You are on page 1of 114

Getting It Right In 2020:

What Washington Employers Need to


Know

Presented by:
Scott Prange
Phone: (206) 247-7022
Email: sprange@fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Agenda

• White Collar Exemptions


• Piece-Rate Pay
• Pay Equity + Salary History Ban
• Paid Family and Medical Leave
• Non-Competes
• Arbitration Agreements

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• General Rule

➢ Under federal/state law, most employees


must be paid at least minimum wage
(whichever higher) and overtime at rate
of 1.5 times regular rate

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Exemptions

➢ Several “white collar” exemptions, where


employees exempt from receiving
minimum wage and overtime
➢ Exemptions narrow; employer must
prove employee “plainly and
unmistakably” exempt. Mitchell v.
PEMCO Mut. Ins. Co., 134 Wn. App.
723, 730-31 (2006).

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Exemptions

➢ Federal/state exemptions do not always


overlap
➢ Where federal/state law both ply
exemptions, most protective for
employee applies

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Exemptions

➢ To qualify for most exemptions, two tests


must be met:
1) Salary Threshold
2) Job Duties Test

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Federal + State Tests

➢ Starting January 1, 2020, new


federal/state salary thresholds and
modified job duties tests apply

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Federal + State Tests

➢ From January 1, 2020, employers must


follow new federal salary thresholds for
overtime exemptions at $35,568/year
($684 per week)

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Federal + State Tests

➢ However, from January 1, 2021,


employers must follow state salary
threshold (depending on size), which will
surpass the federal at $43,004/year
($827/week)

Federal 2021

Washington
fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Federal Salary Thresholds


▪ New (January 1, 2020) ▪ Old
➢Salary Threshold ➢Salary Threshold
$35,568/year
($684/week) $23,660/year ($455/week)
➢Adjustments ➢Adjustments
Every 3 years No
➢Bonuses
10% of salary threshold ➢Bonuses
can be meet with No
nondiscretionary bonus ➢Highly Compensated
payments, incentives,
commissions Employees
➢Highly Compensated $100,000
Employees
$107,432 (including at
fisherphillips.com least $684/week salary)
White Collar Exemptions

• New Federal Job Duties Test

➢ No significant changes

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Washington Salary Thresholds

➢ First change since 1976


➢ From January 1, 2020 -
• Determined by employer’s size + multiple of state’s current
minimum wage for 40-hour workweek
▪ Employer’s size determined by total number of state-
based employees regardless if full/part time
▪ New statute provides multiple of state’s minimum wage for
40-hour workweek
• Salary threshold cannot be met by counting payment of non-
discretionary payments, e.g. incentive payments, bonuses,
commissions
fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Washington Salary Thresholds

➢ From 2020 to 2028, state’s minimum salary threshold will


increase incrementally at start of each year:
• For employers with 50 or fewer employees, increase is
slower than that for those with more than 50
• By 2028, threshold same for all employers regardless of size,
and all salaried employees exempted from overtime will earn
2.5 times minimum wage
➢ After 2028, threshold will increase only if minimum wage is
adjusted for inflation

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Washington Salary Thresholds

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Washington Salary Thresholds

➢ Likewise, for computer professional exemption, new minimum


hourly wage thresholds apply:

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Washington Job Duties Test

➢ Main ”white collar” exemptions mostly now conform with federal law

➢ Still no highly compensated employee exemption


fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Washington Job Duties Test

➢ For teachers – payment required on salary or fee basis, but without


minimum pay rate. Federal salary threshold would then kick in.

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• New Washington Job Duties Test

➢ For academic administrators – salary must be at least equal to


entrance salary for teachers in educational establishment involved.
Federal salary threshold would then kick in.

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Washington Job Duties Test

➢ For outside salespeople – salary but no minimum pay rate.

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Washington Job Duties Test

➢ Agricultural workers – no change.

