Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rol Del Cio PDF
Rol Del Cio PDF
How to Become a
Strategist CIO
Ariel La Paz, Department of Management Control & Information Systems, University of Chile
A strategist CIO is a top IT executive who can exploit the use of information
systems and technologies by participating in business strategy formulation.
This article describes CIOs’ main characteristics and strategist experiences.
I
n the past few decades, information systems munication, and technical skills to lead business
and IT (IS/IT) have changed rapidly in tech- process improvements.4 They must create part-
nological capacity, use, and how businesses nerships with business leaders, translate corporate
depend on them. Consequently, the role of IT goals into projects, and accurately measure the re-
professionals and IT executives has also changed.1 sults to facilitate the implementation of business
The academic and professional literature describes strategies through IS/IT and provide governance
the ideal CIO role as that of a strategist for business on technology use. Failure to do so threatens
growth, survival, and transformation.2,3 The top companies that seek to harvest benefits from IS/
IS executive is expected to marry IS/IT innovations IT investments by misaligning important techno-
with business strategies to generate competitive logical, human, and financial resources; this not
advantages; reduce costs; manage data, informa- only results in economic loss but also hampers the
tion, and knowledge; manage the IT portfolio; and credibility of IS/IT teams and assets as facilitators
govern IS to improve organizational agility. of business processes and value creation.
Today, CIOs are not (or should not be) respon- Several authors describe the evolution of the
sible merely for operational continuity—they must CIO role as shifting from a technical, operational,
also bear responsibility for value creation1 through or utilitarian one to that of an enabler, innova-
the design of IS/IT architectures and the delivery tor, and strategist. Several archetypes and func-
of services. They must combine managerial, com- tions have been attributed to CIOs, but evidence
48 IT Pro January/February 2017 Published by the IEEE Computer Society 1520-9202/17/$33.00 © 2017 IEEE
reflecting failures in the strategic management of Information & Management, Journal of MIS, the
IT units,5,6 as well as the implementation of proj- Hawaii International Conference on System
ects that deliver poor value, bring into question Sciences, the International Conference on In-
whether the ideal profile has been achieved. formation Systems, the Americas Conference
Although the strategist CIO profile has been pre- on Information Systems, and so on);
scribed by the literature3,4,7–10 and is demanded by • professional and practitioner reviews (MISQ
modern companies, the IT executives market has Executive, Communications of the AIS, McKinsey, In-
not produced a sufficient supply.11 Descriptions of formationWeek, Forbes, eWeek, CIO Magazine, and
CIO profiles relate to the agendas, priorities, and so on); and
output of the top IT executive, but little has been • recently published books on CIO experiences
written about the process of becoming a strategist and recommendations.
CIO in accordance with the needs of today’s com-
panies. These agendas indicate great advances in Performing a literature review brings value to
the theoretical and practical specifications on the this study by identifying, analyzing, and synthe-
demand side but contain few insights on how to sizing the findings of previous studies. Figure 1
supply more strategist CIOs to organizations. lists the sources of those reference documents
Given this unmet demand, and the increasing that describe CIO profiles, performance, styles,
need for CIOs who create and capture value via evolution, transformation, success, and similar
IS/IT, this study focuses on clarifying the dif- concepts, leading to an understanding of the
ferences among various CIO profiles. It aims to commonalities and differences between strate-
provide IT professionals and executives with a gist CIOs and other types of CIOs.
