Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://revistas.udistrital.edu.co/ojs/index.php/Tecnura/issue/view/918
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14483/22487638.9169
Investigación
Cómo citar: Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M. (2018). Operational planning capacities associated with pro-
fitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach. Tecnura, 22(57), 32-43. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.14483/22487638.9169
1 Productions Engineer, magister in Industrial Engineering, PhD. (c) in model based public planning, policy design and management. Profes-
sor and researcher in logistics, manufacture, modeling and simulation at the Catholic University of Colombia, leader of Manufacturing
Research Group (GIP). Bogotá, Colombia. Contact: mbecerra@ucatolica.edu.co, mauriciobecerrafernandez@gmail.com
2 Productions Engineer, magister in Industrial Engineering, PhD. (c) in model based public planning, policy design and management. Assistant
professor in production and logistics of the Faculty of Economic Sciences at the Militar University Nueva Granada. Bogotá, Colombia. Contact:
milton.herrera@unimilitar.edu.co
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 32 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 33 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
guarantees a good result in terms of service levels System Dynamics Society is shown in figure 1. An
and labor cost that respond to fluctuations in de- exponential performance of publications is shown
mand. The article is structured into four chapters: in aspects associated with service capacity and
The first presents a review of literature that focuses profitability. It also identifies an increase in the
on the dynamics of publications and the taxonomy number of publications from 1981 to 2017. From
of models related to capacity and profitability from 2004 the number of publications diminishes but
a systems dynamics approach. The second chapter stays constant, reflecting the validity of the subject
presents the method used and its relation to the addressed by various authors.
conceptual model used. The third chapter shows The different models presented by the authors
the model using the methodology proposed by Fo- in System Dynamics can be categorized using five
rrester (Forrester, 1961). And the chapter 4 presents publication approaches: Applied to governmental
the results, the discussion, and the conclusions. politics, logistics, health, planning and telecom-
munications. As shown in figure 2.
Review of Literature On the other hand, the evolution of publica-
tions related to the capacity of addressing a sys-
The System Dynamics methodology allows the per- tem using the System Dynamics Methodology is
formance of highly complex systems to be modeled. presented in figure 3. In referring to profitabili-
The interaction of profitability used in decision ma- ty models using the System Dynamics approach,
king according to capacity allows a company to opti- the dynamics of publications diminishes starting
mize the use of resources to provide the service. One in 2004; however, it continues to have a mini-
of the reasons to use the System Dynamics methodo- mum amount until 2012. This is due to the fact
logy is that the service systems contemplate various that profitability models are approached from a
scenarios and players that interrelate in a complex financial perspective that does not contemplate
and unpredictable way; therefore, if the performance the complexity of assignment relationships in ca-
of this system is understood, the objectives of the sys- pacities that a system comes to have. For that re-
tem can be simulated through archetypes. ason, this study provides information that shows
The dynamics of the publication of articles the need to integrate profitability concept with
presented at the International Conference of the system capacity.
Government Logistics
Tele-
Health
communications
Planning
Figure 1. Dynamics of publications at the international Figure 2. Taxonomy of model classification related to
conference of the system dynamics society in capacity Capacity and profitability
and profitability
Source: own work
Source: own work
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 34 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
6
structures when compared to classical assignment
5
techniques generated by the Operations Investiga-
4
No. Papers
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 35 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Invesment +
Operational
+ Profit
R1 Catchment
+ +
Return On Assest - + B5
Desired Gross B2
Profit
B1 -
+
+
Taxes -
B3 +
B4 Income Before
+ Net Taxes
+
Income -
Gap
-
R2
Return On
Assets +
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 36 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
taxes, and profit after taxes. Figure 5 represents the Forrester model designed to analyze performance
Forrester diagram in the profitability sector. This in assigned work positions according to transac-
contemplates income calculated from profitabili- tions and available capacity.
ty and placement time used as a point for decision The combination of the two sectors allows the
making. analysis of the performance of resource capacity
Profitability is analyzed using this structure, planning from the profitability of financial servi-
keeping in mind the placement time of financial ce companies. The calibration of the model mainly
income, and different rates that intervene in profi- consisted in analyzing the behavior of the alloca-
tability flows. tion of personnel against the installed capacity and
On the other hand, the capacity planning struc- the available capacity of the system, which means
ture was designed according to different workdays that the appropriate assignment is made according
in a financial services company (daytime, addi- to the capacity of the system (see figure 7).
tional hours, and Saturdays), and service levels The following section presents the simulation
(cashiers and representatives). Figure 6 presents a results obtained from the structures of the sector.
