Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ecology An Excerpt From The Natural Building Companion PDF
Ecology An Excerpt From The Natural Building Companion PDF
$59.95 USD
the
Racusin
D E S I G N / B U I L D L I B R A R Y
Natural Building
A S tat e - o f - t h e - A r t R e s o u r c e a n d
I n s t r u c t i o n a l D V D f o r t h e N at u r a l B u i l d e r
“One of the best natural building books Natural buildings not only bring satisfaction to their
published in recent years.” makers and joy to their occupants, they also leave the c o m p a n i o n
Ecology
A critical consideration in gaining an awareness to systems ecology are happening now, and are not
of the context of a building is appreciating the just potential future outcomes. In accepting this
ecological impact of the structure as a whole and reality, we then must also accept responsibility for
of its material components—from the extraction of changing these outcomes.
the feedstock to the disposal of the building upon The primary cause of the current global warming
demolition—as well as the ecology of the proposed trend is the release of greenhouse gases into the
building site. There is far more on this subject than atmosphere; the gases prevent heat from radiating
can be covered in this book; therefore, we will lay through the atmosphere into space, trapping the
out the most significant ecological considerations heat and raising global climate temperatures. As
and the role natural building plays in causation designers and builders we are part of an industry
and/or remediation of these considerations, and we that contributes 35% of the greenhouse gas emitted
encourage you to engage in further research on the in North America (Biello 2008), so we can play a
topics of greatest relevance to your project. big role in achieving significant greenhouse gas
reductions. From material selection to energy
efficiency detailing, much of what makes natural
Global Warming and building a more ecologically favorable building
practice relates to the fact that it contributes less to
Climate Change global warming than do other building practices.
The effectiveness of greenhouse gases in trapping
The largest, most complex, and most urgent social heat in our atmosphere is measured as global warming
and ecological issue we face as a global community potential (GWP); by association, the GWP of a
is that of the steady warming of our Earth’s climate, material, product, or building is directly related to
which is the result of, at least in part, the release of the emissions of these gases. Carbon dioxide (CO2 )
anthropogenically sourced carbon compounds into is the most common and most heavily produced by
the atmosphere. While there are still people who anthropogenic sources. However, methane has 25
question the validity of climate change—the extent of times, nitrous oxide 298 times, and hexafluoride
its potential negative impact, or the human causation 22,800 times the GWP (Malin 2008). Since CO2 is
factors involved—the overwhelming majority of used as a baseline, the value of these gases is referred
scientific research shows measurable evidence of rising to as CO2 equivalent, or CO2e. For example, 1 ton of
global temperatures and shifts in climate, with direct methane is represented as 25 tons CO2e.
human causation. Associated ecosystem degradation, To have an effective impact on reducing CO2e,
biodiversity and habitat loss, phenological changes we have to identify the contributing factors of CO2e
(how plant and animal life-cycle events are influenced in buildings. Given that energy consumption is a
by variations in climate), and myriad other changes primary source of CO2e production, a common tool
12 The Natural Building Companion
Commercial
Residential
Industrial
Transportation
Greenhouse gas production in the United States in 2005, by sector. Graph by Jacob Deva Racusin; source Emrath and Liu 2007.
for analyzing the impact of a material is through its used to calculate the embodied energy for materials.
energy use. The amount of energy used to produce The cradle-to-grave boundary, by comparison,
a material from raw feedstock extraction through includes all energy used in resource extraction,
production and manufacturing is called its embodied manufacturing, production, transportation to site,
energy; this period of analysis, or boundary, is referred inclusion within a building, and disposal (Hammond
to as cradle-to-gate, and it is the common boundary and Jones 2011). In analysis of a new construction
There are ecological impacts throughout a product’s life cycle, from cradle to grave. Illustration by Ben Graham.
