Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OF STUDENT NURSES
____________________
_______________
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree of
MASTER OF ARTS IN NURSING
by
ROSELILY F. COQUILLA
2010
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
What is meant by “Devotional”? When you look at the term, you get a definition
n.d.). In evangelical Protestantism, this refers to a period set aside to study the bible and
pray in an effort to build a stronger relationship with God (“Bible Study,” n.d.). This kind
individual. This is one of the elements that make up the Doing (what one does and how
one acts) characteristic of spirituality. From an analysis of the literature, she also defined
spirituality as the experiences and expressions of one’s spirit in a unique and dynamic
process reflecting faith in God or a supreme being; connectedness with oneself, others,
nature or God; and integration of the dimensions of mind, body, and spirit. (as cited in
Harkreader & Hogan, 2005).The inner experience of spiritual feelings and awareness are
integral part of the everyday religious and spiritual lives of many individual .
variables. However, the particular aspects examined vary from study to study
(Underwood & Teresi, 2008). Currently, in institutions of higher education around the
country, religious studies and spirituality in particular are beginning to be interwoven into
course work, especially in programs preparing students for the helping professions.
that people they reach out have lives that are deeply intertwined with religion
2 Devotional Experience
and matters of the spirit. They reported that the professional must be prepared to deal
Being part of the helping profession is difficult and demanding (Potter & Perry,
2002). In Thinking in the Future Tense: Leadership Skills for a New Age, James
described how tension shuts down the mind and heart. When one is stressed from an
unexpected or unwelcome event, the capacity for altruism is drained (Morton, Fontaine,
Hudak & Gallo, 2005). According to O’neill & Kenny, the human spirit is powerful
force that defines our existence, offers a source of hope and helps to achieve inner
harmony ( as cited in Potter & Perry, 2002). Hope, says Aristotle is a waking dream. As
nurses, we become the source of spiritual hope for the dying patient (Wensley, 2009).
Therefore, the spiritual needs of patients must be recognized as the domain of nursing
care. Expert nursing care involve helping client utilize their spiritual resources as they
identify and explore what is meaningful in their lives as they find ways to cope with the
Nursing students are taught throughout their nursing programs about holistic
approach of care yet several studies showed that the spiritual dimension of holistic
nursing is still an area that has been neglected (Lovanio & Wallace, 2008). Holism
psychological, social and spiritual needs. Holism cannot exist without consideration of
the spiritual aspects that create individuality and give meaning to people’s lives
(Mitchell, Bennett and Ledet, 2006). But how can a nurse give something he or she does
not have? Caring must first start with each of us. We cannot give what we do not
3 Devotional Experience
Our minds and heart need time to renew and be recharged for the next day of
taking care of critically ill patient and their families. To be truly engaged and energized
requires nurturing ourselves first and then empowering others to do the same
In this study, the Level III student nurses are the target population because they
are the ones that have longer exposure in the hospital which is believed to be the most
stressful area of nursing exposure. Will the students be able to maintain a caring behavior
towards their patient despite of the different needs they are going to address? If this is so,
experience of student nurses has an effect on their caring behavior in the clinical area. It
also aims to fill the gaps of what is not being met by health care professionals, the
Review of Literature
The journey to preparedness begins with our spiritual walk. Without this important
foundation, we will begin off course or eventually will be led off course by many voices
of our day. Each of these voices may seem like they are telling us the good and right
and Alpert’s research compared nurses who were prepared in providing spiritual care
4 Devotional Experience
with nurses who were not prepared in spiritual care. On the section of the survey that
identified “personal sources of spiritual strength” the researchers found that parish nurses
ranked prayer, talking to someone and reading spiritual resources as the three most used
sources for finding strength in coping with their own life struggles. Prayer helps to
alleviate anxiety, and it lifts up the spirit (as cited in Hickman, 2006). Reading the Bible
and turning to God in prayer function as a reality check. Finding or starting a nurses’
fellowship group where they can unload their burdens, pray, study the bible, and stay
accountable is the key to survival in nursing. As they find their identity in Christ, they
will increasingly sense the love of God urging them on, giving them the strength to keep
going in nursing (Shelly, 2008). Rowe (2008) had also emphasized in his book, which is
entitled: On Call: Daily Encouragement for Nurses that nurses need encouragement,
care, and medicine for the soul to be an agent of hope and healing. Bible reading help
nurses gain important insight into their own spiritual health as well as learn how to be
better help others. When God is at work in our hearts, it shows in our countenance- both
Peale in his book entitled “A Guide to Confident Living” concludes that it is impossible
to create an efficient man unless he has some kind of spiritual experience. Without this
experience, the thing that gives him the final touch of power is lacking (as cited in
Lardizabal, 2006).
