Professional Documents
Culture Documents
14 - Arthrodesis and Arthroplasty of Wrist PDF
14 - Arthrodesis and Arthroplasty of Wrist PDF
chapter
A pain-free, stable wrist joint is essential for normal function therefore press for a motion-preserving procedure.76 There-
of the hand. Pain arising from the wrist will, through fore, careful assessment of the patient’s needs and require-
the spinal reflex, inhibit the function of the forearm muscu- ments, as well as the patient’s approach to the problem, must
lature, thereby effectively reducing its power and leading to be considered.
weakness of grasp. This response to pain is not a conscious Because the normal wrist enjoys considerable range of
act and is governed by involuntary responses not under vol- motion, loss of any of that range of motion is perceived as
untary control. The same mechanism applies when a wrist is creating an impairment that may give rise to a disability.
unstable; thus, an unstable wrist will similarly be character- However, a number of studies have been performed to
ized by weakness of grasp. Intermittent pain and instability examine the requirements for wrist motion for a variety of
result in an unreliable grasp that can fail capriciously and normal activities, and it is clear that most of the activities of
without warning. In addition to pain and instability may daily living can be performed with quite a restricted range
be added the problems of restricted range of motion and of motion of the wrist.
deformity, which may have an added adverse impact on Palmer and colleagues suggested that the functional range
function.32 of wrist motion is 30 degrees of extension, 5 degrees of
In practice one sees patients with pain at the wrist level flexion, 15 degrees of ulnar deviation, and 10 degrees of
from a number of causes. Primary osteoarthritis of the wrist radial deviation; these values were derived from a study in
is relatively uncommon and is exemplified by degenerative which they evaluated 52 standardized tasks involving activi-
changes at the scaphotrapeziotrapezoid (STT) joint. More ties of daily living and some aspects of work.81 Brumfield
commonly, arthritis ensues after simple trauma, instability, and Champoux found that in performing 15 activities of daily
dislocations, or inflammatory arthritis and less commonly as living, 10 degrees of wrist flexion was required and 35
a result of cerebral palsy,79 penetrating wounds, gunshot degrees of wrist extension was used.9 A later study by Ryu
wounds, infection,25 and chondrolysis. On occasion, giant cell and his group evaluated a smaller number of activities of
tumors require excision and wrist reconstruction with daily living and identified that there was an ideal range of
arthrodesis as the desired outcome.75,111 motion that they described as 60 degrees of extension, 54
Treatment of a painful, unstable, degenerate, or stiff wrist degrees of flexion, 17 degrees of radial deviation, and 40
is the province of the hand and upper limb surgeon, and a degrees of ulnar deviation.94,95 They do go on to say that the
variety of surgical procedures are available within the sur- majority of hand placement and range of motion tasks that
geons’ armamentarium. The choice of treatment depends on were studied in their project could be accomplished with
the cause and the pattern of the effects of the causative 70% of maximum range of wrist motion—40 degrees each
pathology. The procedures available may be grouped into of wrist flexion and extension and 40 degrees of combined
two principal treatment options, namely, wrist arthrodesis, radial and ulnar deviation. Nelson demonstrated with use of
partial8,13,118,122,124 or total,* and wrist arthroplasty,4,15,17,23,41 a splint to mimic stiffness that 123 activities of daily living
although metaphyseal decompression (forage)47 and partial could be performed successfully with limited motion consist-
neurectomy15 are lesser used procedures. ing of 5 degrees of flexion, 6 degrees of extension, 7 degrees
The aim of any treatment is to provide a pain-free, stable, of radial deviation, and 6 degrees of ulnar deviation.78 This
and functional wrist, and each individual patient will have a probably represents considerable coping strategies, compen-
pattern of problems that guide the surgeon toward the appro- satory motion of the shoulder and elbow, and modification
priate treatment for that individual. In the author’s experi- of activity by the individuals in the study. Their study does
ence, some patients cannot tolerate the loss of range of quite clearly identify that although good range of motion is
motion engendered by total wrist arthrodesis133 and will of great value, only a small arc of motion in each direction
is required to maintain independence of existence. However,
*See references 1, 3, 7, 26, 42, 43, 66, 71, 132, 138. for quality of life it is essential to have a greater range than
429
PART that described by Nelson simply because much of life is analog chart of the pain should be scored for pain at rest
III dealing with hobbies, pastimes, and work, and these activities and pain with activity.
may require a specific range of motion that must be consid- 3. The effect on an individual of the limitations generated
14 ered when assessing individual patients for treatment. More by the loss of faculty and the pain is defined as disability.
recently, Franko and co-workers highlighted the issues sur- This identifies the areas of the activities of daily living that
Wrist
rounding the capacity of volunteers to adapt and compromise are affected and the areas of significant difficulty within
to limitations of wrist motion.32 In their study, severe restric- patients’ lives that they wish to resolve.
tion of wrist motion with the use of splints gave rise to only 4. Radiographic assessment to determine the range of pro-
a modest impairment in function of the wrist in activities of cedures that are possible as defined by residual bone stock
daily living. However, when some motion was allowed, there and the pattern of degenerative changes.
was a significant improvement in the ease of performance of
the same tasks and a significant improvement in the range of Physical Examination of the Wrist
tasks that could be performed. This highlights the general Examination of the wrist is necessary to establish the base
need of patients to have some movement at the wrist but line values of movement, strength, deformity, and stabil-
that the range required will be different from individual to ity.57,109,118,125,130 In addition, visual inspection will allow the
individual. examining physician to observe local swelling, scars, evi-
Therefore, when patients seek advice and treatment for a dence of current or previous infection, and the patient’s
painful, unstable wrist, it is important to identify not only the reaction to movement or provocative stressing of the joint or
impairment that is present but also the net effect of that joints. The associated physical signs of inflammatory joint
impairment on functional ability because this will be unique disease may well be apparent, and this must include the
to the individual patient and will have a very great effect on stigmata of inflammatory joint disease, as well as the scaly
the choice of surgical procedure. Thus, with a good history patches and nail changes caused by psoriasis. A patient with
one can identify the patient’s particular activities that are psoriasis must be warned of the Koebner phenomenon,134 in
now inhibited by the painful or unstable wrist so that the which acute psoriatic plaques may develop along the length
correct choice of a motion-preserving procedure, such as of the scar engendered by the surgery. The presence of vas-
limited arthrodesis or arthroplasty, or a motion-ablating pro- culitis or active rheumatoid disease is a contraindication to
cedure, such as arthrodesis, can be made. Similarly, the any surgery until the condition is controlled.
patient’s age and occupation may well be a significant factor
in the decision-making process with regard to the choice Radiographic Evaluation
between arthroplasty and arthrodesis.76 Preoperative assess- The standard posteroanterior, oblique, and lateral views
ment of the patient must include a detailed physical examina- should be the basis for the initial radiographic examination.
tion and a full radiographic assessment to determine the Gross changes can be seen on these three standard views with
residual bone stock and pattern of the disease. Additional the shoulder held at 90 degrees of abduction, the elbow at
investigations may be needed to identify the underlying 90 degrees of flexion, and the hand placed flat on the radio-
pathology, for example, whether the condition is due to an graphic plate.37 This gives a reproducible posteroanterior
inflammatory or degenerative disease process, as well as view in neutral rotation with the beam centered over the
identification of any comorbidity that might prejudice the capitate and including the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ).
outcome of any surgical procedure. Preoperative assessment Marked changes, as seen in the scapholunate advanced col-
should score function, disability, and pain to facilitate mea- lapse (SLAC) pattern of arthritis, the scaphoid nonunion
surement of the outcome of the intervention. An important advanced collapse (SNAC) pattern, and carpal coalitions, are
element of the preoperative assessment is an evaluation of easily identified.18 STT arthrosis may be associated with
the capacity of the patient’s willingness and ability to comply deposition of calcium pyrophosphate (Figure 14.1A and B),
with the appropriate postoperative instructions and the and in this condition the radiolunate joint may well be
therapy program that accompanies it, and such evaluation is involved. Less obvious and more difficult to assess is arthrosis
essential to a successful outcome for most surgical procedures between the capitate and the lunate and between the head
involving the wrist. of the hamate and the lunate. In these circumstances, the
so-called six-shot series37 includes a posteroanterior view of
the wrist in full radial and full ulnar deviation, which is valu-
able in identifying elements of instability with scapholunate
PREOPERATIVE ASSESSMENT gapping. An anteroposterior grip view completes the series
This process therefore consists of four discrete elements. and can magnify carpal collapse, scapholunate diastasis, and
whether there is impingement between the hamate head and
1. Identification of the impairment or loss of faculty. Impair- the hamate facet on the lunate (Figure 14.2A to C).114
ment is defined as the parameters that can be measured Specific x-rays are indicated by the history and examina-
and include range of motion, grip strength, deformity, and tion and, if indicated, should include, for example, a pisotri-
stability. quetral skyline view (a lateral view with the wrist in 10
2. Assessment of the pain, which by definition is a symptom, degrees of supination) (Figure 14.3) to exclude osteoarthritis
and therefore no objective measurement can be made. of this joint, which can coexist with other areas of arthritis
The closest that we can approach assessment of this aspect in the wrist and, if not identified, can give rise to residual
of the patients’ problem with some degree of reliability is symptoms that may overshadow any improvement after
through a visual analog scale, and therefore a visual other surgery.
