Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Stefan J. Kowalski & Jacek Banaszak (2013) Modeling and Experimental Identification of Cracks in Porous
Materials During Drying, Drying Technology: An International Journal, 31:12, 1388-1399, DOI: 10.1080/07373937.2013.796484
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained
in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and
should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for
any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of
the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
Drying Technology, 31: 1388–1399, 2013
Copyright # 2013 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
ISSN: 0737-3937 print=1532-2300 online
DOI: 10.1080/07373937.2013.796484
1388
IDENTIFICATION OF CRACKS IN POROUS MATERIALS 1389
damage in kaolin-clay samples subjected to convective at constant force increments of 1 N=s on a universal
drying at different drying conditions are presented. The AE strength-measuring instrument Cometech QC-508A1.[8]
technique is used to validate the theoretical predictions of
numerically determined spots of possible damage estimated Material
on the basis of the thermo-hydro-mechanical drying model. The experimental tests were carried out on cylindrical
samples made of KOC kaolin-clay produced by the
MATERIALS AND METHODS Surmin-Kaolin S.A. Co., Nowogrodziec, Poland. The
Experimental Set-Up chemical composition and physical properties of KOC
kaolin are presented in Fig. 2 and given in Table 1.
Figure 1 presents the scheme of the experimental equip-
The kaolin-clay was delivered in a dry state and before
ment used for the tests of convective drying.
the experiments it was wetted with a prescribed amount
The kaolin samples, cylindrical in shape (7), were dried
of water and mixed to achieve a greasy paste of initial
convectively in the laboratory dryer chamber (Zalmed
moisture content (MC) approximately equal to X ¼ 0.45
SML 42=250=M) (1). The temperature and relative
[kg water=kg dry kaolin]. (X denotes the ratio of water
humidity of the air in the dryer chamber were measured
mass inside the body to the body’s dry mass, and is
every 30 seconds with a Pt 100 temperature probe and a
expressed as both dimensionless or in a percentage.) The
humidity sensor DO 9861T Delta OHM (3), which was
greasy paste was stored and homogenized in a closed box
located close to the drying sample (7). The digital indicator
for 48 h to level the moisture distribution in the whole
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014
TABLE 1
Chemical and mineralogical composition of KOC kaolin
Chemical composition [%]
SiO2 Al2O3 Na2O TiO2 Fe2O3 MgO CaO K 2O roasting loss
51.5 34.5 0.63 0.54 0.54 0.12 0.08 0.01 12.08
Mineralogical composition [%]
Kaolinite Illite Quartz Others
80 9 9 2
technique in material engineering. The AE arises in stressed contacts. Thus, the capillary forces may bring the particles
materials when the elastic energy accumulated in these to atomic contacts at the final stages of the drying process.
materials is released. The released energy is then trans- During drying and calcination, the material becomes
ported throughout the material in the form of elastic waves porous with a relatively high mechanical strength. A charac-
propagating in various directions. It can be measured by an teristic feature of the dispersed systems is the large value of
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014
AE sensor installed at the material surface and registered the interfacial surfaces. This means that such a system
by a variety of AE descriptors; e.g., AE energy per time contains a large amount of surface energy. As a consequence
period (e.g., 30 s), total AE energy, total number of AE of this, the particles (crystalline grains) tend to join each
signals, etc. Knowing these descriptors, one can assess other and create a porous material of a disordered structure.
the quality of dried samples because they measure the The solid skeleton is created so that the surface energy
intensity and number of micro- and macro-cracks. These is decreased, but the particle bonds become thermo-
descriptors constitute solely the source of information on dynamically stable. Two kinds of interactions between
the dried material quality.[14–17] particles exist: electrostatic forces (repulsive) resulting
In our studies, the one- and two-point acoustic emission from the existence of monomial charges on the particle
(AE) technique was used to monitor the effect of crack surfaces, and London’s disperse forces (attractive) caused
formation in the kaolin-clay samples during drying. The by an instantaneous asymmetry of charge distribution as
advantage of the AE method is that it enables monitoring a result of electron fluctuation. The dispersed forces are of
on line time and place of material damage. a long range and create the main force that attracts the
particles to each other.