self-assessment and career projection tool, along
with a documented description of how some CIO Types and Characters
CIOs became strategists. We want to answer the The literature analysis identified an interesting
question of how to become a strategist CIO in array of CIO archetypes (professional, para-
order to produce professionals and IT executives trooper, consultant, executive, activist, col-
who are better prepared to leverage, expand, pio- laborator, technician, innovator, enabler, and
neer, and transform today’s businesses with IS/ strategist) and functions (spokesman, leader,
IT. Although there is no single answer, I explore communicator, innovator, liaison, and resource
the available literature and document the abilities allocator). However, it revealed neither a theory
of strategist CIOs, synthesizing how these abili- or conceptual model for how to become a strat-
ties could be developed or acquired. This article egist—or other type of—CIO nor a framework
discloses sets of personal competencies schemati- for assessing what type of CIO an IT executive
cally arranged as compounds of capabilities and actually is. Moreover, the role of the top IT ex-
skills linked to the strategist performance, which ecutive was described as a disappearing posi-
can transform IS/IT resources into organizational tion,11 indicating that a desired or ideal type of
competitive advantages12 and thus provide a ratio- CIO performance is difficult to achieve. Some
nale for the process of becoming a strategist CIO. researchers identify CIO features,2,3,7,13 whereas
others investigate the question of who becomes
Unveiling the Strategist Path a CIO.14–16 Figure 2 presents a conceptual map
For the theoretical basis of this study, I systemati- of the literature review findings that identifies
cally explored and analyzed the literature. For the and organizes the various descriptions and il-
empirical analysis, I identified and interviewed a lustrates the transition from technologist to
sample of 12 strategist CIOs. The literature re- strategist CIO.
view involved searching for keywords and terms Four CIO profiles associated with the evolu-
related to CIO profiles, performance, transforma- tion and adoption of IT were obtained from
tion, evolution, and success. The review surveyed the literature to describe the role’s transfor-
mation and shift toward a strategist function.3
• reputed academic journals and conference Additionally, descriptions of the ideal strategist
proceedings in the areas of management infor- profile were found.10,12,17 The review produced
mation systems (MIS Quarterly, IS Management, a schematic progression for the acquisition and
computer.org/ITPro 49
IT Management
Bibliographic sources
Figure 1. Bibliographic academic and professional document sources. These sources were surveyed
to study the CIO profile and synthesize the accrued knowledge.
- Manage IT resources
* Implement IT
- Gain trust in the organization
Technologist * Demonstrate value of IT - Provide operational continuity to a Technical
technological architecture skills
Figure 2. CIO types and associated capabilities, functions, and skills according to descriptions
found in the academic and professional literature. The top half of the figure displays those profiles
associated with companies that consider IT and information systems as strategic for the business
model. The bottom half displays profiles associated with companies that consider these technologies
and systems as utilitarian for operations.
computer.org/ITPro 51
IT Management
scorecard projects, start to see the connection of nological and management degrees is not the
technologies with business results, and broad- only important factor; what the CIO is doing
en their perspectives. —IT consulting CIO is also significant. In this section, I summarize
interviews and tips from individuals on the ne-
A strategist CIO in the C-suite participates in cessity of balancing soft skills, influence in the
the definition of plans and monitors value creation C-suite, IT and business alignment, team build-
for the company using IS/IT. The CIO also coor- ing, planning, and CIO priorities. The synthesis
dinates reactions to competitors, customers, and of experiences with the scholarly documents is
partners’ technological innovations, identifies the schematically presented in Figure 3.
timing for expansion to new digital markets, and
makes IS/IT-based business decisions. By speak- Acquire Soft Skills
ing to experts in IS/IT, I realized that the strategist Often, soft skills tend to be omitted or mini-
CIO vision is business-oriented first and IT-ori- mized in informatics or computing undergradu-
ented second—even though they come mostly ate programs. However, the abilities to effectively
from the technical realm; the goal is to think stra- communicate and negotiate with various stake-
tegically to support and improve the quality of holders, build consensus, persuade and reach
decision-making processes and, in many cases, to agreement, lead complex projects, publicize suc-
understand the business model as a CEO would. cess in a business language, and empathize with
users are fundamental for strategist CIOs. These
What Strategist CIOs Do skills (and others) should be developed or ac-
quired by CIOs both to improve their influence
Undergraduate studies determine much of the in the C-suite and to inspire and build a strong
CIO style, but I’ve also seen industrial engineers and coordinated IS/IT team.