430
PART
III
14
431
PART
III
14
Wrist
A B
C
Figure 14.2 A, This radiograph of a wrist under axial load clearly demonstrates scapholunate dissociation but is also suggestive
of hamolunate impingement. B, This cadaveric specimen demonstrates hamolunate impaction, which can occur and may
compromise radiolunate and radioscapholunate arthrodesis. C, The most appropriate investigation is magnetic resonance
imaging, which shows significant bone edema at the tip of the hamate.
433
PART
III
14
Wrist
A B
C D
Figure 14.6 A, The conservative wrist. Integrity of the ligament and joint surfaces characterizes this phase of the disease,
although erosions may be seen. B, The restorative wrist. The secondary arthrosis is principally confined to the lunate fossa and
suggests that radiolunate fusion is an appropriate option. In this radiograph, the presence of translocation and radioscaphoid
arthritis indicates that radioscapholunate fusion is the preferred option. C, The reconstructive wrist. Bony stock is well preserved,
although all joints are significantly affected, thus giving the opportunity to consider wrist replacement as an option. D, The
salvage wrist. Very poor bone stock remains, and with marked bone loss, arthrodesis remains the most likely choice, although
each case must be taken on its merits.
434
PART
III
14
B
Figure 14.7 A, Radiolunate arthritis and carpal translocation may the extensor pollicis longus (EPL). The digital extensor
be corrected by radiolunate fusion. B, Nature’s own solution to tendons contained within the fourth compartment are raised
the problem of inflammatory arthritis is spontaneous bony in the envelope created by the extensor retinaculum super-
ankylosis. ficially and the capsule of the wrist on the deep surface. This
prevents specific damage to the extensor tendons. The pos-
terior interosseous nerve can be identified lying to the ulnar
side of Lister’s tubercle, and a centimeter should be excised
to its anatomic height, and this involves the use of iliac crest to prevent tethering of this nerve, which may be extremely
bone graft or ulnar head bone graft if available and sufficient. painful when flexing the wrist.64 The wrist capsule is incised
Fixation can be accomplished with Kirschner wires, staples, longitudinally along the capitate–third metacarpal axis. The
miniature pin plates, blade plates, or screws. Headless can- fourth compartment tendons are contained within the tube
nulated or other compression screws passed through the formed by the extensor retinaculum and the dorsal capsule
dorsal horn of the lunate can also be used to achieve rigid of the carpus, and displacing them to the ulnar side allows
fixation (Figure 14.9A and B). identification of the capitolunate and radiolunate joints. The
capitolunate joint should be inspected; if it is degenerated,
AUTHOR’S PREFERRED METHOD OF one would have to consider a full wrist arthrodesis. If the
RADIOLUNATE ARTHRODESIS midcarpal joint is intact, the radiolunate joint is identified and
The wrist is exposed through a standard longitudinal incision the cartilage of the lunate fossa and the proximal lunate
approximately 8 cm long in line with the third metacarpal surface is denuded from the bone with curets, rongeurs, and
and bisected by the radiocarpal joint line (Figure 14.10A limited use of a bur. A graft is taken from the area deep to
and B). The flaps are raised deep to the superficial fascia to Lister’s tubercle if carpal height is maintained. However, if
preserve the vessels and cutaneous nerves while obtaining an carpal height should need to be restored, a corticocancellous
excellent view of the extensor retinaculum. At this point bone graft is taken from the iliac crest with a trephine through
Lister’s tubercle is identified by palpation, and the extensor a small incision. The ulnar head, if it has been removed as
retinaculum is opened over the third compartment just to the part of the procedure, may also be fashioned into a suitable
ulnar side of Lister’s tubercle while taking care to not damage graft (Figure 14.11A and B). This yields a corticocancellous
435
PART sion stretches the anterior capsule, and this process can be
III repeated through two or three iterations. Extension of the
wrist is then improved and arthrodesis can be completed.
14 After preparation of the bone surface and grafting, tempo-
rary fixation with Kirschner wires through the distal dorsal
Wrist
aspect of the radius into the lunate with the lunate in neutral
rotation allows the position to be checked with intraopera-
tive radiographs or fluoroscopy. Careful assessment of the
midcarpal joint should be performed to rule out hardware
penetration. A cannulated headless bone screw can then be
inserted along the wire. If the lunate does not lend itself
readily to fixation with Kirschner wires through the dorsal
horn, consideration can be given to removal of the proximal
pole of the triquetrum. This maneuver reveals the ulnar
aspect of the lunate and allows a Kirschner wire or headless
bone screw to be inserted through the lunate into the radius
from the ulnar side. This ensures extremely good fixation,
may increase range of motion, and also helps prevent
A translocation.
Pitfalls
1. Failure to appreciate that the posterior interosseous nerve
can be damaged during the course of the dissection and
give rise to limitation of motion because of traction on the
neuroma. If there is any doubt about the status of the
posterior interosseous nerve, it should be identified proxi-
mally and 1 cm of the nerve excised with appropriate
diathermy of the posterior interosseous artery. This will
Interposition prevent problems of neuroma of the tethered posterior
graft interosseous nerve.64
2. Fusion of the lunate in an excessively dorsiflexed position
(DISI). This restricts the range of motion in flexion con-
Staple siderably, and a neutral or 10-degree dorsiflexed position
of the lunate in relation to the radius is essential.
3. Failure to restore carpal height leading to a permanently
flexed scaphoid, thereby restricting range of motion
B unnecessarily.
4. Violation of the capitolunate joint by wires from the
Figure 14.9 A, Crossed screws are used here as the construct, radius into the lunate.
the ulnar head has been replaced, and it is imperative that
adequate clearance between the lunate graft and the implant be Postoperative Management
maintained to minimize the potential for the development of an Use of a bulky dressing for 10 to 14 days with the hand
ulna abutment syndrome. B, Staples may provide a simpler elevated whenever possible allows the swelling to subside. A
method of fixation. (B, Copyright Elizabeth Martin.)
short arm cast immobilizes the wrist for a period of 5 to 6
weeks. At that point, early rehabilitation should be restricted
to using the dart thrower’s motion only, namely, radial devia-
tion and extension to ulnar deviation and flexion. This pre-
graft that may be shaped so that it can be inserted to restore vents excessive forces acting on the radiolunate arthrodesis.
carpal height, particularly if a die punch fracture has previ- After a further period of 4 weeks, full mobilization can take
ously occurred (Figure 14.12). place, provided that radiographs confirm the presence of
In a patient with a dorsal intercalated segment instability union. Strengthening exercises for finger motion should start
(DISI) deformity, this must be corrected to achieve proper early. At 3 months it is appropriate to leave patients free of
balance of the remaining carpus. Fixation of the lunate in splintage, but avoidance of contact sports for 2 to 3 addi-
extension during either radiolunate arthrodesis, capitolunate tional months is recommended. Excessive attempts to mobi-
fusion, or four-corner fusion will predictably result in loss of lize the midcarpal joint can result in an increased risk for
extension. To correct the extended lunate, I fully flex the nonunion.
wrist and pass a 0.062-inch Kirschner wire through the dorsal
aspect of the radius into the repositioned lunate. When the Net Analysis of the Literature
wrist is brought back to neutral flexion-extension, the lunate Essentially, an approximately 10% nonunion rate58 and a
is in the correct position as seen in the sagittal view (Figure reduction in range of motion by half in flexion and extension
14.13A to C). Gentle manipulation of the wrist into exten- are reported.
