Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MARKET TECHNICIAN
THE JOURNAL OF THE STA
IN THIS ISSUE
T. Pelc The rhythm of time ....................................................................................................1
R. Miller Point and figure charting...........................................................................................5
J. Monfort Acute monthly reversals (AMRs) .............................................................................7
D. McMinn DJIA peaks, seasonality and market outcomes ..................................................10
D. Watts Bytes and Pieces ......................................................................................................13
This year's IFTA conference was held in Berlin in the week that the city was
celebrating the 20th anniversary of the Wall coming down. As usual it
provided an excellent forum for technical analysts around the world to meet
and exchange views. One day of the conference was devoted to the energy
markets and we hope that some of the speakers will submit articles to the
journal in the coming months. Next year's conference will be held in Sarajevo
on 6-8 October.
THE SOCIETY OF TECHNICAL ANALYSTS COPY DEADLINE FOR THE NEXT ISSUE FEBRUARY 2011
www.sta-uk.org PUBLICATION OF THE NEXT ISSUE MARCH 2011
MARKET TECHNICIAN
5,125 years =
Price Development
Accumulation
The Grand Cycle – The Heavens
Disdain Time Surrender
Disgust and the Earth
But measuring time is an interesting
Looking for when markets may turn, movements, or lunar cycles, or the exercise since humans have manipulated
using cycles gives us the timing element actual natural Earth cycle for timing our measurement of it in history. Today
for strategic activity (50% of the events. The argument is there may be we use the Gregorian calendar (still out
equation, the other half is focusing on little dualism between natural events by 26 seconds a year) which was a
price). The premise is that we, as and the reactions of the financial product of its predecessor the Roman
people, manipulate our measurement of markets. calendar. Why do we have 28 days in
time (and the calendar) and the February and 31 in July and August? It
suggestion is maybe we should use There is a lot of speculation about the is thanks to Augustus Caesar. But 90
external influences such as planetary 2012 date generally; it is significant in countries today use the alternative lunar
calendar in their culture – namely the 13
months calendar with 28 days per
Chart 1: The Grand Cycle – The Heavens and the Earth
month.
Grand Cycle
Procession of the Equinoxes = 25,820 yrs • 65% of US publicly traded companies
use January to measure the fiscal
Earth transits through each of the 12 Zodiac signs
= 2152 yrs approx each year.
Chart 3
Kirikomi
H
Doji
S S Cable Subtract Upside Upside Upside Upside Upside Upside Upside
NL
High RULE OF 7 Additive Divide Given Multiply Given Add
Yo-sen tsutsumi
7.00 5.00 1.40 0.32 0.45 1.3682 1.8193
Chart 6: UK 10 Year generic yield – weekly and 39 week cycle as sunspot activity or lunar cycles
or even in some cases planetary
alignments.
Chart 7: USD Index – Weekly chart with 39 week cycle When China revalued the Renminbi on
21st July 2005, it was the closest the
Moon was to the Earth in eight years.
KENUKI TOP My suspicion is that, as a result of their
cultural heritage, they are extremely
aware of important natural dates. On
the Summer Solstice, 21st June 2010,
another China story hit the market.
The authorities announced they were
adopting a more “flexible” exchange
rate policy, moving from the US dollar
peg.
Chart 1 Chart 2
the low are both significant. The the mistake of assuming that there is
STA Diploma problem in such a case is this: which support at 95. Thus, when the price
price should be recorded? reaches 90 on Day 7, this could be a P&F
Results Some experts say that because it is
double bottom sell signal.
impossible to tell whether the high or However, with the simple addition of the
DISTINCTION low came first during the time period, "RM Dot", which shows 2 "Dots" in the
the basic rule should be maintained, 2nd column, we have a record of the
Pretesh Bhayani
namely: that in a column of X's the high price reaching 90 and, thus, the P&F
Bruno Vignoto takes priority; and, in a column of O's double bottom sell signal could be
the low takes priority. Thus, in short, the ignored until confirmation at, say, 85.
Woo Fook Mun other prices should then be discarded.
