Study of Aa Rated Charts

Birth Time Verification – A Study
May 26, 2005

Rangarajan Krishnamoorthy
ranga@mmsindia.com
For this experiment I ran my program on several AA-rated birth data

provided by Tin Win. My program determines if there is a connection
between the ASC sublord and MOON starlord. If there is a connection,
then the birth time is correct, else it is incorrect. This is based on
the rule proposed by Shri.M.P.Shanmugham in “Astrosecrets and KP”,
Volume – 2, 2003 Edition, pp. 80 – 85.
Definition of “Connection” as Used in the Program

1) For the purposes of calculation, a planet A is deemed to be
“Connected with” a planet B if and only if any of the following is
true:
a) A and B are the same planet
b) A is the sign/star/sub/subsub lord of B
c) B is the sign/star/sub/subsub lord of A
d) A and B are in the same sign
e) B aspects A (by Vedic aspect)
f) A is in the star/sub/subsub of a NODE and the NODE is an agent
for B
2) Agency Rule:
NODE is an agent for PLANET if and only if any of the following is
true:
a) NODE and PLANET are in the same sign
b) NODE is in the sign of PLANET
c) PLANET aspects NODE (by vedic aspect)
Approach Taken
Since the supplied data are AA-rated, we assume that these are
“correct”. We expect the connection rule to “pass” in all these cases.
First I ran the program on the supplied data (some records were
excluded for convenience) and determined the number of passes and fails
of the rule.
Next, I “mutated” the data by adding 10 minutes to each record.

Obviously, the changed record must be “incorrect” for that person. We
expect the connection rule to “fail” in all these cases. I ran the
program once again on the corrupted data and determined the number of
passes and fails of the rule.
The outcome is shown in the following table:
Description Passes Fails

Correct Records 85 24
(109)
Incorrect Records 88 21
(109)
An effective birth rectification technique (BRT) is one that is able to
discriminate between correct and incorrect birth times. Ideally, it
should pass all correct birth times and fail all incorrect birth times.
The effectiveness of the rule can be expressed as a measure of its
passes and fails.
Let N be the number of records known to be correct. By mutating the

correct records we can get N incorrect records.
Let NP be the number of correct records passed by the rule, and NF be the
number of incorrect records failed by the rule. In ideal BRT should
have NP = NF = N.
Then the pair <NP/N, NF/N> can represent the effectiveness of a BRT1. For
convenience, the numbers may be expressed as percentages.
Effectiveness of Shanmugham’s Technique = <78, 19>
It is very important to remember that Shanmugham’s rule only tries to

determine if ANY birth could have taken place at a location L and a
time T. It does not attempt to establish whether a person P was born at
L at time T. So, when the rule passes a time T (at L), it just means
that T is an acceptable birth time. It is possible that no one was born
at that time. Because the connection rule is “weak”, when the rule
fails, the denial is quite strong – “No one could have been born at
this time”.
This raises an interesting question: What are the fundamental criteria

to be satisfied by a birth rectification technique? Is it enough if the
technique determines (like Shanmugham’s rule) whether T is an
acceptable birth time at L, or should it determine whether T is an
acceptable birth time at L for P?
Below, the actual AA-rated data along with program’s output appear
first, followed by the mutated data and program’s output for those
data. To make it obvious for readers, the mutated records are marked
with “****”.
Feel free to let me know if you notice errors or have suggestions on

improving the study.
START OF CORRECT DATA

Date of birth: 2-Jan-1938 [15:42:0]
Lat: 40:51 North
Longt: 74:7 West
TZone: -5, TMode: Standard, DST: 0
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)

Lat: 44:57 North
Longt: 93:6 West
1
For this metric to be meaningful, N should be large. It is therefore
important to collect a large sample of correct records.
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)

Lat: 35:22 North
Longt: 81:26 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)

Lat: 41:54 North
Longt: 12:29 East
TZone: 1, TMode: Standard, DST: 0
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)

Lat: 43:18 North
Longt: 5:24 East
TZone: 0, TMode: GMT, DST: 0
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)

