You are on page 1of 9

Journal of Geophysics and Engineering

J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599–1607 (9pp) https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-2140/aa8eb5

A new lithologic classification method for


tight sandstone reservoirs based on rock
components and logging response
characteristics

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


Xueqing Zhou1,2, Zhansong Zhang1,2,3, Chong Zhang1,2, Xin Nie1,2,
Chaomo Zhang1,2 and Linqi Zhu1,2
1
Key Laboratory of Exploration Technologies for Oil and Gas Resources (Yangtze University), Ministry of
Education, Wuhan, Hubei 430100, People’s Republic of China
2
Hubei Cooperative Innovation Center of Unconventional Oil and Gas (Yangtze University), Wuhan,
Hubei 430100, People’s Republic of China

E-mail: zhangzhs@yangtzeu.edu.cn

Received 10 July 2017, revised 6 September 2017


Accepted for publication 25 September 2017
Published 29 November 2017

Abstract
The original lithology classification method for tight sandstone reservoirs has a low prediction
accuracy and it does not accurately reflect reservoir characteristics. We propose a new method
that uses thin sections, logging curves, and core physical data to classify the lithology of the
Ordos Basin, China. First, the relationship between the rock components and physical properties
in the study area was analyzed and we found that quartz and rock debris played an active role in
the properties of the reservoir, while feldspar minerals in the reservoir had a negative effect on it.
Second, we synthesized the logging response characteristics of various rock components and
divided the lithology into (1) high feldspar content, low quartz content, low rock debris content,
and (2) low feldspar content, high quartz content, high rock debris content, using
((quartz+rock debris)/feldspar) as an index for lithologic classification. The lithology
identification model was established using a support vector machine approach with a regression
accuracy of 84.62%. Applying the model to the well in the study area to distinguish the
lithology, results were in good agreement with thin section data, the physical properties of the
reservoir, and the production capacity. Lithology can effectively reflect reservoir characteristics
and play an important guiding role in the identification of reservoirs and the evaluation of
productivity.
Keywords: rock components, lithologic identification, well logging, tight sandstone reservoir

(Some figures may appear in colour only in the online journal)

1. Introduction methodologies like crossplots (Ellis and Singer 2007,


Zhao 2003), linear methods (Busch et al 1987, Kaźmierczuk
Lithologic classification and identification form an essential and Jarzyna 2006, Zhou et al 2007, Zhang et al 2013b, Shi
foundation for the detailed modeling of reservoir stratum et al 2015), curve superposition (Rogers et al 1992) and
parameters. In tight sandstone reservoir strata, prior research multivariate statistics, as well as nonlinear methods (Ge
has mainly focused on how to improve the discrimination et al 2015a, 2015b, 2015c, Hu et al 2015, Sebtosheikh and
accuracy of sandstone types using logging curves. Common Salehi 2015, Sahoo and Jia 2016) and various improved
methodologies (Wang et al 2011, Zhang et al 2012, Zhang
3
Author to whom any correspondence should be addressed. et al 2012, Zhang et al 2013a, He and Liu 2014) represented

1742-2132/17/0601599+09$33.00 1599 © 2017 Sinopec Geophysical Research Institute Printed in the UK


J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

by neural networks were introduced according to the possible


nonlinear relationship between logging curve response char-
acteristics and the lithology of tight sandstone reservoir strata.
Most prior research was designed to improve the dis-
crimination accuracy of sandstone types using logging curves,
while the older petrology classification scheme continued to
be adopted for lithologic classification in tight sandstone
reservoir strata (Krynine 1948, Mcbride 1963). On the one
hand, the logging response characteristics of different lithol-
ogies are not significantly different and it can be difficult to
accurately classify lithology using the logging curves, due to
minor differences in mineral content among tight sandstone
and the great changes in the mineral contents of the same

