Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SUMMARY: This study proposes a workflow, to combine data from logs and cores to
establish information of exploratory and production interest, which allows visualizing the
results of the integration of geochemistry data with geomechanics in gas or petroleum
prospects in shales (Shale Gas or shale oil). Correlation was performed by conventional
statistical analysis. The laboratory data used for geochemistry were organic content
measurements TOC, Tmax, grain density, S1, S2 and S3. The geomechanical parameters
were the compressional velocity Vp, the shear velocity Vs and some static elastic moduli.
The logs used were: measurements of gamma ray, sonic, density, neutron porosity and
resistivity. Then parameters such as: dynamic Young's Modulus (E), dynamic Poisson Ratio
(ν), organic TOC content (Passey, Tristan and regression methods) and fragility (Rickman)
were calculated. Correlation was performed using statistical correlation methods (regression,
correlation coefficient analysis, principal component analysis, etc.) and combination of
variables according to the literature review, for example, TOC vs Young's Modulus, TOC vs
Poisson ratio, TOC Vs Brittleness.
The trend observed in the behavior of the Young's Module (E) with respect to the organic
content (TOC) follows an inverse relationship. For the data from the Colombian wells
examined this relationship is true in most cases.
The analysis of the data does not provide a clear behavior pattern, so there is not a good
understanding of the effect of the organic matter content with respect to the Poisson ratio.
The same situation was found in the literature review.
Fragility is a parameter that is related in a complex way to lithology, mineral composition,
amount of organic matter, effective stress, reservoir temperature, diagenesis, thermal
maturity, porosity and type of fluid (Wang & Reed, 2009). Some authors discard the presence
of organic matter, but it is clear that the organic matter is a constituent part of the matrix
(especially in shale rocks producing gas or petroleum), the fragility of the rock is affected. It
is necessary that mechanical anisotropy is also sensitive to the kerogen content. This situation
was observed with data from Colombian wells.
1
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
The methodology applied to the correlation of geomechanical and geochemical data allowed
to present, for practical use, the effects and trends that have been made between the
geochemical and geomechanical variables of shales producing gas or oil in Colombian wells.
1 INTRODUCTION 2 UNCONVENTIONAL
RESERVOIRS (UCR) OF TYPE
According to the prospective (BP, 2016) SHALE
for 2035, the shale revolution will
continue. The aforementioned report Shale gas systems are dominated by TOC,
projects a 24% share of global gas maturity, mineralogy and permeability,
production. This paper is based on a while shale oil systems are dominated by
bachelor thesis whose objective is to similar properties but lower levels of
identify trends and possible patterns of maturity. One important problem when
behavior of geomechanical parameters in evaluating shale oil systems is to identify
function of the geochemical properties of whether the oil was generated in situ or has
Shale rocks (Ortiz Murcia, Ribón, migrated into that source rock from
Bejarano, & Pérez, 2016). The shale another source rock, this will make a
deposits are unconventional deposits, difference between treating the reservoir
which are at the place where the as conventional or unconventional (Philp,
hydrocarbons were generated (source rock 2015).
or generator) and in the place where the The term Shale describes a wide variety of
hydrocarbons are stored (warehouse of rocks that are composed of fine particles
rock). Fluids as hydrocarbon found in (usually diameter smaller than 4μm), and
these deposits, commonly are identified as varying amounts of silt size particles
"shale" deposits, have the same general (more than 62.5 μm). The deposition of
characteristics of the fluids contained in these grain sizes occurs very slowly and in
conventional deposits, however, their deposit environments with low slopes.
exploration differs considerably due to the The shales present a wide mineralogical
typical properties of the generating rocks. compositional range that includes: clays,
The present article presents a methodology quartz, feldspars and heavy minerals
for combining data from well logs and (Passey et al., 2010).
laboratory measurements, to establish
required information for exploration and 2.1 Characterization of UCR
production purposes, which allows the
visualization of the results of the According to the state of the art on UCR of
integration of geochemical data and shale type (Ortiz Murcia, 2015), it has
Geomechanics. been found that current trends in the
Simultaneously, the application of the exploration and development focus on
proposed methodology to a set of well data three main areas of study: (1) Petrophysic,
from Colombian formations is presented (2) organic geochemistry and (3)
and the conclusions drawn from this geomechanics of reservoirs (Buller et al.,
analysis are presented. 2010; Labani & Rezaee, 2014; Passey et
al., 2010; Philp, 2015; Pitcher, Buller, &
2
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
3
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
4
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
proposed methodology. G
H=Horizontal, V=Vertical, *Number of
Table 2 Minimum Input Data laboratory data points (measurements)
Geochemistry Geomechanic & others
Variab Variab The available parameters must be
Source Source
le le established as it is shown in Tables 4 and
-Lab 5.
