GE1712

Name: James Ryann Herrera Section: BSIT A301 – Batch 3

Date: 10/06/20 Score:

Directions: Complete the Comparative Matrix table below. (100 points)

Historical Source Author Event Date Event Objective Persons Involved Main Argument Bias
- Secretary Jacinto
Lumbreras
- Andres Bonifacio
- Messrs. Mariano M.
Alvarez
Tejeros Convention Santiago V. Alvarez March 25, 1897 To strengthen the - Pascual Alvarez They needed to tackle the The Magdalo only
defenses in the areas that - Ariston Villanueva major issue first which is wanted the officials from
are still in the control of - Mariano C. Trias what kind of government their side to win the
the Magdiwang - Diego Mojica should they have and positions and election
- Emiliano R. de Dios how they should establish particularly when
- Santiago V. Alvarez it. Once this is answered, Bonifacio won the
- Artemio Ricarte the problem of the Secretary of Interior,
- Santos Nocon organization and Tirona objected and
- Luciano San Miguel strengthening of defenses suggested that a lawyer
- Pablo Mojica will be resolved. which happens to be a
- Severino de las Alas Magdalo needs to win
- Santiago Rillo that position rather than
- Messrs. Baldomero Andres.
Aguinaldo
- Daniel Tirona
- Cayetano Tipacio
- Captain General Apoy
- Messrs. Emilio
Aguinaldo
- General Vibora

- Governor-General
Blanco
- Mariano Alvarez
- Pascual Alvarez
- Emiliano Riego de Dios
- Mariano Trias
Merge the two factions - Ariston Villanueva Everyone must obey the The Magdalo wanted to
(Magdiwang & Magdalo) - Santiago Alvarez will of the majority in the claim the credits over
Seeds of Discontent Teodoro A. Agoncillo March 22, 1897 into one and elect new - Diego Mojica election regardless of victories on the wars,
officers for the - Artemio Ricarte their educational therefore, they shall be
government - Mariano R. de Dios attainment and social superior than the
- Candido Tirona condition – everyone is Magdiwang faction. The
- Cayetano Topacio equal. Magdalo did not want
- Emilio Aguinaldo Andres to win any
- Edilberto Evangelista position so they opposed
01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI
Page 1 of 2
 GE1712
- Vito Belarmino to him winning the
- Crispulo Aguinaldo Director of Interior.
- Andres Bonifacio
- Ciriaco Bonifacio
- Procopio Bonifacio
- Juan Castaneda
- Bladomero Aguinaldo
- Vicente Fernandez
- Antonio Montenegro
- Jacinto Lumbreras
- Teodoro Gonzales
- Severino de las Alas

01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI

Page 2 of 2
 HISTORICAL SOURCE ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Source Material 1

The author of the first source is the general for the Katipunan and for this The information that he disseminated are too short which may lead people
instance, one can assume that he is more knowledgeable on the history of the into thinking that this isn’t what really happened or too much information is
Tejeros Convention election back then as he is basing this on actual pieces of evidences such as being left out or covered up by the Katipunan today which eventually leads
by Santiago V. Alvarez legal documents or letters that were written by any of the people involved on into the readers gaining less factual information.
the election at the Tejeros Convention.

Source Material 2

The author is a historian so it means that he really studied this particular topic History is often changed by historians making it difficult to pinpoint whether
Seeds of Discontent or history, comparing it with other studies done by other historians. It also the information they are sharing are the actual and final events that took place
by Teodoro A. Agoncillo means that the author deliberately researched on this topic with information on this specific date. Historians tend to exaggerate or paraphrase statements
gathered from actual letters or statements by the people involved. The content of the people involved so that it comes out interesting when you read it.
of this source is also overwhelming as it is very articulate and well-written.

Conclusion and Implication

The election even back then was very shady, messy and controversial. It is also filled with jealousy which is still happening today which causes
lives to be taken away most of the time. Corruption is also a thing not only with the money but also with the minds of other people which creates the
story that this person is bad just like what happened to Andres Bonifacio wherein they convinced Aguinaldo that he was a threat to his position,
therefore, he must be shut down.

For the Comparative Matrix: For the Advantages and Disadvantages:

CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS
Provided the correct information with pieces of evidence and supporting Provided a sound argument with pieces of evidence and supporting
Content 12 Content 20
details. details.
Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1 Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1
Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the
6 8
of Ideas paragraph. of Ideas paragraph.
Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1 Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1
TOTAL 20 TOTAL 30