in the Annexure 1
With rising income levels, there is a natural urge for people to acquire a personal motor
vehicle. Hence, the current trend of increasing personal motor vehicle ownership will
68
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
continue for some time and it is unlikely that the trend will slowdown, let alone reverse, in
the next few years. This would create a pressure for parking spaces and unless they are
provided in adequate number, vehicles would use up road sides, footpaths and similar
space for parking purposes. Therefore, it is necessary to provide for parking space within a
city. However, in providing such parking space, it is important to recognize that the
location of such spaces, the car holding capacity and the price at which it is available can
contribute in a significant manner to reducing the use of personal vehicles as well as in
channelizing the demand for travel towards greater use of public transport. It is,
therefore, necessary to strike a balance between the need to provide parking space and
the need to locate it in such a manner as to encourage the use of sustainable modes of
transport.
The focus is to enable decision makers to identify and react to an incident in a timely
manner based on real-time data and disseminate traveler information and hence reduce
congestion and enhance safety. For this the TIMC links various elements of Intelligent
Transportation Systems such as variable message signs, closed circuit video equipment,
roadside count stations, etc.
Patiala MC agrees to set up a TIMC in due course of time with the following objectives:
69
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The operation of buses being a public utility service the major thrust in Patiala is to
provide better transport to the people to avoid congestion in the city. The Administration
has to follow the other parameters to keep the city neat and clean and eco friendly.
Therefore, the revision of fare is the discretion of Punjab State and the Municipal
Corporation of Patiala. However the Punjab State will keep in view the other parameters
like increase in fuel price, spare parts, revision of wages etc.
Fares are fixed by the State according to Section 67 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
having regarded to:
The advantages offered to the public, trade and industry by the development of
motor transport,
70
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Though the objectives for fare fixation are clearly mentioned in the Motor Vehicle Act,
1988, in actual practice, other considerations generally overtake these economic
objectives. In urban STUs, 50% of the revenue is spent on personnel and 23% on material.
Diesel accounts for about 66% of the material cost. In other words 15% of the total cost is
on diesel. Hence, diesel and personnel are the major cost factors in urban STUs. However,
often fare revisions are made without taking into consideration these cost factors. The
Fare adjustment process is linked with cost of the personnel and cost of the diesel. Fare
Revision is carried out as per following illustration:
I. Increase in Diesel price from `. XX paise per litre to `. XX paise per litre.
Diesel Price adjustment fare
F (DPA) = (F-D) + (RPD/BPD) XD
Where F = Is Total Cost per Passenger km at the time of previous fare revision
D = is Diesel Cost per passenger km at the time of previous fare revision
RPD = is revised price of Diesel and
BPD = is Basic Price of Diesel when the last fare revision was permitted.
F = CPKM/SC x LF=2091.5/(CCx0.64)=59.41 fare per passenger km.
D = CPKM (DC)/CC x LF = 845.3/ (55x0.64) =24.01 paise per passenger km.
Carrying Capacity = 55 Load Factor = 64%
CPKM = 2091.5 paise per km (Data Based on figures of June 2006)
Diesel Cost = 845.3 paise per km
BPD = Rs. 35.91 per litre
RPD = Rs. 39.27 per litre
F(DPA)-(59.41-24.01)+(3927.0/3591.0)x24.01
=35.40+ (1.09x24.01)
=35.40+26.17=61.57 paise/km
F (DPA) =61.57 paise/passenger km
Increase in Fares= F(DPA)-F=61.57-59.41=2.16 paise
Increase in Fare=2.16 paise per passenger km.
71
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The Punjab State Government will reimburse all the state taxes, including VAT on urban
buses and city/cluster bus service.
72
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
An Identification number for each and every hoarding would be issued by the
Municipal Commissioner. The same should be displayed on the bottom right hand
corner of each hoarding. In case of non-compliance, the Municipal Commissioner
may demolish the hoarding by categorizing it as an unauthorized hoarding.
1. Advertisement signs are allowed at bus stops provided that they are fully
integrated into the overall design of the bus shelter. This is to ensure a
visually neat and tidy streetscape and to maintain unobstructed and safe
pedestrian movement. Advertising at the bus stops will be allowed subject
to the following conditions.
73
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The Municipal Commissioner may issue separate orders/schemes for design and
installation of bus shelters.
The advertisement, such as illuminated glow sign boxes and illuminated/neon sign
name boards on the business premises shall be permitted/ regularized as per the
MC Act. These advertisements should conform to the following norms:
1. Notwithstanding any permission given for such erection, any such sign
which after erection is, in the opinion of authority, of such intense
illumination so as to disturb occupants of the adjacent or nearby buildings
shall, on the order of authority, be suitably altered or removed by the
74
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
owner of the site concerned within such reasonable period as the authority
may specify.