436
PART
III
14
Figure 14.10 A single dorsal incision allows wide exposure of the dorsum of the wrist through the third dorsal compartment
(A) and deep to the fourth extensor compartment (B), thereby maintaining the “extensor tube.”
CRITICAL POINTS: RADIOLUNATE ARTHRODESIS lunate, and then extend the wrist to reduce the lunate
to the remainder of the carpus.
Indications During the procedure, temporary fixation of the lunate
Isolated cases of radiolunate arthritis, which usually to the radius followed by intraoperative radiographs
arise as a result of localized die punch fractures or helps identify whether adequate height has been
from rheumatoid arthritis achieved and whether the position of the lunate is not
Instability of the proximal row of the carpus in excessively extended with regard to the capitate and
translation radius. In addition, the lunate must be placed so that
Failed soft tissue reconstruction of scapholunate it comes to lie underneath the capitate, not to the
dissociation80,116,121,131 ulnar side of it.
Excision of the proximal part of the triquetrum
Contraindications
can provide easier access for screw fixation if there
The presence of significant degenerative changes in
has been significant ulnar translocation of the
the midcarpal joint
lunate.
Radiographic Evaluation Restoration of carpal height is important in post-
Assessment of the preoperative x-rays is essential to trauma cases and to a lesser extent in rheumatoid
ensure that the midcarpal joint is free of any patients.
degenerative changes, there is no residual
degenerative arthritis in the DRUJ or pisotriquetral Expectations
joint, and the DRUJ is stable. There will be permanent loss of some range of motion
Pearls that is generally on the order of or slightly less than
Maintain the fourth compartment “tube” intact to half the range of a normal wrist.
allow early mobilization. Full recovery may take a period of 9 to 12 months to
Ensure that the posterior interosseous nerve has not learn to adapt to the new situation, and coping
been damaged distally and excise it proximal to the strategies may be developed in conjunction with the
radiocarpal joint if it has. Injury to the posterior hand therapist.
interosseous nerve (which may be intact but tethered Not all pain will be relieved, and aching will usually
in scar tissue) is an important cause of postoperative occur after heavy use.
pain when the wrist is flexed. There is a risk for deterioration over time with the
Reduction of the lunate extension is very important; development of degenerative changes within the
therefore, for reduction, fully flex the wrist, drive a midcarpal joint. This may require further surgery in the
Kirschner wire through the distal radius into the future.
437
PART
III
14
Wrist
B
Figure 14.11 A, If the ulnar head is carefully excised as part of
the procedure, it can, in many circumstances, be sufficient graft
to perform radiolunate or radioscapholunate arthrodesis. B, The
head is held in a gauze sponge and the anterior, posterior, and
medial surfaces are removed with an oscillating saw sequentially.
The remaining cortical bone on the distal face provides a strong
structural element for the graft.
C
Figure 14.13 A, The wrist is fully flexed and a smooth 1.1-mm
Kirschner wire is inserted into the distal radius to fix the lunate in
neutral to slight flexion. If the wrist is moved into ulnar deviation
and flexed before transfixion, the maneuver reduces both the
translocation and flexion deformities. B, When the wrist is
brought into neutral, the position of the lunate remains reduced
and the capitate is in appropriate alignment with the lunate. C, A
joystick in the lunate facilitates proper reduction of the lunate
posture before transfixion.
Figure 14.12 The size of the graft will often allow restoration of
carpal height and is sufficiently robust to permit screw or staple
fixation.
438
Scaphocapitate Arthrodesis73 PART
Indications III
SC fusion is considered a relatively equal alternative to STT
fusion for stabilization of the scaphoid. Accordingly, indica-
14
tions include dynamic or rotatory subluxation of the scaphoid
Preoperative Evaluation
Evaluate scaphoid stability with the Watson scaphoid
shift test.
Obtain a supinated anteroposterior radiograph to
evaluate the scapholunate joint for increased gap and Radioscapholunate Arthrodesis
to be sure that the radioscaphoid and STT joints are Indications
free of degenerative changes. Proximal row destruction, most commonly seen in post-
Obtain a lateral radiograph to evaluate the traumatic cases in which there has been extensive intra-
scapholunate angle. articular damage, but also after chondrolysis, infection, or
Obtain a hyperpronated anteroposterior radiograph to inflammatory arthritis.
evaluate the STT joint. Preservation of midcarpal motion while dealing with the
Pearls painful radiocarpal motion
Preserve the volarmost cartilage surfaces between the
scaphoid and lunate to maintain normal anatomic Contraindications
relationships. Patients who have active infection
It is easier to reduce the scaphoid before Destruction of the distal radius with significant deformity
decortication. Degenerative changes in the midcarpal joint
Technical Points
Protect the radial sensory nerve branches and radial
artery by using a small drill guide during Kirschner AUTHOR’S PREFERRED METHOD
wire placement. OF TREATMENT
Confirm by fluoroscopy or radiographs proper
Through a central longitudinal dorsal incision, full-thickness
reduction of the scaphoid to a 40- to 50-degree
skin flaps are raised to identify the extensor retinaculum.
radioscaphoid angle. Separate lunate reduction is not
required.
Lister’s tubercle is identified and an incision made in the
extensor retinaculum in a line between the third and fourth
Pitfall compartments. The fourth compartment is raised as a tube
Avoid overreduction (extension greater than 50
by dissection of the fourth compartment and the dorsal
degrees) of the scaphoid, which will limit motion,
capsule from the dorsal aspect of the wrist and carpus. The
particularly radial deviation and extension.
EPL tendon is dislocated from its groove. Lister’s tubercle is
440
lems of using Kirschner wires or cannulated screws.101 They PART
reported successful use of 2.4-mm distal radial plates to III
provide locking plate stabilization of their radioscapholunate
fusions. Nagy and Büchler identified two patients who
14
exhibited secondary midcarpal degenerative joint disease.77
Indications
Figure 14.15 Example of radioscapholunate fusion. The diseased Radioscaphoid or radioscapholunate joint arthritic
ulnar head has been excised and prepared in this case as the two deformity after distal radial intra-articular fractures
grafts that are necessary to achieve restoration of carpal height
Rheumatoid arthritis with relative sparing of the
and to ensure that the lunate is neutral in flexion and extension.
midcarpal joint
Normally, it is our practice to excise the distal 20% of the
scaphoid initially and then check during the dart thrower’s range Preoperative Evaluation
of motion that clearance is adequate. Further excision can be Computed tomography can be very helpful as an
done until the surgeon is comfortable with the range of motion. adjunct to the standard x-rays to identify the nature of
Similarly, excision of the triquetrum follows the same principle. the midcarpal joint and in particular identify the
presence or absence of a type II lunate facet.
removed with an osteotome. The ECRB and ECRL are then Pearls
retracted to the radial side, and the capsule is raised from the There must be complete absence of degenerative joint
Lister’s tubercle to the styloid process. Inspection of the disease within the midcarpal joint.
A 2- to 3-mm amputation of the impacting part of the
midcarpal joint to ensure that there is adequate cartilage on
head of the hamate must be performed if there is a
the surface is the first prerequisite of this procedure. Any
significant type II joint on the lunate.
malalignment of the proximal row must be corrected by A 2.4-mm locking plate across the radiocarpal joint is a
reduction of the lunate into the neutral position and reduc- reliable method of fusion.97
tion of the scaphoid into 45 degrees of radioscaphoid flexion, The fourth compartment should be raised as a tube by
as determined by image intensification. The articular surfaces subperiosteal dissection and the EPL dislocated toward
are then excised down to cancellous bone. The space is filled the radial side.
with bone graft, which may be taken from the distal radius Partial osteotomy of the tubercle of Lister and raising
through a small defect created by removal of Lister’s tubercle the flap from the radial side preserve the EPL pulley
(Figure 14.15). Once the graft is in situ and the positions are mechanism.
Displacement of the ECRB and ECRL to the radial side
satisfactory, Kirschner wires are driven across from the
gives adequate exposure.
radius to the scaphoid and from the radius to the lunate.