-TOC lab
-
TOC -Rock- Vp
Compression Table 4 Geochemical Parameters
Eval
al Sonic log TO
TM R
-Rock- Ke C S S S H O P
Tmax / -Lab AX O
Eval y % 1 2 3 I I I
Ro / Vs -Shear Sonic ºC %
-Study of wt
LOM Log
Macerals P1
-Rock- Rock -Lab H X X X X X X X X
S1
Eval density -Density Log P1
-Deep V X X X X X X X X
-Rock-
S2 RD Resistivity P2
Eval
Log. H X X X X X X X X
Hole P3
-Caliper Log
-Rock- Quality V X X X X X X X X X
S3
Eval Radio- -Gamma Ray P3
activity Log H X X X X X X X X X
TOC=total organic carbon; Tmax, S1, S2 and P4
S3 are parameters from pyrolysis Rock-Eval H X X X X X X X X X
analys; Vp= compressional wave velocity; P4
Vs= shear wave velocity. V X X X X X X X X X
HI=Hydrogen index, OI=Oxygen index
A general inventory of laboratory data and PI=Production Index derived from S1,
could be as follows: S2, S3, TOC data.
Table 3 Wells and Formations Table 5 Geomechanical Parameters
LAB DATA* D S F
Geological
N We Geo- Geo- Ke UC BT T Vp Ebrit
Key Formation
To S Vs E
o ll mecani chemis E
y S vbrit
s v v
c try Brit
P1H 19 A P1
1 P1 428 X X X X
P1V 22 B H
C P1
2 P2 P2H 13 106 X X X X
D V
P3V 24 P2
X X X X
3 P3 78 A H
P3H 24 P3
X X X X
P4H 44 E V X
4 P4 68
P4V 43 F
5
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
6
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
7
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
8
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
9
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
10
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
prospects in shales (Shale Gas or shale exploitation of shale deposits has been
oil). enriched with abundant knowledge of
The applied methodology, to the correlate recent years. At present, the metrics that
geomechanical and geochemical data, govern this type of reservoir have been
allowed to present the effects and trends established, among which key parameters
that have been made between the such as: TOC, Kerogen type, maturity,
geochemical and geomechanical variables fragility, etc. can be highlighted.
of some Colombian shale formations. • Following the proposed methodology at
this work allows a good integration
Correlation was performed using between geochemical and geomechanical
statistical correlation methods (regression, data, which, as observed in the present
correlation coefficient analysis, principal study, are related in different ways
component analysis, etc.) and combination according to physical and chemical
of variables according to the literature processes that require a careful
review, for example, TOC vs Young's interpretation.
Modulus, TOC vs Poisson ratio, TOC vs • The kerogen type and the maturity stage
Brittleness. are variables that significantly affect the
The trend observed in the behavior of degree to which the geochemical
the Young's Module (E) with respect to the parameters affect the mechanical
organic content (TOC) follows an inverse properties.
relationship. For the data from Colombian • The observed and reported trend on the
examined wells this relationship is true in behavior of the Young's modulus with
most cases. respect to the kerogen content is of inverse
Regarding to the Poisson’s ratio (ν), the relation. For the data from the Colombian
analysis of the data does not provide a wells of the present study this relationship
clear behavior pattern, so there is not a is also fulfilled in most cases.
good understanding of the effect of the • There is no total understanding of the
organic matter content with respect to it. effect of organic matter on the Poisson
Brittleness follows a complex function ratio; The data analysis does not provide a
of compositional and non-compositional clear pattern of behavior, which is in
parameters; despite, some authors agreement with what was found during the
disregard the effect of organic matter, it is bibliographic review.
clear that the organic matter is a • Fragility is a parameter that is related in
constituent part of the matrix (especially in a complex way to various factors
source rocks), therefore the brittleness of (resistance, lithology, texture, effective
the rock is affected by it. It is necessary stress, temperature, type of fluid,
that mechanical anisotropy is also diagenesis, and TOC). It is clear that
sensitive to the kerogen content, among because the organic matter is a constituent
others reasons, because of the alignment part of the matrix (for the type of rocks
tendency of the kerogen. This situation under study), it has an effect on the
was observed with data from Colombian fragility since it is a weaker material than
wells. the inorganic components of the rock.