becoming too technical. —Finance/banking CIO
Influence Key People
Most individuals in the sample were experienced A strategist should positively influence business
and obtained formal education at the master’s decisions.22 In the C-suite, CIOs should show
level. However, who they are in terms of tech- themselves to be constructive and collaborative,
computer.org/ITPro 53
IT Management
migrating and backing up data, and installing and of how to become strategists and differentiate
configuring applications that provide operational their role and performance from that of other
continuity. CIO types. The process of becoming a strate-
gist requires the acquisition and development of
Lead and Strengthen Their Teams skills that must be applied to many dimensions
It is critical for the strategic performance of CIOs simultaneously. This articulation implies plan-
that they build and maintain autonomous and ning and execution on two fronts: who you are
well-structured teams, so that they can dedicate and what you do. For “who you are,” the strate-
their time to strategic initiatives. This work ne- gist CIO needs to acquire technical and mana-
cessitates more than monitoring and incentive gerial abilities, either by enrolling in academic
schemes. It also requires forming teams with a programs that complement varying abilities or
customer- and user-oriented culture of service, through the systematic accrual of experience.
avoiding, for example, blaming others (users) for “What you do” means using your acquired abili-
unsuccessful projects and services, but building ties and skills in the right context, where infor-
business solutions in partnership with users who mation is a key asset for the sustainability and
are business generators. The team supporting a success of the business model.
strategist CIO requires empowerment and struc- To succeed in making strategic business contri-
ture with clear functions, responsibilities, and butions, the strategist CIO needs to apply techno-
methodologies, so that the strategist CIO can logical, managerial, and soft skills to gain a space
dedicate his or her efforts to influence and align and voice at the C-level; direct a team to produce
the IS/IT performance with the business model. and provide services with autonomy; and com-
Figure 3 presents the different actions and out- municate the strategic value that the use of IS/
comes that strategist CIOs identified for devel- IT brings. Many of the elements described in this
oping a strategic performance. According to this article are common to any C-level person, and
synthesis, a CIO should develop and use soft skills some elements are often natural to individuals. In
to partner with key stakeholders (many of them C- the case of the CIO, however, the acquisition and
suite executives) and to form and lead a powerful, development of managerial abilities seems to be
autonomous, and organized team. The influence slower than both the technology they work with
of the CIO over key organizational players and on and business dynamics. Understanding how ca-
the definition of business models, strategies, and pabilities work together and developing and bal-
plans will act as a mechanism for properly align- ancing them to enhance IS/IT contributions to
ing IT platforms to the business architecture and business value is not trivial, so CIOs need to plan
needs, thus allowing the IT executive to plan ac- and choose to build the right competences and
cordingly. Finally, quality planning will define an business model for a strategist performance.
agenda for the CIO and his or her people to opti- In brief, a strategist CIO must
mally structure the team for outstanding perfor-
mance. The strategist CIOs interviewed succeed • complement soft, technical, and managerial
in balancing most of the elements in the concep- skills by choosing the right combination of ed-
tual map, and recognize that failing to maintain ucational programs (undergraduate, executive,
the equilibrium of these elements could harm the or master’s-level);
value their teams deliver and the perception of cli- • learn to strategically and effectively communi-
ents and users of IS/IT services in the company. cate value contributions in a business language;
• understand the business requirements of the
Becoming a Strategist CIO company and translate them into IS/IT proj-
The role of the person in charge of IS/IT man- ects by implementing and working with an in-
agement has become a strategic one for build- formatics committee;
ing and capitalizing on opportunities that result • consider best practice frameworks to supply
in the appropriate use of information resources robust IS/IT services and applications as busi-
and technologies. Hence, CIOs who take the ness solutions rather than as technical solu-
challenge to become impactful actors for busi- tions; and
ness models and strategies face the problem • manage the team for business value.
B
y building a strategist profile—who you municating Value,” MIS Quarterly Executive, vol. 10,
are—IT executives are better positioned in no. 1, 2011, pp. 47–59.
their organizations to manage their depart- 18. M.G. Sobol and G. Klein, “Relation of CIO Back-
ments under a business perspective—what you do. ground, IT Infrastructure, and Economic Perfor-
Organizations that are receptive to the strategist mance,” Information & Management, vol. 46, no. 5, 2009,
CIO role reap the benefits of IT alignment and cor- pp. 271–278.
porate value derived from the right use of IS/IT. 19. E.R. McLean and S.J. Smits, “Management, Lead-
ership, and the Roles of the CIO,” Robinson College of
References Business, Georgia State Univ., 2012; http://bit.ly/2hscfqL.