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Washington Job Duties Test

➢ Agricultural workers
• Under RCW 49.46.130, most agricultural workers working on
farm still exempt from overtime, including:
▪ Soil cultivation
▪ Raising a crop – including harvesting any agricultural or
horticultural commodity
▪ Handling livestock – including raising, shearing, feeding,
caring for, training, and management of livestock, bees,
poultry, furbearing animals, and wildlife
▪ Farm operations – including management, conservation,
improvement, or maintenance of a farm, its tools and
equipment
fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Washington Job Duties Test

➢ Agricultural workers
• Additionally, other agricultural workers still exempt from overtime
if:
▪ In packing, packaging, grading, storing, or delivering any
agricultural or horticultural commodity
▪ In commercial canning, freezing, or processing any
agricultural or horticultural commodity including its delivery to
a terminal market for distribution for consumption
▪ In the cultivation, raising, harvesting, and processing of
oysters, including delivery to a terminal market for distribution
for consumption
fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

• Washington Job Duties Test

➢ Agricultural workers
• Martinez-Cuevas v. Deyruyter Brothers Dairy, Inc. and
Washington State Dairy Federation and Washington State Farm
Bureau, on appeal from Yakima Superior Court, No. 96267-7
(2019)
▪ Pending @ Supreme Court
▪ Decision expected 2020
▪ Will determine if agricultural workers entitled to overtime

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

➢ Planning Ahead

▪ Take opportunity to make sure that


each employee is classified properly
▪ List all employees, noting each’s
classification as either “exempt” or
“non-exempt”
▪ For each, analyze whether exemption
applies respective of both salary paid
and job duties

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

➢ Planning Ahead

▪ Identify employees needing to be


reclassified from “exempt” to “non-
exempt,” because they are or will be
paid less than salary threshold or no
longer meet job duties test

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

➢ Planning Ahead

▪ Calculate financial feasibility and costs


of raising these employees’ pay to new
salary threshold to make exempt versus
reclassifying as non-exempt and paying
overtime

fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

➢ Planning Ahead

▪ If reclassification necessary, prepare


meaningful employee communications
▪ This includes sharing necessary
changes in company policies,
management training, presenting unified
message on how and why changes are
going to be implemented, and positive
individual communications to
reclassified employees who will now
need to keep track of their hours
worked, take required breaks, and may
have change to their benefits
fisherphillips.com
White Collar Exemptions

➢ Planning Ahead

▪ Seek legal advice


▪ New rules are complex, and employers
who do not adhere may be liable for
serious financial penalties, including
unpaid overtime claims

fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Piece-Rate Pay

fisherphillips.com
Piece-Rate Pay

Piece Rate Pay

➢ Employee paid wages based on production (total number of pieces


produced), includes payment by commission
➢ Typically, employee provided incentives to produce more efficiently

fisherphillips.com
Piece-Rate Pay

Piece Rate Pay


▪ Non-Agricultural ▪ Agricultural
➢Sampson v. Knight ➢Carranza v. Dovex Fruit Co.,
Transportation, 2:17-cv- 190 Wn. 2d 612 (2018)
00028 (2019)
▪ Washington’s Minimum ▪ Washington’s Minimum
Wage Act + WAC 296- Wage Act:
121-021: ✓Permits workweek
✓Permits workweek averaging
averaging ✓Requires payment for rest
✓Requires payment for breaks
rest breaks
✓Does not require ✓Requires payment for
payment for activities activities outside of piece-
outside of piece-rate rate work
work
fisherphillips.com
Piece-Rate Pay

Piece Rate Pay

▪ Non-Agricultural
Must Satisfy
Minimum
Wage
Total Wages
$13.50/hour
Total Hours Worked
(Piece Meal + This Is
Activities Outside Regular Rate
Piece Meal Work) for Calculating
Overtime
• Minimum Wage Paid For Rest Breaks;
Rest Breaks Count as “Hours Worked”
fisherphillips.com
Piece-Rate Pay

Piece Rate Pay

▪ Agricultural

Total Wages Must Satisfy


Minimum
Total Hours Worked Wage
(Only Piece Meal) $13.50/hour

• Minimum Wage Also Must Be Paid


For Rest Breaks + Activities
fisherphillips.com Outside Piece Meal Work
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

The legislature finds that despite existing equal pay laws, there
continues to be a gap in wages and advancement opportunities
among workers in Washington, especially women . . .

The long held business practice of inquiring about salary history


has contributed to persistent earning inequalities; Historically,
women have been offered lower pay than men for the same jobs
even where their levels of education and experience are the same
or comparable.

