Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E-mail: zhangzhs@yangtzeu.edu.cn
Abstract
The original lithology classification method for tight sandstone reservoirs has a low prediction
accuracy and it does not accurately reflect reservoir characteristics. We propose a new method
that uses thin sections, logging curves, and core physical data to classify the lithology of the
Ordos Basin, China. First, the relationship between the rock components and physical properties
in the study area was analyzed and we found that quartz and rock debris played an active role in
the properties of the reservoir, while feldspar minerals in the reservoir had a negative effect on it.
Second, we synthesized the logging response characteristics of various rock components and
divided the lithology into (1) high feldspar content, low quartz content, low rock debris content,
and (2) low feldspar content, high quartz content, high rock debris content, using
((quartz+rock debris)/feldspar) as an index for lithologic classification. The lithology
identification model was established using a support vector machine approach with a regression
accuracy of 84.62%. Applying the model to the well in the study area to distinguish the
lithology, results were in good agreement with thin section data, the physical properties of the
reservoir, and the production capacity. Lithology can effectively reflect reservoir characteristics
and play an important guiding role in the identification of reservoirs and the evaluation of
productivity.
Keywords: rock components, lithologic identification, well logging, tight sandstone reservoir
1600
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
1601
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
used as a reference for lithologic classification. As a result of the response values, and low compensated neutron log (CNL)
differences in mineral physical properties, the rock minerals response values, while differences in the density logging (DEN)
corresponded to different logging curve response values. The and acoustic logging (AC) were not large.
rock debris in the study area was primarily quartzite rock debris, Therefore, in this article, we proposed to use (quartz+rock
which has similar physical properties to quartz; therefore the debris)/feldspar as the lithologic classification index. The index,
logging response value was close to that of quartz. Feldspar was from the perspective of logging response, magnified the differ-
mainly composed of soda and potash feldspar, and the theoretical ences in the different lithologic logging response to improve the
response value of its logging curves integrated the response logging lithologic recognition accuracy. The lithology classifi-
characteristics of soda feldspar and potash feldspar, as shown in cation also made use of the rock mineral content and the phy-
table 2. It can be seen from table 2 that quartz (and rock debris), sical reservoir properties mentioned earlier, so there was a
in comparison with feldspar, had low natural gamma ray (GR) correspondence between the different lithology classifications
response values, low photoelectric absorption cross section (PE) and physical properties.
1602
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
The logging response characteristics were the direct them based on the original log curve and core slice data in the
reaction of the actual formation conditions. If the logging data study area to obtain the most suitable lithologic classification
are able to correctly discriminate between two types of standard. The final lithologic classification standard is shown
lithology, they can reverse describe the boundary between in table 3.
1603
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
Table 2. Theoretical values of logging response for every mineral. is nonlinearly related to input space. It is based on Vapnik
(Vapnik 1982) statistical learning theory; the SVM method
Well logging response Quartz Feldspar
showed the advantage of the following two aspects (Bing
GR/API low high et al 2012): first of all, SVM is based on theory. SVM
DEN/(g cm−3) 2.65 2.56–2.63 learning problems can be expressed as a convex optimization
CNL/% −2 −1–1.3 problem, so it can effectively use known algorithms to find
AC/(s/m) 165.3×10−6 154.8–180.7×10−6 the global minimum value of the objective function. Other
PE/(B/E) 1.806 2.3–2.8
classification methods (such as neural networks) adopt a
greedy learning strategy to search the hypothesis space. This
method can only obtain the local optimal values. Secondly, in
Table 3. Lithology classification standard. view of the problems of small sample data, nonlinear, high
Lithologic classification standard Condition Lithology dimension, based on the structural risk minimization principle
(Zhang 2011), which may produce a better generalization
1604
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
Table 4. Comparing the performance of SVM and BPNN methods in the training and testing process.
Model Number of modeling sample Regression rate Forecast number of sample Discrimination accuracy
SVM 57 91.28% 13 84.62%
BPNN 57 89.47% 13 69.2%
photo. At 1050 m–1057 m, the logging lithologic model lithology of the 14 test layers with relatively higher produc-
classification was high feldspatite, which was identical to the tion capacity were primarily low feldspatite and the lithology
lithology corresponding to the core slice at 1052.46 m; at of the test layers with lower capacity were primarily high
1476–1482 m, the logging lithologic model classification was feldspatite. In addition to the physical reservoir properties, the
low feldspatite, which was consistent with the lithology of the capacity was also influenced by features such as fractured
core slice at 1480.55 m. The upper core porosity was makeup, gas saturation, and more, while the lithologic clas-
4.5238% and permeability was 0.112×10−3 μm2, while the sification method proposed in this article can be regarded as
lower core porosity was 7.82% and permeability was one evaluation index that can assist in identifying favorable
0.474×10−3 μm2. The physical properties of the low feld- reservoirs and their production capacity.
spatite were superior to those of high feldspatite, while the
entire lithologic section matched well with the slice data and
5. Conclusions
physical reservoir properties.
To better validate the accuracy of the lithologic classifi- (1) The existing lithologic classification scheme for tight
cation, we summarized the lithology of the 17 wells in the 27 sandstone reservoirs follows the composition-formation
test layers of the study area obtained by the proposed litho- classification scheme in petrology, while the study area for
logic index (figure 10). The figure clearly shows that for the this paper was mainly composed of lithic feldspathic
seven natural and highly productive test layers, the lithology sandstone and feldsarenite, with feldspathic sandstone,
was low feldspatite. For test layers with fractured makeup, the lithic sandstone, or lithic quartz sandstone. The differences
1605
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
1606
J. Geophys. Eng. 14 (2017) 1599 X Zhou et al
(3) The best application for using the (quartz+rock debris)/ Lai J et al 2013a Pore structures evaluation of low permeability
feldspar lithologic classification index is in the division clastic reservoirs based on petrophysical facies: a case study on
of the study area into high feldspatite and low Chang 8 reservoir in the Jiyuan region, Ordos Basin Pet. Expl.
Develop. 40 606–14
feldspatite, where the lithology differs on the physical Lai J, Wang G, Wang S, Zheng Y, Wu H and Zhang Y 2013b
reservoir properties and the logging response character- Research status and advances in the diagenetic facies of clastic
istics have a high log discrimination accuracy. The reservoirs Adv. Earth Sci. 28 39–50 (in Chinese)
classification scheme proposed in this article can guide Liu R, Wang Y and Zhang B 2011 Turbidite sand bodies’ characters
reservoir identification efforts and subsequently evalu- of petrology and mineralogy and its influence on reservoir
physical property in bonan subsag-case of 0–9 sand groups of
ate their production capacity, improving the exploration es_3 Pet. Geol. Recov. Eff. 18 32
and development of tight sandstone resources. Mcbride E F 1963 A classification of common sandstones
J. Sediment. Res. 33 664–9
Pechnig R, Haverkamp S, Wohlenberg J, Zimmermann G and
Burkhardt H 1997 Integrated log interpretation in the German
1607