2. No ground sign shall be erected so as to obstruct the free access to or exit
from any building.
3. No part of the advertisement or its support structure shall project beyond
the building on its sides. It shall also not project beyond the plot boundary.
4. Only advertisements related to products sold or services rendered by the
entity occupying the business premises are permitted on the said premises.
1. The agency shall display the balloon in such a manner that it does not
interfere with or obstruct other displays of advertisements. The agency
shall make necessary arrangements for monitoring the movement of the
balloon during its display.
2. The agency shall produce No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Ministry
of Civil Aviation, Government of India, and shall observe all their rules and
regulations.
3. The agency shall be liable to pay damages for any accident or any injury
which may be caused to any property or person by reason of keeping the
said balloon or the material, gas or any device used in respect thereof or by
reason of the fall or otherwise of the said balloon or any part thereof due
to storm, faulty operation, negligence, accident or any other cause
whatsoever.
6.0 Procedures
6.1 Erection of hoardings
6.1.1 Application
1. The applicant agency shall apply for permission in the prescribed form
(Annex A) to the Advertisement Department of the Patiala Municipal
Corporation.
75
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
2. Along with the application form duly filled in, the applicant has to deposit
the prescribed processing fees as per the schedule of rates and charges of
MC (available at MC website www.______________.com).
3. Along with the application form, the following documents are required to
be submitted —
a. NOC/ allotment letter from the owner of land/ property and an
agreement between the owner (s) of the building and the applicant.
b. Current property tax bill.
c. Structural Stability certificate of the hoarding and building (if) from
empanelled structural Engineer.
d. Engineering drawing of the proposed structure in triplicate blueprint
duly signed by the structural engineer.
e. Map of the location of hoarding.
f. Two copies of 10"x8" size Photograph taken from a distance of 60
meters from the proposed site with marking of the proposed
hoarding thereon.
g. An affidavit in the prescribed format sworn before a first class
magistrate.
h. NOC from the Commissioner of Police (Traffic) (as applicable)
6.1.2 Scrutiny
1. At the time of submission of the application, a pre-scrutiny of the filled-in
form and the accompanying documents would be made by the personnel
of the Advertisement Department. If the application is found complete in
all respects, only then the same shall be accepted along with the processing
fees. Hence, applicants are advised to file complete applications for faster
processing.
2. On the acknowledgement receipt of the complete application, a call date,
not later than three weeks from the date of receipt, would be indicated
which would be the date on which the applicant shall get the decision on
his application i.e. either a grant of permission or a rejection along with
reasons.
76
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
3. The detailed scrutiny along with the site visit should be completed in such a
manner that the decision of the authority is obtained before the call date
given to the applicant.
4. In case the application is rejected for any reason whatsoever, the
processing fees shall be forfeited.
5. In case the application is accepted, the Municipal Commissioner shall issue
an Identification (ID) number for the hoarding. This ID no. should be
displayed on the bottom right hand corner of the hoarding.
6.1.3 Post-approval
1. Within 48 hrs of erection of the hoarding, the agency shall submit to MC a
certificate from a Structural Engineer certifying that the hoarding has been
constructed as per the specifications and engineering drawings.
2. Within 15 days of receipt of such certificate from the applicant, the MC
shall undertake a field visit to the approved hoarding and check for
inconsistencies or deviations.
3. In case deviations are found, the agency would be given a notice period
upto 30 days to rectify the same, except in cases where immediate action
may be required.
4. After the lapse of 30 days notice, if deviations are still found, MC would get
the hoardings and the structures demolished. The processing fees and all
charges would be forfeited and a suitable penalty may be imposed.
6.1.4 Appeals
Any grievance, in relation to this policy needs to be addressed to the Municipal
Commissioner, within 30 days from the receipt of orders or cause of action as the
case may be. The Municipal Commissioner, for sufficient cause, at his discretion
may condone any delay of filing for upto 30 days.
If the applicant simultaneously seeks redressal in a court of law for the same cause
of action, the appeal to Municipal Commissioner shall stand automatically
dismissed.
77
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
1. All existing hoardings on MC's land/ property shall be regularized as per the
guidelines stated in this document.
2. In case it is required, then such hoardings may be re-aligned, re-adjusted,
shifted or permanently removed as the case may be.
3. Efforts would also be taken to maintain uniformity of size of hoardings on a
particular road.
4. MC or the agency on advice from MC shall complete such regularization
within 6 months of issuance of these guidelines.
5. In case the agency regularizes a particular hoarding within the
regularization period, it shall have the right to continue with the regularized
hoarding for another period of 1 year from the date of lapse of the 6
months regularization time-frame subject to payment of land utilization
fees at 20% over and above the last year's fees and clearing of all arrear
dues.