In British Virgin Islands and Eleuthera, nursing students took part in daily
devotionals. They often shared a prayer or passage from scripture with them. The
experience offered the students a way of seeing how one can use faith to strengthen
5 Devotional Experience
oneself as a practitioner and share the faith with patients in a way that strengthen them”
(Auchmutey, 2005). Dossey, Lynn, & Guzzetta, concurred that spiritual experience can
enhance feeling of compassion, peace of mind, and harmony with the environment
Potter & Perry (2005) on the other hand pointed out that for those people who
find caring a normal part of their life, their caring behavior is a product of their culture,
values, experience and relationship with others. Persons who do not experience care in
their lives, finds it difficult to act in caring ways. This idea coincided to the written article
in Journal of General Intern Medicine (2007) that caring attitudes are feelings and
opinion arising from values that affirm the importance of understanding others as
individual with unique needs, in the context of individual community and cultural
relationship. Warelow, Edward & Vinek (2008) added that caring is neither simply a set
of attitudes or theories, nor does it comprise all that nurses do. Nursing care is determined
by the way nurses use knowledge and skills to appreciate the uniqueness of the person
There were also studies conducted about the influence of sex to the caring
“Gender and Helping Behavior.” The article confirmed that women are more nurturing
findings is contradictory to Khademian and Vizeshfar, (2008) result that gender had no
Nursing is an art .This means that a professional nurse learns to deliver care
artfully with compassion, caring, and respect for each client dignity and personhood
(Potter & Perry 2005). Nursing is a noble profession, but too often, a terrible job (Tee,
2008). Shelly (2008) further elaborated that as the environment where nurses’ work
become increasingly secular, economically driven and impersonal, one can expect
conflict and even persecution. On the other hand, Chambliss described nursing as a
stated that as nurses use the term “care,” it seems to include four meanings, namely: 1)
face-to-face working with patients; nurses believe that nursing care is hands-on. For
example, nurse give baths, catheterize patients, clean the bedcover, etc. They constantly
talk with or listen to patients while doing nursing procedures aside from touching their
patients in intimate ways; 2) dealing with the patient as a whole person. (as cited in Tee,
2008). Javier (2008) agreed to Chambliss description that nurses’ job of caring for
with having to do with the living body, the temple of God’s spirit? It is
one of the Fine Arts, I had almost said, the finest of Fine Arts. (p.5)’
Breunig substantiated Nightingales claim by his story of the Zen master who
draws the bow and waits without purpose until the moment of highest tension.
7 Devotional Experience
Her point is that every great artist is a great craftsperson who knows how to draw the bow
perfectly. This story indicates while both art and craft have purpose, art occurs to the
demands of today’s health care environment. Caring is a word that seems synonymous
with nursing, but what does it mean? What does it look like when nurses are caring and
what does it look like when they are not caring? Barnum sees caring as having three
discreet meanings. Firstly, taking care, or taking care of, as expressed by actions that
meet the patient’s bodily needs. Secondly, caring as expressed when the nurse has an
emotional investment in the patient’s well being: the nurse cares about the patient. The
emphasis here is on emotion and attitudes, rather than actions. Thirdly, he talks about
caring as expressed in being careful and precise, and acting in a way that makes the
patient safe from injury. This again about attitudes but not necessarily emotions (Stroud,
2008).