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

State’s pay equity statute provides for:

1) Fair Compensation
2) Salary History Ban
3) Disclosure of Salary/Wage Range

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

1) Fair Compensation
➢Prohibits discrimination b/w “similarly employed” employees
based on gender unless “bona-fide” job-related factor
➢Can’t prohibit employees from inquiring about or discussing
wages
➢No retaliation

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

2) Salary History Ban


➢Employers prohibited from requesting current or potential employee’s
previous salary or wage history
➢Employers may confirm if current or potential employee voluntarily
discloses

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

3) Disclosure of Salary/Wage Range


▪ New Employee ▪ Promotion/Transfer
➢On job offer, upon ➢If no salary range or wage scale,
employee’s request, employer must provide salary
employer must expectation or minimum wage
provide salary or prior to posting the position or
minimum wage for making promotion or transfer
position ➢If salary range or wage scale,
employer must provide upon offer
of promotion or transfer upon
employee’s request
fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

Similarly Situated

If:

➢ Work for same employer


➢ Performance of job requires
similar skill, effort, and
responsibility
➢ Jobs performed under similar
working conditions

*Job titles alone not determinative


fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

Bona Fide Job Factors

Include:

➢ Education, training, or experience


➢ Seniority system
➢ Merit system
➢ System that measures quantity or
quality of production
➢ Regional differences in
compensation
fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

RCW 49.58 (2019)

Compensation

Includes:

➢ Discretionary and
nondiscretionary wages, e.g.
commissions, bonuses

fisherphillips.com
Pay Equity + Salary History Ban

Best Practices:

➢ Update employee handbook, policies


➢ Train management and human resources
professionals
➢ Ensure employment documents, e.g.
applications are compliant
➢ Never inquire about current or potential
employee’s salary or wage history; avoid
confirming former employee’s
➢ Seek legal advice when in doubt

fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Paid Family and Medical Leave

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Covered Employers
• Most employers – no size threshold

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Covered Employees
• Employers exempt if:

✓ Federal agencies
✓ Federally recognized tribes

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Covered Employees
• However, employers may opt for:

✓ Voluntary plan that meets or exceeds the state


plan’s benefits

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Covered Employees
• Employees eligible if:

✓ Localized in state;
✓ They work in state at least 820 hours in first 4
of the last 5 completed calendars, looking back
from the day they intend to take leave. For
2020, lookback will be just 4 quarters.

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Covered Employees
• Employees exempted if:

✓ Federal employees;
✓ Not localized in state;
✓ Covered by CBA in existence before October
19, 2017 (unless reopened, renegotiated, or
expired);
✓ Self-employed

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Premiums
• Total premium = .4% of employee’s gross wages:

✓ Employer shares 63% of premium (if more


than 50 employees);
✓ Employee shares 37% of premium

❖ ESD calculates number of employees


based on average headcount over previous
4 quarters; For new employees, after 2nd
quarter
❖ Employers with less than 50 employees
fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employer Duties
• Employer must use gross wages to calculate
premiums which includes:

✓ Salary, hourly wages, cash value of goods and


services given in place of money,
commissions, piecework, bonuses, gifts,
prizes, meals and lodging, PTO, holiday pay,
vacation leave, sick leave, bereavement leave,
separation pay, stocks, stipends, per diems

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employer Duties
• Employer must:

✓ Every quarter, report to ESD via Secure


Access Washington all employee hours
worked, wages paid, and premiums withheld
✓ Every quarter, remit to ESD employer +
employee share of premiums

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employer Duties

Reporting Quarter Report Due


Q1: January, February, March April 30
Q2: April, May, June July 31
Q3: July, August, September October 31
Q4: October, November, December January 31

❖For 2019, Q1 and Q2 reports were due August 31st

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employer Duties
• Employer must provide notice:

✓ Must post ESD standard notice in work


common area, e.g. break room

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employer Duties
• If employer failed to withhold in 2019:

✓ May still remit employer/employee share


without penalty;
✓ Responsible for employer + employee share;
can’t retroactively withhold employee’s share
✓ Must give one pay period’s notice before
withholding

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Penalties
• If employer fails to remit premiums:

✓ 1st Occurrence: Warning letter


✓ 2nd Occurrence: $75
✓ 3rd Occurrence: $150
✓ 4th + Occurrence: $250
✓ Entire amount of premiums + interest: 1%
compounded monthly; if willful, plus penalty in
same amount

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employer Duties
• Employer must provide employee notice of their
PMFL rights if they become aware that employee
is out for reason that would qualify as family or
medical leave (or combination):

✓ For a duration of 7 consecutive days of work;


✓ Notice must be sent by 5th business day
following the 7th day;
✓ Employer must use notice provided by ESD

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Covered Leave
• Employee may take leave for:

✓ Bonding with child (newborn, adopted, foster);


✓ Care of own serious medical condition or
injury;
✓ Care for family members’ serious medical
condition or injury;
✓ Certain military-related events, e.g. pre- and
post-deployment activities, and related
childcare issues
fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Amount of Leave
• Employee may take an amount of leave up to:

✓ 12 weeks for family or medical leave;


✓ 16 weeks for combined family and medical
leave;
✓ Up to 18 weeks if serious medical condition
during pregnancy

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employee Notice
• Employee must provide:

✓ If practical, 30 day’s notice;


✓ If not practical, as much advance notice as
possible
✓ If ESD determines employee did not provide
adequate notice, employee’s benefits will be
denied for a period of time equal to the number
of days notice insufficient

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employee Applies To ESD


• Employee submits application to ESD to claim
benefits:

✓ Employee must wait 7 days before applying to


ESD (accept birth or placement of child);
✓ ESD provides employer first notice;
✓ Employer has 18 days after first notice to
contest claim;
✓ ESD will send employer second notice
indicating that claim was either approved or
denied
fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Employee Applies To ESD


• Employee’s application to ESD must be supported
by adequate documentation as provided by the
regulations

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PMFL

➢ Usage
• Employee may:

✓ Take consecutive or intermittent leave;


✓ Use in 8-hour intervals

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Amount of Benefit
• Employee may be eligible for:

✓ Maximum weekly benefit of $1,000, adjusted


annually to 90% of state’s minimum wage;
✓ Minimum benefit of $100

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Interaction With Other Leaves


• General Rule

✓ Employer can’t require employee exhaust


other types of leave before using PMFL
✓ There are strict penalties for doing so

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Interaction With Other Leaves


• Employers may not require that employees delay
applying for PFML until PTO exhausted
• Employees can’t typically use PFML and state
PST at the same time
• Employees not eligible for PFML if on
unemployment or workers’ compensation

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Interaction With Other Leaves


• FMLA and PFML run concurrently if eligibility
aligns
• However, FMLA and PFML may run consecutively
if:

✓ PMFL used for family member not covered by


FMLA
✓ PMFL used for eligibility not covered under FMLA
✓ FMLA used in 2019 for pregnancy; PFML used in
2020 for bonding
✓ PMFL application delayed
fisherphillips.com ✓ Intermittent leave
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Interaction With Other Leaves


• Employees can’t typically use PFML and state
PST at the same time
• Employees not eligible for PFML if on
unemployment or workers’ compensation

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Interaction With Other Leaves


• Employees can use PMFL and PTO, vacation or
sick time at same time, if they choose (check
policy); PTO, vacation, or sick time can be used to
“top off”
• Employees can use PMFL and short-term
disability at same time (check policy)

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Job Protection
• Employers with 50+ employees must:

✓ Restore employees returning from PFML to


same or equivalent position if employee
employed at least 12 months and worked at
least 1,250 hours during last 12 months

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Job Protection
• Employers may be required under other laws to
return the employee to the same or equivalent
position such as:

✓ ADA
✓ Always seek legal advice

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Health Benefits
• Not yet clear if employer must maintain health
benefits during PFML leave – regulations still
forthcoming

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Hypo #1
• A storm hits Washington. An employer in Oregon
dispatches employee who typically lives and
works in Oregon to help with repair work.
Employee works temporarily in Washington for
one week, and then returns to work in Oregon for
the employer.
• Is the employee covered?

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Hypo #2
• 1/1/20: Susana gives birth and applies for PFML
benefits. Job protection starts running under
FMLA and PFML.
• 3/25/20: Susana’s FMLA leave expires; she is still
receiving PFML benefits.
• 4/22/20: Susana stops receiving PFML benefits
and is entitled to job restoration

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

WA PFML

➢ Hypo #3
• 2/3/20: Ricardo’s mother-in-law is hospitalized.
Ricardo takes paid family leave under PFML.
• 4/27/20: Ricardo’s PFML benefits end, PFML job
protection expires.
• 6/1/20: Ricardo’s spouse is in a biking accident.
Ricardo takes caregiving leave under FMLA.
• 8/24/20: Ricardo’s job protection under FMLA
expires.