Lat: 34:16 North
Longt: 88:43 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)

Lat: 33:53 North
Longt: 117:49 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)

Lat: 32:23 North
Longt: 86:19 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 10-Jan-1949 [21:15:0]

Lat: 32:33 North
Longt: 94:23 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 11-Jan-1940 [23:30:0]

Lat: 45:15 North
Longt: 7:35 East
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)

Lat: 37:18 North
Longt: 89:31 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Lat: 34:1 North
Longt: 118:25 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 15-Jan-1029 [13:50:0]

Lat: 32:15 North
Longt: 101:28 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)

Lat: 29:46 North
Longt: 95:22 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 17-Jan-1933 [22:57:0]

Lat: 40:46 North
Longt: 73:59 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 20-Jan-1930 [14:17:0]

Lat: 40:49 North
Longt: 74:13 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)

Lat: 39:58 North
Longt: 83:0 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 40:38 North
Longt: 73:56 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)

Lat: 41:52 North
Longt: 87:39 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)

Lat: 43:8 North
Longt: 80:16 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 2-Feb-1926 [21:30:0]

Lat: 50:21 North
Longt: 7:35 East

Lat: 37:33 North
Longt: 77:27 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)

Lat: 42:20 North
Longt: 83:3 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)

Lat: 40:42 North
Longt: 89:36 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)

Lat: 30:41 North
Longt: 88:3 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)

Lat: 39:6 North
Longt: 84:31 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 34:4 North
Longt: 118:15 West
ASC sublord (Mars) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 10-Feb-1950 [17:45:0]

Lat: 37:39 North
Longt: 121:0 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 42:20 North
Longt: 83:3 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Lat: 26:13 North
Longt: 90:19 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 41:52 North
Longt: 87:39 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)

Lat: 34:4 North
Longt: 118:15 West
ASC sublord (Venus) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 14-Feb-1921 [17:15:0]

Lat: 41:5 North
Longt: 81:31 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)

Lat: 39:32 North
Longt: 87:8 West

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 21-Feb-1925 [14:15:0]

Lat: 36:44 North
Longt: 119:47 West

Lat: 42:17 North
Longt: 71:4 West
Date of birth: 24-Feb-1940 [21:58:0]

Lat: 38:15 North
Longt: 85:46 West

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 25-Feb-1934 [20:14:0]

Lat: 37:49 North
Longt: 122:16 West

Lat: 42:58 North
Longt: 85:40 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 38:35 North
Longt: 121:29 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 15-Aug-1972 [2:53:0]

Lat: 37:52 North
Longt: 122:16 West
TZone: -7, TMode: DST, DST: 1
Date of birth: 17-Jan-1942 [18:35:0]

Lat: 38:15 North
Longt: 85:46 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 4-Apr-1928 [14:10:0]

Lat: 38:37 North
Longt: 90:12 West
ASC sublord (Venus) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 7-Jun-1956 [22:40:0]

Lat: 40:47 North
Longt: 74:29 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 12-Dec-1926 [4:30:0]

Lat: 48:35 North
Longt: 7:45 East
ASC sublord (Mercury) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 30-Mar-1937 [17:30:0]

Lat: 37:33 North
Longt: 77:27 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 9-May-1946 [21:52:0]
Lat: 34:3 North
Longt: 118:15 West

Lat: 55:57 North
Longt: 3:13 West
TZone: 0, TMode: DST, DST: 1
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 18-Sep-1933 [8:30:0]

Lat: 40:49 North
Longt: 74:10 West

Lat: 41:15 North
Longt: 95:56 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 6-Jul-1946 [7:26:0]

Lat: 41:18 North
Longt: 72:55 West
Date of birth: 23-Oct-1925 [7:15:0]

Lat: 40:59 North
Longt: 94:44 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 30-Jan-1941 [19:30:0]

Lat: 40:48 North
Longt: 96:40 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 15-Aug-1912 [23:30:0]

Lat: 34:9 North
Longt: 118:9 West
Date of birth: 30-Oct-1950 [17:45:0]

Lat: 42:22 North
Longt: 71:6 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)

