Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bis and Me2 PDF
Bis and Me2 PDF
Received: 10 September 2001 Abstract Objectives: To evaluate brain-dead at the time of admission,
Accepted: 2 January 2002 the accuracy of bispectral index and their individual BIS values were
Published online: 19 March 2002 (BIS) monitoring for the diagnosis of between 20 and 79. Twenty-seven of
© Springer-Verlag 2002 brain death in severely comatose pa- these patients became brain-dead,
tients. Design: A prospective study and their individual BIS values
in an intensive care unit of a univer- dropped to 0 in a few hours to a few
sity hospital. Population: Fifty-six days. In these 27 patients EEG or ce-
severely comatose patients (Glasgow rebral angiography was performed
Coma Score ≤5) admitted to the ICU after the BIS value decreased to 0
mainly because of intracerebral hem- and confirmed brain death in all
orrhage, head injury, or postanoxic cases. Seventeen patients who did
coma. Methods: BIS was recorded not become brain dead during their
B. Vivien (✉) · X. Paqueron continuously during the hospitaliza- hospitalization in the ICU had per-
P. Le Cosquer · O. Langeron · P. Coriat tion in the ICU. Where necessary, sistent electrocerebral activity on
B. Riou
Département d’Anesthésie-Réanimation, clinical brain death was confirmed EEG, and their average BIS values
Groupe Hospitalier Pitié Salpêtrière, by EEG or cerebral angiography. remained above 35. Conclusion: BIS
47-83 Boulevard de l’Hôpital, 75013 Paris, Measurements and results: Twelve can be used in severely comatose pa-
France patients were already clinically brain tients as an assessment of brain
e-mail: benoit.vivien@psl.ap-hop-paris.fr dead at the time of admission, and death onset, enabling appropriate
Tel.: +33-1-42162251
Fax: +33-1-42162269 their individual BIS values were 0. scheduling of either EEG or cerebral
In each of these 12 patients brain angiography to confirm brain death.
B. Riou
Service d’Accueil des Urgences, death was thereafter confirmed by
Groupe Hospitalier Pitié Salpêtrière, Paris, EEG or cerebral angiography. Forty- Keywords Bispectral index · Brain
France four patients were not clinically death
Initially Finally
tical lines every 10 min) are linked to regular resets of the monitor
for EMG monitoring. No sedative drugs were used in this patient.
b BIS and EMG course in a 53-year-old patient admitted to the
ICU after spontaneous intracerebral hemorrhage. Approximately
2.5 h after admission the BIS value dropped to 0 within a few
minutes, simultaneously with clinical brain death and a slow de-
crease in EMG activity. Sedative drugs were stopped as soon as
Fig. 1a–c Typical bispectral index (BIS) and electromyographic neurological examination worsened. Two EEG performed 1 and
activity (EMG) course in severely comatose patients. a BIS and 5 h later confirmed brain death, and the patient’s family allowed
EMG trend recordings in a 52-year-old brain-dead patient admit- organ donation. c BIS and EMG course in a 46-year-old patient
ted to the ICU for organ donation. Before these recordings brain admitted to the ICU after spontaneous brainstem hemorrhage, with
death was previously assessed by clinical examination and con- an initial GCS of 3. Sedative drugs were used in this patient for
firmed by cerebral angiography in another hospital. After family adaptation to ventilatory support. The BIS course showed slow
authorization this patient was transferred into our ICU for organ variations according to level of sedation during the 20 h of record-
donation. As expected, upon arrival at the ICU the patient’s BIS ing. This patient partially recovered from his cerebral hemorrhage
was permanently equal to 0, except some very small increases due and was transferred 4 days later into a specialized neurological
to environmental activity. The regular peaks in EMG activity (ver- ICU
422
Table 2 Overall accuracy of BIS monitoring to detect brain death. During progression to brain death the BIS sometimes
The overall number of evaluations for each group (brain dead and decreased to 0 a short time before complete clinical brain
not brain dead) was calculated by cumulating both initial (n=56)
and final (n=56) evaluations death. For example, in two patients, although the BIS
value had already dropped to 0 within a few minutes, the
BIS=0 BIS>0 Total cough response to bronchial suctioning was still present;
in less than 2 h it finally disappeared, enabling the clini-
Brain dead 51 0 51 cal diagnosis of brain death, which was thereafter con-
Not brain dead 0 61 61
Total 51 61 112 firmed by EEG.