Excision of the distal pole of the scaphoid should be
Although memory metal staples can be used for this purpose performed to allow free radial deviation of the wrist.
and can be helpful in obtaining compression, positioning of Decortication of the posterior two thirds of the
the staples is crucial. Once reduction and fixation for the scaphoid, lunate, and radius preserves longitudinal
arthrodesis have been achieved, range of motion should be alignment and length, and the area can be grafted
checked. Because the scaphoid is fixed at 45 degrees of quite readily. The use of a rongeur is most helpful in
flexion, flexion-extension may be limited and radial devia- preparing the surfaces.
64
tion is particularly limited. The resultant motion is almost Any doubt about posterior interosseous nerve injury
entirely in the dart thrower’s plane of radial extension to should lead to excision of a centimeter of the posterior
ulnar flexion. Therefore, I prefer to excise the distal pole of interosseous nerve, proximal to the distal radiocarpal
joint.
the scaphoid to enable further radial deviation,35,43 and sepa-
rately, Pervaiz has recommended removal of the triquetrum Pitfalls
to enable unimpeded ulnar deviation of the wrist.82 Failure to recognize that a type II lunate is preventing
full ulnar deviation of the midcarpal joint and therefore
Complications that excision of the proximal tip of the hamate is
necessary
Shin and Jupiter commented on the problems of nonunion
after attempted radioscapholunate arthrodesis and the prob- Continued
441
PART Contraindications
CRITICAL POINTS: RADIOSCAPHOLUNATE
III ARTHRODESIS—cont’d Patients with midcarpal arthritis
Nondissociative ulnar midcarpal instability
14 Dissociative volar intercalated segment instability (VISI)
Failure to adequately excise the distal pole of the
scaphoid
Wrist
Contraindications
Contraindications primarily include radiographic narrowing
or degenerative change of the radioscaphoid joint, which will
become increasingly degenerative and symptomatic after the
increased load transfer associated with STT fusion.
Preoperative evaluation should include radiography of the
STT joint with full ulnar deviation views and full radial devia-
tion views to identify whether the scaphoid moves. If the
scaphoid is highly mobile, as characterized by considerable
flexion and pronation during radial deviation, an STT fusion
condemns patients to painful radioscaphoid subluxation each
time that they move into radial deviation. In this case, one
should consider some form of either interpositional arthro-
Figure 14.16 Headless bone screws are ideal for triquetrolunate
(TL) fusion. A trial of TL fusion can be performed by percutaneous plasty or excisional arthroplasty rather than arthrodesis.
insertion of a TL screw. Similarly, if there is substantial gap formation at the STT joint
on full ulnar deviation that closes on radial deviation, there
may be chronic bone loss involving the distal pole of the
disturbance of sensation on the dorsal/ulnar aspect of the scaphoid. These patients have less satisfactory results with
hand. This complication causes considerable distress to arthrodesis than do those with no appreciable gapping on
patients and significantly detracts from any positive benefit ulnar deviation. The group with appreciable gapping has
of this procedure. To avoid this problem, a small skin incision significant impairment of postoperative motion in the author’s
should be made as is practiced in arthroscopy of the wrist, experience and seems to be better served by excision of the
blunt dissection performed down to the triquetrum, and a distal pole of the scaphoid.35
drill sleeve used to protect the soft tissues.
Preoperative x-rays in full ulnar deviation and full axial AUTHOR’S PREFERRED METHOD OF
compression of the forearm should identify whether there is SCAPHOTRAPEZIOTRAPEZOID FUSION
abutment between the ulnar head and the triquetrum. Ulnar The STT joint is approached through a 4-cm transverse dorsal
impaction may be the cause of lunotriquetral instability; wrist incision just distal to the radial styloid. The dorsal veins
it may also be a cause of significant pain. Treatment and branches of the superficial branch of the radial nerve are
involves an isolated or combined wafer procedure29 or preserved. The radial styloid is exposed through an incision
ulnar-shortening osteotomy. in the capsule, and the distal 5 mm is removed with a rongeur.
A transverse incision in the dorsal capsule is then made, and
What Patients Should Be Told the radioscaphoid joint is inspected. If significant degenera-
There is a nonunion rate of 30%,58 there will always be loss tive disease is found here, the procedure of choice is proximal
of 30% to 40% range of motion, the results are somewhat row carpectomy (if the capitate has a healthy articular
unpredictable, and recovery takes 9 to 12 months. The pain surface) or SLAC reconstruction (if both the scaphoid fossa
may not be entirely relieved. and head of capitate show degenerative wear).
The distal aspect of the extensor retinaculum is then
Triquetrohamate Fusion opened along the EPL and the STT joint approached through
Rao and Culver reported an almost 50% failure rate in pro- a transverse capsular incision between the ECRL and ECRB
viding relief of symptomatic midcarpal instability with tri- tendons. The entire articular surfaces of the scaphoid, trape-
quetrohamate fusion88; therefore, this operation is not zium, and trapezoid are then removed with a rongeur while
recommended. The author’s experience mirrors that of these taking care to remove the proximal half of the trapezium-
authors. trapezoid articulation only. It is mandatory that the subchon-
dral hard cancellous bone also be removed and the softer
Scaphotrapeziotrapezoidal Fusion cancellous surfaces exposed. The dorsal cortex of the trape-
Indications zium and trapezoid is likewise removed to broaden the
The presence of degenerative arthrosis localized to the STT surface area for fusion. The volar lip of the scaphoid is decor-
joint is often associated with calcium pyrophosphate deposi- ticated by inserting a dental rongeur deep into the joint and
443
PART
III TZM TZD
14
Wrist
45˚
Figure 14.17 These diagrammatic representations of the preparation and positioning of the scaphoid highlight the requirement
of ensuring that the scaphoid must lie in a flexed position at 45 to 55 degrees to the long axis of the radius before insertion of
the Kirschner wires. S, scaphoid.
levering the handle distally. Cancellous bone graft is then forearm and arm, but it is difficult to adequately maintain the
harvested from the distal radius at Lister’s tubercle. Two position of the distal carpal row. Therefore, the metacarpo-
0.045-inch Kirschner wires are driven percutaneously from phalangeal (MP) joints of the index and middle fingers are
the distal aspect of the dorsal trapezoid proximally into the flexed to 80 to 90 degrees and included in the long arm cast
prepared space without crossing it. The first, radially posi- and the interphalangeal joints are left free. Four weeks post-
tioned Kirschner wire is passed to the point of just touching operatively, the long arm cast and skin sutures are removed.
the surface of the scaphoid. The second, ulnarly positioned A short-arm thumb spica cast is applied for an additional 2
Kirschner wire is passed proximally to the point of entering to 3 weeks. In patients older than 55 years, 3 weeks in a long
the scaphotrapezoid space. The wrist is then placed in full arm cast followed by 3 weeks in a short arm cast may be
radial deviation and 45 degrees of dorsiflexion while the sufficient. Six weeks postoperatively, the short arm cast is
scaphoid tuberosity is reduced by the surgeon’s thumb to removed and radiographs are obtained. If radiographic evi-
prevent overcorrection of the scaphoid (Figure 14.17). A dence of union is seen, the pins are removed in the office and
5-mm spacer, usually the handle of a small instrument, is the patient is referred for hand therapy for full wrist mobili-
placed into the scaphotrapezoid space to maintain the origi- zation. A splint may occasionally be used for an additional
nal external dimensions of the STT joint, and the radial 1 or 2 weeks if there is any doubt about the status of bone
Kirschner wire is driven into the scaphoid while avoiding healing.
placement into the radioscaphoid joint. The spacer is then
removed, and the ulnar Kirschner wire is similarly driven Alternative Techniques
into the scaphoid. After pinning, the scaphoid should lie at Staples
approximately 55 degrees of flexion relative to the long axis Power-inserted staples can simplify the fixation process and
of the radius when seen from the lateral view. This ensures prevent complications related to Kirschner wire irritation and
optimal radioscaphoid congruity and maximizes postopera- possible infection. After provisional fixation in appropriate
tive range of motion. It is not necessary to correct any abnor- position with Kirschner wires, staples are driven by power
mal rotation of the lunate. Excessive extension of the scaphoid across the scaphotrapezial and scaphotrapezoid joints. The
will limit the motion obtained after surgery. Cancellous bone provisional Kirschner wires can then be removed. Postopera-
is then densely packed into the spaces between the scaphoid, tive care is as outlined earlier.