• Any component of the rock will affect its
5 CONCLUSIONS mechanical response, so that the
geochemical properties can be considered
• The state of the art on the exploration and as effective on the mechanical properties,
11
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
Barree, R. D., Gilbert, J. V., & Conway, Labani, M. M., & Rezaee, R. (2014). The
M. (2009). Stress and Rock Property Importance of Geochemical
Profiling for Unconventional Parameters and Shale Composition
Reservoir Stimulation. In SPE on Rock Mechanical Properties of
Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Gas Shale Reservoirs: a Case Study
Conference. The Woodlands, Texas: From the Kockatea Shale and
Society of Petroleum Engineers. Carynginia Formation From the Perth
https://doi.org/10.2118/118703-MS. Basin, Western Australia. Rock
Mechanics and Rock Engineering,
BP. (2016). Energy Outlook to 2035. 48(3), 1249–1257.
Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1007/s00603-014-
bp.com/energyoutlook. 0617-6
12
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO978110
LeCompte, B., Franquet, J. A., & Jacobi, 7415324.004
D. (2009). Evaluation of Haynesville
Shale Vertical Well Completions Philp, P. (Ocklahoma U. (2015).
With a Mineralogy Based Approach Petroleum and Enviromental
to Reservoir Geomechanics. In SPE Geochemistry [memorias y apuntes].
Annual Technical Conference and In Convenio Marco UIS-Ecopetrol-
Exhibition. New Orleans, Louisiana: ICP No. 5211794, Acuerdo de
Society of Petroleum Engineers, Cooperación No. 6. Bucaramanga,
SPE-124227-MS. Colombia: UIS, CENIVAM.
https://doi.org/10.2118/124227-MS
Pitcher, J. L., Buller, D., & Mellen, M.
Ortiz Murcia, R. D. (UIS). (2015). Estado (2012). Shale Exploration
del arte de los estándares y prácticas Methodology and Workflow. In SPE
recomendadas para explorar y Middle East Unconventional Gas
producir gas y petróleo de Shale Play Conference and Exhibition (p. 10).
en US. Bucaramanga: Grupo de Abu Dhabi: Society of Petroleum
Investigación de Estabilidad de Pozo Engineers.
(not published). https://doi.org/10.2118/153681-MS
Ortiz Murcia, R. D. (UIS), Ribón, H. M. Rickman, R., Mullen, M., Petre, E.,
(UIS), Bejarano, A. (SPSoil), & Grieser, B., & Kundert, D. (2008). A
Pérez, E. R. (Ecopetrol-I. (2016). practical use of shale petrophysics for
Correlación de parámetros stimulation design optimization: All
geoquímicos y geomecánicos de shale plays are not clones of the
formaciones colombianas. Barnett Shale. In SPE Annual
Universidad Industrial de Santander. Technical Conference and Exposition
(pp. 1–11). Society of Petroleum
Passey, Q. R., Bohacs, K. M., Esch, W. L., Engineers.
Klimentidis, R., Sinha, S., & https://doi.org/10.2118/115258-MS
Upstream, E. (2010). From Oil-Prone
Source Rock to Gas-Producing Shale Vanorio, T., Mukerji, T., & Mavko, G.
Reservoir – Geologic and (2008). Emerging methodologies to
Petrophysical Characterization of characterize the rock physics
Unconventional Shale-Gas properties of organic-rich shales. The
Reservoirs. In International Oil and Leading Edge, 27(6), 780–787.
Gas Conference and Exhibition (p. https://doi.org/10.1190/1.2944163
29). Beijing, China: Society of
Petroleum Engineers. Vernik, L. (ARCO), & Liu, X. (Texaco E.
https://doi.org/131350 (1997). Velocity anisotropy in shales:
A petrophysical study. Geophysics,
Peters, K. E., Walters, C. C., & Moldowan, 62(2), 521.
M. J. (2005). The biomarker guide https://doi.org/10.1190/1.1444162
(2nd ed., Vol. I. Biomark).
Cambridge: Cambridge University Wang, F. P., & Reed, R. M. (2009). Pore
Press. Networks and Fluid Flow in Gas
13
7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica 2017
Sustainable Heavy Oil Exploitation, Innovation and Geomechanical Contributions
ISRM Specialized Conference, 13-16 March 2017, Medellin, Antioquia, Colombia
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Research Group in Applied Geomechanics (Eds.)
© 2017, 7° Simposio Internacional de Geomecánica
14