6. In case the agency fails to regularize the hoarding within a time-period of 6
months, MC may decide to demolish the hoarding.
79
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
SN Particulars Details
1. Name of applicant
2. Type of applicant Proprietary firm/company/Charitable Trust/Others
3. Address of applicant
Tel: Fax:
Mobile: Email:
4. Registration Code (if any)
5. Site location
80
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
I have read carefully the advertising policy guidelines of MC and have complied with all
the conditions. I accept that, in the event the information submitted by me is found false, I
am liable for all such penal actions as prescribed under the law.
Designation
-----------------------------------FOR OFFICE USE ONLY------------------------------
Documents submitted
81
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
82
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The statements contained in the foregoing paragraphs are true to my knowledge and
belief.
Signature of Deponent
Designation
83
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Introduction
The MC covers an area of 37.00 sq.km. The population as per census, 2011 was 405164.
The Patiala municipal corporation had a population of 303151 in 2001, which increased to
405164 at 25% growth rate. land area.
The population density of MC area was 8193 persons/sq km in 2001 in comparison to the
population density of 10950 persons/sq. km in 2011.
The growth rates of population in MC during the last decade is 25% respectively.
Every vehicle trip requires parking at the two ends. So parking facilities are an integrated
component of the road transport system. Inadequate parking facilities act as deterrent to
the movement of vehicular trips and act as hindrances to the proper functioning of urban
activities. While adequate parking facilities for vehicular traffic are essential in urban
areas, parking facilities are expensive to construct, imposing financial costs on developers,
building users and government. In addition, parking facilities impose environmental cost,
contradict community development objectives for more livable and walkable
communities, and abundant un-priced parking tends to increase driving and discourage
use of alternative modes.
With the growth of population, activities and trip generations of various categories of
vehicular traffic in the metropolitan area, a Policy for generation of parking facilities need
to be adopted so as to ensure the uninterrupted movement of vehicular traffic along the
major arterial roads and highways and the dispersal of vehicular and pedestrian traffic in
and around the areas of major trip generations.
84
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The Parking Policy should ensure the preparation of Comprehensive Parking Plans by the
ULBs and the actions to be undertaken by other concerned authorities in Patiala Municipal
Corporation for;
i). The provision of adequate off-street parking facilities within the individual premises
as well as in off-street parking lots to meet the increasing
parking demand of various categories of vehicular traffic.
ii). Adoption of appropriate development control measures with incentives in F.A.R to
ensure and encourage the generation of off-street parking facilities.
iii). Formulation of rules and regulations for pricing, management and enforcement of
parking facilities.
iv). Involvement of the private sector in generation, management and enforcement of
parking facilities alongwith the public sector.
v). Minimization of parking demand for personalized vehicles by extension and
augmentation of mass transit facilities and minimization of the parking demand for
goods vehicles viz trucks, van etc within the congested urban areas by relocation of
wholesale trading centres from the core areas to the periphery with the
construction of truck terminals alongside.
Unless a comprehensive parking policy is adopted to ensure advance actions for provision
of parking spaces with appropriate development control measures and concerted efforts
of the public sector and the private sector within the urban areas in the metropolis, the
parking deficiencies may create a major urban problem in future.
Existing landuse pattern, the travel characteristics and the future growth pattern as
envisaged in the Development Plans of their respective areas.
The existing areas of concentration of parked vehicles and the deficiencies in provision of
Off-street parking facilities.
85
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The characteristics of parking demand for various categories of vehicular traffic and the
hourly and daily variations.
Existing building rules and the development control regulations of the Land Use &
Development Control Plans and the requirement for amendments towards provision of
adequate parking facilities for all categories of vehicular traffic.
Scope for generation of public parking facilities particularly for transit vehicles, paratransit
vehicles and slow vehicles by providing innovative incentives in the Floor Area Ratio (F. A.
R.) for new developments and reconstructions and ensuring the free-gifting of such
parking facilities to the ULBs.
Rational use of the parking facilities by pricing mechanism i.e charging parking fee
commensurate with the land price as well as the development cost and operation and
maintenance cost of parking facilities, charging differential rate of parking fees according
to the zone of the town, hours of the day and the size of the vehicles.
Regulations for on-street parking facilities and the need for phase wise removal of on-
street parking facilities for effective utilization of the road spaces for moving vehicles and
pedestrians.
Enforcement mechanism and monitoring system for the proper utilization of the parking
facilities and checking the violation cases. Arrangement for periodic checking of the
utilization pattern of the statutory parking spaces within the premises, particularly the
facilities in the basement or upper stories.
Ensuring provision of public parking spaces for cars, two wheelers, transit vehicles,
paratransit vehicles and bicycles in major private and public developments and for
specified use categories viz commercial, assembly, business etc.