trapezium, and trapezoid. The pins are cut beneath the skin
level, and the wrist capsule and extensor retinaculum are Screw Fixation
simply realigned without suturing. The skin incisions are The STT joint should be reduced and provisionally held by
closed with a single-layer subcuticular monofilament suture. two guide wires and checked under fluoroscopy. Length is
The postoperative dressing consists of a bulky noncompres- measured and an appropriate-length cannulated screw can be
sive wrap incorporating a long arm plaster splint. The hand inserted over each wire.
is placed in a protected position with the wrist in slight exten-
sion and radial deviation, the forearm neutral, and the elbow What Patients Should Be Told
at 90 degrees. Watson has reported excellent functional results and pain-
free, stable wrists after STT arthrodesis. After 4 to 6 weeks
Postoperative Management of hand therapy, the average range of motion is usually 50%
Maximum initial immobilization is mandatory for these to 70% of that of the contralateral normal wrist; it increases
small-bone fusions. Three to 5 days after surgery, the bulky to an average of 80% by 1 year after surgery. Grip strength
dressing is removed and a long-arm thumb spica cast applied. has averaged 90% of that of the unaffected wrist. Long-term
The proximal carpal row is easily immobilized by casting the radiographic follow-up has revealed only rare instances of
444
the SNAC pattern of arthritis may lead to significant symp- PART
tomatic wrist arthritis, and four-corner fusion is an option.100 III
Contraindications
14
The lunate fossa must be intact and free of disease such as
Screw Fixation
The development of headless compression screws has facili-
tated internal fixation of carpal bones by the ability to bury
the screw within the carpus. Several manufacturers have
designed appropriate headless cannulated screws. Screw fixa-
tion affords the opportunity for initiation of earlier range
of motion because more reliable and rigid fixation can be
achieved.
B
A
Figure 14.21 A, Excision of the scaphoid and localized capitolunate fusion fixed with headless bone screws. B, Excision of the
scaphoid and triquetrum occasionally requires an additional capitohamate arthrodesis in the small group of patients with a
mobile capitohamate joint. (Copyright Elizabeth Martin.)
procedure that is reasonably reliable is arthrodesis, and this Ely, 1920: Arthrodesis for tuberculosis25
is often the only practical course of action. Particular atten- Gill, 1923: Devised a method of corticocancellous grafting
tion should be paid to the lateral x-ray of the wrist; it may to provide stability138
show significant volar subluxation of the lunate, which will Smith-Peterson, 1939: Described an ulnar approach with
give rise to some difficulties in reducing the wrist and could distal ulnar excision103
27
precipitate carpal tunnel syndrome as the wrist is relocated Evans, 1955: Wedge arthrodesis
and realigned.
Plates, Wires, and Staples
History of Wrist Arthrodesis60,62,88,96,97,106,113,135 Wood, 1967: Introduced a modification of the Gill tech-
Steindler,1918: Wrist arthrodesis for stabilization in nique involving compression wire fixation138
patients with polio and spastic hemiparesis107 Larsson, 1974: AO plating
59
447
PART
III
14
Wrist
continued motion at the third CMC joint may cause the pin
to work loose and migrate distally. For these reasons, some
surgeons prefer to place the pin retrogradely through the
carpus and out the second intermetacarpal web space. The
pin can then be redirected in an antegrade fashion down
the shaft of the radius. The intermetacarpal pin position
places the hand in a slightly ulnar-deviated position, which
is advantageous mechanically.
Figure 14.22 Introduction of intramedullary pins through the
head of the third metacarpal is rapid and effective fixation for To counteract these problems and to improve secure intra-
radiocarpal arthrodesis. medullary fixation, the Wrightington unit has developed a
specialized instrument kit consisting of modified pins, a
driver, and a countersink driver (Osteotec Ltd,, Christchurch,
Benkeddache et al., 1984: Multiple staples6 Dorset, UK).105 The tip of the pins has a flat cutting edge with
Hastingset al., 1993/1996: Modified AO plate with a chip breaker so that it may be used as a drill when mounted
compression42 on a hand drill piece. There are a variety of sizes and lengths
(Figure 14.23). Preoperative radiographs must be assessed to
Intramedullary Fixation identify the diameter of the third metacarpal so that that the
Robinson and Kayfetz, 1952: Intramedullary rods in rheu- correct size and length of pin can be chosen. The wrist joint
matoid patients92 is opened through a dorsal incision in the midline, and the
Clayton, 1965: Outlined techniques without fixation in extensor retinaculum is opened longitudinally through the
rheumatoid patients15 fifth extensor compartment and reflected to the radial side of
Mannerfelt and Malmsten, 1971: Introduced the Rush pin the second compartment. Extensor tenosynovectomy is per-
technique67 formed as necessary. The dorsal capsule is then detached
Millender and Nalebuff, 1973: Popularized the use of a from the distal radius and reflected distally. Posterior interos-
Steinmann pin and sliding graft71 seous neurectomy is routinely performed. The wrist joint is
then flexed and adhesions broken down with a blunt dissec-
AUTHOR’S PREFERRED METHOD OF TOTAL tor. The presence of volar subluxation of the lunate and a
WRIST ARTHRODESIS large anterior shelf should be excluded (Figure 14.24); if
Precontoured plates may be used for total wrist arthrodesis present, the shelf should be excised. Failure to recognize its
in patients with degenerative arthrosis and inflammatory presence and to remove the shelf may result in postoperative
arthritis but with good bone stock. For patients with signifi- median nerve compression and symptoms of acute carpal
cant bone loss because of inflammatory joint disease, the tunnel syndrome. The joint is then mobilized and reduced if
technique first described by Ferlic and Clayton30 and further necessary. Relocation of the scaphoid and the lunate into
popularized by Millender and Nalebuff71 uses a Steinmann their anatomic positions is often very difficult or impossible;
pin inserted down the third metacarpal shaft and into the however, this can be remedied at the time of driving the pin
radius (Figure 14.22). The technique is both technically across the carpus and radius. Commencing 1 to 2 cm proxi-
simple and effective. mal to the articular surface of the radius and extending to
This technique is not without potential complications since the third CMC joint, the dorsal two thirds of the radius,
the third MP joint will have to be violated. In addition, including the articular surface, and the carpus, including the
because these patients have multijoint involvement, it is base of the third metacarpal bone, are morselized with a
likely that surgery to replace the third MP joint will be rongeur. The bone is usually osteoporotic and easy to
required as a result of the rheumatoid joint disease. The morselize.
Steinmann pin may be difficult to countersink, and if there A stab incision is made over the dome of the metacarpal
is a failure of union of the third carpometacarpal (CMC) joint, head while the MP joint of the third finger is kept fully flexed.
448
PART
III
14
Failed previous partial fusion Remove the ulnar head in one piece if indicated for
Failed total joint or previous arthroplasty additional source of graft.
42
Significant bone loss of the distal radius and carpus Morselize the dorsal two thirds of the scaphoid, lunate,
15,66
Other inflammatory arthritis/deformity capitate, and all of the radial articular surface,
including the distal dorsal rim.
When there is significant ulnar translation, remove part
of the radial styloid to facilitate realignment of the
wrist.
Remove the anterior lunate fossa shelf if present.
Pitfalls
A Insufficient removal of the anterior shelf
Acute carpal tunnel syndrome
Pain from incomplete fusion of the third CMC joint
Insufficient countersinking of the pin past the isthmus
of the third metacarpal
Postoperative Care
Immobilize the hand and wrist in a bulky dressing and
splint for 10 days.
Protect against excessive use with a removable short
arm splint until 6 weeks postoperatively.
At 6 weeks discontinue the splint.
At 8 weeks begin strengthening.
A B
Figure 14.27 The extraperiosteal excised ulnar head can be used as a corticocancellous graft. A, The head is opened into a graft
with a narrow bone rongeur. B, The softer bone of a rheumatoid patient is ideal for this technique. The periosteum holds the
fragments together, and the graft remains a viable supplement to the main morselization of the carpus and distal radius.