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


lithology. On the other hand, if the relationship between
different lithology and parameters like reservoir physical
properties, logging response, and production capacity is not Figure 1. Porosity distribution histogram.
considered, the results have little significance to research on
reservoir properties, the evaluation of reservoir parameters, or
reservoir capacity prediction, rendering the classification of
the lithology meaningless. In this study, we first analyzed the
distribution relationship of the physical properties of the
reservoir, and the logging response characteristics, to classify
the lithology by integrating rock slice information, coring
analysis, and logging data. A lithologic classification system
capable of reflecting reservoir characteristics was obtained by
analyzing the relationships between rock components, the
reservoir parameters, and log responses. This method can
accurately classify and describe the lithology of a certain
block in the Ordos Basin while providing guidance for
reservoir parameter evaluation and capacity prediction.

Figure 2. Permeability distribution histogram.


2. Basic features of the reservoir strata

The study area was in the Upper Palaeozoic Permian system,


whose strata from top to bottom are the Upper Permian Shi-
qianfeng formation, the Middle Permian Shihezi formation, the
Lower Permian Shanxi formation, and the Taiyuan formation.
According to an analysis of core properties, the reservoir prop-
erties are fairly tight, the porosity distribution is primarily
2%∼12%, 6.87% on average, and the permeability distribution
is primarily 0.01∼5×10−3 μm2 and 0.76×10−3 μm2 on
average; therefore, it is composed of low-porosity, low-perme-
ability tight sandstone reservoir strata (Folk 1968). The dis-
tribution of porosity and permeability throughout the different
layers are roughly the same (figures 1 and 2), while the porosity
and permeability of the Shiqianfeng and Shihezi formations are
slightly higher than those of the Shanxi and Taiyuan formations.
According to slice observation and statistics, the main pore types Figure 3. Core mercury injection capillary pressure curve.
in the study area are secondary pores, such as intergranular
solution pores, intragranular solution pores, and primary pores content of different layers varies slightly. Overall, the quartz
based on intergranular pores, of which most of the intragranular particle content was a maximum of 68%, a minimum of 27%,
solution pores are feldspar solution pores, rock debris solution and 46.3% on average, followed by the feldspar content
pores, and calcite solution pores. The entire reservoir in the maximum of 61%, 6% minimum, and 29% average. The rock
study area has low porosity and low permeability, multiple pore debris content was a maximum of 35%, 3% minimum, and
types, and complicated pore structure (figure 3). 16.6% on average. The rock debris granulometric composi-
According to the microscopic observation and statistics tion was mainly sedimentary rock, while metamorphic rock
on 70 rock slices from the research area, the rock mineral debris was the second most common type (figure 4). While, in

1600
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

3. Petrological component-based lithology model

3.1. Relationship between the petrological components and


reservoir physical properties

It can be seen from the casting slice and scanning electron


microscope data that the primary pores in the study area were
mainly intergranular, while the secondary pores were mainly
intragranular and intergranular solution pores (figure 6). The
physical reservoir properties were influenced by various fac-
tors, of which the deposition process and diagenesis were the
most important (Zheng and Ying 1997, Zhong et al 2003).
Meanwhile, the influence of deposition and diagenesis was