Lat: 42:21 North
Longt: 71:3 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)

Lat: 27:30 North
Longt: 99:30 West

Lat: 35:40 North
Longt: 80:28 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 46:47 North
Longt: 92:6 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)

Lat: 35:25 North
Longt: 80:35 West
Date of birth: 31-May-1930 [17:35:0]

Lat: 37:47 North
Longt: 122:26 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 42:2 North
Longt: 0:8 East
ASC sublord (Mars) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Sun)

Lat: 40:46 North
Longt: 73:59 West
Date of birth: 31-Mar-1948 [12:53:0]

Lat: 38:54 North
Longt: 77:2 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 30-Mar-1962 [11:59:0]

Lat: 37:48 North
Longt: 122:16 West
ASC sublord (Venus) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 25-May-1969 [16:51:0]
Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)

Lat: 41:51 North
Longt: 87:39 West
Date of birth: 12-May-1907 [17:47:0]

Lat: 41:46 North
Longt: 72:41 West
Date of birth: 1-Mar-1954 [9:3:0]

Lat: 34:30 North
Longt: 97:57 West

Lat: 34:3 North
Longt: 118:14 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)

Lat: 34:4 North
Longt: 118:15 West
Date of birth: 27-Nov-1957 [8:15:0]

Lat: 40:42 North
Longt: 74:0 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 49:28 North
Longt: 10:59 East
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Sun) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 14-Apr-1977 [13:46:0]

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West

Lat: 37:18 North
Longt: 89:31 West

Lat: 43:36 North
Longt: 83:53 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)

Lat: 18:25 North
Longt: 66:3 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 43:10 North
Longt: 78:41 West

Lat: 34:3 North
Longt: 118:15 West
Date of birth: 23-Apr-1954 [12:45:0]

Lat: 43:0 North
Longt: 83:41 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)

Lat: 34:1 North
Longt: 95:31 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 37:16 North
Longt: 81:13 West
Date of birth: 15-Jan-1920 [14:25:0]

Lat: 39:57 North
Longt: 75:10 West
Lat: 34:11 North
Longt: 118:26 West
Date of birth: 25-May-1887 [16:10:0]

Lat: 41:12 North
Longt: 14:51 East

Lat: 32:42 North
Longt: 117:9 West

Lat: 48:15 North
Longt: 12:51 East
ASC sublord (Ketu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 51:30 North
Longt: 0:10 West
ASC sublord (Mars) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)

Lat: 33:45 North
Longt: 84:23 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)

Lat: 38:2 North
Longt: 84:30 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)

Lat: 39:10 North
Longt: 84:27 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 19:46 North
Longt: 104:22 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)

Lat: 40:42 North
Longt: 74:0 West
Date of birth: 23-Sep-1949 [22:50:0]

Lat: 40:15 North
Longt: 74:16 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 25-Mar-1934 [22:0:0]

Lat: 41:40 North
Longt: 83:33 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)

Lat: 40:44 North
Longt: 74:5 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)

Lat: 40:43 North
Longt: 74:22 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 31-Jan-1981 [18:30:0]

Lat: 35:8 North
Longt: 90:2 West

Lat: 40:44 North
Longt: 74:5 West

Lat: 39:9 North
Longt: 84:27 West

Lat: 40:54 North
Longt: 73:50 West
Date of birth: 19-Nov-1935 [10:30:0]

Lat: 42:31 North
Longt: 70:55 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 26-Sep-1981 [20:28:0]
Lat: 43:25 North
Longt: 83:57 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 17-Jun-1980 [14:12:0]

Lat: 33:55 North
Longt: 118:12 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 30-Dec-1975 [22:50:0]

Lat: 33:46 North
Longt: 118:11 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Total CORRECT charts examined: 109. Connection exists in: 85, No

connection in: 24
START OF INCORRECT DATA

Date of birth: 2-Jan-1938 [15:52:0]****
Lat: 40:51 North
Longt: 74:7 West
Date of birth: 4-Jan-1920 [18:2:0]****

Lat: 44:57 North
Longt: 93:6 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 4-Jan-1935 [14:40:0]****