This basic method works in most cases The great advantage, short of recording
because the market invariably “catches full price movements, is that the addition
PASS up” and consequently the full price of "RM Dots" play no other part in the
movement is recorded in the following P&F analysis; save the simple record that
Joy Basford columns. In short, the market confirms the price, e.g., in my given example,
upwards or downwards movement. dropped to 90. The addition of the "RM
Magnus F Becher
Dot" should, of course, only be made if
Dmytro Bondar However, on some occasions this is not there is a blank box in the opposite
the case and the P&F chart is left with direction. If there is an "X" or "O" in
Sammy Chammas potentially incorrect support/resistance these boxes, then support/ resistance
levels. Indeed, some well known experts has already been recorded and the prices
Kyriakos Charilaou
in this field have said that although this have no impact on support/resistance.
Jack Davidson is a problem it should be ignored as it is
insurmountable. I trust that this brief introduction to the
Jamie Davis "RM Dot", which I believe provides the
Daljit Dhaliwal Well, after years of study and a sudden missing factor in the great value of P&F
moment of realisation, I believe that I analysis, is sufficient for you to
Yeo Kam Fai have found a workable solution to this understand why I am enthusiastic about
insurmountable problem and I wish to its value and why I am keen to share the
Peter S Fox share my idea with colleagues. By idea with colleagues. I would welcome
Goay Chia Chia sharing my idea, I am hoping to see all comments and further discussion.
whether my idea is robust enough to Please feel free to email me on
Philip Heurich withstand the scrutiny of others who are Richard@rmmarketpredictions.com.
also users of P&F charts. For simplicity, I Even better, it would be great to see
Leona Gomez-Lopez
have called my idea the "RM Dot". some discussion played out in the
Peng Kong Mah columns of this Journal.
below show a solid track record back-tested over the last eight to 30 years,
There is, however, a much simpler way
with consistent returns (see results below). which avoids complex trigonometry and
yet encapsulates the core principle of
the idea of a sudden explosive change in
It has been noted that major trend rise after the low. The ‘y’ and ‘z’ degrees direction.
changes often exhibit an early represent the angles of ascent and
characteristic which distinguishes them descent and the odds favour the By simplifying the application of the
from mere corrections of the prevailing occurrence of a reversal when y is principle it can be adopted quite easily
trend. This is not true all the time but higher than z over the same period of as a strategy technique. Using the
many times it is. This characteristic is time. This can be represented height of price bars as a guide and using
that major trend reversals tend to occur mathematically as: monthly bars it is possible to measure
with an initial ‘explosive’ change in price. the rate of ascent and descent of a move
This is the initial lift-off stage. Reversal = y degrees > z degrees (over quickly and easily. At market turns,
Corrections can have this characteristic same time period). where the price bar in the opposite
too but it is more often the case that it direction to the established trend is
accompanies stronger longer term Corrections tend to exhibit the opposite, stronger and higher then the preceding
cyclical market moves. which means the angle of the main bar it signals that the ascent is an AMR.
trend tends to remain the more acute as Where the bar is weaker it signals a
Expressed in another way, it is the angle shown graphically below: correction.
of ascent or descent compared to the
angle of the established trend which The charts below show how the principle
helps differentiate the two types of is applied in practice. Fig 1a represents
market activity. In a reversal, the angle the initial green bar. The next
tends to be sharper in the direction of requirement is for another bar which
the new trend than in the direction of makes a new low/high, and a third bar
the dying trend. This is illustrated in the which fails to make a new high or low
diagram below: and actually breaks down to below or
above the low/high of the first bar. This
signals a reversal. Figs 1a, b and c show
the progression of the bearish version of
the setup. The trigger for the analysis
technique’s signal occurs at point ‘a’ on
figure 1c.
In this case the mode of market
behaviour could be represented Fig 1a Fig 1c
mathematically as
Fig 2a Fig 2c
Fig 2b
Variations
Apart from the classic set-ups described
above, I have included a variation.
Obviously the main principle is that the
market rebounds in a more acute move
to that which it preceded and so I have
widened the definition to include
monthly key reversals too. A monthly
key reversal is a bar which posts a new
high or low and then during the same
bar reverses posting a new low or high
respectively. Chart 1 shows a bearish
key reversal from the chart of the
GBP/USD.