Ecology 13
G WP OF MAIN GR E E N H O U S E GA S E S
(in p p b v * )
25,000
23,900
20,000
15,000
10,000
7,100
5,000 6,500
1
21
320
0 1,400
Carbon dioxide (CO2)
Methane (CH4)
CFC-12 (CCI2F2)
HCFC-22 (CHCIF2)
Perfluoromethane (CF4)
Greenhouse warming potential of different greenhouse gases. Graph by Jacob Deva Racusin; source: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change 1996, 22.
project, the calculation may also include carbon bamboo flooring is 15 megajoules(MJ)/ton, whereas
released from disturbing soil, or transportation of that of the concrete is 1452.3 MJ/ton (a joule is a
workers to and from the site, as well as operational measurement equivalent to the energy expended to
energy use. produce one watt for one second, and a megajoule
Understanding the factors used to determine is one million joules). However, once transportation
the value of embodied energy and the applied to Denver, Colorado, is considered, the embodied
boundaries is critical to having useful comparisons energy of the bamboo flooring, which has traveled
between different products. A good example is a from Hunan Province, China, inflates to 4943.1
comparison between bamboo flooring and concrete. MJ/ton—while the concrete, with in-state sourcing
In one analysis, the material embodied energy of of cement production and quarried aggregate,
14 The Natural Building Companion
Building energy-efficient structures is an essential part of natural Natural building is a relevant and appropriate strategy for
design/build. Photo by Jacob Deva Racusin. development in urban environments. Photo by Jan Tyler Allen.
Evaluat e Pa y b ack
Plastics have become invaluable components of a modern The ecological impacts of petroleum extraction are devastating,
building. Photo by Kelly Griffith. as witnessed during the Gulf oil spill of 2010. Photo by Jeff Warren.
Ecology 21
of human health; however, their unmitigated release Captain Moore found where “downstream” goes.
into the environment affects all terrestrial and aquatic Early sampling determined approximately 3 million
life with which they come into contact. tons of plastic on the surface; the United Nations
It is in the use phase that the benefits of plastics Environment Program reports that 70% of marine
in durability and effectiveness are most evident. refuse sinks below the surface, which would suggest a
Though most plastics are benign in their intended use staggering 100 million tons of plastic in this one area
form, many release toxic gases in their in-place curing of the Pacific alone—with more entering every day.
(such as spray foam) or by virtue of their formulation There are six similar gyres across the planet’s oceans,
(as with PVC additives off-gassing during their use each laden with plastic refuse (Weisman 2007).
phase). Occupational exposure during installation, The effects of this plastic on aquatic life
such as inhalation of dust while cutting plastic pipe are devastating, and accelerating. In addition to
or off-gassing vapors of curing products, is also a suffocation, ingestion, and other macro-particulate
great concern. causes of death in larger birds, fish, and mammals,
The disposal of plastics—the “grave” phase, if the plastic is ingested by smaller and smaller
you will—is one of the least-recognized and most creatures (as it breaks down into smaller and smaller
highly problematic areas of plastic’s ecological impact. particles) and bioaccumulates in greater and greater
Ironically, one of plastic’s most desirable traits—its
durability and resistance to decomposition—is also
the source of one of its greatest liabilities. Natural
organisms have a very difficult time breaking down
the synthetic chemical bonds in plastic, creating the
tremendous problem of the material’s persistence. A
very small amount of total plastic production (less
than 10%) is effectively recycled; the remaining
plastic is sent to landfills, where it is destined
to remain entombed in limbo for hundreds of
thousands of years, or to incinerators, where its toxic
compounds are spewed throughout the atmosphere
to be accumulated in biotic forms throughout the
surrounding ecosystems.
Unfortunately, because of plastic’s low density,
it frequently migrates “downstream,” blowing out of
landfills and off garbage barges. For decades, marine
biologists and researchers had been witnessing
increasing amounts of plastic contamination in
the ocean. Then, in 1997, as mentioned in the
introduction, Captain Charles Moore discovered
widespread plastic garbage contamination in an area
larger than the state of Texas that had formed within
a cyclonic region, called a gyre, in the North Pacific
Ocean. By 2005, the estimated area of contamination
expanded to 10 million square miles, nearly the
size of Africa. Ninety percent of this garbage was
Plastic trash aggregating in bodies of water is a clear example
determined to be plastic, and 80% was originally of the problem of the bio-persistence of petroleum products.
