Professional Documents
Culture Documents
© 2008 Nevada Real Estate Division, Department of Business & Industry, State of Nevada.
(NRS 218.698 and NRS 344.070 (2006)).
This work may be reproduced in whole or in part provided there is no alteration or editing of the material and
provided that an appropriate credit line and copyright notice are included.
No part of this work may be repackaged, reformatted, or modified either electronically or by any other means,
by the addition or removal of any material, information, artwork, design work, images or text.
Funding for this project was provided Sarah Zita, of Zita Group, Inc.,
by the Nevada Real Estate Division, Las Vegas, Nevada, designed and provided
Department of Business & Industry, State the wonderful graphics, photographs,
of Nevada, through the Nevada Education layout, formatting, technical and editorial
Research and Recovery Fund. corrections, and the artwork. The beauty
and functionality of the Guide is all her.
The Guide was conceived and given its
nativity under the auspices of Nothing of this scope is possible without
Gail J. Anderson, Real Estate Division extensive review. The written material
Administrator (2002-2007), and the was reviewed by the late Gail Brown
2005-2006 Nevada Real Estate Fox, long-time corporate broker in Clark
Commissioners: Benjamin Green, Washoe County; Matt D’Orio, formerly Education/
County; Lee Gurr, Elko County; Curry Information Officer with the Real Estate
Jameson, Washoe County; Charlie Mack, Division; Lee Gurr, previous NV Real
Clark County; and Beth Rossum, Clark Estate Commissioner and broker/owner;
County. The format, chapter topic Deanna Rymarowicz, Esq., legal counsel
suggestions and problem areas were for the Greater Las Vegas Association of
identified with a series of round table Realtors®; Ben Scheible, Esq., author and
discussion groups composed of real estate real estate educator; and Robert Aalberts, JD.
industry practitioners. Their insight and professor of law at UNLV, who was also a
comments when the project was just member of the review committee. Current
beginning were invaluable. RED Administrator Ann M. McDermott,
along with Safia Anwari, Education &
Debra March, Executive Director of Information Officer of the Real Estate
The Lied Institute of Real Estate Division, reviewed and edited the text
Studies, College of Business of the to ensure its timeliness. The
University of Nevada, Las Vegas, served Real Estate Division would like to
as administrative project manager. acknowledge the contribution of Bruce
Her extensive background in real Alitt, Chief Investigator, in reviewing
estate education and administration/ and suggesting edits
management kept the project moving
forward. Finally, much thanks goes to the current
Commissioners and Real Estate Division
Melody L. Luetkehans, JD, researched Administrator for seeing this project
and wrote the Guide under contract through to its finalization:
with the Lied Institute. Previously, she RED Administrator Ann M. McDermott;
was General Counsel for the Nevada Beth Rossum, Commission President, from
Association of Realtors® and manned their Clark County; Janice Copple,
Legal Hotline for years. She continues vice-president, Washoe County; Bert
to teach real estate law and is currently Gurr, secretary, Elko County; Marc Sykes,
with the National Judicial College on the Washoe County; and Soozi Jones Walker,
University of Nevada, Reno campus. Clark County.
Table of contents
I. nevada law on real estate agency.................................................................................................................................I - 3
A. Representing the Client.................................................................................................................................................I - 3
B. Duties – Sources............................................................................................................................................................ I - 12
C. Things for Which a Licensee is Not Liable........................................................................................................... I - 14
D. Termination of Agency............................................................................................................................................... I - 19
E. Review............................................................................................................................................................................... I - 22
II. Nevada Law on Fiduciary Duties.......................................................................................................................................II - 3
A. Evolution of the Common Law to Statutory Duties.......................................................................................... II - 3
B. Client Before Self – Absolute Fidelity..................................................................................................................... II - 5
C. Duty of Honesty............................................................................................................................................................. II - 9
D. Reasonable Skill and Care: Competency.............................................................................................................II - 11
E. Disclosure: “Should have Known” – Duty to Investigate...............................................................................II - 13
F. Supplementary Services...........................................................................................................................................II - 17
G. Review..............................................................................................................................................................................II - 20
D. Termination of Agency................................................................................................................................................................................ 19
1. End of Transaction or Contract Date.........................................................................................................................19
2. Mutual Agreement..........................................................................................................................................................20
3. Abandonment or Involuntary Termination – Client or Broker........................................................................20
4. Death - Client or Broker.................................................................................................................................................21
E. Review....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 22
1. 2A Corpus Juris
Secundum, Agency §4
(c), (1972). Here we examine the nature of real estate agency as identified in Nevada
statute, regulation, and as amplified by case law. We review Nevada’s laws
2. NRS 111.450.
on real estate licensee agency and its parameters - what it is and isn’t,
3. Seigworth v. State ,
91 Nev. 536, 538 (1975).
its raison d’être. We look at how real estate agency is created, the legally
recognized types of agency in Nevada, the legal sources of the licensee’s
4. NRS 645.0045.
agency duties, the minimum legal parameters of agency, what activities
5. NRS 645.005.
aren’t included in real estate agency and what terminates an agency
6. NRS 645.0045(2). relationship.
Under general agency law, agency occurs The Nevada Law and Reference Guide, is
when one person (the agent), with the concerned with real estate agency in
consent of another person (the principal), which the broker is the agent of the client.
undertakes to represent and act on the
principal’s account with third-persons Nevada’s real estate brokerage statutes
and usually in business matters. It is (NRS 645) define “agency” as the relationship
voluntary, consensual and as a rule - between a principal (client) and an
when dealing with real property - is agent (broker) arising out of a brokerage
founded upon an express or implied agreement in which the agent agrees to
contract.1 do certain acts on behalf of the principal
in dealings with a third party.4 Real estate
Nevada recognizes two types of agency related acts are identified in the definition
“The Real Estate Division concerning real property: first, there is of “brokerage agreement” and include the
specifically rejects the
general agency in which the agent is broker assisting, soliciting or negotiating
use of the term “dual
agency”. The position
authorized under a general power-of- the sale, purchase option, rental or lease of
statement may be found attorney to perform all duties for the real property, or the sale, exchange, option
at http://www.red.state. principal that the principal could perform or purchase of a business.5 However, by
nv.us/publications/ to convey real property (general agency statute, an agency relationship cannot
PositionStatements/ requires a written power-of-attorney be established solely from a licensee’s
MULTI%20REP%20
with its special recording requirements);2 negotiations or communications with a client
FINAL%20SEP%2007.pdf
second, there is special agency in which of another broker if the licensee has received
the agent is given limited authority to act written permission from that party’s broker.6
for the client within certain restrictions
and for specific transactions.3 Real estate A brokerage agreement is an employment
brokerage agreements create a special contract wherein the broker agrees to
agency wherein the broker’s authority provide real estate related services for
is limited to facilitating a real estate valuable consideration or compensation.
transaction for his or her principal. Unless It may be either oral or written. The client
otherwise noted, all agency referred to in does not need to be the one paying the
I-3
broker’s compensation. The compensation licensee’s basic duties, the licensee 7. NRS 645.005.
may be paid to the broker by either the client is required to provide the client and
or another person.7 Though the brokerage each unrepresented party with a state 8. NRS 645.030.
agreement is an employment contract, mandated form called the “Duties Owed
without some type of alternative agreement, by a Nevada Real Estate Licensee”.10 9. NRS 645.255. The
a real estate broker is an independent exception is when a
contractor and not the employee of the a. Single or sole agency – Single agency client authorizes in
client. is the most common form of agency and writing the broker
the one least likely to create liability for a to waive the duty to
Real estate related services include, but broker. Single agency is where the broker present all offers (NRS
are not limited to, any of the following represents only one party in a given 645.254(4).
acts: the negotiation of, or the sale, transaction. The broker’s duty, loyalty and
exchange, option, purchase, rent or lease, responsibilities are focused on promoting 10. NRS 645.252(3).
of any interest in real estate (improved the interests of that client.
or unimproved); any modular, used 11. Young v. Nevada
manufactured or mobile home (when b. “Acting for More Than One Party to Title Co., 103 Nev. 436,
conveyed with any interest in the the Transaction” – Nevada law provides 439 (1987).
underlying real estate); public lands; or that a broker may represent more than
in a business. It also covers the listing or one party in a real estate transaction. 12. NRS 645.252(1)(d).
soliciting of prospective purchasers, lessees “The same person or entity may act as
or renters, or the taking of an advance fee.8 the agent for two parties interested in the
“Transactional agency” –
same transaction when their interests do
where the broker agrees he
Once agency is established, all the duties not conflict and where loyalty to one does or she is not representing
and responsibilities of representation not necessarily constitute breach of duty either party and is only
attach to the broker (and through the to the other.”11 When representing more hired to facilitate the
broker, to the broker-salesperson or than one party in a transaction, the broker transaction.
salesperson). Those duties are found in must disclose this representation and
statute (NRS), administrative regulation obtain the written consent of each party
(NAC), and as expanded upon in case law before proceeding.12
(Nevada Reports).
I-5
2. Agency Disclosure Forms 16. NRS 645.252(3).
When an agency relationship is A licensee who refers a potential client to 17. NAC 645.637.
established the broker is required to another licensee does not need to provide
provide the client with a state mandated the Duties Owed disclosure form if the 18. NRS 645.193.
disclosure form called the “Duties Owed referring licensee’s only activity is the
by a Nevada Real Estate Licensee”.16 referral.22 For example, a seller contacts 19. NAC 645.650.
Should the broker at any point in a a broker about representing him in the
transaction be deemed to represent more sale of his Fallon ranch. The broker does 20. See Real Estate
than one party, the broker must also not regularly deal with ranch or rural Division forms “Duties
provide the parties with a “Consent to properties therefore, he refers the client to Owed by a Nevada Real
Act” form and receive their permission a broker who regularly works with this Estate Licensee” and
before proceeding with the representation. type of property. The first broker is not “Consent to Act”.
The appropriate agency disclosure required to provide the rancher with a
form (Duties Owed or Consent to Act if Duties Owed form. 21. NRS 645.252(3).
applicable) must be used in all real estate
agency relationships regardless of the type a. Duties Owed By A Nevada Real 22. Real Estate Division
of representation, i.e., single, more than Estate Licensee form – The Duties Owed Position Statement,
one party, and assigned; or the type of real By A Nevada Real Estate Licensee form Joan Buchanan,
estate transaction, e.g., purchase, property (Duties Owed) is divided into three main Administrator,
management. The Duties Owed form sections and several subsections. The first March 10, 1999.
must also be given when a licensee is a section is a box for the identification of
principal in a transaction.17 the licensee, his or her license number, 23. The Duties Owed
the client’s name, the broker’s and form may be found at:
The forms are prepared and distributed brokerage’s names, and finally, the name http://www.red.state.
by the Real Estate Division and reflect of client who the licensee is representing, nv.us/Forms/525.pdf
not only the requirements of statute (NRS e.g., seller, buyer, landlord, or tenant.23
645.252(1)) but also of the real estate
administrative code (NAC 645.637).18 The second section is a paraphrase of the
Each form must be fully filled-in, signed statutes outlining the licensee’s duties to all
and kept in the broker’s transaction file parties in the transaction and those duties
for five years.19 specific to the licensee’s representation of the
client. There is a single sentence reference
It is important to note that an agency to a licensee’s duty of confidentiality under
relationship is not created because a assigned agency and a notice of the activities
party signs either a Duties Owed or which require the licensee to provide the
Consent to Act form. These forms are client with the Consent to Act form.
strictly disclosure documents. Each
form specifically states that it does not The third section is where the client
constitute a contract for services nor signs acknowledging receipt of a copy
an agreement to pay compensation.20 of the form. The client, in signing the
Accordingly, it is irrelevant whether a acknowledgement, also attests that he
brokerage agreement is oral or written, or she has read and understands the
or whether a licensee is acting on his disclosure.
or her own behalf, a Duties Owed form
or Consent to Act form, must be given
to and signed by the licensee’s client.
Additionally, if a party is unrepresented
the broker must keep that party’s signed
form with their client’s transaction file.21
The broker argued there was no agency To this end, the Real Estate Division has
relationship with the Osterhuses as the created a form authorizing a buyer's
broker only represented the developer. broker to negotiate directly with a seller.34
Without agency, there was no duty to the The type of communication authorized
Osterhuses to ensure they received their title. by the RED form is limited to the
The court rejected this argument and said, delivery, communication, or facilitation
of an offer, counteroffer, or proposal;
“[A]fter reviewing the record, we discussion and review of the terms of an
conclude that the interrelated offer, counteroffer, or proposal; and the
transactions of the parties, along preparation of any responses as directed.
with the representations and advice
given by [the agent], constituted Even with a signed “Authorization” form,
substantial evidence to support if the buyer's broker starts performing
the conclusion that the [brokerage] agency duties for the seller outside those
impliedly agreed to act as the authorized by statute, the broker may
[couple’s] agent in their purchase of be held liable for creating an “implied
the Northwood Estates lot and home.” agency”. When the "Authorization" form
is used, the buyer's broker still retains
Furthermore, the court held the agent all the agency duties and responsibilities
negligent in that representation when to his or her client, the buyer. This
he failed to ensure proper title was authorization is not a “Consent to Act”
given. The Osterhuses were awarded form substitute.
approximately $58,000.
I-9
nevada law on real estate agency I - 10
I - 11
35. For example,
the federal law of
RESPA, the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures
Act, 12 U.S.C. 2601.
“U.S.C.” stands for the
United States Code.
I - 13
42. NRS 645.259(1).
C . T hings F or W hich A
L icensee is N ot L iable
1. Client’s Misstatement
A licensee may not be held liable for This protection has its limitations. The
the misrepresentations made by his court in the same case said it was making
client unless the licensee knew of the its findings on the limited arguments
misrepresentation and failed to inform the presented in the appeal. It went on to
person to whom the misrepresentation state that the buyer failed to argue that
was made.42 In Prigge v. South Seventh the broker “knew or should have known
Realty (1981), a purchaser sued both the true facts through the exercise of
the seller and the listing broker for reasonable care”. If the buyer had argued
misrepresentation as to how the property this level of diligence, the outcome of the
was constructed. The purchaser declared case could have been different.
that both the seller and the broker
misrepresented the property as being The “knew or should have known”
a frame and stucco house when in fact criteria is found as an affirmative
it was not. The broker argued that he prescription in NRS 645.252(1) which
had taken the word of the seller and states a licensee shall disclose any
should not be held liable for the seller’s material and relevant facts, data or
misrepresentations. The court relying on
established agency principles found for
the broker and refused to find him liable.
The court quoted a learned treatise in
finding
I - 15
accuracy of a material fact or an inspection 51. Ewing v. Bissell, 105
report, to tell the client of that doubt and Additionally, the licensee is not required Nev. 488 (1989).
urge the client to verify the inspection. In to become a property inspector by
Ewing v. Bissell (1989), Jaeger, a real estate conducting the investigation of the 52. NRS 645.252(4).
licensee acting as a dual agent, sold the condition of the property which is the
Ewing’s a parcel of land in Las Vegas which subject of the real estate transaction.53 53. NRS 645.252(4)(c).
reportedly contained 1.34 acres.51 The plat However, this clause should not be used
map identified the parcel as having 1.34 by the licensee in an attempt to remove 54. NRS 645.252(1).
acres and the purchase agreement stated from the licensee his or her responsibility
there were approximately 1.34 acres. Jaeger to disclose “material and relevant facts,
testified he “inspected the property and data or information which the licensee
thought there might be a question as to the knows, or by the exercise of reasonable care
total acreage of the lot; however, he could and diligence… should have known relating
not determine the actual size of the lot by to the property.” (emphasis added).54
viewing it.” Also, he “knew that a better legal The licensee is always charged with
description of the property was needed.” reasonable care and diligence. It is not
Jaeger told the sellers, but not the buyers, reasonable that a licensee ignore patent or
they could get a survey of the property. observable problems or questions about
Additionally, the buyer had informed Jaeger the property’s condition because he or she
acreage was important to him as he wanted “owes no duty to investigate.” The level
to place two homes on the property and of investigation stated here is the level
the zoning law required .50 acres per home. expected of a professional in a particular
Acreage was therefore a material fact for the field such as a licensed property inspector.
buyers. The licensee owes no duty to reach that
level of investigation.
After the close of escrow, the Clark
County Assessor informed the buyers
they had received only .83 acres. The
buyers sued the sellers, brokerage and
agent for the difference between what
they received and what they thought they
were purchasing. The court found for the
buyers allowing them an abatement of the
purchase price by reducing the price by
the percentage of acreage the buyers did
not receive. The court reviewed Jaeger’s
testimony as to his concern about the
size of the lot and held him liable. It
said Jaeger was the individual in the best
position to ensure the size of the lot was
ascertained before escrow closed and
Jaeger was under the duty to disclose
material facts that may affect the buyer’s
decision to purchase.
56. NRS 645.254(3)(c). A licensee owes no duty to conduct an The caveat on this limitation of liability is
independent investigation of the financial that the licensee can waive this protection
57. Charles v. Lemons condition of a party to the real estate by his or her statements or actions. If
& Assoc. et al., 104 Nev. transaction.55 Nevertheless, a licensee is a licensee presumes to investigate a
388 (1988). still responsible for disclosing to his or principal’s financial condition, gives
her client all material facts of which the specific credit or financial advice or
licensee has knowledge concerning the guidance, reviews a party’s credit report,
transaction.56 For example, if a licensee or designs an alternative financing plan
representing a buyer has knowledge for the parties, the licensee may have
of the seller being in bankruptcy, it is waived any protection this statute could
incumbent upon the licensee to disclose provide.
that information to the client. However,
the licensee has no duty to personally In Charles v. Lemons & Associates, (1988)
examine the financial condition of a party. the sellers, Mr. & Mrs. Charles, sued
their brokerage and agent, Century
Nor does the licensee have a duty to Realty and Larry Geisendorf, for
review a principal’s credit history. This misrepresentation and failure to disclose
may specifically come into play if the material information.57 Geisendorf
client participates in alternative forms negotiated the sale of the Charles’ home
of financing such as the seller carrying with some buyers wherein the buyers
back some of the purchase price. A seller would assume the existing first mortgage,
“carries back” when he or she acts as a obtain a second in the buyers’ names,
lender to the purchaser by “carrying” and have the sellers carry back a third
some of the purchase price in the form deed of trust. The Charles claimed
of a promissory note which is usually Geisendorf told them the buyers were
secured by a deed of trust on the property. financially capable of purchasing the
property and that they were qualified
to make payments on the loans. What
Geisendorf failed to tell his clients was
that the buyers had a combined income of
only $2,400 per month, that they expected
to use the income from a speculative
gold investment to meet their financial
obligations, and that the buyer’s second
mortgage had an APR of 30.85%.
I - 17
5. Providing Other 58. NRS 645.254(3)(d).
“Professional” Services
59. Epperson v. Roloff,
A licensee is not required to perform Other services a licensee may be asked 102 Nev. 206 (1986).
services or give advice if the service or to provide include but are not limited
advice requires expertise outside the to, home inspection,61 tax and income 60. NRS 7.285
realm of real estate related services or for advice (accountant),62 and property (1) prohibits the
which a separate certification or license is management.63 The fact that these unauthorized practice of
required.58 Again, this protection may be activities, or some semblance of them, are law and NRS 645C.260
waived should the licensee undertake to performed daily by licensees does not in requires the licensure
provide such services or advice. and of itself transform the activities from of anyone doing
being unauthorized or illegal unless the appraisals.
A licensee who performs unauthorized licensee is duly certified or licensed in that
services may be held liable not only to the profession. A licensee must be especially 61. NRS 645D.900.
client, but to the various licensing entities conscientious when asked to do any of the
and to any third-party who acts on the above activities and always refer the client 62. NRS 628.540.
licensee’s representations and is damaged. to the appropriate professional.64
In Epperson v. Roloff. Epperson, a buyer, 63. NRS 645.6054.
sued the Roloffs who were the sellers, and To that end, a licensee must be aware of
Alexander, the sellers’ agent, for fraud and the pitfall of relying on a client’s request 64. NRS 645.254 (3)(d).
breach of contract. The sellers told their or permission to perform unauthorized
agent the property had “a solar storage area activities. No client can authorize a 65. Pioneer Title
for auxiliary heating”. Alexander, without licensee to perform services for which Insurance & Trust Co.,
ensuring a solar heating system existed, a certification or license is required and v. State Bar of Nevada,
told the buyers and their agent that “solar a licensee cannot escape liability just 74 Nev. 186, 192 (1958).
really saves on your gas bill” and proceeded because the client requested such service
to make other statements of fact about the or advice. The Nevada Supreme Court has 66. NRS 645.254 (3)(d)
system. Needless to say, there was no solar stated “that one may not legitimize his and see NAC 645.605
heating system. When the buyers sued, the otherwise unlawful practice of the law by (3).
court stated the agent could be held liable to contractually obligating himself to achieve
the third-party buyers if they justifiably relied legal effectiveness.”65 Thus, as with many
on the agent’s statements or advice.59 areas of real estate agency law, a client’s
instruction does not make an illegal act
Giving legal advice or determining the legal or place it within the scope of the
market value of a property are services licensee’s authority. Should a licensee be
a licensee is most commonly asked to requested to perform services beyond
provide.60 Because these activities are so the licensee’s expertise or authorization,
intricately woven into the fabric of a real the licensee has an affirmative duty to
estate transaction the licensee can easily advise the client the matter is beyond his
slip into giving answers and thus providing or her expertise and suggest the advice or
unauthorized services. If a licensee does so, service be obtained from an appropriate
he or she not only violates NRS 645, but also certified or licensed professional.
the statutes regulating those professions. Otherwise, a licensee will be subject to
Commission discipline if found guilty
of attempting to provide specialized
professional services or advice that are
outside the licensee’s licensed authority.66
D . T ermination of A genc y
Nevada has no specific statute that 1. End of Transaction or
provides which event or action terminates Contract Date
agency. Agency can end in various ways,
such as: Most special agency relationships, such
as real estate agency, terminate when the
• when the object of the agency is object of the agency ends. In real estate,
fulfilled, or this is usually when there has been a
successful transaction and the object for
• the agency agreement terminates by which the agency was created, the sale or
contract date, or lease of real property, has been fulfilled.
• the broker and client mutually agree to Agency may also end when the brokerage
terminate the agency, or agreement has an end or termination date
and that date comes and goes without
• the agency is abandoned, or the broker’s efforts procuring a successful
transaction. Each exclusive representation
• the agency is terminated due to a brokerage agreement is required to have
party’s breach, or in writing a specified and complete
termination date.68 That date is generally
• it ends because of the death of either read as ending the agency. A licensee
the broker or the client. should be aware that the licensee’s
statements or actions may extend the
Here we must draw a distinction between agency past the termination date and
the end of the agency and the termination create an unintentional agency.
of a party’s rights under the brokerage
agreement. An agency relationship may
end but each party may continue to
have certain rights stemming from that
relationship. Some of those rights, such
as the licensee’s duty of confidentiality,
are statutorily identified as extending
past the revocation or termination of
the brokerage agreement - in the case
of confidentiality it is one year.67 Other
rights include the broker’s right to
compensation. The broker may have
a right to collect compensation even if
the agency has ended and the broker is
no longer providing real estate related
services to the client.
I - 19
69. Kaldi v. Farmers Ins.
2. Mutual Agreement 3. Abandonment or Involuntary
Exch., 117 Nev. 273, 279
Termination – client or broker
(2001).
