Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Amadeo R. Fernández-Alba
Archive
www.foodsafetysummit.com
Add to your favorites
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Introduction
• In some cultures herbs have been used as a popular beverages for
centuries. Increased interest in those beverages has resulted from
perceived health benefits that may be associated with their
consumption.
Objective
• The aim of the experiments was to compare and choose the best
method for the extraction of pesticides residues in tea. Three
popular extraction methods were selected for the comparison:
• modified QuEChERS with CaCl2
• ethyl acetate method
• mini-Luke
Without
Tomato
dilution Orange
Leek
Tomato
Orange
Leek
European Reference Laboratory - FV
m/z: 100-400
Rt: 7-13 min
m/z: 200-600
2408 Matrix compounds
Rt: 4-7 min Absolute height ≥ 10000 counts
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Selected Compounds
86 LCa- and GCb- amenable pesticides Fungicide
Azoxystrobin a
Benalaxyl b
Insecticide Biphenylb
Acaricide
Boscalid b
Acetamiprid a
Bifenthrinb Methidathion b Carbendazim a
PGR Chlorpyrifos b
Buprofezin a Methiocarb sulfonea Cyproconazole b
Cypermethrin b
Carbaryl a Methiocarb 2,4 Da Cyprodinil b
Ethoprophos b
Carbofuran a sulfoxidea 2,4 DPa Dichlofluanid b
Etofenprox b
Chinomethionat b Methiocarba Dicloran b
Fenitrothion b
Chlorpyrifos Methyl b Methomyl a Fenarimol b
Flucythrinate b
Diazinon b Mevinphos b Fludioxonil b
Fonofos b
Dichlorvos b Monocrotophos a Imazalil a
Imidacloprid a
Dimethoate a Parathion Ethyl b Herbicide Isofenphos
Iprodione b
Endosulfan I b Phorate b Kresoxim Methyl
Methyl b b Metalaxyl a
Endosulfan II b Phosmet b Alachlor b
Lindane b
Endosulfan sulfate b Pirimiphos Methyl a Atrazine a Myclobutanil a
Parathion
Esfenvalerateb Profenofos a MCPP a Omethoate a
Methyl b
Ethion b Propargite b Metolachlor a Oxadixyl b
Permethrin b
Fenpropathrin b Pyridaben b Metribuzin a Penconazole b
Pirimicarb a
Fenvalerateb Quinalphos b Propyzamide b Pyrimethanil b
Pyriproxyfen b
Isocarbophos b Tetrachlorvinphos b Simazine a Triadimefon a
Terbufos b
Malathion b Triazophos b Terbuthylazine Triadimenol a
Thiodicarb a
a Trifluralin b Vinclozolin b
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Spiking procedure
Modified QuEChERS
2 g sample + 4 mL H2O
method Shake 30 sec, wait 30 min
Add 10 mL acetonitrile and
Shake automatically
200 µL TPP (25 ppm)
in Agitax
Shake automatically
in Agitax
Centrifugue 5 min.
3700 r.p.m.
Take 3 mL aliquot
Modified QuEChERS
2 g sample + 4 mL H2O
method Shake 30 sec, wait 30 min
Add 10 mL acetonitrile and
Shake automatically
200 µL TPP (25 ppm)
in Agitax
Take 3 mL aliquot
2 g sample + 4 mL H2O
Shake 30 sec, wait 30 min
Add 10 mL ethyl acetate and
Shake 3 s by hand 200 µL TPP (25 ppm)
Centrifugue 5 min.
3700 r.p.m.
Evaporate to dryness
and reconstitute
Analysis
European Reference Laboratory - FV
miniLuke
extraction method 2 g sample + 4 mL H2O
Shake 30 sec, wait 30 min
Add 10mL of Acetonitrile and
Shake vigorously 200 µL TPP (25 ppm)
30s by Ultra-Turrax
Add 20mL Petroleum ether:
Dichloromethane (1:1)
Shake vigorously
30s by Ultra-Turrax
Centrifugue 5 min.
at 4000 r.p.m.
Evaporate to dryness 3 mL
5 times portion of the upper layer
dilution
Reconstitute with 1 mL of
adecuate solvent
Analysis
European Reference Laboratory - FV
LC and GC analysis
• LC analysis:
– Mobile phases: 0.1% FA in H2O and AcN
– Reversed-phase C8 analytical column of 4.6 mm x
150 mm and 5 µm particle size (Agilent Zorbax SB)
– 6410 LC-QQQ-MS/MS (Agilent Technologies)
– Dynamic MRM software features
• GC analysis:
– Ultra Inert GC column, HP-5MS UI 15 m × 0.25 mm
i.d. × 0.25 μm (Agilent)
– 7000 GC-QQQ-MS/MS (Agilent Technologies)
– Retention Time Locking (RTL) and Blackflushing
– 39 segment SRM method
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Recoveries
50
45
40
35
30
# Compounds
25 QuEChERS
20
15 EtOAc
10
miniLuke
5
0
0-30 30-
40- 50-
40 50 60- 70-
60 70 80- 90-
80 90 100- n.d.