Balanced of Balanced of
placement Deposit Workstations
Aux
Time <Available <Capacity
Shortage Capacity> Used Discrepancy>
Capacity Capacity
Capacity Month
Discrepancy Days
Idle Profitability
<Month
Capacity Police
Days>
FTE's <Available FTE's
Allocated Time> Removed
Transactions
Transactions
Used Capacity Hire Leave
Demand
Rate Delay Delay
Demand FTE´s
<Workers
Used Hire Assignment Leave
Assigned>
Available Time FTE's FTE's
Workstations
Available Workers
Suplements
Capacity Workstations Assigned
Model
Time <Month Available
Days>
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 37 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
12
Capacity and profitability planning
10
8 FTE's assigned
Available capacity
The capacity planning model shows the assign-
6
4 Installed capacity ment performance over time of representatives
2
and cashiers in a financial services company. Per-
0 formance fluctuations are shown in Table 1, whe-
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 re higher assignment values for representatives in
Month daytime work (DW) and a lesser value in the assig-
nment for Saturday work (SW) stand out. Capacity
Figure 7. Calibration of the model planning performance maintains a similar pattern
in the first 12 months to that of profitability perfor-
Source: own work
mance, as shown in table 1 and table 2.
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 38 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 39 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 40 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Chain. International Conference of the System Dy- International Conference of the System Dynamics
namics Society. Athens: System Dynamics Society. Society. Washington, DC: System Dynamics Society.
Becerra, M., Orjuela, J. A., Romero, O. R., Herrera, M. Elmasry, S., Shalaby, M., and Saleh, M. (2012). A System
M. (2013). Model for Calculating Operational Ca- dynamics simulation model for scalable-capacity
pacities in Service Providers Using System Dyna- manufacturing systems. International Conference
mics. System Dynamics Conference. Cambridge, of the System Dynamics Society. St. Gallen: System
USA. Dynamics Society.
Betancur, M., Giraldo, D., and Arango, S. (2011). Effects Evans, G. N. (1994). The Dynamics of Capacity Cons-
of Food Availability Policies on National Food Se- trained Supply Chains. International System Dyna-
curity: Colombian case. International Conference mics Conference, 28-42. Stirling, Scotland.
of the System Dynamics Society. Washington, DC: Forrester, J. W. (1961). Industrial Dynamics. Cambridge,
System Dynamics Society. USA: Massachusetts Institute.
Bijulal, D., and Venkateswaran, J. (2008). Closed-Loop Fukushima, S., and Yamaguchi, K. (2009). Is Japanese
Supply Chain Stability under Different Produc- Manufacturing Style (so-called Monozukuri) rea-
tion-Inventory Policies. International Conference of lly robust?–A Causal Loop Diagram and Modeling
the System Dynamics Society. Athens: System Dy- Approach. International Conference of the System
namics Society. Dynamics Society. Albuquerque: System Dynamics
Campuzano Bolarin, F., Ros McDonnell, L., and Gar- Society.
cía, J. M. (2008). Reducing the impact of demand Giraldo, D., Arango, S., and Betancur, M. (2008). Mo-
process variability within a multi-echelon supply del on Food security in development countries: A
chain. International Conference of the System Dy- systemic perspective. International Conference of
namics Society. Athens: System Dynamics Society. the System Dynamics Society. Athens: System Dy-
Delgado, C. (2011). Capacity Adjustment in a Service namics Society.