ments, and the real-time EEG waveform displayed regu- tively, BIS uses EEG signals up to 47 Hz [18]. Indeed,
lar oscillations at the same frequency as heart rate. To re- clinically, low-frequency EMG activity has already been
duce this hyperpulsatility epinephrine was changed for reported to falsely elevate BIS values in anesthetized pa-
norepinephrine. Immediately after this switch the hyper- tients without muscle relaxants [19]. Significant EMG
pulsatility decreased, and the real-time EEG waveform activity may be present in brain-dead patients [20], and
oscillations disappeared, while BIS values quickly de- has been reported as a major artifact during EEG record-
creased to 0. No other overestimation of BIS values only ings for determining electrocortical silence [21, 22, 23].
due to cardiovascular hyperpulsatility was observed in Elsewhere, Mayr et al. [23], who reported “tetaniform”
the 38 remaining brain-dead patients. muscle activity during EEG recording in five potential
organ donors, suggested that this enhanced EMG activity
could be due to hyperexcitability of the nerve membrane
Discussion caused by artificial hyperventilation in brain-dead pa-
tients. This interference between BIS and EMG activity
This study shows that in the 56 severely comatose pa- is an important pitfall for using BIS in severely comatose
tients studied BIS values were 0 in patients already and brain-dead patients. We hypothesize that this mis-
brain-dead at the time of admission, and always de- take is due in such patients to the very weak, or absence
creased to 0 in the 37 patients who approached brain of, EEG signal, as compared to the EMG activity. In
death during hospitalization in ICU. Against this, aver- these cases the BIS monitor interprets EMG signals in
age BIS values remained above 35 in the 17 patients who the 30- to 47-Hz band as EEG, especially when there is
never progressed to brain death during their hospitaliza- no EEG signal in the 0.5–30 Hz band. Similarly, Mycha-
tion in ICU, and who had persistent electrocortical activ- skiw et al. [14] have reported a case of falsely elevated
ity detected by EEG. Nevertheless, two important limita- BIS during deep hypothermic circulatory arrest and pro-
tions of this monitoring were observed: (a) BIS could de- pose that in such circumstances of extreme EEG sup-
crease to 0 before complete onset on brain death in pa- pression electrical interferences from either EMG or ra-
tients with major intracranial hypertension, and (b) im- diofrequency noise might be interpreted by the algorithm
portant EMG activity and cardiovascular hyperpulsatility as EEG activity and assigned a high BIS value.
could falsely elevate the BIS. This interference between EEG and EMG is also a
In three patients the BIS decreased to 0 although major pitfall for EEG recording, especially in brain-dead
these patients were not clinically brain dead. In one of patients for whom EMG activity may be enhanced [21,
them this decrease was accompanied by a worsening of 22, 23]. Indeed, the administration of muscle relaxants is
neurological status, which required administration of an generally necessary in brain-dead patients to obtain reli-
antiedematous treatment for correction. In the two other able isoelectric EEG recordings [20, 21]. In our clinical
patients the BIS decreased to 0 a short time (1 or 2 h) be- practice we always consider EMG activity in interpreting
fore all the criteria of brain death were fulfilled. Never- BIS values in severely comatose patients. Therefore, if
theless, according to the major cerebral injuries of these necessary, we recommend the administration of muscle
two patients, these decreases were interpreted as signal relaxants when high EMG activity could interfere with
of impending brain death, allowing the scheduling of BIS monitoring. In our opinion, this enables BIS to be-
EEG or angiography and meeting with patients’ families. come a reliable means for monitoring EEG activity in se-
Therefore continuous BIS monitoring in severely coma- verely comatose patients, especially when they are ex-
tose patients seems to be a very useful method for early pected to progress to neurological worsening.