Management of off-street car parking lots for optimum utilization of the facilities, viz
surface parking lots or multistoried or underground parking facilities with ramps or with
lifts, by vehicle zoning and monitoring through Parking Guidance and Information System
and advanced system of charging and collection of parking fees.
Municipal Corporation
The Patiala Municipal Corporation is the planning and development authority in the
Patiala planning area. Patiala Municipal Corporation while taking up major development
projects in the area, particularly the trans municipal projects, would ensure :
86
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
provision of adequate parking facilities for all categories of vehicles including the
transit vehicles, paratransit vehicles, personalized slow vehicles and commercial
vehicles to meet the requirements of new developments as well as to make up the
deficiencies in the existing developments as far as practicable.
modification of the zoning plans and development control regulations of the LUDCPs
prepared by it on the basis of the Punjab T&C (P&D) Act as per the requests
/recommendations of the ULBs to ensure provision of adequate parking facilities
within their respective areas as well as to conform with the changed pattern of land
use. The relaxation of F.A.Rs in new developments or reconstructions towards
generation of public parking spaces and free gifting those to the local bodies also
need to be encouraged in the development control regulations of the LUDCPs.
provision of adequate parking facilities for regional traffic (cars, commercial
vehicles, long distance buses) at suitable nodal locations in the Traffic and
Transportation Master Plan for the Patiala Municipal Corporation .
provision of intermittent parking facilities for cars, commercial vehicles, etc. at an
interval of 3-4 kms. on Expressway integrating with the petrol pumps service
stations and motels / eating house.
dispersal facilities for passengers at major passenger transfer points viz (railway
stations, metrorail stations, busterminals, ferry ghats etc) by adequate provision of
parking facilities of different categories of fast and slow vehicles including transit
and paratransit vehicles.
network of busterminals and depots to meet the future requirements of passenger
movement within the metropolitan area.
Patiala Municipal Corporation being the Planning Authority, would prepare the guidelines
for preparation of the Comprehensive Parking Plans by the ULBs incorporating the steps
and procedures in respect of :
Alternative approaches for provision of parking facilities and norms and standards for
different categories of parking facilities viz surface parking lots, basement parking with
ramp or with lift, elevated parking structures with ramp or with lifts etc.
87
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Pricing of parking facilities including the differential rates of parking as per the zone of the
city, hours of the day and vehicle type.
For the existing bus and minibus routes where no off-street parking facilities are there, the
authorities would suitably alter the routes to ensure off-street parking facilities of buses
and minibuses.
Prior to issuing permits for new auto rickshaw routes the authority would also ensure the
availability of off-street parking spaces of adequate size at the two terminals.
The existing auto rickshaw routes where off-street parking facilities at the two ends are
not available, the routes would be modified to ensure off-street parking facility at the
terminating points.
In view to ensure the off-street parking facility, the PVD and the RTAs as precondition for
registration and issuing licenses would get declaration from the owner of the motorized
vehicles viz cars, two wheelers, trucks and other commercial vehicles in respect of specific
garaging facility with address.
Police Authority
The Patiala police and the Punjab police in consultation with the ULBs will:
Finalise the arrangement and management of existing and future public parking facilities.
Restrict and enforce the movement and parking of different categories vehicles.
Arrange for provision of traffic signs and road markings for control of parking.
88
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Provision of adequate number of off-street terminals for buses and minibuses with
facilities for paratransit.
Utilisation of the existing tram depots and bus depots towards more effective use/uses
including creation of public parking facilities.
Gradual withdrawal of auto rickshaw services from corridors with adequate transit routes.
Persuading the Railway Authority to provide adequate surface dispersal facilities including
off-street parking facilities around the suburban rail stations and the metrorail stations.
Ensure the provision of adequate facility for vehicular and passenger dispersals including
provision of parking spaces for all categories of vehicles at the station locations/ transfer
points of future facilities of rapid bus transit system in Patiala.
Preparation of the Comprehensive Parking Plans by all the ULBs with due regard to the
Development Plans as well as to initiate actions for development of off-street parking
facilities at the congested areas towards minimization of the hazards of on-street parking.
Modifications of the LUDCPs for the ULBs in respect of zoning plans and development
control regulations towards provision of additional parking areas for different categories
of uses within the premises as well as for encouraging the generation of public parking
spaces.
Actions for phased implementation of the wholesale trading centres and truck terminals
proposed in the Master Plan for Traffic and Transportation approved by the Patiala Local
Planning Authority. Provision of technical and financial supports to the ULBs for
89
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
preparation of Comprehensive Parking Plans and short term actions for provision of
parking facilities.