MATERIAL BEHAVIOR BY DRYING According to London-Heitler’s theory, the energy of
Cohesion Forces attraction of two spherical particles of radius r at a distance
Kaolin-clay after wetting has the consistency of a dis- L from each other reads[19]
persed system, which after dehydration to a moisture con- r
U ¼ A ð2Þ
tent (MC) that is approximately equal to 45% becomes a 12L
greasy paste. The particles of the suspension have the tend-
ency to agglomerate due to the liquid bridges between where A (1020 J) is the Hamaker constant of interaction
them. The negative capillary pressures in these bridges between particles.
involve compressive forces that favor particle aggregation.
The value of this pressure determine Laplace’s formula[18]
1 1
Fk ¼ c ð1Þ
R1 R2
The cohesion force between particles is determined by Let us imagine two particles adjoining each other but
the derivative of the above-mentioned energy with respect placed on opposite sides of a cross-section in a tensed bar
to distance (Fig. 4a). If the force interacting between two atoms is F,
@U r then the stress r is approximately equal to F =L20 , and the
Fk ¼ ¼A ð3Þ strain e ¼ (L – L0)=L0. For stretching the two adjoining
@L 12L2
particles by dL, the stress increases as (Fig. 4b)
The relations above are valid when the distance between
particles is less than 100 nm. For greater distances, the rela-
1 @F 1 @F
tions ought to take into account the phase retardation of dr ¼ 2 dL ¼ de ¼ EðX Þde ð6Þ
the vibrating dipoles.[19] L0 @L L¼L0 L0 @L L¼L0
Material Strength where EðX Þ ¼ ð@F =@LÞL¼L0 =L0 denotes the modulus of
Let us consider the strength of material in the form of elasticity, which is a function of the moisture content
paste in which particles are in atomic contact. The structure (MC).
of such a material has a stable character; i.e., it can be Figure 5 presents Young’s modulus for kaolin-clay
damaged only due to an action of de-cohesion forces. determined experimentally as a function of the moisture
The potential energy of particle interactions U results content.
from attraction and repulsion effects between atoms One can state that each drying process is accompanied
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014
FIG. 4. Interaction between material particles during drying: (a) FIG. 5. Young’s modulus as a function of the moisture content (color
compression or tension; (b) stress vs. inter-particle distance. figure available online).
1392 KOWALSKI AND BANASZAK
where
When the drying proceeds further, the surface of sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
kaolin-clay becomes more and more rigid and stressed, rffiffiffi1
EðX Þ c
and in the critical stress state the particle bonds on the rcr ¼ c 1þ2 ð15Þ
LðX Þ r
surface can be broken off. The rupture of the particle
bonds involves an increase in the free surfaces and thus
The above fracture criterion is suitable for drying
also in some amount of surface energy. If we can consider
material, whose boundary surface is in tension. Then the
the energy lost for plastic deformations and reconstruction
fracture takes place on the surface.
of a crystal lattice during the fracture as negligible, then the
Let us consider an elastic layer in the form of a thin plate
newly created surface energy is, according to Griffith’s
having a flaw (pore) of dimension 2c in the middle. Let us
theory, equal to the work U.[20] Denoting the surface
imagine first a similar layer without a flaw but being sub-
energy as c, then U ¼ 2c, hence two new surfaces arise by
jected to a tensional state of stress generating elastic energy
the fracture. This statement allows us to express the
U0 ¼ const in this sample. A similar layer but with a flaw
maximum strength from Eq. (10) as
in the middle and subjected to the same loading as before
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi contains elastic energy expressed by
EðX Þ
rm ðX Þ ¼ c ð11Þ
LðX Þ pr2 c2
U ¼ U0 þ 2cð2cÞ ð16Þ
E
where L(X) ¼ L0[1 þ jX(X – X0)] is the inter-particle dis-
tance in the drying material at moisture content X, and The second term expresses the released energy of the
jX is the coefficient of linear shrinkage. material because of the flaw, and the third one the
Equation (11) expresses the theoretical strength of dried additional surface energy on the flaw. The slit will increase
material. It informs us that the strength of the dried its size spontaneously only when a decrease of energy takes
material increases due to an increase in Young’s modulus place during the drying process,[20] that is
and decreases in the distance between the particles.