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


mainly reflected in the content of quartz, feldspar, and rock
debris among the rock (Liu et al 2011, Lai et al 2013a, b).
Figure 4. Histogram of relative content of detrital composition. Quartz maintained primary pores and has higher porosity and
permeability (figure 7); the physical reservoir properties
figure 4, abscissa in turn is quartz, flint, sedimentary rock improved as the quartz content increased. Minerals in the
debris, metamorphic rock debris, alkaline feldspar, plagio- feldspar group were mainly alkali feldspar and plagioclase.
clase, heavy mineral, mica, quartz group, feldspar group and The study area mainly contained alkali feldspar, while pla-
rock debris group. According to the sandstone classification gioclase was mainly composed of neutral acerbic soda feld-
standard (Folk 1968) (table 1), the main rock types are spar. The two physical reservoir properties, porosity and
feldspathic litharenite, lithic arkose, some feldspathic sand- permeability, of the study area reduce as the total feldspar
stone, litharenite, and lithic quartz sandstone. content increased. (figure 7) (Pechnig et al 1997). This is
Because there is an abundance of feldspar in the research primarily due to the fact that the relationship between the
area, this scheme was adopted to classify the lithology based on minerals and feldspar group properties was comprehensively
a hybrid sandstone content of quartz, feldspar, and rock debris. influenced by the content, brittleness, and solubility. During
Differences between the main lithology the feldspathic lithar- the compaction process, anorthite, with a high level of brit-
enite and lithic arkose of the sandstone pore structure were tleness, was easily broken along the cleavage to form various
small (figure 3). The differences in the physical properties of micro-cracks that improved reservoir permeability. However,
various kinds of sandstone in the reservoir were not obvious the study area had a low anorthite content, mainly being
(figure 5), while the sandstone porosity of different types was composed of soda and potash feldspar, two types of feldspar
distributed between 2%∼12% and the permeabilities were that during the compaction process were difficult to break and
between 0.001–6×10−3 μm2. In addition, there were small produce seepage channels, but on the other hand, they provide
differences in the response characteristics of the natural gamma poorer protection for primary pores than quartz, hence the
log curve, tri-porosity log curve, photoelectric absorption cross primary porosity tends to decrease. The rock debris in the
section exponential log curve, and resistivity log curve, between study area was composed of quartzite rock debris, flint stone
various kinds of sandstone in the reservoir (figure 5). According rock debris, and metamorphic rock debris, all three of which
to the analysis, the main reason for these findings is that among are rigid (Zhong et al 2013), and the total rock debris content
rocks with the same lithology, mineral composition varies was positively related to porosity and permeability (figure 7).
greatly, while mineral composition differs slightly among rocks Therefore, the quartz, feldspar, and rock debris content
with different lithology. This makes it difficult to highlight the can be used to propose a lithologic classification index for
effects of a certain mineral on physical reservoir properties and tight sandstone that is capable of reflecting different physical
results in large changes within the same lithology, while the reservoir properties.
logging response characteristics of different lithologies are not
clear. Lithologic classification no longer maintains its prior
3.2. New lithology classification method for compacted rock in
significance, making it difficult to improve log lithology
combination with logging response characteristics
recognition accuracy.
Therefore, because the tight sandstone reservoirs in this According to the previous analysis in this article, all of the
area are low-porosity and low-permeability, with multiple quartz, feldspar, and rock debris in the rock components in
pore types and complicated pore structure, combined with the study area exerted an influence on the physical reservoir
existing reservoir classification ideas (Lai et al 2013a, b, Ge properties, which means that the lithology of the reservoir
et al 2014, Ge et al 2015a, b, c), it is necessary to conduct under good conditions had a high content of quartz and rock
more refined research on the relationship between various debris, and a low content of feldspar. Poor quality reservoir
rock components, reservoir properties, and the log curve lithology was characteristically low in quartz and rock debris,
response to obtain a lithologic classification method suitable while being high in feldspar.
for the tight sandstone reservoirs in this area and assist in The logging curves response characteristics were capable of
refined reservoir parameter modeling and classification. reflecting the reservoir characteristics directly, and could also be

1601
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

Table 1. Sandstone classification.

Lithological triangle Kinds of rocks Quartz+flint (%) Feldspar/rock debris


I quartz sandstone …90
II feldspathic quartz sandstone …75∼90 >1
III lithic quartz sandstone …75∼90 <1
IV feldspathic sandstone <75 …3
V lithic arkose …1∼<3
VI feldspathic litharenite …1/3∼<1
VII litharenite <1/3

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


Figure 5. Cross plot of porosity, permeability and logging response.