Lat: 35:22 North
Longt: 81:26 West
Date of birth: 5-Jan-1938 [13:15:0]****

Lat: 41:54 North
Longt: 12:29 East
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 7-Jan-1922 [9:10:0]****

Lat: 43:18 North
Longt: 5:24 East
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 8-Jan-1935 [4:45:0]****

Lat: 34:16 North
Longt: 88:43 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 9-Jan-1913 [21:45:0]****

Lat: 33:53 North
Longt: 117:49 West
Date of birth: 9-Jan-1934 [15:10:0]****

Lat: 32:23 North
Longt: 86:19 West
ASC sublord (Venus) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 10-Jan-1949 [21:25:0]****

Lat: 32:33 North
Longt: 94:23 West
ASC sublord (Mars) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 11-Jan-1940 [23:40:0]****

Lat: 45:15 North
Longt: 7:35 East
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 12-Jan-1951 [8:0:0]****

Lat: 37:18 North
Longt: 89:31 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 13-Jan-1925 [10:7:0]****

Lat: 34:1 North
Longt: 118:25 West
ASC sublord (Mars) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 15-Jan-1029 [14:0:0]****

Lat: 32:15 North
Longt: 101:28 West
Date of birth: 16-Jan-1935 [1:35:0]****

Lat: 29:46 North
Longt: 95:22 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 17-Jan-1933 [23:7:0]****

Lat: 40:46 North
Longt: 73:59 West
Date of birth: 20-Jan-1930 [14:27:0]****
Lat: 40:49 North
Longt: 74:13 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 21-Jan-1940 [3:20:0]****

Lat: 39:58 North
Longt: 83:0 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 24-Jan-1941 [23:14:0]****

Lat: 40:38 North
Longt: 73:56 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 25-Jan-1949 [5:22:0]****

Lat: 41:52 North
Longt: 87:39 West
Date of birth: 26-Jan-1961 [7:55:0]****

Lat: 43:8 North
Longt: 80:16 West
Date of birth: 26-Jan-1925 [6:40:0]****

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 2-Feb-1926 [21:40:0]****

Lat: 50:21 North
Longt: 7:35 East
Date of birth: 3-Feb-1940 [0:52:0]****

Lat: 37:33 North
Longt: 77:27 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 4-Feb-1948 [22:43:0]****

Lat: 42:20 North
Longt: 83:3 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 4-Feb-1921 [4:10:0]****

Lat: 40:42 North
Longt: 89:36 West
Date of birth: 5-Feb-1934 [20:35:0]****

Lat: 30:41 North
Longt: 88:3 West
Date of birth: 5-Feb-1942 [4:35:0]****

Lat: 39:6 North
Longt: 84:31 West
Date of birth: 9-Feb-1945 [11:37:0]****

Lat: 34:4 North
Longt: 118:15 West
Date of birth: 10-Feb-1950 [17:55:0]****

Lat: 37:39 North
Longt: 121:0 West
Date of birth: 10-Feb-1930 [1:55:0]****

Lat: 42:20 North
Longt: 83:3 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 11-Feb-1921 [2:40:0]****

Lat: 26:13 North
Longt: 90:19 West
Date of birth: 13-Feb-1933 [8:23:0]****

Lat: 41:52 North
Longt: 87:39 West
Date of birth: 13-Feb-1939 [8:8:0]****

Lat: 34:4 North
Longt: 118:15 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 14-Feb-1921 [17:25:0]****

Lat: 41:5 North
Longt: 81:31 West
Date of birth: 14-Feb-1913 [7:2:0]****
Lat: 39:32 North
Longt: 87:8 West
Date of birth: 17-Feb-1925 [3:26:0]****

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
Date of birth: 21-Feb-1925 [14:25:0]****

Lat: 36:44 North
Longt: 119:47 West
Date of birth: 22-Feb-1932 [4:8:0]****

Lat: 42:17 North
Longt: 71:4 West
Date of birth: 24-Feb-1940 [22:8:0]****

Lat: 38:15 North
Longt: 85:46 West
Date of birth: 25-Feb-1913 [7:40:0]****

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Rahu)
Date of birth: 25-Feb-1934 [20:24:0]****