Unless there is an agreement to the
contrary, a brokerage agreement may be Another, more difficult type of
70. Reese v. Utter, 92
terminated by either party.69 Depending termination is when the agency is
Nev. 377, 380 (1976).
on the circumstances, this end of agency abandoned or involuntarily terminated
may be conditional or unconditional. An (being fired) by either the client or the
unconditional release is when both the broker.
broker and the client mutually agree to
end the agency. At this point the broker Abandonment occurs when one party
and client walk away from their agency ceases to continue with the relationship.
relationship without any obligation to It may happen suddenly or through
the other. A conditional release is when lack of contact over a period of time.
the broker agrees to stop representing the There is no set time frame in which lack
client but holds the client to the client’s of communication between the broker
obligations, such as the payment of and client creates abandonment. The
compensation. courts look at whether a reasonable
period of time has elapsed. What makes
a “reasonable” period of time is fact
specific. In one case, Reese v. Utter
(1976), the broker, Utter, had an exclusive
listing with Reese. During the listing
period Utter submitted an offer which
Reese rejected. After the rejection Utter
abandoned all efforts at negotiating the
sale of the property. A year after the
listing expired, Reese sold the property
to the original offeror on substantially
different terms and without the assistance
or participation of Utter. Utter then
sued Reese for his commission. The
court found Utter was not entitled to a
commission as he had abandoned his
efforts to sell the property and there was
no hint of fraud or bad faith on the part of
the seller.70
A client may abandon a broker. In
Bartsas Realty v. Leverton (1966), Mary
Bartsas, a broker, responded to an open
listing agreement from an institutional
seller, First National Bank of Nevada,
to find a buyer for an estate of which
First National was the executor. Mrs.
Bartsas submitted an offer from Davidson,
president of a construction company.
Without communicating with Bartsas,
Davidson then contacted broker Leverton
and resubmitted a similar offer through
him. When First National told Leverton
of the first offer (which had not yet been
I - 21
E . R eview
The basis of all real estate brokerage when such representation is disclosed to,
representation is founded upon agency and approved of, by the parties. To that
law. This law encompasses the duties end, Nevada requires each licensee to
and responsibilities of the broker (and provide a written agency disclosure form
by extension all licensees under him or called the Duties Owed by a Nevada Real
her). In Nevada, the broker’s duties and Estate Licensee, and if there is multiple
responsibilities are codified – turned representation, the licensee is required to
into statute and made a part of the NRS have the clients complete the Consent to
or NAC. Case law explains by example Act form. The law limits the licensee’s
how those statutory duties (and their liability in certain situations with caveats
common law antecedents) are applied by and exceptions to such liability waiver.
the courts. Most agency occurs with the Finally, the broker’s agency relationship
representation by a broker of one party may be terminated in various ways from
to a real estate transaction. Nevertheless, fulfilling the terms of the brokerage
Nevada law allows the broker to represent contract to the death of the client or
multiple parties with conflicting interests broker.
C. Duty of Honesty.................................................................................................................................................................................................9
1. No Deceit, Fraud or Dishonesty.................................................................................................................................... 9
2. Silence as Deceit...............................................................................................................................................................10
F. Supplementary Services.............................................................................................................................................................................. 17
1. Beyond the Licensee’s Expertise.................................................................................................................................17
2. Beyond the Licensee’s Authority................................................................................................................................17
G. Review....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 20
1. NRS 1.030.
2. NRS 645.251.
The laws and regulations that govern the licensee and the real estate transaction
come from various sources. The main three sources are statute, regulation, and
common law. Besides state law, the licensee is governed by applicable federal
statutes and regulations. The focus here is on state law and regulation as they are
modified by applicable case law.
A. EVOLUTION OF THE
COMMON LAW TO STATUTORY DUTIES
Federal statutes are found
in the United States
Code (U.S.C.). Federal
regulations are in the The common law has its origins in these duties (NRS 645.252, 645.253, and NRS
Code of Federal previous judicial decisions. The United 645.254) the common law was expressly
Regulations (C.F.R.). States derives its common law from rejected.2 Even so, judicial decisions and
England. When deciding a case, a traditional common law terms direct how
Common, or case law, is judge looks at how similar cases were statutes or regulations are interpreted.
law identified through previously decided. This helps the
judicial decisions in
judge and the legal system to maintain Common Law Terms: The rules of agency
lawsuit cases.
consistency. evolved from the common law. Agency
law defines the duties and responsibilities
Over the years a body of law was compiled a real estate licensee has to the client.
from these cases addressing common topics However, the legislators, when writing the
such as contracts, agency, and real property. statutes, often used traditional common law
Nevada has adopted this English common terms but did not define them. Without an
law. 1 It covers any legal issue not addressed understanding of what those common law
by statute or regulation. Statutes or terms mean, the licensee will not know what
regulations control unless otherwise stated. must be done or avoided. For example, a
In 1995, many of the licensee's common licensee must have absolute fidelity to the
law duties were put into statute and for client’s interest. (NAC 645.605(6)) What is
II - 3
absolute fidelity? The licensee must look at 3. Lemon v. Landers, 81
case law to understand the parameters of Nev. 329, 332 , 462 P.2d
648 (1965).
absolute fidelity.
4. Lowe v. State Dep’t
Common Law Agency: Under common of Commerce, 89 Nev.
law, a broker’s main duty is to ensure the 488, 494, 515 P. 2d 388
(1973), see also Jory v.
client’s business and interests are carried
Bennight, 91 Nev. 763,
out to the client’s best advantage.3 This is 542 P.2d 1400, 1404,
the broker’s fiduciary duty. It includes: (1975).
2. Honesty;
6. Lemon v. Landers, 81
Nev. 329, 332, 462 P.2d
648 (1965). B. CLIENT BEFORE SELF–
ABSOLUTE FIDELIT Y
7 & 8. Holland Realty v.
NV Real Estate Comm.,
84 Nev. 91, 98, 436 P.2d
422 (1968).
9. NRS 645.252 (1)(b) A licensee has the duty of absolute fidelity [a] broker when pursuing his own
& (c); NRS 645.633 (1) to the client’s interests.5 Absolute fidelity interest cannot ignore those of his
(g); NAC 645.605 (4); means a licensee must put the client’s principal and will not be permitted
NAC 645.610 (1)(b)(1-2); interests ahead of the licensee’s interest. to enjoy the fruits of an advantage
NAC 645.637 and NAC A licensee “will not be permitted to taken of a fiduciary relationship,
645.640. pervert his authority to his own personal whose dominant characteristic is
gain in severe hostility to the interest of the confidence reposed by one in
10. NRS 645.280. his principal.”6 another.’8
For example, absolute fidelity is breached There are two prongs to the duty of
when a licensee withholds an offer absolute fidelity. First, the duty to disclose
from the client in order to purchase the the licensee’s interest and, secondly, the
property himself. In Holland Realty v. prohibition against taking advantage of
Nevada Real Estate Commission (1968)7 any situation, even if disclosed, that would
Grant Holland, a Las Vegas broker, sued harm the client’s interests.
the Real Estate Division when it revoked
his license. The Real Estate Commission 1. DISCLOSURE OF LICENSEE’S
had found him guilty of violating NRS INTEREST
645 for misrepresentation, making false
promises to induce performance, and A licensee must disclose in writing to
receiving a secret and undisclosed profit. the parties whenever the licensee has a
personal interest in either the transaction
Holland had double escrowed a property or the property. Such disclosure ensures
without disclosure to either party and everyone is aware of the licensee’s
kept the profit. In that transaction, he potential conflicting loyalties.9
misrepresented who was taking title, his
agency status, and who were the real The licensee should be aware that some
parties. He then sold the property a third laws prohibit certain acts even if the
time as an undisclosed buyer’s agent licensee’s interest is disclosed. As an
while acting as the seller’s agent under a example, a salesperson may not receive
net listing agreement. He did not disclose compensation from anyone other than
to the seller the property’s true sale price. his or her broker: taking such payment is
Again, he kept the difference. illegal whether or not it is disclosed.10
After the Commission revoked his license, a. Interest in the Transaction – Any
Holland sued the Division. The court time the licensee has an interest in the
upheld the Division’s discipline and transaction, that interest must be disclosed
found Holland’s behavior breached his in writing. An “interest in the transaction”
basic fiduciary duty of absolute fidelity to occurs when:
his clients. The court stated:
II - 5
1. The licensee receives, or expects to Relationship with a Principal: The 11. NAC 645.605 (4)(e).
receive, compensation from more than licensee must disclose whenever he or
12. NRS 645.252 (1)(b).
one party;11 she has a personal relationship with a
principal to the transaction.18 A licensee 13. NAC 645.605 (4).
2. Is a party in the transaction, or (including permitted property managers)
14. Judy Bendure,
must disclose the licensee’s affiliation
“Preferred Vendor
3. Has a personal relationship with one of with, or financial interest in, any person or Lists,” Real Estate
the principals. entity that furnishes maintenance or other Division Open House,
services related to the property.19 vol. 25, issue 1, Winter
2000, at p. 4. The Open
Compensation: The licensee is under an House is the Real Estate
affirmative duty to disclose to each party RESPA: RESPA (Real Estate Settlement Division’s information
to the real estate transaction each “source” Procedures Act) prohibits referrals from bulletin.
from which the licensee will receive one business to another business when
15. NRS 645.633 (1)(g).
compensation.12 The statute does not owned by the same company unless there
require the licensee to disclose the amount is full disclosure. These are affiliated 16. NRS 645.252 (1)(c);
of the compensation, only its source - the business arrangements.20 If a licensee has NAC 645.637.
identity of the person or company giving an ownership interest in a business and 17 & 18. NAC 645.640
the compensation.13 refers clients to that business, the licensee (1).
must disclose that ownership interest.
19. NAC 645.605 (4)(b).
Compensation includes referral fees and
other payment such as fees received from b. Interest in the Property – A licensee, 20. 12 U.S.C. § 2607.
vendors to be on a broker’s list of service whether acting as an agent or a principal,
21. NRS 645.252 (1)(c)
providers. Even though the broker may has an “interest in the property” whenever
and NAC 645.640.
give a service provider list to a client the licensee has, or anticipates, an
without charge, the broker must disclose ownership interest.21 Failure to disclose 22. NAC 645.605 (4).
if a vendor paid to be on that list.14 the licensee’s interest is an element in the
23. Alley v. NV Real
Real Estate Commission’s determination Estate Div., 94 Nev. 123,
Compensation includes money the broker of whether the licensee was deceitful or 125, 575 P.2d 1334 (1978).
may accept, give or charge as a rebate or dishonest.22
24. Tahoe Village Realty
direct profit on expenditures made for the
v. DeSmit, 95 Nev. 131,
client.15 For example, a buyer asked the Any anticipated interest must be disclosed 134, 590 P.2d 1158 (1979).
broker to have a new air conditioning unit even if it is only a pass-through interest.
installed. The buyer paid for the unit in For example, a licensee must disclose
escrow. The air conditioning manufacturer when the licensee takes title, however
offered a $200 rebate. The broker, when briefly, during a “double escrow.”23
he purchased the unit, applied for and Engaging in an undisclosed double
kept the rebate without disclosing it to his escrow transaction is a breach of the
buyer. This is a violation of the broker’s licensee’s absolute fidelity to the client. The Real Estate Settlement
absolute fidelity to the client. The Nevada Supreme Court has found it Procedures Act (RESPA),
federal law, prohibits a
illegal when, licensee from receiving
Party to the Transaction: When a licensee or giving kickbacks and
is acting as a principal, it is a material fact [t]he broker or salesman purchases unearned fees even if
such kickbacks or fees are
and must be disclosed.16 This ensures all a principal’s property in the first disclosed. (RESPA, 12
parties to the transaction are fully aware escrow, and sells it to a third party U.S.C. § 2607).
of where the licensee’s loyalties may lie. at a profit in a second escrow
The relationships that must be
Moreover, the licensee may not acquire without a full disclosure to both
disclosed are when a principal
(purchase), lease or dispose of (sell), the principal and the third party. is a member of the licensee’s
any time-share or real property without The broker or salesman receives a immediate family, or a member
revealing the licensee’s licensed status.17 commission on the sale in the first of the licensee’s firm, or an
entity (such as a corporation)
escrow and a secret profit on the in which the licensee has an
closing in the second escrow. 24 ownership interest.
II - 7
In Nevada, it is not material if the Required Disclosure: When may a 36. NRS 645.254 (2).
property was the site of a homicide, licensee disclose confidential information?
suicide or death. The exception is if the The law provides protection for disclosure 37. NRS 645.253.
property caused the death, for example, of confidential information under any
someone was electrocuted by the home’s one of four circumstances: first, when a
bad wiring. court of competent jurisdiction orders
disclosure; second, when the client
It is not material if the property was authorizes disclosure;36 third, when
occupied by a person with AIDS or any the licensee discloses information to
other disease not transmitted through the broker;37 and fourth, when the
occupancy of the property. information is required to be disclosed by
law. The courts will not allow the licensee
With one exception, it is not material if to hide behind a client’s instruction to
the property was the site of a felony. The keep information confidential that the
exception is if the property was used to licensee is obligated by law to disclose.
manufacture methamphetamine and the
property was not rehabilitated. The right of confidentiality is held by
the client, not the licensee. That means
It is not material if the property is located it is the client’s decision on whether AIDS stands for acquired
near a licensed facility under NRS confidential information may be disclosed. immune deficiency
syndrome, a deadly disease
449.0055, transitional living for released If there is any question whether a fact
caused by infection and
offenders. (This does not include a or information is confidential, the transmitted through blood or
halfway house for recovering alcohol and licensee must clear it with the client bodily secretions.
drug abusers.) before disclosure.
Methamphetamine (meth)
is an illegal street drug.
Finally, by law it is not material if a sex During the making of meth
offender lives, or is expected to live, in toxic fumes seep into the
walls, floors, sinks and
the community. This information does not counters. General cleaning
need to be disclosed unless the broker and or painting does not remove
a buyer have agreed otherwise. the residue. The property
must be “rehabilitated”
(made habitable again). Only
The licensee may not be held liable to the the government (for example,
other party for non-disclosure of any of a health department) or a
the above items. However, a buyer-client certified entity can legally
rehabilitate a meth property
and licensee may agree the licensee will NRS 40.770(6).
disclose the information if the licensee
knows the answer. Any such agreement NRS 179D.400 defines a
“Sex Offender” as a person
should be in writing and cleared with the who is: (a) Convicted of
broker. a sexual offense listed in
NRS 179D.410; or (b)
Found guilty by a court of a
No Misinformation: A licensee is not
sexual offense, such as: (1)
allowed to lie or give misinformation. A sexually violent predator,
If asked a direct question regarding a or (2) A nonresident sex
confidential matter, the licensee should offender who is a student or
worker within this state.
state the information is confidential and
refuse to answer. The client may authorize NRS 209.081 “Offender”
the licensee to direct the individual to a means any person
convicted of a crime under
reliable source. the laws of this state and
sentenced to imprisonment
in the state prison.
II - 9
Discipline: The Real Estate Commission Nevada’s Supreme Court has said a 50. NRS 645.990 (1)(b).
may discipline any licensee convicted licensee’s willful silence in the face of a
51. Northern NV
of any crime involving fraud, deceit, client’s expressed misunderstanding is
Mobile Home Brokers
misrepresentation or moral turpitude. “more deceit than any other category v. Penrod, 96 Nev. 394,
It may discipline whether or not the that the court can find... .”54 A party 398, 610 Nev. 724 (1980).
licensee pled nolo contendere (no contest) may have a mistaken belief about the
52. NRS 645.252 (1).
or guilty. The Division may file criminal property, elements of the transaction, or
charges against any person, licensee or be ignorant of a material aspect or defect. 53. NRS 645.254 (3)(c).
not, who sells real property by intentional If the licensee knows of the mistaken
54. Holland Realty v.
misrepresentation, deceit or fraud.50 impression, the licensee has the duty NV Real Estate Comm.,
to correct the misunderstanding. If the 84 Nev. 91, 97, 436 P.2d
2. SILENCE AS DECEIT licensee remains silent, this is deceit as 422 (1968).
much as an affirmative lie.
A corollary to the duty to be honest is the
duty to speak the whole truth and not be If a fact is required to be disclosed by
misleading by silence.51 Generally, mere the licensee, no instruction from a client
silence is not a misrepresentation unless can absolve the licensee from liability for
there is a duty to speak. Licensees have willfully withholding the information.
such a duty. Nevada’s agency laws impose
upon the licensee the duty to disclose to
each party all known material facts about
the property.52 Additionally, the licensee
must disclose to the client all known facts
about the transaction.53
II - 11
the buyers, unhappy with the property Strict Liability: Under certain 65. NRS 645.633 (1)(b).
condition, terminate the escrow. The circumstances the law may impose
66. Arnesano v. State,
sellers have lost the sale. In this scenario liability strictly for violating a statute
Dep’t Trans., 113 Nev.
the listing agent breached his duty to or regulation without anyone being 815, 821, 942 P.2d 139
the sellers when he disclosed the sellers’ harmed.67 For example, failing to put a (1997).
confidential information; however, the definite termination date on an exclusive
67. NRS 645.630, 645.633
sellers’ loss was not a result of the agent’s brokerage agreement eliminates the and 645.635.
breach. There is no causal link between broker’s right to collect a commission
the licensee’s breach and the sellers’ harm. regardless of whether the client was 68. Bangle v. Holland
Realty Inv. Co., 80 Nev.
The agent’s negligent act of disclosing the harmed.68 331, 393 P.2d 138 (1964).
divorce was not the cause of the buyers
rejecting the property. “Gross negligence” is negligent 69. Hart v. Kline, 61
Nev. 96, 116 P.2d 672
behavior with a reckless disregard for
(1941). See also
Nevertheless, this does not mean the the consequences of one’s actions. It
NAC 645.605
sellers are without recourse for the agent’s requires the licensee to have understood
breach. The sellers may file a complaint and ignored the potential harm.69 The
with the Division and the licensee may be statutes generally impose regulatory
subject to regulatory discipline.65 liability on the licensee for the licensee’s
gross negligence.
Finally, there must be damages or harm.
Harm occurs when the licensee breaches NAC 645.605 lists a series of actions that
a duty and that breach causes an injury, if not followed, the Commission may
loss or detriment to the client. Often, a consider the lack of doing those things,
client’s loss may be remedied by money gross negligence.
(damages).66 There are various legal
restrictions on the amount and type
of damages a person may claim under
negligence. At no time should a licensee
discuss negligence damages with a client.
II - 13
the property. For example, in Epperson The real estate licensee has a duty to 77. Epperson v. Roloff,
v. Roloff, (1986),77 the listing agent was investigate whether or not a unit has a 102 Nev. 206, 719 P.2d
799 (1986).
told by the seller the home had a “solar fireplace or wood burning stove and then
implication.” The agent did not ask the to provide the seller with the required 78. Washoe County,
client to explain what a solar implication disclosure form.79 However, the licensee District Board of
Health Regulation
might be. Nevertheless, he told potential would not be required to determine if an
Governing Air Quality
buyers the house had a solar feature existing wood stove was in compliance Management, Section
which really saves on winter heating with Code. (That type of inspection 040.051§A(2)(b).
costs. The feature turned out to be a hole requires a county certificate.)
79. NRS 645.252 (4)(b).
in the roof covered with corrugated sheet
metal painted black. The buyers sued the Contracted Investigation: Finally, the 80. Holland Realty v.
broker and sellers for misrepresentation. broker may, by contract, assume a duty NV Real Estate Comm.,
84 Nev. 91, 98, 436 P.2d
The listing agent had a duty to the buyers to investigate and disclose facts that
422 (1968).
to disclose all relevant facts about the are beyond those required by law. For
property. He breached that duty by not example, the broker and client may agree
investigating and disclosing what the that the broker will investigate whether
“solar feature” really was. the property can be zoned for a particular
future use. At all times the broker must be
The level of investigation imposed by careful not to provide services requiring a
the law does not require the licensee to license, permit or certification which the
become a “property inspector,” broker does not have.
NRS 645.252(4)(c) but it does require
reasonable and common sense inquiry Remember, the purpose of the duty to
into the physical condition of the property. investigate is to find and disclose
material and relevant facts about the
Volunteered Information: When property so that a principal may make
the licensee has volunteered specific an informed decision.
information or claims an expertise in a
certain topic, the licensee will be held b. What Must Be Investigated – When
responsible for its reasonable accuracy. a fact relates to the property, the licensee
This does not mean the licensee is required to investigate if it is “material
guarantees the information; however, and relevant.” The Nevada Supreme
Professional property
the licensee must take reasonable steps Court, quoting the Restatement of Agency inspectors are licensed by
to insure the information is up-to-date §390, stated, the state and regulated by
and sufficiently correct. For example, the Real Estate Division
under NRS 645D.
a property fronts an extensive tract of A fact is material… if it is one which
undeveloped land. If the licensee states the agent should realize would be
the land is controlled by the Bureau likely to affect the judgment of the
of Land Management and won’t be principal …which he should realize
developed, that volunteered statement [is] likely to have a bearing upon the
must be accurate and current. Before the desirability of the transaction…80
licensee volunteers facts, he or she has a
duty to investigate the truthfulness of any Anything impacting the physical
statement. condition of the property is material
and relevant. Anything that affects
Disclosure Required by Law: A licensee the property’s value or use is material
has a duty to investigate property facts and relevant.
that may require certain disclosures
obligatory by law. For example, Washoe
County, Nevada, has a Solid-Fuel Burning
Device (wood stove) regulation.78
II - 15
A licensee may reasonably rely on time and effort necessary to gather the 92. Collins v. Burns, 103
financial information provided by the required paperwork and review it for “red Nev. 394, 741 P.2d 819
(1987).
client. In Collins v. Burns (1987),92 Golanty lights”. It means looking at the property
was the listing agent of a small liquor and comparing it with the seller’s 93. NRS 645.252 (1)(a).
store owned by Burns. He prepared a statements to ensure the property is what
sales-and-expense fact sheet and a profit is represented. During this review, the
chart using financial figures provided by licensee is looking for something out of
his client. Relying on the chart and the the ordinary that either contradicts what
licensee’s fact sheet, Collins purchased has been stated, differs from what the
the store. She later defaulted on the note licensee knows, or is otherwise amiss.
and Burns sued for the unpaid principal.
Collins countersued and claimed she was This reasonable level of investigation
defrauded as the information on the fact does not mean a licensee should interpret
sheet and chart were grossly inaccurate. documents, determine their legal
The court found for Collins. Although consequences, or act as an appraiser,
Golanty drafted the chart and fact sheet, property inspector, loan officer, lawyer,
he was not a party to the Supreme Court or private investigator. As discussed
case. He had reasonably relied on the elsewhere, the licensee should not attempt
information provided by his client and to perform any service not specific to the
there was nothing in that information that real estate transaction.
would have alerted Golanty to his client’s
misrepresentation. The duty to investigate does require the
licensee to have sufficient knowledge to
4. LEVEL OF INVESTIGATION identify any warning signs and to point “Statement” refers not just
out these warning signs to the client. to what is said, but to all
A licensee is not required to conduct Once a concern is identified, the licensee the various representations
of the seller such as the
an investigation of the condition of the should suggest the client obtain further multiple listing service
property which is the subject of the real professional services. property profile print-out,
estate transaction. (NRS 645.252(4)(c)) This the Seller’s Real Property
Disclosure Form, and
statute relieves the licensee of the duty
relevant advertising.
to act as a property inspector. Property
inspectors are licensed individuals and are
experts in their field. Under this statute,
a licensee is not required to perform acts
that should be done by licensed property
inspectors. However, this does not relieve
the licensee from his or her duty to
exercise reasonable care and diligence. If
a question arises as to the condition of the
property, the licensee must address that
issue by referring the client to a qualified
expert. A licensee will not escape liability
for not exercising reasonable care and
diligence by using the argument that he or
she has no duty to investigate.