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

Best Practices:

➢ Update employee handbooks, policies


➢ Give employees notice
➢ Ensure compliant postings
➢ Train management
➢ Put tracking systems into place
➢ Seek legal advice

fisherphillips.com
Paid Family and Medical Leave

https://bit.ly/35U9cMd

fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Non-Competes

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

The legislature finds that workforce mobility is important to


economic growth and development. Further, the legislature finds
that agreements limiting competition or hiring may be contracts of
adhesion that may be unreasonable.

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Effective January 1, 2020 . . . [a] noncompetition covenant is void


and unenforceable against an employee unless the employer
meets strict requirements at the time of enforcement

❖ Presumption noncompetition covenant NOT valid and


UNenforceable

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49


• Employees • Independent Contractors
➢Disclosure ➢Disclosure
▪ Disclosed to employee in ▪ N/A
writing no later than
acceptance of job offer,
➢Salary Threshold
unless additional ▪ $250,000 (adjusted
consideration provided annually for inflation)
➢Salary Threshold ➢Term
▪ $100,000 (adjusted ▪ Less than 18 months
annually for inflation) (over 18 months
➢Term presumed invalid)
▪ Less than 18 months (over
18 months presumed
fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Non-Compete?

Does not include:

➢ Non-solicitation agreements
➢ Confidentiality agreements
prohibiting use of trade secrets
➢ Business sale agreements
➢ Franchise agreements

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Salary Thresholds

➢ Salary threshold determined by


compensation reported to
employee on box one of W2 -
this excludes compensation
deferred for tax purposes
➢ Each September 30th, salary
threshold adjusted annually for
inflation using CPI-W

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Park Bench Leave

➢ Non-compete void and


unenforceable on “layoff” without
payment unless compensation
given to employee equivalent to
base salary at time of termination
for period of enforcement minus
compensation earned through
subsequent employment during
period of enforcement
fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Moonlighting

➢ Can’t restrict employee earning


less than 2 X minimum wage from
having additional job

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Forum

➢ Forum for non-compete must be


Washington

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Retroactivity

➢ Remember, existing non-


competes must comply with new
requirements at time of
enforcement; if not, they may not
be enforceable

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

HB 1450 (2019), adding Chapter RCW 49

Damages

➢ Even if Court “blue pencils,” employer


loses
➢ Actual damages or $5,000/violation
plus reasonable attorneys’ fees and
costs

fisherphillips.com
Non-Competes

Best Practices:

➢ Ensure non-compete strictly meets


requirements
➢ Give employee non-compete well before
commencing work; ensure employee
executes
➢ Separate from employee handbook; use
stand-along arbitration agreement
➢ Ensure employee has been given adequate
consideration:
• New employees: Job is enough
• Current employees: a promotion, raise,
one-time discretionary bonus
fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Arbitration Agreements

fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

PROCEDURAL + SUBSTANTIVE

fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

Adler v. Fred Lind Manor, 153 Wn.2d. 331 (2004)

Substantive unconscionability involves cases where a clause or


term in the contract is alleged to be one-sided or overly harsh.
“Shocking of the conscience,” “monstrously harsh,” and
“exceedingly calloused” are terms sometimes used to define
substantive unconscionability.

Procedural unconscionability is “the lack of a meaningful choice,”


considering all the circumstances surrounding the transaction
including the manner in which the contract was entered, whether
the party had a reasonable opportunity to understand the terms of
the contract, and whether the important terms were hidden in a
maze of fine print.
fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

Burnett v. Pagliacci Pizza, 194 Wn.2d. 1001 (2019) (currently on


appeal; decision expected in 2020)

Court asked if employer’s arbitration agreement unconscionable:

1) Did employee receive and sign arbitration agreement before


commencing work?
2) Did employee have meaningful opportunity to read and understand
before signing?
• Was it buried in employee handbook?
• Was it in one document or split among many?
3) Was arbitration agreement supported by adequate consideration?
4) Did employee have chance to opt out?
fisherphillips.com
Arbitration Agreements

Best Practices:

➢ Give employee arbitration agreement well


before commencing work; ensure employee
executes
➢ Separate from employee handbook; use
stand-along arbitration agreement
➢ Ensure employee has been given adequate
consideration:
• New employees: Job is enough
• Current employees: promotion, raise,
one-time discretionary bonus
➢ Give employee chance to opt-out
➢ Seek legal advice
fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM
Thank You
Please Follow Me On Linkedin:

Presented by:
Scott Prange
Phone: (206) 247-7022
Email: sprange@fisherphillips.com
fisherphillips.com
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORKPLACE LAW TM

You might also like