100 120
Recovery (%)
Concentration level: 100 µg/kg (n=5)
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Recoveries
Number of compounds
Ethyl Acetate
QuEChERS miniLuke
method
70 - 120% 75 31 54
70 - 60% 2 26 26
< 60% 6 22 2
Not detected 3 7 4
European Reference Laboratory - FV
a Ansalysed by LC
b Ansalysed by GC
* Thermical degradation into the GC system
CaCl2
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Set-up
Green tea
Chamomile
Validation in 4 different matrices Green tea
with the best method Red Tea
Black tea
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Set-up
Green tea
Chamomile
Validation in 4 different matrices Green tea
with the best method Red Tea
Black tea
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Recoveries
Concentration level: 25 μg/Kg (n=5)
50
45
40
Compounds (%)
35
30 Green Tea
25 Red Tea
20 Black Tea
Camomile
15
10
5
0
Recovery (%)
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Recoveries
Concentration level: 25 μg/Kg (n=5)
50
45
40
Compounds (%)
35
30 Green Tea
25 Red Tea
20 Black Tea
Camomile
15
10
5
0
Recovery (%)
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Recoveries
Concentration level: 100 μg/Kg (n=5)
60
55
50
45
Compounds (%)
40
Green Tea
35
30 Red Tea
25 Black Tea
20 Chamomile
15
10
5
0
Recovery (%)
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Recoveries
Concentration level: 100 μg/Kg (n=5)
60
55
50
45
Compounds (%)
40
Green Tea
35
30 Red Tea
25 Black Tea
20 Chamomile
15
10
5
0
Recovery (%)
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Benalaxyl
LODs Cypermethrin
Fonofos
Quinalphos
Profenofos
45
40 Fonofos
Compounds (%)
35 Mevinphos
30
25
20
Green tea
15
10
Red Tea
5 Black Tea
0 Chamomile
0,1-0,25 0,25-0,5 0,5-1 1-5 5-10 10-50 50-100 > 100
LOD (μg/kg) Quinalphos Mevinphos
Propargite
European Reference Laboratory - FV
• Linearity
– 7 calibration points, 0,5-200 μg/L
– All the compounds had a R2>0.99
• Repetitivity
– Two concentration levels: 5 and 20 μg/L
– RSD<17%
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Matrix effects
18
16
14
Compounds (%)
12
10
Green tea
8 Red Tea
6 Black Tea
4 Chamomile
2
0
< -50% -50% - -20% - 0- 20% - 50% - 100% - 200% - 300% - 400% - >
(-20%) 0 20% 50% 100% 200% 300% 400% 500% 500%
Real samples
75 real samples of different kind of herbs bought in:
6 samples 3 samples
1 sample 1 sample
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Real samples
Results
8.0%
24.0%
68.0%
Real samples
Distribution of the pesticides in the samples
12
10
8
# Samples
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
# Pesticides
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Real samples
Distribution of the pesticides in the samples
12
10
8
# Samples
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
# Pesticides
Most found: Biphenyl (37), Acetamiprid (36), Carbendazim (36), Chlorpyrifos (34),
Imidacloprid, (31), Bifenthrin (30) and Endosulfan (Sum) (22).
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Conclusions
• From the three MRM the preferred method for the analysis of
pesticides residues in green tea was QuEChERS with calcium
chloride. This method was the best in terms of recoveries and the
full scan chromatograms were the least influenced with coextracted
matrix compounds.
Tea infusion
European Reference Laboratory - FV
2 g sample
50mL of boiled
milliQ water
Stir during 15 min
Take 900µL of
infusion + 100µL of
acetonitrile
27.8
times
Filter dilution
Analysis by
LC-MS/MS
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Water solubility
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Participating labs
1 1
1
Results
EU and
EU EU Lab 2
Lab 1 Lab 3 Lab 4 Lab 5 EURL- Lab 6 Lab 7 3rd
Compound Average RSD (Sri
(France) (Sweden) (Germany) (Austria) FV (Thailand) (Thailand) Countries
(mg/kg) (%) Lanka)
RSD (%)
Acetamiprid 0.565 0.583 0.517 0.647 0.606 0.584 8.3 0.567 0.582 6.9
Bifenthrin 0.392 0.683 NA 0.711 0.634 0.605 24.1 0.402 0.801 28.0
Buprofezin 0.043 0.116 0.142 0.108 0.102 41.2 0.098 0.078 34.9
Carbofuran 0.022 0.016 0.027 0.022 26.3 Detected 26.3
Chlorpyrifos 0.014 0.013 0.009 0.012 20.8 Detected NA 20.8
Cypermethrine 0.065 NA 0.113 0.089 38.1 Detected 0.067 NA 33.2
Endosulfan Alpha 0.047 0.099 NA 0.087 0.100 0.083 29.8 0.079 1.781 189.8
Endosulfan Beta 0.077 0.183 NA 0.126 0.171 0.139 34.6 0.506 0.704 85.4
Endosulfan Sulfate 0.088 0.072 NA 0.049 0.080 0.072 23.3 NA 0.086 0.072 19.0
Fenpropathrin 0.090 0.193 NA 0.182 0.200 0.166 30.9 0.281 NA 0.219 32.0
Fenvalerate 0.031 0.050 NA 0.059 0.050 0.047 30.6 Detected 0.038 28.0
Imidacloprid 0.115 0.079 0.077 0.136 0.120 0.105 24.9 0.111 NA 22.2
Methomyl 0.231 0.278 0.388 0.345 0.311 22.5 NA NA 0.327 19.4
Pyridaben NA 0.024 0.024 0.095 84.0
Triazophos 0.028 0.042 0.044 0.033 0.037 20.4 0.219 0.015 121.0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
Acetamiprid
Bifenthrin
Lab 1 (France)
Buprofezin
Carbofuran
Chlorpyrifos
Lab 3 (Sweden)
Cypermethrine
Endosulfan Alpha
Endosulfan Beta
Lab 4 (Germany)
Endosulfan Sulfate
Fenpropathrin
Imidacloprid
European labs results
Lab 5 (Austria)
Methomyl
Pyridaben
EURL-FV
Triazophos
Fenvalerate
European Reference Laboratory - FV
European Reference Laboratory - FV
Thank You
for Your Attention
European Reference Laboratory - FV