The signal created by the AMR can Open position P/L 48,920 0 0 2,189.23
either be used in conjunction with Trading Period 8 yrs 35yrs 35yrs 35yrs
other indicators or as a stand alone 3 months, 1 day 3mon, 29 days 3mon, 29 days 3mon,29 days
investment strategy. The signal works Tradesize 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000
best in volatile markets so it could be (In units of currency)
optimised using Average True Range to
avoid losing signals in sideways currency units, given that margin is for periods out of the market was set at
markets. quite generous in the foreign exchange 2% in the broker account. Brokers do
market, the capital requirement varied vary quite a lot however on what they
If being used as a stand alone depending on the maximum drawdown will pay you. Calculating carry trade
investment strategy, the following for the particular security. At the time of profit or loss would be a necessary
additional rules apply: writing (in Oct 2010) these maximum exercise to any serious application of the
draw-downs stood at $15,433.97 for the strategy given the long periods in the
1) If a key reversal occurs, go back a USD/JPY, $10,551.00 for EUR/USD, market.
month before the first month to find $48,430 for the GBP/USD and
out the direction of the trend. If up $28,616.80 for the USD/CHF. Comparison with 5%
then the key reversal is bearish, if interest/annum
down then bullish. Risk/Reward Taking the minimum capital
2) Allow for pyramiding: if multiple
There was no strict constant static requirements above from the maximum
signals occur in the same direction,
risk/reward because the size of the draw-down figures we can also assess
which is a feature of this strategy,
initiating candlestick could vary. Given what the money would have earned had
allow pyramiding. When a signal in
the moving stop beyond the first month, it been placed in a savings account to
the opposite direction is triggered
the risk/reward varied after that too. make a comparison. Below are the
then close all the trades in the
The results showed however that on results for an annual 5% return.
pyramid. Use the most recent trade
entry point for stop placement and average the rewards far exceeded the
risks. But the actual probability success EUR/USD = $15,588.53
remember to make the stop/buy to
USD/JPY = $85,134.02
cover orders for all the contracts in rate hovered around the 50% or just
GBP/USD = $267,140.60
the pyramid! below and it was the greater reward that
USD/CHF = $157,850.70
made the strategy profitable rather than
These show that, apart from the
Results a higher probability success rate. This
EUR/USD pair which far outperformed a
lends weight to the principle
The table shows the results for various regular savings account, the other pairs
underpinning the strategy that the AMR
periods up until July 2010. The start spread over 35 years only beat the 5%
is good at determining changes in trend
dates were between 8 and 35 years savings account by quite small amounts,
at an early stage. It is also highlights the
back, depending on the security in particularly in the case of GBP/USD – but
importance of overlaying any trading
question. The euro, for example, it is crucially they did outperform the savings
system with a disciplined money
eight years because it has a shorter account. This is particularly attractive in a
management approach i.e. letting low interest rate environment when it is
history compared to the others. The
profits run and cutting losses. increasingly hard to find assets yielding a
results included a 1% commission cost
and 3% slippage costs. 5% return.
‘Carry’ Trade Considerations
Interest accrued or deducted because of Joaquin Monfort is an analyst for the
Capital Requirements internet Forex broker
interest rate differentials were also not
included or calculated although interest www.Forex4you.com
Although trade size was set at 100,000
Anomalies - -
The obvious question arises as to
whether the approach was valid or due Sep 11 – Jan 31 Jan 20 – Aug 05 22
to coincidence. Statistical testing would
Anomalies Nov 13, 1919, Sep 19, 1960, 4
be very difficult to undertake to help
Nov 26, 1973 & Dec 22, 1916
clarify this point. However, it seems
improbable that the numerous examples (a) AODPP rises and falls => 2.00%
in Table 1 would take place collectively
by chance. When the peak-panic
parallels do arise, they can be very Table 3
precise (eg: 1895 – 1899, 1901 – 1946,
1912 – 2007, 1929 – 1987 and so DJIA Highs AODPP Falls No AODPP Rises No
forth). Importantly, some years cannot Feb 01 – Sep 03 Aug 01 – Oct 31 9 Sep 05 – Oct 31 7
be appraised because they contained no
significant AODPP falls over about - Anomalies Feb 01, 1982 1 Jan 28, 1982 Jan 17, 1991 2
2.25% (eg: after the 1956, 1968, 1976 Sep 04 – Sep 10 Dec 18 – 23 2 Dec 18-23 2
and 1981 peaks).