used as a reference for lithologic classification. As a result of the response values, and low compensated neutron log (CNL)
differences in mineral physical properties, the rock minerals response values, while differences in the density logging (DEN)
corresponded to different logging curve response values. The and acoustic logging (AC) were not large.
rock debris in the study area was primarily quartzite rock debris, Therefore, in this article, we proposed to use (quartz+rock
which has similar physical properties to quartz; therefore the debris)/feldspar as the lithologic classification index. The index,
logging response value was close to that of quartz. Feldspar was from the perspective of logging response, magnified the differ-
mainly composed of soda and potash feldspar, and the theoretical ences in the different lithologic logging response to improve the
response value of its logging curves integrated the response logging lithologic recognition accuracy. The lithology classifi-
characteristics of soda feldspar and potash feldspar, as shown in cation also made use of the rock mineral content and the phy-
table 2. It can be seen from table 2 that quartz (and rock debris), sical reservoir properties mentioned earlier, so there was a
in comparison with feldspar, had low natural gamma ray (GR) correspondence between the different lithology classifications
response values, low photoelectric absorption cross section (PE) and physical properties.

1602
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


Figure 6. Types of pore and its assembly in research area. (a) Crude residual intergranular pore; (b) intragranular solution pores; (c) crack; (d)
intergranular solution pores.

Figure 7. Relationship between the physical properties and clastic composition.

The logging response characteristics were the direct them based on the original log curve and core slice data in the
reaction of the actual formation conditions. If the logging data study area to obtain the most suitable lithologic classification
are able to correctly discriminate between two types of standard. The final lithologic classification standard is shown
lithology, they can reverse describe the boundary between in table 3.

1603
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

Table 2. Theoretical values of logging response for every mineral. is nonlinearly related to input space. It is based on Vapnik
(Vapnik 1982) statistical learning theory; the SVM method
Well logging response Quartz Feldspar
showed the advantage of the following two aspects (Bing
GR/API low high et al 2012): first of all, SVM is based on theory. SVM
DEN/(g cm−3) 2.65 2.56–2.63 learning problems can be expressed as a convex optimization
CNL/% −2 −1–1.3 problem, so it can effectively use known algorithms to find
AC/(s/m) 165.3×10−6 154.8–180.7×10−6 the global minimum value of the objective function. Other
PE/(B/E) 1.806 2.3–2.8
classification methods (such as neural networks) adopt a
greedy learning strategy to search the hypothesis space. This
method can only obtain the local optimal values. Secondly, in
Table 3. Lithology classification standard. view of the problems of small sample data, nonlinear, high
Lithologic classification standard Condition Lithology dimension, based on the structural risk minimization principle
(Zhang 2011), which may produce a better generalization