450
PART
III
14
used when large segmental carpal traumatic or tumor defects pressive dressing or sleeve, and the wrist is supported with
require corticocancellous intercalary graft replacement. a wrist immobilization splint, which serves to remind the
These plates do not need contouring and position the wrist patient and others that a surgical procedure has been done;
in neutral extension. If precontoured plates are not available, it does not support or protect the plate. Full active use of the
a straight 3.5-mm LCDCP may be similarly contoured to hand and digits is allowed, but resistance or lifting is limited
follow the dorsal radius, carpal sulcus, and dorsal third meta- to 1 kg. The splint is discontinued at 6 weeks. Full use of the
carpal. In small individuals, a nine-hole, 3.5-mm reconstruc- hand is allowed by the 10th week. Radiographic healing is
tion plate is optimal. In persons with extremely small hands, to be expected by 8 to 10 weeks.
a 2.7-mm reconstruction or 2.7-mm semitubular plate may
be required.
The plate is affixed to the third metacarpal with 2.7-mm CRITICAL POINTS: PLATE FIXATION FOR
screws while taking care to ensure central drilling in its WRIST ARTHRODESIS
narrow isthmus. The distal metacarpal hole is drilled first to
enable fine-tuning of the position. Accurate alignment of the Indications
plate in the dorsal midline of the metacarpal is essential to Pan-carpal arthrosis of the radiocarpal and midcarpal
avoid malrotation and maximize grip strength potential.85 joints
The remaining metacarpal screws are drilled and placed. Failed past limited arthrodesis
Failed total joint or previous arthroplasty
Next, a 2.7-mm cancellous screw is placed in the capitate. If
Paralysis of the wrist or hand (with the potential for
there is space between the plate and the capitate, the capitate
using functioning tendons for transfer)74,106
may be lagged up against the plate, and a shorter screw than
Reconstruction after segmental tumor resection,
measured is required to avoid volar screw penetration into infection, or traumatic segmental bone loss of the
the carpal canal. The hand is then aligned with the forearm, distal radius and carpus26,75
and the capitate is manually compressed into the decorticated Inflammatory arthritis with good bone stock
43
distal radius. With the plate aligned over the radius and the
Pearls
hand properly oriented, the second most distal screw in the
Carefully assess the preoperative carpal tunnel
radius (chosen because it lies in cortical bone) is drilled with symptoms and perform a concomitant release, even
a 2.5-mm bit in compression mode and a 3.5-mm cortical for mild symptoms.
screw inserted. The remaining radius holes are filled in no- Decorticate the dorsal 80% of the third CMC joint.
compression mode. Remove the dorsal distal radius for improved plate fit.
Harvest a distal radius metaphyseal bone graft and
Closure apply to the fusion site.
A small suction drain is routinely used and brought out Removal of the proximal row simplifies fusion and
proximally. The retained radial and ulnar flaps of the previ- avoids ulnocarpal impingement.
In a patient with rheumatoid arthritis and ulnar
ously opened third (EPL) compartment are used to close the
translation, remove part of the radial styloid to
capsule over the plate to the extent possible. The EPL is left
facilitate realignment of the wrist.
transposed radially out of Lister’s canal so that it does not
touch the plate other than proximally. Technical Points
Transpose the EPL.
Excise the proximal row.
Postoperative Management
Decorticate the third CMC joint, capitate, proximal
A bulky short arm dressing incorporating a volar plaster
hamate, and distal radius.
splint is applied. At week 2 this is converted to a light com-
452
PART
CRITICAL POINTS: PLATE FIXATION FOR
WRIST ARTHRODESIS—cont’d
III
14
Place graft in the third CMC joint.
Fix the plate to the metacarpal firstthrough the most
69
anteed if they have undergone multiple previous surgeries. Meuli, 1980: The Meuli implant, a ball-and-socket design
4
Grip strength will take a year to plateau and will approxi- Guepar, 1986: The first distal screw fixation device
mate 72% of normal.42 Bolano and Green found no signifi- Menon, 1998: Universal I, screw fixation of the distal
cant difference in grip strength between fusion with retention component into the second metacarpal and hamate68
of the proximal row and fusion with excision of the proximal Clayton et al., 1988, The CFV wrist, a reverse-polarity
row.7 Patients should expect a 6-month learning/adaptation implant30
31
period to the fusion. Ninety-two percent of tasks will be Figgie et al., 1990: Trispherical wrist
61
performed in a normal manner without undue delay. The Legré et al., 1994: Destot prosthesis
greatest functional problems will be perineal care, lifting a Beckenbaugh, 1996: Biaxial wrist, ingrowth fixation into
glass or can from a low table, and horizontal use of a screw- the radius and third metacarpal17
86
driver. Further surgery for plate removal is unlikely with the Radmer et al., 1999: ATW/APH prosthesis
low-profile precontoured plates. Adams, 2001: Universal II (Integra Life Sciences, Plains-
boro, NJ), change in design to reduce the risk for
dislocation2
Total Wrist Replacement Rozing, 2003: RWS implant
87
Although total wrist arthrodesis yields significant pain relief, Palmer et al., 2005: Maestro (Biomet Orthopaedics,
stability, and power grasp, immobility of the wrist now Warsaw, IN), a design with alignment with the lunate fossa
requires compensatory motion of the elbow and shoulder to Gupta, 2005: Re-Motion (Small Bone Innovations, Mor-
accurately place the hand in space and more particularly to risville, PA), an implant with 10 degrees of pronation-
allow the thumb, index finger, and middle finger to perform supination of the components41
fine activities with precision. Therefore, loss of wrist motion
can give rise to significant dysfunction in occupational, self- Swanson, in the late 1960s/early 1970s, developed a flexible-
care, and recreational activities.32,78 However, the individual hinge silicone arthroplasty of the wrist,108 similar to the suc-
patient’s capacity to adapt, compromise, and develop coping cessful MP joint implants. Patients initially had extremely
strategies, coupled with support and assistance from family good results with a high level of pain relief and functional
members, requires careful assessment and counseling to range of motion. Although the early results were encourag-
ensure the proper choice of surgical reconstruction. In ing, it became apparent over time that balance of the wrist
individual patients a decision has to be made whether to was an important issue. Failure of the implant at its distal
preserve motion at the expense of some residual pain or to stem, when inserted into the carpus and third metacarpal,
remove motion and improve the pain considerably. For some was a common feature, with loss of the ulnar shoulder (Figure
patients the choice is very easy and obvious; for others, loss 14.32) of the implant. This frequently occurred in association
of mobility of the wrist may be associated with difficulties with ulnar deviation of the wrist and caused significant func-
with the shoulder and elbow, as seen in patients with inflam- tional problems, and a number of implants had to be removed
matory arthritis. Many patients with a wrist arthrodesis (Figure 14.33). The long-term results of Swanson arthro-
report significant impairment in the finer dextrous activities, plasty31 showed that those that survived and were well bal-
although they learn to cope. In our practice, patients who anced continued to give good pain relief, although a gradually
have undergone wrist arthrodesis on one side and wrist decreasing range of motion. It has recently been recom-
replacement on the other prefer the wrist replacement to the mended by the group in Zurich that for very low-demand
wrist fusion and state that they find preservation of some elderly patients with inflammatory arthritis, use of a Swanson
motion of considerable importance, particularly in activities flexible-hinge implant may still be considered.54 However,
of daily living.74 the development of metal-on-plastic hip replacements
Normal wrist motion is accomplished by a complex interac- encouraged many to attempt to reproduce this success at the
tion of multiple articulations involving the radius, ulna, and wrist joint, and a number of implants were designed, includ-
carpal bones. Total wrist arthroplasty cannot duplicate this ing the early Voltz,123 Meuli,69 and Guepar group implants.4
intricate system, but it can potentially produce a stable, pain- Subsequently, the Mayo clinic introduced the biaxial wrist.17
free joint with a functional range of motion. Achieving a All these implants had their particular foibles with difficulty
functional and durable outcome requires appropriate patient in balancing the wrist. In 1998, Menon presented the first
selection, preoperative planning, and accurate surgery. reports of the ellipsoid Universal I wrist design, which is
Because arthroplasty poses greater risks than arthrodesis composed of a metallic radial component and a polyethylene
does, low-demand patients with special needs or desire for carpal component fixed to a metal carpal base plate.68 The
wrist motion are the best candidates. Recently, patients with implant was a departure from the normal distal stem and
degenerative arthritis are seeking to have replacement rather cement fixation and instead relied on screw fixation in the
than fusion as they gain greater awareness of the surgical second and fourth metacarpals and a central peg in the capi-
options. Careful patient selection is critical to a good outcome, tate. The particular design of this implant was attractive, and
and caution is advised when advising patients with high a number of these procedures were performed. The Univer-
demands and perhaps unrealistic expectations. sal I results as reported by Menon,68 however, identified a
454
PART
III
14
Figure 14.34 The incision is along the line of the third metacarpal and may be extended proximally and distally to facilitate
exposure of the wrist. A, The fourth compartment is raised as for wrist fusion. The second compartment must be raised as
shown. When the retinaculum has been raised in this manner, it can be passed deep to the ECRL, ECRB, and EPL and, with a
hemostat, can be used to maintain radial displacement of the radial-side tendons to facilitate the exposure. B, The dorsal capsule
is raised as shown. (Copyright Elizabeth Martin.)