Anomalies - - - -
The April 23, 2010 DJIA high marked
the beginning of yet another market
collapse and aligned most closely with Table 4
peaks on April 6, 1956 and April 27, DJIA Peak 1st OD Fall % 2nd OD Fall % OD Rise %
1981. No one day falls over -2.25%
were experienced in the year after the Jun 12, 1901 Sep 07, 1901 -4.43 Sep 13, 1901 -4.27 Sep 16, 1901 +4.10
tops in 1956 or 1981. Even so in the May 29, 1946 Sep 03, 1946 -5.56 Sep 09, 1946 -4.41 Oct 15, 1946 +3.58
month to June 5, 2010, there were
three days that registered falls May 21, 2001 * Sep 11, 2001 na Sep 17, 2001 -7.13 Sep 24, 2001 +4.47
between -3.10% and -3.60%. (This May 02, 2008 * Oct 09, 2008 -7.33 Oct 15, 2008 -7.87 Oct 13, 2008 +11.08
included the May 6 Flash Crash, when
the intra-day low plunged by over - (a) These intra bear market peaks were the high for the calendar year.
9.00%.) Given such inconsistencies, Abbreviation: OD – One Day.
the 2010 market decline may not follow
other historic DJIA bear markets that
commenced in April. Since 1910, major September-October NB: The annual one day fall is taken as
annual one day falls (=> -3.60%) were the biggest % one day fall in the year
preceded by a peak in one of three commencing March 1.
Seasonality
ways:
For all highs between February 1 and Curiously, four autumn panics occurred
September 10, the 23 ensuing AODPP • A record high happened between after market highs between May 1 and
rises and falls (=> 2.00%) happened in September 5 and October 31 and was June 12. Each consisted of two major
the half year commencing August 5, followed by an AODPP fall within 10 one day percentage falls six days apart.
with NO EXCEPTIONS (see Appendix 2). days. The associated downturn was a The autumn panic of 1901 was triggered
This would be very unlikely to arise by brief correction (1927, 1955, 1986 by the assassination of President
chance. For the DJIA peaks between and 1989). McKinley and has been included,
September 11 and January 31, most • If the record high occurred from July together with the 1946, 2001 and 2008
ensuing AODPP rises and falls occurred 15 to September 3, a major AODPP events. (Table 4)
in the 6.5 months commencing January fall took place some months later and
20. (Table 2) the market decline was usually
Conclusions
severe but only lasted a few months
Remarkably, DJIA peaks between (1929, 1987, 1997 and 1998). There was a notable propensity for
February 1 and September 3 nearly • If the market peak for the calendar peak-panic intervals to be similar for
always had ensuing AODPP falls (=> - year happened between February 24 those bear markets beginning at the
2.00%) in the three months to October and May 31 and was not a record same time of the year. As a trend it was
31. The corresponding AODPP rises (=> high, then the ensuing autumn quite reliable – surprising given the
+2.00%) happened in September and AODPP fall was within a protracted simplicity of the approach. When the
October, with two anomalies in January. bear market (1931, 1937, 1946, peak-panic parallels do arise, they can
(Table 3) 2001 and 2008).