Lat: 37:49 North
Longt: 122:16 West
Date of birth: 29-Feb-1936 [8:48:0]****

Lat: 42:58 North
Longt: 85:40 West
Date of birth: 29-Feb-1920 [9:0:0]****

Lat: 38:35 North
Longt: 121:29 West
Date of birth: 15-Aug-1972 [3:3:0]****

Lat: 37:52 North
Longt: 122:16 West
Date of birth: 17-Jan-1942 [18:45:0]****

Lat: 38:15 North
Longt: 85:46 West
Date of birth: 4-Apr-1928 [14:20:0]****

Lat: 38:37 North
Longt: 90:12 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 7-Jun-1956 [22:50:0]****

Lat: 40:47 North
Longt: 74:29 West
Date of birth: 12-Dec-1926 [4:40:0]****

Lat: 48:35 North
Longt: 7:45 East
Date of birth: 30-Mar-1937 [17:40:0]****

Lat: 37:33 North
Longt: 77:27 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 9-May-1946 [22:2:0]****

Lat: 34:3 North
Longt: 118:15 West
Date of birth: 6-May-1953 [6:20:0]****

Lat: 55:57 North
Longt: 3:13 West
Date of birth: 18-Sep-1933 [8:40:0]****

Lat: 40:49 North
Longt: 74:10 West
Date of birth: 3-Apr-1924 [23:10:0]****

Lat: 41:15 North
Longt: 95:56 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 6-Jul-1946 [7:36:0]****
Lat: 41:18 North
Longt: 72:55 West
Date of birth: 23-Oct-1925 [7:25:0]****

Lat: 40:59 North
Longt: 94:44 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 30-Jan-1941 [19:40:0]****

Lat: 40:48 North
Longt: 96:40 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 15-Aug-1912 [23:40:0]****

Lat: 34:9 North
Longt: 118:9 West
Date of birth: 30-Oct-1950 [17:55:0]****

Lat: 42:22 North
Longt: 71:6 West
Date of birth: 8-Oct-1970 [15:32:0]****

Lat: 42:21 North
Longt: 71:3 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 8-Apr-1947 [21:57:0]****

Lat: 27:30 North
Longt: 99:30 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)
Date of birth: 29-Jul-1936 [2:5:0]****

Lat: 35:40 North
Longt: 80:28 West
Date of birth: 24-May-1941 [21:15:0]****

Lat: 46:47 North
Longt: 92:6 West
ASC sublord (Saturn) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 29-Apr-1951 [13:17:0]****

Lat: 35:25 North
Longt: 80:35 West
Date of birth: 31-May-1930 [17:45:0]****

Lat: 37:47 North
Longt: 122:26 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)
Date of birth: 9-Jan-1902 [22:10:0]****

Lat: 42:2 North
Longt: 0:8 East
Date of birth: 21-Dec-1937 [9:24:0]****

Lat: 40:46 North
Longt: 73:59 West
ASC sublord (Venus) connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 31-Mar-1948 [13:3:0]****

Lat: 38:54 North
Longt: 77:2 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 30-Mar-1962 [12:9:0]****

Lat: 37:48 North
Longt: 122:16 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 25-May-1969 [17:1:0]****

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
Date of birth: 9-Apr-1926 [16:30:0]****

Lat: 41:51 North
Longt: 87:39 West
Date of birth: 12-May-1907 [17:57:0]****

Lat: 41:46 North
Longt: 72:41 West
Date of birth: 1-Mar-1954 [9:13:0]****

Lat: 34:30 North
Longt: 97:57 West
Date of birth: 4-Jun-1975 [9:19:0]****
Lat: 34:3 North
Longt: 118:14 West
Date of birth: 5-Jan-1946 [2:59:0]****

Lat: 34:4 North
Longt: 118:15 West
ASC sublord (Venus) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 27-Nov-1957 [8:25:0]****