1. R.D. Banker et al., “CIO Reporting Structure, Strate- 20. D. Chatterjee et al., “Examining the Shareholder
gic Positioning, and Firm Performance,” MIS Quar- Wealth Effects of Announcements of Newly Created
terly, vol. 35, no. 2, 2011, pp. 487–504. CIO Positions,” MIS Quarterly, vol. 25, no. 1, 2001, pp.
2. M. Carter et al., “The Emerging CIO Role of Business 43–70; doi: 10.2307/3250958.
Technology Strategist,” MIS Quarterly Executive, vol. 21. P. Weill and S.L. Woerner, “The Future of the CIO in
10, no. 1, 2011, pp. 19–29. a Digital Economy,” MIS Quarterly Executive, vol. 12,
3. M. Chun and J. Mooney, “CIO Roles and Responsibili- no. 2, 2013, pp. 65–75.
ties: Twenty-Five Years of Evolution and Change,” Infor- 22. D.S. Preston et al., “Examining the Antecedents and
mation & Management, vol. 46, no. 6, 2009, pp. 323–334. Consequences of CIO Strategic Decision-Making
4. V. Grover et al., “The Chief Information Officer: A Authority: An Empirical Study,” Decision Sciences,
Study of Managerial Roles,” J. Management Information Nov. 2008, pp. 605–642.
Systems, vol. 10, no. 2, 1993, pp. 107–130. 23. D.S. Preston and E. Karahanna, “Antecedents of IS
5. C. Sauer, Why Information Systems Fail: A Case Study Strategic Alignment: A Nomological Network,” Infor-
Approach, Alfred Waller, 1993. mation Systems Research, vol. 20, no. 2, 2009, pp. 159–179.
6. P. Simon, Why New Systems Fail, Revised Edition: An Insider’s 24. D. Preston and E. Karahanna, “How to Develop a
Guide to Successful IT Projects, Cengage Learning, 2011. Shared Vision: The Key to Strategic Alignment,” MIS
7. D. Feeny and L. Willcocks, “Core IS Capabilities for Quarterly Executive, vol. 8, no. 1, 2009, pp. 1–8.
Exploiting Information Technology,” Sloan Manage-
ment Rev., vol. 39, no. 3, 1998, pp. 9–21. Ariel La Paz is an assistant professor in the Depart-
8. R. Karlgaard, “What Makes a Great CIO?” Forbes, vol. 172, ment of Management Control and Information Systems at
no. 11, 2003; www.forbes.com/forbes/2003/1124/043.html. the University of Chile and has served as director of the
9. W.R. King, “Including the CIO in Top Management,” School of Information Systems and Auditing. His research
Information Systems Management, vol. 25, no. 2, 2008, interests include the socio-economic impact of information
pp. 188–189. systems, IS/IT alignment to corporate strategies, and com-
10. J. Mechling, “What Does Your CIO Really Need to plexity management. Contact him at lapaz@fen.uchile.cl.
Know?” Government Finance Rev., vol. 25, no. 1, 2009,
pp. 79–80.
11. B.P. Watson, “The Disappearing CIO,” eWeek, vol. 26,
no. 8, 2009, p. 39.
12. J. Peppard et al., “Clarifying the Ambiguous Role of the
CIO,” MIS Quarterly Executive, vol. 10, no. 1, 2011, pp. 31–44.
13. The Essential CIO, IBM Global Business Services, 2011.
14. H.G. Enns et al., “CIO Influence Behaviors: The Im-
pact of Technical Background,” Information & Man-
agement, vol. 40, no. 5, 2003, pp. 467–485.
Read your subscriptions through the
15. B. Ives and M.H. Olson, “Manager or Technician?
myCS publications portal at http://
The Nature of the Information Systems Manager’s
mycs.computer.org.
Job,” MIS Quarterly, vol. 5, no. 4, 1981, pp. 49–63.
computer.org/ITPro 55