be very precise. Unfortunately, the Appendix 1 DJIA peak – AODPP fall intervals
peak-AODPP rise intervals had a poor
1895 and 1899 Peaks
track record and only worked well on a
few occasions (eg: 1895-1899 and DJIA Peak AODPP Fall % AODPP Rise % BM Low
1929-1987-1997). Thus it would be Sep 04, 1895 (a) Dec 20, 1895 -6.61 Dec 23, 1895 +4.37 Aug 08, 1896
spurious to use them as an indicator of Sep 05, 1899 Dec 18, 1899 -8.72 Dec 19, 1899 +4.72 Sep 24, 1900
three months to October 31. Peaks Jan 19, 1906 Apr 27, 1906 -2.76 May 04, 1906 +3.04 Nov 15, 1907
May 01, 1906 -2.73
taking place between September 11 and
Jan 14, 2000 Apr 14, 2000 -5.64 Mar 16, 2000 +4.98 Sep 21, 2001
January 31 usually had the ensuing
AODPP rise and falls in the 6.5 months OD Fall % OD Rise % Panic
commencing January 20. Jan 19, 1906 Mar 15, 1907 -8.72 Mar 16, 1907 +6.69 Oct 22, 1907
Jan 14, 2000 Mar 22, 2001 -4.08 Mar 26, 2001 +3.28 Sep 11, 2001
From the findings, major DJIA peaks 1909 and 1916 Peaks
can be a useful indicator, when the DJIA Peak AODPP Fall % AODPP Rise %
subsequent AODPP falls were most likely Nov 19, 1909 Feb 07, 1910 -3.44 Jun 07, 1910 +2.99
to occur. The month and day when a Jul 28, 1910 +3.01
major peak formed at the beginning of a Nov 21, 1916 Feb 01, 1917 -7.24 Dec 22, 1916 +5.49
bear market are crucial for comparisons
1912 and 2007 Peaks
to be made to historic trends. However,
DJIA Peak AODPP Fall % AODPP Rise %
the relationship was not 100% accurate,
Sep 30, 1912 Jan 20, 1913 -4.90 Jun 12, 1913 +3.01
with historical anomalies being evident.
Oct 09, 2007 Jan 21, 2008 (b) Mar 11, 2008 (c) +3.55
Mar 17, 2008 (c) +3.41
McMinn (2006, 2009) established strong
links between Moon-Sun cycles and 1919 and 1938 PEAKS
market cycles. Given the importance of DJIA Peak AODPP Fall % AODPP Rise % OD Fall % OD Rise %
DJIA peak seasonality, the position of Nov 03 May 19 -4.22 Nov 13 +3.30 Jun 20 -3.49 Jul 06 +3.18
the Sun on the ecliptical circle could be 1919 1920 1919 1921 1921
hypothesised to be highly relevant in the Nov 12 Apr 08 -3.86 Sep 05 +7.26 May 14 -6.76 Jun 12 +4.74
timing of US stock market peaks and 1938 1939 1939 1940 1940
May 21 -6.78
panics. (The Sun is at the same position
1940
on the ecliptical circle at the same time
of the solar year.) Alas, the Moon-Sun 1929, 1987 and 1997 Peaks
mathematics involved in market timing DJIA Peak AODPP Fall % AODPP Rise % PC Low
is extremely complex and impossible to Sep 03, 1929 Oct 28, 1929 -12.83 Oct 30, 1929 +12.24 Nov 13,1929
unravel based on current knowledge. Aug 25, 1987 Oct 19, 1987 -22.61 Oct 21, 1987 +10.17 Dec 04, 1987
Aug 06, 1997 Oct 27, 1997 -7.18 Oct 28, 1997 +4.71 Nov 12, 1997
McMinn, David. Market Timing Moon (a) Peak based on the 12 Stock Average index.
Sun Research 2006-2009. Privately (b) Worldwide stock market panics occurred on January 21, 2008. However, the US market was
Published. 2009. closed on the day due to Martin Luther King Jnr holiday. Even so, this date was taken as the
DJIA AODPP fall for 2007.
(c) The two biggest percentage one day rises in the 11 months after the Oct 09, 2007 high.