The Urban Development Department would also pursue the Eastern & South Eastern
Railways to provide adequate dispersal facilities with off-street parking facilities for
different categories of vehicles in the suburban rail stations in Patiala. For dispersal
facilities around the metrorail stations with off-street parking facilities the Metrorail
Authority would also be pursued.
Preparation of the Comprehensive Parking Plans by the ULBs and short term actions
towards minimization of traffic hazards due to on-street parking at critical areas.
Making appropriate rules under the provision of Punjab Municipal Act, Patiala Municipal
Corporation Act and Patiala Municipal Corporation Act so that the respective ULBs can
levy and collect parking fees for different categories of vehicles at the rates approved by
the government.
Railways:
The Northern Railways should ensure the proper passenger as well as vehicular, dispersal
facilities around the existing as well as proposed suburban rail stations and terminals. The
redevelopment of railway land in the metropolis should also ensure that adequate public
car spaces are generated.
The Metrorail Authority should also ensure that adequate passenger and vehicular
dispersal facilities with provision of off-street parking spaces and loading and unloading
zones are developed around the Metrorail stations.
4.0 Objectives
The objectives of the Parking Policy for Patiala Municipal Corporation is to initiate
concerted actions by the authorities concerned for improvement of the travel
characteristics by minimizing the disruptions due to on-street parking of vehicular traffic
and to ensure the proper functioning of urban activities . The Parking Policy aims at:
i). Ensuring the preparation of the Comprehensive Parking Plans by the ULBs in
consideration of their Development Plans and future travel characteristics so as to
meet the short term as well as long term deficiencies in provision of off-street
parking facilities for all categories of vehicular traffic.
ii). Involving the other concerned Government agencies in taking appropriate actions
towards generation of adequate off-street parking spaces as well as minimizing the
existing on-street parkings in phased manner.
iii). Formulation of uniform rules and regulations towards development, pricing,
management and enforcement of parking facilities.
iv). Ensuring the participation of the private sector in developing public parking
facilities.
v). Initiating advance actions for minimization of parking demand of personalized motor
vehicles by intensification of mass transit facilities and minimization of the goods
vehicle parking in the congested central areas by relocation of wholesale trading
areas with truck terminals to the periphery.
vi). Providing technical and financial support to the ULBs for preparation of the
Comprehensive Parking Plans.
To achieve the above objectives the aspects which need detailed attention are:
4.1 Generation of off-street car parking facilities for all categories of new developments.
All new developments must provide parking facilities for vehicles to be generated in the
area in respect of the total floor area as per the guidelines of the Urban Development Plan
Formulation and Implementation (UDPFI) or the National Building Code (NBC) or any other
Development Control Regulations formulated for the particular area/areas.
91
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Provision for appropriate number of parking facilities for visitors cars/vehicles must also
be provided within the premises. The number and type of such facilities to be provided
would depend on the occupancy of use categories in the particular building/buildings.
Incentives in F.A.R
To encourage generation of additional parking facilities to be used as public car parking
facility, incentives in the form of F.A.R may be allowed subject to the condition that the
additional car parking lot is to be free gifted to the ULB or to the civic authority.
To ensure generation of parking facilities for paratransit vehicles viz Cycle Rickshaws,
Taxis, Auto rickshaws etc at the specified nodal locations to be identified by the ULB/
Planning Authority, incentives in the form of additional F.A.R may be provided subject to
the condition that the parking spaces are free gifted to the ULB/Civic authority and that at
least a minimum number of such parking facility (at least 10-15 nos) is provided and
handed over to the ULB for availing of such concessions. This provision of incentive in floor
area for free gifting of land towards public parking spaces and for widening of the
adjoining roads will be subject to the approval of the local authority.
92
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Over and above, the development control regulations should also prohibit the
development of such facilities in close proximity in order to avoid the disruption of traffic
due to the cumulative effect of the congestion generated
by each other.
Provision of passenger dispersal facilities around suburban railway stations, metro rail
stations, ferry stations and bus terminals.
The passenger dispersal facilities in the form of parking and loading-unloading areas for
different categories of vehicles viz cars, two wheelers, bicycles, taxis, buses, auto
rickshaws, cycle rickshaws etc must be provided prior to the opening of any such new
facility. The Department concerned along with Police authority and the Civic authority
would assess the extent of requirement of such facilities depending on the peak passenger
demand and would provide such facilities within the premises prior to the starting of the
operation of any such facility.
The Public Vehicles Department or the Regional Transport Authority while sanctioning
permit for new bus or minibus route or auto rickshaw route must ensure the availability of
off-street terminal facilities at the two ends. No such new route should be sanctioned
93
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
unless the Authority is assured that adequate off-street terminal facilities are available.
The Police authority should strictly ensure the above.
4.2 Generation of Off-street parking facilities in already built-up areas at locations of major
vehicular and pedestrian concentrations.