F. S U P P L E M E N TA R Y S E R V I C E S
1. BEYOND THE LICENSEE’S EXPERTISE 2. BEYOND THE LICENSEE’S
AUTHORITY
If a licensee is asked by a client to perform
services outside the licensee’s expertise, A licensee may be disciplined for
the client must be told the matter is providing specialized professional
beyond the licensee’s current proficiency services outside the licensee’s authority.95
and advise the client to obtain guidance It does not matter if the advice is accurate
from an expert.94 or the service well done. Liability lies
in doing the thing, not in its result.
This does not mean the licensee cannot “Matters beyond the expertise of the
expand into new areas. It does mean if licensee” include, but are not limited to,
the licensee is unfamiliar with a property activities that requires a license, permit or
type or service, the licensee is required to professional certification. If the licensee
disclose that fact to the client and obtain does not have such a license, permit or
the assistance of a qualified authority certification, the activity is automatically
before proceeding. beyond the licensee’s authority.
II - 17
A licensee must be aware of the boundary Unauthorized Practice of Law: The 96. Goldstein v. Hanna,
between authorized real estate services unauthorized practice of law is strictly 97 Nev. 559, 635 P.2d 290
(1981), Justices Mowbray
and unauthorized services. Often a prohibited in Nevada.98 It is monitored
and Manoukian
licensee is requested by a client to advise by the State Bar of Nevada under the dissenting.
or act on a matter for which the licensee control of the Nevada Supreme Court.99
97. Real Estate
is not authorized. Sometimes however, Unfortunately, there is no statute or
Commission
the licensee, willingly and without regulation which defines what activities Disciplinary Fine Report,
instruction, crosses this boundary. constitute the practice of law. 1/95 through 9/30/04.
Through case law, the courts have
98. NRS 7.285 (1).
In Goldstein v. Hanna (1981),96 Callahan provided a list of some activities that
was the listing agent for a condominium are considered “practicing law.” These 99. NRS 7.725.
owned by Hanna. Goldstein and Hanna include discussing with a client the
100. Pioneer Title
signed a lease with option to purchase to legal effect of an act; interpreting legal
Insurance & Trust Co.,
close by December 9, “unless exercised provisions in a document; discussing the v. State Bar of Nevada,
prior thereto.” During the lease period, rights or responsibilities of the parties; 74 Nev. 186, 326 P.2d 408
Goldstein exercised the option and signed selecting and providing pre-printed legal (1958).
a purchase agreement with another buyer documents; or determining the legal 101. NRS 645.035.
using a double escrow. Both closing sufficiency of any action or document.100
dates were set for August 29. Prior to 102. NRS 645.252(3).
the closing, the ultimate buyer backed Many of the actions done daily by real 103. NRS 645.252(2).
out. Goldstein contacted Callahan estate licensees come close to those listed
who advised him the option was still above. Some of these are found in the 104. NRS 645.254(3)(d).
good until December 9. This was both very definition of a real estate broker.101
105. NRS 645C.030.
a misstatement of the law and beyond Some are required by the broker’s
Callahan’s authority. Goldstein, justifiably statutory duties.102 Other activities are 106. NRS 645C.040.
relying on Callahan’s statement, did inherent in the nature of the broker/
107. NRS 645C.260.
not close on August 29. The seller then client relationship.103 Nevertheless, the
cancelled the escrow and attempted to unauthorized practice of law is a very fine
get the property back. Goldstein sued line which the licensee must stringently
Hanna for specific performance citing his guard against stepping over. As with any
reliance on Callahan’s statement. Though question of unauthorized professional
the court’s decision was split, Hanna counsel, the licensee should suggest the
eventually lost the property. client obtain advice from an expert.104
The two areas in which a licensee is most Appraisal and the BPO: An “appraisal”
likely to provide unauthorized services is “an analysis, opinion or conclusion,
are with legal and appraisal activities.97 written or oral, relating to the nature,
An option once exercised,
Clients will ask a licensee to tell them quality, value… of, identified real estate even if before the option’s
their rights under a contract, or ask what for or with the expectation of receiving ultimate cut-off date,
their legal options are. Additionally, compensation.” 105 In Nevada, only terminates the option
and the contract becomes
clients often ask the licensee what a appraisers are authorized to prepare an a bilateral purchase
property is worth or the value of a appraisal. 106 Appraisers are licensed and agreement. Once the option
business. Because these activities are so regulated by the Real Estate Division. 107 is exercised, if the sale isn’t
completed, the option cannot
intricately woven into the fabric of a real
be resurrected.
estate transaction, the licensee can easily
slip into providing unauthorized answers Ubiquity does not remove
and services. If he or she does so, it is a illegality.
violation of not only NRS 645, but of the
statutes regulating those professions.
II - 19
G . R E view
The licensee’s duties are found in statute, The licensee must exercise reasonable
regulation, and in the common law. skill and care toward all parties in the
Most codified duties evolved from the transaction. This includes not acting
common law using common law terms in a negligent manner. Negligence is
such as “fiduciary,” “absolute fidelity,” unreasonable, but generally unintentional,
“negligence,” and “should have known.” behavior that causes harm.
Generally, these terms are not defined in
statute or regulation. The term “should have known” creates
the duty to investigate. The licensee
Absolute fidelity means putting the must reasonably investigate material
client’s interests before the licensee’s and relevant information relating to the
interest. A licensee may have an interest property and the transaction. This duty
in the property or in the transaction. This has limitations and restrictions, but those
interest must be disclosed in writing. restrictions do not allow the licensee
Sometimes, even if an interest is disclosed, to ignore obvious warning signs that
a licensee may not act on that interest if it something is amiss.
would harm the client.
Lastly, the licensee should be cautious of
A licensee must be honest and not act activities outside the licensee’s expertise
in a deceitful, fraudulent or dishonest or authority, especially legal or appraisal
manner in either the licensee’s personal or services.
professional Life. Silence, when there is a
duty to speak, is deceit.
B. Types of representation............................................................................................................................................................................. 10
1. “Open” Brokerage Agreement................................................................................................................................................... 10
2. “Exclusive” Representation Agreements................................................................................................................................ 11
a. General.........................................................................................................................................................................11
b. Specific Terms............................................................................................................................................................11
c. Buyer's Brokerage Agreement.............................................................................................................................11
d. Missing Elements = No Compensation...........................................................................................................12
3. Limited Service Contracts and Liability................................................................................................................................. 12
a. No Transactional Agency......................................................................................................................................12
b. Limited Service Contracts.....................................................................................................................................12
4. Interference with Brokerage Agreement.............................................................................................................................. 14
a. By Other Brokers......................................................................................................................................................14
b. By the Client...............................................................................................................................................................14
C. compensation..................................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
1. Only the Broker is Paid................................................................................................................................................................. 15
2. Right to Compensation................................................................................................................................................................ 15
a. When Earned and When Due..............................................................................................................................16
b. Procuring Cause.......................................................................................................................................................16
3. Source and Amount...................................................................................................................................................................... 18
a. Source and MLS........................................................................................................................................................18
b. Determining Amount.............................................................................................................................................18
c. Quantum Meruit.......................................................................................................................................................20
4. RESPA and Anti-Trust.................................................................................................................................................................... 20
a. RESPA............................................................................................................................................................................20
b. Anti-Trust.....................................................................................................................................................................20
c. Rebates to Clients....................................................................................................................................................21
5. Disclosure.......................................................................................................................................................................................... 22
E. Review....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 28
1. NRS 645.005.
2. NRS 645.035 The brokerage agreement is one of the most important contracts with which a
& NRS 645.040.
licensee must deal. It defines the relationship between the client and the broker.
3. NRS 645.660 (3)
& NAC 645.600 (4). Discussed in this chapter are the legal parameters to the creation and termination
4. NRS 645.280. of the brokerage agreement, the two types of representation found in Nevada (open
5. NRS 645.630 (1)(c) or exclusive), legal aspects to compensation, and some characteristics of specialized
& NRS 645.633 (1)(c).
brokerage agreements.
6. NRS 645.035
& NRS 645.040.
1. EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT
A broker’s legal relationship with the individual client. The broker always
client starts with an employment contract retains overall responsibility for the
called a brokerage agreement. In the brokerage relationship.3
brokerage agreement, the broker promises
to provide real estate related services for Only a broker may collect compensation
valuable consideration. Real estate related for real estate related services. No
services include the broker assisting, broker-salesperson or salesperson may
soliciting, or negotiating on behalf of accept compensation from, or pay
the client for the sale, purchase, option, compensation to, any person other than a
rental or lease of real property. The broker (or owner-developer) with whom,
consideration may be paid either by the at the time of the transaction, he or she
client or another person.1 is licensed.4 If a non-broker licensee does
accept or pay compensation to anyone
A listing contract is a seller’s brokerage other than the broker, that licensee is
agreement; a buyer’s brokerage agreement subject to a fine up to $10,000, and may
A “client” is a person is with a buyer. Specialized brokerage have conditions placed on his or her
who has entered into a
agreements such as commercial, advance license, such as suspension, revocation,
brokerage agreement with
a broker. NRS 645.009 fee, manufactured home, and listing with or denied renewal.5
option to purchase, as well as property
“Actual knowledge” management agreements, are discussed in a. Independent Contractor – Most
means the broker
personally knows of the their own sections. non-broker licensees (salesperson and
client. In larger brokerage broker-salesperson) are independent
houses, the broker may 2. BROKER REPRESENTS CLIENT contractors; nevertheless, by law they
have scores of agents
cannot enter into their own brokerage
making it difficult, if not
impossible, for the broker There are only two parties to a brokerage agreements with clients. NRS 645 restricts
to know each individual agreement, the client and the broker. a non-broker licensee from being hired
client. Though a licensed broker-salesperson or independent of a broker. For example,
salesperson may represent the brokerage,2 broker-salespersons or salespersons:
the legal relationship is between the
broker and the client regardless of 1. May not perform real estate related
whether or not the broker knows the services without being associated with
a licensed broker;6
III - 3
2. May not accept compensation from 3. FORM OF BROKERAGE AGREEMENT 7. NRS 645.280.
anyone other than the broker;7 8. NRS 645.315 (2).
Brokerage Agreements are employment 9. NRS 645.310 (2), NRS
3. May not advertise without the broker’s contracts and like other contracts, they 645.630 (1)(i) & NAC
supervision;8 and have the same formation requirements. 645.657.
There must be a “meeting of the minds”; 10. NRS 645.300,
4. May not hold a client’s funds, but must the contract must have definite terms as recognizes a non-broker
licensee may prepare
“promptly” turn over any money to the to: subject matter, parties, compensation a written brokerage
broker.9 (payment), and time of performance, agreement, and NRS
and there must be consideration. At a 645.320 (4).
The broker is the entity that represents minimum, there must be the mutual 11. NAC 645.600 (1).
the client. This is true even if the person understanding that the broker will accept 12. NAC 645.605 (6),
dealing with the client is a salesperson valuable consideration from the client or NRS 645.252, 645.254,
645.630, 645.633, 645.635.
or broker-salesperson. The broker’s a third person for the performance of real
salesperson actually represents the broker estate related services.14 13, 14, 15. NRS 645.005.
and all of the salesperson’s activities are 16. AGO 97-28
(12-31-1997).
done through, and in the name of, the Brokerage agreements may be oral or
brokerage. Thus, in a technical sense, written.15 Nevada has no mandatory 17. NRS 645.320.
when a salesperson is referred to as the brokerage agreement form. Though there 18. Morrow v. Barger,
104 Nev. 247, 250, 737
“client’s agent” the wording is incorrect - is no required form, Nevada’s Attorney
P.2d 1153 (1987).
it is the broker who is the client’s agent. General has stated the Real Estate
19. Sahara Realty Corp.
Division is within its authority to adopt v. Adelson, 89 Nev. 147,
b. Broker Liability – The broker gives regulations governing the content of 508 P.2d 1210 (1973).
the salesperson, or broker-salesperson, brokerage agreements.16 Since there is no
authority to act for the broker. For mandatory form, with a few exceptions,
example, a broker may give an agent the all of the terms of the contract depend on
authority to sign a brokerage contract, the agreement of the parties.
to negotiate compensation, and to set
the level of services or representation.10 Oral Contracts: Oral brokerage
However, at no time does this transfer of agreements are legal contracts in which a The term “independent
contractor” as applied to
authority transfer the broker’s liability. broker agrees to represent a client with the
real estate licensees is most
The broker must always supervise any intention or expectation of compensation often used as a federal
agents and is ultimately responsible for and there is no written contract. No oral tax income designation.
26 USC §3508, also see
the agents’ actions.11 brokerage agreement may be exclusive.17
(AGO) 1956-160 (1956).
But Nevada law
This does not remove the salesperson’s With an oral listing contract, the seller is provides for various
individual responsibilities. Each broker- only obligated to compensate the broker other designations (See
NRS 612.133 and NRS
salesperson or salesperson has legal duties if the broker’s services were the procuring 616A.220).
toward the client, the broker, professional cause of a successful transaction.18
peers, and the public, and may be held Regardless of the amount of time, energy
personally liable if those duties are or money a listing broker expends
breached.12 representing a client, if the broker is not
the procuring cause the client is not
c. Who Pays – For a valid brokerage obligated to pay.19
agreement, the client does not need to be
the one who pays the broker. Legally
binding agreements may occur regardless
of whether the broker’s compensation is
paid by the client, the other party’s broker,
or some agreed upon third person.13
III - 5
4. A WORD ABOUT ELECTRONIC Intend to be Bound: Before entering 24. NRS 719.220 (2).
BROKERAGE AGREEMENTS into any electronically created brokerage
25. NRS 719.240.
agreement, the licensee should be aware of
Generally, Nevada law authorizes an an issue concerning NRS 719, the statutes 26. NRS 719.100.
electronic format for any transaction or regulating electronic contracts, and NAC 27. NRS 720.060.
contract in which the parties agree to 645, the administrative code regulating
conduct their business electronically.24 real estate licensees. NRS 719 allows for
28. NAC 645.613.
By law, an electronic record satisfies any the creation of a valid contract purely
statute that requires the contract to be in electronically. NAC 645.613 requires the
writing. An electronic signature satisfies licensee to “obtain appropriate signatures
any statute requiring a signature.25 before entering into a relationship as the
agent of a client.” The regulation goes on to
There is a difference between an electronic state that “ ’appropriate signature’ means
signature and a digital signature. An the legal signature of the client.” NRS 719
electronic signature is an electronic sound, allows for a legal signature to be created
symbol or process attached to, or logically electronically.
associated with, an electronic record and
executed or adopted by a person with the The intent of the Real Estate
intent to sign the record.26 No particular Commission in NAC 645.613 was to
type of electronic signature is required. A require proof a client agreed to sign the
digital signature is an electronic signature brokerage agreement. Specifically, the
that uses an asymmetric cryptosystem Commissioners did not want only “the
to verify to the reader the identity of the clicking of an acceptance box,”28 either
signer.27 on the internet or in an e-mail, to create
a binding brokerage agreement. The
Some software packages, such as prospective client must know he or she is
Microsoft Office, use certain technology signing a contract and must intend to be
to enable the writer to digitally sign a file bound by it – regardless of whether the
by using a preset certificate. This internal contract is created orally, in writing, or
certificate is a piece of technology that electronically.
confirms the file or document originated
from the signer and that it has not been 5. TERMINATION
altered by unauthorized third persons.
The internal or self-signed certificates are a. Events Causing Termination – As with
considered unauthenticated when the all contracts, certain events will terminate
document is sent to another computer the contract. Generally, and unless the
unless the certificate was issued by a contract provides otherwise, these events
formal certification authority. A person are:
must apply to a commercial certification • Completion of the contract’s purpose;
authority to obtain an authenticated
• Termination by contract term;
digital certificate. As with all modern
technology, electronic formats are • Mutual agreement;
changing rapidly. What is cutting edge
today will be passé tomorrow. • Impossibility of performance;
• Breach;
• Operation of law; or
• A party’s death.
30. Humphrey v.
Knobel, 78 Nev. 137,
147, 369 P.2d 872 (1962).
III - 7
contractual obligation to the other. The If the client is claiming the broker 34. Kaldi v. Farmers Ins.
Exch, 117 Nev. 273, 279,
termination of the brokerage agreement breached the contract, the broker may
21 P.3d 16 (2001).
does not release the broker from certain not be entitled to any compensation. The
statutory duties such as confidentiality. client may sue for any actual damages 35. Nebaco, Inc. v.
Riverview Realty Co,
the client suffered due to the broker’s
Inc., 87 Nev. 55, 482 P.2d
A conditional release is when the broker breach.36 305 (1971).
stops representing the client but holds the
36. NRS 645.257 (1).
client to the payment of compensation. If the broker believes the client has
This type of termination usually occurs breached the contract, the broker is
when the client or broker “fires” the other. entitled to any compensation originally
agreed to and earned before the breach,
The Nevada Supreme Court stated or may sue for any alternative remedies
“[a]bsent a contractual provision provided in the contract.
to the contrary, an independent
contractor/principal agency Recording a Lis Pendens: The brokerage
relationship is terminable at any agreement is a contract for services. The
time at the will of the principal or only way to enforce its terms is either
the agent.”34 through ADR or court action. Unfortunately,
some licensees believe they can record a lis
A client has the right to refuse to work pendens to stop the ex-client’s escrow when
with any specific broker-salesman or there is a dispute about compensation or the
salesman; however, as the brokerage brokerage agreement.
agreement is with the broker, the brokerage
agreement continues in force. When this A lis pendens is a notice recorded in the
happens, the broker may transfer the client county Recorder’s Office that lets the
to another agent or release the client from world know there is litigation pending
the brokerage agreement. The broker about the title to, or possession of, real
has no right to force a client to work property. It may only be recorded after
with a particular agent. However, if the a legal complaint is filed with the court
client refuses to work with the brokerage (NRS 14.010).
without cause, the client has breached the
employment agreement. As an employment contract, the brokerage
agreement is not a claim for title to, or
Impossibility of performance: A possession of, real property. Therefore,
contract will terminate if, through no no authorization or right is given to the
fault of either party, the contract becomes broker to record a lis pendens against
impossible to perform. For example, a seller’s property. Should a broker “ADR” stands for
“alternative dispute
the seller’s property burns down - now inappropriately record a lis pendens, the
resolution” and includes
there is nothing to sell. The seller could broker is subject to a counter-suit for mediation, arbitration, or
terminate the brokerage agreement based slander of title. conciliation.
on the impossibility of performance.
A broker, broker-salesman,
The performance need not be totally “Operation of Law”: Most contracts or salesman may be
impossible, only highly impractical. The will terminate when the parties cannot a corporation. The
act creating the impossibility must have perform their obligations under the corporate legal entity may
be dissolved, but unless
been reasonably unforeseeable.35 contract because of a legal change in the legally dissolved, the
status of a party. Usually, the parties do corporation does not die.
Breach: The brokerage agreement may not intend for the law to change their
be terminated when either party breaches rights or liabilities, but it happens anyway.
it. A breach occurs when the client or For example, by “operation of law” a duly
the broker does not perform obligations executed brokerage agreement may be
under the contract. avoided by a client who is a minor.
III - 9
Not all brokerage agreements are created equal. There are two types of representation 47. Humphrey v.
Knobel, 78 Nev. 137,
144, 369 P.2d 872 (1962).
recognized in Nevada — open or exclusive. Open contracts allow the client to hire
48. Morrow v. Barger,
several brokers. Exclusive contracts require the seller to work with just one broker. 103 Nev. 247, 252, 737
P.2d 1153 (1987).
Other forms of brokerage agreements focus not on the type of representation but on
how the broker is to be paid, such as in net listings or option listings.
B . t y pes of representation
An open brokerage agreement is where offer. This is the case even if another
the broker has no exclusive representation broker subsequently produces a ready,
of the client – the client may hire any willing and able prospective buyer. If the
number of other brokers. An open other agreements did not automatically
brokerage agreement allows the seller terminate, the client could be liable for
to sell the property without owing a several commissions.
commission. The courts favor the client in
determining the level of representation. Implied Brokerage Agreements:
The more “open” the contract, the better Though not favored by the courts,
for the client. under some circumstances, a court will
find a broker is owed compensation under
Open brokerage agreements may be oral an implied brokerage agreement.
or written. All oral brokerage contracts are
considered “open.” All written brokerage In Morrow v. Barger, (1987),48 the court
agreements are also presumed to be open found an implied brokerage agreement
unless the contract’s terms or title state it after the written listing ended. Claire
is exclusive. Morrow was a broker who had a written
open listing with the Bargers to sell their
Unless otherwise specified in contract, ranch. During the listing period, Morrow
a broker earns a commission with an showed the property to three potential
open agreement only if the broker is the buyers. When the written brokerage
“procuring cause” of the transaction - that agreement ended, the sellers instructed
is, the broker finds a buyer ready, willing Morrow to continue marketing the
and able to purchase on the seller’s property – which she did. After a while,
precise terms. “Precise terms” does not the sellers stopped communicating with
mean the property must be sold at list Morrow. Eventually, Morrow learned that
price: it may be sold at any price the seller the Bargers personally sold the property to
agrees to accept.47 all three buyers in a complicated escrow.
Morrow sued for her commission and won.
The court will usually find the other The court said Morrow had an implied
brokers’ open agreements terminated as open listing; therefore, she was entitled to
soon as the client accepts one broker’s a commission.
III - 11
d. Missing Elements = No Compensation – to anyone for any compensation, the
55. Bangle v. Holland
If an exclusive brokerage agreement is not broker takes on all legal duties and their
Realty Inv. Co, 80 Nev.
in writing or if it is missing a necessary related liability.58 331, 393 P.2d 138 (1964).
legal provision, the broker will be unable
to collect a commission.55 A faulty b. Limited Service Contracts – There 56. Morrow v. Barger,
103 Nev. 247, 252, 737
exclusive brokerage agreement cannot is a difference between the right of the P.2d 1153 (1987).
become an open brokerage agreement. parties to contract for certain services and
Failure to include a fixed termination date the broker’s level of legal liability. Some 57. Bangle v. Holland
Realty Inv. Co, 80 Nev.
makes the agreement voidable by the services are dictated by statutory duties 331, 393 P.2d 138 (1964).
client and removes the broker’s ability whether or not stated in the contract.
to claim payment under alternative legal 58. NRS 645.030 &
NRS 645.260. See also
theories of compensation.56 By law, a licensee cannot “contract away”
NRS 645.255, no duty
or a client "waive" the statutory duties of in NRS 645.252 or
In Bangle v. Holland Realty Inv., Co., NRS 645.252 or NRS 645.254. The public NRS 645.254 may be
(1964),57 Nevada’s Supreme Court found has the right to expect the licensee will waived.
that Holland, a licensed real estate broker, adhere to the law and abide by all of the 59. NRS 645.321.
could not collect $38,800 for commissions licensee's legal duties. A broker can be
earned from selling Bangle’s houses. held responsible for not performing all of
Holland had not followed the statute the stated duties whether or not the client
requiring a definite termination date in and broker have agreed otherwise.
the exclusive agency brokerage agreement.