Lat: 40:42 North
Longt: 74:0 West
Date of birth: 27-May-1923 [5:40:0]****

Lat: 49:28 North
Longt: 10:59 East
Date of birth: 8-Oct-1946 [18:3:0]****

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) connected to Moon starlord (Jupiter)
Date of birth: 14-Apr-1977 [13:56:0]****

Lat: 41:30 North
Longt: 81:42 West
Date of birth: 12-Jan-1951 [8:0:0]****

Lat: 37:18 North
Longt: 89:31 West
Date of birth: 19-Aug-1958 [7:15:0]****

Lat: 43:36 North
Longt: 83:53 West
ASC sublord (Rahu) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 24-Dec-1971 [17:10:0]****

Lat: 18:25 North
Longt: 66:3 West
Date of birth: 23-Apr-1968 [8:29:0]****

Lat: 43:10 North
Longt: 78:41 West
Date of birth: 1-Jun-1926 [9:40:0]****

Lat: 34:3 North
Longt: 118:15 West
Date of birth: 23-Apr-1954 [12:55:0]****

Lat: 43:0 North
Longt: 83:41 West
Date of birth: 5-Jun-1934 [23:25:0]****

Lat: 34:1 North
Longt: 95:31 West
Date of birth: 13-Jun-1928 [7:10:0]****

Lat: 37:16 North
Longt: 81:13 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Mercury)
Date of birth: 15-Jan-1920 [14:35:0]****

Lat: 39:57 North
Longt: 75:10 West
Date of birth: 13-Jun-1986 [9:55:0]****

Lat: 34:11 North
Longt: 118:26 West
Date of birth: 25-May-1887 [16:20:0]****

Lat: 41:12 North
Longt: 14:51 East
Date of birth: 24-Oct-1972 [9:46:0]****

Lat: 32:42 North
Longt: 117:9 West
ASC sublord (Sun) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 16-Apr-1927 [4:25:0]****

Lat: 48:15 North
Longt: 12:51 East
Date of birth: 21-Apr-1926 [2:50:0]****
Lat: 51:30 North
Longt: 0:10 West
Date of birth: 28-Oct-1967 [0:26:0]****

Lat: 33:45 North
Longt: 84:23 West
ASC sublord (Mercury) connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 29-May-1947 [9:13:0]****

Lat: 38:2 North
Longt: 84:30 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Moon)
Date of birth: 14-Apr-1941 [5:55:0]****

Lat: 39:10 North
Longt: 84:27 West
Date of birth: 20-Jul-1947 [2:10:0]****

Lat: 19:46 North
Longt: 104:22 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 27-Nov-1957 [8:25:0]****

Lat: 40:42 North
Longt: 74:0 West
Date of birth: 23-Sep-1949 [23:0:0]****

Lat: 40:15 North
Longt: 74:16 West
ASC sublord (Ketu) connected to Moon starlord (Mars)
Date of birth: 25-Mar-1934 [22:10:0]****

Lat: 41:40 North
Longt: 83:33 West
ASC sublord (Jupiter) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Saturn)
Date of birth: 3-Aug-1941 [13:43:0]****

Lat: 40:44 North
Longt: 74:5 West
Date of birth: 22-Jun-1949 [8:15:0]****

Lat: 40:43 North
Longt: 74:22 West
ASC sublord (Moon) connected to Moon starlord (Venus)
Date of birth: 31-Jan-1981 [18:40:0]****

Lat: 35:8 North
Longt: 90:2 West
Date of birth: 24-Nov-1949 [8:10:0]****

Lat: 40:44 North
Longt: 74:5 West
ASC sublord (Mars) connected to Moon starlord (Sun)
Date of birth: 19-Nov-1938 [9:0:0]****

Lat: 39:9 North
Longt: 84:27 West
Date of birth: 28-Dec-1954 [12:19:0]****

Lat: 40:54 North
Longt: 73:50 West
Date of birth: 19-Nov-1935 [10:40:0]****

Lat: 42:31 North
Longt: 70:55 West
Date of birth: 26-Sep-1981 [20:38:0]****

Lat: 43:25 North
Longt: 83:57 West
Date of birth: 17-Jun-1980 [14:22:0]****

Lat: 33:55 North
Longt: 118:12 West
ASC sublord (Venus) NOT connected to Moon starlord (Ketu)
Date of birth: 30-Dec-1975 [23:0:0]****