in fact, aligned in both the sagittal and coronal planes (Figure removed. The distal trial implant is then inserted after
14.37A and B). A cannulated drill is introduced along the removal of the guides (Figure 14.39). The metacarpal align-
guide wire and drilled to the appropriate depth as marked ment guide is placed on the second metacarpal to guide
on the drill. The wire and drill are removed and the distal introduction of the screws through the plate and into the
alignment guide is placed in the drill hole. The cutting guide second metacarpal. A similar process allows introduction of
is placed on the alignment guide and temporary Kirschner the screw into the hamate by alignment with the fourth
wires are inserted through the cutting guide (Figure 14.38). metacarpal guides (Figure 14.40). The screw must be in the
The position is checked with a radiograph. With the cutting hamate but must not cross the fourth CMC joint (which is
guide in place, the appropriate amount of capitate head, mobile). The polyethylene central component is then attached
residual scaphoid, and if necessary, part of the hamate is (Figure 14.41), and range of motion and stability are assessed.
456
PART
III
14
B
Figure 14.37 A, A Kirschner wire is inserted into the capitate and
B passed through to the third metacarpal. B, The position of the
Kirschner wire must be assessed with intraoperative radiographs
Figure 14.36 A, With the guide pin reinserted, the medullary or fluoroscopy.
canal can be reamed. B, The trial radial component is then
inserted.
It is particularly important to assess axial distraction to for the tendons to lie to the ulnar side of the long axis of the
ensure that there is no excessive laxity within the joint that implant, they should be centralized to properly balance the
would encourage dislocation. The distal component has implant (see later).
modular sizes so that appropriate tension can be attained. The patient is immobilized in plaster for a period of 2
However, if the component is too large and prevents exten- weeks for wound healing. The sutures are removed at 2
sion, a smaller component should be inserted. If this is not weeks, at which time early controlled motion in the form of
possible, 2 mm must be removed from the distal radius. flexion-extension and some radial-ulnar deviation is allowed.
When satisfied with the sizing, the trial components can be Over a period of 3 months, wrist range of motion recovers
removed and the final components implanted. The compo- and plateaus.
nents may be inserted with or without cement. It is important
to complete an intercarpal fusion of the distal row bones for Centralization of the Extensor Tendons
support of the carpal component plate. After confirmation of Centralization is achieved by performing a hemitransection
adequate range of motion, particularly in extension, the of the ECRL proximally, raising a strip to its insertion on the
wounds are closed, the capsule is closed, and the extensor base of the second metacarpal, and threading it deep to the
tendons are examined. Provided that the common extensors ECRB and the common extensor tendons.12 This should not
are suitably centralized and aligned, closure of the superficial include the extensor digiti minimi. The strip of ECRL is then
fascia and skin is all that is required. If there is a tendency taken superficial to the extensor digitorum communis and
457
PART
III
14
Wrist
459
PART
Intercarpal arthrodesis is essential to ensure stability of
III
the distal component.
14 Cement fixation is an option.
The range of motion to aim for is 40 degrees of
extension, 20 degrees of flexion, 10 degrees of radial
Wrist
460
REFERENCES 32. Franko OI, Zurakowski D, Day CS: Functional disability of the wrist: PART
1. Abbott LC, Saunders JBM, Bost FC: Arthrodesis of the wrist with the
direct correlation with decreased wrist motion, J Hand Surg [Am]
33:485-492, 2008.
III
use of grafts of cancellous bone, J Bone Joint Surg 24:883-898, 33. Friedman S, Palmer A: The ulnar impaction syndrome, Hand Clin
1942. 7:295-310, 1991. 14
2. Adams BD, Khoury JG: Total wrist arthroplasty. In Weiss APC, Hastings 34. Garcia-Elias M, Cooney WP, An KN, et al: Wrist kinematics after
461
PART 64. Loh YC, Stanley JK, Jari S, et al: Neuroma of the distal posterior 99. Shapiro JS: Power staple fixation in hand and wrist surgery: new
III interosseous nerve. A cause of iatrogenic wrist pain, J Bone Joint Surg
Br 80:629-630, 1998.
applications of an old fixation device, J Hand Surg [Am] 12:218-227,
1987.
65. Louis DS, Hankin FM, Bowers WH: Capitate-radius arthrodesis: an 100. Shin AY: Four-corner arthrodesis, J Am Soc Surg Hand 1:93-111, 2001.
14 alternative method of radiocarpal arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 101. Shin EK, Jupiter JB: Radioscapholunate arthrodesis for advanced
9:365-369, 1984. degenerative radiocarpal osteoarthritis, Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg
Wrist
66. Mannerfelt L: Total arthrodesis of the wrist. In Simmen BR, Hagena 11:180-183, 2007.
FW (eds): The Wrist in Rheumatoid Arthritis, Basel, Karger, 102. Shindle MD, Burton KJ, Weiland AJ, et al: Complications of circular
1992:116-121. plate fixation for four-corner arthrodesis, J Hand Surg Eur Vol 32:50-
67. Mannerfelt L, Malmsten M: Arthrodesis of the wrist in rheumatoid 53, 2007.
arthritis: a technique without external fixation, Scand J Plast Reconstr 103. Smith-Petersen MN: A new approach to the wrist joint, J Bone Joint
Surg 5:124-130, 1971. Surg 22:122-124, 1940.
68. Menon J: Universal Total Wrist Implant: experience with a carpal 104. Stanley JK, Boot DA: Radio-lunate arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Br]
component fixed with three screws, J Arthroplasty 13:515-523, 1998. 14:283-287, 1989.
69. Meuli HC: Arthroplasty of the wrist, Clin Orthop Relat Res 149:118- 105. Stanley JK, Gupta SR, Hullin MG: Modified instrument for wrist
125, 1980. fusion, J Hand Surg [Br] 11:245-249, 1986.
70. Meyerdierks EM, Mosher JF, Werner FW: Limited wrist arthrodesis: a 106. Stein I: Gill turnabout radial graft for wrist arthrodesis, Surg Gynecol
laboratory study, J Hand Surg [Am] 12:526-529, 1987. Obstet 106:231-232, 1958.
71. Millender LH, Nalebuff EA: Arthrodesis of the rheumatoid wrist: an 107. Steindler A: Orthopaedic operations on the hand, JAMA 71:1288-
evaluation of sixty patients and a description of a different surgical 1291, 1918.
technique, J Bone Joint Surg Am 55:1026-1034, 1973. 108. Swanson AB: Flexible implant resection arthroplasty, Hand 4:119-
72. Minamikawa Y, Peimer CA, Yamaguchi T, et al: Ideal scaphoid angle 134, 1972.
for intercarpal arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 17:370-375, 1992. 109. Swanson AB, Swanson GD, Goran-Hagert C: Evaluation of impair-
73. Moy OJ, Peimer CA: Scaphocapitate fusion in the treatment of Kien- ment of hand function. In Hunter JM, Mackin EJ, Callahan AD (eds):
böck’s disease, Hand Clin 9:501-504, 1993. Rehabilitation of the Hand: Surgery and Therapy, 4th ed, St. Louis, CV
74. Murphy DM, Khoury JG, Imbriglia JE, et al: Comparison of arthro- Mosby, 1995:1839-1896.
plasty and arthrodesis for the rheumatoid wrist, J Hand Surg [Am] 110. Soejima O, Iida H, Hanamura T, et al: Resection of the distal pole of
28:570-576, 2003. the scaphoid for scaphoid nonunion with radioscaphoid and inter-
75. Murray JA, Schlafly B: Giant-cell tumors in the distal end of the radius: carpal arthritis, J Hand Surg [Am] 28:591-596, 2003.
treatment by resection and fibular autograft inter-positional arthro 111. Szabo RM, Thorson EP, Raskind JR: Allograft placement with distal
desis, J Bone Joint Surg Am 68:687-694, 1986. radioulnar joint fusion and ulnar osteotomy for treatment of giant
76. Murray PM: Current status of wrist arthrodesis and wrist arthroplasty, cell tumors of the distal radius, J Hand Surg [Am] 15:929-933, 1990.