@U
0 ð17Þ
Fracture @c
Any suitable theory of cracking during drying should Differentiating (16), one can find the critical length of
account for the common observations that cracking is the slit ccr, by which the crack formation may begin to arise
more likely if the body is thick or the drying rate is high.[5] for a given stress
This is because these circumstances involve great hetero-
geneity in moisture distribution and induce great stresses. 2cE
Generally, cracks appear at the tips of flaws or pores, ccr ¼ ð18Þ
pr2
where the stress concentration takes place.
The stress that causes the fracture is not the macroscopic The fracture will proceed spontaneously at a given stress
stress r that acts on the network, but rather the stress rc r for all slits with c > ccr.
IDENTIFICATION OF CRACKS IN POROUS MATERIALS 1393
rij;j þ qgi
0; ð19Þ
rrr jr¼R ¼ 0 and rzz jz¼H ¼ 0; ð22aÞ rate equations for the heat and mass transfer. The
distribution and time evolution of the moisture content
ur jr¼0 ¼ 0 and uz jz¼0 ¼ 0: ð22bÞ and temperature in the cylinder can be determined from
the following system of equations[22,23]
The state of stress in the cylinder is fully described by
four components of the stress tensor; namely, rrr, ruu, qs h_ ¼ Kl r2 ðcT W þ cX hÞ vðcT W þ cX hÞ: ð25aÞ
rzz, and rrz. The relation between radial rrr, longitudinal
rzz, circumferential ruu, shear rrz stresses and the displace-
qs cv W_ ¼ KT r2 W lvðcT W þ cX hÞ; ð25bÞ
ments, temperature and moisture content are given by the
constitutive relations
where Kl and KT are the coefficients of moisture mass and
heat transfer, cT and cX are the thermo-diffusion and dif-
@ur
rrr ¼ 2M þ Ae cðTÞ W cðX Þ h; ð23aÞ fusion coefficients, cv
csv þ clv h is the total specific heat
@r of the drying body, l is the latent heat of evaporation,
@uz and v is the coefficient that affects the rate of phase tran-
rzz ¼ 2M þ Ae cðTÞ W cðX Þ h; ð23bÞ sition of liquid into vapor. The influence of body defor-
@r
mation on the distribution of temperature and moisture
ur content is neglected in Eqs. (25a, b) since strains are
ruu ¼ 2M þ Ae cðTÞ W cðX Þ h; ð23cÞ
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014
r assumed to be infinitesimal.
The boundary and initial conditions for mass and heat
@ur @uz transfer are as follows (Fig. 6):
rrz ¼ M þ : ð23dÞ
@z @r
j j@B ¼ Kl gradðcT W þ cX hÞj@B n ¼ am ðlj@B la Þ; ð26aÞ
One of the main problems arising through the drying of
saturated porous materials is the cracking initiated by the
qj@B ¼ KT grad Wj@B n ¼ aT ðWa Wj@B Þ lam ðlj@B la Þ;
drying-induced stresses. Cracks arise when the strength of
the material is exceeded. The energetic strength hypothesis ð26bÞ
is based on the mechanical energy accumulated in the
stressed material and is formulated in terms of an overall cX grad hjz¼0 ¼ cT grad Wjz¼0 ; ð26cÞ
effective stress given by an invariant of the stress tensor
components expressed as follows qjz¼0 ¼ KT grad Wjz¼0 n ¼ aT ðWa Wjz¼0 Þ; ð26dÞ
rðWÞ
Kl ðW; hÞ ¼ f ðhÞ; ð29Þ
gðWÞ
RESULTS
Numerical calculations were carried out for a cylindrical
sample placed on a moisture-impermeable plate (Fig. 6).
Calculations of the time evolution of temperature and
moisture content as well as the distribution of temperature,
moisture content, and stresses in the cylindrical sample
were performed for the data given in Table 2.