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


(Quartz+rock debris)/Feldspar <3.8 high feldspatite
performance than other nonlinear approximation methods.
(Quartz+rock debris)/Feldspar >3.8 low feldspatite
The training sample set is {(xi , yi ), i = 1, 2, ⋅⋅⋅, n}, the
sample input value is xi Î RN , the sample output value is
yi Î R, and n is the sample number.
3.3. Analysis of logging response characteristics with different A nonlinear transformation is used to map the input data
lithology in the training set to a high-dimensional feature space. In this
According to the lithologic classification standard proposed in infinite dimensional linear space, we can find a linear
this article, the capillary pressure curves under core mercury regression estimation function. The form of the estimation
injection of the two lithology types were of clearly different function f (x) is as follows:
shapes (figure 8). High feldspatite had a larger replacement f (x ) = w T F (x i ) + b (1 )
pressure and sharper capillary pressure curve than the low
where w Î RNH , b Î R, F (⋅): 
RN RNH ,
it is nonlinear
feldspatite, which meant that the two types of lithologic
mapping, mapping the input space to a high-dimensional
physical properties were clearly different and the pore struc-
feature space, and b is the offset. The purpose of the solution
tures of the low feldspatite were superior to those of high
is to seek parameters w T, b, so that the input has:
feldspatite. The logging response characteristics under dif-
ferent lithology can be seen in figure 8. High feldspatite had ∣ f (x ) - w T F (x i ) - b ∣  e , (2 )
high PE, high GR, relatively high DEN, and high CNL, while
where ε is a relaxation variable that represents the error metric
low feldspatite had low GR, low PE, relatively low DEN, and
of the data point. According to the response characteristics of
low CNL. Because the GR and PE lithologic curves mainly
the logging curves for different lithologies, we selected the
reflect changes in lithology, high feldspatite had high feld-
four logging curves from the natural gamma ray, photoelectric
spar, low quartz, and low rock debris, so that it approached
absorption cross section index, density, and neutron to be the
the logging response characteristics of the quartz. DEN, CNL
input curves for the model, and set lithology as the output
and AC are the tri-porosity log curves, and the theoretical
curve, while 15 of the 70 slice data points from 18 wells were
response values of the tri-porosity log curves for quartz,
randomly selected as the samples for forecasting. The residual
feldspar and rock debris were not large. The low DEN and
57 modeling samples were divided into three equal sets to
low compensated neutron log of low feldspatite was due to
obtain optimum classification parameters where gamma=
the fact that the physical properties of low feldspatite were
0.0039, nu=2 for cross validation. Comparing the perfor-
better than those of high feldspatite, with higher porosity and
mance of SVM and BPNN methods in the training and testing
low density values in terms of density logging. The study area
process. The final lithologic modeling results can be seen in
also contained a low-porosity and low-permeability air layer,
table 4.
the excavation effect of which may have resulted in the low
neutron log of the low feldspatite. The acoustic logging and
resistivity logging were not sensitive to the two types of
lithology, so differences in logging response characteristics 4. Applied examples
were not obvious.
In this article, we used established litholigic models to eval-
uate a particular well in the study area with two sections of
3.4. Lithology recognition
1475 m–1485 m and 1050 m–1060 m as the example. The
According to the logging response characteristics of different lithologic profile is shown in figure 9. In this figure, the first
lithology, different lithology and logging curves are non- track is the lithologic curve track containing three curves, GR,
linear. In order to improve the accuracy of lithology recog- PE and CAL; the second track is the porosity curve track
nition, we use a support vector machine (SVM) to distinguish containing DEN, CNL and AC; the third track is the depth
lithology. In pattern recognition, the SVM algorithm con- track that indicates well depth; the fourth track is the litho-
structs nonlinear decision functions by training a classifier to logic section for the lithologic model calculation established
perform a linear separation in high-dimensional space which by the support vector machine; and the fifth track is the slice

1604
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


Figure 8. Cross plot of logging response and core mercury injection capillary pressure curve.

Table 4. Comparing the performance of SVM and BPNN methods in the training and testing process.

Model Number of modeling sample Regression rate Forecast number of sample Discrimination accuracy
SVM 57 91.28% 13 84.62%
BPNN 57 89.47% 13 69.2%

photo. At 1050 m–1057 m, the logging lithologic model lithology of the 14 test layers with relatively higher produc-
classification was high feldspatite, which was identical to the tion capacity were primarily low feldspatite and the lithology
lithology corresponding to the core slice at 1052.46 m; at of the test layers with lower capacity were primarily high
1476–1482 m, the logging lithologic model classification was feldspatite. In addition to the physical reservoir properties, the
low feldspatite, which was consistent with the lithology of the capacity was also influenced by features such as fractured
core slice at 1480.55 m. The upper core porosity was makeup, gas saturation, and more, while the lithologic clas-
4.5238% and permeability was 0.112×10−3 μm2, while the sification method proposed in this article can be regarded as
lower core porosity was 7.82% and permeability was one evaluation index that can assist in identifying favorable
0.474×10−3 μm2. The physical properties of the low feld- reservoirs and their production capacity.
spatite were superior to those of high feldspatite, while the
entire lithologic section matched well with the slice data and
5. Conclusions
physical reservoir properties.
To better validate the accuracy of the lithologic classifi- (1) The existing lithologic classification scheme for tight
cation, we summarized the lithology of the 17 wells in the 27 sandstone reservoirs follows the composition-formation
test layers of the study area obtained by the proposed litho- classification scheme in petrology, while the study area for
logic index (figure 10). The figure clearly shows that for the this paper was mainly composed of lithic feldspathic
seven natural and highly productive test layers, the lithology sandstone and feldsarenite, with feldspathic sandstone,
was low feldspatite. For test layers with fractured makeup, the lithic sandstone, or lithic quartz sandstone. The differences