The court found NRS 645.320 had specific The sole exception concerns NRS 645.254
statutory elements for a valid exclusive (4), which states a licensee has the duty to
contract. If those elements were missing, present all offers made to or by the client
the contract failed and could not be as soon as practicable unless the client
converted to an open contract. Therefore, signs a written waiver. The waiver must
Holland’s listing contract, by not having be on a state mandated form (Waiver
a definite termination date as required Form) and signed by both the client and
by statute, was unenforceable. The court the broker.
held “the purpose of NRS 645.320 is best
served by denying any relief to a broker or A licensee and client cannot agree by
salesman, who claims an exclusive agency contract to do an illegal thing – such a
to sell, unless the requirements of the contract is automatically void. For example,
statute are complied with.” the broker cannot agree with the client to
discriminate against a protected class.59
3. LIMITED SERVICE CONTRACTS The RED may bring a complaint against a
AND LIABILITY licensee who breaks the law regardless of
the terms of any brokerage agreement.
a. No Transactional Agency – Nevada
does not recognize “transactional” agency. Non-statutory services may be A “void” contract never
Transactional agency is a limited form contractually limited. For example, had legal sufficiency
or effect – it is as if the
of agency in which the broker does not the broker and client may agree that contract never existed.
represent either party but is hired to the broker does not have to hold an
facilitate the transaction. A transactional open house or personally show the
“agent” is more similar to an escrow property. The broker may have a menu
officer than to a traditional real estate of discretionary services and charge the
agent. At this time, with the exception client piece-meal for those services.
of one duty, a broker may not limit the
broker’s liability to, or representation of, a
client. If a broker provides any real estate
related services
C . compensation
Under Nevada law, only a broker is In purchase transactions, the listing broker
authorized to collect compensation for earns compensation by securing a buyer
real estate related services, whether within the time specified in the contract.
preformed by the broker or by the The buyer must be ready, willing, and able
broker’s agent.62 A broker-salesperson to purchase at the price designated by the
or salesperson cannot accept seller.63 “Able” means financially able. The
compensation from any person other money does not have to be immediately
than the broker (or owner-developer) available as long as funds are available to
with whom he or she is licensed at the close the deal within the time required.64
time of the transaction. Therefore, only The “price designated by the principal,”
a broker may be employed by a client. includes any sale price to which the seller
agrees regardless of the initial list price.
III - 15
A subsequent default by buyer will not broker fulfills the terms of the brokerage 65, 66. Chicago Title
Agency v. Schwartz, 109
limit the broker’s right to commission. agreement. In an open listing, the
Nev. 415, 418, 419, 851
Some purchase agreements require the broker earns the commission when he P.2d 419 (1993).
parties to have an on-going relationship; or she finds a buyer ready, willing and
for example, a Lease with Option to able to purchase on the agreed terms. 67. Nollner v. Thomas,
91 Nev. 203, 533 P.2d 478
Purchase or where the seller is carrying a For purchase transactions, payment is (1975).
portion of the purchase price. Should the typically due upon close of escrow. The
buyer default, unless otherwise agreed Nevada Supreme Court has stated, 68. NRS 645.323.
between the broker and seller, the seller “[t]he law supports the theory that the
69. NRS 645.002.
cannot refuse to pay, nor require the broker’s commission was owed at the
broker to refund, the broker’s earned close of escrow… .”66 For non-purchase 70. NRS 645.322.
commission. If a buyer defaults after transactions, payment is due after the
closing a transaction, it is the buyer who services are tendered. Nevertheless, the
is liable to the seller for all of the damages parties may agree to defer the payment
caused by the default including any until a specific time or event.
broker’s commission already paid. The
seller’s remedy is against the buyer. In exclusive agency agreements,
compensation is generally owed when the
In Chicago Title v. Schwartz, (1993),65 broker fulfills the terms of the agreement.
Schwartz sold a property to the Wrights. The payment terms must be clear and
Chicago Title was the escrow holder. unambiguous.67 In an exclusive agency
Chenin was the seller’s listing agent. agreement, the broker’s commission is
Originally, the transaction was a straight not dependent upon the broker being
purchase and Chenin’s commission was the “procuring cause” of the buyer.
to be paid at the close of escrow. Because Alternatively, the seller and broker may
the Wrights had financial difficulties, agree the property must sell only at a
Schwartz agreed to an installment contract certain price or under specific conditions
and unilaterally instructed Chicago Title before the broker gets paid.
to alter the commission order to pay
Chenin at the end of the installment Advanced fee: An advance fee is
period. However, Chicago Title paid the compensation collected by a broker from
commission at the close of escrow. a client before services are rendered.68 It
may be collected in advance for listing or
When the Wrights defaulted on the advertising a property or a business for
installment contract, Schwartz sued sale or lease.69 Most advanced fees are for
Chicago Title for the early release of the sale of prospecting lists. Any broker
the commission. The court held that who charges an advance fee must give the “Procuring cause” is also
regardless of the buyers’ later default, client an accounting of that fee within three known as the “inducing
Chenin was owed her compensation when months after collecting it, whether or not cause,” “efficient cause,”
or “proximate cause.”
she earned her commission per the listing the property was actually sold or leased.70
contract. Therefore, even if Chicago Title
had mistakenly released the commission, b. Procuring Cause – When there is an
Schwartz was not harmed because Schwartz open listing, in order to be entitled to a
already owed the money to Chenin. If real estate commission, a broker must
Schwartz was harmed, he had to look to the show an employment contract existed and
defaulting buyer for reimbursement. that the broker was the procuring cause
of the sale. If a real estate broker has been
a. When Earned and When Due – In a the “procuring” or “inducing” cause of
purchase transaction, unless the broker a sale, he or she is entitled to the agreed
and client contract otherwise, the commission regardless of who eventually
broker’s commission is earned when the closes the transaction.
III - 17
3. SOURCE AND AMOUNT 75. NRS 148.110.
real property, Nevada law provides the b. Determining Amount – The most The cooperating broker is
maximum commission is 10% of the common way of determining a broker’s the other party’s broker. The
property’s sale price.75 commission is as a percentage of the term usually refers to the
buyer’s broker. The buyer’s
property’s sale price. Nevertheless, broker may also be known as
It is unlawful for any licensee to offer, there are other ways of calculating the the “selling” broker.
promise, allow, give or pay, directly or broker’s compensation. These include
indirectly, any part or share of his or her flat fee arrangements, net listings, and a
commission, compensation or finder’s “fee for services” arrangement where the
fee to any person who is not a real estate client selects from a menu of services and
licensee, in consideration for services.76 selectively pays for each service chosen.
No broker-salesperson or salesperson Each broker and client may mix and
may accept compensation from, or pay match how the broker’s compensation
compensation to, any person other than a will be calculated.
broker (or owner-developer) with whom
he or she is licensed at the time of the
transaction.77 Flat Fee: The broker may charge a client a
set or flat fee regardless of the value of the
property or the type of service rendered.
III - 19
On the other side, net listings are who provides services in connection with 81. National Association
of Realtors®, Code of
considered by prominent real estate a real estate transaction.
Ethics and Arbitration
professional organizations to be ripe Manual, 2006, case
for potential unethical conduct by the Among other items, RESPA regulates who interpretation #1-3.
broker. The concern is that with a net can give and receive compensation for
listing, the broker becomes a speculator settlement services. No person may give 82. Morrow v. Barger,
103 Nev. 247, 252, 737
in the client’s property.81 Additionally, or accept any fee, kickback, or thing of P.2d 1153 (1987).
many multiple listing services refuse value strictly for a referral to a settlement
to take net listings as the co-operating service provider.86 RESPA does not review 83. Flamingo Realty v.
broker’s commission, if any, cannot be whether the commission is reasonable, nor Midwest Devel., 110
Nev. 984, 988, 879 P.2d 69
reasonably determined. does it cover broker-to-broker referral fees.
(1994).
Net listings are still used with hard to b. Anti-trust - There are two sources 84. 12 U.S.C. § 2600 et seq.
sell properties, such as rural land and for anti-trust laws for Nevada brokers
85. 12 U.S.C. § 2602 (3),
environmentally damaged property. – state law (NRS 598A) and federal law
and Reg. X § 3500.2(b).
They are more popular when there is a (Sherman Act87 and the Clayton Act88).
buyer’s market. The object of these laws is to regulate 86. 12 U.S.C. § 2606,
trade to ensure a competitive market RESPA § 8 (a), and Reg.
X § 3500.14.
c. Quantum Meruit – Quantum meruit for the protection of the consumer. The
is a legal theory used to establish the United States Supreme Court, when 87. 15 U.S.C. § 1 (1973).
compensation rate when there is no defining “trade”, said the term included
express agreement or when the agreement all occupations in which men are engaged 88. 15 U.S.C. § 17 (1973).
fails but the court finds it would be for a livelihood.89 That includes real estate 89. United States v.
inequitable not to give the broker a licensees. There are certain jurisdictional National Association of
commission. Quantum meruit allows the issues in applying the federal anti-trust Real Estate Boards, 339
broker to be paid the reasonable value of laws to local (Nevada) brokerage services. U.S. 485 (1950). NAREB
was the precursor to
his or her services.82 The court will look at Nevertheless, some activities dealing with
NAR.
“established customs” when determining the broker’s commission may still fall
the worth of the broker’s services. 83 under the law’s shadow.
Quantum meruit cannot be used to collect The main area of regulation concerning a
compensation when there is a faulty broker’s compensation is price fixing. This
exclusive brokerage agreement. is where a group of brokers determine
a fixed rate of compensation, thereby A “buyer’s market” is
when there are more
4. RESPA AND ANTI-TRUST eliminating competition. Also, it applies to
properties on the market
any activity that would tend to establish a than there are buyers.
Two important sets of laws impact a uniform practice, for example, setting the Therefore, the seller has
a harder time selling the
broker’s compensation: RESPA and the length of listing periods.
property and the buyer can
anti-trust laws. get a better deal.
A broker may set the commission rate
a. RESPA – RESPA stands for the Real in his or her brokerage without being “Quantum Meruit” is
Latin. Literally it means
Estate Settlement Procedures Act.84 in violation of price fixing. The problem “as much as he deserves.”
RESPA is federal law passed in 1974 and it arises when two or more brokers from It refers to the reasonable
is periodically amended. It regulates the various firms act in concert to establish value of a person’s services.
behavior of settlement service providers industry wide fixed commissions. To
who deal with federally related loans in avoid even the appearance of price fixing,
residential real estate transactions. Real brokers should have written policies
estate licensees are specifically identified stating their commission rates and
as being settlement service providers.85 A establishing their independent business
“settlement service provider” is anyone justification for those rates.
III - 21
5. DISCLOSURE 92. NRS 645.252 (1)(b).
98. NRS 645.8705. Some brokerage agreements concern specialized property or services and are
1. COMMERCIAL BROKERAGE
AGREEMENTS
Bankruptcy is federal law that can have Existing Listing Agreement: Usually, an
a profound effect on the sale of real existing listing agreement becomes an
property and any brokerage agreement.112 “executory contract” once the seller files
There are various bankruptcy chapters a for bankruptcy. As such, the bankruptcy
person may file under. Depending on the trustee or the court (they are not the same)
chapter, each debtor, and any contractor can either accept or reject the brokerage
with that debtor, has certain rights and agreement. Even if the trustee accepts
responsibilities. Considered here are the contract, the court may reject it. If
general rules regarding the brokerage the trustee and court accept the existing
agreement when a party files for brokerage agreement, the court may
bankruptcy under Chapter 7 - liquidation modify the compensation. If the contract
or “straight” bankruptcy. Property is rejected, there is little recourse against
management agreements and leases have the court or the trustee.
other requirements not discussed here.
Buyer Files for Bankruptcy: As soon
There are three major instances in as the buyer files for bankruptcy, all
which a broker may be confronted with of the buyer’s assets (with certain
a brokerage agreement subject to the exclusions) are subject to the control of
bankruptcy law: the bankruptcy trustee. If the buyer has
not executed a purchase agreement, any
1. When the broker has an existing, brokerage agreement the buyer has may
valid listing agreement and the be terminated since the debtor no longer
seller files for bankruptcy; has control over the assets necessary to
purchase any property. If there is an
CAUTION! Bankruptcy 2. When the broker’s buyer-client files executed purchase agreement, the court
law is highly technical and for bankruptcy; and may set aside the purchase agreement. At
no broker should attempt
to make a determination on this point the seller, or the buyer’s broker,
the status of the brokerage 3. When the broker is hired by the would have to file a Proof of Claim
agreement without bankruptcy trustee to sell the against the buyer’s bankruptcy estate for
consulting a bankruptcy
attorney.
bankrupt estate’s real property. any loss they suffer.
III - 25
Trustee Hires Broker: Many times the A property management agreement must 113. NRS 645.230 (1)(b)
bankruptcy court or trustee will sell the state the broker’s fee or compensation and & (c); NRS 645.013 &
NRS 645.0195.
debtor’s real property assets. The trustee whether it is calculated as a percentage
is authorized to hire professionals to of the rent, a flat fee, or by some other 114. NRS 645.6056 (1).
help settle or distribute the bankruptcy formula. There must be a provision
115. NRS 645.005.
estate. Under the Bankruptcy Code, a on how the broker is to handle the
broker is considered a “professional” retention and disposition of tenant rents 116. NRS 645.0192.
and therefore, compensation under the and deposits during each term of the
117, 118. NRS 645.6056.
brokerage agreement must be approved agreement. The agreement must outline
by the bankruptcy court. The trustee may the broker’s authority to act as agent for 119. NRS 489.113 & NRS
hire several brokers under an open listing the client, for example, whether or not the 489.120.
agreement. property manager may initiate eviction
120. NRS 361.244
proceedings. Finally, it must state what
The broker may file a motion with the conditions must occur if the agreement 121. NRS 489.091 & NRS
court to have the court appoint the broker is cancelled during its term. The statute 489.201.
and establish the commission. Once the provides that a property management
court approves the broker, the commission agreement may have a no-cause
becomes an administrative expense and is cancellation clause.118
paid out of the assets of the estate before it
is distributed to the debtor’s creditors. 6. MANUFACTURed HOUSING
III - 27
E . review
C. Alternative Contracts...............................................................................................................................................................................25
1. Installment Contract.......................................................................................................................................................25
2. Option to Purchase and Lease With Option...........................................................................................................29
D. Review......................................................................................................................................................................................................................30
1. Frantz v. Johnson, 116
Nev. 455, 465, n.4. (2000). An offer is the first step toward a legally binding purchase contract. Its terms will
2. McCall v. Carlson, 63 create the initial rights and responsibilities of the parties. Since the licensee will often
Nev. 390, 419, 172 P.2d
171 (1946). help draft or review an offer, understanding its legal parameters is crucial.
3. NAC 645.630.
4. NAC 645.632.
IV - 3
1. Creating the offer 2. WITHDRAWAL of an offer 5. NRS 111.210.
6. NRS 645.635(7).
An offer need not be in writing. Though Most written offers contain an expiration
verbal offers are legal, a verbal acceptance date and time. However, setting an 7. NRS 645.254 (4).
by the seller cannot create a legally expiration time does not require the
binding contract for the sale of real offeror to hold the offer open until
property. Nevada’s statute of frauds that time ends. In contract law, any
requires all purchase contracts for real offer, whether oral or written, may be
property to be in writing. Therefore, to withdrawn (revoked) by the offeror any
turn a verbal offer into an enforceable time before it is accepted. A seller cannot
purchase agreement the contract must be demand the offeror keep the offer open
in writing, state the consideration and be until it expires.
signed by the seller.5
After the expiration date the offer is no
In Nevada, most residential purchase longer viable. Thus, an offer cannot be
offers are prepared using preprinted accepted by the offeree after the expiration
forms. There is no state mandated date without the offeror agreeing to
purchase form for real property. accept it. The parties may mutually
agree to extend the expiration date. A
Drafting an Offer for the Non-client: licensee should verify any extension is
Bona fide
A listing broker is to promote the sale or in writing and signed by both parties. If
means an offer made in
lease of the seller’s/landlord’s property no expiration time is stated in an offer, a good faith, without fraud
and one way of doing this is by putting court will impose a “reasonable” time for or deceit, where the offeror
all bona fide offers in writing and acceptance based on the facts of each case. is sincere and genuine.
presenting them. The licensee has a duty,
when requested, to reduce to writing
a bona fide offer made in good faith.6
Consequently, if a listing broker is
requested by a non-represented party to
write an bona fide offer, he or she must
do so; however, drafting an offer does not
automatically make the listing broker the
buyer’s agent, nor does it create multiple
representation necessitating the use of a
Consent to Act form.
IV - 5
Source: Real Estate Division.
IV - 7
Though the previous two activities 5. rejection of offer 22. NRS 645.321 (1)b).
(disclosing offer terms and inserting
23. The 1968 Fair
an acceleration clause) are not a direct Once an offer has been reviewed by Housing Act, as
violation of any law or regulation, and the offeree, if it is rejected, the licensee amended 1988, 42 U.S.C.
there is some controversy regarding this, must obtain a written notice signed by § 3601 et seq. and NRS
118.
nevertheless, the Real Estate Commission the offeree informing the offeror of the
has found these practices to be highly rejection.24 There is no requirement that 24. NAC 645.632.
suspect. the notice explain why the offer is being
rejected. The purpose of this regulation
d. Discrimination – Regardless of any is to satisfy the offeror that his or her offer
instruction or preference of the licensee’s was actually presented, reviewed and
client, a licensee may never reject or rejected by the other party. Most Nevada
modify an offer because the offeror is a preprinted purchase agreement forms
member of a protected class. It is illegal contain a rejection clause with a place for
to discriminate by denying a person an the rejecting party to sign.
opportunity to engage in a real estate The rejection notice should be given to
transaction because of that person’s race, the offeror within a “reasonable” time.
religious creed, color, national origin, When there is no time frame specified,
disability, ancestry, familial status or the courts will determine a “reasonable”
sex (gender). A licensee cannot modify time from the facts of each case. Once
the terms and conditions of an offer the rejection has been delivered, the offer
to discriminate against, or provide a is dead.
preference for, a person based on his or
her protected class status.22 The Administrative Code requirement
that the licensee have the offeree sign a
The licensee must be aware that a client rejection notice is only binding on the
seeking a preference for a person based licensee, not on the client. There are times
on their protected class is also a violation when a client, having rejected an offer,
of the law. For example, a licensee cannot may refuse to sign a rejection notice. In
follow a client’s instruction to accept only these cases, the licensee is still charged
offers from persons of a certain religious with providing the offeror with a written
or racial background. rejection notice that states the client
refused to sign the rejection.
Nevada’s protected classes are race,
religious creed, color, national origin,
disability, ancestry, familial status and
sex.23 Sexual orientation is not a protected
class for housing in either Nevada or
federal law.
IV - 9
27. NRS 129.010.
29. 1916.
IV - 11
c. Who Signs and Various Entities – purchase agreement, and the contract is 35. NRS 111.210.
Legally, only the seller or the seller’s breached, the buyer will have recourse
lawfully authorized agent is required only against the owners who signed. 36. NRS 123.230 (4).
to sign the purchase agreement.35 Again, the licensee should be aware of a
37. NRS 123.220 (3).
However, since most modern purchase possible negligence lawsuit against the
agreements require obligations from both broker if the licensee fails to obtain all 38. NRS 163.023.
parties, seller and buyer, each must accept necessary signatures.
those terms. That acceptance is proved 39. NRS 163.050.
by the parties’ signatures on the purchase Trusts and Guardianships: A trust is
40. NRS 159.1385.
agreement. created by an individual, called the
settlor, who allows the legal title to 41. NRS 159.134.
A licensee must be aware of who has specific property to be held in the name
the signing authority for a given entity. of the trust for the benefit of others or 42. NRS 78.115.
When there is a question regarding a the settlor. A trust is controlled by one
party’s authority to sign, the licensee or more trustees. Individuals named to 43. NRS 78.120.
should request proof or verification at the benefit by the trust’s property are the
44. NRS 78.130.
onset of the transaction. If there is any beneficiaries. Commonly, the trustee
question, the broker should require the has the authority, as granted by the
party’s legal counsel to provide written trust document, to sell or purchase
verification of authority. If the closing real property in the trust’s name.38 The
is through an escrow company or title beneficiaries of the trust do not have the
insurance is being purchased, then the authority to sell trust property. A trustee’s
escrow or title officer will determine who rights are outlined in law; however, trust
is the appropriate legal entity. However, documents may modify the trustee’s
that may not occur until well into the responsibilities. A licensee should have
transaction. If the licensee has been some written verification that the trustee
dealing with an unauthorized principal, is solely authorized to sign the purchase
the whole transaction may unravel at the agreement.
end. It is better to ensure upfront, who-is-
who and who has signing capacity. The licensee should be aware that a
trustee who is not the settlor, usually
Married Parties: Since Nevada is a needs the approval of a court if the trustee
community property state, if a buyer is personally purchasing property from,
is married both spouses must sign the or selling property to, the trust estate.39
purchase contract.36 If a seller is selling
community property, the spouse does A legally appointed guardian of an
not have to sign the purchase agreement incompetent ward may sign a brokerage
but will be required to execute the deed agreement to sell or to purchase real
transferring title.37 Should the non- property from the ward’s estate.40
signing spouse choose not to sign the However, this authority also requires
deed, the buyer may only sue the signing court approval.41
spouse for breach of contract and could
bring an action against the broker for Corporations: In Nevada, the statutes
negligence. A licensee should obtain Controlling most corporations are found
both spouses’ signatures on any purchase in NRS 78. Briefly, a corporation is owned
agreement, whether buyer or seller. by the stockholders but managed by a Title does not show all
ownership interests in a
board of directors,42 which has control property. A married man
Co-ownership: If there are multiple over the affairs of the corporation.43 may hold title as “sole and
owners, each person on title will have Each corporation must have a president, separate” but his wife may
still have a community
to sign the deed if the entire property is secretary and treasurer who are
property interest.
being sold. If all owners do not sign the accountable to the board of directors.44
IV - 13
Nevada’s After-Acquired Title statute f. Broker’s Rights Under the Purchase 59. NRS 719.220(2).
provides that if a person sells the fee Agreement – The parties to a purchase
simple absolute title to a property, which agreement are the buyer and seller – 60. NRS 719.240.
title is not yet in the seller’s name, and the parties’ brokers are agents of the
61. NRS 719.280.
afterwards acquires title to the property, principals and not a party to the sale of
the title immediately passes to the buyer. the real property. The brokers’ authority 62. Seigworth v. State,
This is applicable only in very narrow, and contractual rights are found in the 91 Nev. 536, 539, 539
specific situations. It cannot be used brokerage agreements, not the purchase P.2d 464 (1975).
to avoid transfer taxes – generally, the agreement.62 Since the brokers (or other
transfer tax can be assessed on each licensees) are not a party to the contract,
transaction. No broker should ever rely on they lack standing (legal status) to sue on
this statute when taking a listing or when a breach of the purchase contract’s terms.
representing a buyer. If there is a question When a purchase agreement includes
on ownership or title, the broker should terms which indemnify the brokers,
consult with an attorney to establish the waive or disclaim their liability, state their
validity of the seller’s authority. compensation, or disclose their agency
relationship, the licensee must understand
e. “Signing” by Electronic Signature - those clauses may not be recognized as
Nevada law authorizes an electronic enforceable in a court of law.
format for any transaction or contract
in which the parties agree to conduct
their business electronically.59 An
electronic record satisfies any statute
that requires a writing and an electronic
signature satisfies any statute requiring
a sigNature.60 If the signature must
be notarized, it may be electronically
notarized by the electronic signature of a
notary together with all the information
required to be included under other
applicable law. That information must
be attached to, or associated with, the
electronic signature or record.61
IV - 15
may receive the value of the property The contract may or may not contain a time- 75. NRS 148.330.
from the taking entity, but must pay to the frame which allows the seller to clear title
seller the contract price. defects or encumbrances. The right to extend 76. NRS 148.420.
the contract’s time frame for the seller to
77. NRS 111.239 and
c. If A Principal Dies – Should a principal clear title is not automatic and will only be NRS 278.0208.
die while in contract, his or her interest in granted if provided for in the contract or by
the purchase agreement is determined by agreement.79 78. NRS 111.238.
statute. Should the buyer die, the court
appointed personal representative of the Unmerchantable Title: An encumbrance, 79. Denison v. Ladd, 54
Nev. 186, 187-88, 10 P.2d
deceased (the executor or administrator) lien, restriction or claim can make the title
637 (1932).
has several options. He or she may unmarketable (e.g., unmerchantable). A real
terminate the contract, continue with the estate licensee may not offer or attempt to 80. NAC 645.635.
purchase, or sell the deceased’s rights sell any property with an unmerchantable
under the contract.75 The right to continue title unless the licensee notifies the 81. 12 U.S.C. § 2608.
with the sale belongs to the buyer’s estate, prospective buyer of the title impairment
a seller cannot enforce the contract. If the before the buyer pays any part of the
seller dies while in contract, the buyers purchase price.80
can require, with court approval, the
seller’s estate to continue with the sale.76 Federal law (Real Estate Settlement
Procedures Act – RESPA)81 prohibits
d. Solar Energy and the Flag – No a seller from requiring a buyer to
purchase contract may have any clause obtain title insurance from a specific title
restricting the buyer’s right to obtain company. However, a seller may mandate
solar energy.77 No contract may have a specific escrow company or lender.
any clause restricting the display of the
American flag.78 This includes restrictions This separation between escrow and
in common-interest communities and title often confuses the new licensee.