The thermal coefficients for water, water vapor, and
moist air are tabled in a range from 0 to 100 C with a step
FIG. 8. Distribution of stresses at the bottom surface of the cylinder of one degree in the textbooks.[26–28] The coefficients of
(H ¼ 0) along radius r: (a) individual stresses rrr, rzz, ruu; (b) admissible
and effective stresses, radm, reff, (radm – reff). The places at which (radm – convective vapor transfer am and convective heat transfer
reff) < 0 denote violation of the admissible strength (color figure available aT were estimated experimentally on the basis of drying
online). processes carried out in air temperature Wa ¼ 41.5 C.[22]
1396 KOWALSKI AND BANASZAK
TABLE 2
Data for numerical calculations
KsT ¼ 1.78 W=m K KlT ¼ 2.32 W=m K csv ¼ 728.5 J=kg K clv ¼ 4186 J=kg K
cT ¼ 0.52 J=kg K cX ¼ 3.06 J=kg j(X) ¼ 2.4 103 j(T) ¼ 3 108 1=K
am ¼ 8.64 105 kg s=m4 aT ¼ 40 W= m2 K v0 ¼ 2.5 106 kg s=m5 f0 ¼ 6 107 kg s2=m4
Wa ¼ 70 C Wn ¼ 50 C xa ¼ 0.075 l ¼ 2300 kJ=kg
3
qs ¼ 2640 kg=m / ¼ 0.35 H ¼ 0.06 m R ¼ 0.03 m
2 3
M ¼ 6.25 10 MPa A ¼ 10 MPa r0 ¼ 142 858 Pa rX ¼ 1 688 320 Pa
Cr ¼ 29.653 h0 ¼ 40% hcr ¼ 15% hA ¼ 5%
Some data for vapor pressure were taken from Molnar,[29] The effective stress is zero at the beginning, then starts
and those referring to the moisture diffusivity from to increase, attaining a maximum at some time, and finally
Marinos-Kouris and Maroulis.[30] tends to zero. The maximum of the effective stresses is
Figure 7 presents the drying curve for given drying con- reached at the top of the cylinder in the point (r ¼ 0,
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014
ditions; i.e., humidity and temperature of the drying z ¼ H). Figure 10 allows us to estimate the time at which
medium. The sample was dried at 120 C and the equivalent the crack formation may occur. This numerically predicted
humidity of hot air was registered for this temperature. moment of possible material damage was monitored
One can notice that the humidity slightly rises between experimentally with the acoustic emission (AE) method.
15–130 min of drying, which is caused by the evaporated In our experiments, a two-point AE technique was used
water from the sample. After 100–120 min, one can observe to monitor the development of fractures and, indirectly,
the beginning of the falling drying rate period (FDRP). drying-induced stresses. Two AE sensors were fixed to
Distributions of radial rrr, longitudinal rzz, and circum- the sample, one at the upper and the other at the lower
ferential ruu stresses along radius r at the bottom surface sample surfaces, so that the AE signals were registered on
of the cylinder (H ¼ 0) are presented in Fig. 8a (see both surfaces (Fig. 6). The sample with the fixed AE sen-
also [23]). Figure 8b presents the distribution of admissible sors was suspended to the balance to measure the reduction
radm and effective reff stresses and their difference at the of moisture mass in time and, simultaneously, the develop-
surface mentioned above. ment of cracks in the sample. The drying experiment was
Figure 9a illustrates the evolution of the moisture performed in extremely harsh, dried conditions (high tem-
content at the bottom of the cylinder. A crack in the perature and low air humidity) to excite easier fracture
convectively dried sample is predicted to occur at spots appearances in the sample and to obtain better AE activity.
of the cylinder where the stress (radm – reff) reaches Figure 11 presents the number of registered AE signals
a maximum. Figure 9b presents the time evolution of the per unit time during drying.
difference between admissible and effective stresses. As is seen in Fig. 11, most of these signals were evi-
As follows from Fig. 9b, the crack is most probable to denced in the CDRP, which can be explained by the ten-
occur at the cylinder surface where (radm – reff) < 0. sional stresses that arise at the external layers of the
Figure 10 presents the time evolution of the effective cylinder due to shrinkage. The surface of the body becomes
stresses in different points of the cylinder. drier, while its core is still kept wet. The AE hits rate
descriptor is strictly connected with the development of
FIG. 11. The number of AE signals per time period of 60 s for drying
temperature of 120 C (color figure available online). FIG. 13. Total energy of AE signals (color figure available online).