1605
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


Figure 9. Lithologic profile.

between the physical properties of the lithology layers and


the logging response characteristics were not obvious, so it
was difficult to identify the lithology using the log curve.
(2) The quartz, feldspar, and rock debris found in the
petrological grouping had an important influence on the
physical reservoir properties. Quartz was positively
related to the physical properties because quartz is a
rigid mineral that preserves primary pores well during
reservoir anadiagenesis. Feldspar was negatively related
to the physical properties because the study area was
composed of soda and potash feldspar, two types of
feldspar that does not produce favorable seepage
channels during the compaction process, in addition to
the fact that they do not preserve primary pores as well
Figure 10. Frequency statistics of different productive capacity levels as quartz. The rock debris was primarily rigid and
of different lithology. improved the physical properties of the reservoir.

1606
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al

(3) The best application for using the (quartz+rock debris)/ Lai J et al 2013a Pore structures evaluation of low permeability
feldspar lithologic classification index is in the division clastic reservoirs based on petrophysical facies: a case study on
of the study area into high feldspatite and low Chang 8 reservoir in the Jiyuan region, Ordos Basin Pet. Expl.
Develop. 40 606–14
feldspatite, where the lithology differs on the physical Lai J, Wang G, Wang S, Zheng Y, Wu H and Zhang Y 2013b
reservoir properties and the logging response character- Research status and advances in the diagenetic facies of clastic
istics have a high log discrimination accuracy. The reservoirs Adv. Earth Sci. 28 39–50 (in Chinese)
classification scheme proposed in this article can guide Liu R, Wang Y and Zhang B 2011 Turbidite sand bodies’ characters
reservoir identification efforts and subsequently evalu- of petrology and mineralogy and its influence on reservoir
physical property in bonan subsag-case of 0–9 sand groups of
ate their production capacity, improving the exploration es_3 Pet. Geol. Recov. Eff. 18 32
and development of tight sandstone resources. Mcbride E F 1963 A classification of common sandstones
J. Sediment. Res. 33 664–9
Pechnig R, Haverkamp S, Wohlenberg J, Zimmermann G and
Burkhardt H 1997 Integrated log interpretation in the German

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jge/article-abstract/14/6/1599/5108116 by guest on 05 September 2019