Caring has been shown to facilitate healing in clients and to improve client
satisfaction with nursing care (Potter & Perry, 2005). Often times, we hear the common
expression, “I care about you,” or “I will help you overcome this.” What then is in the
care given by a nurse that is so powerful that it can lead to a process of healing? The
caring energy is so powerful that enhances healing combined with the core factors
identified by Watson. These core factors are: 1) faith and hope; 2) humanistic system of
Moreover, there is power in nursing profession when nurses articulate not only
the core values of “caring” but of advocacy, accountability, autonomy, and collaboration
Erb, Berman & Synder, 2004). Most nurses still enter the profession of nursing because
of a desire to help others. Caring for others is obviously a positive character trait, but
many nurses have not learned the importance of taking care of themselves in the process
(Slaninka, 2003). Caring must first start with each of us. We cannot give what we do not
possess. Self care is very important and is the key to giving compassionate care to our
patients, families and others who may cross our paths. When you feel good about
yourself, it spills over into every aspect of your life (“ Nursing as Caring,” n.d.).
Caring is central to nursing practice but perhaps it has never been more important
because of today’s hectic health care environment. The pressure and time constraints on
health care workers in most health care settings can result in nurses and other
professionals becoming cold and indifferent to client needs (Potter and Perry, 2005).
Clients quickly know when nurses fail to relate them. It is in this context that some
researchers made a study about the different perception of patient on the care given to
them by the health care provider. This is important because healthcare is placing
frequently clients and nurses differ in their perception in caring. For that reason, nurses
must focus on building a relationship that allows them to learn what is important to their
“If we hope to improve the health status of all people, health care and
Need to address the psychosocial and cultural component – the mind and
The said statement was supported by Neuman who conceptualized the client as a
structure energy resources of the client and function to attain, maintain or retain system
stability ( as cited in Hickman, 2006). Jung also asserted that human beings are not only
psychosexual and psychosocial but they are also psycho-spiritual. Hence, he suggested
that healing is not possible without spiritual awakening or addressing issues related to
moral insights alone are insufficient to address human dilemmas (as cited in Maximo,
2001).
treatment. However, the study conducted by Wright (2002) showed that the spiritual
needs of patients are still neglected by health care professionals who are already over-
stretched by the physical demands of their role. Furthermore, there is also ignorance of
the spiritual needs of health care professionals especially nurses who may have personal
uncertainties about their own spirituality. This lack of understanding can lead nurses to
Furthermore, nurses strive to incorporate holistic care that includes spiritual care
into nursing practice. The concept of providing spiritual care is derived from nursing
spiritual care by nurse is often infrequent and underutilized facet of care (Wensley,
2009).
A spiritually adept individual has adequate self object relations which make it
possible for him to be serene despite the lures of materialism, emotionally-loaded events,
Nursing today acknowledges that the needs of the spirit are as important as
physical needs for a person’s well being. Increased awareness and preparation together
with a united approach to this dimension of nursing practice, will be shown to enhance
the quality of our care and strengthen our contribution to the ongoing development of our
enjoying music and arts are activities that nurture the mind and spirit, it contributes to the
person’s
11 Devotional Experience
spirituality (Potter and Perry, 2005). Spirituality according to Underwood (2002) can call
processes, which have now replaced her carative factors that results in the satisfaction of
certain human needs (as cited in Octaviano & Balita, 2008). The philosophy underlying
her theory involves concepts of psychic energy and love, and her expectation is that
nurses wishing to work authentically with it need develop life practices such as
meditation, prayer, yoga and connection with nature (To Touch on Caring, n.d.). It is also
cited in Potter and Perry (2005) that Watson’s view of caring becomes almost spiritual
and application of such caring model in practice can enhance nurse’s caring practice.
Patricia Benner speaks of the “power” of caring. Her description of the caring role
power, participative/affirmative power and problem solving (as cited in Fly, 2008). Her
work together with Wrubel, the theory of connectedness emphasized that thoughts,
feelings and actions are all important to the conception of caring behavior ( “To touch on
Caring”, 2002).
relating to a valued other toward whom one tells a personal sense of commitment and
responsibility. In presenting her theory, Swanson described the five caring processes as
12 Devotional Experience
enhance the value of professional caring. They have helped to create an atmosphere
within the nursing profession which values the wholeness of human beings including
their psychosocial and spiritual needs which is the focus of this study. Many of their
beliefs can be accepted and affirmed by nurses who developed a strong relationship with
Swanson’s theory on the other hand can help to provide a meaningful base for
student nurses to manifest a caring behavior that can be perceived as nurturing or helpful
to the patients.