Off-street vehicle parking facilities to be generated in built up areas near office complexes,
shopping complexes, cultural activity zones or major passenger terminals etc where the
existing on-street parking of vehicles create major traffic bottlenecks. Where land for such
off-street parking facilities are not available attempts to be made for providing
underground parking in nearest parks or public open spaces and by the construction of
multistoried parking structures with commercial activities over the existing bus terminals
and depots.
The, development control regulations for such areas should have the mandatory provision
of public parking facilities in cases of redevelopment of existing structures and should also
be supplemented with incentives towards F.A.R.
Redevelopment of markets
In Patiala Municipal Corporation, a number of old markets are being redeveloped or under
consideration for redevelopment. Since these markets are generally located on bigger size
94
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
plots, provision of additional public parking space over and above the parking spaces
required for the commercial floor area within the market need to be arranged. In some of
the markets the redevelopment process have already started with the participation of the
private developer. The Government may by order instruct the local bodies to ensure that
some additional parking spaces are generated and kept reserved for public parking spaces
to meet the parking demand of various categories of vehicular traffic generated in the
adjoining areas. This parking space must be in addition to the requirement of parking
space for the occupancies in the redeveloped market and may be provided in the ground
level or in the basement or in the upper stories served by ramps or by lifts. The area of
such public parking space and the connecting ramps would not be counted in the FAR of
the building and to provide incentive towards generation of such public parking space the
ULB may allow some additional FAR. In municipalities where such additional parking
spaces are not immediately required provisions for future construction should be ensured.
Taking into consideration the high land value and excessive demand for business and
commercial uses, it is to be decided as a policy to develop all vacant or underutilized plots
belonging to the public sector in the area to generate floor areas of conforming and
remunerative use categories along with public parking facilities with other uses viz
commercial, business etc. In this regard the floor space allotted for public parking facilities
to be exempted from the permissible floor area in F.A.R.
The locations for the off-street parking facilities need to be identified with priority. The
prospects of PPP projects in the above mentioned locations are to be pursued for
immediate generation of off-street, parking facilities.
The existing public parking facilities are mostly on-street. These facilities should be utilized
effectively. It is to be ensured that the parking fee is scheduled in such a manner that the
turnover of the parking spaces may be maximum. This implies the followings
The parking fee should be commensurate with the land price. The fees for multi
storied and underground parking should also include the construction cost and the
operation and maintenance costs.
The parking fee should be progressively higher for longer duration of parking. The
monthly parking fee system should be discontinued in the context of the acute
shortage of supply in relation to the demand.
The car parking fee should be higher in the CBD area and should be progressively
reduced with the distance from the City center.
The fee structure should vary at different hours of the day according to the peak
demand. The fee structure may be highest during the 20 peak demand and may be
lesser during the period of lean demand. This will ensure the utilization of parking
spaces more effectively as well as influence to some extent the travel habits.
The parking fee for different category of vehicles should be different. This should
depend on the total area occupied and also on the income level of the users.
A guideline for Schedule of Parking Fees for different categories of vehicles and for
different zones in Patiala Municipal Corporation have been given in Annexure-2.
The ULBs in consultation with Police authority would however determine the Parking fees.
The on-street parking facilities would likely to continue unless alternative provisions for
off-street parking facilities are developed. Some regulations for on-street parking of
96
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
vehicles need to be enforced in order to minimize the disruptions and congestions created
out of on-street parking.
The vehicle parking arrangements and whether the parkings would be allowed on one side
or on both sides should be decided on the basis of the width of carriageway, volume and
composition of traffic as well as the character of the road. For important transit corridors
where buses and minibuses ply, the on-street parking should be restricted so as to ensure
the smooth flow of transit vehicles as well as passenger loading -unloading.
The minimum width of carriageway for on-street parking arrangements would also
depend on nature of flow of traffic i.e one-way movement or both directional movement
of traffic. Depending on the traffic volume, the landuse and the parking demand, the ULBs
in consultation with the Police may notify a road as one-wav to increase capacity and to
minimise accidents.
The on-street parking should be away from the bus and minibus stops so that the loading
unloading of passengers is performed close to the foot path and not in the middle of the
carriageways which may result traffic accidents.
The on-street parking lots should be clear of the driveways to the adjoining properties.
Delineation of on-street parking lots with traffic signs and road markings.
The, zones or stretches of on-street parking need to be specifically delineated with
appropriate traffic signs indicating the category of vehicles, time periods and mode of
97
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
parking (parallel, angular or perpendicular) as per the specifications of the Indian Roads
Congress (IRC)
The no-parking zones and stretches similarly need to be delineated by appropriate traffic
signs supplemented with road markings as per IRC specifications.
