Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Roger Wesley
Business Consultant - Aspen Technology, Inc.
roger.wesley@aspentech.com
Agenda
• Introduction and Overview
• Design and Cost Basis
• Process Equipment and Bulk Models
• Activated Economics Workflow Overview
– Configuring Templates
– Mapping Simulation Data to Equipment Models
– Evaluating the Project and Reviewing Reports
• Appendix (Detailed Information)
– Economic Evaluation Templates
– Sizing (Interactions with EDR and customer sizing rules)
– FAQ
2 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Introduction and Overview
3 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Key Concepts
Activated
Economics
Takes Weeks!
Design in Days!
7 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Work Process Facilitates Collaboration with Estimating
Integration of conceptual design workflow simplifies and accelerates early project
screening by bringing together process simulation and relative economic analysis.
Process
Engineer
Relative Economics
(CAPEX/OPEX)
Preferred Option
Cost
Estimator
Conceptual to
Detailed Cost
Estimate
Identify preferred option and pass to Estimating for full capital project estimate development
8 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Aspen Economic Evaluation Family and the Project Lifecycle
Aspen Aspen
Process Capital
Economic Cost
Analyzer Estimator
Both tools use the same
underlying file format (.IZP)
Projects created in Aspen
Process Economic Analyzer
Two interfaces to the can be revised in Aspen
same underlying model Capital Cost Estimator
APEA ACCE
Limited discipline specifications Detailed specifications by discipline
Fixed dimensions assumed Detailed definition of plot plan dimensions
Estimated Process Control and Power Complete flexibility in defining Process Control
Distribution requirements driven by fixed and Power Distribution requirements
options (Project Type)
Single contractor and E-P-C workforce Multiple contractors and workforces (construction
and engineering) possible
Volumetric models (including P&IDs) Volumetric models (including P&IDs) generate
generate conceptual bulk quantities for conceptual bulk quantities for process equipment
process equipment
CAPEX and OPEX capabilities Capital Cost estimates only
• Product sales estimated using stream data and user entered information
• Profit = Sales - (Capital Costs + Operating Costs)
• Investment analysis module generates typical economic metrics
– NPV
– IRR
– PO, etc.
16 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Economic Evaluation Design and Cost Basis
• Consistent basis for APEA and ACCE
• Design and cost basis updated annually by AspenTech
• Five base locations maintained by AspenTech
– US Gulf Coast
– Middle East
– EU
– UK
– Japan
• China design basis only – go-by templates available
• Base locations reflect typical commodity pricing, labor rates, and design code rules
• Material and labor specifications can be adjusted to represent site-specific
conditions
• Adjusted basis can be saved as Economic Evaluation template
17 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Economic Evaluation Templates
• Templates define Economic Evaluation default settings
• Templates provide a consistent basis for comparing different project options
• Templates can be shared between Activated Economics (Aspen Plus and Aspen
HYSYS), Aspen Process Economic Analyzer (APEA), and Aspen Capital Cost Estimator
(ACCE)
• Templates provide a means to preconfigure project basis
– Default mappings (unit operations to equipment models)
– Equipment sizing parameters
– Stream costs/values
– Utilities
– Raw materials
– Products
– Workforce wage rates and productivity adjustments
– Material cost indices
18 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Aspen Process Economic Analyzer Project Basis
Design assumptions
and rules of thumb by
equipment type
Electric utility
unit costs in
simulation case
will take
precedence
over unit cost
data in template
25 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Process Equipment
• Primary equipment items derived from simulation
– Simulator blocks mapped to one or more Economic Evaluation equipment models
– User-defined parameters govern designs
• Additional process equipment items added by user
– Pumps
– Storage tanks
– Spares
• Equipment models have attached P&ID
– Used to estimate piping and instrumentation costs
– Sizing equations used to estimate pipe quantities (length and diameter)
• Volumetric modeling used to estimate other bulk quantities and costs (civil,
paint, insulation, etc.)