Clin Plast Surg 23:385-394, 1996. 112. Taleisnik J: The Wrist, New York, Churchill Livingstone, 1985:
77. Nagy L, Büchler U: Long-term results of radioscapholunate fusion 229-303.
following fractures of the distal radius, J Hand Surg [Br] 22:705-710, 113. Thomas DF: A method of arthrodesis of the wrist, Lancet 1:808-809,
1997. 1950.
78. Nelson DL: Functional wrist motion, Hand Clin 13:83-92, 1997. 114. Thurston AJ, Stanley JK: Hamato-lunate impingement: an uncommon
79. Nissen KL: Symposium on cerebral palsy (orthopaedic section), Proc cause of ulnar-sided wrist pain, Arthroscopy 16:540-544, 2000.
R Soc Med 44:87-90, 1951. 115. Tomaino MM, Miller RJ, Cole I, et al: Scapholunate advanced collapse
80. Palmer AK, Dobyns JH, Linscheid RL: Management of post-traumatic wrist: proximal row carpectomy or limited wrist arthrodesis with
instability of the wrist secondary to ligament rupture, J Hand Surg scaphoid excision? J Hand Surg [Am] 19:134-142, 1994.
[Am] 3:507-532, 1978. 116. Trumble T, Bour C, Smith R, et al: Intercarpal arthrodesis for static
81. Palmer AK, Werner FW, Murphy D, et al: Functional wrist motion: a and dynamic volar intercalated segment instability, J Hand Surg [Am]
biomechanical study, J Hand Surg [Am] 10:39-46, 1985. 13:396-402, 1988.
82. Pervaiz K, Bowers WH, Isaacs JE, et al: Range of motion effects of 117. Trumble TE, Easterling KJ, Smith RJ: Ulnocarpal abutment after wrist
distal pole scaphoid excision and triquetral excision after radioscaph- arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 13:11-15, 1988.
olunate fusion: a cadaver study, J Hand Surg [Am] 34:832-837, 118. Tubiana R, Thomine JM, Mackin E: Examination of the Hand and Wrist,
2009. St. Louis, CV Mosby, 1996:185-197.
83. Peterson HA, Lipscomb PR: Intercarpal arthrodesis, Arch Surg 95:127- 119. Vance MD, Hernandez JD, Didonna ML, et al: Complications and
134, 1967. outcome of four-corner arthrodesis: circular plate fixation versus tra-
84. Pisano SM, Peimer CA, Wheeler DR, et al: Scapho-capitate intercarpal ditional techniques, J Hand Surg [Am] 30:1122-1127, 2005.
arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 16:328-333, 1991. 120. Vender MI, Watson HK, Wiener BD, et al: Degenerative change in
85. Pryce JC: The wrist position between neutral and ulnar deviation that symptomatic scaphoid non-union, J Hand Surg [Am] 12:514-519,
facilitates the maximum power grip strength, J Biomech 13:505-511, 1987.
1980. 121. Viegas SF, Patterson RM, Peterson PD, et al: Evaluation of the biome-
86. Radmer S, Andresen R, Sparmann M: Wrist arthroplasty with a new chanical efficacy of limited intercarpal fusions for the treatment of
generation of prostheses in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, J Hand scapho-lunate dissociation, J Hand Surg [Am] 15:120-128,
Surg [Am] 24:935-943, 1999. 1990.
87. Rahimtoola ZO, Rozing PM: Preliminary results of total wrist arthro- 122. Viegas SF, Patterson RM, Peterson PD, et al: Ulnar-sided perilunate
plasty using the RWS Prosthesis, J Hand Surg [Br] 28:54-60, 2003. instability: An anatomic and biomechanical study, J Hand Surg [Am]
88. Rao SB, Culver JE: Triquetrohamate arthrodesis for midcarpal instabil- 15:268-278, 1990.
ity, J Hand Surg [Am] 20:583-589, 1995. 123. Voltz RG: The development of a total wrist arthroplasty, Clin Orthop
89. Rayan GM: Wrist arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 11:356-364, 1986. Relat Res 116:209-214, 1976.
90. Resnik C, Grizzard J, Simmons B, et al: Incomplete carpal coalition, 124. Watson HK, Ashmead D: Triscaphe fusion for chronic scapho-lunate
Am J Radiol 147:301-304, 1986. instability. In Gelberman R (ed): The Wrist, New York, Raven Press,
91. Ritt MJ, Stuart PR, Naggar L, et al: The early history of arthroplasty 1994:183-194.
of the wrist. From amputation to total wrist implant, J Hand Surg [Br] 125. Watson HK, Ashmead D, Makhlouf MV: Examination of the scaphoid,
19:778-782, 1994. J Hand Surg [Am] 13:657-660, 1988.
92. Robinson RF, Kayfetz DO: Arthrodesis of the wrist: preliminary report 126. Watson HK, Ballet FL: The SLAC wrist: scapholunate advanced col-
of a new method, J Bone Joint Surg Am 34:64-70, 1952. lapse pattern of degenerative arthritis, J Hand Surg [Am] 9:358-365,
93. Rogers WD, Watson HK: Radial styloid impingement after triscaphe 1984.
arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 14:297-301, 1989. 127. Watson HK, Fink JA, Monacelli DM: Use of triscaphe fusion in the
94. Ryu J, Askew LJ, Chao EYS, et al: Biomechanical measurements of treatment of Kienbock’s disease, Hand Clin 9:493-499, 1993.
human wrist joint strength, Orthop Trans 10:420-421, 1986. 128. Watson HK, Goodman ML, Johnson TR: Limited wrist arthrodesis: II.
95. Ryu J, Cooney WP III, Askew LJ, et al: Functional ranges of motion of Intercarpal and radiocarpal combinations, J Hand Surg [Am] 6:223-
the wrist joint, J Hand Surg [Am] 16:409-419, 1991. 232, 1981.
96. Sagerman SD, Palmer AK: Wrist arthrodesis using a dynamic com- 129. Watson HK, Ryu J, DiBella A: An approach to Kienböck’s disease:
pression plate, J Hand Surg [Br] 21:437-441, 1996. triscaphe arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 10:179-187, 1985.
97. Salenius P: Arthrodesis of the carpal joint, Acta Orthop Scand 37:288- 130. Watson HK, Weinzweig J: Physical examination of the wrist, Hand
296, 1966. Clin 13:17-34, 1997.
98. Sennwald GR, Ufenast H: Scaphocapitate arthrodesis for the treat- 131. Watson HK, Weinzweig J, Zeppieri J: The natural progression of
ment of Kienböck’s disease, J Hand Surg [Am] 20:506-510, 1995. scaphoid instability, Hand Clin 13:39-50, 1997.
462
132. Weiss APC, Hastings H: Wrist arthrodesis for traumatic conditions: a 136. Wright CS, McMurtry RY: AO arthrodesis in the hand, J Hand Surg PART
study of plate and local bone graft application, J Hand Surg [Am]
20:50-56, 1995.
[Am] 8:932-935, 1983.
137. Wyrick JD, Stern PJ, Kiefhaber TR: Motion-preserving procedures in
III
133. Weiss APC, Wiedeman G, Quenzer D, et al: Upper extremity function the treatment of scapholunate advanced collapse wrist: proximal row
after wrist arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 20:813-817, 1995. carpectomy versus four-corner arthrodesis, J Hand Surg [Am] 20:965- 14
134. Weiss G, Shemer A, Trau H: The Koebner phenomenon: review of 970, 1995.
463