the drying-induced stresses, so this descriptor offers a good A highly fractured material is qualified as a bad-quality
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014
tool for on-line prediction of approaching material destruc- one. The description of total energy released may serve as
tion. So, one can state that the intensity of AE signals and an indicator as to whether the dried product is of good
the time of their occurrence are both related to the or bad quality at the end-state. Strong cracks in the body
development of the drying-induced stresses. structure release high energetic EA signals. The high and
Figure 12 illustrates the rise of mean acoustic energy medium energetic signals are evidenced in Fig. 13 as the
referred to as a single hit during the drying process. straight, upright lines. In some cases the high energetic sig-
Although most of the AE signals were evidenced in the nals denote macro cracks or material splits that are visible
CDRP, they turned out to be of low energy in general. on the sample surface. Thus, from the analysis of the total
These signals are referred to as stresses involving rather AE energy description one can deduce whether the dried
inelastic shape deformations of still strongly wet material, product is of good or bad quality.
which caused dissipation of the accumulated energy inside The fractures of materials subjected to drying are more
the material. In the FDRP fewer signals were observed, but likely to take place in fair-sized dried products and when the
their mean energy per hit was much higher than those aris- drying conditions are severe (e.g., too high temperature or
ing in the CDRP. This is because in the FDRP the surface too low drying medium humidity). An optimal drying process
became dry, so the formed cracks released stronger elastic should be able to eliminate or minimize the high or medium
energy propagating through the material. energetic AE impulses by the drying. The majority of notified
Figure 13 presents the total energy of the AE signals. AE signals ought to be low energetic (horizontal or almost
Monitoring of the total AE energy of all AE signals makes horizontal lines in Fig. 13). Such an AE energy descriptor
it possible to foresee the final quality of the dried samples. would mean a lack of destruction of the dried products.
The AE method can be applied not only to register the
time of the crack commences in the drying sample on-line,
but also to localize the cracks in the sample. Localization
of fractures by the AE method can be possible when
R cylinder radius m 7. Couture, F.; Bernada, P.; Roques, M.A. Continuous thermome-
chanical models using volume-averaging theory. In Modern Drying
r radial coordinate m Technology, Vol. 1; Tsotsas, E., Mujumdar, A., Eds.; Wiley-VCH
< individual gas constant J=kg K Verlag GmbH & Co. KgaH: Weinheim, Germany, 2007; 103–154.
sij stress deviator Pa 8. Kowalski, S.J.; Banaszak, J.; Rybicki, A. Plasticity of materials
t time s exposed to drying. Chemical Engineering Science 2010, 65,
tR relaxation time s 5105–5116.
9. Perre, P.; Remond, R.; Turner, I.W. Comprehensive drying models
T temperature K based on volume averaging: Background, application and perspective.
ur, uz displacements m In Modern Drying Technology, Vol. 1; Tsotsas, E., Mujumdar, A.,
xa, xn mole fractions of vapor in air 1 Eds.; Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KgaH: Weinheim, Germany,
X moisture content (dry basis) 1 2007; 1–55.
Xcr critical moisture content 1 10. Mihoubi, D.; Bellagi, A. Two-dimensional heat and mass transfer dur-
ing drying of deformable media. Applied Mathematical Modelling
XA final moisture content 1 2008, 32, 303–314.
z longitudinal coordinate m 11. Kowalski, S.J.; Perre, P., Guest Eds. Special issue: Damage of
Greek letters materials by drying: Modeling, numerical simulations, experimental
am vapor transfer coefficient kg s=m4 studies. Drying Technology: An International Journal 2009, 27(78).
aT heat transfer coefficient W=m2 K 12. Kowalski, S.J. Control of mechanical processes in drying: Theory and
experiment. Chemical Engineering Science 2010, 65, 890–899.
jv viscous bulk modulus Pa s 13. Kowalski, S.J.; Banaszak, J.; Rybicki, A. Damage analysis of microwave-
j(T) coefficient of thermal expansion 1=K
Downloaded by [Aston University] at 03:47 09 January 2014