Appendix 2 DJIA peaks and ensuring AODPP rises and falls (a)
Bytes and
DJIA High DJIA AODPP Fall % Fall DJIA AODPP Rise % Rise
Feb 09, 1966 Oct 03, 1966 -2.10 Oct 12, 1966 +2.58 Pieces
Mar 10, 1937 Oct 18, 1937 -7.75 Oct 20, 1937 +6.07
Maximize your profits with
Apr 06, 1956 (b) - (b) - Omnitrader 2011
Apr 27, 1981 (c) Aug 24, 1981 -2.23 Jan 28, 1982 +2.56 Nirvana Systems Omnitrader now
comes with a new dynamic profits
Feb 01, 1982 -2.22
module that maximises the potential
May 29, 1946 Sep 03, 1946 -5.56 Oct 15, 1946 +3.58 profit in every trade by allowing
optimisation of systems, filters,
Jun 12, 1901 Sep 07, 1901 -4.43 Sep 16, 1901 +4.10
confirmers and stop exits. This uses
Jul 16, 1990 Aug 06, 1990 -3.32 Jan 17, 1991 +4.57 the adaptive reasoning module to
derive the optimal parameters via
Jul 17, 1998 Aug 31, 1998 -6.63 Sep 08, 1998 +4.98
a dynamic optimisation that can
Aug 25, 1987 Oct 19, 1987 -22.61 Oct 21, 1987 +10.17 constantly adapt to new market
conditions. For details, see:
Sep 03, 1929 Oct 28, 1929 -12.83 Oct 30, 1929 +12.34 http://www.omnitrader.com/up
Sep 04, 1895 (d) Dec 20, 1895 -6.61 Dec 23, 1895 +4.73 grade/OT2011.pdf
Sep 05, 1899 Dec 18, 1899 -8.72 Dec 19, 1899 +4.72 Trade with Precision
Sep 12, 1939 (c) May 14, 1940 -6.76 Jun 12, 1940 +6.73 Head trader Nick McDonald presents
May 21, 1940 -6.78 free training online to those who
open an account with the brokerage
Sep 21, 1976 (b) - (b) -
firm ICE Futures. He aims to give
Sep 30, 1912 Jan 20, 1913 -4.90 Jun 12, 1913 +3.01 people a real feel for trading the
markets. So, for the price of a trade,
Oct 09, 2007 (e) Jan 21, 2008 (f) Mar 11, 2008 +3.55
you get free training. For those with
Mar 17, 2008 +3.51 a large enough brokerage account,
Nov 03, 1919 May 21, 1920 -4.21 Nov 13, 1919 +3.30
two complimentary trading videos
are available via the following link.
Nov 12, 1938 Apr 08, 1939 -3.86 Jul 17, 1939 +3.41 http://www.tradewithprecision.
com/ice_market_outlook.
Nov 19, 1909 Feb 07, 1910 -3.44 Jul 28, 1910 +3.01
Nov 21, 1916 Feb 01, 1917 -7.24 Dec 22, 1916 +5.49 Tick-Tock
VICE-CHAIRMAN
Axel Rudolph .........................................................................axel.rudolph@commerzbank.com
TREASURER
Simon Warren ....................................................................................................warrens@bupa.com
PROGRAMME ORGANISATION
Axel Rudolph .........................................................................axel.rudolph@commerzbank.com
Mark Tennyson-d'Eyncourt ...............................................................deynvest@hotmail.co.uk
LIBRARY
John Douce: .........................................................................................................jdmjd@tiscali.co.uk
Clive Lambert ..........................................................................................clive@futurestechs.co.uk
EDUCATION
Axel Rudolph .........................................................................axel.rudolph@commerzbank.com
Guido Riolo ............................................................................................guidoriolo@bloomberg.net
IFTA LIAISON
Robin Griffiths ................................................................robin.griffiths@cazenovecapital.com
MARKETING
Karen Jones.............................................................................karen.jones@commerzbank.com
Clive Lambert ..........................................................................................clive@futurestechs.co.uk
Adam Sorab ................................................................................................adam.sorab@cqsm.com
MEMBERSHIP
Simon Warren ....................................................................................................warrens@bupa.com
REGIONAL CHAPTERS
SCOTLAND: Alasdair McKinnon ............................................................AMcKinnon@sit.co.uk
IRELAND: Robert Reid ...................................................................robertreid64@gmail.com
COMPANY SECRETARY
Mark Tennyson-d’Eyncourt ...............................................................deynvest@hotmail.co.uk
STA JOURNAL
Editor, Deborah Owen......................................................................................editor@irc100.com
WEBSITE
David Watts .........................................................................................................DWattsUK@aol.com
Simon Warren ....................................................................................................warrens@bupa.com
Deborah Owen .....................................................................................................editor@irc100.com
The Society is not responsible for any material published in The Market
Technician and publication of any material or expression of opinions does not
necessarily imply that the Society agrees with them. The Society is not
authorised to conduct investment business and does not provide investment
advice or recommendations.
Articles are published without responsibility on the part of the Society, the editor
or authors for loss occasioned by any person acting or refraining from action as
a result of any view expressed therein.