detection of neurological worsening. In our ICU, this is Nevertheless, it should be kept in mind that this inter-
particularly true for patients who have been hospitalized ference between EEG and EMG during BIS monitoring
for several days in ICU, and whose neurological status is is not specific to severely comatose and brain-dead pa-
apparently stabilized, but who may be expected to deteri- tients but has been previously reported to falsely elevate
orate because of their cerebral injuries. Thus a decrease BIS values in anesthetized patients without muscle relax-
in BIS values, for example, during the night, is some- ants [19]. Indeed, EMG activity is not specifically a pit-
times the first signal of such a deterioration. Indeed, fall for BIS monitoring, having been described 20 years
good correlations between the BIS and neurological sta- ago as a frequent contaminant of the EEG signal during
tus have been reported in unsedated ICU patients and in general anesthesia [24].
neurosurgical ICU patients [8, 16]. Moreover, for refrac- The results presented here should be interpreted with
tory intracranial hypertension, Riker et al. [17] success- caution. BIS monitoring in severely comatose patients is
fully used the BIS to titrate pentobarbital infusions. a new concept [7, 8, 9], far from the initial purpose of
EMG activity is undoubtedly the main pitfall of BIS this monitor, and therefore new algorithms of analysis of
monitoring in severely comatose patients. While EEG bispectral index should probably be developed for such
and EMG signals are conventionally considered to re- cases, especially in cases of very low EEG activity.
main in the bands of 0.5–30 Hz and 30–300 Hz, respec- Nonetheless, BIS seems to be an interesting monitoring
425
technique in severely comatose patients suffering from tion [26]. Therefore the diagnosis of brain death should
cerebral injuries. Indeed, the decrease in BIS to 0 might be made required as soon as possible.
be used as an assessment of brain death onset, facilitat- In conclusion, the decrease in BIS to 0 in severely co-
ing appropriate timing for either EEG or cerebral angiog- matose patients could be used as an assessment of brain
raphy to confirm brain death. On the one hand, perform- death onset, enabling scheduling of appropriate timing
ing these examinations too early, before actual brain for either EEG or cerebral angiography to confirm brain
death, is of limited value. Moreover, they should not be death. Nevertheless, further studies are needed to deter-
repeated since they are expensive and, at least regarding mine whether BIS, which is a simple noninvasive moni-
cerebral angiography, potentially deleterious. Against toring of EEG, can improve the timely diagnosis of brain
this, brain death is characterized by a major hemody- death and therefore facilitate organ procurement for
namic instability [2, 25], which is detrimental to the pa- transplantation.
tient’s organs. This instability is one important limit to Acknowledgements The writers are indebted to Dr. D.J. Baker,
organ donation, leading sometimes to a sudden and irre- (Département d’Anesthésie-Réanimation, Hôpital Necker, Paris,
versible cardiac arrest, which prevents any organ dona- France), for reviewing the present manuscript.
References
1. Wijdicks EF (2001) The diagnosis of 8. Gilbert TT, Wagner MR, Halukurike V, 18. Johansen JW, Sebel PS (2000) Devel-
brain death. N Engl J Med Paz HL, Garland A (2001) Use of bi- opment and clinical application of elec-
344:1215–1221 spectral electroencephalogram moni- troencephalographic bispectrum moni-
2. Baillard C, Vivien B, Jasson S, toring to assess neurologic status in un- toring. Anesthesiology 93:1336–1344
Mansier P, Oubenaissa A, Riou B, sedated, critically ill patients. Crit Care 19. Bruhn J, Bouillon TW, Shafer SL
Swynghedauw B (2000) Brain death Med 29:1996–2000 (2000) Electromyographic activity
assessment using instant spectral anal- 9. Hana AR, Inchoisa MA, Frost EAM falsely elevates the bispectral index.