sourced from land, such as construction waste—so Photo by Leung Cho Pan/Bigstock.com
22 The Natural Building Companion
concentrations up the food chain—with humans at straw or cellulose-based insulation in walls and roofs
the top. Exacerbating these problems of persistence and mineral board insulation below basement walls
and bioaccumulation is plastic’s propensity to instead of foam insulation, using wood or cement-
act as a magnet and sponge for persistent organic board siding or plaster as an exterior finish instead of
pollutants such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) vinyl, and using clay, lime, or casein-based finishes
and the pesticide DDT. So, in addition to ingesting instead of acrylic or latex paints. In other cases, our
the physically and chemically damaging plastic best option may be to replace a more toxic plastic, such
compounds, aquatic life is also ingesting concentrated as PVC, with a less toxic one, such as polyethylene,
quantities of highly bioaccumulative compounds ABS, or metallocene polyolefin (a newly developed
that are some of the most potent toxins found on plastic of lesser environmental footprint) pipe instead
the planet. Again, this bioaccumulation increases in of PVC pipe, fiberglass instead of PVC window
concentration as it works up the food chain and into profiles, polyethylene instead of PVC-jacketed wire, or
our diets. polyester instead of PVC commercial wall coverings.
A final consideration of plastic disposal comes The field of bio-plastics is also growing rapidly. These
from the release of POPs and other toxic chemicals products have the benefits of being nonpetroleum in
into the environment from the plastics themselves. feedstock, supportive of the farm sector (although LCA
These compounds present a host of ecological must also evaluate industrialized farming practices),
and human health issues and, like plastic, are also and, perhaps most importantly, biodegradable.
bioaccumulative. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) is Additionally, vegetable oils such as soy have been
particularly noxious, owing to its formulated inclusion proven to effectively replace pthalates as plasticizers in
of halogenated compounds (those containing PVC, reducing its POP load.
bromine or chlorine), and are particularly dangerous
if burned, in which case dioxins are produced, some
of which are among the most harmful of all human- H um an H e alth Co ncerns
made compounds. Consider, then, the terrific health
liability of exposure through accidental or unwitting While substances that are toxic to human health
incineration or house fire. Halogens are also sourced are generally toxic to other biotic forms, and vice
from a class of flame retardants that are commonly versa, there are a few categories of toxins that are
formulated into a variety of plastic products found quite insidious in their ubiquity within our built
in the building industry, particularly polystyrene environment that enact particularly harmful effects on
insulation (XPS, EPS); the effects of flame retardants occupant safety, which we feel bear specific mention.
are discussed in the next section. Collectively, these
harmful chemicals are known to cause the following
severe health problems: cancer, endometriosis, H alo genat e d Flame Ret ard ant s (H FRs)
neurological damage, endocrine disruption,
birth defects and child developmental disorders, As mentioned in the discussion of plastics,
reproductive damage, immune damage, asthma, and halogenated compounds are chlorine- or bromine-
multiple organ damage. based formulations that have the potential—when
While we recognize the need for plastic products exposed to fire, for example—to create dioxins,
in our homes, in light of the tremendous ecological a family of very highly carcinogenic, immune-,
impact throughout plastic’s life cycle, we are hormone-, reproductive-, and neurologic-damaging
compelled to select alternatives when possible. In bioaccumulative POPs. These halogenated compounds
many cases, we can elect to utilize a different material are created in the formulation of PVC; they are also
altogether; examples of alternatives include using found as chlorinated or brominated fire retardants
Ecology 23
(C or BFRs). BFRs are added to a host of common (MDF), paints, and insulation, our potential expo-
materials and products, including plastics like sure via degraded indoor air quality (IAQ) is very
polystyrene foam insulation, hard plastic cases for high. In fact, a U.S. governmental study on newly
electric and electrical products, and furniture and constructed, inhabited temporary relief housing pro-
bedding products. vided by FEMA for survivors of Hurricane Katrina
Avoiding BFRs—and HFRs in general, for that in the Gulf Coast region concluded that baseline
matter—is tricky, in part because it can be very levels of formaldehyde in the trailers were sufficient
difficult to determine the nature and quantity of to cause acute health symptoms.