CC & Rs (covenants, conditions and In the western United States, most title
An unmerchantable title
restrictions). There are some limitations insurance companies are intimately is title that a reasonable
on how the flag may be displayed. associated with escrow companies where buyer would refuse to
the purchase of title insurance and accept because of use
constraints, conflicting
e. Property Title & RESPA – Title is the legal the purchase of escrow services seem interests, or the possibility
evidence of ownership of a property. One seamless - both services and product of litigation.
of the basic assumptions when buying a coming as a package. In reality, title and
property is that the buyer will receive clear escrow are separate and distinct services
title. When a property is subject to a financial and entities. There are independent
obligation or use constraint, the title is escrow companies that are not associated
encumbered. No property is completely free with a title insurance company and title
and clear of all title restrictions. All property insurance companies from which a buyer
may be subject to public restrictions (e.g., may purchase title insurance without
taxes, zoning) or private restrictions (e.g., using any escrow service.
C C & Rs, easements, financing obligations).
Many purchase agreements have clauses
disclosing these to the buyer. Often these
clauses state the buyer will take title to the
property in spite of the restriction if the
restriction is common and reasonable, for
example, property taxes.
IV - 17
basement area are damaged and sheet legal rules, they would lose their lawsuit. 85. Thornton v. Agassiz,
rock is moldy from excessive moisture”. However, the court said in this case there 106 Nev. 676, 799 P.2d
The Mackintoshes reviewed and signed was a “special relationship” between 1106 (1990).
this report. They obtained their home the parties thereby making the seller
86. NRS 645.252 (1)(a).
loan from Cal Fed and closed escrow obligated to disclose even patent defects.
soon thereafter. After the close of escrow, 87. Bill Stremmel
the Mackintoshes became aware of the A special relationship occurs when Motors v. IDS Leasing
extensive water seepage problem and the one party confides in and relies on, Corp., 89 Nev. 414, 418,
other major construction defects. the other party because of the nature 514 P.2d 654 (1973).
of their relationship. In Mackintosh, the
The Mackintoshes sued Cal Fed, the court found that Cal Fed was not only
brokerage and others for failure to the seller but the lender as well. As
disclose and for breach of fiduciary duty. their lender, the Mackintoshes confided
Cal Fed argued the Mackintoshes were personal and confidential information to
aware of a water problem but accepted Cal Fed - information a buyer would not
the property, with this visible defect, normally share with a seller, and Cal Fed
“as is.” It argued that as the seller, took the property as security for their
under general contract law, it owed loan - thereby reasonably leading the
no special duty to the buyers to disclose Mackintoshes to believe that there was a
patent defects. The lower court granted “special relationship” between themselves
summary judgment for Cal Fed and and Cal Fed. This special relationship
the other defendants. The Mackintoshes invested Cal Fed with the requirement of
appealed. full disclosure which nullified the onerous
effects of the “as is” clause. Based on its
The Nevada Supreme Court extensively finding of a special relationship, the court
reviewed the history of the “as is“ clause reversed the lower court’s ruling and
from cases across the nation. It found found for the Mackintoshes.
generally, that when a property was sold
“as is,” the seller’s nondisclosure of A licensee should never rely on an “as
adverse information (e.g., defects) will not is” clause to shield him or her from non-
allow the buyer to rescind the contract or disclosure liability. A licensee must always
sue for damages. When a defect is patent, disclose, as soon as practicable and to
the buyer will only be able to rescind or each party to the transaction, all material
get damages if the seller made actual false and relevant facts, data or information
statements, not just remained silent. relating to the property. This disclosure is
required whether the licensee had actual
Moreover, since the buyer was put on knowledge of the information, or “should
notice of a possible defect, the buyer have known” of it using reasonable
had an affirmative duty to reasonably diligence.86
inquire as to the nature of the problem
or defect— the traditional “should have h. Unconscionability – No purchase
known” rule. This principle provides that agreement may have unconscionable
if a buyer knew, or should have known clauses. The Nevada Supreme Court stated
using reasonable diligence, of a defect, yet
accepted the property anyway, the buyer “[a] contract is unconscionable only
waives any right to seek damages for that when the clauses of that contract An unconscionable clause
defect.85 The court found that since the and the circumstances existing at is one that requires a party
Mackintoshes were aware of some water the time of the execution of the to do an act which affronts
the sense of justice,
damage, they were required to investigate contract are so one-sided as to decency, or reasonableness,
further the potential water problem. Since oppress or unfairly surprise an or which requires a party
they did not do this, under traditional innocent party.”87 to give-up a vested right.
94. NAC 645.605 (2) “seller reserves the right to increase a. Reasonable Skill and Care – A licensee
and (10). the sale price or cancel this contract has the duty to use reasonable skill and
without penalty. Should seller care with respect to all parties to the real
95. NRS 645.635 (1)(h). exercise this right, buyer agrees estate transaction.90 What is reasonable
to give up his right to mediate, skill and care? It is the skill and care that
96. Real Estate Division
arbitrate or seek damages or specific a reasonably prudent licensee brings to
v. Soeller, 98 Nev. 579,
656 P.2d 224 (1982). performance against seller.” any transaction by applying the licensee’s
knowledge of the law, the profession, and
The courts reserve to themselves the the property. The licensee, at a minimum,
right to determine if various clauses are must have the degree of knowledge
unconscionable. If they find a clause required to obtain a then current real
unconscionable, it may be stricken from estate license.91 This requires the licensee
the contract or the whole contract may be to keep current with all real estate related
unenforceable. laws92 and to understand and properly
adhere to those laws.93 Additionally,
reasonable skill and care includes the
licensee reasonably obtaining knowledge
of the material and pertinent facts about
the property and the transaction.94
IV - 19
to negotiate directly with the Bennetts c. Authentic Terms - The purchase 97. NAC 645.605 (7).
because he was going on vacation. agreement must accurately reflect the
authentic terms of the parties’ agreement. 98. NAC 645.605 (8).
Eventually, Lund was unable to perform For example, a licensee may not represent
99. NRS 645.635 (5).
on the contract and verbally agreed (either verbally or in writing) to any
with the Bennetts to cancel escrow. lender or other interested party, an amount 100. NAC 645.525.
Nevertheless, she did not cancel the in excess of the actual sale price, terms
escrow nor did Soeller, the Bennett’s differing from those actually agreed 101. NRS 40.750 (2).
broker, ever verify escrow was cancelled. upon,99 or name any false consideration.100
102. See also, NRS
Lund later found a buyer for the property Any misstatement or concealment of a
645.633(1)(i).
(Howarth) and agreed to sell the Bennetts’ material fact to a lender is fraud and will
property to Howarth in a double escrow subject that person to criminal and civil 103. NRS 205.380.
for several thousands of dollars over lawsuits as well as regulatory discipline.101
the Bennetts’ asking price. Because A licensee who supplies false terms is in 104. NRS 645.635 (10).
there was no close of escrow date on the breach of NRS 645.3205102 which states:
105. NRS 645.630 (1)(l).
purchase agreement and the escrow had
not been cancelled, Lund proceeded to “A licensee shall not deal with any
force the Bennetts to sell the property to party to a real estate transaction
her which she, in turn, immediately sold in a manner which is deceitful,
to Howarth. The profit was identified fraudulent or dishonest.”
as “commission” to Lund’s brokerage.
Soeller received his full commission. Including a false term or fact or excluding
When Soeller was sued, he claimed any material term or fact from the
both the Bennetts and Howarth had full purchase agreement in order to deceive
disclosure of the transaction as it was laid anyone is fraud and such behavior is
out in the escrow instructions. However, illegal. Anyone attempting to obtain
the court found there were at least three anything of value using false pretense
different sets of escrow instructions and with the intent to deceive may be found
there may have been more. guilty of a category B felony.103 This
prohibition includes submitting a false
The Real Estate Commissioners found or fraudulent appraisal to any financial
Lund, his brokers, and Soeller, in institution or other interested party.104
violation of NRS 645 for misconduct,
negligence, lack of supervision, lack of d. No Inducement to Breach - A licensee
honest dealing, and failure to protect the should not for personal gain, induce
interests of their clients. Lund's license any party to the purchase agreement to
was revoked, Soeller's and the brokers' breach it in order to substitute a new
licenses were suspended. None of the agreement.105 The question becomes,
licensees had used the reasonable skill or what is the liability if the licensee presents
care necessary to protect the interests of an offer and the client breaks an existing
their clients. contract in order to accept the new offer?
The answer is, the licensee should not A category B felony is one
b. Writing Reviewed - A licensee must be liable as long as the licensee did not to six years in prison and/
ensure all the terms and conditions of actively persuade the client to break the or a fine of $10,000 per
charge.
the purchase agreement are in writing current contract.
and that it is properly signed by all In a specific performance
parties.97 The licensee must make Whenever a contract is breached, there lawsuit, the non-breaching
party asks the court to
certain each change or modification of is the potential for damage claims or a
enforce the terms of the
the agreement is incorporated into the specific performance lawsuit from the contract – in other words
contract and signed or initialed by the non-breaching party. A licensee who to force the seller to sell the
appropriate parties.98 encourages the breach of a contract may property.
IV - 21
4. REQUIREMENTS FOR SPECIALIZED On resales, a buyer must be given a resale 114. NRS 116.021.
PURCHASE AGREEMENTS disclosure package at the unit owner's
expense.122a The buyer may cancel the 115. NRS 116.615.
Not all real estate purchase agreements contract without penalty five days after he
116. NRS 116.1108.
are created equal. Depending on the or she receives the package whether or not
type of real estate being sold, there are the unit was inspected.123 The cancellation 117. NRS 116.1104.
specific clauses or provisions that must be provision must also be in the purchase
incorporated into the purchase agreement agreement. 118. NRS 116.1112.
before it is enforceable.
In either cancellation case – new or resale 119. NRS 116.1113.
This is a binding contract by which The contract must list all major
you agree to purchase an interest in improvements in the subdivision. If
real property. You should examine a separate document contains the
your rights of revocation contained description of the major improvements,
elsewhere in this contract. that document must be incorporated into
the purchase agreement by reference.
Also, the following wording must be The Division will decide which
clearly and conspicuously placed just improvements are considered major.136
above the buyer’s signatures:
If the deed won’t be delivered to the buyer
The purchaser of any subdivision until 180 days after the close of escrow, the
or any lot, parcel, unit or interest contract must say so. The buyer must be
in any subdivision not exempted advised at signing that the contract should
pursuant to the provisions of NRS be recorded in the county where the
119.120 or 119.122 may cancel the property is located to give public notice of
contract of sale, by written notice, the buyer’s interest in that property.137
until midnight of the fifth calendar
day following the date of execution The purchase contract may not contain any
of the contract, unless the contract wording similar to: “[P]urchaser agrees
prescribes a longer period for that no representations, oral or implied,
cancellation. The right of cancellation have been made to purchaser other than
may not be waived. Any attempt what is contained in this contract.”138
by the developer to obtain such a
waiver results in a contract which is Neither the developer, broker nor salesperson
voidable by the purchaser. may make any written or oral statements,
which change the true nature or legal
The notice of cancellation must be significance of any document approved
delivered personally to the developer or by the RED,139 nor can they state that the
sent by certified mail or telegraph to the subdivision was approved by the RED.140
business address of the developer.
The broker, salesperson, or developer may
The developer shall, within 15 days after be sued by the buyer for any violation
receipt of the notice of cancellation, return of NRS or NAC 119. The Division
IV - 23
may press criminal charges, as well as of the estate, guardian of the person, 141. NRS 119.330.
hold administrative hearings, against special guardian, and guardian ad litem,
violators.141 each with their own restrictions and 142. NRS 163.050.
authority.
143. NRS 148.080 and
c. Purchase Contracts Requiring Court NRS 148.220-270.
Approval – Certain purchase agreements Once a guardian is court appointed, all of
require court approval or confirmation. the ward’s property is put into a trust 144. NRS 159.134-1415.
These may include contracts executed held for the ward’s benefit. Generally, the
by an executor or administrator for a guardian is given the authority to purchase 145. 11 U.S.C. §§ 101 et
seq.
decease’s estate; those where the owner or sell real property for the ward’s estate.
is legally incompetent and under a Each contract must be confirmed by 146. 11 U.S.C. § 541.
guardianship; certain trust purchase the court before title passes. Much like
agreements; or those contracts where the probate, the sale of a ward’s real property 147. 11 U.S.C. § 704.
seller has filed for bankruptcy. requires public notice, a court hearing,
and confirmation. At the public hearing, 148. 11 U.S.C. §§ 327, 704.
Trusts: A trustee is a fiduciary to the trust other persons may bid against an existing
149. 11 U.S.C. § 544.
and, by extension, to the beneficiaries. The purchase agreement. The court may
trustee cannot take personal advantage confirm a higher bid, thereby setting aside 150. 11 U.S.C. § 547.
of his or her position. Therefore, a trustee the original purchase contract. 144
must have the approval of a court when 151. 11 U.S.C. § 363.
the trustee is personally purchasing Bankruptcy: When a person files for
property from, or selling property to, the bankruptcy145 all of the property which
trust estate.142 the debtor owns, and the debtor’s interests
in other property, becomes part of the
Probate: In a probate situation where an bankruptcy estate.146 Depending on the
executor or administrator is selling the bankruptcy chapter, the estate is under the
deceased’s real property, public notice must control of a bankruptcy trustee147 who
be given, there must be a court hearing, may sell the estate’s real property with court
and the court must review the purchase approval.148
contract prior to confirming the sale. When
an offer has been presented to the court If the debtor is in contract to purchase or
for confirmation at a hearing, any would-be sell real property prior to filing bankruptcy,
buyer may bid on it. If the second bid is the trustee has the authority to set aside
within certain statutory guidelines, the court that contract and cancel the transaction.149
may accept that offer, order a new sale, or Also, under certain conditions, the trustee
conduct a public auction in open court.143 may undo a closed transaction if it was
The licensee must be aware that no purchase done within the recent past and was
contract for the sale of real property in consummated to defraud creditors or strip
probate is binding on the deceased’s estate the estate of value before the debtor filed
until confirmed by the court. 143 bankruptcy.150
IV - 25
Liability: Both buyer and seller need to One way to protect the buyer’s rights is 153. Title Insurance and
be made aware of the potential liability to record the installment contract. In Trust Co. v. Chicago Title
inherent in an installment contract. For Title Ins. and Trust Co. v. Chicago Title Ins. Insurance Co., 97 Nev. 523,
example, a seller may have a buyer that Co. (1981),153 Moser lent Fullmer money 634 P.2d 1216 (1981).
does not meet all the obligations under secured by a deed of trust on Fullmer’s
the installment contract, damages the property. Title Insurance Co. was the trustee.
property, or encumbers it with liens. Fullmer then sold the property to Suleman
Depending on the contract’s wording, under an installment contract, which was
the seller may have to file for a judicial recorded. Suleman took possession and
foreclosure to evict the buyer and then immediately constructed the Peter Pan
sue for damages. Motel. Suleman later assigned his interest
under the installment contract to Nazarali.
On the other hand, keeping legal title in Fullmer eventually defaulted on the note to
the seller’s name can be a problem for Moser, who foreclosed under the deed of
the buyer. The seller may default on an trust.
existing loan; sell the property; further
encumber it; or have a judgment or lien
attach to the property; each of which
could effect or terminate any rights of
the buyer. The buyer could sue the seller
for breach of contract, but may still lose
the property.
IV - 27
Historically, an installment contract would 2. OPTION TO PURCHASE AND 157. Southern Pacific Co.
only be considered a mortgage if a deed LEASE WITH OPTION v. Miller, 39 Nev. 169, 176,
154 P. 929 (1916).
was executed by the seller to the buyer
and the seller reserved to him or herself a An option contract is a separate, 158. Mosso v. Lee, 53
security interest.157 However, depending on independent contract even though it Nev. 176, 178, 295 P. 776
the contract’s wording, today’s courts may may contain the necessary terms of the (1931).
find an installment contract is a mortgage purchase agreement. An option requires
without the reservation right or a signed the seller to hold open to the buyer, for 159. McCall v. Carlson, 63
Nev. 390, 420, 172 P.2d
deed. It is more likely to be considered a a set time and with set terms, the right
171 (1946).
mortgage if the contract contains onerous to purchase the property. Depending on
terms of forfeiture, or when the buyer has its wording, the option’s consideration
paid a considerable portion of the purchase may be independent of the purchase
price, or where the buyer has substantially agreement and non-refundable, or it
improved the property, or when it would be may be incorporated into the property’s
inequitable not to allow the buyer more time purchase price once the option is
to cure his or her default. The Court has said: exercised. The seller is the optionor, the
buyer is the optionee.
[e]quity will relieve from forfeiture for
default in payment of money under Unlike a purchase agreement, an option
contract for sale of land if caused confers no interest in the property; it is
by accident, fraud, surprise, mistake, merely a contractual right to acquire the
inadvertence, ignorance, or if default property in the future. An option is a
is unintentional and due to neglect unilateral contract that becomes a bilateral
which is not willful.158 contract once the option is exercised.
It is unilateral in that only one party is
It should be evident that installment required to perform. The buyer may or
contracts should not be drafted by real may not choose to exercise the option,
estate licensees nor should the licensee but the seller must sell to the buyer if the
advise his or her client on offering or buyer does exercise it. The exercise of the
accepting an installment contract without option must be unequivocally performed
also advising the client to seek legal on its original terms to be binding.
advice.
As option contracts are distinct from the
offer and purchase agreement, they need
different types of terms. The parties should
identify in the option contract what rights
A time is of the essence
each one has regarding a party’s death,
clause requires the parties
the property’s destruction, the option’s to perform certain acts
assignability, and the eventual disposition within the time frames set
of the consideration. Time to perform must in the contract. Failure to
perform by the stated time
be stated. Nevada’s Supreme Court has said is a breach of the contract.
that all option contracts, by their very nature,
are time sensitive and will be read as having
a “time is of the essence” clause.159
IV - 29
D . R eview
An offer is only the first step toward a responsibilities or rights. These include
legally binding purchase contract. In public policy provisions which are
Nevada, most residential purchase offers automatically read into each contract and
are prepared using preprinted forms even prohibitions against certain restrictions
though there is no state mandated purchase or covenants. Additionally, the purchase
form. When a broker is used, the licensee agreement must accurately reflect the
is responsible for ensuring the form is authentic terms of the parties’ agreement.
complete with clear and definite terms. It cannot contain any discriminatory
The licensee has a duty, when requested, to language indicating a preference for, or a
put into writing all bona fide offers made bias against, anyone of a protected class.
in good faith. The licensee must always
present all offers made to, or by, the client Some purchase agreements must have
as soon as practicable. Regardless of any certain clauses or provisions before they
instruction or preference of the licensee’s are enforceable. Others require court
client, at no time may a broker reject or approval such as probate, guardianship,
modify an offer because the offeror is of or bankruptcy contracts. Finally, the
a protected class. Once an offer has been licensee should be aware of installment
reviewed by the offeree, if it is rejected, the contracts and option contracts (including
licensee is charged with obtaining a written the lease with option to purchase).
notice, signed by the offeree, informing the
offeror of the rejection. A licensee has statutory duties when
dealing with purchase agreements.
Once an offer has been accepted, it These include general duties - not being
turns into a purchase agreement. Every negligent, and specific duties - ensuring
purchase agreement must comply with the a copy of the contract was given to the
statute of frauds. It 1) must be in writing, client. First among these is the duty to use
2) state the consideration given by the reasonable skill and care with respect to
parties for the contract, and 3) be signed all parties to the real estate transaction.
by the owner (seller), or his or her lawfully A licensee may not induce any party to
authorized agent. Unless the licensee the purchase agreement to breach that
has a separate notarized and recorded agreement in order to substitute a new
power-of-attorney, the licensee is not one if the licensee will secure personal
authorized to sign the purchase agreement gain from the breach.
for the client. Nevada law authorizes
an electronic format for any transaction Purchase contracts should not be drafted
or contract in which the parties agree to by real estate licensees nor should the
conduct their business electronically. licensee advise his or her client to accept
an unknown or complicated contract type
The law requires specific contract without also advising the client to seek
clauses which affect the parties’ various legal advice.
D. Review......................................................................................................................................................................................................................22
E. Appendixes...........................................................................................................................................................................................................25
I. Legal Cites to Required Disclosures
II. RED Forms
III. Non-RED Forms
1. Holland Realty v.
NV Real Estate Comm., This chapter identifies the why, when, who, how and what of disclosure for the
84 Nev. 91, 98, 436 P.2d
422 (1968). licensee. Discussed are generalized disclosure information and specific disclosure
2. NRS 645.252 (1). requirements broken down into the topics of agency, transaction, and property
3. 42 USC §4852d disclosures. Mandatory disclosure forms and summary disclosure tables are found
(a)(4). The disclosure
requirement is made in the Appendices.
applicable to licensees by
statute.
4. NRS 645.252.
A. GENER AL DISCLOSURE
5. NRS 645.252, NRS
I N F O R M AT I O N
645.254. For a fuller
discussion, see II. Nevada There is an old saying in real estate 2. SOURCES OF DISCLOSURE LAW
Law on Fiduciary Duties. that when in doubt – disclose, disclose,
6. For example, NRS disclose. Because the licensee helps to The laws requiring disclosure have a
119.182 deals with facilitate most real estate transactions, variety of sources – statute, regulation,
subdivisions and requires the burden of disclosure falls heaviest on common law, and contract. Statutes and
the licensee to disclose
certain facts about the
the agent. Over the years, extensive law regulations are found in federal, state
subdivision. and regulation has evolved requiring a and local laws, codes and ordinances. By
host of disclosures by the licensee. Many contract, the licensee and client may agree
7. For example, NAC
disclosures concern the property, but to have the licensee make disclosures he
119A.285 requires a
licensee selling a time the licensee must also disclose certain or she would otherwise not be required
share to disclose if the specifics about the licensee’s agency and by law to make.
licensee has an interest in the transaction.
the unit.
