Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AT
HELD AT
ON
4TH MAY, 2016
ahabeebb4u@gmail.com/+2348133835092
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
2
DEDICATION
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
3
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
5
KEY POINTS
• The rationale for Sugarcane value chain development in Nigeria is premised
on several grounds that include: viability as a lever for guiding the country’s
economic transformation; creating huge number of job opportunities; raise
local production to attain self sufficiency; contribute in the development of
sugar by products i.e molasses and bagasses; stern the tide of unbridled
importation; potency for addressing the growth inclusiveness challenge facing
the country; and effectiveness in driving sustained growth through delinking
the economy from fluctuations in commodity prices and weather conditions.
• To take advantage of these benefits, Nigeria needs to take advantage of its
vast potentials in wide array of activities that include agricultural commodity
(sugarcane for this paper) and similar activities.
• Structural transformation of sugar sub sector is possible in Nigeria through
Global Value Chain development via industrialization, technology upgrade,
emergence of new ancillary activities, export diversification, and inclusive
growth promotion like Vertical Integration (Backward and Forward
Integration Programmes)
• The current active support of the government through the Economic
Transformation Agenda, specifically the Implementation of Nigeria Sugar
Master Plan under the coordination of the National Sugar Development
Council is creating a momentum leading to emergence of some Sugarcane
Value Chain firms.
• To consolidate these gains and tackle the remaining challenges, there is need
to articulate a national policy on value chain development, deepen reforms to
further improve the business and regulatory environment, focus on areas of
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
6
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
7
INTRODUCTION
Data obtained from the National Sugar Development Council (NSDC) indicates
that sugar consumption in 2012 was 1.1m tonnes against the domestic
production of 10,843 tonnes.
Within the period, 1.1m tonnes was imported at $517.2 million5. To address
the shortage, the Federal Government has come out with a policy to increase
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
8
local production. The policy aims at instituting mini sugar plant technology
and a package of incentives.
But industry watchers, who applaud the policy, said with a landmass of over
500,000 hectares suitable for cane and capable of producing over five million
metric tonnes of sugarcane, the nation had no business importing sugar4.
Nigeria produces two per cent of its requirement, importing 98 per cent of the
commodity3. Due to challenges faced by sugar cane farmers, which have made
the commodity highly unexploited, key players have remained in the business
by importing from Brazil.
There are five major players in the industry: Dangote Sugar Refinery (DSR),
BUA Sugar Refinery, Savannah Sugar and Josepdam Sugar Company, and Flour
Mills of Nigeria. Dangote Sugar produces 1.44 million tonnes. BUA adds
720,000 metric tonnes8.
Dangote Refinery, which supplies 70 per cent of the local market requirement,
plans to spend $1.5 billion to increase output over the next five years. 8
It is expected that Nigeria should be able to produce 1.5 million metric tonnes
locally, from around 50,000 metric tonnes now5
To revamp the sector, the Federal Government has initiated incentives for an
enabling environment for investors.Among the incentives are zero per cent
duty on machinery and spare parts by companies, as well as 10 per cent
import duty and 50 per cent levy on imported raw sugar. There is equally a 20
per cent duty and 60 per cent levy on imported refined sugar 5.
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
9
The government has also begun a credit support scheme for sugarcane
growers through the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) and commercial banks; in
addition to provision of infrastructure, such as access roads, boreholes, power
lines, land acquisition, and health care facilities for new sugar estates.8
But the challenge remains evolving strategies to meet the demands of about
168 million consumers and prevent huge spending on imports.
Industry players contend that there is an urgent need to establish mills where
sugarcane can be crushed. They also add that sufficient portions of land
should be made available to grow the plant. Sugar cane farmers complain of
dearth of industrial buyers which leads to immense post-harvest wastage.
States as Katsina, Zamafara, Jigawa, Imo, Ogun, Kwara, Kogi, Edo, Cross River,
Benue,Oyo, Taraba, Ogun, Plateau, Ondo, Anambra and Adamawa.have the full
potentials to utilize sugar as one of its major source of revenue on which along
the value chain will provide them with huge job opportunities as well as
industrialization and market that will boost their respective economies5. Sugar
industry is a promoter of investment, job and wealth creation and a tool for
rapid rural development as it creates communities that are self-sufficient. For
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
10
example, in India, sugar industry employs one million people directly and six
million indirectly and that is very much applicable in Nigeria. This will stem
the tide of importation and enhance the production of ethanol and electricity
generation.