Lat: 33:46 North
Longt: 118:11 West
Total INCORRECT charts examined: 109. Connection exists in: 88, No

connection in: 21
**** END OF DATA ****

Study of Aa Rated Charts

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Study of Aa Rated Charts

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Birth Time Verification – A Study

May 26, 2005

For this experiment I ran my program on several AA-rated birth data

Definition of “Connection” as Used in the Program

Next, I “mutated” the data by adding 10 minutes to each record.

The outcome is shown in the following table:

Description Passes Fails

Let N be the number of records known to be correct. By mutating the

Effectiveness of Shanmugham’s Technique = <78, 19>

It is very important to remember that Shanmugham’s rule only tries to

This raises an interesting question: What are the fundamental criteria

Feel free to let me know if you notice errors or have suggestions on

START OF CORRECT DATA

Date of birth: 4-Jan-1920 [17:52:0]

Date of birth: 4-Jan-1935 [14:30:0]

Date of birth: 5-Jan-1938 [13:5:0]

Date of birth: 7-Jan-1922 [9:0:0]

Date of birth: 8-Jan-1935 [4:35:0]

Date of birth: 9-Jan-1913 [21:35:0]

Date of birth: 9-Jan-1934 [15:0:0]

Date of birth: 10-Jan-1949 [21:15:0]

Date of birth: 11-Jan-1940 [23:30:0]

Date of birth: 12-Jan-1951 [7:50:0]

Date of birth: 15-Jan-1029 [13:50:0]

Date of birth: 16-Jan-1935 [1:25:0]

Date of birth: 17-Jan-1933 [22:57:0]

Date of birth: 20-Jan-1930 [14:17:0]

Date of birth: 21-Jan-1940 [3:10:0]

Date of birth: 24-Jan-1941 [23:4:0]

Date of birth: 25-Jan-1949 [5:12:0]

Date of birth: 26-Jan-1961 [7:45:0]

Date of birth: 26-Jan-1925 [6:30:0]

Date of birth: 2-Feb-1926 [21:30:0]

Date of birth: 3-Feb-1940 [0:42:0]

Date of birth: 4-Feb-1948 [22:33:0]

Date of birth: 4-Feb-1921 [4:0:0]

Date of birth: 5-Feb-1934 [20:25:0]

Date of birth: 5-Feb-1942 [4:25:0]

Date of birth: 9-Feb-1945 [11:27:0]

Date of birth: 10-Feb-1950 [17:45:0]

Date of birth: 10-Feb-1930 [1:45:0]

Date of birth: 13-Feb-1933 [8:13:0]

Date of birth: 13-Feb-1939 [7:58:0]

Date of birth: 14-Feb-1921 [17:15:0]

Date of birth: 14-Feb-1913 [6:52:0]

Date of birth: 17-Feb-1925 [3:16:0]

Date of birth: 21-Feb-1925 [14:15:0]

Date of birth: 22-Feb-1932 [3:58:0]

Date of birth: 24-Feb-1940 [21:58:0]

Date of birth: 25-Feb-1913 [7:30:0]

Date of birth: 25-Feb-1934 [20:14:0]

Date of birth: 29-Feb-1936 [8:38:0]

Date of birth: 29-Feb-1920 [8:50:0]

Date of birth: 15-Aug-1972 [2:53:0]

Date of birth: 17-Jan-1942 [18:35:0]

Date of birth: 4-Apr-1928 [14:10:0]

Date of birth: 7-Jun-1956 [22:40:0]

Date of birth: 12-Dec-1926 [4:30:0]

Date of birth: 30-Mar-1937 [17:30:0]

Date of birth: 6-May-1953 [6:10:0]

Date of birth: 18-Sep-1933 [8:30:0]

Date of birth: 3-Apr-1924 [23:0:0]

Date of birth: 6-Jul-1946 [7:26:0]