Nevada statutes and regulations:
8. Federal Interstate Land 1. WHY DISCLOSE? Nevada’s laws are codified in the Nevada
Sales Full Disclosure Revised Statutes (NRS). Most real estate
Act (15 USC § 1701)
The purpose for full and honest disclosure licensees are familiar with NRS Chapter
and Nevada’s Sale of
Subdivided Land (NRS is to ensure all parties to the transaction 645, the laws governing real estate
119.119). have sufficient information on key licensees; however, disclosure requirements
issues to make informed decisions.1 are found throughout the NRS.6
9. The federal department
of Housing and Urban These disclosures may be as broad as
Development (HUD) demanding the licensee disclose “any NAC stands for the Nevada
requires the disclosure material and relevant facts, data or Administrative Code. Each state agency
of the opportunity for
a home inspection. (For
information … relating to the property,”2 that licenses a profession has a set of
Your Protection, Get a to as narrow as requiring the licensee to regulations which govern that profession.
Home Inspection, form) disclose the possibility of lead-based paint These regulations are found in the NAC.
HUD mortgage letter
on the property. 3 Like the NRS, other sections of the NAC
99-18.
have disclosure requirements that are
The duty of disclosure varies with the applicable to the real estate licensee,
licensee’s relationship to a party. For property or transaction.7
example, the licensee owes to all parties
the obligation of disclosing all material Federal laws and regulations: The federal
facts concerning the property as well government has applicable real estate
as certain facts regarding the licensee’s disclosure laws. Some of these disclosures
status and source of compensation.4 In deal with the same topics as state law,8
addition, the licensee owes to the client while others are specific to federal law.9
not only the above, but full and honest
disclosure of all material facts concerning
the transaction.5
V-3
Like Nevada, federal law has its statutes agent will disclose if the licensee is aware 10. For example, the
known as the United States Code (USC). of someone dying on the property.15 presence and compliance
certification of a wood
These are the laws passed by Congress.
burning stove. Washoe
Corresponding federal regulations are The licensee and client may not contract County Health
found in the Code of Federal Regulation to do an illegal thing. For example, no Department Regulation
(CFR). Additionally, various federal agreement between a seller and the listing 040.051§§ A & D.
agencies, such as HUD, have their own agent will relieve the licensee of liability 11. Federal Public Law
statements of policy that are applicable to for the nondisclosure of a material defect 96-551 (12-19-80) [94 Stat.
the real estate transaction. of the property. 3234], wherein the U.S.
Congress established
the Tahoe Regional
Local laws: Some disclosures are required 3. DUTY OF INQUIRY AND Planning Agency
by local government entities such as “SHOULD HAVE KNOWN” (TRPA), administered in
cooperation between the
counties and cities. These may be found
states of California and
in the respective government codes Disclosure is a core duty to agency. The Nevada (see NRS 321.595
or ordinances.10 Moreover, there are licensee has a duty to disclose to each et seq., NRS 268.098).
“hybrid” governing entities that take their party to the transaction any material and
12. Mackintosh v. Jack
authority from various federal and state relevant facts, data, or information which Matthews & Co, 109
laws. For example, the Tahoe Regional he or she knows, or which, by the exercise Nev. 628, 855 P.2d 549
Planning Authority (TRPA) that controls of reasonable care and diligence, should (1993).
and monitors development and land use have known, relating to the property.16
13. Lowe v. Real Estate
practices in the Lake Tahoe basin, is a This includes information of which the Division, 89 Nev. 488,
federally related agency with interstate licensee has actual knowledge as well as 490, 515 P.2d 388 (1973).
jurisdiction.11 The TRPA has its own Code facts about which licensee must inquire.
14. Charles v. Lemons &
of Ordinances that regulate land use. Assoc., 104 Nev. 388, 760
Any licensee dealing with Lake Tahoe The licensee should note that material P.2d 118 (1988).
properties must be aware of restrictions “facts”, not just problems or defects, must
15. NRS 40.770 (5).
imposed by the TRPA and disclose be disclosed. A “material fact” is any
relevant TRPA issues. fact that is likely to influence a principal 16. NRS 645.252 (1)(a).
about the desirability of the property or
17. Holland Realty v. NV
Common law: Historically, case the transaction.17 Such facts include the
Real Estate Comm., 84
law provided that a licensee was licensee’s agency status and loyalty, facts Nev. 91, 98, 436 P.2d 422
responsible for disclosing the condition about the real estate transaction, certain (1968).
of the property,12 the condition of the facts about the property.
18. NRS 645.252.
neighborhood,13 and conditions of the
transaction that affected the client.14 A licensee must disclose facts of which the 19. Garff v. J.R. Bradley
licensee has actual knowledge.18 What is Co., 84 Nev. 79, 85, 436
P.2d 428 (1968).
Today, most common law disclosures actual knowledge? The Nevada Supreme
have been codified into statute. However, Court has found,
sometimes the statute is not specific as to
how or when a disclosure is to be made. [a]ctual knowledge consists not only
At those times, a review of the original of what one certainly knows, but
case law may bring into focus the edges of also consists in information which
the disclosure’s boundaries. he might obtain by investigating
facts which he does know and
Contract: By contract, the broker may which impose upon him a duty to
agree to disclose to the client items which investigate.19
the broker is otherwise exempt from
disclosing. For example, a buyer’s agent The law requires the licensee to inquire
is not required by law to disclose if the about facts or situations that would cause
property was the site of a death; however, a reasonable person to question an item.
the buyer and licensee may agree that the A licensee will not be allowed to ignore
A “stigmatized” property When reviewing any disclosure law, the Additionally, the broker and buyer may
is a property considered licensee should identify the statute’s agree to have the broker disclose:
“damaged” because of an exemptions or exceptions to ensure the
event that occurred there;
for example, a murder. law is properly followed. 4. The fact that a sex offender resides in
Generally, it does not refer the community; or
to actual physical damage a. Stigmatized property - Nevada’s
or a property defect.
stigmatized property law contains a list 5. That the property is located near a
NRS 179D.400 defines a of certain facts that a licensee does not facility for transitional living for released
“Sex Offender” as a person need to disclose.22 offenders.
who is: (a) Convicted of
a sexual offense listed
in NRS 179D.410; or These exempted facts include: The statute only states a buyer’s broker
(b) Found guilty by a 1. Whether the property was the site of may agree to make these disclosures;
court of a sexual offense, a homicide, suicide or a death by any however, there is no statute stopping a
such as: (1) A sexually
violent predator, or (2) A other means, except deaths caused by a seller and listing broker from agreeing to
nonresident sex offender condition of the property (for example, disclose to a buyer information the broker
who is a student or worker faulty wiring); is not otherwise required to disclose.
within this state.
For example, the seller may allow the
“Released offenders” 2. Whether the property was occupied by listing broker to disclose that the seller
are persons who have been a person with human immunodeficiency has received a notice from the local law
released from prison and virus or HIV, or any other disease that is enforcement agency that a sex offender is
who require assistance
with reintegration into not known to be transmitted by living in living in the neighborhood.
the community. the property;
NRS 449.0055 Should a broker consent to take on such
3. Whether the property was the site liability to make those disclosures, the
of a felony or any other crime, except parties’ contract controls the how, when
if the crime was the manufacture of and to whom the disclosure will be made.
methamphetamine and the property has
not been rehabilitated;
V-5
b. Client Misrepresentations - By law, c. No Duty to Investigate: Professional 24. NRS 645.257 (2).
it cannot be assumed that the licensee Inspections or Financial Condition - A
has the client’s knowledge about the licensee does not need to independently 25. Prigge v. South
Seventh Realty, 97 Nev.
property.24 In Prigge v. South Seventh verify the accuracy of a statement 640, 637 P.2d 1222 (1981).
Realty, (1981)25 Prigge purchased a concerning the property made by a duly
property and then sued South Seventh licensed or certified professional.29 A 26. & 27. NRS 645.259 (2).
Realty for falsely representing in the licensee should disclose to the client that
28. NRS 645.259 (2)
listing that the home was frame and a professional report exists if the licensee referring to NRS 645.252.
stucco, which it was not. Prigge argued is aware of such a report; however, the
that the brokerage should be liable for all licensee is exempted from any duty to 29. & 30. NRS 645.252 (4).
facts, false or not, contained in a listing. independently verify the accuracy of
South Seventh Realty argued it had that report.
simply relied upon the statements of the
sellers and it did not know, nor did it have A licensee is not required to
reason to know, the seller’s statements independently investigate the financial
were false. The court, in finding for the condition of a party to the real estate
brokerage, stated an agent had the right to transaction.30 For example, a seller cannot
rely on the statements of the client, unless claim it was the licensee’s responsibility to
there was contradicting information. investigate and disclose the buyer’s credit;
nor can a buyer claim it was the licensee’s
Interestingly, in the Prigge case, the court responsibility to investigate and disclose
opined that Prigge did not argue that the seller’s financial condition.
South Seventh Realty should have known
the true facts if it had exercised reasonable There is a caveat to these exemptions –
care. Had Prigge argued the agent should should a licensee independently verify the
have known whether a building was accuracy of an inspection or investigate
frame and stucco or otherwise, the court’s the financial condition of a party, the
finding may have been different. licensee then assumes the liability for
any inaccuracies in the disclosure. A
A licensee cannot be held liable for the licensee cannot escape responsibility for
Seller’s nondisclosure of information misinformation or inaccuracy by claiming
on the Seller’s Real Property Disclosure he or she was not legally obligated
Statement, if: to disclose it in the first place and
therefore, should not be held liable for the
1. The licensee did not know of the inadequate or inaccurate disclosure.
nondisclosure, or
V-7
Required Disclosure: When may a Gramm-Leach-Bliley Privacy Disclosure 37. NRS 645.253.
licensee disclose confidential information? Statement: In July 2001, the privacy
The law authorizes the disclosure of disclosure provisions of the Gramm- 38. 15 USC §6801 et seq.
and 12 CFR Sec. 225.
confidential information in any one of five Leach-Bliley Act (GLB Act) became
circumstances: effective.38 These provisions require
certain disclosures to a client when
1. When a court of competent jurisdiction handling the client’s personal financial
orders disclosure; information. The GLB Act is not relevant
to most real estate transactions; however,
2. When the client authorizes in writing if the broker collects the client’s personal
the disclosure; financial information for use in any
mortgage loan process or other financial
3. When the licensee discloses acquisition procedure, the GLB Act
information to his or her broker;37 becomes applicable.
4. When the information is required to be Briefly, the GLB Act applies to all
disclosed by law; and businesses engaging in a “financial
activity” as defined by the Act. Generally,
5. When a year has passed since the real estate brokerage and property
termination of the brokerage agreement. management services are exempt. If the
licensee is involved in ancillary financial
A licensee is not bound to a client’s services (such as lending or various
instruction to keep information appraisal services), then the licensee is
confidential that the licensee is obligated required to provide the consumer with
by law to disclose. certain disclosure information.
1. When must the disclosure be made? An ancient Greek once said “timing is
When is the last permissible time before everything.” 39 Legally, this is certainly
licensee liability? When is the best time to true. When a disclosure is made can be as
disclose? important as making the disclosure itself.
Timing is dictated by statute, contract, or
2. Who is responsible for making the general common law principles.
disclosure and to Whom must the
disclosure be made? Various statutes a. When Required by Statute - When
may make different persons responsible a statute requires a disclosure it usually
for disclosure. For example, NRS 113.130 indicates when that disclosure must
requires the seller to disclose what he be made. Often, it will state the last
or she knows about the property. NRS permissible time for the disclosure. For
645.252(1) requires the licensee to disclose example, Nevada’s Seller’s Real Property
what the licensee knows or should Disclosure Statement (SRPD) must be
reasonably know about the property. provided by the seller to a buyer “at least
10 days before residential property is
3. How should the disclosure be made? conveyed to a purchaser.”40 Because the
Does the disclosure require a specific SRPD form is important in ensuring the
form? Is a verbal disclosure sufficient? buyer is aware of what the seller knows
about the property, most buyer’s agents
4. Finally, What needs to be disclosed - is require the seller to provide the SRPD
it a matter concerning the property, the within a set time frame after signing the
transaction, or the licensee’s agency? purchase agreement.
V-9
Finally, some statutes require a disclosure the licensee knows a party is under a 42. NRS 645.252 (1)(b).
be made within a relative time frame. mistaken belief.
For example, the licensee is required 43. American Fidelity
Fire Ins. v. Adams, 97
to disclose to each party “as soon as When the licensee has a duty to speak, Nev. 106, 108, 625 P.2d 88
practicable” each source from which he the licensee cannot remain silent or (1981).
or she will receive compensation.42 When allow a party to continue under a
44. Lowe v. State Dep’t
is “as soon as practicable”? Nevada’s misapprehension regarding a material fact of Commerce, 89 Nev.
Supreme Court has stated, – the licensee must affirmatively disclose 488, 515 P.2d 388 (1973)
and correct any misunderstanding a (Justices Mowbray, J.
and Thompson. C.J.,
clauses … calling for notice of a party has. Obviously, the licensee will
dissenting).
liability creating event “as soon only be charged with the duty to disclose
as practicable” or “promptly” or if the licensee is aware of a party’s 45. Holland Realty v. NV
“within a reasonable time” all misunderstanding. Real Estate Comm., 84
Nev. 91, 98, 436 P.2d 422
essentially mean the same thing. (1968) and Goldstein v.
‘. . . “[S]uch clauses do not require Equitable Estoppel: The doctrine of Hanna, 97 Nev. 559, 635
instantaneous notice of an [event], equitable estoppel, very simply put, states P.2d 290 (1981).
but rather call for notice within a that the law will not allow a person who
46. NGA #2 Ltd. Liab.
reasonable length of time under all has intentionally misled another to take Co. v. Rains, 113 Nev.
the facts and circumstances of each advantage of that person’s ignorance or 1151, 1160, 946 P.2d 163
particular case.” (cites omitted)43 misunderstanding. Equitable estoppel (1997).
56. NRS 645.254. 3. Identifying the licensee’s brokerage.51 3. The licensee’s compensation
sources; and
d. When a Party Does Not Disclose - A
licensee must disclose what the licensee 4. The licensee’s interest in the
knows about a property regardless of a transaction or property (if any).54
seller’s similar responsibility to disclose.52
Even though a licensee cannot be held Each party is entitled to know certain
liable for knowing what the seller facts about the licensee’s agency
knows about a property,53 the licensee and about the licensee’s sources of
is responsible if the licensee knew, or compensation. Additionally, the licensee
reasonably should have known, of a must disclose any interest the licensee
material defect or relevant fact that a has in the transaction or the property.
seller did not include on the Seller’s Real Disclosing this information to all parties
Property Disclosure (SRPD) form. The ensures everyone has sufficient facts to
licensee will not be allowed to avoid reasonably and intelligently proceed with
this disclosure duty by relying upon the the transaction with full knowledge of
seller’s duty to disclose. any conflict of interest by the licensee.
Does this mean the licensee has to verify b. Disclosures Only to the Client -
everything on the SRPD? No, but it could Traditionally, all licensees worked for the
be considered licensee negligence not to seller. As times changed, the law allowed
review the form before providing it to buyers to have their own agents and to
the buyer. demand the undivided loyalty of that
agent regardless of the agent’s source of
RISK REDUCTION TIP! compensation.55
The prudent licensee will review the
Seller’s Real Property Disclosure form, In addition to the issues above, the
completed by the seller, in order to licensee is required to disclose to the client
ensure the seller has not forgotten to list all material facts about the transaction.56
a known material fact. Should a seller When it comes to disclosing to the client
refuse to disclose a relevant item, the facts about the transaction, the licensee
licensee should inform the seller that is only required to disclose facts about
under the law, the licensee is required which the licensee has actual knowledge
to disclose to all parties all material and - there is no “should have known,”
relevant property facts. therefore, the licensee is not required to
investigate transaction facts.
V - 11
c. Required Disclosure to Other Parties - Advertising: If the licensee has a 57. NRS 645.035, NRS
There are potentially four other entities brokerage agreement in place and 645.040.
to whom a licensee has a disclosure duty. advertises a property, the advertisement
58. NRS 645.195. NRS
These are: must identify the licensee’s licensed
645.400, NRS 645.580,
status. This disclosure must be made NRS 645.610 et seq. and
• The licensee’s broker; whether the licensee is acting as an agent NRS 645.635 (5).
or as a principal.61 If the licensee has an
59. NRS 645.690 (1), NRS
• The Nevada Real Estate Division; ownership interest in the property, the 645.720.
advertisement must disclose “for sale by
• The public (by way of advertising); and owner-broker” (owner-licensee, owner- 60. NAC 645.605 (11),
NRS 645.990 and NRS
salesperson, etc.).62 645.993.
• Applicable law enforcement agencies.
Law Enforcement: No one wants 61. NAC 645.637.
The licensee’s broker: The real estate criminals loose and doing harm. The
62. NAC 645.610.
salesperson or broker-salesperson natural inclination is to cooperate with
performs all real estate activities through law enforcement officials when asked 63. NRS 645.252.
the authority of the broker. Legally, to provide information on a client or
the broker represents the client and client’s property. Should the licensee be
the salesperson or broker-salesperson requested to provide a client’s personal
represents the broker in all dealings information to law enforcement, the
with the client.57 Since the broker licensee should immediately direct the
ultimately represents the client, the officer to the broker. Certain client
broker is assumed to be vested with the information may be confidential and,
client’s confidences. Thus, the licensee unless the client has authorized the
is authorized to make all disclosures disclosure of that information, the
concerning the transaction or property to broker may be liable for its unauthorized
his or her broker. release.63 The broker should consult with
his or her legal counsel before making
The Nevada Real Estate Division (RED), such disclosure to law enforcement. The
as Nevada’s licensing entity, has the right broker’s attorney may very reasonably
to require certain disclosures from the and appropriately request the law
licensee. These disclosures often concern enforcement officer to provide a duly
the licensee’s real estate related practices court executed subpoena duces tecum
and business issues, but may include (subpoena of documents) before releasing
specific disclosures about a transaction client information.
or property if it is the subject of a RED
proceeding.58 The RED’s authority
includes the ability to compel disclosure
of a licensee’s books and papers.59
Failure to disclose information when
validly requested by the RED, subjects
the licensee to RED discipline and the
possibility of criminal action.60
V - 13
c. Delivery and Acknowledgment – Any The licensee should review everything 71. NRS 116.41095.
disclosure is ineffective unless it is that is delivered to him or her to ensure
delivered to the person to whom it is that no disclosure is delivered unnoticed. 72. Hornsilver Cases, 35
Nev. 464, 467 (1913).
meant to inform. Some disclosure forms, This helps remove liability to the client for
such as the Duties Owed by a Nevada non-disclosure.
Licensee, incorporate a signature line for
the recipient. Some forms only require
the recipient's initials.71 Once signed and
dated, this acknowledgment serves as
evidence that the disclosure was made
and delivered.
V - 15
must also be given when the licensee is a 2. DISCLOSURES CONCERNING 81. NAC 645.637.
principal in the transaction.81 THE TRANSACTION
82. & 83. NRS 645.252
(1)(e).
b. Changes in Agency Status - A licensee a. Disclosure Situations - There are three
must disclose to all parties any change in main situations for disclosure regarding 84. See Real Estate
the licensee’s relationship with a party to the real estate transaction. These are: Division forms “Duties
Owed by a Nevada Real
the transaction.82 This disclosure must be Estate Licensee” and
made as soon as practicable and must be • Disclosure to the client of all “Consent to Act”, ed.
in writing. If a client’s consent is required, material facts concerning the
85. Real Estate Division
for example, when the broker represents transaction of which the licensee has
Position Statement,
two or more parties to the transaction knowledge;86 Joan Buchanan,
that have conflicting interests (multiple Administrator, March 10,
representation), permission must be • Disclosure to all parties of the 1999.
obtained before representation occurs – licensee’s compensation sources; 86. NRS 645.254 (5).
disclosure alone is insufficient to ensure and 87
consent! Any time there is a change in the 87. NRS 645.252 (1)(b),
NRS 645.633 (1)(g) and
identity of the parties or licensees, a new • Disclosure to all parties of the
NAC 645.605 (4)(e).
form must be completed and signed.83 licensee’s anticipated or present
interest in either the transaction or 88. NRS 645.252 (1)(c),
Form Does Not Create Agency: The the property.88 NAC 645.605 (4), NAC
645.637 and NAC
agency relationship is not created because 645.640.
a party signs either the Duties Owed b. The Client and the Transaction – The
or Consent to Act forms. These forms law requires the licensee to disclose to 89. NRS 645.254 (5).
are strictly disclosure documents. Each the client “material facts of which the 90. Holland Realty v.
form specifically states that it does not licensee has knowledge concerning the NV Real Estate Comm.,
constitute a contract for services or an transaction.”89 What is a material fact? 84 Nev. 91, 98, 436 P.2d
422 (1968), quoting the
agreement to pay compensation.84 It is a fact that is significant or essential to
Restatement (Second) of
the issue or matter at hand. The Nevada Agency §390.
c. Not Required on a Referral - A Supreme Court has stated,
licensee who refers a potential client to
another licensee does not need to provide A fact is material … if it is one which
the Duties Owed disclosure form if the the agent should realize would be
referring licensee’s only activity is the likely to affect the judgment of the A new Duties Owed form
referral.85 For example, a seller contacts principal … [or is] likely to have a should be provided to each
client when there is any
a broker about representing him in the bearing upon the desirability of the licensee change.
sale of his Fallon ranch. The broker does transaction… .90
not Regularly deal with ranch properties;
therefore, he refers the client to a broker Anything impacting the physical
who does. The first broker is not required condition, value or use of the property
to provide the seller with the Duties is material and relevant. These include
Owed form. facts about the escrow, title, the status
of the other party’s agency (ex: if there
has been a change), financing and
issues related to financing (ex: IRS 1031
exchanges), contingency issues (ex: sale
of another property or double escrow)
and any interest the licensee may have
in the transaction. It also includes the
disclosure of the known development of
adjacent parcels.
The statute does not dictate when the • Has received compensation from
disclosure should be made, but common more than one party.
law would require it be made before the
transaction ends. This would ensure each Consent Required: If a broker anticipates
party is aware of any potential conflicts receiving compensation from more than
of interest the licensee may have. Since one party, the broker must disclose this
the other party usually does not see the to each party and obtain each party’s
broker’s employment agreement (the consent.101 Should a party refuse
brokerage agreement) where both the consent, the licensee cannot accept the
source and amount of compensation compensation.
are usually identified, compensation
sources are often identified in the parties’ A licensee may not take an undisclosed
purchase agreement. Since the purchase profit at the expense of another party
agreement is a contract between a seller nor may the licensee purchase or sell the
and buyer, a better business practice property of a client through the use of a
The federal Real Estate is to have the licensees’ sources of third person without full disclosure and
Settlement Procedures
Act (RESPA), prohibits compensation identified in the common the client’s consent.102
a licensee from receiving escrow instructions or on a separate
or giving kickbacks and disclosure form. The licensee should note that disclosure
unearned fees even if
alone does not make the receipt of
such kickbacks or fees are
disclosed. (RESPA, 12 What is Compensation? Compensation certain compensation legal. For
U.S.C. § 2607) is anything of value. It includes money, example, a salesperson may not accept
Goods or services.94 It includes referral compensation directly from a client even
fees and other payments such as fees if that compensation is fully disclosed to
received from vendors to be on a broker’s all parties.103
V - 17
d. Licensee’s Interest - A licensee must Interest in the Property: A licensee, 104. NRS 645.252 (1)(b)
disclose to the parties in writing whenever whether acting as an agent or a principal, & (c), NRS 645.633
the licensee has a personal interest in either has an “interest in the property” (1)(g), NAC 645.605
(4), NAC 645.610 (1)(b),
the transaction or the property. Such whenever the licensee has or anticipates NAC 645.637 and NAC
disclosure ensures everyone is aware of the an ownership interest.110 Failure to 645.640.
licensee’s potential conflicting loyalties.104 disclose the licensee’s interest is an
105. NAC 645.605 (4)(b)
element in the Real Estate Commission’s
& (c).