Painfully, Nigeria produces two per cent of the 2.5 million metric tonnes of
sugar required for its 170 million population while over 75 per cent of raw
sugar is imported and granulated by a few investors in the sugar sector8. Thus,
the country is the lowest producer in the region, in spite of abundant raw
materials for sugar production across the country3.
For instance, Benin Republic produces 25.6 per cent of its sugar requirement;
Burkina Faso, 47 per cent; Cote d’Ivoire 54 per cent; Senegal, 48 per cent and
Mali, 28 per cent5
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
11
Nigeria is highly endowed with basic inputs and commodities that would
normally form the foundation for GVC. The country is rich in sugarcane which
holds a high potential for significant value chain processes that remain largely
untapped. The lackluster performance has deprived the country of all the
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
12
benefits derivable from a vibrant sugar sector. Chief among these are the
annual drain on the nation's foreign exchange earnings put at N101.9 billion in
20115, the loss of hundreds of thousands of employment opportunities for
skilled and semi-skilled labour and food insecurity arising from sugar import
dependence. Recently, several efforts are being made to improve the Value
chain and integrate it to the Global Value Chain. Thus;
The Plan has estimated that Nigeria’s demand for sugar would breach the 1.7
million metric tonnes (MMT) mark by 2020. To be able to satisfy this from
domestic production, need to establish some 28 sugar factories of varying
capacities and bring about 250,000 hectares of land into sugarcane cultivation,
over the next 10 years. The bulk of the investment capital will come from
private investors.5
The implementation of the NSMP has been making steady progress with 17
sites already earmarked for development – 10 sites with pre-feasibility studies
ongoing or concluded and three green field projects ongoing. There was also
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
13
the commissioning of 4500 tcd plant, which started under NSMP to be carried
out in the second quarter of 2016; two new 12,000 and 9,000 tcd major plants
ordered and to be test-run by 2017, bringing total installed capacity to nearly
30,000 tcd or about 500,000 tonnes sugar per annum8.
For the first time in over 30 years, the industry was able to attract fresh
investment, with $3.16 billion pipeline investment commitments. There has
been a total of N15 billion funds created with BOI and BOA under Managed
Fund Agreements, leveraging on the sugar levy accruals, achieved, with
smuggling reduced to the barest minimum, through the administration of a
sugar import quota regime and a robust monitoring and evaluation
framework3.
For the first time as well, the implementation of the NSMP is being done in
collaboration with officials from different government agencies – National
Sugar Development Council (NSDC ), Federal Ministries of Finance,
Agriculture, Works, Power, NAFDAC, Standards Organisation of Nigeria,
Customs, and the Manufacturers Association of Nigeria, among others, which
constitute the technical committees working together to oversee NSMP
implementation with over N4.5 billion already paid up. Domestic stability in
sugar market prices have also been together to oversee NSMP
implementation5.
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
14
The sugar value chain includes many stages: the production of sugarcane on
farms; the processing of sugar, ethanol and derivate products in mills;
research, technical assistance and financial services; transportation;
commercialization; and exports. All of these links build a network around
sugarcane will no doubt enhance economic growth. The output of a mill
depends on the supply of sugarcane and capital goods4. The main products
(ethanol, sugar, and energy) are sold to fuel distributors, the food industry,
wholesalers, retailers, exporters and electric energy distributors. Byproducts
are destined to other industries, wholesalers and retailers of other sectors
such as orange juice and animal feed. In addition, sugarcane mills use
residues, such as vinasse and cake filter, as biofertilizers4.
the area cultivated with sugarcane is either owned or leased by mills while
35% belongs to independent producers – mostly under some form of contract.
The following are identified as the major benefits;
One of the most important potential benefits for the Nigerian people is
the immediate reduction in pollution at large cities. As compared to
gasoline and diesel, emissions from engines run on ethanol are
increasingly smaller with considerable improvements in air quality and
thus quality of life.
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
16
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
17
CHALLENGES
The observed weak sugarcane value chain development and global integration
in Nigeria despite the high potentials hinges on several identifiable challenges.