Restrictions on on-street parking on major arterial roads with heavy traffic volume and
on transit corridors.
On major arterial roads and transit corridors with the volume/capacity ratio (V/C) more
than 0.7, no on-street parking of vehicles should be allowed.
The on-street as well as off-street parking facilities need to be managed efficiently for
convenience of the parkers as well as for efficient utilization of the parking spaces. In
parking lots there should be zones for different categories of vehicles and the parking slots
should be of the specific size of that particular vehicle category. There may be zones for
small size vehicles as well as zones for bigger size vehicles and the areas should be
properly delineated for maximum utilization of the available space.
In major off-street parking lots, in multistoried car parking structures with ramps or
automated and in underground parking facilities with ramps or automated there must be
proper Parking Guidance and Information (PGI) system for improving the efficiency of the
system by vehicle monitoring communication to the incoming drivers, in station control
and graphical user interface (GUI) message signs both variable and numerical for zone
monitoring as well as for space monitoring.
For charging and collection of parking fees appropriate system need to be introduced to
minimize hassles and delays.
98
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Some turning movements occur on roads at the locations of on-street parking lots and
these movements interfere the movements of through vehicles causing serious traffic
accidents at times. With the growth of vehicles, the traffic management by Police needs to
be improved particularly at the locations of major vehicular and pedestrian trip
generation.
The violation of the regulations of the on-street and off-street parking facilities need to be
checked regularly by the traffic police. The tendency of admitting unauthorized parking in
no-parking zones and excessive overloading of the parking lots for extra revenue must be
checked in the interest of smooth movement of vehicular traffic.
The use of personalized motor vehicles viz. cars, two-wheelers etc. need to be minimized
in the context of conservation of energy, environmental pollution as well as reduction of
congestion and traffic accidents. The demand for parking in the City of these categories of
vehicles can also be reduced if the mass transit facilities are extended and the service
levels are maintained in such a way that the facility becomes both economical as well as
convenient to owners of cars and two wheelers. Thus the extension and improvement of
mass transit services as well as introduction of high capacity rapid transit system with
electric traction need to be one of the essential components of transportation planning for
growing cities.
The wholesale trading centers are the generators goods vehicles. These centers located in
and around the central area create traffic bottlenecks due to the movement and parking
of goods vehicles. As a part of the transportation plan, these centers need to be relocated
to the periphery in nodal locations served with highways and arterial roads. This will not
99
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
only minimize the congestion in the central area but also will ensure the better functioning
of the wholesale trading activity with scope for future expansions.
Most of the ULBs in Patiala MC lack technical manpower in planning and therefore need to
be supported with experts to frame the Comprehensive Parking Plan. As such the PMC
even has not yet prepared any Parking Plan for the city. So for preparation of the Parking
Plans, the Urban Development Department, Government of Punjab needs to extend
technical and financial support to the ULBs.
In view of limited road space, high density of traffic and the mix of fast vehicles, slow
vehicles and pedestrians, the arterial roads in PMC need to be kept free of on-street
parking of vehicles to ensure a desirable level of flow of vehicular traffic as well as
pedestrian traffic. It has been observed that the on-street parking of vehicles reduces the
effective carriageway widths of roads to a significant extent and with the steady growth of
vehicle population this phenomenon would seriously affect capacities of the existing roads
and thereby the travel situation in future. Parking facilities for different categories of
vehicles at specific locations and off the major roads and pedestrian activity zones are to
be created both within the metropolitan core area as well as in the municipalities outside
for sale and smooth movement of vehicular and pedestrian traffic and for the proper
functioning of various urban activities.
Since the population and urban activities in PMC is going to be decentralized from the core
area to outside at a much faster rate in future, advance actions for provision of off-street
parking facilities in the municipalities are of equal importance.
The areas which should get priority for provision of Off-street parking are:
100
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
Wholesale trading areas and goods handling zones including Ports, Docks, freight
handling zones.
In all the above mentioned areas the parking facilities to be provided should be away from
the roads and should be managed by the urban local bodies with the help of Police
Authority. In MC and MC area and for some densely built up municipalities, the immediate
provisions of parking facilities is essential particularly for new developments of buildings
belonging to the categories viz business, commercial, assembly, institutional etc. Some
major housing complexes are also coming up with multistoried apartments and
condominiums along with shopping plazas and multiplexes. These facilities also generate
substantial demand for parking of cars, taxis, two-wheelers, bicycles, cycle rickshaws etc
and in most of the cases sufficient parking provisions are not made within the premises.