A licensee (including permitted property determination of whether the licensee is
managers) must disclose the licensee’s deceitful or dishonest. 111 106. NRS 645.252 (1)(c),
affiliation with, or financial interest NAC 645.637.
in, any person or entity that furnishes Any anticipated interest must be disclosed 107. & 108. NAC 645.640
maintenance or other services related even if it is only a pass-through interest. (1).
to the property.105 If a licensee has an For example, a licensee must disclose if
109. RESPA, Real Estate
ownership interest in a business and refers the licensee takes title, however briefly,
Settlement Procedures
clients to that business, the licensee must during a “double escrow.” 112 Act. 12 USC. § 2607.
disclose that ownership interest.
110. NRS 645.252 (1)(c),
Disclosure in Writing: Whether the
NAC 645.637.
Party to the Transaction: When a licensee licensee’s interest is in the transaction or
is a principal, it is a material fact and in the property, the disclosure must be 111. NAC 645.605 (4).
must be disclosed.106 The licensee may in writing – an oral disclosure does not
112. Alley v. NV Real
not acquire (purchase), lease or dispose satisfy the regulations.113 When disclosing Estate Div., 94 Nev. 123,
of (sell), any time-share or real property the licensee’s interest in the property, 125, 575 P.2d 1334 (1978).
without revealing the licensee’s licensed the disclosure must state the licensee is
113. NAC 645.637.
status.107 acquiring or selling the property for him
or herself and that the licensee is a broker, 114. NAC 645.640 (1).
Relationship with a Principal: The broker-salesperson, or salesperson. The
licensee must disclose whenever he or Real Estate Division will recognize the 115. American Fidelity
Fire Ins. v. Adams, 97
she has a personal relationship with disclosure if the licensee includes the term Nev. 106, 108, 635 P.2d 88
a principal to the transaction.108 The “agent,” “licensee,” or “broker, broker- (1981).
relationships that must be disclosed are salesperson, salesperson,” whichever
when a principal is a member of the designation is appropriate. 114
licensee’s immediate family, a member
of the licensee’s firm, or an entity (such Timing: These disclosures must be made
as a corporation, LLC, etc.) in which the “as soon as practicable” but not later than
licensee has an ownership interest. the date and time on which any written
document is signed by the parties. The
Affiliated Business Relationships: Nevada Supreme Court has defined “as
Licensees are subject to federal as well soon as practicable” to mean “promptly”
as Nevada law. One federal law that or “within a reasonable length of time”
addresses licensee disclosure is RESPA considering the facts and circumstances of
(Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act). each particular case.115
It prohibits referrals from one business
to another business when the businesses
An Affiliated Business
have joint ownership unless there is full Arrangement is when
disclosure. These intertwined businesses two or more businesses
are Affiliated Business Arrangements.109 providing various
settlement services to
A broker who has any Affiliated Business a client are owned (in
Arrangement with other real estate whole or part) by the same
settlement service providers should company or entity.
review the RESPA statutes to determine
the specifics of disclosure.
V - 19
d. Various Non-Mandated Disclosures - Also, as previously discussed, the Nevada 118. NRS 645.194.
Listed here are various environmental Real Estate Division has developed for the
items that should be disclosed if consumer a basic “Residential Disclosure
applicable. Obviously, no list can be Guide” for residential properties.118 This is
comprehensive. Items that have specific the Nevada Legislature’s attempt to inform
statutory disclosure requirements are not the consumer of potential disclosure
listed. issues. This booklet contains information
for the consumer - it is not designed to
• Mold (hazardous) relieve the licensee or seller of any of his
• Agricultural uses, and those or her disclosure duties.
with noxious odors
• Airport flight path (see individual Because no form or booklet can be all
regional requirements) inclusive of every possible disclosure, the
• Encroachments licensee must continually be alert to those
• Underground tanks (active and disclosures required by law, those required
abandoned) when they impact the property, and those
• Urea-formaldehyde that address the concerns of
• Foam insulation (UFFI) the client.
• Radon
• Waste Processing e. Disclosing the Human Condition - In
• Mercury any discussion of disclosure, certain issues
• Earthquake Zone continue to be of concern to the client.
• Dump (present/past) These include noisy neighbors and dogs,
• Arsenic crime, and neighborhood demographics
• Slide area (zone) (racial, ethnic, religious).
• Asbestos
• Landfills Noisy neighbors and dogs can be
• Forest fire (zone) disclosed if the seller has given permission
• Flood (zone) since these are things that are based in
• Pest Infestation individual perception. They are also
• Extensive dust (natural/construction) conditions that can change overnight – the
• Mining (historical and present) dog dies, the neighbor moves. A potential
• Groundwater contamination buyer may not have the same experience
as the current seller.
Gone are the days of “Buyer Beware”
Licensee liability lies in inadequate A neighborhood’s crime statistics
disclosure. The fear of many licensees is should be disclosed by an authority
that they will not catch all the potential other than the licensee. If the client is
issues, defects and hazards that should concerned about crime in a particular
be disclosed. To address this fear, some neighborhood, the licensee should refer
brokers have developed “homemade” the client to the local law enforcement
disclosure forms that attempt to disclose unit. Perception of criminal activity is too
every possible hazard regardless of often erroneously linked with the racial or
whether a particular item affects the ethnic composition of an area. The licensee
property. As previously discussed, if should always refer the client who asks
used, these forms should be drafted by a about criminal activity in a neighborhood
licensed Nevada attorney. to a knowledgeable authority such as law
enforcement. Repeating media reports is
dangerous - even the media sometimes
gets it wrong.
V - 21
D . review
The licensee’s duty for full and honest For each disclosure the licensee must
disclosure is an important and significant be aware of “when” the disclosure
duty. Disclosure laws can be found must be made, “how” the disclosure is
throughout federal, state and local laws to be made, and lastly, to “whom” the
and regulations. Inadequate disclosure is disclosure is to be made. When using
a major source of liability for the licensee; non-government created disclosure forms,
therefore, it is necessary to ensure a the broker should insure such forms will
working familiarity with the various provide the brokerage with appropriate
disclosure laws and regulations. The liability protection.
licensee must not only be aware of what
needs to be disclosed, but the when, who In addition to knowing the various
and how of the disclosure. disclosures, the licensee should be aware
of any exceptions or exemptions to the
There are three main areas for disclosure, disclosure laws and how they affect the
these constitute the “what” of disclosure. client’s confidences and general consumer
They are disclosures concerning the privacy.
property, those concerning the licensee’s
agency, and those dealing with the parties’ Finally, the licensee should review the
transaction. following tables and forms to familiarize
him or her self with the most common
disclosures and their requirements,
limitations and sources.
Creation of agency Duties Owed to by Given to, and acknowledged by, a Client. Lists the statutory duties of a NRS 645.252 (3) Licensee Client and any “As soon as practicable”
with Client. A Nevada Licensee Licensee and the various levels of representation. unrepresented but before any documents
RED form # 525 party are signed by Client.
Agency for Clients Consent to Act Acknowledges authorization of Licensee from all parties for Licensee to act NRS 645.252 (1)(d) Licensee All parties, “As soon as practicable”
with conflicting interests. RED form # 524 in a “dual agency” position. Dual agency occurs when the Licensee is acting Clients See text for various
in an agency capacity for two or more clients who have interests adverse to one signing time frames.
other. Should either party refuse to sign, the Licensee cannot act as a dual agent.
When the Licensee’s No Mandatory Form Licensee must disclose any changes in his or her relationship to a party NRS 645.252 (1)(e) Licensee All parties “As soon as practicable.”
relationship to a party to the transaction.
changes.
When Licensee is acting No Mandatory Form – Disclose to all parties Licensee’s relationship as agent of a party, or NAC 645.637 Licensee All parties to Not later than the time
as agent or principal. must be in writing. Licensee’s status as a principal. the transaction any document is signed
by parties.
When the Licensee No Mandatory Form Licensee must disclose that the Licensee is a principal to the transaction NRS 645.252 (1)(c) Licensee All parties to “As soon as practicable.”
has an interest in the or has an interest in a principal to the transaction. NAC 645.640 the transaction
transaction or the
property.
Licensee has an interest No Mandatory Form Must disclose that Licensee (or anyone associated with Licensee) has an interest NAC 645.660 Licensee All parties to Before money is deposited.
in any escrow business in any escrow business before Licensee can deposit any money received in a the transaction
or company. real estate transaction, into such escrow company.
Referral to certain Affiliated Business Affiliated Business Arrangement (ABA) - RESPA restricts a Licensee/ Broker from RESPA, 12 USC Broker/Licensee Client/consumer When referral is made.
settlement services Arrangement Disclosure receiving a referral fee from a settlement service provider unless the Broker has § 2607, 24 CFR
providers. Statement an ABA with the provider. IF there is an ABA, the Broker must disclose in writing Part 3500.15(d)
the nature of the ABA relationship, a written estimate of the fees, and a notice and Reg. X
that the consumer does not need to utilize the provider.
V APPENDIX I - 1
agency and transaction disclosures
V APPENDIX I - 1
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
REQUIRING FORM PERSON TIME FOR
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED DISClosure
Licensee is Inexperienced No Mandatory Form Provides that the Real Estate Division may discipline a Licensee if there is no NAC 645.605 (3) Licensee Client Before services are
in type of transaction. disclosure to Client that Licensee is providing specialized professional services rendered.
outside the Licensee's field or experience or competence.
When Licensee has a No Mandatory Form Licensee must disclose, in writing, any interest, or contemplated interest, in any NAC 645.605 (4) Licensee All Parties to “As soon as is practicable.”
financial relationship property or time share, including, but not limited to, an affiliation with or transaction
with any entity servicing financial interest in, any person or company that furnishes services related to
the property. the property, whether Licensee is managing the property, has an interest in,
or financial arrangement with such entity; or expects to receive a referral fee for
referring a Client to a service provider.
Any agency relationship. No Mandatory Form A Licensee who represents a Client shall disclose to the Client material facts NRS 645.254 (3)(c) Licensee Client As soon as known.
of which the Licensee has knowledge concerning the transaction.
When a Broker or No Mandatory Form Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (Financial Privacy) – If Broker engages in any “financial 12 USC § 1843 Broker Client Before any documents
Brokerage engages in activity”, Broker must inform Client how the Client’s “nonpublic personally 12 CFR § 225 are signed by Client.
any “financial activity.” identifiable information” will be used. “Financial activity” are activities involving
mortgage lending or mortgage Brokering. “Non public information” is any
information collected about the Client by the Broker providing the financial
product or service. Most Brokerage services are not affected by this
disclosure requirement.
When Broker includes No Mandatory Form Truth in Lending – requires a Broker to provide specific information when 15 USC § 1601 Broker All persons When placing
any credit terms in – specific information must certain credit “trigger terms” are used in advertising. Trigger terms include 12 CFR part 202.2(1) advertisment.
advertisement. be presented when TIL the amount of the down payment, amount of monthly payment, number (1990)
“trigger terms” used of payments or payment period, interest rate, Annual Percentage Rate,
or the amount of the finance charge.
Licensee’s unsolicited No Mandatory Form Licensee must adhere to all disclosure requirements found in law or regulation. NAC 645.613 Licensee All persons When placing
Advertising on Internet Broker advertisment.
for any service or property.
agency and transaction disclosures
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
REQUIRING FORM PERSON TIME FOR
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED DISClosure
Advertising property No Mandatory Form A Licensee must disclose in advertisement his or her status as a Licensee NAC 645.610 Licensee All persons In advertisement.
when Licensee is and may not use “for sale (lease) by owner” without qualifying wording such as
an owner. “by Broker/agent owner”.
When Advertising the No Mandatory Form A Licensee, (a Broker, Broker-salesperson, or salesperson) must disclose the NRS 645.315 Licensee All persons In advertisement.
Licensee’s services. name of the Licensee’s Brokerage in any advertisement for real estate services.
When Listing Broker No Mandatory Form A Licensee must disclose to a seller that a buyer is offering something “other than NRS 645.630 (1)(j) Licensee Seller Before seller accepts Offer
Accepts “other than cash” cash” as an earnest money deposit. Once disclosed, the seller may refuse to to Purchase.
earnest money. accept that type of “earnest money.”
When any deposits are No Mandatory Form Broker must disclose the disposition of all deposits accepted and retained by the NRS 645.310 (1) Broker or owner All persons At termination of
accepted by Broker. Broker pending consummation or termination of the transaction. - developer transaction.
Close of transaction No State Mandatory Form Unless there is a escrow holder who performs these duties, Broker is responsible NRS 645.635 (4) Broker Seller and Buyer Within 10 business days
when there is no escrow – the federal form is a for disclosing to the parties in a complete, detailed closing statement all the after the transaction is
holder. HUD-1 receipts and disbursements handled by the Broker for the parties. closed.
Offer or counteroffer No Mandatory Form Licensee must disclose to other party or agent, that the licensee's client has NAC 645.632 Licensee Other party or Within reasonable time.
rejected by client. must be in writing rejected the offer or counteroffer. Licensee must attempt to have client sign their agent.
notice; however, the regulation is only binding on the licensee.
Sale of Residential Residential Disclosure A 15-page disclosure booklet produced by the Nevada Real Estate Division for NRS 645.194 Licensee Seller and Buyer Not stated, but made to.
property. Guide consumers of residential properties. Contains discussions on the most
commonly-required state, federal and local disclosures. Last page is an
acknowledgment receipt which must be filled out and held in the broker's file.
V APPENDIX I - 3
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT DISCLOSURES
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
V APPENDIX I - 4
Requiring FORM PERSON TIME FOR
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED Disclosure
Property tax disclosure. No Mandatory Form Amount of annual property taxes landlord pays for unit and the 1980 NRS 118.165 Landlord/ Tenant/Lessee Every July or
amount of property taxes for the unit. property manager when rent
changes.
New Tenant/Lessee No Mandatory Form, Name and address of: 1. person managing premises, 2. person authorized NRS 118A.260 Landlord/ Tenant/Lessee Whenever there
or new landlord. given to Tenant/Lessee or to receive legal notices and demands, 3. principal or corporate owner. NRS 118A.270 property manager is a new Tenant/Lessee,
posted in conspicuous place. Additionally, the telephone number of a responsible person within the county new landlord, or
to be called in emergencies. Information must be kept current. information changes.
Termination of landlord’s No Mandatory Form Termination of landlord’s interest in rental property by either sale, assignment, NRS 118A.244 Landlord/ Tenant/Lessee Before transfer of deed.
interest in property. death, appointment of receiver or otherwise. Notice of new successor in interest property manager
(owner, etc.) name, address, telephone number, and statement that the Tenant/
Lessee’s security deposit is being transferred.
Residential Property No Mandatory Form, Seller or landlord must provide buyer/Tenant/Lessee with the EPA disclosure 42 USC § 4852 (d) Seller or Landlord Buyer or Tenant/ As a condition
built before 1978 – but required wording booklet “Protect Your Family From Lead in Your Home” (EPA747-K-94-001), Lessee of the sale or lease
lease or sale. and information. and give notice that buyer/Tenant/Lessee is allowed to perform a lead-based agreement.
Lead Paint paint risk assessment/inspection. Buyer/Tenant/Lessee may cancel.
Increase in rent. No Mandatory Form Increase in rent, amount of increase. NRS 118A.300 Landlord/property Tenant/Lessee 45 days before increase
manager due.
Adoption or change No Mandatory Form Adoption of Tenant/Lessee rules and regulations. Timing may be waived by NRS 118A.320 Landlord/property Tenant/Lessee 30 days before
of tenancy rules or Tenant/Lessee if consents in writing. manager enforcement.
regulations.
Required in any No Mandatory Form Defines public nuisance under NRS 202.450 - .470. NRS 118A.200 (1) Landlord, agent, Tenant/Lessee With any written rental
written rental agreement. but required statutes property manager agreement.
property disclosures
New Unit in CIC - Public Offering Statement Identifies type of CIC (condo, cooperative, planned community), construction NRS 116.4102 Declarant or Dealer Initial Buyer Date offer becomes
Common Interest schedule, the CIC’s bylaws, rules, regulations, C,C & Rs, financial statement, 116.4103 (seller) binding on buyer.
Community. budget, service, initial or special fee, warranties, cancellation notice, 116.4104
judgments or lawsuits, monthly fees, CIC Information statement, date of
information. Development rights of contractor. Location and description of
proposed improvements. Buyer cancellation rights NRS 116.4108.
New Unit which may Public Offering Statement Same as above + number & identity of units. Total number of shares with NRS 116.4105 Declarant or Dealer Initial Buyer Date offer becomes
become Time Share. minimum duration. (seller) binding on buyer.
New Unit – Converted Public Offering Statement Same as above + description of present condition of all structural components NRS 116.4106 Declarant or Dealer Initial Buyer Date offer becomes
Building. and mechanical, electrical installations. Useful Life of each item. Outstanding (seller) binding on buyer.
uncured building code or other municipal violations and cost to repair.
(Applicable to buildings with 13+ units)
New Unit – Notice of Conversion Notice of conversion, public offering statement, and right of Tenant/Lessee and NRS 116.4112 Declarant or seller Existing Tenant/ 120 days before Tenant/
Converted Building in CIC. subtenant/Lessees to acquire that unit on same or better terms than declarant Lessee/ renter Lessees required to vacate.
offers to public.
Sale of any Subdivision,* Property Report Name & address of each person owning a 10%+ interest in the subdivision. NRS 119.182 Broker or salesman Buyer Before signing of any
lot, parcel, unit or As prepared by the Name, occupation, address of every officer, director or owner of the subdivision. purchase contract.
interest in subdivision. Nevada RED Legal description and area of lands, condition of title, public utilities, conditions
of disposition of land with copies of related documents, use of land, maximum
*see NRS 119.110 for depth of fill, soil condition (with engineering reports), statement of liens for
definition of subdivision. improvements, agricultural activities in area adversely affecting property. Notice
of right of buyer to cancel contract.
Subdivision Sale of any No Mandatory Form Location in subdivision of rights-of-way and easements for transmission lines of NRS 119.1835 Developer Buyer Before signing any
lot, parcel, unit or public utility electric lines and in all lands contiguous to it. binding agreement.
interest in a subdivision.
Subdivision Sale of any No Mandatory Form Location in subdivision of rights-of-way and easements for transmission lines of NRS 119.1835 Developer Buyer Before signing any
lot, parcel, unit or public utility electric lines and in all lands contiguous to it. binding agreement.
interest in a subdivision.
V APPENDIX I - 5
property disclosures
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
V APPENDIX I - 6
REQUIRING FORM PERSON TIME FOR
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED DISClosure
When licensee becomes No Mandatory Form Licensee must disclose any material and relevant facts, data or information which NRS 645.252 (1)(a) Licensee All Parties “As soon as is practicable.”
an Agent in a real estate licensee knows, or by the exercise of reasonable care and diligence, to transaction
transaction. should have known, relating to the property.
Previously unsold home No Mandatory Form Water & sewage rates of a public utility servicing 25 to 2,000 customers. Notice NRS 113.060 Seller Buyer Before the home is sold.
+ any improved lot. must contain name, address, and telephone numbers of public utility and Div.
Consumer Complaint for the Public Utilities Comm. of NV.
New construction – No Mandatory Form - Zoning classification & master plan designation of subdivision or parcel map. NRS 113.070, Seller or any person Initial Buyer Before signing sales
subdivided land. separate written document Designated land use of parcel and general land uses of adjoining parcels. Clark Co. Code who sells land that agreement or
Notice that the designations are subject to change. Provide instructions on how 7.65.010, or was subdivided. opening escrow,
to obtain current zoning information. 30.36.040 whichever is first.
Unit not occupied by No Mandatory Form Provide copies of certain statutes (NRS 11.202 - .206, and NRS 40.600 - .695). NRS 113.135 Seller Initial Buyer Upon signing
buyer more than 120 These statutes deal with construction defect claims. sales agreement.
days before completion.
Unit not occupied by No Mandatory Form Notice of “soil report” prepared for the property or for the subdivision in which NRS 113.135 Seller Initial Buyer Upon signing
buyer more than 120 the property is located. After receipt of notice, buyer has 5 days to request copy sales agreement.
days before completion. of the actual report and 20 days to rescind the sales agreement. Rescission
right may be waived.
Sale of any land. No Mandatory Form Any conditions or obligations connected with any gift or other free benefit offered NRS 599A.060 (1)(d) Seller Customer Not stated, but
to potential buyers. made to “prospective”
customer.
Offering for sale or lease Statement of Record, Interstate Land Sales Full Disclosure Act, (ILSFDA). Administered by HUD through 15 USC § 1701-1720, Developer & agents. Buyer or Before any sales
across state borders, and Property Report. the Office of Interstate Land Sales Registration. Extensive and detailed 24 CFR Parts Lessee / agreement or
undeveloped “subdivided” requirements for disclosure items are included in the Statement of Record 1700-1730.100, Tenant/Lessee lease, is signed.
(25+ parcels) land not and Property Report. These include, but are not limited to, title condition, NRS 119.119
larger than 20 acres each. soil condition, availability of recreation facilities, utilities and their fees,
number & type of buildings currently on site, etc. If disclosure does not adhere to
all guidelines, buyer has two (2) years to rescind the contract.
property disclosures
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
REQUIRING FORM PERSON TIME FOR
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED DISClosure
Sale of property by No Mandatory Form Notice that city, county, school district and special districts are not obligated to NRS 119.183 Seller Buyer Before signing any
“seller of more than one furnish any service (specifically mentioning fire and roads), and that public binding agreement.
lot created by a map of utilities may not be obligated to service parcel.
division into large parcels.”
Property being sold No Mandatory Form All that is required to be stated is that the final subdivision map NRS 278.350 Seller or agent Buyer Not stated, but
before the final has not been recorded. made to “potential buyer.”
subdivision map is
recorded.
Property subject to No Mandatory Form Actual or pending impact fees. Amount of impact fee not yet paid and the name NRS 278B.320 Seller Buyer Before property
impact fee. of the local government which imposed (or will impose) the fee. is conveyed.
HUD – FHA loan HUD adopted Licensees should be aware of the various Hazards and Nuisances required to be 24 CFR part 200 Appraiser Lender/insurer At time of
insurance, appraisal Fannie Mae appraisal listed on FHA appraisal Forms. These include: Airport Runway Clear Zones; appraisal inspection or
Hazard and Nuisance (Form 1004) Railroad tracks & other high noise sources; Flood zones (as determined under when licensee becomes
disclosures. FEMA maps); Radon, Overhead high voltage transmission towers & lines; aware of a H & N.
Operating & Abandoned oil & gas wells, tanks, and pressure lines; presence of
asbestos, foam plastic/core materials; lead based paint; and avalanche hazard.