Demographic Profile
Age
Sex
Religion
Civil Status
Intervening Variables
It is a common knowledge that nursing is a tough job. Most nurses need some
form of reassurance from others that they are doing a good job. Praise from the patients,
colleagues and supervisors keeps them going. But in today’s health care scene, nurses
according to Shelly ( 2008), don’t often received that affirmation. Nurses need to draw
from a deeper source for them to become effective in rendering care to the clients.
The conceptual model as illustrated above shows that devotional experience such
as scripture reading, bible sharing, exhortation and prayer has influence on the physical,
psychosocial and spiritual aspect of caring behavior apparent to the student nurses.
Age, religion, sex and civil status are other mediating variables that intervene in
The study aims to determine the relationship between devotional experience and the
2.1 physiological
2.2 emotional
2.3 spiritual
3.1 age
14 Devotional Experience
3.2 sex
3.4 religion
Hypothesis
• age
• sex
• Civil status
• religion
CHAPTER II
METHODS
research designs, research locales, samples and the sampling technique, the subjects,
research instruments, data gathering procedures and the statistical tools, treatments and
Design
The study will use the post-test descriptive correlational design to compare the
caring behavior of student nurses who have devotional experience and those that do not
have devotional experience. The caring behavior of students will be measured using a
post test which will be administered to both the control and the experimental.
To enhance the validity of the quantitative results, the investigator would like to use
qualitative analysis to understand what is about the devotional experience that affect the
X ------------ O1
------------------- O2
Whereas:
16 Devotional Experience
X – devotional experience
Setting
General Santos City occupying almost one hectare of land. BCSI has gained its
BCSI is already on its sixth year of operation offering six courses namely: Bachelor of
which it comprises majority of student population, midwifery and the six months
caregiving program.
efforts to the cause of Christian education, the development of christian character and
personal discipline among students. Presently, the college still keep on working out a
Participants
The participants/respondents of this study will be regular Level III student nurses
of BCSI.This is particularly because Level III student nurses have longer hours spent in
17 Devotional Experience
the hospital as compared to other levels. It is also believed that hospital duties are
considered the most demanding and stressful area of exposure for student nurses. Thusthe
likelihood of stress affecting their caring behavior towards their patients is great.
Measures
The researcher then will be using two sets of questionnaires for this study. The
first one is a self-administered questionnaire, which is divided into two parts. The first
portion contains the demographic questions. The aim is to collect data as regards to the
which the element of life may influence emotion, cognition and behavior of student
nurses. The measure includes 10 items statements. Each item is scored using a modified
Likert scale, in which response categories are many times a day, everyday, once in a
while and never. Higher scores, reflect more frequent experience with God’s presence.
The statistical instrument to be used in this study are Mean and Spearman’s rank order
on the qualitative part of the study. Meanings will be formulated and the statement will
Procedure
Pre-experimental phase
1. The researcher-made questionnaire will be shown to the mentor for checking and
approval.
2. The instrument will undergo validation by experts and reliability testing will also
be done.
3. Once approval from the mentor is secured, a cover letter will be sent to the Chief
Executive Officer of BCSI and Dean of the College of Nursing, explaining the
4. Two groups that consist of twelve students for each group will be selected by
cluster random sampling using Fish Bowl Technique where samples will be
drawn out from eight RLE groupings of Level III students with identifying marks.
A group who will be able to pick the letter O1 will be considered as experimental
group and for the group who picks O2 will be considered as control group.
5. Once the sample has been determined, cover letters and consent forms will be
Experimental stage
end of their second week of rotation in the same area with the same clinical
the investigator herself and will be collected immediately after they have
completely answered the items. Same procedure will follow to the controlled
group but they will not be having devotional during their pre-conference.
7. All the data gathered would be tallied and tabulated then will be analyzed and
8. For the qualitative aspect of the study,. A focus group discussion will be
private, quiet room in the vicinity of BCSI.I will be recorded and transcribed
verbatim. The guide questions for the students are the following:
you?