Facility with Reactive Customers and Delays: Si- Gyu Rim, K. (2009). Analysis of Global Food Market
mulation and Experimental Analysis. System Dyna- and Food-Energy Price Links: Based on System Dy-
mics Conference. Washington,USA. namics Approach. International Conference of the
Deogratias, K., Jain, S., and McLean, C. (2009). A Sys- System Dynamics Society. Albuquerque: System
tem Dynamics Framework for Sustainable Manu- Dynamics Society.
facturing. International Conference of the System Hettesheimer, T., and Lerch, C. (2013). Future Trends of
Dynamics Society. Albuquerque: System Dynamics the automotive Li-Ion Battery Supply Chain in Ger-
Society. many – Dynamic effects on raw materials and em-
Diaz Pabon, F., Espinoza, C., Namen Leon, M., Pala- ployment. International Conference of the System
cio, M., and Cuervo, R. (2010). Humanitarian Cri- Dynamics Society. Cambridge: System Dynamics
sis: when Supply Chain really matters. International Society.
Conference of System Dynamics Society. Seoul: Hoa Vo, T. L., and Thiel, D. (2008). A System Dynamics
System Dynamics Society. Model of the Chicken Meat Supply Chain faced
Douglas, J. Morrice, G. L. (2005). The “physics” of ca- with Bird Flu. International Conference of the Sys-
pacity and backlog management in service and tem Dynamics Society. Athens: System Dynamics
custom manufacturing supply chains. System Dy- Society.
namics Review, 21(3), 217-247. DOI: https://doi. Killingsworth, W., Chavez, R., and Nelson, M. (2008).
org/10.1002/sdr.319 The Dynamics of Multi-Tier, Multi-Channel Supply
Dudley, R. (2011). Might Continued Emphasis on Mai- Chains for High-Value Government Aviation Parts.
ze at the Expense of More Drought Tolerant Crops International Conference of the System Dynamics
Endanger Food Security in the Horn of Africa? Society. Athens: System Dynamics Society.
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 41 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Lee, Y., An, L., and Connors, D. (2010). Controlling International Conference of the System Dynamics
Workforce in Response to Demand Disturbances Society. Albuquerque: System Dynamics Society.
in Services Supply Chains. International Conferen- Pruyt, E., and De Sitter, G. (2008). Food or Energy? Is
ce of the System Dynamics Society. Seoul: System that the question? International Conference of the
Dynamics Society. System Dynamics Society. Athens: System Dyna-
Lehr, C., and Milling, P. (2009). From Waste to Value–A mics Society.
System Dynamics Model for Strategic Decision Ma- Rodrigues, L., Farahnaz, M., Deepak, R., and Vasanth,
king in Closed-Loop Supply Chains. International K. (2012). System Dynamics Model for Remanu-
Conference of the System Dynamics Society. Albu- facturing in Closed Loop Supply Chains. Internatio-
querque: System Dynamics Society. nal Conference of the System Dynamics Society. St.
Lopez, L., and Zuniga, R. (2012). The Dynamics of a Ju- Gallen: System Dynamics Society.
dicial Service Supply Chain: A case study. Interna- Rogelio, O., Herrero, L., Kraizelburd, S., and Watson,
tional Conference of the System Dynamics Society. N. (2010). Understanding Supply Chain Repleni-
St. Gallen: System Dynamics Society. shment Decisions. International Conference of the
Maani, K., and Fan, A. (2008). Resolving Performance System Dynamics Society. Seoul: System Dynamics
Measure Conflicts in a Supply Chain using Systems Society.
Thinking Methodology. International Conference of Romero, O. R., and Becerra, M. (2017). Dynamic Plan-
the System Dynamics Society. Athens: System Dy- ning of Infraestructure and Logistics Resources in
namics Society. Distribution Centers. Communications in Computer
Mejia Solanilla, A. M., Hincapié Isaza, R. A., and Ga- and Information Science,752(1), 760-773.
llego Rendón, R. A. (2015). Planeación óptima de Sanches, L., and Lima, O. (2011). Hockey-stick phe-
sistemas de distribución considerando múltiple ob- nomenon: supply chain challenges in Emerging
jetivos: costo de inversión, confiabilidad y prédidas countries. International Conference of the System
técnicas. Tecnura, 19(43) 106-118. DOI: https://doi. Dynamics Society. Washington, DC: System Dyna-
org/10.14483/udistrital.jour.tecnura.2015.1.a08 mics Society.
Morecroft, J., and Sterman, J. (1994). Modeling for Lear- Senge, P. M. (1993). Developing Theory of Service Qua-
ning Organizations. Portland, EEUU: Productivity lity/Service Capacity Interaction. System Dynamics
Press. Conference, (p. No). Cancun, Mexico.