Acknowledgments continental deep drilling program: lithology, porosity, and
fracture zones J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 102 18363–90
This research project was financially supported by the Rogers S J, Fang J H, Karr C L and Stanley D A 1992 Determination
National Natural Science Foundation of China (no. 41404084 of lithology from well logs using a neural network AAPG Bull.
76 731–9
and no. 41504094). The authors would also like to thank the Sahoo S and Jha M K 2016 Pattern recognition in lithology
anonymous reviewers for their valuable advice and comments classification: modeling using neural networks, self-organizing
that improved this paper. maps and genetic algorithms Hydrogeol. J. 25 311–30
Sebtosheikh M A and Salehi A 2015 Lithology prediction by support
vector classifiers using inverted seismic attributes data and
References petrophysical logs as a new approach and investigation of
training data set size effect on its performance in a
heterogeneous carbonate reservoir J. Pet. Sci. Eng. 134 143–9
Bing P P, Zao S Y and Lu J T 2012 Non-linear AVO inversion based Shi N, Li H Q and Luo W P 2015 Data mining and well logging
on support vector machine Chinese J. Geophys. 55 1025–32 interpretation:application to a conglomerate reservoir Appl.
(in Chinese) Geophys. 12 263–72
Busch J M, Fortney W G and Berry L N 1987 Determination of Vapnik V N 1982 Estimation of Dependencies Based on Empirical
lithology from well logs by statistical analysis SPE Formation Data (Berlin: Springer) (https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-
Evaluation vol 2 SPE-14301-PA 34239-7)
Ellis D V and Singer J M 2007 Well Logging for Earth Scientists Wang J, Guo H and Shi X 2011 Application of multi-fractal
(Dordrecht: Springer) clustering method to carbonate reservoir evaluation with logs
Folk R L 1968 Petrology of Sedimentary Rocks vol 21 (Austin, TX: Well Log. Technol. 35 436–40 (in Chinese)
Hemphill Publishing) pp 714–27 Zhang J, Li J, Hu Y and Zhou J Y 2012 The identification method of
Ge X, Fan Y, Cao Y, Wang Y, Cong Y and Liu L 2015a A hybrid igneous rock lithology based on data mining technology Adv.
method for geological and geophysical data with multi-peak Mater. Res. 466–467 65–9
distributions using the pso-grg algorithm J. Geophys. Eng. 12 Zhang M L, Feng L, Lin J and Zeng K 2013a The optimal selecting
283–91 technique on well logging items and its application to identify
Ge X, Fan Y, Cao Y, Xu Y, Liu X and Chen Y 2014 Reservoir pore complex lithology profile Adv. Mater. Res. 652–654 2508–14
structure classification technology of carbonate rock based on Zhang M L, Zhou B W, Lin J H and Yu F L 2013b Achieving the
NMR T2 spectrum decomposition Appl. Magn. Reson. 45 155–67 logging item’s sensitive analysis of complex lithology by using
Ge X, Fan Y, Chen H, Deng S and Cao Y 2015b Probing the influential the cross plot technique Adv. Mater. Res. 734–737 269–75
factors of NMR T1-T2 spectra in the characterization of the Zhao J 2003 Application of crossplots based on well log data in
kerogen by numerical simulation J. Magn. Reson. 260 54–66 identifying volcanic lithology World Geol. 22 136–40
Ge X, Fan Y, Li J and Zahid M A 2015c Pore structure Zhang X 2011 Structural risk minimization Encyclopedia of
characterization and classification using multifractal theory— Machine Learning (New York: Springer) pp 929–30
an application in Santanghu Basin of western China J. Pet. Sci. Zheng J and Ying F 1997 Reservoir characteristics and diagenetic
Eng. 127 297–304 model of sandstone intercalated in coal-bearing strata (acid
He S M and Liu L W 2014 Using the improved genetic BP neural water medium) Acta Petrolei Sinica 18 19–24 (in Chinese)
network algorithm for lithologic identification Adv. Mat. Res. Zhong D, Zhou L, Sun H, Yao J, Liu X and Luo A 2013 Petrology
1037 389–92 of sandstone reservoirs in Longdong area, Ordos Basin Earth
Hu Q H, Wang C, Zhang X and Fan J J 2015 Application of som Sci. Frontiers 20 52–60 (in Chinese)
neural network in lithology recognition Appl. Mech. Mat. Zhong D, Zhu X and Zhou X 2003 Diagenesis and controlling
713–715 2169–72 factors of reservoir quality of Devonian Donghe sandstones in
Kaźmierczuk M and Jarzyna J 2006 Improvement of lithology and central Tarim Basin J. Palaeogeogr. 5 378–89 (in Chinese)
saturation determined from well logging using statistical Zhou C, Liu Z, Zhang L, Dai D, Li C, Shi Y and Liu G 2007
methods Acta Geophysica 54 378–98 Applications of NMR logs to complex lithology interpretation
Krynine P D 1948 The megascopic study and field classification of of Ordos Basin SPWLA 48th Annual Logging Symp. (Austin,
sedimentary rocks J. Geol. 56 130–65 Texas, 3–6 June 2007)

1607

You might also like