A. BOOK REFFERENCES
Asperas, C.M. (2005) Basic nursing research: Trends, methods and applications (1st ed.).
Philippines: Educational Publishing House Inc.
Dagohoy, D.H., Decena, N.T. (2008). Preparedness of student nurses to care for
terminally ill clients in ICU setting. Mindanao Nursing Journal, 2012-2713,59-71.
Hilman, O. (2000). Today God is first. Shippensburg, PA: Destiny Image Publishers,
Inc.
Maximo, S. (2001). The constructs of spiritual intelligence, its correlates with stress
management and variation across selected variables. Saint Louis University,
Baguio City.
Morton, P. G., Fontaine, D. K., Hudak, C. M., Gallo, B. M. (2005). Critical care nursing:
A holistic approach. (8th ed.). Philadelphia PA. Lippincot Williams & Wilkins
Potter, P.A., Perry, A.G. (2005). Fundamentals of nursing. (6th ed.). Singapore Mosby
Inc.
Preparing theses and dissertations: Basic guidelines on using APA format. (2008) Davao
City: San Pedro College Research Publication.
Tee, E.A. ( 2008). Assessment of caring behavior in nursing education: Quantitative and
phenomenological approach. Mindanao Nursing Journal, 2012-2713, 46-58.
Van Leeuwen R., Tiesinga L., Post, D., Jochemsen, H. (2006). Spiritual care:
Implications for nurses professional responsibility. Journal of Clinical Nursing,
15, (7), 875-884
Warelow P., Edward K. L., Vinek J. (2008). Care: What nurses say and what nurses do.
Holistic Nursing Practice, 22 (3), 146-153
Warren, R. (2002). The purpose driven life. USA: Zondervan Grand Rapids.
Wilkinson, J.M, Van Leuven, K. (2007). Fundametals of ursing: Theory concepts &
application (vol.1). Philadelphia: F.A Davis Company.
Wright S.G. (2002). Examining the impact of spirituality on nurses and health-care
provision. Professional Nurse, 17, (12), 709-711.
B. ELECTRONIC REFERENCES
Finch, L.(n.d.). Uncovering the science behind the value of caring. Retrieved December
15, 2008, from
www.anfonline.org/MainCategory/.../NRGScholars/Finch.aspx
Fly, N. A. (1993). Beyond professional caring: Teaching nursing students the art of
Christian caring. Retrieved May 20, 2009,from
http://aiias.edu/ict/vol_10/10cc_167-185.htm
Heffern, R. (2001). Loyola Chicago trains spirituality in social work and nursing.
Retrieved December 14, 2008, from
http://findarticles. com/p/mll41/is_41_37/ai_7912874
Markham, I. (2006). Daily space with God. The practices of personal devotion in
mainline, protestant, roman catholic, and Evangelical Traditions. Retrieved
December 2, 2008, from
http://www.hartsem.edu
Mahoney, K. (2008). What is devotional and why is devotional important? Do I really
need a devotional? . Retrieved November 15,2008, from
http://www.cpals.net
Men or Women: Which is the more generous sex? (n.d.). Retrieved January 26, 2009,
from
http://www.incharacter.org/article.php?article=70
Rowe, L. (n.d.). On call: Daily encouragement for nurses. Exerpt retrieved December 15,
2008, from
http://www.christianbook.com
Shelly, J.A. (2000). Fanning the flame. Journal of Christian Nursing. Retrieved
December 15, 2008, from
http:// ncf-jcn.org/archive/oosp/oosp_editorial.html
Shelly, J. A., & Miller, A. B. (2006). Called to care: A christian worldview for nursing.
Retrieved Novemeber 3, 2008, from
http://www.ncf-jcn.org
Swanson, K. M., (1993). Nursing as informed caring for the well-being of others.
Retrieved May 2009, from
http://www.son.washington.edu/departments
/fcn/swanson/Nursing%20as%20informed%20caring.pdf
Walker, C. (n.d.). Inspiration for practice. Retrieved December 15, 2008, from
http://www.ncf-jcn.org.