26 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Equipment Design and Cost Procedure
PROJECT SPECS:
• Mechanical design specs
• Project components specs
Equipment design
MECHANICAL DESIGN:
generated
Develop physical dimensions using:
• Design code procedures
• Industry standard methods
FABRICATION LABOR:
• Shop [+ Field]
• Labor
• Man-hours
Bare equipment
(FOB) cost VESSEL COST:
estimated 1. Mat’l cost of parts
2. Shop [+ field] fab labor
3. Labor overheads
4. G and A
5. Profit
27 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Aspen Economic Evaluation – Volumetric Models
• Consistent models in Aspen Capital Cost Estimator and Aspen Process
Economic Analyzer
• Volumetric models generate estimated installation bulk quantities (ISBL)
– Piping
– Civil / steel
– Instrumentation
– Electrical
– Insulation and paint
x
Set materials of construction and ladders
x
Pipe lengths
Calculate fittings Insulate vessel
x
Fabrication cost and piping
x
Scaffolding
Installation labor Paint vessel
and piping
Design and build foundation
By default,
piping
material
follows
equipment
material
specification
Large library
based on
industry best
practice or
add your own 11:43
Pipe
5
Envelope
Height 1
4
Pipe 3
Pipe
Envelope Length Envelope Width
31 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Default Volumetric P&IDs
33 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Activated Economics Analysis
Relative Capital and Utility Costs
• Material costs, site conditions, local labor rates, design standards, and other factors are
drawn from one of our built-in templates, or one created by your Cost Estimation
department using ACCE
• Utility costs, raw material costs, product prices, and carbon tax are specified by the user
• Equipment sizes are drawn from the model if available, or estimated if not available
• Equipment costs are derived by modeling the fabrication and installation process
Evaluate costs
Sizes equipment
Select individual
unit operations
to review and
change mapped
equipment Drop-down list allows
model(s) user to select alternate
equipment model
• If no sizing is done in Aspen Plus / HYSYS, then APEA sizes component based on APEA
sizing rules
• If EDR sizing is used on an exchanger, APEA will base the cost estimate on the EDR
results
• If Tray Sizing utility is used, APEA will use those sizing results and use nearest
packing/tray sizing
• Acid Gas Columns can use geometry specified by user on Acid Gas form
• Custom APEA equipment sizing models can be set up (Excel) and used in conjunction with
activated economics
51 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Activated Economics Provides A Quick Relative Cost
Estimate to Help Guide Decisions
Name of Sub-folder
(Scenario1) defined
as part of Costing
Options
• Equipment costs
• Project summary
• Cashflow report
– NPV
– IRR
– Etc.
• Executive summary
• Utility and utility resource summary
• Raw material and product summaries
• Decision Analyzer
– Analyzer Scale-Up Module (ASM)
– Analyzer Relocation Module (ARM)
– Analyzer Economic Module (AEM)
• Utility Models
– Air (instrument and plant)
– Cooling water
63 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
APEA Templates
64 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Templates
Location, Process
type, Design Codes…
Material pricing
adjustments
• This type of project is used to configure the electrical power distribution system
inside Aspen Process Economic Analyzer. The power distribution specification
generated by Aspen Process Economic Analyzer provides the means of
designating MAIN and UNIT substations and the cabling between them.
• In addition, for plant modifications/revamps, the capital cost excludes cable
costs related to connecting the main substation with the unit; in contrast, for
the remaining project types, a default distance of 1,000 FEET [300 M]
(excluding hook-up allowance) is used to cost the power distribution
components.
Design assumptions
and rules of thumb by
equipment type
Electric utility
unit costs in
simulation case
will take
precedence
over unit cost
data in template
79 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Benefits of Consolidated Economic Evaluation Template
84 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Equipment Specs in Activated Economics
• Users can overwrite data in the equipment • Values in this form are treated as input by
grid like the number of shells, the which the system can recalculate the sizing
equipment application, materials of
• Initiating interactive sizing will clear any
construction, Installation Option, and more.