flame retardants in products in absence of legislation In 2007, the California Air Resource Board
requiring adequate labeling, and in part because of (CARB) released regulations that dramatically limit
a lack of alternatives to products containing HFRs. allowable concentrations of urea formaldehyde (UF)
Certainly, fire safety should not be compromised in products; while this does not fully outlaw UF, it
in an effort to move away from HFRs, nor should certainly creates incentives for alternative binders for
compromises in building performance and durability common products. Already in the marketplace are
be made. That said, there are a series of steps that many no-added-UF and no-added-formaldehyde
can be taken to reduce occupant and environmental board products in wide distribution that are
exposure to HFRs in buildings, as recommended performance- and cost-competitive. While these
by the editors of Environmental Building News, alternatives all have occupational and production-
including the use of inherently non-flammable phase exposure health hazards, they do not have
products, avoiding the use of foam products and deleterious effects on IAQ. There are formaldehyde-
halogen-clad wiring, and pressuring manufacturers free fiberglass batt insulation products commonly
to develop safer alternatives. available, as well as cotton batt insulation to replace
not only the formaldehyde, but also potentially
carcinogenic and highly irritating fiberglass. As
Formalde hyde natural builders, our approach—whenever practical
and cost-feasible—is to use all-wood or no-added-
Formaldehyde is a simple organic compound, built formaldehyde casestock cabinet construction, 2 × 6
of oxygen, carbon, and hydrogen molecules; it is part tongue-and-groove flooring (in lieu of a subfloor or
of a large family of compounds called volatile organic phenol formaldehyde-based plywood for a subfloor),
compounds (VOCs), discussed later in this chapter. and straw or cellulose insulation.
At atmospheric conditions and temperatures, it is If avoiding formaldehyde is impossible or
a colorless gas with a pungent odor. Formaldehyde impractical, it is recommended to seal the products
occurs naturally in trace levels; however, its ubiquity with paint, hard sealer, or other effective barrier to
in industrial chemistry has increased our exposure to reduce emissions, or isolate their exposure to the indoor
dramatically higher concentrations of formaldehyde, environment through physical barriers. Additionally,
which prove harmful to human health. In 2011, in all cases and all houses, adequate ventilation rates
the National Toxicology Program (a division of the and distribution should be designed to help control
United States Department of Health and Human IAQ. New product developments, such as wallboards
Services) formally changed the status of formaldehyde that absorb formaldehyde and other pollutants from
to that of a “known human carcinogen.” It is used the air and more effective and affordable air filtration
within the building industry primarily as a binder systems, can assist us in airborne toxin remediation,
and as a biocide. and it can be expected that future developments will
From upholstery to carpets, laminated flooring come online as the marketplace continues to respond
products, particleboard and medium-density fiberboard to this issue.
24 The Natural Building Companion
Volat ile O rganic Comp ounds ( VO Cs) As mentioned above in discussing formaldehyde,
the combination of VOCs’ ubiquity, direct exposure
VOCs are carbon-based (organic) compounds that in the interior of the building, highly concentrated
vaporize (become volatile) at room temperature, and potent toxicity, and frequently inadequate
and are therefore highly mobile and easy to inhale. ventilation create substantial IAQ problems. In
Formaldehyde, discussed above, is the most common fact, some studies have found the indoor built
VOC in our built environment, but there are plenty environment to be up to ten times more polluted than
of other compounds that find their way into our the outdoor environment, as highlighted by recent
buildings through a host of products. publicity surrounding “sick building syndrome,”
Further study over the last few decades which plagues many structures that were tightened
has conclusively linked long-term exposure to for energy efficiency and now have inadequate
petrochemical VOCs to a host of human disorders, ventilation and a host of airborne contaminants. The
including neurological damage, respiratory damage, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency estimates
nervous system impairment, multiple organ damage indoor pollution from VOCs to be responsible for
(kidney, liver, lung), multiple cancers (leukemia, more than 11,000 deaths a year in the United States.