ysis of heart rate variability. Crit Care (1999) The bispectral index as a pre- Anesthesiology 92:1485–1487
Med 30:306–310 dictor of outcome after head injury 20. Guerit JM (1986) Unexpected myogen-
3. Paolin A, Manuali A, Di Paola F, (abstract). Anesth Analg 88:S56 ic contaminants observed in the so-
Boccaletto F, Caputo P, Zanata R, 10. Anez Simon C, Recasens Urbez J, matosensory evoked potentials record-
Bardin GP, Simini G. Reliability in di- Lorente Cogollos C, Bodi Saera M, ed in one brain-dead patient. Electro-
agnosis of brain death (1995) Intensive Rull Bartomeu M (2000) The bispec- encephalogr Clin Neurophysiol
Care Med 21:657–662 tral electroencephalographic index 64:21–26
4. Gan TJ, Glass PS, Windsor A, Payne F, (BIS) and brain death. Rev Esp Ane- 21. Reilly EL, Kelley JT, Pena YM (1985)
Rosow C, Sebel P, Manberg P, and the stesiol Reanim 47:422–423 Failure of Pavulon to consistently pro-
BIS Utility Study Group (1997) Bi- 11. Valero R, Gambús P, Zavala B, Guix E, vide adequate EMG attenuation for re-
spectral index monitoring allows faster Fábregas N (2001) BIS monitoring as cording electrocerebral inactivity. Clin
emergence and improved recovery an outcome predictor in severely brain Electroencephalogr 16:72–76
from propofol, alfentanil, and nitrous damaged nonsedated critically ill pa- 22. Wee AS (1986) Scalp EMG in brain
oxide anesthesia. Anesthesiology tients (abstract). Eur J Anaesthesiol 18 death electroencephalogram. Acta Neu-
87:808–815 [Suppl 21]:A245 rol Scand 74:128–131
5. De Deyne C, Struys M, Decruyenaere 12. Gallagher JD (1999) Pacer-induced ar- 23. Mayr N, Zeitlhofer J, Auff E, Wessely
J, Creupelandt J, Hoste E, Colardyn F tifact in the bispectral index during car- P, Deecke L (1990) The significance of
(1998) Use of continuous bispectral diac surgery. Anesthesiology 90:636 EMG artefacts in isoelectric EEG. EEG
EEG monitoring to assess depth of se- 13. Guignard B, Chauvin M (2000) Bi- EMG Z Elektroenzephalogr Ele-
dation in ICU patients. Intensive Care spectral index increases and decreases ktromyogr Verwandte Geb 21:56–58
Med 24:1294–1298 are not always signs of inadequate an- 24. Harmel MH, Klein FF, Davis DA
6. Simmons LE, Riker RR, Prato BS, esthesia. Anesthesiology 92:903 (1978) The EEMG-a practical index of
Fraser GL (1999) Assessing sedation 14. Mychaskiw G, Heath BJ, Eichhorn JH cortical activity and muscular relax-
during intensive care unit mechanical (2000) Falsely elevated bispectral in- ation. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand Suppl
ventilation with the bispectral index dex during deep hypothermic circulato- 70:97–102
and the sedation-agitation scale. Crit ry arrest. Br J Anaesth 85:798–800 25. Power BM, Van Heerden PV (1995)
Care Med 27:1499–1504 15. Grayzel J (1989) A statistic for inter- The physiological changes associated
7. Watson BJ, Van Delft M, Evans JJ, ferences based upon negative results. with brain death-current concepts and
Menon DK (1996) Bispectral index in Anesthesiology 71:320–321 implications for treatment of the brain-
coma patients (abstract). J Neurosurg 16. Triltsch A, Spies C, Lenhart A, Witt M, dead organ donor. Anaesth Intensive
Anesthesiol 8:1103 Welte M (1999) Bispectral Index (BIS) Care 23:26–36
correlates with Ramsay sedation scores 26. Nygaard CE, Townsend RN, Diamond
in neurosurgical ICU patients (ab- DL (1990) Organ donor management
stract). Anesthesiology 91:A295 and organ outcome: a 6-year review
17. Riker RR, Wilkins ML, Fraser GL from a Level I trauma center. J Trauma
(1999) Titrating pentobarbital infusions 30:728–732
for refractory intracranial hypertension
using the bispectral index (abstract).
Am J Respir Crit Care Med 159:A828