current specifications or sizing for the
• Updates here will affect costs, but will not selected equipment
recalculate or update related values and
• Completing Interactive Sizing will
fields
completely recalculate the sizing and cost
• To update the overall project and dashboard evaluation for the selected unit; to update
following changes, the evaluate button in the the overall project and dashboard with the
ribbon should be used results of interactive sizing, the evaluate
button in the ribbon should be used
85 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Evaluating in Activated Economics
• Project evaluation will take the sizing • Available in the equipment grid next to the
results for the entire project and evaluate interactive sizing button
costs • Only evaluates the selected equipment item
• If previous steps (mapping and sizing) are • Will update the equipment grid with further
not yet complete, the tool will automatically costs, but will ignore project related costs
perform them before evaluating
• Must use a full project evaluation to update the
• Must use this option to update the results from a single item evaluation to the
dashboard and overall results overall project totals
87 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Aspen EDR: Product Portfolio
• Process data and property data are automatically updated based on HYSYS flow sheets
• If EDR Sizing results are available when performing economic evaluation, then those
results will be used by economics to evaluate costs
– EDR cost data is not used
– EDR occasionally has more rigor in terms of materials and configurations which can not be reflected
in economics; the tool will do it’s best to model the data given by EDR, but occasionally some
quantities must be changed to the next closest design option
• The Economics engine will still perform its own sizing and let the user know if there is a
large discrepancy in the design
• Users can still resize or modify the equipment with economics to overwrite EDR results –
just be sure to set the “Allow Resize” option to “No” so that EDR doesn’t overwrite your
changes on subsequent evaluations
92 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Custom Model - Overview
Users can:
Step 1: Activate Economics (either through the dash or the ribbon) to start up the Economic Engine
Step 2: Click Map and check the “Size Equipment” and “Customize Sizing” options
Step 4: Select System or Custom Sizing Methods for each equipment item
Step 6: Click “Size” to review and modify any manual input in the custom model spreadsheet as needed
(check for ACCE Icon in Task Bar)
Input
Custom
Rules
Output
103 ©
© 2016
2017 Aspen
Aspen Technology,
Technology,Inc.
Inc.All
All rights
rightsreserved
reserved.
Other Questions
Q1: When one simulation is done with its mapping, can this mapping be transferred to another simulation
easily without doing all the remapping?
A1: The template capability enables setting up standard mapping for each unit operation type in the
simulation model. A template file can be saved and used with different simulation models to enforce
consistent mapping. However, if there are exceptions to the standard mapping rule for a particular
instance of a unit operation, those exceptions would need to be mapped as exceptions when the template
is used with a different simulation model if that same exception is desired.
A2: The previous mapping can be re-used by selecting the “Last Mapping” radio
button during the mapping process. Any blocks or stream data which was
present during the first mapping process will have their mapping retained, but
ALL blocks and streams must be recalculated on subsequent evaluations in
V8.6.
Stream data is actually loaded into the IPOD database (in V8.8 and forward the
faster “ADS” database is used) by HYSYS at the end of a successful simulation
run, before the mapping or sizing steps start. During the mapping step, APEA
will check the results in this database and use them as the starting point for
sizing and economic calculations. This is an important distinction because some
actions like changing the utility designation on a flowsheet are not important to
the simulator (the simulation will not re-calculate the run) so new inputs and
results will not be pushed to the underlying database. As such, APEA will not
pick up these differences during mapping unless the user has forced the
simulation to re-run. This can be accomplished easily by making an insignificant
change like modifying the inlet feed stream temperature by 0.1 C.
105 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Other Questions
Q3: Can mapping from HYSYS to APEA be selective, namely only map some of the HYSYS blocks into
APEA equipment models?
A3: Yes, the mapping for an item can be deleted, and that object will not be included in the evaluation. If
this is a regular occurrence, the template could be set up in APEA such that the mapping is always
deleted for certain unit operation types. In V8.8, the ability to perform costing on a partial flowsheet
selection was added to further enhance this workflow.
Q4: How to add a new equipment model, which Aspen does not have? For example, the thermal
oxidizer.
A4: In order to account for this, users can just quote the cost of the equipment (one of the first fields for
any equipment item on the equipment grid), enter the equipment as a quoted “C” item during mapping, or
create a custom excel model of the equipment. In standalone APEA or ACCE, an Equipment Model
Library (EML) item can be used to provide a middle ground between a generic quoted cost item or a full
custom model.
106 © 2017 Aspen Technology, Inc. All rights reserved.
Other Questions
Q5: How to calibrate the base cost data for an equipment? For example, a compressor cost $20M from
vendor quote, while HYSYS default shows $10M. How to update the base cost and still keep HYSYS cost
model for this compressor?
A5: Calibration and indexing is an important process in ACCE for relating the system costs in the tool to
reality. This is especially important considering that the default cost bases in the system can’t possibly
account for all factors for all users. Once you’ve gone through this process in ACCE, it can be included in
a template (note that APEA does not have this level of detail during template creation, but will inherit this
information if the template is developed in ACCE)
Q6: Can ACCE modules (skid, truckable, piperack, etc.) somehow be used in APEA environment?
A6: Module type areas are currently not available in APEA. Though this may affect the overall numbers,
Activation focuses on relative comparisons as opposed to complete project accuracy.
A7: Once the “Sizing” or “Evaluation” steps have been completed, results can be viewed by clicking on
the “View Equipment” button within HYSYS. A detailed report can also be generated and viewed in
Excel by clicking on the “Investment Analysis” button.