A licensee must always disclose to all parties any condition affecting the property
of which the licensee is aware, whether or not disclosed under an FHA insured
appraisal (NRS 645.252.)
Property subject to No Mandatory Form Lien for deferred taxes. Interestingly, the amount of lien nor the entity creating NRS 361A.290 Seller Buyer When property is
deferred taxes. the lien is required to be disclosed. Deferred taxes statutes - NRS 361A.265, sold or transferred.
361A.280 or 361A.283.
After any construction No Mandatory Form Disclosure of construction defects. Written disclosure must be in understandable NRS 40.640 (5) Contractor & agents Buyer Before purchase.
by any contractor. language, underlined and in boldfaced capital letters.
V APPENDIX I -7
property disclosures
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
REQUIRING FORM PERSON TIME FOR
V APPENDIX I - 8
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED DISClosure
Any construction, No Mandatory Form; Informs owner of the Nevada “Recovery Fund” available to the property owner NRS 624.520 Contractor Owner At time of
remodeling, repair or however, NRS 624.520 when a residential contractor fails to perform qualified services adequately. signing contract.
other improvements on has suggested wording Notice must identify NRS 624.400 to NRS 624.560. Real Estate Licensee should
a Single-family residence for Notice. be aware of this notice when representing a seller or buyer and there has been
(SFR). construction or contractor services on the property.
Whenever a general No Mandatory Form Requires a general building contractor to provide specific information to a SFR NRS 624.600 General Building Owner No time specified.
building contractor owner about material men and subcontractors and their right to lien the property contractor
contracts with a SFR under NRS 108, Mechanics Lien laws. Real Estate Licensee should be aware of this
owner. notice when representing a seller or buyer and there has been construction
or contractor services on the property.
Title to property is No Mandatory Form Property’s title is unmerchantable. “Unmerchantable” = unmarketable, “bad title”, NAC 645.635 Licensee Buyer Before any part of
unmerchantable. or nonmerchantable. Property title a reasonable buyer would refuse to accept purchase price is paid.
because of possible conflicting interest in or litigation over the property.
Property subject to a No Mandatory Form Provide copies of all notices of construction defect given to contractor(s), all NRS 40.688 Claimant, Owner Buyer Generally, immediately
construction defect claim opinions of experts; terms of any settlement, order or judgment of defect claim; or Seller upon signing sales
under NRS 40.600 - .695. detailed report of all repairs made. ** Note ** Timing of disclosure is complicated agreement. See ** note.
– 30 days before COE; or if complaint is made while in escrow, w/i 24 hours of
complaint; or if escrow is less then 30 days, immediately upon signing.
Resale – Residential. Seller’s Real Property An evaluation by the seller of the condition of property systems (plumbing, NRS 113.120 to Seller Buyer 10 days before
Disclosure – electrical, etc.) and the condition of any other aspect of the property which NRS 113.150 property conveyance
may effect its use or value. Information is based on what seller is aware or as agreed between
RED Form #547 of and is not a warranty. Includes statutes NRS 113.140 - .150(5). the parties.
Non-disclosure allows buyer to rescind sales agreement. Buyer may waive all rights.
Resale – Home in CIC – Required disclosures, Required disclosures: Resale Package Copy of declaration, rules or regulations NRS 116.4109 Unit’s owner - seller Buyer By parties’ agreement,
Common Interest plus Form - Before You of association, statement of monthly assessment, unpaid assessments, current NRS 116.41095 but before close of escrow.
Community. Purchase Property … operating budget, financial statement of association, summary of financial
components of Reserve Study, unsatisfied judgments, status of any pending
RED Form #584 legal actions. Buyer may cancel within 5 days after receipt of resale package.
Before You Purchase Property in a Common-Interest Community
Did You Know…
PROPERTY DISCLOSURES
EVENT REQUIRING DISCLOSURE FORM WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE TIME
DISCLOSURE NAME PERSON FOR DISCLOSURE
Residential Property built No Mandatory Form, Seller or landlord must provide buyer/Tenant/Lessee with the EPA disclosure 42 USC § 4852 (d) Seller or Landlord Buyer or Tenant/ As a condition of the sale
before 1978 - lease or sale. but required wording booklet “Protect Your Family From Lead in Your Home” (EPA747-K-94-001), and 24 CFR part 35, Lessee or lease agreement.
and booklet. give notice that buyer/Tenant/Lessee is allowed to perform a lead-based subpart A
www.hud.gov/offices/ paint risk assessment/inspection. Buyer/Tenant/Lessee may cancel if lead is
lead/1018/selr_eng.pdf found.
Revision Effective: Open Range Disclosure Property is adjacent to open range on which livestock are permitted to graze or NRS 113.065 Seller Buyer Before signing sales
July 1, 2009 RED Form 551 roam. Property may also be subject to county or state claims of rights-of-way agreement.
Home or Improved or granted by Congress over public lands (commonly referred to as R.S. 2477),
Unimproved Lot detailed in Form 551. Identifies fencing requirements and warns about harming
adjacent to open range. livestock. Open range is all unenclosed land outside cities or towns.
Buyer obtaining an FHA For Your Protection Get a Informs buyer about the limits of the Federal Housing Administration and HUD mortgage Lender or licensee Buyer/Borrower Before or on signing sales
insured home loan. Home Inspection Form is suggests buyers obtain a home inspection to evaluate the physical condition of letter agreement.
HUD-92564-CN the property prior to purchase. 99-18
Purchase of HUD-owned Radon Gas and Mold PURCHASERS ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED AND UNDERSTAND THAT RADON GAS AND HUD Notice 2004-8 HUD-licensee Buyer At presentation of sales
SFD property. Notice and Release SOME MOLDS HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO CAUSE SERIOUS HEALTH PROBLEMS. (released may 28, agreement.
Agreement. HUD Form Outlines HUD responsibility for home being sold “as-is” by HUD. Encourages buyers 2004)
9548-E(6/04) to obtain inspections.
Property in Road No Mandatory Form Notice property is within Road Maintenance District. The amount of assessments NRS 320.130 Seller Buyer Before property is sold.
Maintenance District for the last two (2) years.
Selling Used Used Manufactured/ Informs consumer that a manufactured home is personal property and is subject NRS 645.258 Broker/Licensee Buyer Before property is sold.
Manugactured (Mobile) Mobile Home Disclosure to personal property taxes unless converted. Also, instructs consumer to submit
Home with underly real RED Form #610 certain documents to Nevada’s Manufactured Housing Division pursuant to NRS
property. 489.521 and NRS 489.531.
Property was Meth Lab. No Mandatory Form If the property was the site of the manufacture or preparation of NRS 40.770(6) Licensee or seller Buyer or tenant Before sale or rental.
methamphetamine (meth). No disclosure is necessary if the property has been
declared safe for habitation by a governmental agency.
Effective: Energy Consumption An evaluation of the energy consumption of property based on State-prescribed NRS 113.115 Seller Buyer Before close of escrow
January 1, 2011 Evaluation Disclosure standards and information about State programs for improving energy for the conveyance of
Form to be prepared and consesrvation and efficiency in residential properties. Evaluation served to property.
published by the Nevada buyer must have been completed 5 years or less from date parties enter into an
V APPENDIX I - 9
Energy Commissioner. agreement to purchase. Includes statues NRS 113.115. Buyer may waive rights.
property disclosures
county specific disclosures as of february 2006
V APPENDIX I - 10
EVENT DISCLOSURE LEGAL CITE RESPONSIBLE GIVEN TO LAST POSSIBLE
REQUIRING FORM PERSON TIME FOR
DISCLOSURE NAME WHAT IS BEING DISCLOSED DISClosure
Property in a subdivision No Mandatory Form Copy of deed restrictions IF property is located in a county with a Population NRS 278.565 Seller Buyer Not stated, but presented
subject to deed restrictions. between 100,000 and 400,000. As of February, 2006, this is only applicable to to “prospective” buyer.
in Washoe County . Washoe County.
When the Property has Presented at sale of any residence, or change of title of any residence Washoe Co. Health Seller or agent Buyer Before escrow is complete
a Wood Burning Stove or in Washoe County. Dist. Regulation or title is changed.
solid fuel burning device 040.051§§ A & D
in Washoe County.
New construction. No Mandatory Form Gaming Enterprise District – (for NV counties with a Population over 400,000. NRS 113.080 Seller Initial Buyer 24 hrs before signing
Currently, only As of Feb. 2006, this is only applicable to Clark County). Copy of most recent sales agreement,
Clark County. gaming enterprise district map, the location of the nearest gaming enterprise time may be waived.
district and notice that map is subject to change.
Selling Residential No Mandatory Form Information sheet presented to real estate licensees titled “What Every Realtor Information sheet Licensees Clients Information sheet only.
Property in Churchill Should Know About Water in Churchill County”. Provided by the City of Fallon, only, not required
County. 2001. Local professional associations, such as the Sierra Nevada Association of by code or statute.
Realtors®, may have other consumer disclosure pamphlets.
Any property subject to No Mandatory Form Lake Tahoe – Best Management Practices – Residential property at Lake Tahoe TRPA Code of Licensees Clients and Various.
Lake Tahoe Regional is subject to multi-jurisdictional environmental controls that regulate ground, Ordinances §25.5.A consumers
Planning Authority. water and air quality in the Tahoe area. Licensees need to be aware of these
restrictions, called Best Management Practices, when dealing with Tahoe property.
appendix I I
1. Brokerage Signs................................................................................................................................................................10
2. Franchises and Fictitious Names................................................................................................................................10
3. Teams....................................................................................................................................................................................10
4. Licensee Status.................................................................................................................................................................11
5. Cold Calling and the “Do Not Call” Laws..................................................................................................................12
F. review......................................................................................................................................................................................................................17
1. NRS 645.254 (3) A core duty of the real estate licensee is to promote the interests of the client by seeking
2. NRS 598.0905 “a sale, purchase, option, rental or lease of real property ... at the price . . . acceptable to
the client.” 1 Most licensees advertise to promote either the client’s property or to market
3. NAC 645.610 (3)
the licensee’s services. The public has a societal interest in promoting accurate and fair
4. NRS 41.710 representations of the things or services being advertised.To this end, various laws regulate
real estate advertising. Here, we explore the advertising laws that impact the licensee’s
marketing plan, whether marketing the licensee’s services or the client’s property.
VI - 3
5. NRS 207.174
to control commerce for the public good examples of such laws.14 8. NRS 207.173
by requiring merchants to present a true
9. 15 U.S.C. §1601 et seq.
picture of what is being sold. Truth in 4. FosteRing Equal Access
advertising is such an integral concept 10. NRS 598 – Deceptive Trade
Practices.
to our free market economy that the law Finally, many advertising laws are
provides for civil penalties for a violation5 designed to ensure that members of 11. NRS 645.630 (1)(b) A licensee
shall not make false promises
and has made intentional false advertising various protected classes have equal access
to influence, persuade or
a crime.6 A court has the authority to order to advertised services and properties. induce; NRS 645.633 (1)(8), a
such false advertising stopped through These rules are found in the fair housing licensee shall not participate
an injunctive action.7 Interestingly, actual laws.15 in any deceitful, fraudulent or
dishonest conduct.
deception of a consumer is unnecessary
(in other words, the consumer doesn’t 12. NRS 645.990 (1)(b) a person
who sells or attempts to sell
need to have been actually deceived); any
any interest in real property
statement with the tendency to deceive is by means of intentional
subject to the law.8 misrepresentation, deceit or
fraud is guilty of a category D
felony. A category D felony is
Other laws that fall under the True Picture 1-4 years in prison and a fine of
purpose include the federal Truth-in- not less than $5,000.
Lending laws9 and Nevada’s Deceptive 13. Federal Sherman Act, 15
Trade Practices statutes.10 Various real estate U.S.C. §3 et seq. and Nevada’s
statutes require licensees to advertise in an Unfair Trade Practices chapter
NRS 598A.
honest and truthful manner.11 Intentional
misrepresentation, deceit or fraud by a 14. Federal “Do Not Call” Act,
real estate licensee is a felony criminal act 47 U.S.C.§227; and 15 U.S.C.
§1601, as well as Nevada’s Do
subjecting the licensee to imprisonment.12 Not Call laws found in NRS
228.590 and NRS 598.0918.
2. Promoting Fair Trade
15. Federal Fair Housing laws
42 U.S.C. § 3604(c) (1991) and
Some advertising laws are designed to 42 U.S.C. §1982, and NRS 118,
ensure fair trade and competition in the specifically made applicable to
real estate licensees under
open market. These are the state and NRS 645.321.
federal anti-trust laws. The real estate
licensee is subject to both sets of laws.13
nevada law on advertising VI - 4
16. NRS 228.590 & 5. Sources of Advertising Law
NRS 598.0918.
17. Clark County Code Advertising laws are found in federal, In addition to federal and state laws and
30.72.040. state, county, city, and local laws, statutes, regulations, a real estate licensee may
codes, and ordinances. Many of the state be subject to various local advertising
18. Las Vegas Municipal
Code 6.42.140-145. statutes echo federal law. For example, restrictions. These restrictions range
anti-discrimination housing laws are from controlling the size and placement
19. Henderson found in both federal and state law. of signs, to door-to-door solicitation
Municipal Code 4.72.200.
hours, to the permitting and placement
20. NRS 233B.040 (1) Generally, federal law is the controlling of handbills. For example, Clark County
law and any state law in conflict has a “sign” code which establishes
21. NAC 645.690 with federal law will not be enforced. parameters regarding the location of
However, at times, federal law allows signs;17 the Las Vegas Municipal Code
state law to take precedence if that law is addresses the distribution of handbills;18
within certain parameters. For example, and the City of Henderson’s Municipal
the federal “Do Not Call” laws provided Code restricts the hours a solicitor may
that a state may make “Do Not Call” laws knock on a residential door.19
that are more restrictive than the federal
law, but it will not allow state laws that There are various administrative
are more lenient than the federal law. regulations that impact a licensee’s
Nevada’s “Do Not Call” laws are more advertising. When applicable, these
restrictive and thus are the controlling law regulations have the force and effect of
in Nevada. Nevada real estate licensees law.20 In Nevada, the regulations are
who are “cold calling” are required to codified in the Nevada Administrative
follow the stricter Nevada “Do Not Call” Code and the cites have the designation
laws.16 of NAC. The Nevada Real Estate
Commission, and the Real Estate Division
with Commission approval, promulgates
regulations. (NRS 645.190). The Real
Estate Division oversees enforcement of
those regulations. If a licensee is found in
violation of an advertising regulation, the
RED may grant a licensee up to 10 days
to correct any deficiency. After a hearing
it may suspend or revoke a real estate
license if the licensee fails to timely correct
the noticed deficiency.21
VI - 5
22. NAC 645.610 (1)(a),
NRS 207.171.
The conspiracy part (two or more brokers) An “advanced fee” is when the broker
of an anti-trust violation claim need not charges a client a fee in advance of
be based on a formal agreement between performing services.30 In the advertising
competitors to price fix. A general casual realm, most advance fee agreements occur
conversation between when a broker advertises that he or she
competitors that results has a list of potential properties, clients
in common terms or or rentals available and will provide that
prices is sufficient to list for a fee.31 When a licensee takes an
warrant the charge of advanced fee, the licensee cannot advertise
anti-trust. and imply that a buyer for the property is
immediately or soon available.32
VI - 7
A licensee taking available property return email and physical postal address; 34. NAC 645.613
information from the internet and selling a clear and conspicuous “opt-out”
that information is a violation of this provision which must be honored by the 35. NAC 645.610
regulation unless the licensee has the sender within 30 days; and a notice “clear 36. NAC 645.613 (2)
owner’s permission. and conspicuous” that the email is an
advertisement or solicitation. There is 37. 16 C.F.R. Part 316
5. The Internet no prior or existing business relationship
38. NRS 41.705 et seq.
exemption.
The law concerning what constitutes 39. 47 U.S.C. §227 et seq.
appropriate advertising on the internet If a licensee is found in violation of the
continues to evolve. Nevada statutes and FTC rules, he or she may be fined up
regulations provide that the dissemination to $250 per violation (that is per email
of unsolicited information concerning real that went out), with a maximum award
property or the marketing of real property of $2 million dollars. There is also the
is “advertising” and all advertising laws possibility of five years imprisonment if
are applicable.34 the emails were sent for the furtherance
of any felony.
When advertising on the internet, each
internet “page” should be considered a Nevada has its own statutes regarding
distinct advertisement and should comply advertising by email.38 For emails, an
with all advertising laws. For example, “advertisement” is defined as an email
identifying the brokerage only on the transmittal, for commercial purpose,
first page of the website and not on each stating the availability of real property,
subsequent webpage may violate the goods or services. The federal law
regulation requiring each advertisement to specifically preempts all state laws that
prominently display the brokerage name.35 expressly regulate commercial emails,
even if such state’s laws are more
There are additional rules whenever a stringent than the federal law (this is
licensee attempts to enter into an agency unlike the federal “Do Not Call” law
relationship with a client by internet. which allows states to have laws that
Though not specific to advertising, these are more stringent, but not less strict,
rules should be reviewed to ensure the than the federal law).
licensee includes the necessary disclosures
and adheres to the appropriate signature For all email advertisements generated
requirements.36 by a licensee, each of the advertising
rules regarding brokerage name, etc. are
6. Electronic Mail (Email) applicable.
VI - 9
44. NRS 645.560
4. Licensee Status
VI - 11
5. Cold Calling and the 56. Federal “Do Not
“Do Not Call” Laws Call” Act, 47 U.S.C. §227;
and 15 U.S.C. §1601, as
well as Nevada’s Do
Cold calling is a common real estate should have an office policy regarding Not Call laws found in
marketing technique. Licensees “cold using cold calling by their agents. NRS 228.590 and NRS
call” when they solicit previously 598.0918.
unknown individuals by telephone in Nevada’s Do Not Call laws are more
57. NRS 598.0915 through
order to sell their real estate services. restrictive than the federal law and are NRS 598.0953.
This type of telephone solicitation is found in Nevada’s Deceptive Trade
currently regulated by both the federal Practices NRS 598 statutes. Nevada’s
and state “Do Not Call” laws.56 Do Not Call rules include:
Briefly, the cold calling procedure requires • No calling between 8 p.m. and 9 a.m.;
a person to gather a list of telephone
“Block-busting”
numbers of potential customers. The • No annoying, abusive or harassing
This is the practice by
licensee or broker must then register with language; which a person frightens
the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). a homeowner into selling
Once registered, the licensee will receive • No fair housing violations – his property at less than
market value by spreading
a list of restricted telephone numbers blockbusting; rumors that certain racial
filed with the FTC. The licensee then groups will move into the
“scrubs” (compares) his or her list against • No claiming to be information gathering neighborhood. AGO
1972-71, March 24, 1972.
the restricted list removing any matching when the intent is to induce a sale;
numbers. The remaining telephone
numbers may be called. Once called, if • The caller must inform the person
the recipient expresses a desire not to be who answers the telephone of the sales
disturbed or called again, the licensee nature of the call within 30 seconds after
must put that telephone number on an beginning the conversation and must
internal “do not call” list. All brokers provide the name, address and telephone
number of the business or organization.57
61. Though not required Advertising a client’s property advertising laws. Specifically, the Nevada
under federal or state
encompasses laws and entities not Administrative Code requires the broker
law, using – and abiding
by – the fair housing previously dealt with when a licensee or to supervise his or her licensees and
disclaimer is a good broker advertises their services. Often, familiarize them with the requirements of
business practice. “We the property owner will want to share federal and state law prohibitions against
list, sell and rent any
property without any in how the property is advertised or in discrimination.58
preference, limitation or the very least, review what the broker
discrimination based on proposes. When advertising a client’s Protected Classes: There are seven federally
race, color, religion, sex
or national origin or any property the broker needs to retain identified protected classes. Nevada
intention to make such a control over the advertised content and fair housing law echoes those protected
preference, limitation or process as it is the broker who retains the classes but includes an eighth class, that of
discrimination.”
most liability for errors, misleading or ancestry.59 In 2011, the Nevada Legislature
fraudulent advertising. added gender identity or expression and
sexual orientation to the protected classes. 59a
In this chapter, the fair housing rules are The federal protected classes are race, color,
reviewed along with the laws regarding religion, sex, handicap (disability in Nevada),
Truth-in-Lending, Regulation Z, property familial status, and national origin.60 Most
signs, land, subdivisions and owner/ fair housing advertising violations arise from
developer regulations as they relate to indicating, either directly or indirectly, a
advertising. preference for, or a bias against, a protected
class.61
1. Fair Housing
Though each protected class may be
Fair housing laws, both federal and state, violated in an advertising forum, the three
are often the first set of restrictions people protected classes which tend to have the
think of when it comes to real estate greatest advertising violations are religion,
advertising. familial status, and sex.
VI - 13
no Muslims), but occurs when expressing meets certain restriction guidelines for 62. Though not a Nevada
a preference for a particular religion (e.g., either 55 or 65 year old or older persons. case but illustrative of the
point, is Commonwealth
Christians preferred). Advertising for “mature”, “retired”, or of Virginia v. Lotz Realty
“settled” persons is a violation unless an Company, Inc., 376
Brokers have been found in violation of exemption applies. S.E.2d 54 (Va., 1989),
the fair housing laws when they placed in which the broker
Paul Lotz was found in
signs, symbols or other indices of religion The licensee should be careful about violation of Virginia’s
in their advertising.62 Additionally, allowing the client to express a fair fair housing laws
violations can occur when references are housing violation in an indirect manner when he placed signs,
symbols and wording
made in the advertising to a local religious by advertising that certain properties have on his advertisements
site, e.g., “house within walking distance “children only” sections, or that children indicating a religious
of Beth Shalom”. An exception may be will require an additional deposit or fee. No preference for clients
based on a specific
granted when the religious institution real property advertisement should include religion.
mentioned is of such national recognition any reference to a bias against children or a
that it becomes a landmark, such as the preference for childless persons. 63. 24 C.F.R. §109.15 (i)
National Cathedral in Washington, D.C. (4-1-94)
VI - 15
Any advertising in Nevada of a Whenever a licensee is hired by a 75. NRS 119.184
subdivision, whether that subdivision developer to sell subdivisions, the
is in Nevada or another state, must licensee must ensure that the advertising 76. NAC 119.015
be pre-approved by the Nevada Real was submitted to and approved by the
77. NAC 119.035
Estate Division.75 Advertising under Real Estate Division.80 Nothing in the
the subdivision regulations additionally subdivision laws of Nevada excuses a 78. NAC 119.040
includes any advertisement for the person licensed under NRS 645 from the
79. NAC 119.050.
retention of purchasers after the sale.76 obligations imposed in NRS and NAC Under NAC 119.080 a
In advertising subdivisions, all advertising 645.81 vacation certificate is a
rules apply when using traditional written promise which
offers accommodations
advertising media as well as when the There are very specific laws and in or transportation
licensee uses any telephone solicitation,77 regulations regarding sales presentations. to any location as
promotional meetings,78 or the offering of For example, all oral and written part of a program to
solicit prospective
vacation or other gift certificates.79 advertising designed to induce any
purchasers to attend a
attendance at or participation in a sales sales presentation for a
presentation must conspicuously include subdivision.
the following statement: “The purpose of
80. NAC 119.400
(the event or activity) is to attempt to sell
you property in (name of state in which 81. NAC 119.330 (2)
property is located).”82
82. NAC 119.455, see also
NAC 119.500 to 119.520.
VI - 17
At no time does an “as is”
clause allow the seller or
licensee to conceal or not
disclose known defects.