In the existing building regulations, the provision of car parking spaces in relation to the
floor arras of specific use categories is mandatory, but these regulations do not cover the
requirements of parking facilities for visitors cars and the transit and paratransit vehicles
viz buses, auto rickshaws, taxis, cycle rickshaws etc. The responsibility of providing
adequate parking facilities for such vehicles must be borne by the urban local bodies or
the development authorities. Due to scarcity of available land and for resources crunch of
the local bodies, appropriate actions in this regard often do not become possible and as a
result serious traffic bottlenecks occur at the critical locations affecting the movement of
all categories of traffic. Since in Patiala Municipal Corporation more than 35% of the
person trips are performed by transit and paratransit modes, the provision of adequate
parking facilities for these vehicles are essential. In order to minimize the use of
personalized vehicles the facilities for mass transit would require to be extended in future
and the requirement of providing off-street parking facilities for such vehicles would
increase considerably.
Similarly the parking facilities for goods vehicles viz trucks, tempos, vans, cycle vans etc
are also essential since these are related with the trading and commercial activities of the
urban area and generally very marginal parking facilities are provided with the existing
markets, wholesale trading areas or railway siding areas. Since bottlenecks created in one
area due to absence of proper off-street parking and loading unloading areas affect the
101
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
movement of vehicular traffic in adjoining localities also, the provision of parking facilities
is very important towards proper functioning of the urban activities.
The Comprehensive Parking Plan and its successful implementation in phases would
require some actions by the ULBs which include:
The assessment of future requirement of parking facilities would be based on the present
trend as well as the developments envisaged in future in the respective development
plans of the ULBs.
Land
To meet the existing deficiencies of parking, the ULBs would require to identify vacant
land for creation of off-street parking facilities. The land under the ownership of the ULB
or the State Govt would be most suitable for generation of public car parking facility along
with other uses. The ULBs would need to identify such land and while according
development permissions would ensure that along with remunerative uses, public parking
spaces are generated and handed over to the ULB. In achieving the above objective the
ULB if necessary, would extend the benefit of additional F.A.R.
Redevelopment
In blighted areas located in the central areas or adjoining the nodal locations like railway
stations, bus terminals etc, redevelopment actions would require to be taken up for
generations of additional floor areas for remunerative uses. In such cases along with
provisions of parking facilities required for the built up areas additional public car parking
facilities would be arranged which would be under the control of the ULB. The ULB would
identify such blighted areas and would negotiate with the landowners and occupants for
phased implementation of the redevelopment scheme.
102
Detailed Project Report for funding of buses under MoUD Scheme for Patiala
The ULBs would take initiative in the development of its own land and Government land
(with the prior consent of the respective department) for conforming uses with the
participation of private developer if adequate fund provisions are not there. The
necessary urban infrastructures like roads, water supply, drainage, sewerage etc would be
provided by the ULBs and the revenue from the developed floor areas would be shared
proportionately. In all such cases the ULBs would ensure that public parking spaces are
developed to minimize the traffic hazards created out of on-street parking in the adjoining
areas.
Incentives in FAR
The ULBs have the statutory power to allow additional F.A.R. over the existing permissible
limits for public interest. The ULBs would exercise the power for ensuring development of
public parking spaces and the related road widening. The benefit of additional F.A.R.
would only be extended to compensate the developer the loss of floor space it incurs for
providing land for development of off-street car parking facilities be it in the form of
surface parking lots, multistoried car parking structures or underground parking facilities.
The action plan for implementation of the Parking Policy would consist of:
be based on the existing land use pattern, travel characteristics and future growth
patterns as envisaged in the Development Plans of the ULBs. These plans would
also take into account the necessary inputs form the Perspective Plan and the
Traffic and Transportation Master Plan for Patiala
The Comprehensive Parking Plans will identify short terms actions for the next one
year and long term actions including the actions to be taken for identification and
procurement of land for generation of parking facilities at the important locations.
The Comprehensive Parking Plans would have estimate of costs of the proposed
actions.
ii) The Patiala Municipal Corporation will prepare a Guideline for Preparation of
Comprehensive Parking Plans in PMC highlighting the surveys and studies to be
undertaken in respect of ascertaining the characteristics of parking demand, the
procedures for estimating the future demand, the regulations for on-street and
off-street parking facilities, the options for supply of parking facilities and the
possible traffic management actions.
iii) The Urban Development Department will provide technical and financial support
to the ULBs for preparation of the Comprehensive Parking Plan and will also
earmark a fund for implementation of the schemes for generation of parking
facilities in PMC
8.0 The ultimate Goal
The ultimate goal of this Parking Policy is to ensure a concerted effort of all the stakeholders
towards generating parking facilities for all categories of vehicular traffic in a sustainable manner
and to minimize the traffic disruptions and congestions in PMC due to the on-street and
uncontrolled parking of vehicles. The Policy will ensure a planned approach of the ULBs to meet
the parking problems in their respective areas and thereby the whole of the urban area in the
Patiala City.
104