Thus ;
i) There is weak local technological and skill capacity in key areas that
could strengthen sugar value chain development and global
integration. For example, the country’s industrial and manufacturing
base is yet weak with limited capacities in important areas like
fabrication and metallurgy for simple crushers to be used in open
pan technology3.
ii) Weak regulatory and institutional framework for domestic
production of quality sugar that would meet the minimum acceptable
specifications in global developed markets. Existing regulatory and
institutional frameworks are duplicative, and with overlapping mandates that
evoke confusion among market players.
iii) Weak state of sugarcane and sugar infrastructure. Over the years, the
state of infrastructure in Nigeria has ranked below average. In 2010,
for instance, Nigeria ranked 100 out of 155 countries in
the Global Logistics Performance Index1. The good news is that the situation
has gradually improved over the years with a peak ranking of 75 out of 160
countries in 2014. Despite this improvement, challenges remain high in
logistics and infrastructure1,
iv) Though the NSDC’s Backward Integration Programme (BIP) is
contributing a lot in providing proper linkages i.e the outgrowers of
sugarcane and the processors, Yet, there is insufficient coordination
mechanisms as the scheme is yet to cover the whole country and also
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
18
NSDC are from time to time facing weak compliance from the side of
some investors. In some areas, for instance, there is no effective
coordination among farmers, farm gate buyers, processors, and
sellers. Buyers and suppliers do not have code of standards that
would compel farmers to comply with given quality criteria.
v) Weak overall global competitiveness. The performance of the
Nigerian economy in the global indices measuring competitiveness
has not been sufficiently satisfactory. For instance, the World
Economic Forum ranked Nigeria 115th out of 144 countries in its
2013 Africa Competitiveness Report9. Similarly on the World Bank’s
Doing Business, the country has not been faring too well, sliding in its
global ranking from 138 out of 189 countries in 2013 to 147 in
20149.
vi) Limited support to local producers and processors in facilitating
their participation in sugar value chains. The production and
processing of sugarcane and sugar that could be integrated into the
global value chain is undertaken predominantly by NSDC, individuals
and SMEs without significant active support from the State
Governments.
vii) Inadequate or lack of electricity continues to be a big factor militating
against any industrial development in Nigeria, Sugar sub sector
cannot be an exception.
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
19
To effectively develop and integrate Sugar value chain in Nigeria into the GVC
and avoid the current marginalization in GVC trading activities,
implementation of some salient policy recommendations are necessary.
a) Articulate a clear National Policy on Value Chain Development that is
effectively integrated with the national trade, industrial development
and competitiveness strategies. This should provide streamlined
approach to, not just domestic value addition, but also GVC integration.
The policy should be effectively aligned with the country’s Industrial
Development Policy and the Vision 20:2020.
b) Deepen policy to further improve sugar and ethanol business and
regulatory environment to make investment in GVC attractive to
domestic industries and globally successful transnational corporations.
c) The provision of basic infrastructure such as electricity, water, transport,
ports and logistics should be given more attention. Existence of these
basic infrastructures will improve sugarcane value chain development
and global integration in several activities including ethanol bagasses
and molasses.
d) There is also need to improve access to credit for local businesses,
especially SMEs.
e) The state and local governments needs to redirect their policies towards
the improvement of Sugarcane, processing it, and it’s marketing. These
will no doubt create huge economic activities within their respective
states.
f) Facilitative role of government is also required to improve access
to land for commercial agriculture and building factories. This will require a
reform of the current land titling system. Regulatory agencies such as
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
20
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
21
Conclusion
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
22
AKNOWLEDGEMENT
1) I thank the Departments of Policy Planning Research and Statistics
(PPRS) and Technical Services (TS) of NSDC for the Research works that
generated this paper. I acknowledge all the efforts done by the people
and establishments I used as references.
2) I acknowledge the generosity of the Central Organizing Committee of
the National Economic and Poverty Eradication Conference (NEPEC) for
this opportunity.
3) Continuous appreciation to my parents, Alhaji Habib Ilyas and Haj.
Fatima Ibrahim
REFERENCES.
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB
23
Office. Online:
http://www.ilo.org/global/About_the_ILO/Media_and_public_information/
Feature_stories/lang--en/WCMS_087408/index.htm
8) Quartely Report(2015), National Bureau of Statitics.
9) Quarterly Report(2014) Africa Competativeness Report
DEVELOPMENT OF SUGARCANE VALUE CHAIN IN NIGERIA;AN IMPORTANT TOOL FOR REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH
BY ABDULLAHI HABIB