Moxnes, E. (2009). Peak oil, biofuels, and long-term Shamsuddoha, M., Quaddus, M., and Klass, D. (2013).
food security. International Conference of the Sys- Poultry Supply Chain: A System Approach. Interna-
tem Dynamics Society. System Dynamics Society. tional Conference of the System Dynamics Society.
Niu, M. (2008). The Dynamic Analysis of a Simplified Cambridge: System Dynamics Society.
Centralised Supply Chain and Delay Effects. Inter- Soloukdar, A. (2012). Designing and Analysis a Dyna-
national Conference of the System Dynamics Socie- mic Model of World Class Manufacturing in Iranian
ty. Athens: System Dynamics Society. Automotive Industry. International Conference of
Orjuela, J., and Huertas, I. (2004). Las empresas de pres- the System Dynamics Society. St. Gallen: System
tación de servicios y la determinación de su capa- Dynamics Society.
cidad de operaciones. Tecnura, 7(14), 7-16. Struben, J., and Chan, D. (2011). Non-communica-
Gonçalves, P. Hines, J., and Sterman, J. (2005). The im- ble Disease Dynamics and Prevention: Dynamics
pact of endogenous demand on push–pull pro- of Nutritious Food Market Transformation Initiati-
duction systems. System Dynamics Review, 21(3), ves. International Conference of the System Dyma-
187-216. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/sdr.318 nics Society. Washington, DC: System Dymanics
Poles, R., and Cheong, F. (2009). Inventory Control in Society.
Closed Loop Supply Chain using System Dynamics.
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 42 ]
Operational planning capacities associated with profitability of service companies. A system dynamics approach
Becerra F., M. & Herrera R., M.M.
Sveiby, K.-E. (2002). Building a Knowledge-Based Stra- and Inter-firm Trust. International Conference of the
tegy: A system Dynamics Model for Allocating Va- System Dynamics Society. St. Gallen: System Dy-
lue-Adding Capacity. International Conference of namics Society.
the System Dynamics Society. Palermo, Italy. World Trade Organization (2015). WTO Statistics Da-
Sverdrup, H., Koca, D., and Ragnarsdottir, V. (2012). tabase. Geneva, Switzerland: International Trade
The WORLD model: Peak metals, minerals, energy, Statistics Section. Recovered https://www.wto.org/
wealth, food and population. International Confe- english/res_e/statis_e/statis_e.htm
rence of the System Dynamics Society. St. Gallen: Yasarcan, H. (2011). Information Sharing in Supply
System Dynamics Society. Chains: A Systemic Approach. International Confe-
Tasrif, M., and Juniarti, I. (2011). A Dynamic View rence of the System Dynamics Society. Washington,
on Knowledge Development: A Case of Indus- DC: System Dynamics Society.Zilouchian, E., Car-
trial Aerospace Supply Chain Development in In- denas Martinez, A., Koochak-Yazdi, S., and Murad,
donesia. International Conference of the System H. (2012). Industry Analysis: The Fastener Supply
Dynamics Society. Washintong, DC: System Dyna- Chain in Aerospace Industry. International Confe-
mics Society. rence of the System Dynamics Society. St. Gallen:
Tiru, A., Yuhua, Z., and Anson, L. (2012). Leveraging System Dynamics Society.
Supply Chain Relationships – A System Dynamics Zimmermann, N. (2011). Mechanisms of consumer bo-
Perspective. International Conference of the System ycotts: Evidence from the Nestlé infant food con-
Dynamics Society. St. Gallen: System Dynamics troversy. International Conference of the System
Society. Dynamics Society. Washington, DC: System Dyna-
Tseng, Y.-t., and Yang Wang, W. (2012). A System Dyna- mics Society.
mics Model of Evolving Supply Chain Relationships
Tecnura • p-ISSN: 0123-921X • e-ISSN: 2248-7638 • Vol. 22 No. 57 • Julio - Septiembre de 2018 • pp. 32-43
[ 43 ]
Copyright of Tecnura is the property of Tecnura and its content may not be copied or emailed
to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.