lung, lymphoma), chemical sensitivity, and more. We believe these deaths are preventable, and that the
Acute symptoms include dizziness, nausea, headaches, use of VOCs in our buildings can be dramatically
blurred vision, and fatigue. Common VOCs include reduced simply by choosing nontoxic paints and
formaldehyde, toluene, isocyanates, and benzene; finishes, furniture, carpeting, and flooring—simple
they can be found in nearly every component of a changes that will make a big difference.
conventional building, as identified in our exploration
of formaldehyde above. Some VOCs will volatize, or
off-gas, very rapidly over a short period of time, such Moving Forward
as epoxy binders and certain spray-foam products.
Others, like paints and varnishes, can off-gas for years. In reading through this chapter, an appropriate
Leaving aside the ubiquitous formaldehyde, one response might be to feel overwhelmed, frustrated,
of the greatest common sources of VOCs in buildings or downright terrified by the variety and severity of
comes from interior flooring and finishes, especially ecological and human hazards created by our built
carpeting and paint. The story of paint and its environment in its contemporary form. While we
formulation relating to VOC content is told in chapter provided proactive strategies for improving our
20. In light of the health concerns listed previously, design and construction practices with each topic
it is important to stress the risk of exposure from we covered, and we devote much of the rest of this
contact with conventional paint. The health impacts book—particularly in part 3—to describing positive
are so great that associated occupational hazards solutions that can be taken in response to these
have been officially deemed “painter’s syndrome” in issues, we now provide some fundamental tools and
Australia, or “painter’s dementia” in Denmark. As far principles that we can use to help us take progressive
back as 1987, the World Health Organization stated steps in creating positive change. None of us alone
that there was a 40% increased occupational risk for can bring about the momentum needed to change the
cancer among painters. current tide, but by advancing and adopting a major
Many of these VOCs also create ozone, which philosophical shift that is responsive to these pressing
may be helpful at stratospheric levels, but at ground concerns, we can address these problems the way
levels this smog production causes respiratory disease most major problems in this world are successfully
and plant damage and contributes to global warming. addressed—through a collective movement built one
U.S. reports have stated smog production from the person, and one building, at a time.
creation of paint to be close to that of automobiles.
Ecology 25
The Prec auti o nary Principle A proactive approach can be found in the
precautionary principle, defined at the 1992 United
A cornerstone of this philosophical shift can be Nations’ Earth Summit: “Where there are threats of
realized in changing our approach to the adoption serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific
of new technology. The burden of proof of the certainty shall not be used as a reason for postponing
environmental or human safety of a product has, in cost-effective measures to prevent environmental
the United States, largely fallen on the shoulders of degradation.” This principle shifts the burden of proof
consumers, consumer and environmental advocates, from presuming a product or material is safe until
and regulators, who often can prove that a product proven hazardous to presuming a product or material
is dangerous only long after it has been released may be hazardous until testing proves its safety
into the marketplace and in many cases resulted in before general dissemination into the world via the
widespread damage. A handful of recent examples marketplace. We can already see effective adoption of
in the building industry include lead paint, asbestos, the precautionary principle affecting market viability
and POPs. This “catch-up” process is currently being and increased scientific and regulatory scrutiny of new
played out with formaldehyde and BFRs, now that technologies, such as Europe and Japan’s rejection
they have been shown through multiple studies to of widespread adoption of genetic engineering
have already widely contaminated the planet and our (particularly in the food sector). New unproven
bodies. In the aforementioned FEMA formaldehyde technologies such as nanotechnology have the potential
study, it was reported that “additional research is to reshape our world much in the same way plastic did
needed to better clarify the potential reproductive in the last century. Learning from the past, we can see
and developmental toxicity of formaldehyde,” well the potential danger we face should the precautionary
after widespread contamination has been built into principle not be applied to new innovations as they
nearly all residences in the United States. appear in the markets and in our daily lives.
The Living Building Challenge helps buildings such as the Omega Center for Sustainable Living create a paradigm for a new built
environment. Photo courtesy of Omega Institute for Holistic Studies, Rhinebook, NY.
26 The Natural Building Companion